DOCSLIB.ORG

Assessing the Impacts of Wind Integration in the Western Provinces

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Assessing the Impacts of Wind Integration in the Western Provinces Assessing the Impacts of Wind Integration in the Western Provinces by Amy Sopinka B.A., Queen’s University, 1992 M.A., McGill University, 1995 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the Department of Geography Amy Sopinka, 2012 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This dissertation may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. ii Supervisory Committee Assessing the Impacts of Wind Integration in the Western Provinces by Amy Sopinka B.A., Queen’s University, 1992 M.A., McGill University, 1995 Supervisory Committee Dr. G. Cornelis van Kooten, (Department of Geography) Supervisor Dr. Kurt Niquidet, (Department of Geography) Departmental Member Dr. David Scoones, (Department of Economics) Outside Member iii Abstract Supervisory Committee Dr. G. Cornelis van Kooten, Department of Geography Supervisor Dr. Kurt Niquidet, Department of Geography Departmental Member Dr. David Scoones, Department of Economics Outside Member Increasing carbon dioxide levels and the fear of irreversible climate change has prompted policy makers to implement renewable portfolio standards. These renewable portfolio standards are meant to encourage the adoption of renewable energy technologies thereby reducing carbon emissions associated with fossil fuel-fired electricity generation. The ability to efficiently adopt and utilize high levels of renewable energy technology, such as wind power, depends upon the composition of the extant generation within the grid. Western Canadian electric grids are poised to integrate high levels of wind and although Alberta has sufficient and, at times, an excess supply of electricity, it does not have the inherent generator flexibility required to mirror the variability of its wind generation. British Columbia, with its large reservoir storage capacities and rapid ramping hydroelectric generation could easily provide the firming services required by Alberta; however, the two grids are connected only by a small, constrained intertie. We use a simulation model to assess the economic impacts of high wind penetrations in the Alberta grid under various balancing protocols. We find that adding iv wind capacity to the system impacts grid reliability, increasing the frequency of system imbalances and unscheduled intertie flow. In order for British Columbia to be viable firming resource, it must have sufficient generation capability to meet and exceed the province’s electricity self-sufficiency requirements. We use a linear programming model to evaluate the province’s ability to meet domestic load under various water and trade conditions. We then examine the effects of drought and wind penetration on the interconnected Alberta – British Columbia system given differing interconnection sizes. v Table of Contents Supervisory Committee ...................................................................................................... ii Abstract .............................................................................................................................. iii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................. v List of Figures .................................................................................................................... xi List of Tables ................................................................................................................... xiii Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................ xv Dedication ........................................................................................................................ xvi Glossary .......................................................................................................................... xvii Chapter 1: The Growth in Wind Capacity ........................................................................... 1 1.0 Introduction ........................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Renewable Energy Standards ............................................................................ 4 1.2 Growth in Wind Capacity .................................................................................. 5 Worldwide ........................................................................................................... 5 United States ........................................................................................................ 7 Canada ................................................................................................................. 7 Western Canada ................................................................................................... 9 1.3 Research Questions .......................................................................................... 19 Research Question One ..................................................................................... 20 Research Question Two ..................................................................................... 21 Research Question Three ................................................................................... 22 1.4 Methods ........................................................................................................... 23 Simulation .......................................................................................................... 23 vi Mathematical Programming Models ................................................................ 