FIDS Report 93-6
Forest Insect and Disease Conditions Vancouver Forest Region • 1992 Rod Turnquist and Dennis Clarke
Forestry Forêts lel Canada Canada Canada Table of Contents
Page
VANCOUVER MAINLAND AND VANCOUVER ISLAND
FOREWORD 3 INTRODUCTION 4 SUMMARY 4 DOUGLAS-FIR PESTS 7 Western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis 7 Douglas-fir beetle, Dendroctonus pseudotsugae 10 Douglas-fir tussock moth, Rusty tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata, 0. antiqua badia 12 Laminated root rot, Armillaria root rot, Phellinus weirii, Armillaria ostoyae 13 Abiotic damage 14
PINE PESTS 14 Mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae 14 Pine sawfly, Neodiprion nanalus contortae 15 European pine shoot moth, Rhyacionia buoliana 17
SPRUCE PESTS 17 Spruce beetle, Dendroctonus rufipennis 17 Spruce weevil, Pissodes strobi 17 Spruce aphid, Elatobium abietinum 18
TRUE FIR PESTS 18 Western balsam bark beetle, Dryocoetes confusus 18 Balsam woolly adelgid, Adelges piceae 18 Needle blights, Isthmiella sp., Phaeocryptopus nudus 19
CEDAR PESTS 19 Cedar leaf blight, Didymascella thujina 19 Cedar flagging 19
HEMLOCK PEST 19 Western blackheaded budworm, Acleris gloverana 19
SPECIAL SURVEYS 21 Pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus 21 Acid rain plots 21 Pests of young stands 23 Seed orchards 23
DECIDUOUS TREE PESTS 26 Gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar 26 Winter moth, Operophtera brumata 26 Cottonwood sawfly, Nematus currani 27 Bigleaf maple scorch and leafspots, Xylella fastidiosa, Rhytisma punctatum, Cristulariella depradens 27 Western winter moth, Erranis tiliaria vancouverensis 28 Dogwood leaf blight, Discula destructiva 28 Birch leafminers, Fenusa pusilla, Profenusa thomsoni 29 Fall webworm, Hyphantria cunea 29 Jumping gall wasp, Neuroterus saltatorius 29 An oak leaf phylloxeran, Phylloxera sp. near glabra 30
NEW RECORDS OF OCCURRENCE AND DISTRIBUTION 30
OTHER NOTEWORTHY AND MINOR PESTS 31
QUEEN CHARLO FIE ISLANDS
SUMMARY 33
HEMLOCK PESTS 33 Western blackheaded budworm, Acleris gloverana 33 Hemlock sawfly, Neodiprion tsugae 34 Hemlock dwarf mistletoe, Arceuthobium tsugense 34
SPRUCE PESTS 34 Spruce aphid, Elatobium abietinum 34 Cooley-spruce gall adelgid, Adelges cooleyi 35 Spruce needle blight, Lirula macrospora 35 Large-spored spruce-Labrador tea rust, Chrysomyxa ledicola 35
PESTS OF YOUNG STANDS 35
MINOR PESTS 37
APPENDICES 39 Foreward
Forest Insect and Disease Survey (FIDS) is For the Vancouver Island district: a nation-wide network within Forestry Canada with the responsibility of: (1) producing an Forest Insect and Disease Survey overview of forest pest conditions and their Forestry Canada implications including predictions where possi- Kye Bay, R.R.#1 ble; (2) maintaining records and surveys to sup- Comox, B.C. port quarantines; (3) supporting forestry V9N-5N1 Ph. 339-4722 research with field studies, records, Herbarium and Insectary collections; (4) providing advice For the Queen Charlotte Islands: and extension on forest insect and disease con- ditions; (5) developing and testing survey tech- Forest Insect and Disease Survey niques; (6) and conducting related biological Forestry Canada and impact studies, Box #23, Terrace, B.C.
During the year, correspondence and V8G-4A2 Ph. 635-7660 inquiries regarding forest pest problems, and requests for publications can be directed to For the Bella Coola/Mid-Coast area: FIDS headquarters at: Forest Insect and Disease Survey Pacific Forestry Centre Forestry Canada Forestry Canada Sidcum sub., Comp. 33, R.R. #3 506 West Burnside Road Williams Lake, B.C. Victoria, B.C. V2G-1 M3 Ph. 392-6067 V8Z-1 M5 Ph. 363-0600
During the field season, May to October, inquiries can be directed to the FIDS field sta- tions.
