:KDW·V%XJJLQJ www.SmithRealEstate.com Call or Click Today! (575) 538-5373 or 1-800-234-0307 7 #OLLEGE !VENUE s 0/ "OX s 3ILVER #ITY .- Quality People, Quality Service for over 40 years! REDUCED ONE-OF-A-KIND HOME & LOCATION! HIGH-QUALITY STATELY MANSION - overlooking Silver VINTAGE 1960. This house has all its “original equipment” Adobe/brick/stucco home right next door to WNMU City from 10 lovely acres. 7100 + sq. ft. built to last. Custom – flagstone fireplace, wood cabinets, shag carpet – all in good Campus on wooded lot with beautiful landscaping, 2 guest features throughout - 6 bedrooms, 5 baths, 3 car finished shape. Possibly the university area’s best view spot! 2 BR 2 or rental homes with the possibility for a 3rd. Family & living room garage. 12 ft. ceilings, hickory, travertine stone & ceramic tile floors, custom BA, with room to expand downstairs. Carport, workshop, double lot, fireplaces, formal dining, appliances, study/library, master bedroom cabinetry, R-50 walls, + lots of southern exposure. PRICE REDUCED to vaulted ceilings, and much more! $199,000 #27252 Call Becky Smith ext fireplace, dressing room. French door. Private patio for entertaining, 3-car $1,100,000! MLS #24210 Call Becky Smith ext 11 11 garage + double carport. $495,000 #26040 Call Becky Smith ext 11 GREAT BACK YARD is fenced, has lots of room for ROOM TO ROAM! This 5-6 BR 3 Bath home has loads of RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET FROM WNMU, these 2 BR gardening and adjoins open space. 3 BR 1 BA Tyrone home potential -- just 2 miles from town on 1 3/4 acre with more 1 BA units are always occupied. Very clean, nice decks on is situated on quiet cul de sac and has expansive views out available. City water, privacy, and nice views, + double the north side, covered parking and storage underneath. the back. Carport, storage, and priced to sell at only $124,900. # 25813 garage & outbuilding -- nearly 3,000 sq. ft. for only $259,000 -- See it soon! $210,000 -- Make an appointment to see this one soon! Becky Smith ext 11 Becky Smith ext 11 # 26146 Becky Smith ext 11 DESERT EXPOSURE OCTOBER 2011 A3 HOME FURNITURE Special Purchase! Huge Savings! MON- FRI FREE 9 AM - 6 PM HOME FURNITURE DELIVERY SAT 538-3767 10 AM - 5 PM In-Store Financing APPLIANCES & CARPETING with approval 207 South Bullard Street Family owned and operated in Historic Downtown Silver City Since 1937 A4 OCTOBER 2011 www.desertexposure.com Contents • Section A Publisher & Editor David A. Fryxell (575) 538-4374 • [email protected] 5 Editor’s Notebook • Trapped in the Past 20 Ramblin’ Outdoors • Taking a Fall Why trapper’s friends on the game commission may ultimate- Lessons learned the hard way. By Larry Lightner Creative Director & ly be their worst enemies. By David A. Fryxell Silver City Advertising Sales 22 The Starry Dome Lisa D. Fryxell 6 Letters This month in the skies. By Bert Stevens (575) 538-4374 • [email protected] Our readers write. 23 Body, Mind & Spirit • It Feels Personal—But It Isn’t Advertising Sales 8 Desert Diary Knowing what’s personal and what’s structural. By Bina Silver City: Shopping and sex, bravery and blondes. Breitner Ilene Wignall (575) 313-0002, [email protected] 10 Tumbleweeds •If Horses Could Talk 25 Body, Mind & Spirit • Slow Down, You Move Too Fast Las Cruces/Mesilla: Equine Voices rescues horses used in the border drug trade. Are you too busy to find time for you? By Sheri Lynn Kristi Dunn By Dawn Newman-Aerts (575) 956-7552, [email protected] 26 Body, Mind & Spirit • Pill Pollution Robyn Rivas 12 Henry Lightcap’s Journal • Kids These Days! Are we medicating our water supply? EarthTalk (575) 312-4685, [email protected] Whippersnappers, listen up! By Henry Lightcap Deming: 27 Grant County Weekly Events Marjorie Lilly 14 Southwest Wildlife • What’s Bugging You? (575) 544-3559, [email protected] In the insect world of the Southwest, variety is indeed the 28 Borderlines • A Visit to Juarez spice of life. By Jay W. Sharp Despite the violence, not what you