Chapter III Jonathan Wild's Morality

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Chapter III Jonathan Wild's Morality Chapter III Jonathan Wild's Morality In accordance with the title above, the analysis in this chapter will be focused on the main character in Henry Fielding's Jonathan Wild. The thesis writer regards that the main character in the novel, Jonathan Wild, is important to be analyzed since Wild is the hero in the novel, who has a lot of problems about morality. As a first step to depict the character of Jonathan Wild, it is very important to understand Wild's background, although it does not guarantee that someone's background has a great influence on one's inner self or even one's life. There are many reasons why the main character has problems about morality. In this chapter, the thesis writer divides them into the outer factors and inner factors which cause Wild's immoral life. Wild's family background, 20 situations in the society at that time, the social injustice and other man like Heartfree can be classified into the outer factors which bring Jonathan as an immoral figure. While the inner factors can be seen in Jonathan Wild's personality and his own life. Jonathan Wild, as Henry Fielding says is a 'great man'. The term 'great' is different from 'good'. The term 'great' does not only mean 'good'. 'Good' means benevolence, honour, honesty, and charity; and that parts and courage can be call 'great'. A man can be 'great' without being good or 'good' without being great (Defoe 31). Henry Fielding also admits it in his book: Nothing seems to me more preposterous than that, while the way to true honour lies so open and plain, men should seek false by such perverse and rugged paths: it is so easy and safe, to be good, men should wade through difficulty and danger, and to be great, or, to use a synonymous word, villains (31). The great criminal is contemplated as the typical 'great man'. That is why all 'great' and' surprising event' should be produced by 'great man'. The perfect example of greatness, Fielding says, is Jonathan Wild. Greatness is badness as he says:" No two things can be possibly be more distinct from each other, for greatness consist in bringing all manner of mischief of man kind, and goodness in removing it from them" (108). 21 111.1 The Outer Factors of Jonathan's Morality There are many outer factors discuss in this analysis. They are the background of Wild's family. It is important to know how actually Wild's family is because it has an important role to his life. The second is the situations in the society which influences his morality. The situation at that time, eighteenth century, also can influence Wild to decide something whether that is wrong or right. The other outer factor is the social injustice that brings Wild's immoral life. And the last is the other people who serve as a device to show Wild's immoral life. III.1.1 The Background Of Wild's Family In the first place, the outer factors that push Wild to become a man without morality is his ancestors. All his ancestors are 'great men'. This fact can be seen through his first ancestor named Wolfstan Wild. He is the expert of 'picking pocket'. This can be shown from the following quotation: Mr Jonathan Wild, was descended from the great Wolfstan Wild, who distinguished himself very eminently at famous festival, he immediately applied to the pocket of his guest, and contented himself with taking all that he had, without attempting his life (42). 22 The next ancestor is an eminent man surnamed Longfinger. His name shows his characteristic that he can take a man's purse without the knowledge of the owner with his dexterity. This gentleman is the first of Wild's family who has the honour of suffering his country by his skill. This can be proved by this following epitach: O shame o'justice! Wild is hang'd, For thatten he a pocket fang'd, While safe old Hubert, and his gang, Doth pocket o' the nation fang (43). From all his ancestors it can be seen that actually Wild has an ability to become 'great'. Although it does not guarantee that Wild will become 'great' but there are wise words which say that "Fruits do not fall far away from the trees". This means that more or less, Wild has an ability to become 'great'. The other outer factors that force Wild is his family. A family is needed in building someone's character. If he or she has a strong family ties, he or she can overcome the problems he or she faces because his or her family helps to form his mentality. If his or her mental foundation is not strong enough to face the problems, he or she will be in despair everytime he or she has a difficulty. He or she cannot solve it and tries to find an easy way out which is usually wrong. The fact that Jonathan Wild does not have strong family ties can be seen through Wild's brothers. His second brother, at first, is a public officer in 23 town. He is the man who is respected by people, but he steps out of his work and makes himself popular by ruining the meeting-house at Wolverhampton. However, he is caught of being a rebel by his deeds: Edward was so remarkable for his compasionate temper that he spent his life in soliciting the causes of the distressed captives in Newgate, and is reported to have held a strict friendship with an eminent divine who solicited the piritual causes of the said