The MELVIN E. JAHN COLLECTION of Early Geoscience 1550-1850
Offered by SCHOYER’S BOOKS and SERENDIPITY BOOKS
The Melvin E. Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience 1550-1850
With a special concentration on Paleontology, Conchology, Mineralogy, and Private Museums of Natural History.
Some Significant Books: A List...... page 3
Melvin Jahn, Bibliophile ...... pages 4 – 5
Survey of the Jahn Collection ...... pages 6 – 8
Catalogue of the Collection arranged chronologically ...... pages 9 – 89
Author Index arranged alphabetically, with values...... pages 90 – 96
References Cited ...... pages 97 – 98 SCHOYER’S BOOKS and SERENDIPITY BOOKS, ABAA/ILAB
—Schoyer’s Books— —Serendipity Books— PO Box 9471& 1201 University Ave. Berkeley, CA 94709 Berkeley, CA 94702 510-548-8009 510-841-7455 [email protected] [email protected]
“Nature reserves many things from our knowledge.” —Ole Worm, Museum Wormianum, 1655
Essays: Ian Jackson Catalogue: Marc Selvaggio (Schoyer’s Books) © Schoyer’s Books, 2004 Design: Andrea Latham
This is a revised edition of the original sales prospectus. Although the collection is only available as a single unit, an approximate value for each item appears [set in brackets] in the Author Index section.
Schoyer’s Books & Serendipity Books Are Members of the Antiquarian Booksellers Association of America.
2 The Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience
Some Significant Books in the Jahn Collection
Aldrovandi, Ulisse. Opera Omnia. Bologna, 1599-1667. Complete 13-volume set in uniform contemporary bindings.
Beringer, Johann Bartholomew Adam. Lithographiae Wirceburgenis. Both the first (1726) and second (1767) editions.
Boodt, Anselmus de. Gemmarum et lapidum historia. First, second, and third editions (1609, 1636, 1647), each in contemporary binding.
Buonanni, Filippo et al. Rerum Naturalium Historia…in Museo Kircheriano, 1773-82.
Burtin, Francois-Xavier de. Oryctographie de Bruxelles, 1784 issue with hand-colored plates.
Ellis, John. An essay towards a natural history of the corallines, 1755—presentation copy from Ellis to his illustrator, Georg Dionysius Ehret.
Gualtieri, Niccolo. Index Testarum Conchyliorum, 1742.
Hebenstreit, Johann Ernst. Museum Ricterianum, 1743—the exceedingly rare first issue with hand-colored plates, one of five known copies.
Lhwyd, Edward. Lithophylacii Britannici Ichnographia—the rare 1699 first edition.
Lister, Martin. Historiae Animalium Angliae, 1678; Conchyliorum bivalvium, 1696; and his magnificently illustrated Historiae sive Synopsis methodicae conchyliorum, 1770.
Mercati, Michele. Metallotheca, both the first (1717) and second (1719) editions.
Moscardo, Ludovico. Note overo Memorie del museo de Ludovico Moscardo, 1656.
Rashleigh, Philip. Specimens of British Minerals. London: Bulmer, 1797-1802.
Rumpf, Georg Eberhard. D’Amboinische Rariteitkammer, 1705 and Thesaurus Imaginum Piscium Testaceorum, 1739.
Scheuchzer, Johann Jacob. Geestelyke Natuurkunde, 1728-1738. Fifteen vols. in six.
Volta, Giovanni S. Ittiolitologia Veronese del Museo Bozziano, Verona, 1796.
Willughby, Francis. De Historia Piscium Libri Quatuor, 1686.
Worm, Ole. Museum Wormianum, 1655. Both issues of the first edition, including Cuvier’s copy.
3 SCHOYER’S BOOKS and SERENDIPITY BOOKS, ABAA/ILAB
Melvin Jahn, Bibliophile
A Note on the Collector and His Library Melvin Jahn (1938-2003) was the youngest and the last of the great Berkeley scientific book collectors. It has often been noted that there is a certain contagion to book-collecting. Influential bibliographies, historic events or inspiring personalities can establish a vogue. Admiration, emulation and rivalry sustain it, but when the stimulus is withdrawn, or the circle of enthusiasts is dispersed or dies off, the epidemic is over. At the University of California it ran for just over a century.
