DOCSLIB.ORG

Nicollet County Broadband Strategic Plan

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nicollet County Broadband Strategic Plan Broadband Strategic Plan Nicollet County, Minnesota August 2, 2020 Finley Engineering CCG Consulting Nicollet County Broadband Report Table of Contents Page Executive Summary ...........................................................................................................3 Findings...............................................................................................................................5 Recommendations / Next Steps.........................................................................................9 I. Market Analysis............................................................................................................12 A. Providers, Products, and Price Research.................................................................................. 12 B. Surveys / Interviews................................................................................................................. 28 C. Broadband GAP Analysis ........................................................................................................ 34 II. Engineering Design and Cost.....................................................................................73 A. Network Design ....................................................................................................................... 74 B. The Technology........................................................................................................................ 78 C. Competing Technologies.......................................................................................................... 81 III. Financial Projections.................................................................................................97 A. Services Considered................................................................................................................. 97 B. Financial Assumptions ............................................................................................................. 99 E. Financial Results .................................................................................................................... 112 IV. Other Issues..............................................................................................................121 A. Funding for Broadband Networks.......................................................................................... 121 B. Finding an ISP Partner ........................................................................................................... 131 C. Our Recommendations / Next Steps ...................................................................................... 136 Exhibit I: Service Areas of the Incumbent Telephone Companies ...........................144 Exhibit II: Study Area ...................................................................................................145 Exhibit III: Backbone Fiber Design ...........................................................................1456 Exhibit IV: Hybrid Network Design ............................................................................145 Exhibit V: Summary of Financial Results...................................................................145 Page 2 Nicollet County Broadband Report EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Finley Engineering and CCG Consulting submit this Broadband Feasibility Study that provides our findings and recommendations for bringing better broadband to the rural parts of Nicollet County. The first phase of the study was to look at the need for broadband in the county. We tackled that task in several ways. We first communicated with residents and businesses through surveys, speed tests, and interviews to understand the broadband needs in the county. We talked to the existing service providers in the county to understand their long-term plans for broadband expansion. We investigated the current broadband products and prices available in the county today. Our analysis verified the county’s belief that the rural parts of the county have slower and mostly inadequate broadband. We then looked at what we call the broadband gaps in the rural parts of the county. This involved comparing broadband in the rural areas to broadband available in the cities in the county and elsewhere in the country. This report discusses the various broadband gaps we identified during our research and includes things like the urban / rural gap mentioned above. We discuss the homework gap where students without home broadband don’t perform as well in school. We discuss the computer gap where homes without computers don’t do as well as homes with them. We look at the broadband speeds available in the county today and compare them to other places. We discuss a number of ideas for overcoming the various identified broadband gaps. One of the issues we identified is that the databases the FCC uses to define broadband availability overstate the broadband available in the rural areas of the county. The FCC believes that most of the homes in the county have access to broadband of at least 25/3 Mbps – something that we are certain is not true. Unfortunately, the faulty maps are used by the FCC when determining the areas that are eligible for federal broadband grants. We discuss steps the county should consider taking to correct the FCC maps. The next phase of the study quantified the cost of bringing broadband to rural parts of the county. Finley Engineering studied three scenarios for bringing better broadband. The first scenario brings fiber to all rural parts of the county. The second scenario brings fiber to everywhere except the area served by Nuvera, since the company is likely to eventually bring fiber to those areas. The third scenario considered bringing fiber to Nicollet and to six wireless towers and would provide fiber broadband to 750 homes and businesses and bring 50 Mbps wireless broadband to the rest of the rural areas. Finley Engineering undertook the engineering analysis in such a way that they could generate the cost for building to any portion of the county if an ISP wants to consider coming to Nicollet County. We think this might be one of the most important parts of our product, since knowing the cost of building a network is generally the number one question asked by any ISP considering serving there. Next, CCG