captives (43). Another brother of Jonathan also becomes a prisoner at that time because of debt. At first, he is a Birmingham ware-man, or in a particular is a buckle-maker. Yet, he leaves his own city and comes up to London. Because of debt, he is arrested. However, it seems that Wild's families have their own business so that they do not have time to give their attention to each other. Since Wild's two brothers take a wrong way and give wrong examples to him, so he also imitates and does it. From the proofs above, it seems that the three brothers have the same qualities to become 'great'. Or in other words that nature can produce men like Jonathan and his two bothers if they have a background of the family like that. 24 III.1.2 Situations In The Society Which Influence Jonathan Wild's Morality Certain situations can force someone to do something wrong. The time when Jonathan lives is during the eighteenth century, that is the time when crime is mostly done by everyone. At that time, money always plays an important role in the society. The society in which Wild lives is the society which praises wealth and social status. The rise of the middle class introduces bourgeouis life style to the society. Wild is not born with those respectable status of the middle class. Living in such of situation, Wild feels the dissatisfaction of his life and himself. His dissatisfaction forces him to do something to make his life better. He wants the society to admit him. The way that he takes to make his life better can be seen through his acquaintance with Miss Mary Milliner: "An accident soon happened after his arrival in town in which almost saved the father his whole labour on his head, and provided Master Wild a better tutor than any care or expense could furnished him with" (48). Through his acquaintance with Mrs. Milliner, he learns many things about crime such as prostitution, theft, and robbery. Mrs. Milliner and Jonathan, then, are doing business together. Mrs. Milliner teaches many new things to Jonathan how to get money that Wild never knows before. From the fact above, it shows that Jonathan can not live in poverty. He hates his position as a lower 25 class, that is why he makes his life up to a middle class. His acquaintance with Miss Milliner is only one of his ways to be respected in the middle class society. The crime itself is more as the result of Wild's obession to become rich because in context with the eighteenth century London society, to be rich will put him in a position of respect among the middle class society. The crime which he learns from Miss Milliner that he does is theft. However, he is not endangering his life with his crime because he is afraid of the punishment that thieves must be hang in the gallows. It can be proved by the quotation below: How easy is the reflection of having taken a few shillings and pounds from a stranger, without any breach af confidence, or perhaps any harm to the person who loses it, compared to that of having betrayed a public trust, and ruined the fortunes of thousands, perhaps of a great nation?(56). For that reason, he asks his man to steal for him and he informs the owner that the things he robs are found. However, the owner must give him such as a ransom to get their things back: Lost, the 1 st of October, a black shagreen Pocket-Book, edged with Silver, with some Notes of Hand. The said Book was lost in the Strand, near the Fountain Tavern, about 7 or 8 o'clock at 26 Night. If any Person will bring the aforesaid Book to Mr Jonathan Wild, in the Old Bailey, he shall have a Guinea reward (10).
Recommended publications
  • Volume 1, Issue 1 2017 ROBIN HOOD and the FOREST LAWS
    Te Bulletin of the International Association for Robin Hood Studies Volume 1, Issue 1 2017 ROBIN HOOD AND THE FOREST LAWS Stephen Knight The University of Melbourne The routine opening for a Robin Hood film or novel shows a peasant being harassed for breaking the forest laws by the brutal, and usually Norman, authorities. Robin, noble in both social and behavioral senses, protects the peasant, and offends the authorities. So the hero takes to the forest with the faithful peasant for a life of manly companionship and liberal resistance, at least until King Richard returns and reinstates Robin for his loyalty to true values, social and royal, which are somehow congruent with his forest freedom. The story makes us moderns feel those values are age-old. But this is not the case. The modern default opening is not part of the early tradition. Its source appears to be the very well-known and influential Robin Hood and his Merry Men by Henry Gilbert (1912). The apparent lack of interest in the forest laws theme in the early ballads might simply be taken as reality: Barbara A. Hanawalt sees a strong fit between the early Robin Hood poems and contemporary outlaw actuality. Her detailed analysis of what outlaws actually did against the law indicates that robbery and assault were normal and that breach of the forest laws was never an issue.1 The forest laws themselves are certainly medieval.2 They were famously imposed by the Norman kings, they harassed ordinary people, stopping them using the forests for their animals and as a source for food and timber, and Sherwood was one of the most aggressively policed forests—but this did not cross into the early Robin Hood materials.
