First Reported Case of Lorazepam-Assisted Interview in A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Case Reports in Psychiatry Volume 2014, Article ID 346939, 4 pages http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/346939 Case Report First Reported Case of Lorazepam-Assisted Interview in a Young Indian Female Presenting with Dissociative Identity Disorder and Improvement in Symptoms after the Interview Raheel Mushtaq,1,2 Sheikh Shoib,1,2 Tasleem Arif,3 Tabindah Shah,4 and Sahil Mushtaq5 1 ECT Clinic, Postgraduate Department of Psychiatry, Government Medical College, Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir 190010, India 2 Memory Clinic, Postgraduate Department of Psychiatry, Government Medical College, Srinagar 190010, India 3 Post Graduate Department of Dermatology, Government Medical College, Srinagar 190010, India 4 Government Medical College, Srinagar, Jammu and Kashmir 190010, India 5 Acharya Shri Chander College of Medical Sciences, Jammu, India Correspondence should be addressed to Raheel Mushtaq; [email protected] Received 30 May 2014; Revised 17 July 2014; Accepted 18 July 2014; Published 5 August 2014 Academic Editor: Toshiya Inada Copyright © 2014 Raheel Mushtaq et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Dissociative identity disorder (DID) is one of the most fascinating disorders in psychiatry. The arduous search to reveal the obscurity of this disorder has led to colossal research in this area over the years. Although drug-assisted interviews are not widely used, they may be beneficial for some patients that do not respond to conventional treatments such as supportive psychotherapy or psychopharmacotherapy. Drug-assisted interviews facilitate recall of memories in promoting integration of dissociative information. We report a case of a 16-year-old female with dissociative identity disorder (DID) that was treated with lorazepam-assisted interview and there was rapid improvement in symptoms after the interview. 1. Introduction identity disorder (DID) in general population was found to be 1 to 3%. Various studies done in various countries Dissociation is a defensive mental process to exigency, a found 1 to 5% of DID in inpatient psychiatry units [4]. The “shut-off mechanism” against severe anxiety and severe trau- highest prevalence of DID (6–14%) was seen in emergency matic events, especially which involve serious threat to health psychiatric departments [5]. or life. DSM IV TR classifies dissociative disorders into disso- In dissociative amnesia, there is sudden loss of memory ciativeamnesia,dissociativefugue,dissociativeidentitydis- for a variable period of time, without any central nervous sys- order, depersonalization disorder, and dissociative disorder tem (CNS) disease, and that is not explained by normal for- not otherwise specified1 [ –3]. The prevalence of dissociative getfulness and understanding of the patient that no memory amnesia (DA) in various epidemiological studies is found to loss has occurred [1, 6]. DID involves presence of two or more personalities and control behaviour and feeling of the be 1.8 to 7.3%. Sar et al. found the highest prevalence (7.3%) dominant host with amnesia interfering with significant life in Turkish women. In Ross’s epidemiological study, DA was events between the parts of the personality [7, 8]. In disso- the most common (6%) dissociative disorder (DD). In other ciative disorders, the disturbances in memory do not occur studies DA was the second common DD after dissociative exclusively during the course of posttraumatic stress disorder, disorders not otherwise specified (DDNOS). On the other acute stress disorder, and somatisation disorder and also hand dissociative fugue (DF) is quite rare [2]. In Ross’s do not result from direct physiological effects of a substance, epidemiological study as well as in Johnson’s epidemiological neurological disorder, or general medical conditions [1, 9, 10]. study, no cases of DF were found [3]. Sar’s study found DF The various differential diagnoses of dissociative disorders tobetheleastcommonDDandlifetimeprevalenceofDF are seizure disorder, substance intoxication, substance with- was found to be 0.2% [3]. The prevalence of dissociative drawal, malingering, factitious disorder, psychotic disorders, 2 Case Reports in Psychiatry and dementia. Dissociative amnesia occurs mostly in cases Mental state examination revealed a young cooperative (without any history of psychiatric illness) involving sexual girl who was appropriately dressed. She described her mood drives or physical injury to self [6, 9, 10]. DID occurs as euthymic. Thinking was goal directed with thoughts con- mostly in adolescents abused by caretakers in situations in nected to each other. She had no delusions/hallucinations/ which trauma occurs in the context of trusted relationship derealisation/thought disorders. She was oriented to time, [7, 8]. The use of drug-assisted interviews in psychiatry place, and person with intact attention and concentration at dates back to 1938 and their usefulness has been explored in the time of the examination, performed serial sevens, digit catatonia, confusion, conversion disorder, factitious disorder, span,andrecalled3of3objectsin5minutes.Shehadinability mutism, dissociative amnesia, and DID [10–13]. Drug- in remembering her name, information of the past (retro- assisted interviews are seen useful in patients of dissociative grade amnesia), could not tell her home address, personal disorders that do not respond to pharmacological agents or biodata, and was also unable to recall events of her life, prior psychological measures. Drug-assisted interview usefulness to the admission. Several questions of the examiner were in dissociative disorders is by facilitating recall of memories associated with confabulations of embarrassment. She had no in promoting integration of dissociative information [1, 12]. insight of her illness and appeared unconcerned for the same. The various drugs used for drug-assisted interviews include Her physical examination was unremarkable. Neurological amobarbital, thiopentone, diazepam, lorazepam, and mida- assessment and basic laboratory testing including electroen- zolam. Although amobarbital is the most commonly used cephalography (EEG), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), drug in the last 80 years, in recent years, benzodiazepines and drug screening revealed no significant abnormalities. The have begun to replace it to a large extent. The possible reasons Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES) was administered to for the decline in the use of amobarbital include the side the patient and she had a score of 50% on DES. The DES effects of barbiturates, especially respiratory depression and is an instrument used for screening dissociative disorders. absence of a specific antagonising agent [1, 11]. To the best of High DES scores occur in chronic dissociative disorders like the knowledge of the investigator, there are just three case DID DF and DDNOS. Further score of 48% or above is reportsofdissociativeamnesiaintheliteratureontheuse indicative of diagnosis of DID [14]. Based on the longitudinal of lorazepam-assisted interviews [1]. However there are no history, mental status examination (MSE) of the patient, and case reports in the literature for the use of lorazepam-assisted high score on DES (50%), a diagnosis of dissociative identity interviews in DID, although there is a case report of a disorder was established as per DSM 5 [15]andpatientwas depressive patient, whose discovery of DID occurred by admitted to the hospital for further management. amobarbital interview [13]. We report a case of a 16-year-old Patient was engaged in psychotherapy by the clinical psy- Kashmiri (Indian) female with DID, that was treated with chologist of the department. Psychoeducation was given to lorazepam-assisted interview and there was rapid improve- the patient and her parents, regarding this disorder. Sessions ment in symptoms after the interview. of psychotherapy were started by the clinical psychologist for the patient. However her memory did not recover. Therefore 2. Case Report it was decided to use a drug-assisted interview for recovery of her memory. Informed consent was obtained from the patient A 16-year-old unmarried Kashmiri (Indian) girl, student of as well as her parents. Two psychiatrists participated as inter- the 10th class, nonsmoker, was referred by the neurologist for viewers and an anaesthesiologist monitored and recorded loss of memory for the last 5-month duration. Detailed his- her clinical state during the interview. The interview was tory taken by the attendants revealed that she did not remem- performed according to previously described protocol [1, 11]. ber her name, did not recognise her relatives, including During the drug-assisted interview, the patient was able to her parents, did not remember important events of her life recall memories that precipitated the incident. In the inter- likeifsheeverwenttoschool,andevendidnotrecognizeher view, she stated that she was sexually abused by her cousin, school friends. Whenever her parents would tell her to go to who was 12 years her elder. She further stated that sexual school, she would reply that she has never been to school abuse started 6 months ago, when her cousin would come to and is an illiterate and does not know any arithmetic or any their house to help her in studies. She told that she was too shy basic knowledge, that is expected for a 10th class student.