DOCSLIB.ORG

Hardesty: the Archaeology of the Donner Party

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Hardesty: the Archaeology of the Donner Party UC Merced Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology Title Hardesty: The Archaeology of the Donner Party Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/0tf2c4qw Journal Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology, 20(1) ISSN 0191-3557 Author Scott, Douglas D Publication Date 1998-07-01 Peer reviewed eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California 134 JOURNAL OF CALIFORNIA AND GREAT BASIN ANTHROPOLOGY Levy, Richard edy of 1846-1847. The Archaeology of the Don­ 1978 Costanoan. In: Handbook of North Amer­ ner Party is a concise and well-written account ican Indians, Vol. 8, CaUfomia, Robert F. Heizer, ed., pp. 485-495. Washington: of the history, archaeological investigations, and Smithsonian Institution. reinterpretation of the events. This slim volume Margolin, Malcolm is a model of multidisciplinary research and a 1978 The Ohlone Way. Berkeley: Heyday team approach to producing a publicly oriented Books. archaeological interpretation of interesting events Milliken, Randall T. of our recent past. 1983 The Spatial Organization of Human Popu­ lation on Central California's San Fran­ The book's six chapters and appendices give cisco Peninsula at the Spanish Arrival. the reader the story of the Dormer Party both in Master's thesis, Sonoma State University. historical and archaeological context. The intro­ 1995 A Time of Little Choice: The Disintegra­ duction sets the stage for this contextual place­ tion of Tribal Culture in the San Francisco ment in both time and space, as well as stressing Bay Area, I769-I810. Ballena Press An­ thropological Papers No. 43. the multidisciplinary nature of today's historical archaeological investigations. Chapter 1 gives Milliken, Randall T., Julia Costello, Carina Johnson, Glory Anne Laffey, Ann-Marie Sayers, and Patrick us the details of the Donner Party and the trag­ Orozco edy resulting from being snowbound with lim­ 1993 Archaeological Test Excavations at Four­ ited resources. The second chapter, by Michael teen Sites Along Highways 101 and 152, Brodhead, places the Donner Party trek in a ho­ Santa Clara and San Benito Counties, Cal­ ifomia, Vol. 2: History, Ethnohistory, listic context of the entire overland emigration and Historic Archaeology. Report on file era, 1840 to 1860. In a well developed style, at the Northwest Information Center, So­ Brodhead provides the reader with a neat encap­ noma State University. sulation of the emigrant experience on the trail, and places the Donner Party in a comparative context. In the third chapter, Hardesty and Susan Lindstrom delve into the archaeological investi­ gations of the Murphy Cabin site. They effec­ tively use the historical sources to place the cabin in context. They also build to the story of the modern excavations by recounting the early efforts made to document and locate the cabin The Archaeology of the Donner Party. Donald site for various memorialization purposes. In a L. Hardesty. Reno: University of Nevada pleasant prose style, Hardesty and Lindstrom Press, 1997, xii + 156 pp., 38 figs., 4 then recount their excavations at Murphy Cabin maps, 15 tables, 3 appendices, bibliography, and the finding of the remains. This chapter index, $27.95 (hard cover). alone is a good example of how the application of modern investigation techniques can squeeze Reviewed by: just a bit more data from a previously excavated DOUGLAS D. SCOTT or impacted site. Midwest Archeological Center, National Park Service, Chapter 4 relates the investigations of Alder Federal Building, Room 474, Lincoln, NE 68508. Creek Camp. Here Hardesty demonstrates the Don Hardesty and his contributors have given value of combining traditional excavation and us a new perspective on the Donner Party trag­ sampling strategies with metal detecting to REVIEWS 135 achieve large area coverage. Using metal detec­ cludes from the smallest of ceramic sherds that tion equipment, the investigators were able to the Donner Party members were not carrying focus on specific areas where traditional excava­ old or cast-off ceramics to California. Rather, tion strategies allowed for a more detailed mate­ the ceramic evidence demonstrates that they may rial culture recovery. have purchased new plates and dishes for the The fifth chapter is entitled "Donner Party overland trip. Certainly, the ceramic types re­ Baggage." Along with the appendices, which flect that these Oregon Trail travelers were well should be read in concert with this chapter, the aware of their middle-class social and economic artifact assemblage is described and interpreted. status. Although the ceramic assemblage is An important finding is tiiat the "baggage" of small, both in size and quantity, MUler effective­ the party consisted of what would be expected ly demonstrates the importance of going beyond on an overland trek of people seeking a new mere