DOCSLIB.ORG

The University of Chicago the Panic of the Robaniños

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The University of Chicago the Panic of the Robaniños THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO THE PANIC OF THE ROBANIÑOS: GRINGO ORGAN STEALERS, NARRATIVES OF MISTRUST, AND THE GUATEMALAN POLITICAL IMAGINATION A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE DIVISION OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DEPARTMENT OF ANTHROPOLOGY BY DANIEL ROTHENBERG CHICAGO, ILLINOIS MARCH 2018 Copyright 2018 Daniel Rothenberg. All rights reserved. In honor of my father, Abraham Joseph Rothenberg, for the constancy and depth of his love, for all that he taught me, and for understanding what is most important about this and other work. Table of Contents List of Tables .................................................................................................................................. vi Acknowledgments .......................................................................................................................... vii Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 1. Outline of a Nationwide Panic .............................................................................................................. 1 2. “It is Something Completely New”: The Importance of an Integrated Analysis of the Panic .. 10 3. Situating the Panic within Anthropology’s “Discovery” of Violence ............................................ 20 4. Narratives of Revelation and Uncertainty .......................................................................................... 27 5. Narratives and Violence ........................................................................................................................ 32 6. Narratives of Mistrust ........................................................................................................................... 41 7. Study Methodology and Structure ....................................................................................................... 55 Chapter 1 – Certitude and Verification: The Truth Claims of “Fantastic” Tales and the Narrative Expression of Uncertainty .............................................................................................................. 58 1. “Es la pura verdad”: The Tales’ Binary Nature and the Challenges of Verification ....................... 58 2. Witchcraft Claims, Occult Economies, and the Power of the Fantastic to Make Sense of Contemporary Social Systems ................................................................................................................... 70 3. How Fantastic Stories Work: Three Perspectives ............................................................................. 81 4. Antecedents to the Panic: Guatemala’s International Adoption Industry ................................. 103 5. The Panic Starts: The Appearance of Tales of Organ-Stealing Gringos ...................................... 121 Chapter 2 – The Panic of the Robaniños: Narrative Logic and the Legacy of State Terror in Guatemala .................................................................................................................................... 127 1. Simple Tales and the Legacy of State Terror .................................................................................. 127 2. The Legacy of La Violencia and the Impact of State Terror on Representation ........................ 134 3. Tensions within Transition: Truth-telling and Accountability in the Period Preceding the Panic ..................................................................................................................................................................... 148 4. Discovered and Mutilated Corpses: The Communicative Logic of Brutalized Bodies ............ 158 5. What is Hidden and Revealed: The Narrative Logic of the Tales of the Robaniños .................. 177 Chapter 3 – Riot in Santa Lucía: Guatemala’s Justice Crisis and Critique of the Country’s Democratic Transition ................................................................................................................. 181 iv 1. Popular Violence in Santa Lucía Cotzamalguapa ........................................................................... 181 2. The Riot as an Expression of Guatemala’s Justice Crisis ............................................................. 190 3. Questioning the Open Promises of Political Transition: Democracy as a Metanarrative ........ 199 4. The Context of Mistrust and Social Uncertainty in Guatemala’s Justice Crisis ......................... 213 5. After the Riot: the Political Significance of an Expressly Apolitical Threat .............................. 220 Chapter 4 – Riot in San Cristóbal: The Signifying Power of Gringo and Other Bodies .................. 226 1. Incident in San Cristóbal de Alta Verapaz: Violence against Gringo Bodies............................... 226 2. Another Riot: The Motivating Power of Bodies Present and Absent ........................................ 236 3. Gringo Status and Gringo Bodies ........................................................................................................ 252 4. Gringo/Non-Gringo: The Relative Value of Bodies ......................................................................... 265 5. Children’s Bodies, the Truth of Gringo Intentions and the Compromised Body Politic .......... 272 Chapter 5 – The Legacies of the Panic: The Logic of Narratives of Mistrust ................................ 