19820019331.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
N O T I C E THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REPRODUCED FROM MICROFICHE. ALTHOUGH IT IS RECOGNIZED THAT CERTAIN PORTIONS ARE ILLEGIBLE, IT IS BEING RELEASED IN THE INTEREST OF MAKING AVAILABLE AS MUCH INFORMATION AS POSSIBLE (NASA-C -16 9088) WOliKS110 P ON I(INAR BR ECCIAS AhJ) SO.4LS AND TIJE-ja METEORITIC ANAICJS N82-27207 (LUn4r and p.Lalletary 'Inst.) HC A09/MF A01 177 p CSCI 03B uncl. a z G3/91 24229 WORKSHOP ON 1,4 1 ' 1, M-O& *Q . In 5 )IINAR BRECCIAS AND SOILS ANDA. THEIR METEORITIC ANALOGS RECEIVED %SA STI ROW. NCO= LPI Technical Reortp Number 82-02 LUNAR AND PLANETARY INSTITUTE 3303 NASA ROAD I HOUSTON, TEXAS 7705$ iifI " l x zk ^, yy4 WORKSHOP ON Fi E LUNAR IBRECCIAS AND SOILS AND I I THEIR METEORITIC ANALOGS Edited by. G. Jeffrey Taylor Laurel L. Wilkening A Lunar and Planetary Institute Workshop November 9-11, 1981. Lunar and Planetary Institute 3303 NASA Road 1 Houston, Texas 77058 LPI Technical Report 82.02 (1 ^i I l^ r tli i Compiled in 1982 by the LUNAR AND PLANETARY INSTITUTE t The 'Institute Is operated by Universities Space Research Association under Contract NASW-3389 with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Material in this document r o y be copied Without restraint for library, abstract service, educational or personal research purposes; however, republication of any portion requires the written permission of the authors as well as appropriate acknowledgment of this publication, This report may be cited as; Taylor C, J. (1982) Workshop on Lunar Brecclas and Soils and Their Meteoritle Analogs, LPI Tech. Rpt, 82-02, Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston. 172 pp. Papers in this report may be cited as; Author A. (1982) Title of part, in Workshop on Lunar Brorrias and Soils and Their Meleorll_le Analog-,v (C, J. Taylor, Ed,) p , ,, x—v . , L.' , .- 'feel:, n pt. e'=02, .Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, Y~ This report is distributed by; LIBRARY/ INFORMATION CENTER Lunar and Planetary Institute 3303 NASA Road l Houston, TX 77058 Mail order requestors will be invoiced for the cost of postage and handling. ERRATA FOR Workshop_on Lunar Mccias and Soils and Their Meteoritic Analogs The information on the second page of this volume concerning proper referencing of this publication is incorr-oct duo to the face that one of the editors' Pames was inadvertently left off. This volume should be correctly ref'orenced as; Taylor G. J. and L. L. Wilkening (1982) Workshop on Lunar Brcccias and SoiZs and Their huteoritic Analogs. LPI Tech. Rpt, 82-02, Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston. 172 pp. Papers in this volume should be cited as; Author A. (1982) Title of part. In Workshop on Lunar Breacias and Soils and Their Aleteoritic Analogs (G. J. Taylor and L. L. Wilkening, Rds.) p. xx-yy. LPT 'Tech. Rpt. 82-02. Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston. r Cover. Lunar (67015, left) and meteoritic (BTNA78004, right)breccias, Both rocks are fragmental breccias consisting of mechanically-interlocked rock and mineral clasts. The largest clast in the photograph of BTNA 78004 is_2 cm long; the largest one in 67015 is 1 cm long, i 7, Contents Preface i. Workshop Rationale and Format G. J, Taylor and L. L. Wilkening II, Program III, Discussion Summaries Petrology of breccias E. R, D, Scott and A. Basu Properties and dynamics of asteroidal regoliths and thi^ relation to B accretionary processes C. R. Chapman and L. L, Wilkening Chronometric constraints 12 C.M. Hohenberg Impact processes 14 S, K. Croft IV. Future Research Directions 17 G. Wetherill V, Abstracts of Keynote Talks and Contributed Abstracts 21 Impact dynamics of asteroidal brecciation 23 T. J. Ahrens and J. D, O'Keefe Chronology of breccias 26 D.D. Bogard Properties and dynamics of asteroidal regoliths and the relation 31 t6 accretionary processes C. R. Chapman and L L. Wilkening Pristinity problems on a basaltic achondrite parent (BAP): Chondritic 36 contamination of basalt clasts from Aolymict eucrites J. S. Delaney, M Prinz, G. E. Harlow, and C; E, Nehru Spectral uariations on asteroidal surfaces; Implications for composition 40 and surface processes M, J. Gaffey, T, King, and B. R. Hawke h ^E f =t Constraints on the irradiation history of the gas-rich meteorites 44 i J. N, Goswamt and K. Nishlizuml f The origin of achondrite breccias 49 R. H, Hewins Meddling the evolution of asteroidal regoliths 54 M' K. R, Housen K Volatile trace metal transport in planetary ragoliths 59 R. M. Housley and E. H. Orlin An extension of lunar rust petrogenesis to the uolatile element regime 62 of light-dark chondritic meteorites R. H, Hunter and L A, Taylor ri a' I` Composition and origin of chondritic breccias 65 K. Kell Roundness and sphericity of clasts in meteorites, lunar soil breccia, 84 i and lunar soils I K. Kordesh and A, Basu Evolution of an asteroidal regolith: Granulometry, mixing and maturity 87 Y, Langevin Space exposure of breccia components 94 t J. D, Macdougall Primary structures in lunar cores and regolith breccias 97 J S Na le H5 clast and unequilibrated host in Yamato 75028 chondrite 102 T. Ohta and H, Takeda Carbonaceous chondritest Do we see relics of planetesimal 105 formation in them? R. S. Rajan y Petrologic insights into the fragmentation history of asteroids 107 A. E. Rubin, G. J. Taylor, E, R. D, Scott, and K, Kell Nutshell guide to lunar breccias I11 G. Ryder I t Electron microprobe study of impact-melted regolith breccias 120 x:a O G. Sato, H, Takeda, K. Yanai, and H, Kojima k _..... .., ....0 .. .... s. c,. a ..