Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

1 01/R141T/(1) 001 QUARRY RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 321,100 199,500 SB (1) RAVELRIG P - 77900 M - 243200 BALERNO GERALD EVE LLP EDINBURGH 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 2 01/R141T/(1A) 001 PLANT RV AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES UK LTD 30,100 30,100 SB (1A) RAVELRIG BALERNO GERALD EVE LLP EDINBURGH 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 3 01/R141T/(1A) 002 PLANT RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 30,100 30,100 SB (1A) RAVELRIG BALERNO GERALD EVE LLP EDINBURGH 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 4 01/R141T/(1A) 003 PLANT RR AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES UK LTD 30,100 30,100 SB (1A) RAVELRIG BALERNO GERALD EVE LLP EDINBURGH 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 5 01/R141T/(1A) 004 PLANT RR TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 30,100 30,100 SB (1A) RAVELRIG BALERNO GERALD EVE LLP EDINBURGH 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 1 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

6 03/A530/5 001 HOTEL RR ABILITY HOTELS (EDINBURGH) LTD 976,000 976,000 RP 5 ALMOND AVENUE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 7 03/A530/5 002 HOTEL RR ABILITY HOTELS (EDINBURGH) LTD 976,000 976,000 RP 5 ALMOND AVENUE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 8 03/B567P/(1) 001 GARDEN RV THE JUPITER ARTLAND COMPANY LIMITED 36,500 36,500 ALM (1) BONNINGTON HOUSE KIRKNEWTON BONNINGTON HOUSE MIDLOTHIAN BONNINGTON KIRKNEWTON MIDLOTHIAN EH27 8BB 9 03/B568/(B) 001 QUARRY RV CEMEX UK MATERIALS LTD 12,000 12,000 SB (B) BONNINGTON MAINS FARM KIRKNEWTON ESTATES & DEVELOPMENT MIDLOTHIAN CEMEX UK PROPERTIES, CEMEX HOUSE COLDHARBOUR LANE, THORPE, EGHAM, SURREY TW20 8TD 10 03/C412R/1 001 DISTRIBUTION WAREHOUSE RV MENZIES DISTRIBUTION LTD 395,000 395,000 SB 1 CLAYLANDS ROAD NEWBRIDGE ERNST & YOUNG MIDLOTHIAN 1 COLMORE SQUARE BIRMINGHAM B4 6HQ

Page 2 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

11 03/C754G/(A) 001 UNWORKED MINERALS RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 3,450 3,450 SB (A) CRAIGIEHILL QUARRY,DALMENY SOUTH QUEENSFERRY GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 12 03/D049/(6) 001 HOTEL & GOLF COURSES RV MARRIOTT HOTEL LTD 1,140,000 1,140,000 GE (6) DALMAHOY KIRKNEWTON GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 13 03/D051/(4) 001 PLANT RV B.P. EXPLORATION OPERATING CO. LTD. 13,000 13,000 SB (4) DALMENY SOUTH QUEENSFERRY GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 14 03/D051/(4) 002 PLANT RR INEOS FPS LIMITED 13,000 13,000 SB (4) DALMENY SOUTH QUEENSFERRY GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 15 03/D880M/(GL) 001 CAMPING PARK RR DUNDAS PROPERTIES 10,000 10,000 ALM (GL) DUNDAS ESTATE,DALMENY SOUTH QUEENSFERRY PER DAVID SEED & CO. WEST LOTHIAN COTHILL DUNS

TD10 6YW

Page 3 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

16 03/E210/100 004 HOTEL RR AMARIS HOSPITALITY LIMITED 964,000 964,000 GE 100 EASTFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH L & H VALUATION LTD

145 BALSHAGRAY AVENUE GLASGOW G11 7DL 17 03/E210/100 005 HOTEL RR AMARIS HOSPITALITY LIMITED 964,000 964,000 GE 100 EASTFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH L & H VALUATION LTD

145 BALSHAGRAY AVENUE GLASGOW G11 7DL 18 03/G280/167 001 SCHOOL RV THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND PLC 656,000 656,000 NC 167 GLASGOW ROAD EDINBURGH AVISON YOUNG

149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 19 03/G280/175-179 001 OFFICE RV THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND PLC 5,515,000 5,515,000 NC 175-179 GLASGOW ROAD EDINBURGH AVISON YOUNG

149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 20 03/H655/(2) 001 BUILDINGS & PLANT RV TARMAC LTD. 135,500 135,500 SB (2) HILLWOOD NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 4 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

21 03/H655/(3) 001 BATCHING PLANT RV AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES UK LTD 29,900 29,900 RM (3) HILLWOOD NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 22 03/I578/(2) 003 HOTEL RR INTERSTATE HOTELS AND RESORTS 356,000 356,000 GE (2) INGLISTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 23 03/I578/(2) 004 HOTEL RR INTERSTATE HOTELS AND RESORTS 356,000 356,000 GE (2) INGLISTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 24 03/N943/(9) 002 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 25 03/N943/(9) 003 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 5 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