285 1. Crisis and Dissolution: The Events of 1994 as a Moral Panic ..................................................... 285 2. Continued Stories: Attacks on Gringos and Generalized Threats ................................................. 298 3. Los Linchamientos: Public Popular Violence against Criminals ...................................................... 306 4. The “Success” of the Panic of the Robaniños: Engaging Narrative Form and Narrative Operation ................................................................................................................................................... 314 5. The Panic and the Idea of Spectacle ................................................................................................ 328 Conclusion – Narratives, Political Imagination and the Meaning of Guatemala’s Transition from “War” to “Peace” ......................................................................................................................... 335 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................. 349 v List of Tables Table 1 Overview of Approached to Fantastic Tales .................................................................... 102 Table 2 Communicative Logic of Brutalized Bodies ..................................................................... 179 Table 3 Bodies Seen/Unseen and Local/Distant .......................................................................... 249 Table 4 Narrative Form of the Tales of the Organ-Stealing Gringos .............................................. 320 Table 5 Narrative Operation - Elements and Accountability in the Tales of the Organ-Stealing Gringos .......................................................................................................................................... 324 vi Acknowledgments This document is the result of years of research, thinking, and writing. To complete this project, I relied on the kindness, generosity, and patience of far too many people to mention. However, several individuals stand out. Very special thanks to my dissertation committee: Stephan Palmié, John L. Comaroff, and Judith B. Farquhar. They were exceptionally helpful in guiding my work, providing critical support, and displaying the very best of the field’s vision and commitment. Over the years, I also worked closely with other University of Chicago faculty, including Albert Alschuler, Arjun Appadurai, Douglas Massey, and Marshall Sahlins. In addition, while they were not directly involved in this study, I have been fortunate to have several inspiring academic mentors, including Mary Gluck, Martha Nussbaum, Dietrich Rueschemeyer, and Robert Scholes. I owe a special debt to a number of friends who stood with me throughout this process including Nassim Assefi, Paul Berman, Alberto Coll, Laura Dickinson, Noah Feldman, Carolyn Frantz, David Gartner, Robert Kaestner, Julia Lieblich, Michael Hechter, Gabriel Rebeiz, Jim Silk, Paul Silverstein, and Neda Ulaby. In Guatemala, I worked closely with many people involved in civil society and human rights issues and am particularly grateful to Victoria Sanford and Amílcar Méndez and his family. This project has been guided by a sense of responsibility to those who spoke with me about their lives, detailing brutal acts of political violence and the crushing impact of poverty and lost dreams. There is no way to adequately acknowledge the value and significance of these encounters. I only hope that this work and related activities serve to honor their lives, concerns, and stories. I am deeply thankful for the support of my parents, of blessed memory, who stood with me at all times and taught me about the joy and importance of big ideas. A very special thanks to my brother, David, who has always been an inspiration, and also to his family. Finally, I am grateful beyond words for the love, care, insight, and unwavering support of my wife, Ilissa, and the always joyful presence of our son, Isaac. vii Introduction 1. Outline
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Trafficking in Persons for the Removal Of
    TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS FOR THE REMOVAL OF ORGANS IN INDIA: EXPLORING THE IMPACT OF ECONOMIC, SOCIAL, AND CULTURAL FACTORS ON VULNERABILITY AND PROTECTION By KATHERINE FINDLEY A dissertation submitted to the School of Graduate Studies Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Program in Social Work Written under the direction of Dr. Patricia Findley And approved by ____________________________________ ____________________________________ ____________________________________ ____________________________________ New Brunswick, New Jersey October, 2018 TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS FOR THE REMOVAL OF ORGANS IN INDIA: EXPLORING THE IMPACT OF ECONOMIC, SOCIAL, AND CULTURAL FACTORS ON VULNERABILITY AND PROTECTION By KATHERINE FINDLEY Dissertation director: Dr. Patricia Findley This dissertation explores how influences on the individual, family, community, and governmental level impact susceptibility to trafficking in persons for the removal of organs (TPRO) in India. Two of the research questions examine specifically what impacts vulnerability and protection among a sample of 43 individuals living in a community in India. The third research question explores the role of the living organ donor assessment process in the prevention of trafficking. In this dissertation, the theoretical understanding of how choices are made, or not made, particularly by vulnerable individuals, is explored. Qualitative interviews were conducted with persons trafficked for organ removal and persons not trafficked for organ removal who are living within the same socio-economic environment, but who were not all trafficked for organ removal. Study data were analyzed using constructivist grounded theory methods. Findings from this study show that economic, cultural, and social influences affect both protection from and susceptibility to trafficking.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Trafficking for the Purpose of Organ Removal