    [Show full text]
  • REFORMATIVE SYMPATHY in NINETEENTH-CENTURY CRIME FICTION Erica Mccrystal
    Erica McCrystal 35 REFORMATIVE SYMPATHY IN NINETEENTH-CENTURY CRIME FICTION Erica McCrystal (St. John’s University, New York) Abstract Nineteenth-century British crime novels whose heroes were criminals redefined criminality, alerting readers to the moral failures of the criminal justice system and arguing for institutional reform. My research on this topic begins with William Godwin’s novel Caleb Williams (1794) as a social reform project that exposes hypocrisy and inconsistency of governing institutions. I then assess how contemporary social criticism of crime novels contrasts with the authors’ reformative intentions. Critics argued the ‘Newgate novels’, like those of Edward Bulwer-Lytton and William Harrison Ainsworth, glorified criminality and were therefore a danger to readers. However, Bulwer-Lytton’s Paul Clifford (1830) and William Harrison Ainsworth’s Jack Sheppard (1839) serve, like Caleb Williams, as social reform efforts to alert readers to the moral failings of the criminal justice and penal institutions. They do so, I argue, through the use of sympathy. By making the criminal the victim of a contradictory society, Godwin, Bulwer-Lytton, and Ainsworth draw upon the sympathies of imagined readers. I apply contemporary and modern notions of sympathy to the texts to demonstrate how the authors use sympathy to humanise the title characters in societies that have subjected them to baseless mechanisation. The emergence of crime fiction in nineteenth-century Britain provided readers with imaginative access to a criminal’s perspective and history as they conflicted with the criminal justice system and its punitive power. Novelists working within the genre re- examined criminality, morality, and justice, often delivering powerful social critiques of extant institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Godwin's Use of the Newgate Calendar As a Scource for Caleb
    Godwin's use of The Newgate Calendar as a source for Caleb Williams by Karen Catherine Elder A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Partial Fulfillment of The Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS Major: English Signatures have been redacted for privacy iowa i>tate University Ames, Iowa 1976 11 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 1 SUMMARY OF CALEB WILLIAMS 4 Review of Criticism Regarding Caleb Williams 6 Thesis Proposal 10 HISTORY AND ATTITUDE OF THE NEWGATE CALENDAR 12 GODWIN'S REACTION TO THE ATTITUDE OF THE NEWGATE CALENDAR 18 ALLUSIONS IN CALEB.WILLIAMS TO THREE NEWGATE CALENDAR CRIMINALS 30 Eugene Aram 30 Jonathan Wild 36 John (Jack) Sheppard 40 Conclusion 49 FOOTNOTES 51 LIST OF WORKS CONSULTED 55 INTRODUCTION The following study of Caleb Williams^ began as a project paper for a graduate class in "Romantic Writers: Shelley and His Circle." Although Godwin is not usually considered a figure in the romantic movement, there are at least two reasons for his inclusion in Shelley's "circle": first, his influence on his more famous son-in- law was profound; and, second, CW itself contains a romantic element, e.g., the isolated, alienated individual struggling against a threatening, menacing society. For the course work, CT was reviewed in conjunction with The Newgate 2 Calendar, a source which contains the biographies of some of England's most notorious criminals incarcerated at Newgate prison in London. Godwin, noting that he was "extremely conversant" with the had himself cited this work as bearing on the subject of the novel (CW, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • Situational Crime Prevention Or Problem-Oriented Situational Interventions POPPOP Andand SCPSCP -- SIMILARITIESSIMILARITIES
    Situational Crime Prevention Or Problem-Oriented Situational Interventions POPPOP andand SCPSCP -- SIMILARITIESSIMILARITIES Both are preventive approaches One is defined within policing while the other is not Both originated in the 1970s, SCP in the UK and POP in the USA Both focus on highly specific problems Both use action research models CrimeCrime PreventionPrevention Intervening in the causal chain of opportunity to prevent crime from occurring TheThe EnglishEnglish HeritageHeritage 1748, Judge Henry Fielding and the Bow Street runners Jonathan Wild story and Fieldings’ failures Modern Police created in London (1829) under Sir Robert Peel (1788-1850) (father of modern policing) SirSir RobertRobert Peel'sPeel's NineNine PrinciplesPrinciples forfor ModernModern PolicingPolicing 1) The basic mission for which the police exist is to prevent crime and disorder. 2) The ability of the police to perform their duties is dependent upon public approval of police actions. 3) Police must secure the willing cooperation of the public in voluntary observance of the law to be able to secure and maintain the respect of the law. SirSir RobertRobert Peel'sPeel's NineNine PrinciplesPrinciples forfor ModernModern PolicingPolicing 4) The degree of cooperation of the public that can be secured diminishes proportionally to the necessity of the use of force. 5) Police seek and preserve public favor not by catering public opinion, but by constantly demonstrating absolute impartial service to the law. SirSir RobertRobert Peel'sPeel's NineNine PrinciplesPrinciples forfor ModernModern PolicingPolicing 6) Police use physical force only to the extent necessary to secure observance of the law or to restore order only when exercise of persuasion, advice and warning is found to be insufficient.