24 1.5 Outline of the Thesis ........................................................................................ 24 Chapter 2: The Alberta and British Columbia (Weakly) Connected Grids ....................... 26 2.0 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 26 2.1 The Alberta Interconnected System ................................................................. 26 History of Electricity Market Deregulation in Alberta ...................................... 27 The Electric Utilities Act ................................................................................... 29 Stranded Benefits ............................................................................................... 29 Obligations and Entitlements: 1996 to 2000 ..................................................... 30 The Power Purchase Arrangements and Auction .............................................. 31 MAP I, MAP II and MAP III ............................................................................ 34 Current Market Operations ................................................................................ 36 2.2 Alberta's Markets for Energy and Ancillary Services ..................................... 37 System Marginal Price ....................................................................................... 39 Offers to Increase Supply .................................................................................. 40 Bids to Reduce Demand .................................................................................... 40 Supply Surplus ................................................................................................... 41 SMP and Pool Price ........................................................................................... 41 2.3 System Operations in a High Wind Environment ........................................... 42 System Operations with Operational Certainty and No Interconnections ......... 42 Net Imports ........................................................................................................ 43 Planned Maintenance, Forced Outages and Critical Failures ............................ 44 System Operation with Wind ............................................................................ 45 vii Dispatch Example .............................................................................................. 47 2.4 Alberta Price Dynamics ................................................................................... 48 2.5 Ancillary Market for Operating Reserves ........................................................ 52 Active Reserve Pricing ...................................................................................... 55 Standby Reserve Pricing .................................................................................... 55 Transmission Must Run ..................................................................................... 56 2.6 Wheeling .......................................................................................................... 58 2.7 British Columbia Electric Grid ........................................................................ 60 Exports ............................................................................................................... 62 Mid-Columbia Market ....................................................................................... 63 California ........................................................................................................... 65 2.8 Conclusions...................................................................................................... 68 Chapter 3: Estimating the Economic Costs of Increased Wind Penetration in Thermally Dependent Grids ...............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Salmon Inlet Landscape Unit Plan for Old Growth Management Areas
    Salmon Landscape Unit Plan For Old Growth Management Areas Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations South Coast Region December 2014 i Acknowledgements The Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations recognises the following participants and contributors, without which the completion of this Landscape Unit Plan would not have been possible: Interfor Corporation (formerly known as International Forest Products Limited: Brynna Check, RPF; Kevin Stachoski, RPF A&A Trading: Dave Marquis, RPF Tania Pollock, RPF, Warren Hansen, RPF Eric Ralph; Michelle Mico, RPBio; Wayne Wall, RPBio; Laslo Kardos, and Melinda McClung for their work on the original plan in 2005 Province of British Columbia: Chuck Anderson, RPF; Cris Greenwell; Lew Greentree; Steve Gordon, RPBio ii Executive Summary The Salmon Inlet Landscape Unit is situated on the North and South sides of Salmon Inlet on the southern mainland coast (see FIGURE 1). The Landscape Unit (LU) covers a total of 64,995 hectares (ha), excluding ocean, and is within the Pacific Range Ecoregion1. Watersheds included within the LU that drain into Salmon Inlet are Clowhom River, Misery Creek, Sechelt Creek, Taquat Creek, Red Tusk Creek, Thornhill Creek, Slippery Creek and Dempster Creek. Coastal Western Hemlock (CWH) and Mountain Hemlock (MH) Biologeoclimatic Ecosystem Classification (BEC) zones with Natural Disturbance Types (NDT1 and NDT2)2 are located within this LU. There is also a significant amount of high elevation non-forested areas in NDT 5. Four protected areas, Sechelt Inlet Marine Park Thornhill and Kunechin Point sites, Tetrahedron Park, and Tantalus Park are within the Salmon Inlet LU. Portions of Kunechin Point, Tetrahedron Park, and Tantalus Park were identified as having suitable characteristics for biodiversity conservation.