expect. By Marjorie Lilly Senior Writer Jeff Berg 17 Southwest Storylines • Tuning In 29 Southwest Gardener • Big Horses and a Big Tree For Kyle Johnson, Gila/Mimbres Community Radio is only Horsepower for growing vegetables, plus Fort Bayard’s “al- Web Designer the latest stop on the dial. By Richard Mahler ligator” landmark. By Vivian Savitt David Cortner Columnists Henry Lightcap, Larry Lightner, Marjorie Lilly, Richard Mahler, Vivian Savitt, Bert Stevens, Scott Thomson P.O. Box 191 Silver City, NM 88062 (575) 538-4374 • fax (575) 534-4134 www.desertexposure.com Desert Exposure is published monthly and distributed free of charge at establishments throughout Southwestern New Contents • Section B Mexico. Vol. XV, number 10, October 2011. Mail subscriptions are $18 for 6 issues, $35 for 12 issues. Single copies by mail $4. All contents copyright © 2011 Continental Divide Publishing 1 Good Neighbors• Out of the Ashes 12 Arts Exposure • Portraits of North India LLC. All rights reserved. No portion of this publication may be Grant County emerges from a devastating fire season with a An exhibit of photography and folk arts captures part of a reproduced without written permission. All rights to material new commitment to community and preparedness. crowded subcontinent poised between past and future. by outside contributors revert to the author. Views expressed By Harry Williamson By Manda Clair Jost in articles, advertisements, graphics and/or photos appearing in Desert Exposure do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors or advertisers. 4 The Lively Arts• With a Banjo on Her Knee 14 Arts Exposure • Arts Scene Desert Exposure is not responsible for unsolicited submis- Botanist and banjo player Lillis Urban looks for the elusive Area arts happenings. sions of articles or artwork. Submissions by mail must include Chihuahua scurfpea by day and plays music by night. a self-addressed stamped envelope for reply or return. It will By Jeff Berg, photos by Robert Yee 15 Arts Exposure • Our Cover Artist be assumed that all submissions, including e-mail letters, are Chris Alvarez. intended for publication. All submissions, including letters to 6 Looking Backward• Crash Program the editor, may be edited for length, style and content. America’s first military air campaign, launched from Colum- 16 Arts Exposure • Gallery Guide About the cover: bus, NM, in 1916, had its ups and downs. By Ken Emery Where to indulge in art. “Southwest Cloud 8 Red or Green? 17 40 Days & 40 Nights Temple” by Chris Al- varez, a featured artist Dining guide for Southwest New Mexico. Your complete guide to what’s going on in the month of Octo- at Seedboat Center ber, plus a peek into early November. 8 Red or Green? • Table Talk for the Arts in Silver City. For more about Latest restaurant news. 20 The To-Do List the artist and the 15th This month’s must-see events. 9 Red or Green? • Best of Both Worlds annual Weekend at the Galleries, Oct. The initials in “M & A Bayard Café” stand for “Mexican and 22 Continental Divide • Leaf Me Alone! 7-9, see this issue’s American”—and the café serves up good food of both types. Fall colors are great, if you don’t mind the bare limbs, bliz- Arts Exposure section. By Peggy Platonos zards and berserker rage. By David A. Fryxell Fri Oct 7 First Fridays Downtown. Free street dance on Market St, 7-10pm. Store specials, entertainment, and family activities. SilverCityMainStreet.com Oct 7-10 Weekend at the Galleries. www.mimbresarts.org Fri Nov 4 First Fridays Downtown: Day of the Dead. Dance and family activities in the SC Museum courtyard. Stores and galleries open late. SilverCityMainStreet.com Saturdays, 8am-6pm Sit, Sip and Shop on Yankie Street. Yankie Street becomes a haven for people, not cars, so come out and play! Enjoy coffee and goodies from Yankie Creek Coffee House and Bad Kitty Bakehouse and browse the galleries. MainStreet Gift Certificates accepted by 100+ Downtown merchants Available at AmBank ($25, $10 & $5 certificates) silvercitymainstreet.com Ad paid by Town of Silver City Lodger's Tax ©DE s DESERT EXPOSURE OCTOBER 2011 A5 Editor’s Notebook • David A. Fryxell WINDOWSWINDOWS Trapped in the Past DOORSDOORS The game commission must stop ignoring public concerns about trapping. CABINETSCABINETS ew Mexicans are increasingly moving to- ered to our surprise not long after moving to New . 