Interpretation: a Journal of Political Philosophy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Interpretation A JOURNAL 10F POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY Winter 2001-2 Volume 29 Number 2 Harry Adams Aristotle on "the Vulgar": An Ethical and Social Examination Nasser Behnegar The Political and Theological Psychology of Shakespeare's Measure for Measure Zdravko Planinc ". this scattered kingdom": A Study of King Lear Henry T. Edmondson III Modernity versus Mystery in Flannery O'Connor's Short Story Woods" "A View of the Review Essay Richard Freis A Triple Inquiry into the Human Center Book Review Will Morrisey The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading of the Odyssey, by Seth Benardete Interpretation Editor-in-Chief Hilail Gildin, Dept. of Philosophy, Queens College Executive Editor Leonard Grey General Editors Seth G. Benardete (d. 2001) Charles E. Butterworth Hilail Gildin Robert Horwitz (d. 1987) Howard B. White (d. 1974) Consulting Editors Christopher Bruell Joseph Cropsey Ernest L. Fortin John Hallowell (d. 1992) Harry V. Jaffa David Lowenthal Muhsin Mahdi Harvey C. Mansfield Arnaldo Momigliano (d. 1987) Michael Oakeshott (d. 1990) Ellis Sandoz Leo Strauss (d. 1973) Kenneth W. Thompson International Editors Terence E. Marshall Heinrich Meier Editors Wayne Ambler Maurice Auerbach Fred Baumann Amy Bonnette Patrick Coby Elizabeth C de Baca Eastman Thomas S. Engeman Edward J. Erler Maureen Feder-Marcus Pamela K. Jensen Ken Masugi Will Morrisey Susan Orr Charles T. Rubin Leslie G. Rubin Susan Meld Shell Bradford P. Wilson Martin D. Yaffe Michael P. Zuckert Catherine H. Zuckert Manuscript Editor Lucia B. Prochnow Subscriptions Subscription rates per volume (3 issues): individuals $29 libraries and all other institutions $48 students (four-year limit) $ 1 8 Single copies available. Postage outside U.S.: Canada $4.50 extra; elsewhere $5.40 extra by surface mail (8 weeks or longer) or $11.00 by air. Payments: in U.S. dollars and payable by a financial institution located within the U.S.A. (or the U.S. Postal Service). The Journal Welcomes Manuscripts in Political Philosophy as Well as Those in Theology, Literature, and Jurisprudence. contributors should follow The Chicago Manual of Style, 13th or later editions "reference-list" or manuals based on them. Instead of endnotes, the journal uses the (or "author-date") system of notation, described in these manuals, illustrated in cur rent numbers of the journal, and discussed in a sheet available from the Assistant to the Editor (see below). Words from languages not rooted in Latin should be trans literated to English. To ensure impartial judgment, contributors should omit mention of their other publications and put, on the title page only, their name, any affiliation desired, address with postal zip code in full, E-mail address, and telephone number. Please send four clear copies, which will not be returned, and double space the entire text and reference list. Composition by Bytheway Publishing Services Printed by the Sheridan Press Binghamton, NY 13901 U.S.A. Hanover, PA 17331 U.S.A. Inquiries: (Ms.) Joan Walsh, Assistant to the Editor interpretation, Queens College, Flushing, N.Y. 11367-1597, U.S.A. (718)997-5542 Fax (718) 997-5565 E Mail: interpretation [email protected] Interpretation A JOURNAL 10F POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY Winter 2001-2 Volume 29 Number 2 Harry Adams Aristotle on "the Vulgar": An Ethical and 133 Social Examination Nasser Behnegar The Political and Theological Psychology 153 of Shakespeare's Measure for Measure Zdravko Planinc ". this scattered kingdom": A Study of 171 King Lear Henry T. Edmondson III Modernity versus Mystery in Flannery 187 O'Connor's Short Story "A View Woods" of the Review Essay Richard Freis A Triple Inquiry into the Human Center 205 Book Review Will Morrisey The Bow and the Lyre: A Platonic Reading 233 of the Odyssey, by Seth Benardete Copyright 2002 interpretation, All rights reserved. ISSN 0020-9635 Interpretation Editor-in-Chief Hilail Gildin, Dept. of Philosophy, Queens College Executive Editor Leonard Grey General Editors Seth G. Benardete (d. 2001) Charles E. Butterworth Hilail Gildin Robert Horwitz (d. 1987) Howard B. White (d. 1974) Consulting Editors Christopher Bruell Joseph Cropsey Ernest L. Fortin John Hallowed (d. 1992) Harry V. Jaffa - David Lowenthal Muhsin Mahdi Harvey C. Mansfield Amaldo Momigliano (d. 1987) Michael Oakeshott (d. 1990) Ellis Sandoz Leo Strauss (d. 1973) Kenneth W. Thompson International Editors Terence E. Marshall Heinrich Meier Editors Wayne Ambler Maurice Auerbach Fred Baumann Amy Bonnette Patrick Coby Elizabeth C de Baca Eastman Thomas S. Engeman Edward J. Erler Maureen Feder-Marcus Pamela K. Jensen Ken Masugi Will Morrisey Susan Orr Charles T. Rubin Leslie G. Rubin Susan Meld Shell Bradford P. Wilson Martin