    [Show full text]
  • Bcts Dcr, Dsc
    Radio Channel Assignment Map DCR, DSC, DSI Version 10.8 BCTS January 30, 2015 BC Timber Sales W a d d i Strait of Georgia n g t o n G l a 1:400,000 c Date Saved: 2/3/2015 9:55:56 AM i S e c r a r Path: F:\tsg_root\GIS_Workspace\Mike\Radio_Frequency\Radio Frequency_2015.mxd C r e e k KLATTASINE BARB HO WARD A A T H K O l MTN H O M l LANDMAR K a i r r C e t l e a n R CAMBRIDG E t e R Wh i E C V A r I W R K A 7 HIDD EN W E J I C E F I E L D Homathko r C A IE R HEAK E T STANTON PLATEAU A G w r H B T TEAQ UAHAN U O S H N A UA Q A E 8 T H B R O I M Southgate S H T N O K A P CUMSACK O H GALLEO N GUNS IGHT R A E AQ V R E I T R r R I C V E R R MT E H V a RALEIG H SAWT rb S tan I t R o l R A u e E HO USE r o B R i y l I l V B E S E i 4 s i R h t h o 17 S p r O G a c l e Bear U FA LCO N T H G A Stafford R T E R E V D I I R c R SMIT H O e PEAK F Bear a KETA B l l F A T SIR FRANCIS DRAKE C S r MT 2 ke E LILLO OE T La P L rd P fo A af St Mellersh Creek PEAKS TO LO r R GRANITE C E T ST J OHN V MTN I I V E R R 12 R TAHUMMING R E F P i A l R Bute East PORTAL E e A L D S R r A E D PEAK O O A S I F R O T T Glendale 11 R T PRATT S N O N 3 S E O M P Phillip I I T Apple River T O L A B L R T H A I I SIRE NIA E U H V 11 ke Po M L i P E La so M K n C ne C R I N re N L w r ro ek G t B I OSMINGTO N I e e Call Inlet m 28 R l o r T e n T E I I k C Orford V R E l 18 V E a l 31 Toba I R C L R Fullmore 5 HEYDON R h R o George 30 Orford River I Burnt Mtn 16 I M V 12 V MATILPI Browne E GEORGE RIVER E R Bute West R H Brem 13 ke Bute East La G 26 don ey m H r l l e U R
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of Techniques for Flood Quantile Estimation in Canada
    Evaluation of Techniques for Flood Quantile Estimation in Canada by Shabnam Mostofi Zadeh A thesis presented to the University of Waterloo in fulfillment of the thesis requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Civil Engineering Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 2019 ©Shabnam Mostofi Zadeh 2019 Examining Committee Membership The following are the members who served on the Examining Committee for this thesis. The decision of the Examining Committee is by majority vote. External Examiner Veronica Webster Associate Professor Supervisor Donald H. Burn Professor Internal Member William K. Annable Associate Professor Internal Member Liping Fu Professor Internal-External Member Kumaraswamy Ponnambalam Professor ii Author’s Declaration This thesis consists of material all of which I authored or co-authored: see Statement of Contributions included in the thesis. This is a true copy of the thesis, including any required final revisions, as accepted by my examiners. I understand that my thesis may be made electronically available to the public. iii Statement of Contributions Chapter 2 was produced by Shabnam Mostofi Zadeh in collaboration with Donald Burn. Shabnam Mostofi Zadeh conceived of the presented idea, developed the models, carried out the experiments, and performed the computations under the supervision of Donald Burn. Donald Burn contributed to the interpretation of the results and provided input on the written manuscript. Chapter 3 was completed in collaboration with Martin Durocher, Postdoctoral Fellow of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Waterloo, Donald Burn of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Waterloo, and Fahim Ashkar, of University of Moncton. The original ideas in this work were jointly conceived by the group.