    HUMAN TRAFFICKING FOR THE PURPOSE OF ORGAN REMOVAL Jessica de Jong Human trafficking for the purpose of organ removal Jessica de Jong Copyright © 2017, Jessica de Jong Cover art: Roger Klaassen Layout cover: Liedewij Vogelzang ISBN 978-90-393-6817-6 Financial support by the National Police is gratefully acknowledged. All rights reserved. No part of this thesis may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, without prior written permission of the author. Human trafficking for the purpose of organ removal Mensenhandel met het oogmerk van orgaanverwijdering (met een samenvatting in het Nederlands) PROEFSCHRIFT ter verkrijging van de graad van doctor aan de Universiteit Utrecht op gezag van de rector magnificus, prof.dr. G.J. van der Zwaan, ingevolge het besluit van het college voor promoties in het openbaar te verdedigen op vrijdag 20 oktober 2017 des middags te 4.15 uur door Jessica Elisabeth Clasina de Jong geboren op 24 februari 1986 te Driebergen-Rijsenburg Promotoren: Prof. dr. D. Siegel Prof. dr. C.R.J.J. Rijken Voor Koos, mijn grote liefde Contents List of abbreviations 9 Introduction 11 1. Research and analysis process 15 1.1 Research methods 16 1.1.1 Desk research 16 1.1.2 Case studies 17 1.1.2.1 Interviews 20 1.1.2.2 Court documents 23 1.1.2.3 Documentaries 23 1.1.3 Expert meetings 25 1.2 Analysis methods 26 1.3 Validity and triangulation 26 1.4 Ethical issues 27 1.5 Limitations of the study 28 2. Prohibition, violation and enforcement 29 2.1 The prohibition and its influence 30 2.1.1 WHO’s Guiding Principles 30
    [Show full text]
  • Trafficking in Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal
    TRAFFICKING IN HUMAN BEINGS FOR THE PURPOSE OF ORGAN REMOVAL A Comprehensive Literature Review Assya Pascalev - Bulgarian Center for Bioethics, Bulgaria Jessica de Jong - Central Division of the National Police, the Netherlands Frederike Ambagtsheer - Erasmus MC University Hospital Rotterdam, The Netherlands Susanne Lundin - Lund University, Sweden Ninoslav Ivanovski - University of St. Cyril and Methodius, Macedonia Natalia Codreanu - Renal Foundation, Moldova Martin Gunnarson - Lund University, Sweden Jordan Yankov - Bulgarian Center for Bioethics, Bulgaria Mihaela Frunza - Academic Society for the Research of Religions and Ideologies, Romania Ingela Byström - Lund University, Sweden Michael Bos - Eurotransplant International Foundation, The Netherlands Willem Weimar - Erasmus MC University Hospital Rotterdam, The Netherlands December 2013 This report is published with the financial support of the Prevention of and Fight against Crime Programme European Commission – Directorate General Home Affairs. The HOTT project has been funded with the support of the European Commission. This publication reflects the views only of the authors, and the European Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which can be made of the information contained therein. Trafficking in Human Beings for the Purpose of Organ Removal Please do not cite this report This report will be published in 2014 as: Pascalev A, De Jong J, Ambagtsheer F, Lundin S, Ivanovski N, Codreanu C, Gunnarson M, Yankov J, Frunza M, Byström I, Bos M, Weimar W, Trafficking in human beings for the purpose of organ removal: a comprehensive literature review. Lengerich: Pabst Science Publishers 2014. This review is the first delivery of a series of reports forthcoming under the HOTT project: 1. Literature review (December 2013) 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Durham Research Online
    Durham Research Online Deposited in DRO: 28 June 2018 Version of attached le: Submitted Version Peer-review status of attached le: Peer-reviewed Citation for published item: Atkinson, S. (2016) 'Care, kidneys and clones : the distance of space, time and imagination.', in The Edinburgh companion to the critical medical humanities. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press., pp. 611-626. Edinburgh companions to literature and the humanities. Further information on publisher's website: https://edinburghuniversitypress.com/book-the-edinburgh-companion-to-the-critical-medical-humanities.html Publisher's copyright statement: Additional information: Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in DRO • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full DRO policy for further details. Durham University Library, Stockton Road, Durham DH1 3LY, United Kingdom Tel : +44 (0)191 334 3042 | Fax : +44 (0)191 334 2971 https://dro.dur.ac.uk Care, Kidneys and Clones: the distance of space, time and imagination Sarah Atkinson Department of Geography and the Centre for Medical Humanities, Durham University ‘We lived, as usual by ignoring. Ignoring isn't the same as ignorance, you have to work at it.’ (Margaret Atwood in The Handmaid’s Tale)1 Care as a concept is central to any engagement with health, ill-health and the practices that aim to prevent, mitigate or cure, and the term itself is mobilised in a variety of different ways and at a variety of different scales.