    [Show full text]
  • Criminology Police Science and Law Enforcement Remove Or Reduce
    Role Name Affiliation Criminology Police Science and Law Enforcement Remove or Reduce Risk - Henry Fielding Methods 1 | P a g e Principal Investigator Prof.(Dr.) G.S. Bajapai Professor/Registrar, National Law University, Delhi Paper Coordinator Dr. Mithilesh Narayan Assistant Professor, Sardar Patel Bhatt University of Police, Security and Criminal Justice, Jodhpur Content Writer/Author Dr. Swikar Lama Assistant Professor, Sardar Patel University of Police, Security and Criminal Justice, Jodhpur Content Reviewer Prof. Arvind Tiwari Professor, TISS, Mumbai DESCRIPTION OF MODULE Items Description of Module Subject Name Criminology Paper Name Police Science and Law Enforcement Module Name/Title Remove or Reduce Risk - Henry Fielding Methods Module Id Crim/PSLE/XXXV Objectives Learning Outcome: To make the learners understand the concepts of removal or reduction Risk To make the learners aware about Henry Fielding and his work To familiarize the learners with various methods of risk management Prerequisites General understanding of crime prevention methods Key words Remove or Reduce Risk , Henry Fielding, risk management 2 | P a g e Module 35: Remove or Reduce Risk - Henry Fielding Methods 1. Introduction Fielding was a playwright and novelist who accepted a position as magistrate deputy of Bow Street Court in 1748. He is credited with two major contributions to the field of policing (Gaines et al.). First, Fielding advocated change and spread awareness about social and criminal problems through his writings. Second, he organized a group of paid non uniformed citizens who were responsible for investigating crimes and prosecuting offenders. This group, called the Bow Street Runners, was the first group paid through public funds that emphasized crime prevention in addition to crime investigation and apprehension of criminals.
    [Show full text]
  • Jack Sheppard: Narration
    1 The Tale of Jack Sheppard: Narration Welcome to this performance of Escape was on Everyone's Mind – The Tale of Jack Sheppard. It is part of a tour, supported using public funding by the National Lottery through Arts Council England. On this tour we are working with Bristol Radical History Group and other local history groups to hold post show discussions; and also with the Woodcraft Folk, with whom we are running puppetry workshops. Before we begin, a word from our narrator: There are several songs in the show. It's worth paying attention to the lyrics, as they tell parts of the story [all the song lyrics are in this document]. There are a couple of songs to sing along with. It should be obvious which ones. We'd also like to encourage cheering and booing, and maybe a bit of supportive heckling. Some of you have paper balls, to throw at the judges. I'll throw the first one, and that's your cue to throw the rest. Some people have beer mugs, or pub signs. At one point in the show there will be a pub crawl: when that happens we'd like you to hold up the pub signs, and raise your glasses. And now, on with the show. Ladies and gentlemen, rebels and riff-raff, we present to you “Escape was on Everyone’s Mind: The Tale of Jack Sheppard,” legendary jailbreaker and hero of the people. We will first introduce to you some of the chief actors of our play: The English Justice System: protector of the rich, guardian of private property, scourge of the ordinary people.