    [Show full text]
  • 396 BC Hydro Independent Power Producers (IPP) Supply Map (Bates No
    DOCKETED Docket 16-RPS-02 Number: Project Title: Appeal by Los Angeles Department of Water & Power re Renewables Portfolio Standard Certification Eligibility TN #: 213752 Document Title: 396 BC Hydro Independent Power Producers (IPP) Supply Map (Bates No. LA002914) Description: Map Filer: Pjoy Chua Organization: LADWP Submitter Role: Applicant Submission 9/21/2016 4:05:12 PM Date: Docketed Date: 9/21/2016 i n i h s n r e e v h i s R t Kelsall a L T TAGISH Kelsall G la R LAKE d YUKON y Alsek s TESL IN Taku Gladys S wi Arm Lake ft R Hall L S urprise R L LAKE Fantail L eria ATLIN h N W T c n a R Atlin R Crow R LAATL ittle KE L R R Maxhamish L Petitot R ladys R G River O 88 J ' enn D lue o l B Thinahtea nne ings L LIARDmith River S Grayling River R Sahd River T e Tsea Sloko R s oanah A l R i sh Cr Red Thetlaandoa Sloko n L R y ina k R a C N Rabbit RIVER o se Cr t lundeber t R G wood R o ea apid n D T Cr Cr uya w FORT Kwokullie o I L o Dead L d R n R R k R l i n NELS h ile N a l River M i n Meek Taku Kotcho R iver L ON Saht Lake Net D R udi R our M uncho iver F R R son dontu aneh Lake River ahine Kechika utl agle S E Cry L Kledo S R Kotcho Dall Cr he Dease T urn Toad Cr FORT NELSON IPP SUPPLY again slay T R River uya R acing R Lake iver WSP 1L357 RIVE KLC Cr R FNG Kyklo Hay K utcho FNC R DLK B wa eat R Denetiah R R TO 86 R 1L359 ty L G ataga ALBERTA Musk Elleh LEGEND illa Cr R Cr anz Cr Cheves T R R iver R Prophet an R lt R EXISTING ah R Fontas River T IPPs with BC Hydro contracts (Total Number 131) ALBERTA O/HEAD OTHER R CABLE ucho rog T F w UTILITIES ide RI r o K 500 kV No.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nathan E. Stewart and Its Oil Spill MARCH 2017 HEILTSUK NATION PHOTO: APRIL BENCZE
    PHOTO: KYLE ARTELLE PHOTO: KYLE HEILTSUK TRIBAL COUNCIL INVESTIGATION REPORT: The 48 hours after the grounding of the Nathan E. Stewart and its oil spill MARCH 2017 HEILTSUK NATION PHOTO: APRIL BENCZE A life ring from the Nathan E. Stewart floating in sheen of diesel oil. **Details regarding the photographs contained in this report are contained in the Schedule of Photographs located at the end of this document. TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 GLOSSARY 4 6.0 HEILTSUK NATION’S POSITION 31 1.1. GLOSSARY OF ORGANIZATIONS 4 ON OIL TANKERS 1.2. GLOSSARY OF VESSELS 4 6.1. MARINE USE PLAN 31 1.3. LIST OF SCHEDULES 5 6.2. SUPPORT FOR A TANKER 31 MORATORIUM 2.0 HEILTSUK NATION JURISDICTION 7 6.3. ENBRIDGE NORTHERN GATEWAY 31 PIPELINE PROJECT 3.0 INVESTIGATION 9 3.1. DOCUMENTS 9 7.0 GALE PASS AND SEAFORTH 32 3.1.1. Requests 9 CHANNEL 3.1.2. Limited Access to 16 7.1. LOCATION OF INCIDENT 32 IAP Software 7.2. CHIEFTAINSHIP OF AREA 33 3.2. INTERVIEWS 16 3.2.1. Requests 16 8.0 EVENTS OF OCTOBER 13, 2016 36 3.2.2. Witnesses 16 (DAY 1) 8.1. CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS 36 4.0 NATHAN E. STEWART AND DBL-55 17 8.2. SPECIFIC ISSUES 42 4.1. KIRBY CORPORATION 17 4.1.1. Tug and Barge Business 17 9.0 EVENTS OF OCTOBER 14, 2016 44 4.1.2. Oil Spill History 18 (DAY 2) 4.2. NATHAN E. STEWART AND DBL-55 20 9.1. CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS 44 4.2.1.
