Close Encounters: Anna Seward, 1742–1809, a Woman in Provincial Cultural Life
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by University of Birmingham Research Archive, E-theses Repository CLOSE ENCOUNTERS: ANNA SEWARD, 1742–1809, A WOMAN IN PROVINCIAL CULTURAL LIFE by MARION ROBERTS A thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham for the degree of MASTER OF LETTERS School of Humanities College of Arts and Law The University of Birmingham December 2010 ABSTRACT Anna Seward (1747–1809) is best known today as a poet, but one whose reputation did not survive her death. Most studies of Seward since the nineteenth century have been critical or dismissive, but in recent years her published work has attracted more attention. Academics, particularly feminist scholars, have focused on her environmental observations, and the ways in which her writings draw attention to the gendered nature of eighteenth-century society. This study adopts a different approach by exploring Anna Seward’s private and public life within the provincial culture in which she emerged and remained until her death. Seward’s identity was shaped by her early life in the Derbyshire Peak District and the cathedral city of Lichfield. Her relationships with male mentors and friends of both sexes provided learning experiences and opportunities to develop her literary skills and personal confidence. Her wealthy clergyman father educated her at home and developed her literary interests. She was also heavily influenced by Dr Erasmus Darwin who encouraged her literary abilities and developed her confidence. Influenced by other provincial literary figures, such as Thomas Whalley, William Hayley, Robert Southey, Helen Maria Williams, Hannah More and the Ladies of Llangollen, she embarked on a publishing career, became a commentator on public affairs and acted as a critic. Her extensive letters bear witness to a wide range of interests and a large network of correspondents. Unlike other cultural figures, Seward did not move to London to participate in the competitive life of the capital. She disliked large towns and did not become part of the Bluestocking circle of metropolitan intellectuals; instead, people came to her or solicited her opinions from a distance. Seward was self- willed, independent and prepared to criticise the famous, such as Samuel Johnson and 2 Darwin, her former mentor. Her life in Lichfield, moreover, secured the disapproval of the local ecclesiastical establishment, because of her close public relationship with a married man, John Saville. Towards the end of her life she worked to secure her reputation as a poet and commentator, through the agency of Walter Scott, but after her death, his savage editing of her letters and works did much to destroy her reputation. Though Seward was a literary figure orbiting within an environment which excluded London, her life was important. It revealed how middle-class women could develop a national cultural reputation outside of the capital and provided a commentary on the vigorous nature of provincial life in the English Midlands. 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My sincere and heartfelt thanks go first to my supervisors, Sebastian Mitchell and Malcolm Dick for their support, guidance and encouragement throughout this study, then to the staff of various establishments and organisations: Pat Bamford, Librarian, Lichfield Cathedral Library; Mithra Tonking, Diocesan Records, Lichfield; Martin Sanders and Joanne Peck, Lichfield Record Office; Joanne Wilson, curator, Samuel Johnson Birthplace Museum, Alison Wallis, curator, Erasmus Darwin House, Lichfield; Sally Baggott, Curator, the Birmingham Assay Office; staff at Derbyshire Record Office and the William Salt Library, Stafford; Elizabeth Eger, The British Library, London and staff at their Reproduction Services, Wetherby, Yorkshire; Iain Gordon Brown, National Library of Scotland, Edinburgh; Lona Jones, National Library of Wales, Aberystwyth; staff at the Information Services Department, University of Birmingham; Sian Roberts and Alison Smith, Birmingham Archives and Heritage, Birmingham Central Library; Patsy Folan and Jane Love, Wythall Library, Worcestershire Libraries Service; John Clifford, Curator, Eyam Museum, Derbyshire; Anne Newport, Victoria & Albert Museum, London; Peter Meadows, Keeper of Ely Diocesan Records, Cambridge University Library, Cambridge; staff at the County Records Office, Cambridge; Lucy Peltz, National Portrait Gallery, London and Dr. Desmond King-Hele, historian and Erasmus Darwin biographer. In the United States of America, I wish to thank Bruce Kirby, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington; Becca Findlay Lloyd, the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut; Leslie 4 Morris, Curator of Manuscripts, Houghton Library, Harvard College Library, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts; Josephine Dobkin, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; Janie Cohen, Director, The Robert Hull Fleming Museum, Burlington, Vermont and staff at the National Library of Congress, Washington, all of whom have been most courteous and helpful throughout. My greatest debt, though, is to my family – my late husband, Sydney Roberts and sons, Andrew and Eric, who have supported me, in so many ways, in my quest for the Swan of Lichfield. 