DOCSLIB.ORG

Israeli Oscar Nominee: ‘Films Have No Nationalities’

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Israeli Oscar Nominee: ‘Films Have No Nationalities’ Israeli Oscar nominee: ‘Films have no nationalities’ Guy Davidi (left) with co-director Emad Burnat Our frequent online critic, Ted (not to be confused with our friend, Ted Jonas), made a particularly hurtful, vituperative comment some weeks ago, calling me a “racist” among other things, for allegedly denigrating the role of the Palestinian co-director of “5 Broken Cameras,” Emad Burnat. I knew from my previous contacts with Guy Davidi, the Israeli co-director, that Davidi had taken the lead in shaping the film, given the fact that he is a trained and experienced professional filmmaker and Burnat is not. And so, as a co-administrator of this blog, I deleted Ted’s abusive comment, but not before making note of his explicit challenge for me to ask Davidi more about his working relationship with Burnat. Davidi did not respond to my initial email a month ago, but he did reply more recently. Our new interaction, in which he responded to my questions on how he is faring now that “5 Broken Cameras” is a finalist for an Oscar in the best documentary category, resulted in a new article at The Forward’s Arty Semite blog. The title was not my choice and could be misread as an attack on the filmmaker: “Why Oscar Nominee Doesn’t Represent Israel.” Davidi registers his disappointment over the competing nationalist claims for authorship of this film: “Films have no nationalities,” he declared, and went on to depict in some detail his role and that of his Palestinian colleague, in this “Palestinian-Israeli-French co-production, [with] Israeli and Palestinian directors and a story that is told [with] Palestinian characters and in the West Bank.” This is his entire email response (not published in full in The Forward piece) about how he and Burnat worked together, and whether Burnat will continue to make films: By the way, indeed, I wrote the texts [script]. Originally Emad didn’t want to make a film on himself, his family or Gibreel [his youngest son]. Since he filmed many things, he did have some great personal footage. Now in reflection, he says he always wanted to make a personal film, but when we met in the beginning, he presented me a film that focused on Phil and Adeeb [villagers who were charismatic figures in the protests]. After Phil’s death [from being struck with a teargas canister], he even had a name for it, “Elephants in Bil’in,” so when I entered the project, I worked with him so he would film more personal scenes to be able to shape the story of Emad, Gibreel and his family. I don’t know if he will do more films; I’m not sure if [he] wants to. If he has a good team that will help him to shape a story, he might be able to do so. Creating a film is team work, and the most important quality is to be able to bring all the creative people to work together. You can hear Emad Burnat’s voice front & center in a joint guest appearance with Guy Davidi on Brian Lehrer’s WNYC radio talk show: Also edited out of my Forward piece is Davidi’s effort to use the film to teach young Israelis about the reality of the occupation in the West Bank: I also launched a campaign to bring the film to Israeli schools. The ministry of education rarely takes a film like ours as part of the school program, so I hope an Oscar will give me back wind to do that. I have created a promo screening documented here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=i1wEszQYEzg and an indiegogo campaign: http://www.indiegogo.com/5bcyouth.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Animation! [Page 8–9] 772535 293004 the TOWER 9> Playing in the Online Dark
    9 euro | SPRING 2020 MODERN TIMES REVIEW THE EUROPEAN DOCUMENTARY MAGAZINE CPH:DOX THESSALONIKI DF ONE WORLD CINÉMA DU RÉEL Copenhagen, Denmark Thessaloniki, Greece Prague, Czech Paris, France Intellectually stimulating and emotionally engaging? [page 10–11] THE PAINTER AND THE THIEF THE PAINTER HUMAN IDFF MAJORDOCS BOOKS PHOTOGRAPHY Oslo, Norway Palma, Mallorca New Big Tech, New Left Cinema The Self Portrait; Dear Mr. Picasso Animation! [page 8–9] 772535 293004 THE TOWER 9> Playing in the online dark In its more halcyon early days, nature of these interactions. ABUSE: In a radical the internet was welcomed Still, the messages and shared psychosocial experiment, into households for its utopi- (albeit blurred for us) images an possibilities. A constantly are highly disturbing, the bra- the scope of online updating trove of searchable zenness and sheer volume of child abuse in the Czech information made bound en- the approaches enough to sha- Republic is uncovered. cyclopaedia sets all but obso- ke anyone’s trust in basic hu- lete; email and social media manity to the core («potential- BY CARMEN GRAY promised to connect citizens ly triggering» is a word applied of the world, no longer seg- to films liberally these days, Caught in the Net mented into tribes by physical but if any film warrants it, it is distance, in greater cultural un- surely this one). Director Vit Klusák, Barbora derstanding. The make-up artist recog- Chalupová In the rush of enthusiasm, nises one of the men and is Czech Republic, Slovakia the old truth was suspended, chilled to witness this behav- that tools are only as enlight- iour from someone she knows, ened as their users.