D. Yaffe Michael P. Zuckert Catherine H. Zuckert Manuscript Editor Lucia B. Prochnow Subscriptions Subscription rates per volume (3 issues): individuals $29 libraries and all other institutions $48 students (four-year limit) $ 1 8 Single copies available. Postage outside U.S.: Canada $4.50 extra; elsewhere $5.40 extra by surface mail (8 weeks or longer) or $ 1 1 .00 by air. Payments: in U.S. dollars and payable by a financial institution located within the U.S.A. (or the U.S. Postal Service). The Journal Welcomes Manuscripts in Political Philosophy as Well as Those in Theology, Literature, and Jurisprudence. contributors should follow The Chicago Manual of Style, 13th or later editions "reference-list" or manuals based on them. Instead of endnotes, the journal uses the (or "author-date") system of notation, described in these manuals, illustrated in cur rent numbers of the journal, and discussed in a sheet available from the Assistant to the Editor (see below). Words from languages not rooted in Latin should be trans literated to English. To ensure impartial judgment, contributors should omit mention of their other publications and put, on the title page only, their name, any affiliation desired, address with postal zip code in full, E-mail address, and telephone number. Please send four clear copies, which will not be returned, and double space the entire text and reference list. Composition by Bytheway Publishing Services Printed by the Sheridan Press Binghamton, NY 13901 U.S.A. Hanover, PA 17331 U.S.A. Inquiries: (Ms.) Joan Walsh, Assistant to the Editor interpretation, Queens College, Flushing, N.Y. 11367-1597, U.S.A. (718)997-5542 Fax (718) 997-5565 E Mail: interpretation [email protected] Aristotle on "the Vulgar": An Ethical and Social Examination Harry Adams Rice University The utter vulgarity of the herd of men comes out in their preference for the sort of existence a cow leads. (Aristotle 1961, 10956b20) Aristotle's practical philosophy is known, with some notoriety, to be colored by a certain aristocratic or elitist tone. An integral part of this tone derives from vulgar," his many scattered and pejorative comments on "the "the vulgar class men," craftsmen," of "vulgar and so on. In this paper, I trace the salient features (which center on the ways vulgarity is "inimical to virtue and happiness") of Aristotle's account of vulgarity. Although concentrating on his account of the vulgar working class, or craftsmen (banausoi), I also consider his comments on rich." "the vulgar In addition, I critically evaluate his account as being marked by the following strengths and weaknesses. To its credit, his account contains many incisive and valuable social insights concerning the characteristics, causes, and influences of such vulgarity. As part of the value of these insights lies in their relevance to the moral landscape of contemporary capitalism, I suggest that, to whatever degree capitalist society suffers from such vulgar influences, it can improve itself only by squarely facing the vacuum of virtue left in its midst by these influences. To its detriment, Aristotle's account suffers from masses." a morally specious and priggish condescension towards the "vulgar Correspondingly, as I argue, Aristotle is to be faulted for implicitly endorsing virtuous," an enjoyment of the fruits of vulgar labor by "the without an adequate vulgars' appreciation of these necessary and substantial contribution to the good life of the polis. THE VULGAR 'vulgar' We may commence by examining what Aristotle means by this term (banousos). In our contemporary usage of the term, we often associate vulgarity with coarseness, repulsiveness, or profaneness of a vaguely sexual nature. But these associations are as misleading as enlightening. For Aristotle, the term 'common' connoted a threefold type of "commonness': in the sense of fre 'common' quently found and commonplace, in the sense of socially crude and 'common' unrefined, and also in the sense of morally base and ignoble. In interpretation, Winter 2001-2, Vol. 29, No. 2 134 Interpretation Aristotle's usage of this term, each of these three senses informs and overlaps his meaning, with now one, now another, being emphasized (E.g. A/1095b20, 1107M9, P1260a40Politics, hereafter cited as P. For elucidation of Aristot 'vulgarity' le's conception of against the backdrop of its usage in ordinary Greek of the time, see Liddell & Scott). Expanding beyond a mere definition of the word, how may we say that Aristotle understands and employs the concept of vulgarity? At its core, vulgarity may be understood as a common set of ethical shortcomings, centered on pettiness and ignobility, and an inversion of base for lofty values, that arise from an improper relation to the material resources in one's life. There are six ancillary features that compose and inform his interpre tation of this concept.