For the Vancouver Mainland district:
Forest Insect and Disease Survey Forestry Canada P.O. Box 692 Agassiz, B.C. VOM-1A0 Ph. 796-2042 The Queen Charlotte Islands section, Introduction included seperately in this report, was submitted by the Prince Rupert west FIDS Ranger, John This report outlines the status of forest pest Vallentgoed. The annual survey of the Queen conditions in the Vancouver Forest Region for Charlotte Islands was conducted from July 13 to 1992 and forecasts population trends of some 24. Insect and disease data from the Mid-coast Forest District was collected by Cariboo FIDS potentially damaging pests. Pests are listed by host in order of importance with emphasis given Ranger, Bob Erickson. FIDS insectary biologist, to those capable of sudden damaging out- Robert Duncan contributed to the sections on breaks. Most of the information was gathered the oak leaf phylloxeran and the jumping gall wasp as well as providing information on the through the monitoring of already known or recently reported insect or disease problems; winter moth situation in the Greater Victoria the detection of pest problems through travels area. The FIDS pathologist/mycologist Dr. through the region; annual aerial surveys during Brenda Callan contributed to the bigleaf maple scorch and leafspot section. The author wishes which major pest problems are mapped for area and severity; and several special surveys and to acknowledge the support of the British Columbia Ministry of Forests which assisted collections. with air transportation and Scott Paper Ltd., Special surveys carried out during the field which assisted with ground transportation and season included: inspections of provincial parks, defoliator and disease sampling. ecological reserves, seed orchards and acid rain Defoliation intensities are referred to a num- plots; pheromone trapping of spruce budworm, gypsy moth and Douglas-fir tussock moth; ber of times in the report are defined as follows: Douglas-fir tussock moth egg mass surveys; Trace - evidence of feeding barely poplar pest surveys; young stand surveys; detectable close up European pine shoot moth and pine shoot beetle Light - some branch and/or upper crown surveys at Christmas tree farms and; pinewood defoliation, barely visible from the air nematode surveys at log sort yards. Additionally, Moderate - pronounced discoloration and many enquiries from public and industry were noticeably thin foliage, severe top defoliation investigated with pest identification and, where Severe - top and many branches completely possible, control advice provided. Cooperation was also extended to a graduate student from defoliated, most trees more than 50% defoliated Simon Fraser University doing pheromone trap- ping studies on the western hemlock looper. Summary Special collections made during the field season included woodborers and woodborer infested material, pinewood nematode samples, This summary of pest conditions in the cottonwood sawfly larvae, maple leaf scorch, Vancouver Forest Region in 1992 includes a Douglas-fir tussock moth larvae, spruce weevil summary of weather conditions and lists the infested leaders, and worms. These collections most damaging pests, generally in order of contributed to current and continuing studies at importance by host affected. the Pacific Forestry Centre and other research institutes. The winter of 1991-92 and the 1992 grow- ing season were marked by noticeably warmer The forest pest survey field season extend- than normal temperatures. Mean tempera- ed from early May to late September. One hun- tures at the Vancouver, Victoria, and Port Hardy dred and sixty insect and 140 disease collec- Airports from October 1991 to March 1992 were tions were submitted to the Pacific Forestry warmer than the 30 year (1951-80) average by Centre by FIDS personnel. Figure 1 shows the 21, 21, and 19% respectively. Temperatures at locations where samples were collected and the these locations from April to September 1992, area covered by 11 hours of fixed-wing aircraft (considered to be the growing season) were surveys. warmer than the 30 year average by 8, 7, and VANCOUVER FOREST REGION
0 40 80 km
FOREST INSECT AND DISEASE SURVEY
Figure 1. Locations where one or more forest insect and disease samples were collected and areas covered by aerial surveys to map bark beetle and defoliator infestations in 1992. 8% respectively. These warmer temperatures Balsam bark beetle killed mature alpine fir probably contributed to the marked increase in over 625 ha, down from 1105 recorded in 1991, defoliator populations and resulting damage mostly in the Fraser TSA. New balsam woolly seen regionally this year. adelgid quarantine zone boundaries have offi- cially been adopted. Also, populations and Western spruce budworm lightly to damaged trees were found for the first time on severely defoliated mostly Douglas-fir over Lasqueti Island. Needle blights were 21 130 ha, an almost fourfold increase from the widespread on amabilis fir near Sayward on 5850 ha recorded in 1991. Defoliation increased Vancouver Island and in watersheds in greater in most previously infested stands in the Vancouver. Birkenhead River area and expanded signifi- cantly up the Lillooet River valley north of Western blackheaded budworm popula- Pemberton. New