^ e .. ...x.. .::3 ,4,....,^,.s. _. ;. iiisii.A,^" ..rifuaY _,,........_........^..._..®.r..._..... Ages of Serenitatis breccias 123 O. A, Schaeffer, R. Warasila, and T. C. Lxabolka k` Thermoluminescence of a gas-rich meteorite and the relationship 126 k between gas-rich and gas-poor meteorites ' D. W. G. Sears Primitiue breccias among Type 3 ordinary chondrites—origin and 130 relation to regolith breccias E. R. D, Scott and G. J. Taylor 1 About regolith dynamics and the ancient solar corpuscular radiation; 135 potential of lunar and meteoritic studies P, Signer, Ph, Rtique, and R, Wieler Terrestrial impact breccias 139 . D, Sttsffler Magnetic and thermal history of the brecciated chondrite Abee 147 i N, Sugiura and D. W, Strangway 1i Mineralogical characteristics of polymict breccias on the howardite 148 parent body and the moon H.Takeda Comment., Problems regarding meteorite and lunar chronology 152 M, Tatsumoto, D, M, Unruh, and P. J. Patchett l Petrologic comparison of lunar and meteoritic breccias 153 G. J, Taylor VI. List of Registered Attendees 169 I r r I Preface This report documents the results of a workshop on "Comparisons between Lunar Breccias and Soils and Their Meteoritic Analogs," which was held at the Lunar and Planetary Institute November 9-11, 1981, This workshop was the third in a series organized by the Lunar and Planetary Sample Team as part of the Highlands Initiative, an effort organized to help focus research aimed at understanding the early evolution of the moon's crust. However, in contrast to two previous workshops, Workshop on Apollo 16 (LPI Technical Report Number 81.01) and Workshop on Magmatic Processes in Early Planetary Crusts (LPI Technical Report Number 8201), this workshop was designed to use our knowledge about lunar brecclas to help sharpen our understanding of meteoritic breccias and, therefore, of meteorite parent bodies, , 1, Workshop Rationale and Format G, J. Taylor and L„ L, Wilkenins Lunar soils and brecclas have been studied In detail since the first samples were returned from the Apollo 11 mission, They have been analyzed for their chemicalcompos;»ions, mineralogy, petrology, physical characteristics, and cosmic-ray, solar-flare and solar .w .^ A exposure histories. Models describing the evolu. tion and dynamics of the present regolith and the ant; Ant megaregolith have been developed, used on comparisons with terrestrial impact craters, lunar brecclas have been 0assifled by their probable locations within or outside craters, The aim of the workshop was to use this extensiv y body of data and theory to help us understand the evolution of meteoriteparent bodies, Although meteoritic (,Nrecciashave also been studied In considerable detail, there never has been a concerted effort to compare diem to lunar soils and brecclas. Such comparisons can lead to a better understanding of a number of problems In planetary science; 1)The accretion of the planets and meteorite parent bodies must have Involved Impacts, Can we see evidence for these accretionary impacts? How would the brecclas produced differ from those formed at the present surfaces (the regolith; I.e. "gas-rich" brecclas)? Can we distinguish the effects of processes operat ing during accretion from those that operated before and after accretion? 2)How comparable are the properties of lunar and meteoritic regolith brecclas? What do differences in their respective solar•wind inventories tell us about the formation of lunar and meteoritic breccias? Do lunar and meteoritic breccias record different eras of solar activity? What are the significant differences in their exposure histories? How different are meteorite and lunar regoliths in their physical properties (e,g,, grain size)? 3) What can we learn about cratering processes on asteroids from studies of lunar and meteoritic breccias? Are differences between lunar and meteoritic brecclas due to differences In Impact velocities, the population of projectiles (fluxes, size distributions), or properties of the target materials? What effect does chemical composition have on regolith development? 4) How can we date the assembly of regolith (and other fragmental) breccias? What do breccia ages mean? Can we use them to learn about meteorite fluxes or the frequency of impacts in the asteroid belt? 5) What can volatiles tell us about processes on and in meteorite parent bodies? Many gas-rich lunar breccias have large concentrations of volatiles on grain surfaces.