    [Show full text]
  • How the Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Crisis Changed Private Law
    CARDINAL SINS: HOW THE CATHOLIC CHURCH SEXUAL ABUSE CRISIS CHANGED PRIVATE LAW MAYO MORAN* ABSTRACT For several decades now, the unfolding of the Catholic Church sexual abuse crisis has been front-page news. It has wreaked havoc on hundreds of thousands of lives, cost the Church billions of dollars, and done irreparable harm to a once-revered institution. Along the way, it has also helped to transform the all- important private law of responsibility. When the crisis began to break in the early 1980s, the few survivors who sought legal redress faced a daunting array of obstacles. Limitations periods alone had the effect of barring almost all child sexual abuse claims. Immunities also helped to shield the Church. Private law itself was generally hostile to institutional liability, particularly where the harm resulted from the criminal act of an individual. All of that has changed. Among the catalysts for change within private law, the Catholic Church sex abuse crisis looms large. The scale of the crisis and the universal nature of the Church were certainly both important factors, but so too was the Church's response. From the initial impulse to cover up instances of abuse to choices made in the legal and political arenas, it appeared willing to do almost anything to protect itself. Yet the Church had traditionally bene®ted from special treatment precisely on the ground that it was not an ordinary, self-interested legal actor. The tension between the Church's mission and its approach to covering up abuse began to attract notice. Courts and legislators were prompted to act.
    [Show full text]
  • Radio Essentials 2012
    Artist Song Series Issue Track 44 When Your Heart Stops BeatingHitz Radio Issue 81 14 112 Dance With Me Hitz Radio Issue 19 12 112 Peaches & Cream Hitz Radio Issue 13 11 311 Don't Tread On Me Hitz Radio Issue 64 8 311 Love Song Hitz Radio Issue 48 5 - Happy Birthday To You Radio Essential IssueSeries 40 Disc 40 21 - Wedding Processional Radio Essential IssueSeries 40 Disc 40 22 - Wedding Recessional Radio Essential IssueSeries 40 Disc 40 23 10 Years Beautiful Hitz Radio Issue 99 6 10 Years Burnout Modern Rock RadioJul-18 10 10 Years Wasteland Hitz Radio Issue 68 4 10,000 Maniacs Because The Night Radio Essential IssueSeries 44 Disc 44 4 1975, The Chocolate Modern Rock RadioDec-13 12 1975, The Girls Mainstream RadioNov-14 8 1975, The Give Yourself A Try Modern Rock RadioSep-18 20 1975, The Love It If We Made It Modern Rock RadioJan-19 16 1975, The Love Me Modern Rock RadioJan-16 10 1975, The Sex Modern Rock RadioMar-14 18 1975, The Somebody Else Modern Rock RadioOct-16 21 1975, The The City Modern Rock RadioFeb-14 12 1975, The The Sound Modern Rock RadioJun-16 10 2 Pac Feat. Dr. Dre California Love Radio Essential IssueSeries 22 Disc 22 4 2 Pistols She Got It Hitz Radio Issue 96 16 2 Unlimited Get Ready For This Radio Essential IssueSeries 23 Disc 23 3 2 Unlimited Twilight Zone Radio Essential IssueSeries 22 Disc 22 16 21 Savage Feat. J. Cole a lot Mainstream RadioMay-19 11 3 Deep Can't Get Over You Hitz Radio Issue 16 6 3 Doors Down Away From The Sun Hitz Radio Issue 46 6 3 Doors Down Be Like That Hitz Radio Issue 16 2 3 Doors Down Behind Those Eyes Hitz Radio Issue 62 16 3 Doors Down Duck And Run Hitz Radio Issue 12 15 3 Doors Down Here Without You Hitz Radio Issue 41 14 3 Doors Down In The Dark Modern Rock RadioMar-16 10 3 Doors Down It's Not My Time Hitz Radio Issue 95 3 3 Doors Down Kryptonite Hitz Radio Issue 3 9 3 Doors Down Let Me Go Hitz Radio Issue 57 15 3 Doors Down One Light Modern Rock RadioJan-13 6 3 Doors Down When I'm Gone Hitz Radio Issue 31 2 3 Doors Down Feat.