The taste for scientific books was well established at Berkeley in the 1890’s, by the botanists E.L. Greene, W.L. Jepson, H.M. Hall and W.A. Setchell, each collecting within their specialty, from a taxonomic and historical point of view. The taste became a mania by the 1920’s, with the advent of two omnivorous collectors, Charles Atwood Kofoid and Herbert McLean Evans.
Kofoid (1865-1947), a zoologist, specialized in natural history, and by unrelenting accumulation died with 80,000 or 100,000 volumes. They were donated to the University Library, although duplicates were sold, eventually enriching the Jahn Collection.
Evans (1882-1971), the discoverer of Vitamin E, by incessant ebb and flow, never had more than a few thousand volumes on hand at any given moment, but circulated some 20,000 books in the course of his career. Bridson and Jackson’s Naturalists’ Libraries lists sixteen catalogues from which Evans’s books were recorded and dispersed between 1930 and 1975. Every leading American history of science library has at least a few volumes that once were his.
Still more influential was Evans’s 1934 exhibition catalogue of First editions of epochal achievements in the history of science, listing 116 works. This small booklet, succinctly annotated, with its clear purpose and manageable number of landmark publications, established for the first time the humble scientific offprint as an object of bibliophilic pursuit. The catalogue contains in nuce everything for which Dibner and Horblit are commonly acclaimed. Unlike the staid Kofoid, Evans was an inspiring and flamboyant presence—a bookseller manqué. He clearly captivated the young Jahn in his student days at Berkeley in the late 1950’s, tempting him with dealers’ catalogues and even passing on books from his library.1 Jahn’s simple and elegant sans-serif book-label—Ex Libris/ Melvin Edward Jahn—is obviously inspired by Evans’s more elaborate bookplate. Here alone does Jahn use his full name (as never in scientific publications), echoing his mentor’s resonant triplet.
Jahn was a graduate student of paleontology under Charles L. Camp (1893-1975). His M.A. thesis (1963) was devoted to the fossil tigers and other carnivores of the La Brea tar-pits, a subject on which Camp had published years earlier. Camp was another of the great Berkeley book-collectors, with an enthusiasm for the complementary subjects of Western Americana and geology. He is best known for his revisions (1937 and 1953) of Henry Raup Wagner’s bibliography of The Plains and the Rockies (1920-21), still known in its fourth, posthumous edition (1982) simply as “Wagner- Camp.” Professor Camp, too, supplied Jahn with books from his library.
1 On July 3, 1961, Evans inscribed a copy of his Men and moments in the history of science (Seattle 1959) to Jahn with these encouraging words: “To Melvin Edward Jahn with hearty congratulations on his determination to collect treatises which have enlarged man’s knowledge and man’s horizon.” Coincidentally, July 3 was also the very day that Sothey’s of London auctioned off the scientific library of the Earl of Bute. And Jahn would later purchase six “treatises” from that sale.
4 The Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience
Stimulated by such “ardent fellow enthusiasts” (as Evans once phrased his relationship to Jahn), it is little wonder that the disciple’s publications were overwhelmingly bibliographical. At the age of 25, in collaboration with the Latinist Daniel J. Woolf, Jahn published his only book in the history of science, The Lying Stones of Dr. Johann Bartholomew Adam Beringer (University of California Press, 1963). This study of the most famous hoax in the history of paleontology took the form of an extensively annotated translation of Beringer’s rare Lithographiae Wirceburgensis (1726), reproducing the engravings in which the gullible Würzburg professor published hundreds of wildly improbable forged fossils. In his “Acknowledgments,” Jahn paid tribute to the endeavors of half a dozen booksellers from whom he had obtained 17th and 18th century texts [still in the collection]. His usual sources for antiquarian books included the firms of Bernard Quaritch Ltd., Wheldon and Wesley, and Zeitlin & Ver Brugge. Jahn appropriately dedicated his book (in Latin) to Charles L. Camp.