    [Show full text]
  • Crime, Deviance, and the Social Discovery of Moral Panic In
    UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON FACULTY OF HUMANITIES History Volume 1 of 1 Crime, Deviance, and the Social Discovery of Moral Panic in Eighteenth Century London, 1712-1790 by Christopher Thomas Hamerton Thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy November 2016 ABSTRACT This thesis utilises the theoretical device of Folk Devils and Moral Panics, instigated by Stanley Cohen and developed by Erich Goode and Nachman Ben-Yehuda, to explore the discovery of, and social response to, crime and deviance in eighteenth- century London. The thesis argues that London and its media in the eighteenth- century can be identified as the initiating historical site for what might now be termed public order moral panics. The scholarly foundation for this hypothesis is provided by two extensively researched chapters which evaluate and contextualise the historiography of public opinion and media alongside the unique character and power located within the burgeoning metropolis. This foundation is followed by a trio of supportive case studies, which examine and inform on novel historical episodes of social deviance and criminality. These episodes are selected to replicate a sequence of observable folk devils within Cohen’s original typology – youth violence, substance abuse, and predatory sex offending. Which are transposed historically as the Mohocks in 1712, Madam Geneva between 1720-1751, and the London Monster in 1790. Taken together, these three episodes provide historical lineage of moral panic which traverses much of the eighteenth-century, allowing for social change, and points of convergence and divergence, to be observed. Furthermore, these discrete episodes of moral panic are used to reveal the social problems of the eighteenth-century capital that informed the control narratives that followed.
    [Show full text]
  • Ebook Download Jonathan Wild Ebook, Epub
    JONATHAN WILD PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Henry Fielding,Senior Rare Books Cataloguer Houghton Library Hugh Amory,Maynard Mack Professor of English Claude Rawson,Linda Bree | 352 pages | 01 Sep 2008 | Oxford University Press | 9780199549757 | English | Oxford, United Kingdom Jonathan Wild PDF Book Keeping in mind the tribulations of modern readers, not used to such peregrinations of oratory during the course of novels, I would say that a devotion to English literature would better lead to enjoyment of such a work than a preference for modern style in which dialogue might be deemed more natural. Heartfree, justice remains elusive. And thus we see the policy of a mean and scandalous thief-taker, conducted with as much prudence, caution, and necessary courage, as the measures taken by even the greatest persons upon earth; nor perhaps is there, in all history, an instance of a man who thus openly dallied with the laws, and played with capital punishment. The mercer insisted that a day or two would lessen the value of the goods one half to him, and Jonathan insisted, as peremptorily, that it was not in his power to do anything sooner. For the modern reader, the novel is somewhat heavy-handed in its attacks on the Great and on reducing Wild to a cipher for Walpole, or a Walpole-like villain. Sort order. She waited there about three quarters of an hour, when Mr. The passing of the Theatrical Licensing Act in effectively ended Fielding's career as a playwright. Mullan, p. I went, he desired me to call a porter, but I not knowing where to find one, he sent a person who brought one that appeared to be a ticket-porter.
    [Show full text]
  • ENFORCING LAW and ORDER (Catching Criminals) in THE
    ENFORCING LAW AND ORDER (Catching criminals) IN THE INDUSTRIAL PERIOD (1700 – 1900) Reasons for changes in the Industrial period The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries were an age of great industrial and agricultural change in Britain. Two of the most important developments were: a huge rise in the population of Britain, from around 9 million in 1700 to 42 million in 1900 the concentration of many of the new population in large towns and cities – the process known as urbanisation With such changes, the old medieval system of policing which had existed for centuries had to change. The new industrial towns had to have a new system of law enforcement. What also had to change was the idea that communities were responsible for their own law enforcement. The idea gradually developed that policing should become a specialist job and that enforcing law and order would have to become the responsibility of government. By the mid nineteenth century, the system of law enforcement in Britain was completely changed. Due to its size and particular problems, most of the initial experiments in finding a more effective way of combatting crime took place in London. The inadequacies of the old system were really obvious here with neither constables nor watchmen being effective in such a growing city. Another problem was the opportunist ‘thief-takers’ who captured criminals for reward money or who negotiated the return of stolen goods for a fee. The most infamous of the ‘thief-takers’ were Charles Hitchen and Jonathan Wild, both of whom were also corruptly involved in arranging the crimes from which they made a profit.