26 03/N943/(9) 004 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 27 03/N943/(9) 005 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 28 03/N943/(9) 006 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 29 03/N943/(9) 007 HOTEL RR HAND PICKED HOTELS LIMITED 666,000 666,000 GE (9) NORTON NEWBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 30 03/W366K/(1) 001 CARAVAN PARK RV ALASTAIR GUINAN 18,200 18,200 ALM (1) WEST CLIFTON MID CALDER GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 6 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

31 12/O040/101 001 HOTEL RV ATLAS HOTELS LTD T/A EXPRESS BY 508,000 508,000 RP 101 OCEAN DRIVE HOLIDAY INN EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 32 12/W627/8 001 BATCHING PLANT RR AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES UK LTD 125,250 125,250 RM 8 WESTERN HARBOUR, LEITH DOCKS EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 33 14/S678/114-116 002 HOTEL RR MITCHELLS & BUTLERS PLC 232,000 232,000 GE 114-116 ST. JOHN'S ROAD EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 34 15/C473/7-8 001 HOTEL RR PLATFORM 5 (EDINBURGH) LTD 456,000 456,000 RP 7-8 CLIFTON TERRACE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 35 15/C473/7-8 002 HOTEL RR PLATFORM 5 (EDINBURGH) LTD 456,000 456,000 RP 7-8 CLIFTON TERRACE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 7 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

36 15/C473/(8) 002 PUBLIC HOUSE RR GREENE KING BREWING AND RETAILING LTD 170,000 170,000 RP (8) CLIFTON TERRACE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 37 15/E323/23-26 002 HOTEL RR TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD 184,250 184,250 GE 23-26 EGLINTON CRESCENT EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 38 15/E323/23-26 003 HOTEL RR TRAVELODGE HOTELS LTD 184,250 184,250 GE 23-26 EGLINTON CRESCENT EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 39 15/G959/14-16 001 HOTEL RR FOURTEEN2EIGHTEEN LIMITED 70,500 70,500 GE 14-16 GROSVENOR STREET C - 66900 D - 3600 EDINBURGH 14-16 GROSVENOR STREET

EDINBURGH 40 15/H334/(5) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV EXTERION MEDIA LTD 20,400 20,400 ALM (5) HAYMARKET EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU

Page 8 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

41 16/B333/69 001 HOTEL RV BRITANNIA HOTELS 479,550 479,550 RP 69 BELFORD ROAD EDINBURGH Sanderson Weatherall LLP

46-54 Great Titchfield Street London W1W 7QA 42 16/C339/9 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RV ROTHESAY RESICENCE LTD 42,000 42,000 GE 9 CHESTER STREET EDINBURGH PETER HENRY

9 ST. VINCENT STREET EDINBURGH EH3 6SW 43 16/M096/59 001 HOTEL RV GREGORY FAVIER 37,900 37,900 RM 59 MANOR PLACE C - 35900 D - 2000 EDINBURGH 59B MANOR PLACE

EDINBURGH

EH3 7EG 44 16/P048/37 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RV YORK SERVICES LTD 81,000 81,000 GE 37 PALMERSTON PLACE EDINBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD

199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 45 16/R819/6 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RV ROTHESAY RESIDENCE LTD 35,000 35,000 GE 6 ROTHESAY PLACE EDINBURGH PETER HENRY

9 ST. VINCENT STREET EDINBURGH EH3 6SW

Page 9 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

46 16/R819/7-9 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RV ROTHESAY RESIDENCE LTD 133,000 133,000 GE 7-9 ROTHESAY PLACE EDINBURGH PETER HENRY

9 ST. VINCENT STREET EDINBURGH EH3 6SW 47 16/R824/7-9 001 TIME SHARE UNITS RV HAPIMAG RESORTS & RESIDENCES LTD 189,000 189,000 GE 7-9 ROTHESAY TERRACE EDINBURGH BUSINESSRATESADVICE.COM

REGENT COURT 70 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 2QZ 48 17/I839/5 001 HOTEL RR S.G. & A.L. CASE 30,700 30,700 GE 5 INVERLEITH TERRACE C - 26000 D - 4700 EDINBURGH 5 INVERLEITH TERRACE

EDINBURGH 49 18/F936/42 001 LODGE HOTEL RV FREDERICK HOUSE HOTEL LTD 188,250 188,250 RP 42 FREDERICK STREET EDINBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD

233 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QY 50 18/G110/16 001 HOTEL RV GLENDOLA LEISURE GROUP 557,000 557,000 GE 16 GEORGE STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 10 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