typologies and looking for the meaning of home. As such, the artifacts are the physical objects. evidence of what was in a wagon traveling on The Archaeology of the Donner Party is well die Oregon Trail. By themselves, the artifacts illustrated and a fine contribution to the archaeo­ are interesting in this context, but the additional logical literature. Hardesty and his contributors interpretations presented in the appendices by have demonstrated, in their fluid prose style, Donald Grayson and George Miller offer some that archaeology need not be boringly presented fascinating insights into the story by detailing the in long, technical, descriptive passages. This is zooarchaeology, ceramic assemblage, and demo­ a readable and informative book. The archaeol­ graphics of the members of the Donner Party. ogy is professionally presented, yet written in a Hardesty has incorporated Grayson's and Mil­ manner easily understood by the lay reader. ler's observations and conclusions from their re­ The layout and design are well done and tmly spective appendices into his "Baggage" chapter enhance the narrative contribution. For those and the final chapter. However, die material in interested in the Overland Trail experience, any the appendices is so interesting and important, it emigrant experience, the westward expansion is this reviewer's opinion that it should have movement, or more specifically the Donner Par­ been worked directiy into the body of the last ty story, this is a book that should be on your two chapters. By way of example. Miller con­ shelf. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A New Look at the Donner Party
    ETTER FROM CALIFORNIA A New Look at the Donner Party The Native American perspective on a notorious chapter in American history is being reveaied by the excavation and study of a pioneer campsite ULIE M. SCHABLITSKY n late October 1846, an early Donner Party are remembered for out for CaUfornia from Springfield, snowstorm stranded 22 men, cannibalizing their dead in a lastrditch Missouri, in 1846. Hoping to make Iwomen, and chUdren in Alder effort to survive. the Sacramento VaUey by autumn, Creek meadow in CaUfornia's Sierra Almost 10 years ago, I arrived at they feU behind schediile after takr Nevada. The squaU came on so fierce- Alder Creek meadow, a few mues outr ing an untried shortcut through the ly and suddenly that the pioneers had side of Truckee, CaUfomia, with my Great Salt Lake Desert. When an just enough time to erect sleeping excavation codirector KeUy Dixon, of October snowstorm hit, the party was tents and a small structure of pine the University of Montana, and just 100 miles from their destination. trees covered with branches, quUts, a team of coUeagues to search Most of the migrants sought and the rubber coats off their backs. for archaeological evidence of shelter in cabins near Truckee Living conditions were crowded, and that miserable winter. The Lake (now Donner Lake), their wool and flannel clothes were story of the Donner Party is a while the famiUes of brothers useless against leaks and the damp famiUar tale, weU knovm from George and Jacob Donner, ground. As time passed, seasoned the accounts of survivors and their teamsters, and trail wood became so hard to find that rescuers.
    [Show full text]
  • Donner Memorial State Park
    Donner Memorial State Park GENERAL PLAN Volume 1 of 2 Approved by the State Park and Recreation Commission April 5, 2003 VOLUME 1 This is Volume 1 of the Final General Plan for Donner Memorial State Park. It contains the Summary of Existing Conditions; Goals and Guidelines for park development and use; Environmental Analysis (in compliance with Article 9 and Article 11 Section 15166 of the California Environmental Quality Act); and Maps, Matrices, and Appendices relating to the General Plan. Volume 2 of the Final General Plan contains the Comments and Responses (comments received during public review of the General Plan and DPR response to those comments); and the Notice of Determination (as filed with the State Office of Planning and Research), documenting the completion of the CEQA compliance requirements for this project. Together, these two volumes constitute the Final General Plan for Donner Memorial State Park. COPYRIGHT This publication, including all of the text and photographs in it, is the intellectual property of the Department of Parks and Recreation and is protected by copyright. GENERAL PLANNING INFORMATION If you would like more information about the general planning process used by the Department or have questions about specific general plans, contact: General Planning Section California State Parks P.O. Box 942896 Sacramento, CA 94296 - 0001 All Photographs Copyright California State Parks DONNER MEMORIAL STATE PARK GENERAL PLAN Approved April 5, 2003 State Clearinghouse #2001102069 Arnold Schwarzenegger Governor Mike Chrisman Secretary for Resources Ruth Coleman Director of California State Parks State of California The Resources Agency California State Parks P.O.