areas of defoliation were also tions remained at endemic levels following their mapped in the Nahatlatch River valley near collapse last year. Boston Bar. Top-kill of up to 3m was recorded on up to 40% of trees in areas that have suf- Cedar leaf blight infections were similar to fered repeated defoliation. Although the area of those recorded in 1991 while the incidence of Douglas-fir beetle attacks declined to 170 ha cedar flagging increased. from 240 ha recorded in 1991, the number of infestations increased to 210 from 57 in 1991. Pinewood nematode surveys concentrat- Douglas-fir and rusty tussock moth popula- ed on western hemlock and its susceptibility to tions in the Fraser Valley collapsed by mid-sum- attack by sawyer beetles. Assessments at 10 mer in the third year of high populations. Some acid rain national early warning system light to moderate defoliation was recorded (ARNEWS) plots in the region found no evi- before the collapse. A nuclear polyhedrosis dence of acid rain damage. Additionally, one virus (NPV), along with direct control action at new ARNEWS plot was established in the two golf courses, contributed to the collapse. Vancouver region. Fifteen seed orchards were Root rots, a common and ongoing widespread visited at least once for the detection of pests, problem in both young and mature stands, were some of which included balsam woolly found in various locations region-wide. Multiple adelgid, cooley spruce gall adelgid, and the tops resulting from previous winter-killed termi- hemlock woolly adelgid. A total of 36 young nal buds were recorded at several locations in stands were surveyed for pest problems, two of the southwestern part of the region. which were abiotic damage and needle dis- eases. Mountain pine beetle killed an estimated 15 000 trees over 775 ha in 152 infestations, up from Gypsy moth traps were placed at 105 loca- 7000 trees over 465 ha in 71 infestations in 1991. tions by FIDS staff throughout the region. Three Most mortality continues to occur in the Soo adult males were caught in traps placed in the Timber Supply Area (TSA). Pine sawfly caused lower mainland. As well, about 163 adult males moderate to severe defoliation in a 15-to 20-year- were caught in traps placed by Agriculture old stand at Spuzzum Creek, northwest of Yale. Canada in various locations on Vancouver There was no further recorded spread of Island and the lower mainland. All of these European pine shoot moth populations in native adults were European, no Asian biotype adults trees at Richmond. Infested Scots and Austrian were trapped this year. Winter moth popula- pine were found in the same general area. tions increased on the lower mainland causing patchy light to moderate defoliation in, widely Spruce bark beetle populations remained scattered areas. Damage on Vancouver Island low for the seventh consecutive year. About remained similar to last year. Western winter 2 ha of recent mortality were recorded in the moth populations collapsed, there was no Mid-Coast Forest District. Spruce weevil popu- recorded defoliation at any previously infested lations continued to cause significant leader mor- sites. Severe scorching of Garry oak by the tality throughout the host range. Spruce aphid jumping gall wasp in the the Capital Region populations increased, causing widespread light continued for the seventh consecutive year. to severe defoliation in coastal areas. Damage was also reported for the first time near Duncan and Nanaimo. Oak leaf phylloxeran Defoliation continued at levels higher than or spread to Comox, but damage levels in Greater similar to 1991 in the Haylmore-Spruce-Eight Victoria remained similar to those recorded last Mile creeks area and in the Birkenhead-Gates year. Defoliation by a cottonwood sawfly on rivers and Sockeye Creek areas while declin- islands in the Fraser River in the Chilliwack- ing slightly in the Blackwater-Phelix creeks Agassiz area increased to 685 ha of light to area (Table 1). These latter areas are the severe damage, up from 50 ha recorded in some of oldest defoliated during this outbreak. 1991. Dogwood leaf blight infections contin- ued at moderate to high levels throughout the In the Fraser TSA, defoliation increased host range. The incidence and intensity of and was recorded in several new locations. bigleaf maple scorch and Ieafspot increased New defoliation, consisting of two patches of in lower mainland areas while remaining similar mainly light and one small area of severe, were to levels recorded last year on Vancouver recorded near Hannah and Francis lakes. One Island. Fall webworm populations continued new area of light defoliation was seen on south- at high levels throughout the region, especially west facing slopes above the Nahatlatch River in the upper Fraser Valley. in the Four-Barrel main area. A very small area of light defoliation was again recorded near A table summarizing other noteworthy Hannah Creek. and minor pests is included in this report, as well as a summary of occurrences of new The 21 130 ha recorded this year is both records in the region. the largest area defoliated, and the first time that severe defoliation has been recorded dur- ing this current outbreak, which is in its seventh Douglas-fir Pests consecutive year (Figure 3).