Jahn’s extensive notes in The Lying Stones form a bibliographical history of the study of fossils, albeit in somewhat disconnected form. A glance at a list of Jahn’s own library reveals the extent to which this masterly survey of Beringer’s sources was based on careful examination of his own shelves, demonstrating yet again that there is rarely a substitute for the intimate familiarity bred by actual possession.
Jahn’s superb library of 208 titles (in 242 volumes) contains a remarkably comprehensive collection of the monuments of early paleontology (1600-1800): the local inventories of petrifactions, the illustrated museum catalogues that record many a fossil for the first time, the magnificent illustrated folios on corals and shells, the English county histories in which fossils mingle with arrowheads and urns, the travel books, the learned correspondence, the diluvian theology, and the earliest truly scientific monographs. Reflecting the state of paleontology in the 17th and 18th centuries, many of the works encompass other scientific fields, including geography, comparative anatomy, zoology, mineralogy, and gemology.
Apart from The Lying Stones, Jahn published twelve articles, all but one in The Journal of the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History, between 1963 and 1975—studies of such notable early paleontologists as John Woodward, Johann Jacob Scheuchzer, and Edward Lhwyd. These too are bibliographical studies, based on Jahn’s own collections, which were essentially complete for each author. His publications are still standard points of reference in spite of the passage of time. Evans’s death in 1971, followed by Camp’s in 1975, foreshadowed Jahn’s own withdrawal from the history of science. He published nothing on the subject after 1975, and placed much of his splendid library in storage, where it was only discovered after his death.
Jahn’s library is a period piece, from a vanished era of the recent past, a monument to what was available in the bookshops forty years ago to a diligent scholar with a refined taste. The gaudily rebound copies of antiquarian books so often seen at book fairs today are entirely absent. Jahn’s copies are in remarkable condition, almost all in original or contemporary bindings, many with interesting or intriguing associations. The collection is not only pleasing to the eye. It is above all an exceptional assemblage of original source material that would be extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible, to replicate today.
5 SCHOYER’S BOOKS and SERENDIPITY BOOKS, ABAA/ILAB
The Meaning of Fossils and The Theory of the Earth: A Brief Survey of the Jahn Collection Melvin Jahn’s mentor, Herbert McLean Evans, was fond of quoting the dictum of the physicist James Clark Maxwell: It is of great advantage to the student of any subject to read in the original memoirs on that subject, for science is always most completely assimilated when it is found in its nascent state. Every student of science should, in fact, be an antiquary in his subject.
As a student of paleontology, Melvin Jahn evidently took these words to heart. He built up a collection that was remarkable for its scope. It mirrored his interests and inspired his scholarly writings, which centered around man’s varied attempts to come to terms with Noah in the broadest sense—to harmonize the fossil record with a dwindling scriptural authority on the eve of the modern world. Every shade of opinion from ovism and animalculism to Panspermia and diluvianism is represented in the Jahn collection, as is every scale of investigation, from Schwenkfeld’s detailed account of the fossils of Silesia (1601) to Johann Zahn’s mammoth survey of the entire world of science, Specula physico-mathematico-historica (1696, folio with 61 plates), or the collected works in thirteen volumes of Ulisse Aldrovandi (1522-1605), the renowned Bolognese naturalist who introduced the word “Geologia” to science in its present sense. Johann B.A. Beringer, inevitably, was the nexus of Jahn’s research, not least because he offered so useful a bibliographical guide to the “original memoirs” in their “nascent state.”
Beringer The name of Jahn is most closely identified with the Beringer hoax—no history of geology can ignore this famous episode, and Jahn’s publications are invariably the only point of reference in an author’s footnotes. In addition to The Lying Stones (1963), Jahn published three articles on Beringer, including the definitive statement (1972) on the bibliography of the Lithographiae Wircebergiensis.2 His own collection contains fine copies of the two editions there described. In his Lithographiae, Beringer refers to several dozen eminent predecessors and authorities. Jahn identified their scattered publications (see The Lying Stones, Appendix A. pp.111-24) and acquired many of these rare books for his library, including Lodovico Moscardo’s Note overo Memorie del museo de Lodovico Moscardo (1656), Karl Lang’s Tractatus de Origine Lapidum Figuratorum (1709), Micheli Mercati’s Metallotheca (1717), and Daniel Büttner’s Rudera Diluvii Testes (1710).