3WAN 3TREET s 3ILVER #ITY .- Nward a consensus that foothold trapping of Mexico, when a companion’s dog got trapped as we furbearer animals ought to be more closely were hiking Saddlerock Canyon. 575-534-4110 regulated—if not mostly banned, as our neighbors in Trappers will tell you how easy it is to open a trap Arizona did in 1994. Unfortunately, at the same time and free a trapped pet—or its owner. That’s because the New Mexico State Game Commission has taken they know what they’re doing. We’ve tried opening important steps in the opposite direction. Increas- a 6 1/2-inch foothold trap—the maximum allowed— ingly, the commission seems to serve only a tiny mi- and trust me, it’s not so easy for a tenderfoot. Trying nority—only 1,921 furbearer licenses were sold for to do it while a panicked dog is writhing in the trap 2009-10. But more than 40,000 people hike in areas would be a nightmare. where traps could be set. Don’t even think, by the way, of moving or spring- The latest evidence of an out-of-touch game com- ing a trap you encounter along a favorite trail. A 1978 mission came in July, when it ignored 12,000 public state law prohibits “intentionally affecting the condi- comments advocating a ban on trapping on public tion or altering the placement of personal property lands. Worse than ignored—the commission lifted used for the purpose of killing or taking a game ani- a year-old ban on furbearer trapping in the Gila and mal, bird or fish”—even an illegally placed trap. The Apache national forests that had been enacted to first offense is a petty misdemeanor, the second a protect reintroduced Mexican gray wolves. misdemeanor. The point here isn’t to revisit the emotional de- The American Veterinary Medicine Association, bate about wolf reintroduction. Rather, as the pub- the American Animal Hospital Association and the lic is clamoring for tighter controls on trapping, the National Animal Control Association have all con- In the Haunted House commission thumbed its nose at voters and did the demned foothold traps as “inhumane.” Trapped ani- or In the Belfry… opposite. mals, they say, suffer terror, exhaustion, exposure, Silver City outdoorsman and former game com- frostbite, thirst, starvation and shock. The Wildlife LLC missioner Dutch Salmon had it Protection Network says, “Vic- Frumpy Fox right, we suspect, when he com- tims suffer excruciating pain and Petsitting mented in the Sun-News, “If New Contact us! fear as they tear ligaments and Free ConsultationÊUÊÃÕÀi`ÊUÊ `i`Ê Mexico had a referendum, trap- 32%R[ break teeth in their struggle to MEMBER Frumpy Fox LLC ping would be gone.” Unfortu- Silver City, NM 88062 free themselves…. Animals suffer nately, Salmon’s voice of reason telephone 538-4374 lacerations, broken bones, joint 575-313-0690 and insights into the balance be- fax 534-4134 dislocations and gangrene.” The www.frumpyfox.com Silver City, NM tween nature and those who find email: World Animal Foundation claims ©DE ÊU their sport in hunting, fishing and [email protected] that up to a quarter of all trapped trapping will no longer be heard [email protected] animals escape by chewing off in Santa Fe. Gov. Susana Martinez [email protected] their own foot. Free the Animals abruptly removed Salmon and two cites a study in Wheeler National other commissioners in March, even though Salmon Wildlife Refuge in Tennessee that found 28% of mink, still had nine months remaining on his term. 24% of raccoons and 26% of trapped fox bit off their “I’m on my own limbs to escape. ast month, Animal Protection New Mexico and LTrapFreeNM.org sponsored a public forum in nd yet we understand that a case