    [Show full text]
  • FILMS on Palestine-Israel By
    PALESTINE-ISRAEL FILMS ON THE HISTORY of the PALESTINE-ISRAEL CONFLICT compiled with brief introduction and commentary by Rosalyn Baxandall A publication of the Palestine-Israel Working Group of Historians Against the War (HAW) December 2014 www.historiansagainstwar.org Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution – NonCommercial – ShareAlike 1 Introduction This compilation of films that relate to the Palestinian-Israeli struggle was made in July 2014. The films are many and the project is ongoing. Why film? Film is often an extraordinarily effective tool. I found that many students in my classes seemed more visually literate than print literate. Whenever I showed a film, they would remember the minute details, characters names and sub-plots. Films were accessible and immediate. Almost the whole class would participate and debates about the film’s meaning were lively. Film showings also improved attendance at teach-ins. At the Truro, Massachusetts, Library in July 2014, the film Voices Across the Divide was shown to the biggest audiences the library has ever had, even though the Wellfleet Library and several churches had refused to allow the film to be shown. Organizing is also important. When a film is controversial, as many in this pamphlet are, a thorough organizing effort including media coverage will augment the turnout for the film. Many Jewish and Palestinian groups list films in their resources. This pamphlet lists them alphabetically, and then by number under themes and categories; the main listings include summaries, to make the films more accessible and easier to use by activist and academic groups. 2 1. 5 Broken Cameras, 2012.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Guises of Transnationalism in Israel/Palestine
    Guises of Transnationalism in Israel/Palestine: A few notes on 5 Broken Camerasi Yael Friedman University of Portsmouth The discussion of Israeli cinema is governed, predominantly, by the perspective of national cinema. The dominant framework of analysis tends to be that of Zionism and, by and large, both in critical writing and exhibition contexts, a very clear dichotomy is maintained between Israeli and Palestinian cinemas and between Israeli cinema and cinemas of the Middle East. Such a governing perspective often excludes or distorts a critical discussion of the transnational in films that emerge both from Israel and Palestine. The changes brought about by processes of globalisation to the production, circulation and reception of films around the world also shape contemporary cinema in Israel/Palestine to a considerable extent. Throughout the history of Palestinian cinema its production and exhibition contexts were distinctively transnational, while Israel’s small-scale national film industry increasingly shifts towards transnational modes of production. The survival and the recent success of Israeli cinema, both internationally and domestically, is largely dependent upon co-production agreements, the involvement of European funders, and the global festival circuit. Despite this prominent trend, only a few recent publications address Israeli cinema from a transnational perspective.ii This short article follows in a similar vain. It offers a critical discussion of the acclaimed documentary 5 Broken Cameras (Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi, Israel/Palestine/France/Netherland, 2011), whose joint Palestinian-Israeli direction and transnational context of production, challenge the national boundaries of both Israeli and Palestinian cinemas while, at the same time, probelmatizing the notion of the transnational.
