Lynching in Florida During the Era of World War II Tameka Bradley Hobbs
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2004 "Hitler Is Here": Lynching in Florida during the Era of World War II Tameka Bradley Hobbs Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES “Hitler is Here”: Lynching in Florida During the Era of World War II By TAMEKA BRADLEY HOBBS A Dissertation submitted to the Department of History in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded Summer Semester 2004 Copyright © 2004 Tameka Bradley Hobbs All Rights Reserved The members of the Committee approve the dissertation of Tameka Bradley Hobbs, defended June 24, 2004. Maxine D. Jones Professor Directing Dissertation Darryl Dickson-Carr Outside Committee Member Joe M. Richardson Committee Member James P. Jones Committee Member Matthew D. Childs Committee Member Approved: Neil T. Jumonville, Chair, Department of History The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii In memory of A. C. Williams, Cellos Harrison, Willie James Howard, and Jesse James Payne iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work is the result of the support of many individuals. I thank Dr. Maxine D. Jones for not only her scholarly guidance, but her advice, encouragement, and, most of all, her friendship during my matriculation. The members of my committee, Joe Richardson, Jim Jones, Matt Childs and Darryl Dickson-Carr, have been shining examples of scholarship and wisdom. I am thankful for their direction and encouragement in accomplishing this task. I am grateful for those who helped me with my research, especially all of the people who shared with me their most intimate and painful memories, easier forgotten than revived. I can only hope that I have done justice to your memories. During the course of my research, I have depended on the help of several librarians and archivists, but the assistance of two individuals in particular, Fred Romanski and Edward Barnes of the National Archives and Records Administration II, was invaluable to me and I am grateful. I am appreciative to the Florida Education Fund, especially the late Israel Tribble, as well as Betty Parker Smith, and Lawrence Morehouse, for providing me with an opportunity to pursue higher education and for the inspiration, encouragement and the example of scholarship and leadership that they have provided. I thank the staff and board of directors of the John G. Riley House Museum, especially Althemese Barnes and Geraldine Johnson, for the opportunity to work with them and to learn from their creativity, drive, and dedication. My greatest resource has been my family. I stand upon the shoulders of my ancestors; their example of strength, faith, and endurance in the face of oppression has not been forgotten. My grandmother, Cleo McDaniel Grimmage, showed me the value of iv pursuing a dream, no matter how distant. My mother, Dorothy Bradley, is my first and best teacher; she has continued to build me up with her belief in me and her faith in God. My father, Lawrence Bradley, is my rock; his love and steadfastness have been the foundation of my success. My husband, William Hobbs, III, has had the unfortunate job of picking up my parts the many times I have fallen to pieces during this process. For that, I thank you. My son, Ashanti, has been my inspiration, a source of comic relief, and remains my greatest body of work. And, lastly, I am forever indebted to Dr. Murell Dawson, who first spawned my interest in African American history a decade ago. Since that time, she has continued to be my toughest critic and my dearest friend, both in academia and in life. v TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables..............................................vii List of Figures.............................................viii Abstract....................................................ix INTRODUCTION................................................1 1. STRANGE FRUIT: LYNCHING IN AMERICA.....................7 2. LYNCHED TWICE: THE MURDER OF A. C. WILLIAMS............31 3. THE FAILURE OF FORBEARANCE: THE LYNCHING OF CELLOS HARRISON........................................79 4. “THE LIFE OF A NEGRO IN SUWANNEE COUNTY IS A VERY CHEAP ARTICLE”: THE DEATH OF WILLIE JAMES HOWARD, 1944...................................................134 5. “JUDGE WHAT WE SAY OVER THERE BY WHAT WE DO OVER HERE”: PEDAGOGY, THE PRESS, AND THE LYNCHING OF JESSE JAMES PAYNE, 1945................................169 6. CONCLUSION.............................................214 EPILOGUE....................................................235 REFERENCES..................................................242 BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH.........................................254 vi LIST OF TABLES 1. Chronology of Events Surrounding the Lynching of A. C. Williams...............................................44 2. Chronology of Events Surrounding the Lynching of Cellos Harrison........................................107 3. Chronology of the Events Surrounding the Lynching of Jesse James Payne......................................180 vii LIST OF FIGURES 1. A. C. Williams ....................................... 