As a German, Beringer was well acquainted with the publications of his countrymen, whose contributions to the seventeenth century study of fossils concentrated on the discoveries made in a particular locality, a style of scientific investigation still notable in the study of fossil man, who is always given an address—from Neanderthal to Olduvai. The Lying Stones (pp.166-68) describes a few of these regional catalogues. Jahn’s own collection includes George Anton Volkmann’s Silesia Subterranea, (1720), George A. Helwing’s Lithographia Angerburgica, (1717), and Peter Wolfart’s Historiae Naturalis Hassiae Inferioris, (1719).
In turn, Italian studies of paleontology of the time were influenced less by mining and chorography than by the Mediterranean sea. The peninsula’s lengthy coastline gave access to marine shells of similar configuration whether discovered as fossils embedded in rock or as living creatures in the sea. (The understanding of extinct creatures required leaps of imagination that
2 Jahn also contributed the entry on Beringer for the Dictionary of Scientific Biography (II, pp.15-16) and Jahn is cited as a major secondary reference in the entries on Karl Lang, Edward Lhwyd, and John Woodward.
6 The Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience
were difficult in the absence of a conceptual framework—the world was not psychologically prepared for dinosaurs until the nineteenth century.) Jahn’s library includes a fine copy (in contemporary binding and with rare hand-colored plates) of Marsigli’s beautiful folio, Histoire physique de la mer (1725), the pioneering work in oceanography, with geological ramifications that would have appealed to the collector. The Italians were the great accumulators of the seventeenth century; almost all of their investigations were documented not in theoretical works but in private museum catalogues, often handsomely illustrated folios.
Museums According to an author’s note (in 1969) Melvin Jahn was at work on “a projected series of articles on the history of museums.” None of these were published but Jahn had clearly laid the foundations, in his usual comprehensive fashion, with an impressive assembly of key texts. Jahn’s collection includes some twenty rare museum catalogues, many of which figure in his survey of literature in The Lying Stones (pp.162-6). These include Georges Cuvier’s copy of Ole Worm’s famous Museum Wormianum (1655).
When Jahn was collecting in the 1950’s and 60’s, the only reliable guide to these publications was the Glasgow bibliographer David Murray’s three-volume Museums, their history and their use (1904). In the last twenty years, however, there has been an astonishing growth of interest in every ramification of provenance, in cabinets of curiosities and early museology, a trend confirmed by the establishment of the first specialist serial, Oxford University Press’s Journal of the history of collections. Such museum catalogues as Jahn was able to gather forty years ago are now very difficult to obtain, being much sought after by institutions endeavoring to support faculty research. Almost none of them has been reprinted, although such spectacular folios as the Museum Richterianum (1743), perhaps the most beautiful of mineralogical books (and present here in one of five known hand-colored copies) richly deserve reproduction in facsimile.
Topography Closely allied to the museum catalogue as a source of early documentation of the fossil record is the topographical survey, often similarly based on a private collection. The only catalogue of the Yorkshire antiquary Ralph Thoresby’s famous museum, for instance, is contained in his topographical survey of Leeds, Ducatus Leodiensis (1715). Jahn not only owned this in its lavish enlarged folio re-edition (1816), but he also assembled the other great English and Scottish county topographies of the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, as discussed in The Lying Stones (pp.170-1 and 178-81): Robert Sibbald’s Scotia illustrata (1684), Charles Leigh’s The Natural History of Lancashire, Cheshire… (1700), John Morton’s The Natural History of Northampton-shire (1712), and two variant copies of Robert Plot’s The Natural History of Oxfordshire (1677). Plot was first keeper of the Ashmolean Museum.