5 CONTENTS Pages Abstract 2 Acknowledgements 4 Abbreviations 7 Anna Seward (1742–1809): Chronology 8 Introduction 13 1. Eighteenth-Century Lichfield and Provincial Society 43 2. Anna Seward: Early Life and Education, 1742–1756 57 3. Independence and Defiance: The Seward and Saville Relationship, 1754–1809 76 4. Dependence and Independence: Anna Seward and Erasmus Darwin, 1756–1802 92 5. Discovering Anna Seward: Batheaston and Beyond, 1780–1795 108 6. Decline and Death, 1796–1809 131 7. Conclusion 150 Appendix 1: Correspondence between Anna Seward and Erasmus Darwin, September 1780: the ‘Cat’ Letters and Poems 157 Appendix II: Anna Seward: Last Will and Testament 170 Bibliography 175 6 ABBREVIATIONS The following abbreviations appear in the thesis: AS Anna Seward CUL Cambridge University Library DRO Derbyshire Record Office FM Fleming Museum, Vermont HU Harvard University LoC Library of Congress, Washington LCL Lichfield Cathedral Library LRO Lichfield Record Office MM Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York NA National Archives, Kew NPG National Portrait Gallery, London PRC Prerogative Court of Canterbury SJBM Samuel Johnson Birthplace Museum, Lichfield UBL University of Birmingham Library UCL University College Library, London WSL William Salt Library, Stafford YL Yale University 7 ANNA SEWARD (1742–1809): CHRONOLGY 1742: Born St. Laurence’s Rectory, Eyam, Derbyshire, 12 December (Father: Reverend Thomas Seward. Mother: Elizabeth Hunter. Married: Newton- In-the-Thistle, Warwickshire, 1740). 1744: Sarah Seward born 17 March (Five other children born to the Sewards, between 1747–1753 of which three died early in life and two were stillborn). 1749: Reverend Thomas Seward appointed Residentiary Canon, Lichfield Cathedral. Family move to 15 Saddler (Market) Street, Lichfield. 1754: Seward family move into the Bishop’s Palace. 1755: John Saville, Vicar Choral, commences harpsichord lessons with Anna Seward. 1756: Dr. Erasmus Darwin comes to set up practice in Lichfield. Honora Sneyd comes to live with the Sewards. Darwin praises Anna’s poetry. Parents forbid her to write. 1757: Darwin marries Anna Seward’s friend, Mary Howard. 1759: Anna Seward writes poem, Portrait of Miss Levett 1761: Samuel Johnson visits his mother and Lucy Porter. Anna Seward begins to write verse epistle, Louisa 1762: Portrait painted by Tilly Kettle. Meets Captain Hugh Temple (October). Begins the ‘juvenile’ letters. Reads Rousseau’s Julie (May). 1763: Sarah is engaged to Johnson’s stepson, Joseph Porter (June). Lucy Porter inherits fortune from her brother, Capt. Jervis Porter of £10,000. Builds Redcourt in Lichfield. 1764: Saville is mentioned for the first time in the ‘juvenile’ letters. April: Joseph Porter arrives from Italy. June: Sarah becomes ill with ‘putrid fever’, 2 June and dies 9 June from possibly Miliary Tuberculosis. July: Seward and her father go to Eyam. She starts a relationship with Major Wright of Eyam Hall. Aug: Returns to Lichfield. Major Wright visits. He proposes marriage but is dismissed by Canon Seward. Sept: Seward goes to London. Meets Captain Temple again. Becomes engaged. After her return, her father breaks the engagement. She is wooed and then jilted by Cornet Vyse. Seward writes and publishes, The Visions, an Elegy. 8 1765: Seward writes and publishes, Elegy, Addressed to Cornet Vyse. 1766: Richard Lovell Edgeworth visits Lichfield. Lucy Porter lives at Redcourt. 1767: Samuel Johnson’s mother is very ill. Lucy Porter asks him to visit but he fails to do so. Lucy Porter informs him of his mother’s death on the 23 January. Johnson does not attend her funeral. August: Seward is away from home for three months. 1768: Capt. Temple renews his courtship. Seward writes that she is not interested. She fractures her right knee-cap in a fall down steps. Darwin treats her. 1769: Seward meets John André in Buxton. He travels back to Lichfield, meets Honora Sneyd. André conducts a ‘triangular’ romance with Honora Sneyd through letters addressed to Anna Seward. André proposes marriage to Honora. 1770: Edgeworth, Day and his two orphan girls come to live at Stowe House. André dismissed by Mr. Sneyd. Mary Darwin dies. Seward and Saville painted by John Smart. Seward begins her cycle of Sonnets. 1771: Edgeworth in love with Honora Sneyd. Day proposes marriage