might be way to Mis Albuquerque to try to counter the game com- Amade for the practical necessity of continu- mission’s intransigence on trapping regulation. An ing some carefully regulated trapping. We’re editorial in the Albuquerque Journal prior to the not so naïve, for instance, as to flatly ban trapping of Amigos!” meeting likened trapping to cockfighting—“another skunks that can infest houses. Trapping is also more subculture in New Mexico that justified its animal effective than hunting for controlling animal-spread The place to go in cruelty as a way of life.” Just as the legislature finally diseases such as rabies. In Colorado and Arizona, banned cockfighting in 2007, the editorial conclud- according to a national trappers’ association, coy- Silver City for your ed, it should put an end to trapping. The editorial ote populations have expanded since those trapping pet’s boarding, brought a spate of letters in response—all even more bans to cause millions of dollars in damage to sheep vehemently anti-trapping. and cattle. Coyotes are also said to be hurting wild- grooming, It’s easy for trapping advocates to dismiss such life populations, such as antelope. daycare, dietary opinions and animal-lovers’ meetings up in Albu- These are issues that need to be carefully consid- daycare, dietary querque as the soft-hearted rantings of uninformed ered by a game commission that weighs the input of and training needs. city folk. But in Desert Exposure’s extensive past wildlife experts, trappers and animal activists. Unfor- coverage of the trapping controversy, it’s clear tunately for all concerned—especially New Mexico’s that even people who might think a ban goes too furbearers—that doesn’t seem to be on the agenda. far ought to be concerned about New Mexico’s lax Public opinion be damned, that’s the message from trapping rules. the current game commission. Unlike almost every sort of hunting, there’s no Trappers, too, ought to be concerned. Because bag limit on trapping furbearers. There’s no limit on as long as the game commission remains deaf to the 11745 HWY 180 E the number of traps an individual can set, as long as opinions of the 99.9% of New Mexicans who don’t 3 miles east of Silver City he can “make a visual inspection” every 24 hours. A trap, quashing even minimal reforms, the threat to Arenas Valley Road and HWY 180 trapping license costs just $20 for adult residents, their “way of life” that trappers most fear looms larger. s less than half that for hunting deer or bear—and yet Enlightened trappers and the game commission ought trapping activity is partly spurred by hopes of eco- to consider steps to better align the rules with wildlife nomic gain, increasing as pelt prices rise. Unlike management and to minimize the interactions of non- hunting, the wildlife management aspect of trapping trappers and their pets with traps, such as: is an afterthought at best, driven by the fur market • Establish quotas on some species, such as bob- rather than by furbearer populations; until 2006, trap- EDITOR’S NOTEBOOK continued on next page pers in New Mexico weren’t even required to report their catches (except for federally UÊ-ÕÌ ÜiÃÌiÀÊiÜiÀÞ tracked bobcats). Foothold traps must be placed UÊ1µÕiÊ}vÌà more than a quarter-mile from an The Music Space occupied dwelling (unless the oc- UÊ iÀ>ÊëiVià cupant consents in writing) or an Musical Instruments UÊÀiiÊ iÀ>Ê ÕÃiÕ established public campground, & Accessories roadside rest area, picnic area or UÊ,VÊÕ`}Ê boat launching area. Traps have Inside The Marketplace at the HUB Plaza to be more than 25 yards from any ÃÕ««iÃÊ>`ÊLà (6th & Bullard) designated US Forest Service or £näxÊÌÌiÊ7>ÕÌÊ,`°ÊUÊ-ÛiÀÊ ÌÞ]Ê ÊnnäÈ£ BLM trail. Less-formal trails have Special Orders possible. no such protection, as we discov- #ARLA 2IVERS OWNER s HOME 575.538.9001ÊUÊnÇÇ°xÎn°ää£ÊÌÊvÀii A6 OCTOBER 2011 www.desertexposure.com EDITOR’S NOTEBOOK continued inhumane and that it must be banned in a civilized society. Like the death