Consulting created financial models that reflect the potential profitability for an ISP operating a broadband business in the rural parts of Nicollet County. Just like with the Finley Engineering analysis, we could modify our work to fit some smaller footprint if an ISP were to be interested. These studies include assumptions that we think are representative for estimating the revenues and the costs from operating a broadband business. We were not surprised to find out that grants would be required to finance fiber construction in the rural parts of the county. That was fully expected; we’ve never seen a rural area where customer revenues fully Page 3 Nicollet County Broadband Report support the cost of fiber without some grant assistance. Our analysis shows that building fiber everywhere in the rural parts of the county would require at least 4.3 million in grants. We conclude the report by providing a list of specific steps that Nicollet County should consider after getting this report. The most obvious next step is to share this report with ISPs. This study is going to answer a lot of questions about serving in Nicollet County and might bring interest from an ISP that might not have otherwise considered coming to the county. There are a number of other recommendations talking about ways that the county can address the various broadband gaps. Page 4 Nicollet County Broadband Report FINDINGS Following are our primary finding: Existing Providers and Market Rates. The county has a long list of ISPs operating somewhere in the county today. This includes incumbent telephone service provided by CenturyLink, Consolidated Communications, and Nuvera. There are three incumbent cable companies operating in the populated areas including Comcast, Charter Communications, and Mediacom. There is some fiber to homes in the north of the county that has been built by RS Fiber Cooperative. There are several wireless providers in the county including MVTV, LTD Broadband, Radio Link, Nuvera, and the RS Fiber Cooperative. Some rural homes get home broadband using the cellular broadband from AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile, which recently merged with Sprint. The county is also served with satellite broadband and cable TV. The study looks at the key products and prices currently offered by these existing ISPs. The Study Areas. The county elected to look at a study that brings faster broadband to all parts of the county that are either unserved or underserved today using the Minnesota state definition of broadband. That defines anything slower than 25/3 Mbps as unserved and speeds between 25/3 Mbps and 100/20 Mbps as underserved. The study area is essentially all of the areas outside the cities, and a map is shown on a map in Exhibit II. The Study Scenarios. The broadband studies assume that the County will be seeking ISP partners to bring better broadband to the rural parts of the county, and our analysis was done from the perspective of the ISPs. The studies considered three scenarios: Bringing fiber to all of the rural parts of the county. Bringing fiber to all of the rural county except the area served by Nuvera (since they are likely to bring fiber to that area eventually). Bringing better broadband with a network
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Impact of Broadband Speed and Price on Small Businesses
    The Impact of Broadband Speed and Price on Small Business by Columbia Telecommunications Corporation Kensington, MD 20895 for under contract number SBAHQ-09-C-0050 Release Date: November 2010 This contract was developed under a contract with the Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, and contains information and analysis that was reviewed by officials of the Office of Advocacy. However, the final conclusions of the report do not necessarily reflect the views of the Office of Advocacy. Contents 1. Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................. 1 1.1. Purpose ........................................................................................................................................ 1 1.2. Key Observations Regarding the U.S. Internet Market ............................................................... 1 1.3. Policy Recommendations and Considerations ............................................................................. 3 2. Report Definitions and Data Gathering ................................................................................................ 5 2.1. Defining Broadband .................................................................................................................... 5 2.2. Survey Development, Distribution, and Analysis ....................................................................... 6 3. Understanding the U.S. Broadband Market Today .............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • How Different Parameters Affect the Downlink Speed
    Linköping University | IDA Bachelor Thesis | Computer and Information Science Spring 2016| LIU-IDA/LITH-EX-G—16/071--SE How Different Parameters Affect the Downlink Speed Martin Claesson Lovisa Edholm Handledare/Tutor, Niklas Carlsson Examinator, Nahid Shahmehri Abstract Today many societies rely on fast mobile networks, and the future seem to place even larger demand on the networks performance. This thesis analyzes which parameters af- fects the downlink speed of mobile networks. Various statistical analyses are performed on a large dataset provided by Bredbandskollen. We find that parameters such as the in- ternet service provider, the type of phone, the time of day and the density of population affect the downlink speed. We also find that the downlink speeds are significantly higher in urban areas compared to more rural regions. Acknowledgments Thanks to Rickard Dahlstrand at .SE for sharing the Bredbandskollen dataset, without the dataset this study would not have been possible. Thanks to our supervisor Niklas Carlsson for all the great guidance in this project. We would also like to thank our Tim Lestander and Jakob Nilsson for proof reading our thesis as well as providing us with helpful feedback during the process. iii Contents Abstract ii Acknowledgments iii Contents iv List of Figures v List of Tables vi 1 Introduction 2 1.1 Contributions . 3 1.2 Thesis outline . 4 2 Related Work 5 3 Method 6 3.1 The dataset . 6 3.2 Linear regression . 7 4 Results 9 4.1 Urban and rural areas . 9 4.2 Phones and tablets . 10 4.3 Time of day .