51 18/G465/6 001 HOTEL RV SHANTI HOSPITALITY UK LTD 91,700 91,700 GE 6 GLOUCESTER PLACE EDINBURGH PRESTON TAIT

CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE

PH8 0BW 52 18/G465/6 002 HOTEL RR SHANTI HOSPITALITY UK LTD 91,700 91,700 GE 6 GLOUCESTER PLACE EDINBURGH PRESTON TAIT

CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE

PH8 0BW 53 18/G465/10 001 HOTEL ANNEXE RV NIRA CALEDONIA 69,400 69,400 GE 10 GLOUCESTER PLACE EDINBURGH PRESTON TAIT

CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE

PH8 0BW 54 18/G465/10 002 HOTEL ANNEXE RR NIRA CALEDONIA 69,400 69,400 GE 10 GLOUCESTER PLACE EDINBURGH PRESTON TAIT

CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE

PH8 0BW

Page 11 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

55 18/H159/4 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR DESTINY SCOTLAND PROPERTY LIMITED 42,000 42,000 GE 4 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP 56 18/H159/18 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR DESTINY SCOTLAND PROPERTY LIMITED 60,000 60,000 GE 18 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP 57 18/H159/18 002 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR DESTINY SCOTLAND PROPERTY LIMITED 60,000 60,000 GE 18 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP 58 18/H559/21-23 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR YORK SERVICES LIMITED 73,800 73,800 GE 21-23 HILL STREET EDINBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD

199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD

Page 12 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

59 18/H719/7-11 001 HOTEL RV GLENDOLA LEISURE GROUP 335,000 335,000 GE 7-11 HOPE STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 60 18/P939/64(A) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR BLOWUP MEDIA UK LTD 21,600 21,600 ALM 64(A) PRINCES STREET EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 61 18/P939/64(A) 002 ADVERTISING STATION RR COAL PENSION PROPERTIES LIMITED 21,600 21,600 ALM 64(A) PRINCES STREET EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 62 18/P939/125A 001 LODGE HOTEL RV PARCOTEL LTD 61,000 61,000 RP 125A PRINCES STREET EDINBURGH RYDEN

PROPERTY CONSULTANTS & CHARTERED SURVE 7 EXCHANGE CRESCENT CONFERENCE SQUARE EDINBURGH EH3 8AN

Page 13 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

63 18/Q322/74-77 002 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR GLOAG SERVICED APARTMENTS LTD 451,000 451,000 GE 74-77 QUEEN STREET EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 64 18/S567/42 002 APART HOTEL RR St Andrew Square (Property) Limited 578,000 578,000 RP 42 ST. ANDREW SQUARE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 65 18/Y584/44 002 HOTEL RR PREMIER INN 581,000 581,000 GE 44 YORK PLACE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 66 18/Y750/10-12 002 SERVICED APARTMENTS RR EDINBURGH ETERNAL SPRING 212,500 212,500 GE 10-12 YOUNG STREET EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 67 19/B849/(165) 001 REFUSE DEPOT RV CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 400,000 400,000 SB (165) BROUGHTON ROAD EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 14 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

68 19/C961/10-12(A) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 47,400 47,400 ALM 10-12(A) CROALL PLACE EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 69 20/G850/2 002 HOTEL RR ECF OMNI S.A.R.L 668,000 668,000 GE 2 GREENSIDE PLACE EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP 70 20/G850/2 003 HOTEL RR ECF OMNI S.A.R.L 668,000 668,000 GE 2 GREENSIDE PLACE EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP 71 20/G850/20 001 THEATRE RV AMBASSADOR THEATRE GROUP (VENUES) UK 456,000 456,000 RP 20 GREENSIDE PLACE LTD EDINBURGH BOLTON BIRCH

CASTLE HILL HOUSE CASTLE HILL WINDSOR

SL4 1PD

Page 15 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

72 22/C240/(1A) 002 ADVERTISING STATION RR FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 43,500 43,500 ALM (1A) CARRON PLACE EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 73 22/E276/65 001 BATCHING PLANT RV CEMEX UK MATERIALS LTD 41,500 41,500 SB 65 EDINBURGH DOCK, LEITH DOCKS EDINBURGH ESTATES & DEVELOPMENT

CEMEX UK PROPERTIES, CEMEX HOUSE COLDHARBOUR LANE, THORPE, EGHAM, SURREY TW20 8TD 74 22/E276/67 001 BATCHING PLANT RV CEMEX UK MATERIALS LTD 74,300 74,300 SB 67 EDINBURGH DOCK, LEITH DOCKS EDINBURGH ESTATES & DEVELOPMENT

CEMEX UK PROPERTIES, CEMEX HOUSE COLDHARBOUR LANE, THORPE, EGHAM, SURREY TW20 8TD 75 22/S006/114(A) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR PRIMESIGHT LTD 21,700 21,700 ALM 114(A) SALAMANDER STREET EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW

Page 16 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

76 22/S006/114(B) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV PRIMESIGHT LTD 21,700 21,700 ALM 114(B) SALAMANDER STREET EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 77 22/S177/1(B1) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 47,400 47,400 ALM 1(B1) SEAFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 78 23/G988/21 001 SHOP RV MARKS & SPENCER PLC 1,920,000 1,920,000 SB 21 GYLE AVENUE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 79 23/L699R/1 003 HOTEL RR WHITBREAD PLC 909,000 909,000 RP 1 LOCHSIDE COURT EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 80 23/L700/1-3 001 OFFICE RV AEGON UK PLC 2,430,000 2,430,000 NC 1-3 LOCHSIDE CRESCENT EDINBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD

199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD

Page 17 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

81 23/L700/1-3 003 OFFICE RR AEGON UK PLC 2,440,000 2,440,000 NC 1-3 LOCHSIDE CRESCENT EDINBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD

199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 82 28/S375/153 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 41,000 41,000 ALM 153 SLATEFORD ROAD EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 83 28/W649/39(B) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 61,000 61,000 ALM 39(B) WESTFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 84 29/W674/9 001 DISTILLERY RV NORTH BRITISH DISTILLERY CO. LTD 805,000 805,000 SB 9 WHEATFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 85 30/S219/5 001 LODGE HOTEL RR CITYROOMZ EDINBURGH 177,250 177,250 RP 5 SHANDWICK PLACE EDINBURGH RYDEN LLP

130 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5HF

Page 18 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

86 30/S219/25A 001 LODGE HOTEL RV CITYROOMZ EDINBURGH LTD 245,500 245,500 RP 25A SHANDWICK PLACE EDINBURGH RYDEN

PROPERTY CONSULTANTS & CHARTERED SURVE 7 EXCHANGE CRESCENT CONFERENCE SQUARE EDINBURGH EH3 8AN 87 30/S219/25A 002 LODGE HOTEL RV MFW PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT LIMITED 245,500 245,500 RP 25A SHANDWICK PLACE EDINBURGH A B ROBB LIMITED

10B QUEENS GARDEN ABERDEEN AB15 4YD 88 31/B041/7 001 PUBLIC HOUSE RV EDINBURGH NAPIER UNIVERSITY 80,700 80,700 RP 7 BAINFIELD PLACE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 89 32/C095/10 001 THEATRE RV CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 139,500 139,500 RP 10 CAMBRIDGE STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 90 32/C265/537 001 HOTEL ANNEXE RV CASTLEGATE INVESTMENTS (EDINBURGH) LTD 46,200 46,200 GE 537 CASTLEHILL EDINBURGH GRAHAM & SIBBALD

233 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QY

Page 19 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

91 32/G665/94-96 001 LODGE HOTEL RV G1 GROUP 348,500 348,500 RP 94-96 GRASSMARKET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 92 32/G915/15(01)-17 001 THEATRE RV CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 167,800 167,800 RP 15(01)-17 GRINDLAY STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 93 32/L459/2 001 THEATRE RV CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 232,000 232,000 RP 2 LEVEN STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 94 32/S370L/36 001 APART HOTEL RV AZURE EDINBURGH INVESTMENT LTD 690,000 690,000 RP 36 SIMPSON LOAN EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 95 33/R524/7 001 LODGE HOTEL RV UOE ACCOMMODATION LTD T/A EDINBURGH 76,000 76,000 RP 7 RICHMOND PLACE FIRST EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 20 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

96 34/C169/231 001 APART HOTEL RV ADAGIO HOTELS UK LTD 996,000 996,000 GE 231 CANONGATE EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 97 34/C519/20 001 HOTEL RV CAMERON GUEST HOUSE GROUP 162,250 162,250 RM 20 COCKBURN STREET EDINBURGH 51 MITCHELL STREET

EDINBURGH

EH6 7BD 98 34/C519/20 002 HOTEL RR CAMERON GUEST HOUSE GROUP 207,250 207,250 RM 20 COCKBURN STREET EDINBURGH CAMERON GUEST HOUSE GROUP

8 JOHN'S PLACE EDINBURGH EH6 7EL 99 34/C697/139 001 HOTEL RV G1 GROUP 471,000 471,000 RP 139 COWGATE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 100 34/N044N/1 001 APART HOTEL RV HOLYROOD APARTHOTEL (EDINBURGH) LTD 465,500 465,500 GE 1 NETHER BAKEHOUSE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 21 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

101 34/N297/13-29 001 THEATRE RV CITY OF EDINBURGH COUNCIL 418,000 418,000 RP 13-29 NICOLSON STREET EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 102 34/S645/12-26 001 APART HOTEL RV FRASERS ST GILES STREET MANAGEMENT LTD 502,000 502,000 RP 12-26 ST. GILES STREET EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 103 34/W229/16-22 001 APART HOTEL RV BDL MANAGEMENT LTD 359,500 359,500 RP 16-22 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 104 35/L807/65 001 CAR WASH RV ANDUFF CAR WASH LTD T/A IMO 28,100 28,100 LH 65 LONDON ROAD EDINBURGH 35-37 AMERSHAM HILL