    [Show full text]
  • Donner Pdf Layout
    Our Mission The mission of the California Department of Parks and Recreation is to provide for The Donner Party the health, inspiration and education of the people of California by helping to preserve the state’s extraordinary biological diversity, he United States of America was grow protecting its most valued natural and cultural Ting rapidly during the 1830s, when resources, and creating opportunities for American frontiersmen and sailors began to high-quality outdoor recreation. bring back stories about the wonders of Alta California. The political situation was uncer- ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER tain. Mexico still held the area, but it was Governor widely believed that she was losing control of MIKE CHRISMAN her northernmost province. It seemed inevi- Secretary for Resources table that, sooner or later, the U.S.A. would step in. It was “manifest destiny,” they said, RUTH COLEMAN that the United States of America should Director, California State Parks stretch across the continent from sea to shining sea. Interest in California was further heightened in 1841, when word reached the eastern settlements that it was possible to travel directly overland to the West Coast and California State Parks does not discriminate thus avoid an expensive sea voyage. against individuals with disabilities. Prior to Two prosperous Illinois farmers, George arrival, visitors with disabilities who need Donner and his brother Jacob, were among the assistance should contact the park at the phone many who listened to the fabulous stories of number below. To receive this publication in an fine soil, gentle climate and virtually unlim- alternate format, write to the Communications ited opportunity in California.
    [Show full text]
  • Fernley Swales Timeline
    A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE FERNLEY SWALES ON THE TRUCKEE RIVER ROUTE OF THE CALIFORNIA TRAIL 8,500 BC First Americans occupy shores of receding glacial Lake Lahontan. 1833, Oct. Joseph Walker expedition crosses the Carson sink near Fallon. (Mummy at Spirit Cave, Grimes Point, dated at 10,600 years before present.) 1843, Jan. 16 Fremont Expedition leaves the Big Bend of the Salmon Trout (Truckee) River and crosses the Fernley Swales on the way south to the Carson Sink. 1844 Stephens-Townsend-Murphy party (11 wagons, 26 men, 8 women, 16 children) cross the Forty-Mile Desert to the Big Bend of the Truckee River, following directions given them at the Humboldt sink by Paiute Chief "Truckee". 1845, Spring Mountain man Caleb Greenwood led a pack party through the Fernley Swales to establish the new route over Stephens (Donner) Pass. 1845, year end Estimated 250 emigrants through the Fernley Swales on the Truckee River Route of the California Trail. 1846, Oct. 15 The ill-fated Donner Party through the Fernley Swales. 1846, year end Estimated 1,500 emigrants through the Fernley Swales. 1848, Jan. Gold discovered in California at Sutter's Fort. 1848, August A party of the 'Mormon Battalion', returning to Salt Lake from Placerville, blazes a trail eastward across Carson Pass, follows the Carson River to near today's Silver Springs, then joins the Truckee River Route at the Big Bend of the Truckee River. After traveling east through the Swales they meet emigrant wagons heading west and the news of the discovery of gold and the new easier route over Carson Pass starts to divert westbound emigrants from the Truckee River Route.