    [Show full text]
  • Combat Casualty Care and Lessons Learned from the Last 100 Years of War
    Author’s Accepted Manuscript Combat Casualty Care and Lessons Learned from the Last 100 Years of War Matthew Bradley, Matthew Nealiegh, John Oh, Philip Rothberg, Eric Elster, Norman Rich www.elsevier.com/locate/cpsurg PII: S0011-3840(16)30157-5 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1067/j.cpsurg.2017.02.004 Reference: YMSG552 To appear in: Current Problems in Surgery Cite this article as: Matthew Bradley, Matthew Nealiegh, John Oh, Philip Rothberg, Eric Elster and Norman Rich, Combat Casualty Care and Lessons Learned from the Last 100 Years of War, Current Problems in Surgery, http://dx.doi.org/10.1067/j.cpsurg.2017.02.004 This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain. COMBAT CASUALTY CARE AND LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE LAST 100 YEARS OF WAR Matthew Bradley, M.D. 1, 2, Matthew Nealiegh, M.D. 1, John Oh, M.D. 1, Philip Rothberg, M.D. 1, Eric Elster M.D. 1, 2, Norman Rich M.D. 1 1 Department of Surgery, Uniformed Services University -Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, 8901 Wisconsin Ave., Bethesda, MD 20889 2Naval Medical Research Center, 503 Robert Grant Ave., Silver Spring, MD 20910 Corresponding Author: Matthew J.
    [Show full text]
  • Tsetusuo Wakabayashi, Revealed
    Tsetusuo Wakabayashi, Revealed By Dwight R. Rider Edited by Eric DeLaBarre Preface Most great works of art begin with an objective in mind; this is not one of them. What follows in the pages below had its genesis in a research effort to determine what, if anything the Japanese General Staff knew of the Manhattan Project and the threat of atomic weapons, in the years before the detonation of an atomic bomb over Hiroshima in August 1945. That project drew out of an intense research effort into Japan’s weapons of mass destruction programs stretching back more than two decades; a project that remains on-going. Unlike a work of art, this paper is actually the result of an epiphany; a sudden realization that allows a problem, in this case the Japanese atomic energy and weapons program of World War II, to be understood from a different perspective. There is nothing in this paper that is not readily accessible to the general public; no access to secret documents, unreported interviews or hidden diaries only recently discovered. The information used in this paper has been, for the most part, available to researchers for nearly 30 years but only rarely reviewed. The paper that follows is simply a narrative of a realization drawn from intense research into the subject. The discoveries revealed herein are the consequence of a closer reading of that information. Other papers will follow. In October of 1946, a young journalist only recently discharged from the US Army in the drawdown following World War II, wrote an article for the Atlanta Constitution, the premier newspaper of the American south.
    [Show full text]
  • Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland
    An Inconvenient Truth: Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland McAlinden, A-M. (2013). An Inconvenient Truth: Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland. Legal Studies, 33(2), 189-214. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-121X.2012.00243.x Published in: Legal Studies Document Version: Peer reviewed version Queen's University Belfast - Research Portal: Link to publication record in Queen's University Belfast Research Portal General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Queen's University Belfast Research Portal is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The Research Portal is Queen's institutional repository that provides access to Queen's research output. Every effort has been made to ensure that content in the Research Portal does not infringe any person's rights, or applicable UK laws. If you discover content in the Research Portal that you believe breaches copyright or violates any law, please contact [email protected]. Download date:24. Sep. 2021 Legal Studies, 2012 DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-121X.2012.00243.x An inconvenient truth: barriers to truth recovery in the aftermath of institutional child abuse in Irelandlest_243 1..26 Anne-Marie McAlinden* School of Law, Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland Contemporary settled democracies, including the USA, England and Wales and Ireland, have witnessed a string of high-profile cases of institutional child abuse in both Church and State settings.
