Discovery of a Novel Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitor by Fragment-Based Design and Virtual Screening
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
molecules Article Discovery of a Novel Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitor by Fragment-Based Design and Virtual Screening Georgi Stavrakov 1,2,* , Irena Philipova 2, Atanas Lukarski 1, Mariyana Atanasova 1 , Borislav Georgiev 3, Teodora Atanasova 1, Spiro Konstantinov 1 and Irini Doytchinova 1,* 1 Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, Medical University of Sofia, Sofia 1000, Bulgaria; [email protected]fia.bg (A.L.); [email protected]fia.bg (M.A.); [email protected]fia.bg (T.A.); [email protected]fia.bg (S.K.) 2 Institute of Organic Chemistry with Centre of Phytochemistry, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia 1113, Bulgaria; [email protected] 3 Institute of Biodiversity and Ecosystem Research, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Sofia 1113, Bulgaria; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected]fia.bg (G.S.); [email protected]fia.bg (I.D.) Abstract: Despite extensive and intensive research efforts in recent decades, there is still no effective treatment for neurodegenerative diseases. On this background, the use of drugs inhibiting the enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE) remains an eternal evergreen in the symptomatic treatment of mild to moderate cognitive impairments. Even more, the cholinergic hypothesis, somewhat forgotten in recent years due to the shift in focus on amyloid cascade, is back to life, and the search for new, more Citation: Stavrakov, G.; Philipova, I.; effective AChE inhibitors continues. We generated a fragment-based library containing aromatic Lukarski, A.; Atanasova, M.; moieties and linkers originating from a set of novel AChE inhibitors. We used this library to design Georgiev, B.; Atanasova, T.; 1220 galantamine (GAL) derivatives following the model GAL (binding core) - linker (L) - aromatic Konstantinov, S.; Doytchinova, I. fragment (Ar). The newly designed compounds were screened virtually for blood–brain barrier (BBB) Discovery of a Novel permeability and binding to AChE. Among the top 10 best-scored compounds, a representative lead Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitor by molecule was selected and tested for anti-AChE activity and neurotoxicity. It was found that the Fragment-Based Design and Virtual selected compound was a powerful non-toxic AChE inhibitor, 68 times more active than GAL, and Screening. Molecules 2021, 26, 2058. https://doi.org/10.3390/ could serve as a lead molecule for further optimization and development. molecules26072058 Keywords: acetylcholinesterase inhibitor; fragment-based library; molecular docking; BBB perme- Academic Editors: Irena Kostova and ability; galantamine; neurotoxicity; neuro-2A cell line; Ellman’s method Diego Muñoz-Torrero Received: 8 March 2021 Accepted: 31 March 2021 1. Introduction Published: 3 April 2021 Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) is one of the most active enzymes in the central cholin- ergic system [1]. At the cholinergic synapses, it catalyzes the degradation of the neuro- Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral transmitter acetylcholine (ACh) to choline and acetyl and terminates its action on the with regard to jurisdictional claims in postsynaptic ACh receptors. An extensive network of cortical pyramidal neurons, rich in published maps and institutional affil- AChE, has been observed by histochemical analysis of human brains [2]. It has been found iations. that these neurons are absent at birth and during childhood, gradually emerge during adolescence, reach a maximum in early adulthood, and then gradually decrease in the course of normal aging. In patients with neurodegenerative disorders, a severe loss of cholinergic neurons in the cortex and hippocampus is observed due to abnormal accumu- Copyright: © 2021 by the authors. lation of misfolded proteins like amyloid-β (Aβ), τ-protein, α-synuclein [3–7]. This severe Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. loss is one of the factors responsible for cognitive impairments, typical for Alzheimer’s and This article is an open access article Parkinson’s diseases [8,9]. distributed under the terms and In this regard, the use of drugs able to inhibit the enzyme AChE and hence, to increase conditions of the Creative Commons the levels of ACh in the brain and to improve the cognitive functions has a clear, rational Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// benefit in the treatment of neurodegenerative disorders especially Alzheimer’s disease creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). (AD). Currently, the AChE inhibitors like donepezil, galantamine and rivastigmine, are the Molecules 2021, 26, 2058. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules26072058 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/molecules Molecules 2021, 26, x 2 of 14 disease (AD). Currently, the AChE inhibitors like donepezil, galantamine and rivastig- Molecules 2021, 26, 2058 mine, are the only FDA- and EMA-approved drugs for the symptomatic treatment2 of 14 of mild to moderate cognitive impairments [10]. The levels of AChE inhibition found in pa- tients treated by current AChE inhibitors are less than the minimum of 50% required for effectiveonly FDA- therapy and EMA-approved of AD [11]. Any drugs attempt for the to symptomatic increase the treatment dose to achieve of mild toa moderatebetter AChE inhibitioncognitive results impairments in an increase [10]. The in levels drug of toxicity AChE and inhibition limits foundthe clinical in patients benefits treated [12]. byThus, thecurrent demand AChE for inhibitors more powerful are less thanand theless minimum toxic AChE of 50% inhibitors required is forstill effective an extremely therapy im- portantof AD [11and]. Anyurgent attempt scientific to increase challenge. the dose to achieve a better AChE inhibition results in anGalantamine increase in drug (GAL) toxicity is one and of the limits most the widely clinical prescribed benefits [12 drug]. Thus,s for the treating demand AD for [13]. Apartmore powerfulfrom being and an less AChE toxic inhibitor, AChE inhibitors GAL is is an still allosteric an extremely modulator important of andnicotinic urgent ACh receptorscientific [14 challenge.], has antioxidant properties [15] and facilitates the clearance of Aβ peptide in rat brainsGalantamine [16]. Due (GAL) to this is onevariety of the of mostactions, widely GAL prescribed can serve drugs as а formultitarget treating ADscaffol [13].d to designApart fromnew derivatives being an AChE with inhibitor, a higher GALAChE is inhibitory an allosteric effect modulator and lower of nicotinictoxicity. AChSteadily inreceptor recent [14decades], has antioxidant, GAL is the properties focus of [15 many] and lab facilitates projects the around clearance the of world Aβ peptide aiming in to developrat brains safer [16 ].and Due more to this powerful variety anti of actions,-neurodegenerative GAL can serve agents as a multitarget [17–27]. scaffold to design new derivatives with a higher AChE inhibitory effect and lower toxicity. Steadily in In the present study, we use GAL as a core structure and design a series of deriva- recent decades, GAL is the focus of many lab projects around the world aiming to develop tives to improve the binding affinity to AChE. Several well-defined domains exist in the safer and more powerful anti-neurodegenerative agents [17–27]. deep Inand the narrow present binding study, we site use of GAL AChE. as aAmong core structure them of and greatest design importance a series of derivatives is the active catalyticto improve site the (CAS), binding consisting affinity of to the AChE. triad Several Ser203 well-defined, Glu334 and domains His447, existand responsible in the deep for ACh'sand narrow hydrolysis binding [28 site]. Along of AChE. the Among binding them gorge of greatest are situated importance the anionic, is the active acyclic, catalytic and ox- yanionsite (CAS), domains. consisting Near of the the triadgorge Ser203, entranc Glu334e is placed and His447, the peripheral and responsible anionic for site ACh’s (PAS), whichhydrolysis is associated [28]. Along with the the binding initiation gorge of areamyloidogenesis situated the anionic, [29]. The acyclic, X-ray and structure oxyanion of the complexdomains. rh NearAChE the-GAL gorge [28 entrance] (Figure is1) placedshows thethat peripheral GAL binds anionic at the sitebottom (PAS), of whichthe binding is siteassociated where withthe CAS the initiation is located of amyloidogenesisand fills only one [29-].third The X-rayof the structure binding ofgorge. the complex The GAL ammoniumrhAChE-GAL group [28] (Figure is pointing1) shows towards that GAL the bindsentrance at the of bottomthe binding of the bindinggorge and site is where the only positionthe CAS in is locatedthe GAL and molecule fills only available one-third for of thesubstitution binding gorge. without The affecting GAL ammonium the binding mode.group is pointing towards the entrance of the binding gorge and is the only position in the GAL molecule available for substitution without affecting the binding mode. FigureFigure 1. 1. XX-ray-ray structure structure of the complexcomplex galantaminegalantamine (GAL)- (GALrh)AChE-rhAChE (pdb (pdb code: code: 4ey6). 4ey6). Protein Protein is is givengiven in in gr grayay ribbon, GAL—inGAL—in ball-and-stickball-and-stick colored colored by by element. element. Our previous structure—AChE affinity studies on GAL derivatives showed that the Our previous structure—AChE affinity studies on GAL derivatives showed that the substitution of CH3 group at the quaternary N-atom with a linker containing five to seven substitution of CH3 group at the quaternary N-atom with a linker containing five to seven carboncarbon atoms atoms and ending