    [Show full text]
  • From Providence to Police: the Development of the Literary
    From providence to police: The development of the literary detective figure in the long eighteenth century September 2013 Joanne Holland Department of English McGill University, Montréal A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy © Joanne Holland 2013 i Table of Contents Abstract ....................................................................................................................... ii Résumé ....................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgements ................................................................................................... vi Introduction ................................................................................................................ 1 “Murder Will Out”: Providential Discovery of Crime in Early Modern England ... 5 The Rationalization of Criminal Detection ............................................................ 11 The Development of the Literary Detective Figure in the Eighteenth Century ..... 16 Chapter 1: Deception and Analysis in the Early Development of the Literary Detective Figure........................................................................................................ 25 Jonathan Wild (1683-1725) .................................................................................... 30 Elizabeth Canning (1734-1773) ............................................................................. 55 Chapter
    [Show full text]
  • 8.2 What Were the Main Turning Points in Policing Methods, 1700-19007
    8.2 What were the main turning points in policing methods, 1700-19007 Law enforcement during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries Continuity Maintaining law and order continued Change Experiments in using a force of paid and trained to be the responsibility of unpaid and untrained local officers based at Bow Street; the development of the officials - the JP,Constable and Watchman Metropolitan Police Force and the development of police forces across the rest of the country The sharp rise in population levels, together with the growth of towns and cities, during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries put great pressure on the medieval system of using unpaid amateurs to maintain law and order. One result of this was that some private individuals, known as thief-takers, started acting as unofficial policemen. They captured criminals and claimed the reward money, or acted as go- betweens and negotiated the return of stolen property for a fee. Here are two noted thief-takers: • Charles Hitchen (c.1675-1727): he was a fence and abused his '3hN"·.....·....··..·..·..··..·........·......·......·····l position as Under City Marshall for London to put pressure on l Fence - a person who buys and l thieves to sell their goods through him; he would then negotiate a l. sells stolen goods ! fee for the return of the stolen goods to their original owner. • Jonathan Wild (1683-1725), 'Thief-Taker General of Great Britain and Ireland': having previously worked for Hitchen, Wild built up an empire of organised crime; he planned thefts, trained and organised burglars, and then negotiated the return of the stolen goods; he periodically turned in thieves to the authorities and so appeared to 'police' the streets of London.
    [Show full text]
  • An Enquiry Into the Causes of the Frequent Executions at Tyburn
    An Enquiry into The Causes of the Frequent Executions At Tyburn By Bernard Mandeville An Enquiry into the Causes of the Frequent Executions at Tyburn INTRODUCTION The Enquiry into the Causes of the Frequent Executions at Tyburn was originally published as a series of letters to the British Journal. The first letter appeared on February , ; just twelve days before, Jonathan Wild, self-proclaimed "Thief-Catcher General of Great Britain and Ireland," had been arrested and imprisoned in Newgate. Thus the Enquiry had a special timeliness and forms a part of the contemporary interest in the increasingly notorious activities of Wild. Wild's systematic exploitation of the London underworld and his callous betrayal of his colleagues in criminality (he received £ from the government for each capital conviction he could claim) had created public protest since at least when an act (which Mandeville cites in his Preface) directed against receivers of stolen goods was passed, most probably with the primary intenti<[,,,,,,,,,]on of curtailing Wild's operations. Wild's notoriety was at its peak in - after his successful apprehension of Joseph Blake ("Blueskin") and Jack Sheppard, the latter figure becoming a kind of national hero after his five escapes from prison (he was recaptured by Wild each time). The timeliness of Mandeville's pamphlet extends, of course, beyond its interest in Jonathan Wild, who after all receives comparatively little of Mandeville's attention. The spectacle of Tyburn itself and the civil and moral failures it represented was one which Londoners could scarcely ignore and which for some provided a morbid fascination. Mandeville's vivid description of the condemned criminal in Newgate, his journey to Tyburn, and his "turning off," must have been strikingly forceful to his contemporaries, who knew all too well the accuracy of his description.
    [Show full text]