HIGH WYCOMBE BUCKINGHAMSHIRE

HP13 6NU

Page 22 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

105 37/S177/10 001 CAR WASH RV ANDUFF CAR WASH LTD T/A IMO 20,400 20,400 LH 10 SEAFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH 35-37 AMERSHAM HILL

HIGH WYCOMBE BUCKINGHAMSHIRE

HP13 6NU 106 37/S177/46(1) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 47,400 47,400 ALM 46(1) SEAFIELD ROAD EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 107 37/T484/3/1-17 001 SERVICED APARTMENTS RV OAKHILL APARTMENTS EDINBURGH LTD 102,500 102,500 GE 3/1-17 THORNTREESIDE EDINBURGH OAKHILL APARTMENTS (EDINBURGH) LTD EDEN MANSION CUPAR ROAD ST ANDREWS FIFE KY16 0UP 108 39/S179/40/2(A) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV SIS DIGITAL MEDIA LIMITED 49,000 49,000 ALM 40/2(A) SEAFIELD ROAD EAST EDINBURGH WYM REAL ESTATE

THE MERCHANTS HALL 22 HANOVER STREET EDINBURGH

EH2 2EP

Page 23 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

109 42/C071/(B) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RV PRIMESIGHT LTD 21,700 21,700 ALM (B) CALDER ROAD EDINBURGH COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL

6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 110 42/C071/(D) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR JCDECAUX UK LTD 37,800 37,800 ALM (D) CALDER ROAD EDINBURGH MONTAGU EVANS

RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 111 42/C979/28 001 BATCHING PLANT RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 24,400 24,400 RM 28 CULTINS ROAD EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 112 54/M802N/7(A) 001 SHOP RR KLONDYKE GARDEN CENTRES LTD 6,800 6,800 ALM 7(A) MORTONHALL GATE EDINBURGH GERALD EVE LLP

140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 24 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

113 54/M802N/38 001 CARAVAN PARK RR THE CATCHELRAW TRUST 101,000 101,000 ALM 38 MORTONHALL GATE EDINBURGH CKD GALBRAITH LLP

59 GEORGE STREET EDINBURGH EH2 2JG 114 57/N177/(80/1) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR CLEAR CHANNEL UK LTD 21,700 21,700 ALM (80/1) NEWCRAIGHALL ROAD MUSSELBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE MIDLOTHIAN 150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 115 57/N363/(78A) 003 ADVERTISING STATION RR FORREST OUTDOOR MEDIA LTD 21,700 21,700 ALM (78A) NIDDRIE MAINS ROAD EDINBURGH JONES LANG LASALLE

150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND 116 04/P320AM/(A) 001 FOOTBALL GROUND RV MIDLOTHIAN COUNCIL 11,100 11,100 ALM (A) PENICUIK PARK PENICUIK GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 117 05/O290AM/(10) 001 BATCHING PLANT RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 104,500 104,500 RM (10) OLD CLIPPENS LOANHEAD GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 25 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

118 10/N750AM/(1E) 001 BATCHING PLANT RV TILLICOUTRY QUARRIES 159,500 159,500 RM (1E) NEWTONGRANGE DALKEITH GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 119 11/U330AM/(B) 001 SAND RV TILLICOULTRY QUARRIES 86,600 57,800 SB (B) UPPER DALHOUSIE P - 29000 M - 57600 BONNYRIGG GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 120 11/U330AM/(B) 002 SAND RR TILLICOULTRY QUARRIES 87,400 58,600 SB (B) UPPER DALHOUSIE P - 29800 M - 29800 BONNYRIGG GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 121 13/E695AM/2-4 001 HOTEL RV ADMIRAL TAVERNS 23,600 23,600 RM 2-4 ESKBANK ROAD DALKEITH GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 122 13/M576AM/(1) 001 HOTEL RV MELVILLE CASTLE LTD 218,000 218,000 GE (1) MELVILLE CASTLE LASSWADE RYDEN MIDLOTHIAN PROPERTY CONSULTANTS & CHARTERED SURVE 7 EXCHANGE CRESCENT CONFERENCE SQUARE EDINBURGH EH3 8AN

Page 26 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

123 16/C324AM/(1) 001 BATCHING PLANT RV BREEDON NORTHERN LIMITED 14,100 14,100 RM (1) CATWELL QUARRY,COUSLAND DALKEITH GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 124 18/B725AM/(1) 001 UNWORKED MINERALS RV TILLICOULTRY QUARRIES 4,000 4,000 SB (1) BROADLAW GOREBRIDGE GERALD EVE LLP MIDLOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 125 18/M671AM/(A) 001 QUARRY RV CEMEX UK MATERIALS LTD 130,850 88,600 SB (A) MIDDLETON HALL P - 46350 M - 84500 GOREBRIDGE CEMEX UK MIDLOTHIAN C/O CEMEX UK OPERATIONS LTD COLDHARBOUR LANE THORPE EGHAM, SURREY

