Arxiv:1106.0315V1 [Astro-Ph.HE] 1 Jun 2011 a R Ag Iha Xeto Est Udesp,And Pc, 10 Hundreds of Order to the Tens in of Velocity Nebu- Extent a These an at 2003)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Draft version July 25, 2018 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 11/10/09 COMPACT OPTICAL COUNTERPARTS OF ULTRALUMINOUS X-RAY SOURCES Lian Tao1,2, Hua Feng1, Fabien Grise´2, and Philip Kaaret2 Draft version July 25, 2018 ABSTRACT Using archival Hubble Space Telescope (HST) imaging data, we report the multiband photometric properties of 13 ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs) that have a unique compact optical counterpart. Both magnitude and color variation are detected at time scales of days to years. The optical color, variability, and X-ray to optical flux ratio indicate that the optical emission of most ULXs is dominated by X-ray reprocessing on the disk, similar to that of low mass X-ray binaries. For most sources, the α optical spectrum is a power-law, Fν ∝ ν with α in the range 1.0 to 2.0 and the optically emitting region has a size on the order of 1012 cm. Exceptions are NGC 2403 X-1 and M83 IXO 82, which show optical spectra consistent with direct emission from a standard thin disk, M101 ULX-1 and M81 ULS1, which have X-ray to optical flux ratios more similar to high-mass X-ray binaries, and IC 342 X-1, in which the optical light may be dominated by the companion star. Inconsistent extinction between the optical counterpart of NGC 5204 X-1 and the nearby optical nebulae suggests that they may be unrelated. Subject headings: black hole physics — accretion, accretion disks — galaxies: stellar content 1. INTRODUCTION ulation synthesis indicates that colors and magnitudes of Ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs) are nonnuclear the optical counterpart of ULXs can help distinguish be- X-ray sources with luminosity above the Eddington limit tween stellar mass and intermediate mass black holes, 39 −1 and a sample of 6 sources favors the latter interpretation of stellar mass black holes (LX > 3 × 10 erg s ) as- suming isotropic emission. ULXs with fast variability (Madhusudhan et al. 2008). The continuum component or long-term chaotic flux variation may contain accret- in the optical spectrum of NGC 5408 X-1 is consistent ing black holes in an attached binary system. They with that from a standard accretion disk with irradiation could be powered by accretion onto either intermedi- (Kaaret & Corbel 2009). However, this result is obtained 2 4 from a ground-based telescope so the nebular contribu- ate mass black holes of 10 − 10 M⊙ at sub-Eddington rate (Colbert & Mushotzky 1999; Makishima et al. 2000; tion cannot be directly resolved and has to be subtracted Kaaret et al. 2001) or normal or slightly massive stellar based on model prediction. Therefore, in most cases, HST observations are required for the study of the com- black holes of . 100 M⊙ at super or near Eddington rate (Watarai et al. 2001; Begelman 2002). pact optical counterpart of ULXs, in particular for the In black hole binaries, the X-ray emission probes the continuum emission. deep potential at regions close to the event horizon There are 10 ULXs with a unique optical counterpart while the optical emission is important to constrain their identified in the literature. We make 3 new identifica- masses, interaction with environment, and evolutionary tions in this paper. Here, we analyze all available HST history of the binary. Optical observations of ULXs have imaging data for these 13 ULXs, see Table 2, to investi- played a key role in unveiling the nature of these sources. gate their multiband spectra and variation at long time Many bright ULXs are found to be spatially associated scales. The observations and data analysis are described with an optical nebula (Pakull et al. 2003). These nebu- in § 2, and the results are discussed in § 3 and conclusions lae are large with an extent of tens to hundreds pc, and summarized in § 4. arXiv:1106.0315v1 [astro-ph.HE] 1 Jun 2011 expanding at a velocity in the order of 102 km s−1. Most of them are powered by strong shocks created by out- 2. OBSERVATIONS AND DATA ANALYSIS flows from the binary hitting the surrounding medium, 2.1. Sample and in a few cases, extraordinary photoionization is re- quired (Kaaret et al. 2004; Kaaret & Corbel 2009). The