    [Show full text]
  • Rioting and Time
    Rioting and time Collective violence in Manchester, Liverpool and Glasgow, 1800-1939 A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities 2018 Matteo Tiratelli School of Social Sciences 1 Table of contents Abstract 4 Declaration & Copyright 5 Acknowledgements 6 Chapter 1 — Rioting and time 7 Chapter 2 — Don’t call it a riot 24 Chapter 3 — Finding riots and describing them 42 Chapter 4 — Riots in space, time and society 64 Chapter 5 — The changing practice of rioting 102 Chapter 6 — The career of a riot: triggers and causes 132 Chapter 7 — How do riots sustain themselves? 155 Chapter 8 — Riots: the past and the future 177 Bibliography 187 Appendix 215 Word count: 70,193 2 List of tables Table 1: The spaces where riots started 69 Table 2: The places where riots started 70 Table 3: The number of riots happening during normal working hours 73 Table 4: The number of riots which happen during particular calendrical events 73 Table 5: The proportion of non-industrial riots by day of the week 75 Table 6: The likelihood of a given non-industrial riot being on a certain day of the week 75 Table 7: The likelihood of a given riot outside of Glasgow involving prison rescues 98 Table 8: The likelihood of a given riot involving begging or factory visits 111 Table 9: The likelihood of a given riot targeting specific individuals or people in their homes 119 List of figures Figure 1: Angelus Novus (1920) by Paul Klee 16 Figure 2: Geographic spread of rioting in Liverpool 67 Figure 3: Geographic spread of rioting in Manchester 68 Figure 4: Geographic spread of rioting in Glasgow 68 Figure 5: The number of riots per year 78 Figure 6: The number of riots involving prison rescues per year 98 3 Abstract The 19th century is seen by many as a crucial turning point in the history of protest in Britain and across the global north.
    [Show full text]
  • Theorising Gender Justice in the Context of Catholic Clerical Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland and Australia
    2016 Thematic: Responsibility and Redress 779 14 RESPONSIBILITY AND REDRESS: THEORISING GENDER JUSTICE IN THE CONTEXT OF CATHOLIC CLERICAL CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE IN IRELAND AND AUSTRALIA KATE GLEESON* I INTRODUCTION Justice for survivors of institutional child sexual abuse is a defining theme of this age. Inspired by remedies associated with transitional justice and human rights abuses, various governments have sought to investigate and make amends for institutional child abuse perpetrated in the context of welfare and services provided on behalf of states, often by autonomous organisations such as Christian churches. The investigatory-commission model of justice predicated on individual ‘truth recovery’ and restorative outcomes for survivors has predominated since the Republic of Ireland’s Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (‘Ryan Commission’) commenced in 1999.1 Internationally, outcomes for complainants have varied, with all investigatory bodies and redress schemes facing limitations regarding the forms and functions of justice that may be delivered at the meta level of state apparatus.2 In some countries, much more than others, civil justice has been delivered as the outcome of mass and individual lawsuits brought against religious organisations and individuals with a duty of care to protect children.3 In general, the international institutional child abuse scandal of the past 30 years presents a conundrum concerning the ways in which sexual harms are understood. Institutional child abuse has been a feature perhaps * [email protected]. Senior Lecturer, Macquarie Law School. Earlier versions of this article were presented to the International Conference on Public Policy, Milan; the University of Technology Sydney, Feminist Legal Research Group; and the Macquarie Law School Staff Seminar Series.
    [Show full text]
  • Copyright by Colleen Anne Hynes 2007
    Copyright by Colleen Anne Hynes 2007 The Dissertation Committee for Colleen Anne Hynes certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: “Strangers in the House”: Twentieth Century Revisions of Irish Literary and Cultural Identity Committee: Elizabeth Butler Cullingford, Supervisor Barbara Harlow, Co-Supervisor Kamran Ali Ann Cvetkovich Ian Hancock “Strangers in the House”: Twentieth Century Revisions of Irish Literary and Cultural Identity by Colleen Anne Hynes, B.S.; M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin August 2007 Acknowledgements This dissertation project would not have been possible with the support, wisdom and intellectual generosity of my dissertation committee. My two supervisors, Elizabeth Butler Cullingford and Barbara Harlow, introduced me to much of the literature and many of the ideas that make up this project. Their direction throughout the process was invaluable: they have been, and continue to be, inspirational teachers, scholars and individuals. Kamran Ali brought both academic rigor and a sense of humor to the defense as he pushed the manuscript beyond its boundaries. Ann Cvetkovich translated her fresh perspective into comments on new directions for the project and Ian Hancock was constantly generous with his resources and unique knowledge of the Irish Traveller community. Thanks too to my graduate school colleagues, who provided constructive feedback and moral support at every step, and who introduced me to academic areas outside of my own, especially Miriam Murtuza, Miriam Schacht, Veronica House, George Waddington, Neelum Wadhwani, Lynn Makau, Jeanette Herman, Ellen Crowell and Lee Rumbarger.
    [Show full text]