    [Show full text]
  • Scale Site SS Region SS District Site Name SS Location Phone
    Scale SS SS Site Region District Site Name SS Location Phone 001 RCB DQU MISC SITES SIFR 01B RWC DQC ABFAM TEMP SITE SAME AS 1BB 2505574201 1001 ROM DPG BKB CEDAR Road past 4G3 on the old Lamming Ce 2505690096 1002 ROM DPG JOHN DUNCAN RESIDENCE 7750 Lower Mud river Road. 1003 RWC DCR PROBYN LOG LTD. Located at WFP Menzies#1 Scale Site 1004 RWC DCR MATCHLEE LTD PARTNERSHIP Tsowwin River estuary Tahsis Inlet 2502872120 1005 RSK DND TOMPKINS POST AND RAIL Across the street from old corwood 1006 RWC DNI CANADIAN OVERSEAS FOG CREEK - North side of King Isla 6046820425 1007 RKB DSE DYNAMIC WOOD PRODUCTS 1839 Brilliant Road Castlegar BC 2503653669 1008 RWC DCR ROBERT (ANDY) ANDERSEN Mobile Scale Site for use in marine 1009 ROM DPG DUNKLEY- LEASE OF SITE 411 BEAR LAKE Winton Bear lake site- Current Leas 2509984421 101 RWC DNI WESTERN FOREST PRODUCTS INC. MAHATTA RIVER (Quatsino Sound) - Lo 2502863767 1010 RWC DCR WESTERN FOREST PRODUCTS INC. STAFFORD Stafford Lake , end of Loughborough 2502863767 1011 RWC DSI LADYSMITH WFP VIRTUAL WEIGH SCALE Latitude 48 59' 57.79"N 2507204200 1012 RWC DNI BELLA COOLA RESOURCE SOCIETY (Bella Coola Community Forest) VIRT 2509822515 1013 RWC DSI L AND Y CUTTING EDGE MILL The old Duncan Valley Timber site o 2507151678 1014 RWC DNI INTERNATIONAL FOREST PRODUCTS LTD Sandal Bay - Water Scale. 2 out of 2502861881 1015 RWC DCR BRUCE EDWARD REYNOLDS Mobile Scale Site for use in marine 1016 RWC DSI MUD BAY COASTLAND VIRTUAL W/S Ladysmith virtual site 2507541962 1017 RWC DSI MUD BAY COASTLAND VIRTUAL W/S Coastland Virtual Weigh Scale at Mu 2507541962 1018 RTO DOS NORTH ENDERBY TIMBER Malakwa Scales 2508389668 1019 RWC DSI HAULBACK MILLYARD GALIANO 200 Haulback Road, DL 14 Galiano Is 102 RWC DNI PORT MCNEILL PORT MCNEILL 2502863767 1020 RWC DSI KURUCZ ROVING Roving, Port Alberni area 1021 RWC DNI INTERNATIONAL FOREST PRODUCTS LTD-DEAN 1 Dean Channel Heli Water Scale.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Harbour Spiel January 2020 Issue
    LOCALLY OWNED & OPERATED The independent voice of HARBOUR Pender Harbour & Egmont January 2020 since 1990. SPIEL Issue 349 Denise Brynelsen 604.740.1219 We stand apart from the rest Joel O’Reilly 604.741.1837 by selling the very best! Personal Real Estate Corporations Sussex www.brynelsenoreilly.com “We have the tools to market your home and we are willing to invest the time, the money and the resources to do so.” SOLD Gorgeous ocean views from this 1920 Architecturally designed 4 bdrm/3 bath cottage situated on over 1 acre of privacy. waterfront home with 218’ of shoreline. Garden Bay $448,000 Madeira Park $1,698,000 SOLD Immaculate condition! Like new 2 bed/2 Incredible waterfront property w/ 1,000’ bath on a level, sunny 1/3 acre. of frontage & 3 homes, set on 1.23 acres. Madeira Park $398,000 Madeira Park $1,750,000 SOLD Architecturally designed home at “Whit- 17+ acre private estate in quiet com- takers” w/ private moorage & ocean views. munity. Zoned for 30+ 1/2 acre lots. Garden Bay $1,365,000 Garden Bay $1,100,000 883-9100 OPEN DAILY • 8:30 am - 7 pm 4-plus acres of waterfront with 2 homes, Fabulous 4 bedroom waterfront home at spectacular views & privacy. Farrington Cove w/ deep water moorage. Like us on Middlepoint $2,888,000 Garden Bay $1,290,000 Facebook Open until 8 pm Fridays. @ Marketplace IGA Madeira Park To view all of our listings, visit www.brynelsenoreilly.com Page 2 Harbour Spiel editorial HARBOUR Predictions for 2020 SPIEL Brian Lee • Human-caused climate change is revealed to be a hoax.