Damage Spruce budworm Choristoneura occidentalis Although no tree mortality has been record- ed during this current infestation, cumulative The area of western spruce budworm-dam- top-kill on both mature and younger douglas-fir aged Douglas-fir increased almost fourfold to was observed. Top-kill was most evident in 21 130 ha in 47 pockets from 5850 ha in 23 areas where defoliation has been recorded for areas in 1991 (Figure 2). There were 14 230 several years, mainly in the SOO TSA. Areas ha of light, 5420 ha of moderate, and 1480 ha of where top-kill was noted included North Creek, severe defoliation. 40% of semi-mature trees with 1-3m top-kill; Blackwater Creek, up to 1m on 20% of young to Defoliation semi-mature trees; Eight Mile Creek, approxi- mately 2-3m top-kill on up to 50% of young to The area and intensity of defoliation semi-mature trees, worse on understory trees; increased in most previously defoliated areas and Birkenhead River (Fowl Creek), up to m in the Soo TSA. New areas were recorded in top-kill on approximately 10% of semi-mature patches up the Lillooet River valley from the and mature trees. Johnny Sandy Creek area on the northeast side of the valley near Pemberton through the Defoliation was also recorded in young Railroad-North-Pebble-Salal creeks area stands that had recently been spaced. Light almost to Silt Lake at the head of the valley. defoliation was recorded in one stand near Some defoliation was also recorded on the Blackwater Creek and was reported in stands in southwest side of the valley at South, the Birkenhead River-Tenquille Creek area, Meagher, and Manatee creeks. The North while moderate to severe defoliation was Creek area was defoliated last year, however, observed near Eight Mile creek. Growth loss the rest of these areas were newly defoliated and top-kill will result from repeated defoliation in 1992. Defoliation in the upper valley near in these younger, higher value, spaced stands. Pebble, Salal, and Manatee creeks was mod- Some budworm larvae were also noted in plan- erate to severe, and mostly on amabilis fir. tations adjacent to defoliated stands. Near
VANCOUVER FOREST REGION
0 40 80 km
C AAA P B E L..L NNE' ,„,E ,,,,,4 1- CE'rN E..„-, L. L F?? „LER NIS L F N y I ,,,, = 17— , E L 7 rEN- \ \lo. A i , - 4 ,;",1, "z„:1 "„t,..L .iD ti F:LI. EN AY lik) ,E-L-70 77/7 41,1- . f t:4 it :: „t,,, . , \ . , ,,, st, \\ ,i," "1.• N . , . i 1 12 ,..... . /Ai • ddddd d g
ca • • --- - -, ,A=j i • ) 7 .A BPEC 7 1". ---‘- - VAN C CI ti V E N t-;=-.1 l t - • , . _EN
N A N A M 0 Y 'w , N /rrk3,7 w • F-, w , ni
plei). V i C TO R I A FOREST INSECT AND DISEASE SURVEY
Figure 2. Areas where current defoliation by the Western spruce budworm was detected during ground and aerial surveys in 1992. Figure 3. Area of Douglas-fir defoliated by Western spruce budworm dur- ing current outbreak, 1986-1992, Vancouver Forest Region.