TW20 8TD 126 02/E663AW/(A/3) 001 BONDED WAREHOUSE RV MORRISON BOWMORE DISTILLERS LIMITED 57,500 57,500 SB (A/3) EDINBURGH ROAD LINLITHGOW MONTAGU EVANS WEST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU

Page 27 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

127 03/B276AW/(D) 001 CARAVAN PARK RV WEST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 10,400 10,400 ALM (D) BEECRAIGS LINLITHGOW D.M. HALL WEST LOTHIAN 17 CORSTORPHINE ROAD EDINBURGH EH12 6DD 128 05/H886AW/(A) 001 HOTEL RV MACDONALD HOTELS LIMITED 410,500 410,500 GE (A) HOUSTOUN HOUSE HOTEL,UPHALL BROXBURN L & H VALUATION LTD WEST LOTHIAN 145 BALSHAGRAY AVENUE GLASGOW G11 7DL 129 05/H900AW/(17A) 001 GARDEN CENTRE RV WILLIAMSON DESIGN FLORIST LTD 50,100 50,100 NC (17A) HOUSTOUN MAINS,UPHALL BROXBURN PRESTON TAIT WEST LOTHIAN CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE

PH8 0BW 130 05/N600AW/(F) 001 BING RV AITHRIE ESTATES 26,200 15,900 SB (F) NIDDRY MAINS P - 5600 M - 20600 WINCHBURGH THE FACTOR WEST LOTHIAN HOPETOUN ESTATES OFFICE HOME FARM, HOPETOUN SOUTH QUEENSFERRY EH30 9SL 131 15/H343AW/1 002 LODGE HOTEL RR MR RANDEZ T/A LIVINGSTON LODGE HOTEL 109,000 109,000 RP 1 HAWK BRAE LIVINGSTON BUSINESSRATESADVICE.COM WEST LOTHIAN REGENT COURT 70 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 2QZ Page 28 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

132 18/A348AW/1 001 HOTEL RV JUPITER HOTELS LTD 334,500 334,500 GE 1 ALMOND VIEW LIVINGSTON GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 133 18/A462JW/(I/2) 001 STANCE RV MARS PENSION TRUSTEES LTD 10,000 10,000 LD (I/2) ALMONDVALE AVENUE LIVINGSTON GL HEARN LIMITED WEST LOTHIAN 3RD FLOOR 1 GUILDHALL SQUARE SOUTHAMPTON

SO14 7FP 134 18/A462JW/(I/3) 001 STANCE RV MARS PENSION TRUSTEES LTD 10,000 10,000 LD (I/3) ALMONDVALE AVENUE LIVINGSTON GL HEARN LIMITED WEST LOTHIAN 3RD FLOOR 1 GUILDHALL SQUARE SOUTHAMPTON

SO14 7FP 135 18/A462JW/(I/6) 001 STANCE RV MARS PENSION TRUSTEES LTD 10,000 10,000 LD (I/6) ALMONDVALE AVENUE LIVINGSTON GL HEARN LIMITED WEST LOTHIAN 3RD FLOOR 1 GUILDHALL SQUARE SOUTHAMPTON

SO14 7FP

Page 29 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

136 18/A464AW/(C1) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C1) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 137 18/A464AW/(C2) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C2) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 138 18/A464AW/(C2) 002 STANCE RV DATT ASSOCIATES LTD T/A CLEAR-COAT LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C2) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 139 18/A464AW/(C3) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C3) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG

Page 30 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

140 18/A464AW/(C5) 001 STANCE RV PHOTO ME INTERNATIONAL PLC 5,600 5,600 LD (C5) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL WEST LOTHIAN 6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 141 18/A464AW/(C5) 003 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 5,600 5,600 LD (C5) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 142 18/A464AW/(C5) 002 STANCE RR PHOTO ME INTERNATIONAL PLC 5,600 5,600 LD (C5) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL WEST LOTHIAN 6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 143 18/A464AW/(C6) 001 STANCE RV PHOTO ME INTERNATIONAL PLC 5,600 5,600 LD (C6) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL WEST LOTHIAN 6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW

Page 31 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

144 18/A464AW/(C6) 003 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 5,600 5,600 LD (C6) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 145 18/A464AW/(C6) 002 STANCE RR PHOTO ME INTERNATIONAL PLC 5,600 5,600 LD (C6) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL WEST LOTHIAN 6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 146 18/A464AW/(C7) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C7) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 147 18/A464AW/(C8) 001 STANCE RV AA 20,000 20,000 LD (C8) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON AVISON YOUNG WEST LOTHIAN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 32 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