Up to beginning of analysis work for this paper, there photoionized nebulae can be used as bolometers to ex- have been 10 ULXs with a unique optical counter- treme ultraviolet and soft X-ray photons, and suggest part identified: Holmberg II X-1 (Kaaret et al. 2004), that the ULX luminosities are indeed high. Point-like op- Holmberg IX X-1 (Gris´eet al. 2011), IC 342 X-1 tical objects as compact counterparts of ULXs have been (Feng & Kaaret 2008), M81 ULS1 (Liu et al. 2008), M81 identified for 10 sources in the literature. The companion X-6 (Liu et al. 2002), M101 ULX-1 (Kuntz et al. 2005), star, intrinsic emission from the disk at large radii, and NGC 1313 X-2 (Ramsey et al. 2006; Pakull et al. 2006; disk irradiation may all contribute to the optical emission Liu et al. 2007), NGC 5204 X-1 (Liu et al. 2004), NGC and even dominate at different wavelengths. Binary pop- 5408 X-1 (Lang et al. 2007), and NGC 6946 ULX-1 (Kaaret et al. 2010). Moreover, Ptak et al. (2006) and 1 Department of Engineering Physics and Center for Astro- Roberts et al. (2008) reported possible optical counter- physics, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China parts of another 50 ULXs. However, these sources ap- 2 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Iowa, pear to have more than one optical counterparts shown Van Allen Hall, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA in the X-ray error circle. Here, using Chandra and HST 2 Tao et al. TABLE 1 TABLE 2 Positions of the reference objects, ULXs, and their List of the ULXs studied in this paper. unique optical counterparts ULX D Eg En Neb. Ref. source instrument R.A. decl. ∆ (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (J2000.0) (J2000.0) (′′) Holmberg II X-1 3.05 0.032 0.07 Y 1-4 NGC 4559 X-7 Holmberg IX X-1 3.6 0.079 0.26 ± 0.04 Y 1,2,5,6 IC 342 X-1 3.3 0.565 0.82 Y 1,2,7,8 Ref. 1 Chandra 12 36 00.353 +27 54 56.61 0.271 M81 ULS1 3.63 0.080 ··· N 1,5 HST 12 36 00.354 +27 54 56.67 M81 X-6 3.63 0.080 ··· Y 1,2,5 ULX Chandra 12 35 51.724 +27 56 04.35 0.052 M83 IXO 82 4.7 0.066 ··· N 1,9 corrected 12 35 51.725 +27 56 04.41 0.28 M101 ULX-1 7.2 0.009 0.13 Y 1,10,11 counterpart HST 12 35 51.719 +27 56 04.41 NGC 1313 X-2 3.7 0.085 0.13 ± 0.03 Y 1,2,9,12 M83 IXO 82 NGC 2403 X-1 3.2 0.040 ··· N 1,13 Ref. 1 Chandra 13 37 14.764 −29 54 28.47 0.318 NGC 4559 X-7 10 0.018 ··· N 1,9 HST 13 37 14.761 −29 54 28.26 NGC 5204 X-1 4.3 0.013 ··· Y 1,2,14 NGC 5408 X-1 4.8 0.069 0.08 ± 0.03 Y 1,15-17 Ref. 2 Chandra 13 37 19.986 −29 53 18.09 0.169 +0.08 HST 13 37 19.979 −29 53 17.68 NGC 6946 ULX-1 5.1 0.343 0.50−0.07 Y 1,18-22 ULX Chandra 13 37 19.804 −29 53 48.80 0.029 Note. — D is the adopted distance to the host galaxy in corrected 13 37 19.799 −29 53 48.43 0.18 Mpc. Eg is the Galactic extinction and En is the total extinction counterpart HST 13 37 19.797 −29 53 48.58 estimated from the surrounding optical nebulae. Column (5) in- NGC 2403 X-1 dicates whether or not the source is spatially associated with an optical nebula. Column (6) lists the references from where the ULX Chandra 07 36 25.567 +65 35 39.87 0.6 information is obtained: 1Schlegel et al. 1998; 2Pakull et al. 2002; Chandra 07 36 25.558 +65 35 39.98 0.6 3Stewart et al. 2000; 4Hoessel et al. 1998; 5Freedman et al. 1994; mean 07 36 25.563 +65 35 39.93 0.42 6Gris´eet al. 2011; 7Gris´eet al. 2006; 8Saha et al. 2002; 9Tully counterpart HST 07 36 25.562 +65 35 40.08 1988; 10Abolmasov et al. 2007; 11Stetson et al. 1998; 12Gris´eet al. 2008; 13Freedman & Madore 1988; 14Tully, Shaya, & Pierce 1992; Note. — The used Chandra observation is 2686 for NGC 4559, 15 16 17 793 for M83, and 2014/4630 for NGC 2403. The used HST datasets Karachentsev et al. 2002; Kaaret & Corbel 2009; Pakull et al. 2003; 18de Vaucouleurs, G. 1979; 19Abolmasov et al. 2008; are j92w02030, j9h811010, and j9h803010, respectively for the three 20 21 22 targets. ∆ is the 90% statistical error radius; for NGC 2403 X-1, it is Blair et al. 2001; Roberts & Colbert 2003; Blair & Fesen the absolute astrometry error of Chandra. 1994. data up to date, we surveyed ULXs in these catalogs for X-ray and optical. This alignment technique, based on possibilities of improving the relative astrometry, which a small number of reference sources, has been used for leads to the identification of a unique counterpart for an- most ULX optical identifications.