    [Show full text]
  • Rhetorics of Belonging
    Rhetorics of Belonging Postcolonialism across the Disciplines 14 Bernard, Rhetorics of Belonging.indd 1 09/09/2013 11:17:03 Postcolonialism across the Disciplines Series Editors Graham Huggan, University of Leeds Andrew Thompson, University of Exeter Postcolonialism across the Disciplines showcases alternative directions for postcolonial studies. It is in part an attempt to counteract the dominance in colonial and postcolonial studies of one particular discipline – English literary/ cultural studies – and to make the case for a combination of disciplinary knowledges as the basis for contemporary postcolonial critique. Edited by leading scholars, the series aims to be a seminal contribution to the field, spanning the traditional range of disciplines represented in postcolonial studies but also those less acknowledged. It will also embrace new critical paradigms and examine the relationship between the transnational/cultural, the global and the postcolonial. Bernard, Rhetorics of Belonging.indd 2 09/09/2013 11:17:03 Rhetorics of Belonging Nation, Narration, and Israel/Palestine Anna Bernard Liverpool University Press Bernard, Rhetorics of Belonging.indd 3 09/09/2013 11:17:03 First published 2013 by Liverpool University Press 4 Cambridge Street Liverpool L69 7ZU Copyright © 2013 Anna Bernard The right of Anna Bernard to be identified as the author of this book has been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
    [Show full text]
  • Atavism and Modernity in Time's Portrayal of the Arab World, 2001-2011
    Atavism and Modernity in Time's Portrayal of the Arab World, 2001-2011 A dissertation presented to the faculty of the Scripps College of Communication of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy Mary R. Abowd August 2013 © 2013 Mary R. Abowd. All Rights Reserved. This dissertation titled Atavism and Modernity in Time's Portrayal of the Arab World, 2001-2011 by MARY R. ABOWD has been approved for the E. W. Scripps School of Journalism and the Scripps College of Communication by Anne Cooper Professor Emerita of Journalism Scott Titsworth Dean, Scripps College of Communication ii ABSTRACT ABOWD, MARY R., Ph.D., August 2013, Journalism Atavism and Modernity in Time's Portrayal of the Arab World, 2001-2011 Director of Dissertation: Anne Cooper This study builds on research that has documented the persistence of negative stereotypes of Arabs and the Arab world in the U.S. media during more than a century. The specific focus is Time magazine’s portrayal of Arabs and their societies between 2001 and 2011, a period that includes the September 11, 2001, attacks; the ensuing U.S.- led “war on terror;” and the mass “Arab Spring” uprisings that spread across the Arab world beginning in late 2010. Using a mixed-methods approach, the study explores whether and to what extent Time’s coverage employs what Said (1978) called Orientalism, a powerful binary between the West and the Orient characterized by a consistent portrayal of the West as superior—rational, ordered, cultured—and the Orient as its opposite—irrational, chaotic, depraved.
    [Show full text]
  • Searching for Peace in the West Bank Through 5 Broken Cameras
    From the Instructor Camden Dean’s excellent paper, written for WR 100: “Global Documen- tary,” explores the destructive role that cameras play in the Israeli-Palestin- ian conflict. He focuses on the Academy Award-nominated documentary 5 Broken Cameras (2011), which tells the story of a Palestinian farmer who films his fellow villagers’ protest against the Israeli wall erected on their land. We studied this film at a poignant moment in the semester. The Israel-Gaza conflict had ended four months earlier. And we had just studied One Day in September (1999), which revisits the 1972 Munich Olympics, where 11 Israeli athletes and trainers were taken hostage and then killed by Palestinian terrorists—an event largely streamed on live television. The assignment’s sole requirement was that students pose and answer a question about any of our semester’s documentaries. After presenting an outline of his ideas and receiving feedback from the class, Camden began to write. Many of our theoretical readings helped to shape his ambitious argument—Jean Rouch on cinéma vérité, Michel Foucault on the Panopti- con, Susan Sontag on the desensitizing effect that images engender. While drafting his essay, however, Camden started to question the direction of his argument and wondered whether he should abandon it. Peer reviewers stepped in to offer just the right kind of feedback, inspiring the counter- arguments that frame his position for a skeptical reader and motivating him to keep going. Camden’s ability to view the role of cameras in the West Bank from multiple angles gives his essay its rhetorical force and judicious tone.