    [Show full text]
  • AARP Net Neutrality FCC Comments July 13 2014
    Before the Federal Communications Commission Washington, D.C. 20554 ) In the Matter of ) ) GN Docket No. 14-28 Protecting and Promoting the Open Internet ) ) ) Comments of AARP July 15, 2014 Trevor R. Roycroft, Ph.D. David Certner Economic Consultant Legislative Counsel and Legislative Policy Director Government Affairs AARP 601 E Street, NW Washington, DC 20049 AARP Comments GN Docket No. 14-28 July 15, 2014 _________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Table of Contents Summary and Overview of Comments ...................................................................................... iii Broadband has changed since the Cable Modem Order—telecommunications is the dominant service provided to end-users and edge providers over broadband connections .................................................................................................................................................... iv The NPRM's discrimination solution to no-blocking will harm the Internet ecosystem ... v “Minimum levels of access” require Title II classification .................................................. vi Case-by-case evaluation of “commercially unreasonable” practices based on the “totality of circumstances” will place an impossible burden on the Commission............................ vii Reclassification will support Internet innovation and broadband investment ................. vii I. Introduction .............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Click Below to Download
    April 2007 Worldwide Satellite Magazine Vol. 5 No. 1 ? The Future of Satellite Broadcasting 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Vol. 5 No. 1, April 2007 Click on the title to go directly to the story COVER STORY FEATUREFEATURE REGIONAL UPDATES T 19 / The Future of 23 / The Satellite 26 / Exploring the 30 / High-Jinks over Broadcasting Channel Wars Fixed Satellite the Middle East Service by Chris Forrester Market A new entrant into the market is shaking things up By Howard Greenfield By Patrick French, NSR by Bruce R. Elbert in the Middle Eastern satellite market. The explosion of new Commercial satellite The FSS satellite applications and hybrid operators are scrambling .business has been broadband models are driving to get as many video marked by stable growth CASE STUDY channels under their the future of broadcasting. and profitability due to the 35 / Tools for wing. steadily increasing demand for new Broadcasters to VIEWPOINT applications. Deliver Interference- free HD Content by Bob Potter 38 / After Iraq: What’s Communications Systems Next for the Satellite Monitors (CSMs) are providing Industry? an essential tool for broadcasters wanting to deliver by Alan Gottlieb interference-free HD content. New opportunities exists in a post-Iraq War satellite industry. REGULAR DEPARTMENTS 3 / Notes from the 43 / Market Intelligence: 41 / EXECUTIVE Editor India’s Satellite Crisis: SPOTLIGH Capacity Barriers and Interview with 4 / Calendar of Events “Spectrum Grab” presented by the Global Integral Systems 5 / Industry News VSAT Forum CEO Peter Gaffney 46 / Stock Quotes / Peter Gaffney who took 10 / Executive Moves over as CEO of Integral Advertisers’ Index Systems from founder 15 / New Products and Steve Chamberlain Services: speaks to SatMagazine Update on Satellites April 2007 on a variety of issues.