    [Show full text]
  • KHS—History Knowledge Organiser—Half Term 6 - Moving West
    KHS—History Knowledge Organiser—Half Term 6 - Moving West Key Dates: 17176-1783: War of Independence - Settlers in the 13 colonies look to move west. By the end of this Half Term I should know: 1836: First travellers to use the Oregon Trail. The main reasons for white Americans moving 1837: An economic crisis in the East leading to westward across the Plains and to the west coast. high unemployment. The problems facing these pioneers migrating west 1846: More than 5,000 travellers including the including the Donner party. Donner Party use the Oregon trail. How the 1848 Californian gold rush led to a mass 1848: Gold discovered in California. migration across the country. 1849: Gold rush - 100,000 people use the Oregon trail to find their fortune. How the 1848 gold rush led to an increase in law- 1855: Over 300,000 people in California. lessness in the western towns and camps. 1862: Homestead Act - Government encourage How the US government encouraged people to be- settlers by offering cheap land for farming. come homesteaders and populate the Plains. Key Terms: Expansion: The political/ deliberate strategy of extending territory (land). Settlement: A place which has previously been uninhabited, where people establish a community. Economic crisis: A downturn in trade and a loss of money, resulting in a loss of jobs, busi- nesses closing and banks collapsing. Oregon Trail: A wagon trail from the east to the west (Oregon). Donner party: A group of people led by a member of the Donner family on the trail from east to west. Claim: A small plot of land for the purpose of panning for gold, that a person has made an official claim for.
    [Show full text]
  • John C. Freemont's Expeditions Into Utah: an Historical Analysis of the Explorer's Contributions and Significance To
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 1986-12-01 John C. Freemont's Expeditions into Utah: An Historical Analysis of the Explorer's Contributions and Significance ot the Region Alexander L. Baugh Brigham Young University - Provo Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the Mormon Studies Commons, and the United States History Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Baugh, Alexander L., "John C. Freemont's Expeditions into Utah: An Historical Analysis of the Explorer's Contributions and Significance ot the Region" (1986). Theses and Dissertations. 4511. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/4511 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. JOHN C FREMONTS expeditions UTAH historical ANALYSIS EXPLOREREXPLORERS contributions significance REGION thesis presented department history brigham young university partial fulfillment requirements degree master arts aleaiealenanderalexanderandtandir L baugh december 10198686 thesis alexander L baugh accepted present form department history brigham young university satisfying thesis requirement degree master arts B allenailencommittee chairman av er committee member 7 jez532 datejjz D michael quinn Ggraduateduatecuate coordinator00oordiadinator acknowledgementsACKNOWLEDGE MENTS my sincere thanks must
    [Show full text]
  • Donner Party by Emily Rose Oachs
    DEATH IN THE DONNER PARTY BY EMILY ROSE OACHS A CAUSE-AND-EFFECT INVESTIGATION THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK DEATH IN THE DONNER PARTY BY EMILY ROSE OACHS A CAUSEANDEFFECT INVESTIGATION CAUSE EFFECT DISASTERS LERNER PUBLICATIONS MINNEAPOLIS Copyright © 2017 by Lerner Publishing Group, Inc. All rights reserved. International copyright secured. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise—without the prior written permission of Lerner Publishing Group, Inc., except for the inclusion of brief quotations in an acknowledged review. Lerner Publications Company A division of Lerner Publishing Group, Inc. 241 First Avenue North Minneapolis, MN 55401 USA For reading levels and more information, look up this title at www.lernerbooks.com. Content Consultant: Tim McNeese, Associate Professor of History, Department of History, York College, York, NE Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Oachs, Emily Rose, author. Title: Death in the Donner party : a cause-and-effect investigation / by Emily Rose Oachs. Description: Minneapolis : Lerner Publications, 2017. | Series: Cause-and-effect disasters | Includes bibliographical references and index. | Audience: Age 9-12. | Audience: Grade 4 to 6. Identifiers: LCCN 2016008861 (print) | LCCN 2016009342 (ebook) | ISBN 9781512411157 (lb : alk. paper) | ISBN 9781512411263 (eb pdf) Subjects: LCSH: Donner Party—Juvenile literature. | Pioneers—California—History—19th century— Juvenile literature. | Pioneers—West (U.S.)—History—19th century—Juvenile literature. | Overland journeys to the Pacific—Juvenile literature. | Frontier and pioneer life—West (U.S.)— Juvenile literature. | Sierra Nevada (Calif. and Nev.)—History—19th century—Juvenile literature.