    [Show full text]
  • History of the Provincial Forest Inventory Program
    A HISTORY OF THE BRITISH COLUMBIA PROVINCIAL FOREST INVENTORY PROGRAM* PART TWO THE POGUE ERA: 1940 - 1960 Written by ROBERT E. BREADON “Too bad it isn’t morning, so we could fly at ‘er again!” Mickey Pogue et al. MAY 2017 THE ORIGINAL WORK WAS COMPLETED IN 1995 © Forest History Association of British Columbia, Victoria, B.C. *This version contains some changes made to the final edit by Jacy Eberlein, who digitized and created this file in July 2014 using a printed copy lent by Bob Breadon. Formatting, design and additional editing were carried out by John Parminter in 2016 and 2017. ii INTRODUCTION In 1991, while gathering material for articles on the early history of the Research Branch of the B.C. Forest Service, I began to realize that many old-timers of the 1920s and 1930s were still active and alert. I also discovered that several had worked in both the research and forest surveys divisions. A little more digging indicated that there were still around 30 survivors who had worked in forest surveys during the pre-war period. I felt that it would be worthwhile for someone to interview these old-timers, and preserve a record of their experiences in the B.C. Forest Service while the opportunity still existed. I discussed the matter with Dave Gilbert, Director of the current Resource Inventory Branch, and he concurred. He also felt that any history project of this nature should cover events right up to the present time. I then commenced to seek a volunteer to write the next section of the project.
    [Show full text]
  • Local Fish and Wildlife Projects Receive $175,000
    For Immediate Release May 5, 2014 Local Fish and Wildlife Projects Receive $175,000 SQUAMISH – Fish and wildlife projects in the Cheakamus River Watershed and Clowhom Lake area being given close to $175,000 through the Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program (FWCP). The Squamish River Watershed Society will use the funds to create spawning and rearing habitat for Coho, Chinook, Pink and Chum Salmon, as well as Cutthroat and Steelhead Trout in the Cheakamus River. The Clowhom Lake project will help conserve Western Screech Owls, Northern Goshawks, bats and wetlands. Projects funded in Squamish area watersheds start this spring and conclude by early 2015. They are among 31 fish and wildlife projects approved for more than $1.7 million in funding this year in the FWCP’s Coastal Region, which includes the Squamish area. Learn more at www.fwcp.ca. QUOTES: Jordan Sturdy, MLA for West Vancouver-Sea to Sky “The natural resource wealth of British Columbia is what built this province and what will sustain us in the future. The Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program recognizes the need to support and enhance habitats so that our natural heritage will continue to benefit our province for generations to come.” Brian Assu, Chair, FWCP – Coastal Region Board "Salmon stocks are of great importance to First Nations and others, and these projects will support stocks in local watersheds. We are fortunate to have strong working partnerships with conservation groups and others working to make a real difference in these watersheds.” Patrice Rother, Manager, Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program “We are pleased with the interest in the FWCP and the quality of project proposals that support the FWCP vision of thriving populations in watersheds that are functioning and sustainable.” A few facts about the Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program • The Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program funds conservation and enhancement projects in the Coastal, Columbia River and Peace River regions.