Edward Lhwyd Plot’s successor at the Ashmolean was the Welsh antiquary and naturalist Edward Lhwyd (1660- 1709), succinctly characterized by Jahn (The Lying Stones, p.172) as “a member of the animalculist faction of the preformationist movement, (and) perhaps the greatest proponent of the aura seminalis.” Lhwyd published (in an edition of only 120 copies, sponsored by a group of friends that included Sir Isaac Newton) the first work devoted solely to British fossils, Lithophylacii Britannici Ichnographia (1699), illustrating 267 specimens on 23 folding plates, including many extinct trilobites, a common fossil in the Welsh borders where he was raised. Jahn published articles on Lhwyd’s collections in the Ashmolean Museum, his correspondence and his
7 SCHOYER’S BOOKS and SERENDIPITY BOOKS, ABAA/ILAB
bibliography. The Jahn collection, once again, contains the essential texts, including a presentation copy of Lhywd’s folio Archeologia Britannica (1707).
John Woodward Another of Jahn’s enthusiasms was John Woodward, “the Grand Protector of the Universal Deluge” according to the skeptical Vallisnieri, and the first notable fossil collector to publish his speculations on the Theory of the Earth (see The Lying Stones, p.176-8). Melvin Jahn published the definitive bibliography of Woodward’s An Essay towards a natural history of the earth in 1972, describing in 33 pages the many editions and translations of this influential work, several of which are in the Jahn collection. Jahn also owned the posthumous catalogue of Woodward’s museum (1729): the collection was bequeathed to the University of Cambridge and is one of the very few original collections to survive intact, and in its original cabinetry.
Johann Jakob Scheuchzer Beringer cited Woodward’s Essay not in its original English but in the Latin translation (1704) by J.J. Scheuchzer. Inevitably, Jahn became an expert on Scheuchzer too, publishing four articles: he remains the leading authority in English on the Swiss scientist. A projected sequel to The Lying Stones, intended to contain an annotated translation of two of Scheuchzer’s works, never appeared, nor did Jahn publish the bio-bibliography announced in 1975. As usual, however, Jahn had all of the materials in his own library, including Scheuchzer’s Herbarium Diluvianum (or Herbarium of the Flood) from 1709, one of the earliest works on fossil plants—botany was the key to assigning a season to the Flood—with a magnificent evocation of the rising waters on the title-page. Other Scheuchzer publications in the collection range from the very rare pamphlet, Homo Diluvii Testis, (1726) to the massive fifteen-volume (in eight) illustrated history of nature in the Bible, Geestelyke Natuurkunde, (1728-39, text in Dutch).
The History of Paleontology and Geology The foregoing notes have concentrated on Jahn’s personal scholarly enthusiasms, as reflected on his shelves and recorded in his publications, but the collector was never an isolationist. The themes and personalities of his research were embedded in a larger historical matrix. A number of early works on fossils in the collection were listed under “Beringer” but Jahn ranged far more widely. His collection, in fact, includes a reasonably full survey of the literature of geology and paleontology from 1600 to 1800. Jahn owned a number of works by John Ray, the leading British naturalist of the seventeenth century, an associate of all and a student of everything. Embracing Ray and his circle, Jahn collected the works of the British physician and naturalist Martin Lister, including his famous folio on shells, Historiae sive synopsis methodicae conchyliorum et tabularum anatomicarum (1770, second ed., corrected) illustrated with over 1000 copper-plates. Fellow naturalist Francis Willughby is represented by his De Historia Piscium Libri Quatuor (1686), the first large English work on ichthyology. An interest in fossils and stones naturally took Jahn into the realms of mineralogy and gemology. The rare and important works present range from Anselmus de Boodt’s Gemmarum et lapidum historia (1609) to Richard Kirwan’s Elements of Mineralogy (1784).
Appropriately, the collection is rounded off by the chief works of the Rev. William Buckland, the eccentric first reader in geology at the University of Oxford. His Reliquiae diluvianae (1823) hearkens back to the old Flood debate, while his Oxford inaugural address, Vindiciae Geologiae (1820) is a call to arms, heralding the era of specialization that was to transform the study of the evolution of the earth and its inhabitants.
8 The Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience
The Melvin E. Jahn Collection of Early Geoscience 1550-1850
The Birth of Modern Mineralogy