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Reading # 23 Article 1: the Donner Party
    Weekly Reading # 23 Article 1: The Donner Party By the mid-1800s land and opportunities in the East were no longer plentiful. Cholera outbreaks had become common place in the overpopulated eastern cities where sanitation was poor. People began to cast wistful eyes in a westerly direction. Thousands of pioneers packed family and belongings for the move west. George Donner, a sixty-five year old farmer, was among those pulled by the lure of open spaces. Eagerly responding to a proposal by neighbor and businessman James Frazier Reed, Donner decided to move his family west. He promptly posted a bulletin in the Springfield Gazette that began “Westward Ho!” and promised free travel to California for up to eight able-bodied young men capable of driving a team of oxen. The Donners and the Reeds left Springfield, Illinois on April 16th, 1846, for Independence, Missouri. Their party consisted of thirty-two people. The twenty-five undred mile trip from Independence to San Francisco was expected to take four months. Survival would depend on nearly perfect timing: they could not leave until the spring rains stopped and they had to make it over the Sierra Nevada mountains before the first snows flew. Neither Donner nor Reed was worried; they would follow a new route over the mountains. A route touted by attorney Lansford Hastings as able to cut three to four hundred miles from the trip. The Donner party left Independence on May 12th and became one in the thousands of wagon trains heading out that spring. There was hardship from the beginning.
    [Show full text]
  • DONNER PARTY by Candon Hatalla DONNER PARTY
    DONNER PARTY By Candon Hatalla DONNER PARTY • The Donner Party was a group of two family's, the Reed family and the Donner family. They were traveling west to California. WHO WAS THE DONNER PARTY? • The Reed family and Donner family. • The Donner Party was group of families wanting to travel west to start a new life. http://www.history. com WHO WAS LEADING THE PARTY WESTWARD? • George Donner was leading the two families westward along with Lansford Hasting https://en. wikipedia. org WHAT WAS THEIR PLAN WHEN THEY GOT TO CALIFORNIA? • Their plan was to start a new life Lansford Hasting wanted to move to California because he wanted to be president of California http://www.le gendsofameri ca.com WHAT STATE DID THE DONNER PARTY LEAVE FROM? • The Donner Party left from Springfield Illinois and they wanted to travel to California to start a new life. http://www. history.com WHEN DID THE DONNER PARTY LEAVE FOR CALIFORNIA? • The Donner Party was leaving Springfield in April 1846 https://en.wikipe dia.org WHAT HAPPEN WHEN THEY GOT ONE THE TRAIL? • When the Donner Party set out to start their journey, they left to late and were stuck in the middle of a bad snow storm http://ww w.legends ofamerica. com WHAT DID THEY EAT WHEN THEY WERE STRANDED? • When they were on the trail, they had to eat there mules, and all of their food that they were saving http://www. history.com DETAILS • On the Oregon trail they wanted to take a shortcut which was a bad idea • During there time taking the short cut their wagon broke and they had to set up camp • During the tie period that they had to camp out a huge snow storm made them stranded EXTRA DETAIL • The snow storm made them stranded and they were running out of food • They had to eat their mules and had to turn to cannibalism PICTURES.