penalty or abortion, for many cat, raccoon and fox. (Coyotes and skunks are so New Mexicans this is an all-or-nothing issue. prolific that they don’t need limits.) In 2007-08, for Nonetheless, trappers and their game-commission example, both bobcats and gray foxes were trapped allies need to understand that a similarly hard-line in numbers that reached the “estimated sustainable stand can’t succeed when you’re so in the minority. harvest limit” range. They need to be reasonable and take steps to better • Require a trailhead to be marked with a sign that separate their activity from those who find it at best traps are present. startling and at worst abhorrent. • Increase the minimum distance for a trap from Otherwise, if those who are supposed to be regu- a trail to 50 feet. lating trapping won’t listen, eventually the political • Limit the number of traps that a trapper can set wheel in Santa Fe will turn and the legislature and a in a season. different governor will. That’s when trapping will be • Ban non-resident trapping. While this would rep- finally banned in New Mexico. And its advocates will resent a small blow to tourism, veteran outdoorsmen have only themselves to blame. k say non-residents come here to make a living off of trapping, setting hundreds of traps in an area, then moving on after they’ve caught most of the furbear- David A. Fryxell is editor of Desert ers—very different from hobbyist trappers. Exposure. None of these reforms, of course, will suffice if you’ve concluded that trapping is simply cruel and Letters Winners, Apaches and Pearce Plus losing touch with reality and Larry Lightner’s “death wish.” Real Winners talking about seeing “animals” that turned out to be enjoyed Heather Null’s prizewinning story, “Mid- logs or boulders. And, now, it seems he is afraid of Idle of Nowhere,” in the September issue but hope- almost everything in the forest: bears, lions, wolves fully she is taking artistic license in her descrip- and snakes. tion of the rest stop on Hwy. 180 between Deming Gosh, I’ve been hiking alone in the forest since I and Silver City. While it might be lonely at night I was five years old. I’ve met bears, lions, rattlesnakes have always found it to be one of the neatest, clean- and wolves. No problem. I carry a camera—not a gun. est, best kept-up rest stops I have ever seen. I doubt Somebody! Get Larry some help! Tell him it’s OK that a coyote could find even a scrap of leftover food not to go into the forest. Tell him it’s OK to stay in— to eat there. The area is always nicely maintained. All maybe take up crafts or something. the rocks surrounding the paths are painted white; Deirdre Wolf some of the bushes are even painted and trimmed to Silver City resemble hearts or dice cubes. Three cheers to the people who keep up this great rest area! Pearce’s Pop Quiz Kathy Cassell have a few comments on the editorial about Steve Silver City IPearce’s visit to Silver City (“Editor’s Notebook,” September). Steve Pearce is a total fraud and liar. was reading this month’s issue of your magazine Many of the comments made in the editorial are very I(September) and I couldn’t believe my eyes when accurate and to add a little more to it: Pearce never talks I read the story of the cover, and I can’t believe about the $6 trillion of government waste and handouts (575) 531-0124 that the cover was actually colored in (by contest during George Bush’s years in office, which Pearce sup- winner Sarah Stills, over Ben Balas’ drawing)! Its ported 100%. In Pearce’s “limited” government scheme, absolutely remarkably beautiful. Congratulations on Bush, with support from the likes of Pearce and all the such an original concept. Both artists, the one who Tea Baggers out there today, gave Halliburton a “no-bid” drew the cover and the one who colored it in and contract to “rebuild” Iraq during the Iraq War. Where do won the contest, are amazing! I hope that they do “no bid” contracts fit in with the “free market” system SINCE more work for you on the future. I think there is no that Pearce and the Tea Baggers swear by? This cost other magazine out there such as yours! taxpayers many billions of dollars. 