Nation and Loyalty in a German-Polish Borderland: Upper Silesia, 1848–1960. by Brendan Karch. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2018
BOOK REVIEWS 465 Nation and Loyalty in a German-Polish Borderland: Upper Silesia, 1848–1960. By Brendan Karch. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2018. Pp. xiii + 331. Cloth $105.00. ISBN 978-1108487108. Primed for Violence: Murder, Antisemitism, and Democratic Politics in Interwar Poland. By Paul Brykczynski. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2018. Pp. xvii + 215. Paper $19.95. ISBN 978-0299307042. Brendan Karch’s imaginative book conjures up German speakers resistant to being “German.” Paul Brykczynski’s admirable work highlights Poles who so strenuously rejected Jewish fellow citizens’ efforts to share in the country’s fate that they abetted and applauded the 1922 murder of independent Poland’s first elected president, killed by an upper-class, ultranationalist artist-antisemite. Karch’s study of Upper Silesia, an area inhabited by one of Europe’s largest bilingual popu- lations, advances the cutting-edge debate over the concept of national indifference ignited in recent years by Habsburg historians—notably, Jeremy King, Tara Zahra, Pieter Judson, and Jakub Beneš (for useful orientation, see Maarten van Ginderachter et al., National Indifferentism and the History of Nationalism in Modern Europe [2019]). Of pre-modern Upper Silesians, who lived under Austrian and Prussian rulers from the late Middle Ages, Karch says they “were not pre-divided into pre-nations,” as essentialist modern nationalism holds. “They existed in local communities defined by bilingualism, shared religious practice, and a social mixing so natural that it was barely considered mixing at all. Rather than being awakened, Polish and German loyalties had to be constructed” (11). Following the influential historical sociologist Rogers Brubaker, Karch aims to “examine nationalism as an always unfinished mode of catego- rization rather than as the formation of [fully realized – WH] group identities” (14).
[Show full text]