47 2. Claude Neal .......................................... 87 3. Cynthia Goff ......................................... 144 4a. International Labor Defense Flyer (front) ............. 198 4b. International Labor Defense Flyer (back) .............. 199 5. Cartoon, “Wrong forever on the throne, Right forever on the scaffold” ..................................... 210 6. Cartoon, “Still at It” ............................... 212 7. Governor Spessard Holland and governor-elect Millard F. Caldwell ......................................... 223 8. Cartoon, “Hitler is Here” ............................ 227 viii ABSTRACT This historical study will examine four lynchings that took place in Florida during the 1940s. The investigations include the lynching of A. C. Williams in Gadsden County in 1941; Cellos Harrison in Jackson County in 1943; Willie James Howard in Suwannee County in 1944; and Jesse James Payne in Madison County in 1945. In addition to describing the circumstances surrounding each incident, this study also discusses the reaction of local law enforcement, Florida state public officials, the federal government, and the press. To tell these stories, the study relied on records from local and state governments, investigative records of the U. S. Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation and, oral history from family members and residents of the communities in which these lynchings occurred. The study gives these incidents further exploration, in attempting to fit them into the chronology of the lynching phenomenon in the United States by extracting similarities as well as changes in the practice of lynching itself. These lynchings also indicate an increasingly negative reaction but segments of the American public against such acts of violence. This was due in part to U. S. participation in World War II and the government’s increasing concern about the nation’s international reputation. ix BIBLIOGRAPHY PRIMARY SOURCES: Manuscript Collections: Caldwell, Governor Millard Papers. Administrative Collection. Florida State Archives. Tallahassee, Florida. Gray, William, Jr., Papers, Southeastern Regional Black Archives, Research Center and Museum, Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University, Tallahassee, Florida. Holland, Governor Spessard L. Papers. Administrative Collection. Florida State Archives. Tallahassee, Florida. NAACP papers, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress. Washington, D. C. Microfilm. Suwannee Valley Genealogical Society, Live Oak, Florida. Marriage Records. Tuskegee Institute News Clipping Files. Lynching Files. Tuskegee University. Tuskegee, Alabama. Microfilm. Warren, Governor Fuller Papers. Administrative Collection. Florida State Archives. Tallahassee, Florida. Government Documents and Manuscripts: Florida Department of Agriculture. Sixth Census of the State of Florida. Tallahassee: Department of Agriculture, 1935. Florida State Archives, Tallahassee, Florida. Florida State Planning Board, ed. Statistical Abstract of Florida Counties. Jacksonville: Florida State Chamber of Commerce, 1944. Live Oak, Florida. Suwannee County Courthouse. Marriage Records. 242 ———. Suwannee County Courthouse. Deed Records. ———. Suwannee County Courthouse. Circuit Court Records. Marianna, Florida. City Hall. Municipal Court Records. ———. Jackson County Courthouse. Deed Records. ———. Jackson County Courthouse. Court Records. Records of the Florida Supreme Court. Florida State Archives. Tallahassee, Florida. Records of the United States District Courts, Record Group 21, National Archives and Records Administration, East Point, Georgia. U. S. Congressional Record. 75th Congress. 1st Session. 1937. U. S. Department of Commerce. Statistical Abstract of the United States. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1954. U. S. Department of Justice, Record Group 60, National Archives and Records Administration II, College Park, Maryland. Newspapers: Atlanta Daily World. Baltimore Afro-American. Chicago Defender. Chicago Tribune. Daily Democrat (Tallahassee). Daily Worker (New York). Florida Times Union (Jacksonville). Gadsden County Times. Jackson County Floridan. 243 Jacksonville Journal. Lakeland Ledger. Miami Herald. New York Age. New York Herald Tribune. New York Times. Orlando Reporter-Star.