Blackwater Creek, 90% of 1-to 2-year-old increasing populations continued in 1992; how- seedlings suffered trace feeding, as did 10% of ever, the larval sampling phase was dropped. newly planted seedlings near Hannah Creek. Pheromone-baited dry "Multipher" traps were These seedlings should not be affected by placed (5/site) in each of four areas of previous minor feeding, however, repeated moderate to infestations - Devine, Skagit Valley, North Bend severe defoliation could result in growth loss and Anderson River - to attract male adults and leader/stem deformities. (Table 3). While the average number of moths per trap increased at all four sites, only trace Based on previous outbreaks, the incidence defoliation was recorded at two sites. of top-kill will continue as long as the infestation does, and probably even after the infestation This is the second consecutive year of subsides. Increment cores taken in 1989 in increasing moth catches at 3 of the 4 sites, how- lightly to moderately defoliated stands showed ever, higher numbers of moths were recorded in an average 12% growth loss. the late 1980 s at 3 of the 4 sites (Figure 4). Even with high numbers of moths recorded in Forecast the late 1980 s, only light (1 988-90) or trace (1987, 91, 92) defoliation has ever been record- An average of 50 egg masses/10m2 of ed at the Devine site. Also, this is the first year foliage (range 35-73) were collected at 7 loca- that any defoliation has been recorded at the tions, 6 North of Pemberton and 1 near Boston Anderson River site. Bar, down 43% from an average of 81 (range 21-174) in 1991 (Table 2). Despite declining All locations where more moths were populations, defoliation is predicted to continue, caught in 1992 than in 1991 will be monitored mainly at light levels, in 1993. closely next year, particularly the Anderson River site. Calibrating the traps to relate the The pheromone trapping portion of a bud- number of moths to defoliation will take at least worm sampling project started in 1987 to detect another year. Table 1. Defoliation of Douglas-fir by western spruce budworm, from aerial surveys, Vancouver Forest Region, 1992 and 1991.
Area of defoliation (ha) Light Moderate Severe Total Tsa and location 1992 1991 1992 1991 1992 1991 1992 1991
SOO TSA
Birkenhead R. 1 420 470 800 720 2 220 1190 Blackwater-Phelix 860 1320 860 1320 creeks Spruce-Haylmore- 2 200 720 420 2 620 720 Eight Mile creeks Birkenhead Lk.- 540 960 1310 1 850 960 Sockeye creek Gates River 780 500 110 - 780 610 Lillooet River 8 090 650 2890 380 1450 12 430 1030
FRASER TSA Hannah Creek- 50 20 50 20 4 Barrel main Hannah-Francis 290 30 320 lakes
Total 14 230 4640 5420 1210 1480 21 130 5850
Douglas-fir beetle killed timber was mapped in 1991. Several spot Dendroctonus pseudotsugae infestations were recorded along the east side of Lillooet River and Lake, from Rogers Creek to For the second consecutive year the area Joffre Creek including a number of small infes- containing recent beetle-caused Douglas-fir tations still occurring in the Twin One and Two mortality decreased to 170 ha in 210 infesta- creeks area. A few small areas were also tions from 240 ha in 57 infestations in 1991. mapped in the Birkenhead River and Gates While the area was reduced the number of Lake areas. small, 1-5 tree, infestations increased through- In the Fraser TSA, the recorded area of out the region. Most of the mortality continues beetle-killed timber was 140 ha in 175 infesta- to occur in the Interior Douglas-fir Bio- tions, compared to 145 ha over 44 infestations geoclimatic Zone near Pemberton and Boston in 1991. Although the area was virtually the bar. same, the number of infestations increased The biggest decrease occurred in the Soo fourfold. Most of the area and over half the TSA where the area of beetle-attacked infestations were seen along the Fraser River Douglas-fir declined to 30 ha in 35 infestations and associated side drainages between Yale and the mouth of the Nahatlatch River. The from 95 ha in 13 infestations. There was no recent mortality seen along the west side of number of infestations in the Anderson River Lillooet Lake opposite Lizzie and Twin One area increased, with several new spot infesta- creeks where almost 75% of the area of beetle- tions south of the fork of the East Anderson Table 2. Predicted 1993 spruce budworm defoliation based on egg counts, Vancouver Forest Region, 1992.
Avg. no. of egg masses/10m2 of foliage/plot Defoliation1 %increase/– Location 1992 1991 decrease 1992 1993(predicted)
Soo TSA Birkenhead R. 60 174 -66 Moderate Light-moderate 8-Mile Cr. 46 119 -61 Moderate Light Haylmore Cr. 35 28 +25 Light Light Blackwater Cr. 38 21 +81 Light Light North Cr. 47 92 -51 Light Light Salal Cr. 73 new Light-moderate Light-moderate
Fraser TSA Hannah Cr. 49 new Light Light
Average 50 87 -43
1. 1-50 egg masses/10 m2 = light defoliation 51-150 egg masses/10 m2 = moderate defoliation 151+ egg masses/10 m2 = severe defoliation
Table 3. Comparison of 1992 and 1991 pheromone sampling results at spruce budworm calibration plots in the Vancouver Forest Region, 1992.
Avg. no. moths/trap average defoliation at plots Location 1992 1991 1992 1991
Soo TSA Devine 306 150 trace trace
Fraser TSA North Bend 127 94 none none Anderson R. 257 49 trace none Skagit Valley 16 4 none none