1970 Gloria Hernandez There was so much of this government wasteful El Paso spending that Pearce and the Tea Baggers supported for eight years under Bush, which contributed to Ringing a Bell our huge debt today, far more than anything Obama NO TRICKS HERE! just read the article on “ringing in your ears” has done. Yet here we are listening to their rhetoric I(Body, Mind & Spirit, September). I have had tin- about “too much” government. Pearce’s only beef WE CAN PUT YOU ON THE BIKE nitus for quite awhile, and since it doesn’t inter- with Obama is that Obama has tilted the scale ever fere with my hearing (my wife’s opinion to the con- so slightly towards the middle class and the poor and THAT’S RIGHT FOR YOU! trary), I find it useful. I can actually hear my pulse this is intolerable to Pearce and his Tea Bagger sup- as I go through the day, and when I exert myself, the porters who want to give the rich their “deserved” DON’T BE A beat speeds up and then happily settles back down federal subsidies. PUMPKIN HEAD, to my normal rate. William Joseph COME ON DOWN TO Also, if I ever hear just a constant tone in my Silver City GILA HIKE & BIKE! ears, I’ll know the ride is over. Bert de Pedro Unfriending Facebook Red Rock ust a note here to let you know I super-enjoyed Jyour “Continental Divide” column (“The Anti-So- Death Wish? cial Network,” September). It is sooo nice to read ambling Larry Lightner (“Rambling Out- that someone else who’s not a regular Joe Blow thinks R doors,” September) asks, “Any more ques- all this tweeting and social networking has gotten a bit tions?” before closing with his usual oddball out of hand. It’s amazing how hard it seems to be for reference to the strange god he believes in. I have even relatives to drop an email (or better yet, call) be- one: What is the psychological relationship between cause they are so hung up on Facebook. People gripe his love of killing defenseless wild critters and his at me all the time because I don’t have a Facebook stated precarious lifestyle? Is there a death wish in account, like I’m out of touch with reality. there somewhere? I have come to the conclusion that there are so Bob Young many people living in the “virtual world” that THEY Las Cruces have lost touch with reality. A lot of these people I know spend so much time gaming and hanging out ’m very concerned about Larry Lightner. Why online that I get to wondering if they even have GILA HIKE & BIKE Idoes he drive himself to hunt the forest he is so physical friends much anymore. In fact, my daughter Adventure Down! afraid of? I remember an article he wrote say- who lives in Phoenix says it’s getting really hard to Corner of College & Bullard ing how scary it was when noises heard could not know people physically. I warned her that life now Open 7 days a week 575-388-3222 be identified. I also remember an article he wrote has changed dramatically and that this seems to be DESERT EXPOSURE OCTOBER 2011 A7 a major ailment in our culture/society. Sure, it is nice studied before she characterizes me as writing with to be able to chat with folks around the world; I used “racist bias.” These were brutal wars with extreme bru- the bikeworks to do it in email and enjoyed it. But doggone. You are tality on all sides. Treacherous political decisions were right. Where DO these people get the time to hang made, and dishonest military actions were committed. a community bicycle workshop out online so much? But many fair attempts were made to convince the Chir- )N (OUSE 4OOL ,IBRARY s %ARN A "IKE 0ROGRAM #OMMUNITY "IKE 2IDES Thanks again for a delightful editorial of “real life.” icahuas that their lifestyle was tenuous. At some point, And I’m sure that psychologists who specialize in cy- some Chiricahua Apaches made a conscious decision The Bike Works shop is undergoing a facelift! ber-psychology