    [Show full text]
  • New Archaeological Perspectives on the Donner Party Saga
    NEW ARCHAEOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON THE DONNER PARTY SAGA Donald Hardesty Department of Anthropology University of Nevada, Reno Reno, NV 89557 Susan Lindstrom P.O. Box 3324 Truckee, CA 95734 Richard E. Markley Tahoe National Forest Nevada City, CA 95959 ABSTRACT In 1990 the University of Nevada, Reno, in cooperation with the Tahoe National Forest, began another documentary and archaeological investigation of the Donner party camps near Truckee, California. This study, like the ones which have preceded it - one at the Murphy's Cabin Site at Donner Lake and the other at the Donner-Reed Wagon site in Utah - have shed new light on the Donner Party saga. In addition, these archaeological investigations afforded a superb public education opportunity. Visitors who observed the excavations numbered in the thousands. On-site tours, national media coverage, and the involvement of a volunteer work force from the federal, state and private sector further enhanced these interpretive advantages. The preliminary results of this latest study are discussed. INTRODUCTION The tragedy of the Donner Party is one of the best known events in American history. Trapped in the Sierra Nevada mountains of California during the winter of 1846-1847, nearly half of the group perished. Of the group of 89 taking the ill­ fated Hastings Cutoff south from Fort Bridger, Wyoming, only 47 survived. This so-called "short-cut" was not what Hastings had claimed; in fact it delayed the party enough so that they were unable to cross the Sierra before snowfall and were forced to spend the winter in 2 encampments in the Truckee Basin.
    [Show full text]
  • Pioneer Monument at 100 We’Re Pretty Parochial at the Donner Summit Historical Society’S Heirloom Offices
    June, 2018 issue #118 Pioneer Monument at 100 We’re pretty parochial at the Donner Summit Historical Society’s Heirloom offices. We focus on Donner Summit history, of which there is a lot and so no need to go elsewhere for good stories. Coming up this month, though, on June 9 (see the ad later in this issue), is the one hundredth anniversary of the Pioneer Monument at the Donner State Park. At first look, that has nothing to do with us since it’s down at Donner Lake, miles away, and a thousand feet lower in elevation. Since we’re addressing the subject here in the Heirloom, though, you can guess that there is a connection to Donner Summit. The Pioneer Monument celebrates the achievement of thousands of emigrants who came over Donner Summit on their way to new opportunities and new lives in California. They’d just endured almost unimaginable hardships crossing the deserts of Utah and Nevada and must have been so glad when they reached the Truckee Meadows (today’s Reno) where there was water, grass, and rest. And then they approached the Sierra. To Edwin Bryant in 1846 the Sierra was a "formidable and apparently impassable barrier...” David Hudson (1845) said, “When we reached Sierra Nevada mountains they looked terrible." William Tustin (1846) said that when they saw the Sierra “every heart was filled with terror at the awful site [sic].” Wm. Todd (1845) said the Sierra were "Tribulations in the extreme.” We’ve carefully acquired a long list of emigrant quotes so we could continue, but you have the idea.
    [Show full text]
  • ONE MORE MOUNTAIN DISNEY EDUCATIONAL PRODUCTIONS, 1994 Grade Levels: 7-10 90 Minutes
    ##99557755 ONE MORE MOUNTAIN DISNEY EDUCATIONAL PRODUCTIONS, 1994 Grade Levels: 7-10 90 minutes DESCRIPTION In 1846, hundreds of Americans traveled the Oregon Trail to California. Margaret Reed, a wealthy, proud woman, becomes a reluctant member of the Donner party of emigrants. After an early winter storm closes mountain passes, she struggles to keep her family alive. ACADEMIC STANDARDS Subject Area: United States History - Era 4 - Expansion and Reform (1801-1861) Standard: Understands how the industrial revolution, increasing immigration, the rapid expansion of slavery, and the westward movement changed American lives and led to regional tensions • Benchmark: Understands elements of early western migration (e.g., the lure of the West and the reality of life on the frontier; motivations of various settlers; Mormon contributions to the settlement of the West; differences in the settlement of California and Oregon in the late 1840s and 1850s; routes taken by settlers of the Western U.S.; interactions between settlers and Native Americans and Mexicans in the western territories). (See Instructional Goals # 1, 2, and 3) INSTRUCTIONAL GOALS 1. To understand the meaning and the importance of the westward expansion. 2. To depict the historical period in which the westward expansion took place. 3. To introduce the Oregon Trail, the California Trail, and the mountain ranges the emigrants had to cross. 4. To examine the infamous Donner Party. 5. To depict the hardships and challenges of the journey west in the mid-1800s. VOCABULARY 1. open spaces 11. emigrant 2. territory 12. abandon 3. struggle 13. hazardous 4. determined 14. journey 5. courageous 15.
    [Show full text]