    [Show full text]
  • How Cable Companies Use Hidden Fees to Raise Prices and Disguise the True Cost of Service CR CABLE BILL REPORT 2019
    How Cable Companies Use Hidden Fees to Raise Prices and Disguise the True Cost of Service CR CABLE BILL REPORT 2019 Jonathan Schwantes, Consumer Reports October 2019 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Consumers are clearly fed up. Nearly everyone (96%) of those who reported having encountered From cable TV to online ticket vendors, utilities, hidden or unexpected fees in an industry that we airlines or hotels, companies are piling on more asked about said fees are a real nuisance. Nowhere and more hidden fees that result in higher bills for is this more true than in the cable industry. The consumers. Overall, 85% of Americans say they CR survey found telecommunications providers have encountered an unexpected or hidden fee (which includes cable companies) are the worst in the past two years for a service they had used, offender when it comes to charging unexpected according to a recent nationally representative or hidden fees. What a cable company advertises survey of 2,057 U.S. adults, conducted by to a consumer as a monthly price for services, and Consumer Reports (CR). And nearly two-thirds say what the consumer actually ends up paying, can be they are paying more now in surprise charges than dramatically different. they did five years ago. For a typical family, these fees can potentially add up to thousands of dollars What a cable company a year in extra costs, posing a big financial strain, CR found. advertises to a consumer as a monthly price for services, and what the consumer actually ends up % paying, can be dramatically OF U.S.64 CONSUMERS different.
    [Show full text]
  • ETSI White Paper on Ipv6 Best Practices, Benefits, Transition
    ETSI White Paper No. 35 IPv6 Best Practices, Benefits, Transition Challenges and the Way Forward First edition – August 2020 ISBN No. 979-10-92620-31-1 ETSI 06921 Sophia Antipolis CEDEX, France Tel +33 4 92 94 42 00 [email protected] www.etsi.org Contributing organizations and authors CAICT Zhiruo Liu China Telecom Chongfeng Xie, Cong Li Cisco Patrick Wetterwald, Pascal Thubert, Francois Clad Hewlett-Packard Enterprise Yanick Pouffary Huawei Giuseppe Fioccola, Xipeng Xiao, Georgios Karagiannis, Shucheng(Will) Liu KPN Eduard Metz Luxembourg University Latif Ladid PT Telecom Jose Cananao, Jose Palma Post Luxembourg Sébastien Lourdez Telefonica Luis M. Contreras IPv6 Best Practices, Benefits, Transition Challenges and the Way Forward 2 Contents Contributing organizations and authors 2 Contents 3 Executive Summary 6 1 Background 8 1.1 Why should IPv6 become a priority again? 8 1.2 Goals of this White Paper 9 2 IPv6 progress in the last 5 years 10 2.1 Devices supporting IPv6 10 2.2 Content (web sites, cloud services) supporting IPv6 11 2.3 Networks supporting IPv6 12 2.4 Number of IPv6 users 12 2.5 Amount of IPv6 traffic 13 2.6 IPv6 standardization progress 14 3 IPv6 service design for Mobile, Fixed broadband and enterprises 14 3.1 IPv6 transition solutions from operator perspective 15 3.1.1 For IPv6 introduction 16 3.1.2 For IPv6-only service delivery 17 3.2 IPv6 prefix and address assignment at the CPEs 22 3.2.1 For MBB UEs 23 3.2.2 For FBB RGs 23 3.2.3 For Enterprise CPEs 23 3.3 IPv6 Packet Transport 24 3.4 IPv6 deployment inside enterprise
    [Show full text]
  • Ticket: # 1282280
    _____________________________________________________________________________ Ticket: # 1282280 - Extremely Poor Internet Service Date: 10/22/2016 7:27:26 PM City/State/Zip: Shawano, Wisconsin 54166 Company Complaining About: Frontier Communications _____________________________________________________________________________ Description Frontier Communications has been delivering unacceptable service to residents in Richmond, WI for years while continuing to charge high rates for service they cannot provide. The town of Richmond held a public meeting with one of the Wisconsin representatives of the company last week. However, the representative was reluctant to provide information, was dodging questions, and did not take the concerns of their customers seriously. Frontier Communications is not providing advertised speeds and is unwilling to expand operations to resolve the issue. They are also unwilling to reduce bill amounts. _____________________________________________________________________________ Ticket: # 1282354 - T-Mobile towers Date: 10/22/2016 9:05:42 PM City/State/Zip: Atlanta, Georgia 30308 Company Complaining About: T Mobile _____________________________________________________________________________ Description I find it odd that everywhere I go T-Mobile seems to be working in towers in that area I called to complain and they already had their we are working on towers in your area excuse ready but they were telling me about my address in Atlanta in zip code 30308 because that was on file but what they didn't know is I