    [Show full text]
  • ARC88 International Forest Products Ltd (FL A19220)/ 9096 Investments
    Audit of Timber Harvesting and Road Construction, Maintenance and Deactivation International Forest Products Ltd. 9096 Investments Ltd. Forest Licence A19220 (affiliated with Homalco First Nation) Terminal Forest Products Ltd. F.A.B. Logging Co. Ltd. Forest Licence A19229 Timber Sale Licence A20492 Northwest Hardwoods (a division of Weyerhaeuser Company Ltd.) Non- Replaceable Forest Licence A47297 FPB/ARC/88 April 2007 Table of Contents Board Commentary.....................................................................................................................1 Audit Results...............................................................................................................................3 Background ...............................................................................................................................3 Audit Approach and Scope........................................................................................................6 Planning and Practices Examined.............................................................................................6 Audit Opinion.............................................................................................................................8 Appendix 1: Forest Practices Board Compliance Audit Process..........................................9 Forest Practices Board FPB/ARC/88 i Board Commentary In fall 2006, the Board conducted a limited scope compliance audit of five forest tenure holders in the Sunshine Coast Forest District (see map on page
    [Show full text]
  • Screening Tool to Identify Lower Risk Withdrawals from Lakes in Alberta and Northeast BC
    Screening Tool to Identify Low Risk Withdrawals from Lakes in Alberta and Northeast British Columbia March 2016 Prepared for: Petroleum Technology Alliance Canada Calgary, Alberta and British Columbia Oil and Gas Research and Innovation Society Victoria, British Columbia #200 - 850 Harbourside Drive, North Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V7P 0A3 • Tel: 1.604.926.3261 • Fax: 1.604.926.5389 • www.hatfi eldgroup.com SCREENING TOOL TO IDENTIFY LOW RISK WITHDRAWALS FROM LAKES IN ALBERTA AND NORTHEAST BRITISH COLUMBIA Prepared for: PETROLEUM TECHNOLOGY ALLIANCE CANADA SUITE 400, CHEVRON PLAZA 500 – FIFTH AVENUE S.W. CALGARY, AB T2P 3L5 BRITISH COLUMBIA OIL AND GAS RESEARCH AND INNOVATION SOCIETY # 300, 398 HARBOUR ROAD VICTORIA, BC V9A 0B7 Prepared by: HATFIELD CONSULTANTS #200 - 850 HARBOURSIDE DRIVE NORTH VANCOUVER, BC CANADA V7P 0A3 MARCH 2016 PTAC7367 VERSION 5 #200 - 850 Harbourside Drive, North Vancouver, BC, Canada V7P 0A3 • Tel: 1.604.926.3261 • Toll Free: 1.866.926.3261 • Fax: 1.604.926.5389 • www.hatfieldgroup.com TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................................ iii LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................... iii LIST OF APPENDICES ....................................................................................... iv LIST OF ACRONYMS ............................................................................................v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Mmsi Vessel Name 316016637
    MMSI VESSEL NAME 316016637 (NO NAME) 316015977 (NO NAME) 25K72711 316023428 [NO NAME] 316014178 [NO NAME] 26K6002 316029097 11K117438 316002713 12K3789 316003869 13K 114201 316009098 13K101581 316026963 13K103561 316026368 13K103957 316025709 13K113397 316008334 13K113457 316029599 13K113730 316004208 13K113963 316001348 13K114054 316003925 13K114465 316003288 13K116747 316015384 13K116853 316009459 13K118467 316006099 13K118720 316025193 13K119330 316009093 13K119592 316007675 13K119794 316029479 13K31140 316013192 13K47221 316025572 13K62754 316012088 13K90506 316018364 13K96395 316018315 14K38261 316007368 14K41267 316010998 14K41341 316011547 15K5456 316004555 15K7380 316003086 15K7394 316004724 15K7690 316005536 15K7986 316011218 15K8698 316005035 17K2546 316029098 17K7641 316011508 17K8128 316028121 180BR‐2625 316001240 1999‐02 316029053 19TH HOLE 316029075 19TH HOLE 316005362 1H26768 316234000 1K 3307 316009661 1K3693 316026983 1K4181 316005956 1K4428 316001456 1K727 316012874 1ST OFFENCE 316029787 2 DREAM 316009218 2 MUCH DRAFT 316015376 2 OUTRAGEOUS 316008342 2 PIECES OF EIGHT 316011593 2 REEL 2 316013023 2 TANGO 316029394 2004 LARSON 260 316028393 21 FT STRIPPER 316031217 215 EXPLORER 316006485 215 WEEKENDER 316025817 22 CHAPARRAL 316021665 22 TANGO 316026656 2301 STRIPER 316010927 23K6588 316008335 25K4696 316022231 25K7360 316011331 27K1694 316026831 28 BAYLINER 316027226 2H83258 316019344 2ND BEST 316004211 2ND CHAPTER 316014093 2ND PHASE 316022716 2REEL 316011993 30 SOMETHING 316017062 300 EXPRESS 316001281 30K5728 316001196
    [Show full text]