    [Show full text]
  • Re-Verzio Documentary Film Series
    -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 6 PM WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 6 PM WEDNESDAY, MARCH 6, 6 PM -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- 5 BROKEN CAMERAS PIT No. 8 NOAH'S CANOE -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- Emad Burnat & Guy Davidi / France & Marianna Kaat / Estonia / 2010 / 95 min / Juliet Brown / UK / 2011 / 44 min / English -------------------------------------- The Netherlands & Israel & Palestine / Russian The journey of Noah, a female to 2011 / 90 min / Arabic & Hebrew Cold, hungry, out of work? Dig male transgender, as he moves RE-VERZIO A family saga with 4 children, a hole in your backyard and mine from a difficult past into a healing 5 broken cameras, and countless some coal. Ukrainian know-how future, finding his place as a man DOCUMENTARY burnt olive trees. A first-person for a "post-industrial" society. in a family of his own. story of non-violent resistance -------------------------------------- -------------------------------------- in a West Bank village.
    [Show full text]
  • 5 Broken Cameras
    5 BROKEN CAMERAS a film by Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi Sundance World Cinema Documentary Directing Award (USA) IDFA Special Jury Prize and Audience Award, Amsterdam (The Netherlands) Grand Jury Award, London Open City Docs Fest Audience Award, Doc/Fest Sheffield Best Picture, Traverse City Film Festval (USA) Louis Marcorelle Award, Cinéma du Réel, Paris (France) Eurodok Award, Oslo (Norway) Best Documentary, Jerusalem Film Festival (Israel) Best Documentary, Durban Film Festival (South Africa), and many more… France / Israel / Palestine 2011/ 90 mins / Arabic and Hebrew with English subtitles / Certificate TBC Release date: 19 October 2012 FOR ALL PRESS ENQUIRIES PLEASE CONTACT Sue Porter/Lizzie Frith – Porter Frith Ltd Tel: 020 7833 8444/E‐mail: [email protected] FOR ALL OTHER ENQUIRIES PLEASE CONTACT Robert Beeson – New Wave Films [email protected] 10 Margaret Street London W1W 8RL Tel: 020 3178 7095 www.newwavefilms.co.uk SYNOPSIS Filmed from the perspective of a Palestinian farmer (Emad Burnat), 5 Broken Cameras was shot using six different video cameras – five of which were destroyed in the process of documenting Emad’s family’s life as well as the Palestinian and international resistance to Israeli appropriation of land and occupation. Emad, who lives in Bil'in, just west of the city of Ramallah in the West Bank, was thrust into global politics when his community peacefully resisted Israeli plans to erect a wall through their land to separate them from the ever growing Israeli settlements. Initially given the camera to chronicle the birth and childhood of his new son Gibreel, the film captures Gibreel growing up against the backdrop of the many non‐violent protests that have become an intrinsic part of life in Bil'in.
    [Show full text]
  • Statiscal Data Collection Project on Film and Audiovisual Markets in 9 Mediterranean Countries
    EU funded Programme STATISCAL DATA COLLECTION PROJECT ON FILM AND AUDIOVISUAL MARKETS IN 9 MEDITERRANEAN COUNTRIES Country Profile: 5. Palestine EUROMED AUDIOVISUAL III / CDSU in collaboration with the EUROPEAN AUDIOVISUAL OBSERVATORY Dr. Sahar Ali, Media Expert, CDSU Euromed Audiovisual III Under the supervision of Dr. André Lange, Head of the Department for Information on Markets and Financing, European Audiovisual Observatory (Council of Europe) Tunis, November 10, 2013 Responsibility Disclaimer “The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of Euromed Audiovisual III programme and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union, or of the European Audiovisual Observatory or of the Council of Europe of which it is part.” The report is available on the programme website: www.euromedaudiovisual.net Film and audiovisual data collection project NATIONAL AUDIOVISUAL LANDSCAPES IN NINE PARTNER COUNTRIES PALESTINE 1. BASIC DATA ..................................................................................................................................5 1.1 Overview ..................................................................................................................................5 1.2 Benchmarks ............................................................................................................................7 1.3 Domestic policy ........................................................................................................................8 1.4 Membership of Palestine and
    [Show full text]
  • 5 Broken Cameras a Film by Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi
    POV Community Engagement & Education DISCUSSION GUIDE 5 Broken Cameras A Film by Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi www.pbs.org/pov STATEMENT FROM THE FILMMAKING TEAM Co-directors Guy Davidi and Emad Burnat. Photo courtesy of Kino Lorber, Inc. BACKGROUND In 2005 when the demonstrations against the wall started, Emad got his first camera and started to film the happenings in the village. He also filmed his personal life and family not thinking that this would be part of any future film. For the next years Emad’s purpose wasn’t to make a film. He filmed for many other reasons. First, it was a way to participate in the demonstrations. It also protected people in court when his footage was used as evidence. And it was a way to distribute information to news agencies and to the Internet. Other filmmakers made films around the resistance in Bil’in and many of them utilized Emad’s footage, as he was the only cameraman of the village. He had access that others didn’t have. He was the one who could film the soldiers and the raids at night when the other cameramen left. These events were sometimes violent, and many times, he was in danger for filming. In 2006 he was arrested and accused of throwing rocks and spent weeks in jail and under house arrest – after which, his cam - eras were broken. It was the peace activists and donors that helped to get Emad new cameras, so that he could continue to film and document what was happening. DISCUSSION GUIDE 5 Broken Cameras |2 STATEMENT FROM THE FILMMAKING TEAM Right from the start, Israeli and international peace activists helped and participated in the movement against the separa - tion wall.
    [Show full text]
  • Palestine on the Screen: Trauma and Ignored Voices Yanping Ni
    Palestine on the Screen: Trauma and Ignored Voices Yanping Ni, University of Warwick, United Kingdom The Asian Conference on Media, Communication & Film 2018 Official Conference Proceedings Abstract The Israeli-Palestinian conflicts can trace back to the Nakba in 1948 and are probably to continue at least in the near future, rendering the region invariably a turbulent land and a focus in the international society. For a long time in the past, the western media largely engaged in broadcasting news about these conflicts, while Palestine itself, as the colonised part, appeared much too silent in both international politics and mass media to be noticed. However, such a silent situation has been considerably changed in recent years, with the emergence of certain distinctive Palestinian films across various film festivals. Thanks to the accessibility of inexpensive camera equipment and international co-production, the indigenous filmmakers are able to document the region’s collective memory as well as the ongoing repressions. These films, thus, can be regarded as the region’s creative responses to the conflicts and as non-violent protests to the occupation. They, on the one hand, call for human rights, and, on the other, attempt to present the real Palestinian people and alter the impression around the region of being uncivilised. Moreover, these works share common stylistic features, such as documentary-like quality, handheld camerawork and discursive editing. Drawing on two recent, typical Palestinian films, Five Broken Cameras (2011) and Ambulance (2016), this paper examines the cinematic representations of the region and the people in response to the destructive ethno-nationalism, and the multiple roles of film as a media: witnessing the reality, re-enacting the traumatic moments, and voices calling for human rights.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Rights Watch
    POV Community Engagement & Education DISCUSSION GUIDE 5 Broken Cameras A Film by Emad Burnat and Guy Davidi www.pbs.org/pov STATEMENT FROM THE FILMMAKING TEAM BACKGROUND In 2005 when the demonstrations against the wall started, Emad got his first camera and started to film the happenings in the village. He also filmed his personal life and family not thinking that this would be part of any future film. For the next years Emad’s purpose wasn’t to make a film. He filmed for many other reasons. First, it was a way to participate in the demonstrations. It also protected people in court when his footage was used as evidence. And it was a way to distribute information to news agencies and to the Internet. Other filmmakers made films around the resistance in Bil’in and many of them utilized Emad’s footage, as he was the only cameraman of the village. He had access that others didn’t have. He was the one who could film the soldiers and the raids at night when the other cameramen left. These events were sometimes violent, and many times, he was in danger for filming. In 2006 he was arrested and accused of throwing rocks and spent weeks in jail and under house arrest – after which, his cam - eras were broken. It was the peace activists and donors that helped to get Emad new cameras, so that he could continue to film and document what was happening. Right from the start, Israeli and international peace activists helped and participated in the movement against the separa - tion wall.
    [Show full text]