    [Show full text]
  • Microsofttokentv: TV Meets .NET
    Thinkweek MicrosoftTokenTV: TV meets .NET Curtis Wong & Steven Drucker – Next Media Research Introduction This paper discusses an application of existing technology combined in a new way that could be implemented at Microsoft and enhance .NET functionality to broadcast television. The fundamental issue that we wish to discuss is how to fashion the appropriate business strategy to best apply this technology towards enhancing Microsoft’s television platforms. Specifically, TokenTV is an architectural blueprint for a service that would allow convenient remote programming of Personal Video Recorders (PVRs) and delivery of TV related services. Moreover, it is designed in such a way that allows third parties to build upon a platform provided by MS that can greatly increase the influence of the Internet and the .NET approach to the Television space. PVRs are already turning the TV into a device that enables users to watch what they want, when they want it, and less when the content airs. By opening up remote PVR recording to email and the Internet, we can enable PVRs to be remotely directed to record broadcast television programs from anywhere and any device. This is not just about the convenience of remote programming, but enabling everyone to easily record and share television programming without the gating factors of transport bandwidth or copyright infringement issues. TokenTV enables 3rd parties to build business and content services around delivering (via TVTokens) broadcast television programs and related services enabling a new level of consumer convenience. Examples of these will be described later in this document. 11/29/2016 1 Next Media Research Thinkweek Table of Contents The table of contents and other references are hyper linked in the electronic form of this document to related information.
    [Show full text]
  • Talk About Value, Not Product… the Solution to Widen the B2B Sales Pipeline?
    Talk about value, not product… The solution to widen the B2B sales pipeline? Malin Väringstam & Annina Wede Department of Business Administration Master's Program in Management Master's Program in Business Development and Internationalisation Master's Thesis in Business Administration II, 15 Credits, Spring 2021 Supervisor: Christopher Nicol Acknowledgements We want to give our warmest appreciations to our respondents from Tele2, who gave us the opportunity to explore sales development within their organization. Your inputs, competences, and inspiring experiences have provided great insights for this thesis. We also want to thank our supervisor, Christopher, for motivational meetings and wise insights, but also for teaching us a thing or two about proper English. Finally, we would like to say thank you to Umeå University for these five years and for preparing us for our future careers. Umeå School of Business, Economics and Statistics, 26th of May 2021 _____________________ _____________________ Malin Väringstam Annina Wede Abstract Business-to-business (B2B) organizations are facing challenges related to complex sales cycles and increasing competition, resulting in more value-driven sales processes and a holistic ecosystem for the B2B marketplace. Recent studies have acknowledged the lack of research on inside sales and sales development in B2B organizations. Scholars point at the increasing importance of inside sales due to changes in the environment and increasing customer demands, which has resulted in the development of digital sales processes within companies. In this study, we have examined the early phase of the sales process referred to as customer acquisition, which is an important part for companies to do business and be profitable over time.