are making a mint nowadays. This is to raid, kill and plunder Americans and Mexicans after Come by to see our expanded tool stations & to find the the psychology of people who are so hung up on cy- even some other Chiricahuas (e.g., the Chihene N’de affordable reconditioned bike that is right for you. berspace and virtual reality that they have lost touch of Loco) had finally surrendered in 1884. with real reality and they likely don’t even have to be In my article “Chihuahua’s Journey” (April 2011), I 5IF#JLF8PSLT4IPQr&UI4Ur doing drugs or alcohol to achieve this dysfunction. recount how Chihuahua (whom I admire as a total hu- Th:QNQNtF:QNQNtSa: 10am-2pm-RIDE QNQNtSu: 5pm-8pm Laura Boyd man being) urged Geronimo to torture a Mexican family Silver City even after he’d promised to not do so. The entire family were tortured and killed brutally. I’ve noted that once the Artist Yankie Street Studios: Moving Like the Wind Chiricahua went into captivity, they were astonishingly erry Eagan’s August 2011 article on Apache his- peaceful and free of pathological violence: Chihuahua Studio Available Now! Jtory (“From Water to Water”) reeks of racist bias, was so gentle that when Captain Marion Maus came to Spaces Bright, heated artist spaces for rent. which is all the worse as his subtitle suggests Mount Vernon Barracks to hear the Apaches’ laments, self-reflection, none of which is apparent anywhere Chihuahua was lovingly tending an infant. Maus waited Call Secure, upstairs artist studios, in the piece. This rambling, disjointed bit of writing while he handed the baby to another person. 415.738.8379 with easy downtown access. seems to serve no clear purpose other than to pro- Torture and outrages happened on both sides, as or email Utilities included. vide Eagan with a forum for self-congratulation and I’ve acknowledged in writing in detail about the man- paul@ Not for overnight use. to demonstrate his, and non-Apache society’s, superi- ner in which Mangas Coloradas was tormented by goodnightnaturals ority to the Apache. Throughout the article he paints soldiers poking him with heated bayonets before kill- .com $230 per month. Apache people as unreasonably violent, drunk, servile ing and decapitating him. and existing meaningfully only in the past. As for the challenges of tracking the Apache, hav- Eagan writes, “It’s a myth to state that no one ing read 100-plus rolls of microfilm of the American +DSS\+DOORZHHQ)URP7KH*DQJ$W could follow Apaches save other Apaches.” Sure, Army from 1840-1890, I know there were ample oc- others could follow the Apache but ultimately, no casions when Americans working with non-Apache P rty Z ne one but other Apaches succeeded in finding them, scouts succeeded in finding down the Apache. and those Apaches were thanked with imprisonment The tragic instances of alcohol abuse among the :H+DYH&RVWXPHV:LJV0DNHXS+HDG%RSSHUV&RVWXPH along with the “renegades.” Despite the lack of “vigi- Apache are similarly well documented. Geronimo -HZHOU\:LQGRZ&OLQJV7DEOH'HFRUDWLRQ3ODWHV1DSNLQV lance” Eagan describes, it is nevertheless true that himself died from pneumonia contracted on a drink- DQG%DOORRQV,QRWKHUZRUGV(YHU\WKLQJ\RXQHHGIRU 5,000 US troops (one-quarter of the entire US army at ing spree in 1909. \RXUKDOORZHHQSDUW\H[FHSWWKHFDQG\ the time), 3,000 Mexican troops and nearly another As for non-Apaches telling this story, it’s ironic that (Behind Daylight Donuts) 1,000 of miscellaneous vigilantes—9,000 in all—were in just the previous paragraph Ms. Ramnarace ad- % TH 3T s 534-0098 in Silver City s Mon-Fri 9:30-5, Sat 10-3 unable to catch 37 Apaches (18 warriors, 13 women miringly quotes historian David Roberts, whom I’ve and 6 children) when they did not want to be caught. likewise cited in my articles. Roberts, of course, is not '( Eagan says, “Geronimo never fully apologized an Apache, either. for those many deaths, nor did any other Apaches at Canyon de los Embudos apologize.” Has the US Call for Compassion <0-*-;<3-8<;-+:-<16/:)6<+7=6
<<