148 18/A464AW/(C8) 002 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C8) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 149 18/A464AW/(C9) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C9) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 150 18/A464AW/(G1) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (G1) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 151 18/A464AW/(C10) 002 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C10) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG

Page 33 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

152 18/A464AW/(C11) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C11) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 153 18/A464AW/(C13) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C13) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 154 18/A464AW/(C14) 001 STANCE RV LIVINGSTON CENTRE LTD 20,000 20,000 LD (C14) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON ERIC YOUNG & CO. WEST LOTHIAN WAVERLEY GATE 2-4 WATERLOO PLACE EDINBURGH

EH1 3EG 155 18/A464AW/(F/2) 001 ADVERTISING STATION RR CLEAR CHANNEL UK LTD 96,700 96,700 ALM (F/2) ALMONDVALE CENTRE LIVINGSTON JONES LANG LASALLE WEST LOTHIAN 150 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5ND

Page 34 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

156 20/P675AW/(1) 001 BUILDINGS RR GREEN TOWN (HEARTSLANDS) LTD 50,000 50,000 SB (1) POLKEMMET WHITBURN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL WEST LOTHIAN 6TH FLOOR 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 1RW 157 23/B428AW/(C) 001 HOTEL RV HANNIGAN HOTELS LTD 124,250 124,250 GE (C) BLACKBURN ROAD BATHGATE PETER DARROCH WEST LOTHIAN CDLH 166 BUCHANAN STREET GLASGOW

G1 2LW 158 23/S646AW/(1) 001 FACTORY RV GLEN TURNER COMPANY LTD 2,044,000 2,044,000 SB (1) STARLAW ROAD LIVINGSTON MONTAGU EVANS WEST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 159 23/S646AW/(1) 002 FACTORY RR GLEN TURNER COMPANY LTD 2,112,000 2,112,000 SB (1) STARLAW ROAD LIVINGSTON MONTAGU EVANS WEST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU

Page 35 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

160 23/S646AW/(1) 003 FACTORY RR GLEN TURNER COMPANY LTD 2,149,000 2,149,000 SB (1) STARLAW ROAD LIVINGSTON MONTAGU EVANS WEST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 161 25/D660AW/(J) 001 BATCHING PLANT RV BREEDON NORTHERN LIMITED 47,000 47,000 RM (J) DRUMSHORELAND BROXBURN GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 162 27/W500AW/18 001 FACTORY RV DIAGEO 1,438,000 1,438,000 SB 18 WESTERTON ROAD, EAST MAINS IND. ESTATE BROXBURN AVISON YOUNG WEST LOTHIAN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 163 28/L252AW/(1) 001 SAND RV AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES 286,300 211,500 SB (1) LEVENSEAT P - 136700 M - 149600 FAULDHOUSE GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 164 28/L252AW/(3) 001 UNWORKED MINERALS RV AGGREGATE INDUSTRIES 3,000 3,000 SB (3) LEVENSEAT FAULDHOUSE GERALD EVE LLP WEST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 36 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

165 29/M126AW/32-34 001 HOTEL RR MR G & MRS S MCLAUGHLIN 16,900 16,900 GE 32-34 MAIN STREET STONEYBURN 32-34 MAIN STREET WEST LOTHIAN STONEYBURN WEST LOTHIAN 166 29/M884AW/(1) 001 BONDED WAREHOUSE RV NORTH BRITISH DISTILLERY CO. LTD 1,574,000 1,574,000 SB (1) MUIRHALL,ADDIEWELL WEST CALDER MONTAGU EVANS WEST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 167 30/P631AW/(5M) 001 YARD RV MULHOLLAND PLANT SERVICES LTD 6,300 6,300 ALM (5M) POLBETH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WEST CALDER BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE WEST LOTHIAN 15 EXCHANGE PLACE GLASGOW G1 3AN 168 01/M288AE/(102A) 001 FOOTBALL GROUND RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 10,600 10,600 ALM (102A) MARKET STREET MUSSELBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD MIDLOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 169 03/L036AE/(1B) 001 THEATRE RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 102,250 102,250 RP (1B) LADYWELL WAY MUSSELBURGH CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD MIDLOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD

Page 37 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

170 14/W441AE/(C1) 001 MALTINGS RV BAIRDS MALT 444,000 444,000 SB (C1) WESTER PENCAITLAND PENCAITLAND BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE EAST LOTHIAN 15 EXCHANGE PLACE GLASGOW G1 3AN 171 15/Y246AE/(A) 001 CARAVAN PARK RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 51,100 51,100 ALM (A) YELLOW CRAIG,DIRLETON NORTH BERWICK CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD EAST LOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 172 16/G532AE/(A) 001 DISTILLERY RV DIAGEO SCOTLAND LTD. 116,000 116,000 SB (A) GLENKINCHIE PENCAITLAND AVISON YOUNG EAST LOTHIAN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 173 16/G532AE/(A) 002 DISTILLERY RR DIAGEO SCOTLAND LTD. 112,000 112,000 SB (A) GLENKINCHIE PENCAITLAND AVISON YOUNG EAST LOTHIAN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 174 16/H969AE/(G) 001 QUARRY RV TARMAC NORTHERN LTD 16,700 16,700 SB (G) HUNTINGTON HADDINGTON GERALD EVE LLP EAST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 38 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

175 17/C819AE/70 001 HOTEL RV BELHAVEN BREWERY CO. LTD. 26,300 26,300 RM 70 COURT STREET HADDINGTON GERALD EVE LLP EAST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 176 17/C819AE/70 002 HOTEL RR BELHAVEN BREWERY CO. LTD. 34,000 34,000 RM 70 COURT STREET HADDINGTON GERALD EVE LLP EAST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 177 18/B768AE/5 001 HOTEL RV JOHN MCINTOSH & LYNN GORDON-MCINTOSH 29,000 29,000 RM 5 BRIDGE STREET HADDINGTON RYDEN LLP EAST LOTHIAN 130 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5HF 178 18/H690AE/11A 001 GARDEN CENTRE RV HELEN MCDONALD 56,800 56,800 NC 11A HOLDING,EAST FORTUNE NORTH BERWICK 11A HOLDING EAST LOTHIAN EAST FORTUNE NORTH BERWICK EAST LOTHIAN

179 19/H539AE/(A3) 001 HOTEL RV LYNN & JOHN MCINTOSH 19,600 19,600 RM (A3) HIGH STREET,GIFFORD HADDINGTON RYDEN LLP EAST LOTHIAN 130 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5HF

Page 39 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

180 19/L812AE/(12C) 001 SAND RV TILLICOUTRY QUARRIES 67,700 50,400 SB (12C) LONGYESTER P - 33100 M - 34600 HADDINGTON GERALD EVE LLP EAST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG 181 21/T035AE/(A) 001 CARAVAN PARK RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 65,500 65,500 ALM (A) TANTALLON PARK CARAVAN SITE NORTH BERWICK CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD EAST LOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 182 21/T035AE/(A) 002 CARAVAN PARK RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 65,500 65,500 ALM (A) TANTALLON PARK CARAVAN SITE NORTH BERWICK CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD EAST LOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 183 22/B272AE/(16) 001 HOTEL RV BROXMOUTH LEISURE LTD 42,800 42,800 RM (16) BAYSWELL PARK DUNBAR MONTAGU EVANS EAST LOTHIAN RAVENSEFT HOUSE 302 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW

G2 5RU 184 22/B720AE/(4) 001 BREWERY RV BELHAVEN BREWERY CO. LTD. 117,000 117,000 SB (4) BREWERY LANE DUNBAR GERALD EVE LLP EAST LOTHIAN 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 40 of 41 11/06/2020 Lothian Valuation Appeal Committee - 15/10/2020 Court - R072 LOTHIAN VJB 17A SOUTH GYLE CRESCENT EDINBURGH EH12 9FL CITATION LIST

CASE REFERENC SEQ. DESCRIPTION AND SITUATION TYPE APPELLANT ASSESSOR'S VALUE DECISION VALUER NO NO NO OF PROPERTY NAV RV

185 22/E523AE/(1) 001 CARAVAN PARK RR EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 31,750 31,750 ALM (1) EDINBURGH ROAD,BELHAVEN DUNBAR CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD EAST LOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 186 23/O956AE/(15) 001 LANDFILL SITE RV VIRIDOR WASTE MANAGEMENT LTD 457,000 457,000 SB (15) OXWELLMAINS DUNBAR MTS CONSULTANCY LTD EAST LOTHIAN 1 BERRYMEAD ROAD CARDIFF CF23 6QA 187 23/O956AE/(15) 002 LANDFILL SITE RR VIRIDOR WASTE MANAGEMENT LTD 457,000 457,000 SB (15) OXWELLMAINS DUNBAR MTS CONSULTANCY LTD EAST LOTHIAN GER-Y-LLYN 1 BERRYMEAD ROAD CYNCOED

CF23 6QA 188 23/T555AE/(A) 001 CARAVAN PARK RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 14,400 14,400 ALM (A) THORNTONLOCH,INNERWICK DUNBAR CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD EAST LOTHIAN 199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD 189 23/Z999AE/(13) 001 BUS SHELTERS RV EAST LOTHIAN COUNCIL 29,700 29,700 ALM (13) THROUGHOUT EAST LOTHIAN DISTRICT EAST LOTHIAN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD

199 ST. VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QD

Page 41 of 41 11/06/2020