    [Show full text]
  • The Meaning of Approximative Adverbs: Evidence from European Portuguese
    THE MEANING OF APPROXIMATIVE ADVERBS: EVIDENCE FROM EUROPEAN PORTUGUESE DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Patrícia Matos Amaral, Master’s Degree in Linguistics ***** The Ohio State University 2007 Dissertation Committee: Approved by Professor Scott Schwenter, Adviser Professor Craige Roberts ____________________________ Professor John Grinstead Adviser Spanish and Portuguese Graduate Program ABSTRACT This dissertation presents an analysis of the semantic-pragmatic properties of adverbs like English almost and barely (“approximative adverbs”), both in a descriptive and in a theoretical perspective. In particular, I investigate to what extent the meaning distinctions encoded by the system of approximative adverbs in European Portuguese (EP) shed light on the characterization of these adverbs as a class and on the challenges raised by their semantic-pragmatic properties. I focus on the intuitive notion of closeness associated with the meaning of these adverbs and the related question of the asymmetry of their meaning components. The main claim of this work is that the meaning of approximative adverbs involves a comparison between properties along a scalar dimension, and makes reference to a lexically provided or contextually assumed standard value of comparison. In chapter 2, I present some of the properties displayed by approximative adverbs cross-linguistically and more specifically in European Portuguese. This chapter discusses the difficulties raised by their classification within the major classes assumed in taxonomies of adverbs. In chapter 3, I report two experiments that were conducted to test the asymmetric behavior of the meaning components of approximative adverbs and the role that they play in interpretation.
    [Show full text]
  • Final Document Guja Armannsdottir1
    UNIVERSITY OF HULL MARKETING COMMUNICATIONS PRACTICES IN SMES THROUGH A CULTURAL LENS A ONE NATION PERSPECTIVE: ICEALND being a dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Hull by Guðríður Ármannsdóttir December 2010 Abstract The marketing environment has in the past two decades changed dramatically. The Internet has given businesses of all sizes the opportunity to compete throughout the world with brands of seemingly similar quality, and to promote their wares in ways previously unimagined. Simultaneously, media fragmentation and the overarching need for cost-effective and efficient marketing has changed the way marketers conduct and evaluate their marketing and marketing communications activities (De Pelsmacker et al, 2004). This research explores the emergence, relevance and applicability of marketing communications/Integrated Marketing Communications (IMC) within SMEs in Iceland and if marketing communications activities are affected by organisational culture. Iceland was chosen because prior to this research, its economy was in stage of growth and substantial proportion of GDP was derived from SME activity. In order to answer the objectives, a mixed methods design was used in which senior managers in SMEs were interviewed in the first phase and surveyed, via a questionnaire, in the second phase. The findings confirmed and corroborated the previous literature regarding SMEs as managers were found to be using mostly traditional advertising methods. The results also showed that they were not using systematic methods when planning, budgeting or ii measuring their marketing communications activities. However, some findings were contradictory as managers were also found to be gathering information about their customers and appeared to be interested in what was happening in their field of business abroad.
    [Show full text]
  • KPN's Response to the BEREC Public Consultation on the Draft BEREC
    BEREC Report on Oligopoly analysis and regulation BoR (15)74 KPN response KPN PO Box 30 000 2500 GA The Hague The Netherlands Contact persons: Gera van Duijvenvoorde ([email protected]) Paul Knol ([email protected]) Reference: GCO/15/U/053 31 July 2015 Introduction and summary KPN welcomes the opportunity to provide input to BERECs consultation on the Report on Oligopo- ly analysis and regulation (June 2015). BEREC describes the purpose of the report as twofold: Provide initial assistance to National Regulatory Authorities (NRAs) under the current regu- latory framework on the SMP analysis in ‘oligopolistic markets’; An assessment whether the future regulatory framework to deal ex ante with ‘oligopolistic markets’ should be amended. In its submission to the earlier BEREC questionnaire on the analysis of oligopolistic markets, of January 2015, KPN concluded that the discussion on ‘the regulation of oligopolistic markets’ lacks an adequate problem definition. KPN considered the concept of ‘oligopolies’ as such too broad and unspecified to build any conclusion upon. After reading the current report KPN is not con- vinced that one should conclude that existing regulation should be applied differently. Nor should a future regulatory framework be extended to regulate oligopolies on an ex ante basis. As described in the report the current framework allows ex ante regulatory intervention only if a sufficient level of proof of single or joint significant market power (‘SMP’) has been provided by the NRA. As for joint dominance / joint SMP the criteria have been defined by the ECJ in the Air- tours decision. There is no need or reason to change the standard of proof beyond or below the general threshold in cases of presumed oligopolies.
    [Show full text]