Thesis Final Document Paddy Absolute Final 25:11:19
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Low, Patrick (2021) Capital punishment in the north east of England 1800-1878 and post mortem punishment 1752-1878. Doctoral thesis, University of Sunderland. Downloaded from: http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/id/eprint/13373/ Usage guidelines Please refer to the usage guidelines at http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/policies.html or alternatively contact [email protected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email protected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`!/%)-7.701!A+)$!?8!*%&%-*($!-0/!27/%*!,70/701&9!! O6*)$%*?+*%;!-!&?-..!&%()7+0!+,!($-')%*!)2+!-''%-*&!70!)$%!,+..+2701!-*)7(.%;!S9!V+2;! ]#$%!K$-01701!S*%&%0)-)7+0!+,!5>%(6)7+0!70!<%2(-&).%!Q'+0!#80%!BC^^EBCaLM;!! !"#$%&'()*%"+,%-(./0'1$!C!_B`!_"DBC`;!''9!LCEG"9! ! ! ! ! ! ^! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! X%/7(-)%/!)+!)$%!?%?+*8!+,!R-**8!T%/,%*0!-0/!I-*(6&!S*7(%9! ! ! ! ! ! ! % ! ! ! ' ' ' ' ' ' G! ! ,"#*' ' ' ! !"#$%&'()$&'*+,(*-&(.$/#&0"#+(*&(*-&12)%$"*&34456& a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`B6$a! PQ7!_!P10A.(2!Q)(:&H!713:&'1(&!! P\!_!71*.(2&!.A!'H1!P)(%1(!\9(31.-&! P6$!_!P(:':&H!61/&8)81(!$(*H:E1! <@T\!_!<9(H)4!@.*)0!T:&'.(G!\.*:1'G!