Comparative Population Dynamics of Two Closely Related Species Differing in Ploidy Level
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Comparative Population Dynamics of Two Closely Related Species Differing in Ploidy Level Lucie Cˇ erna´ 1, Zuzana Mu¨ nzbergova´ 1,2* 1 Department of Botany, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic, 2 Institute of Botany, Academy of Sciences, Pru˚honice, Czech Republic Abstract Background: Many studies compare the population dynamics of single species within multiple habitat types, while much less is known about the differences in population dynamics in closely related species in the same habitat. Additionally, comparisons of the effect of habitat types and species are largely missing. Methodology and Principal Findings: We estimated the importance of the habitat type and species for population dynamics of plants. Specifically, we compared the dynamics of two closely related species, the allotetraploid species Anthericum liliago and the diploid species Anthericum ramosum, occurring in the same habitat type. We also compared the dynamics of A. ramosum in two contrasting habitats. We examined three populations per species and habitat type. The results showed that single life history traits as well as the mean population dynamics of A. liliago and A. ramosum from the same habitat type were more similar than the population dynamics of A. ramosum from the two contrasting habitats. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that when transferring knowledge regarding population dynamics between populations, we need to take habitat conditions into account, as these conditions appear to be more important than the species involved (ploidy level). However, the two species differ significantly in their overall population growth rates, indicating that the ploidy level has an effect on species performance. In contrast to what has been suggested by previous studies, we observed a higher population growth rate in the diploid species. This is in agreement with the wider range of habitats occupied by the diploid species. Citation: Cˇ erna´ L, Mu¨nzbergova´ Z (2013) Comparative Population Dynamics of Two Closely Related Species Differing in Ploidy Level. PLoS ONE 8(10): e75563. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0075563 Editor: Fei-Hai Yu, Beijing Forestry University, China Received June 11, 2013; Accepted August 15, 2013; Published October 7, 2013 Copyright: ß 2013 Cˇerna´,Mu¨nzbergova´. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Funding: The study was supported by project GACˇ R P504/10/0456 and partly also by institutional research projects RVO 67985939 and MSMT. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. * E-mail: [email protected] Introduction However, such knowledge is still largely lacking (but see [15], [20], [21], [22]). Understanding the population dynamics of a species is a key One of the types of species that is suitable for studying the prerequisite when attempting to understand the factors determin- dynamics of closely related species and obtaining information ing the performance of its populations [1], [2], [3]. Most studies about the minimum differences in the population dynamics of addressing the population biology of various plant species closely related species are pairs of diploid and polyploid species. investigate specific life-cycle stages or single traits, such as seed Polyploidy is relatively frequent in the plant kingdom, and it is production, seedling survival or population size (e.g., [4], [5], [6], estimated that between 47 and 70% of all plant species are [7], [8], [9], [10], [11]). However, to understand the causes of polyploid [23]. More recent estimates even suggest that all changes in population size, it is necessary to investigate the angiosperms have undergone at least one polyploidization event complete life cycle of a species, as it is only by putting the various [24]. Understanding the consequences of polyploidization for the life-cycle transitions into the context of the whole life cycle that we population dynamics of plants is therefore of major importance can understand the consequences of the differences in single life and can help us to evaluate the consequences of polyploidization history traits for the dynamics of a population (e.g., [12], [13], events for species diversity. Studies comparing the behavior of [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19]). diploid and polyploid species have usually concentrated on Performing a detailed analysis of the entire life cycle of a species individual stages of the life cycle, e.g. germination and seedling is a demanding task, and it is not possible to perform such analyses recruitment (e.g. [25], [26]) and individual growth rates, for all species of interest. It would therefore be useful to be able to inflorescence production and flower morphology (e.g. [27], [28], transfer knowledge obtained from one population and/or species [29], [30]). Only few studies have compared the complete life to other populations of the same species and/or different species. cycles of diploid and polyploid species. Mu¨nzbergova´ [15] To evaluate this possibility, we need to understand the differences compared the complete life cycles of diploid and autohexaploid in the population dynamics of closely related species in the same perennial herbs and detected no overall differences in population habitat type and of individual species in different habitat types. dynamics, despite large differences in single life history traits. PLOS ONE | www.plosone.org 1 October 2013 | Volume 8 | Issue 10 | e75563 Population Dynamics of Diploid and Allotetraploid However, the hexaploid populations exhibited a higher extinction Republic, A. ramosum can be found in both Bohemia (western part) probability. Bucharova´ et al. [21] compared diploid and allote- and Moravia (eastern part). For A. liliago, the eastern boundary of traploid ferns and demonstrated the existence of a higher the distribution range is in central Bohemia. extinction probability and smaller number of populations in the In the Czech Republic, the two species usually occur separately. diploid species. Buggs & Pannell [31] compared performance of A. liliago prefers open, sunny stony slopes and rocks with a southern diploid and tetraploid individuals of annual Mercurialis annua and exposure. A. ramosum occupies sunny hillsides (often on a demonstrated that diploid plants have higher fitness. This is in calcareous substrate) and dry open forests. On some open sunny agreement with the fact that diploids are currently displacing slopes, these two species co-occur. In these habitats, it is possible to polyploids in the area. compare the population dynamics of the two species under the Another type of comparison that could help us to understand same habitat conditions and, thus, detect minimum differences in the variability of population dynamics and therefore tell us the population dynamics of two closely related species with something about the possibility of transferring the conclusions of different ploidy levels. Furthermore, the different habitat types studies on the population dynamics of single species is analysis of occupied by A. ramosum allow differences in the dynamics of the dynamics of a single species in different habitat types. As for populations of a single species to be studied in different different ploidy levels, many studies have compared single life environmental conditions. Unfortunately, it is not possible to set history traits between populations from different habitats (e.g., up a full factorial study in this system, as A. liliago does not occur in [32], [33]). Recently, various authors started to compare the whole forests. life cycle of populations of the same species occurring in different habitat types (e.g., [34], [35], [36], [37], [38], [15], [39], [40], Study Localities [41], [42], [43]). To compare the population dynamics of A. liliago and A. In the present study, we estimated the importance of habitat ramosum, we selected 3 localities in open habitats where the two types and species (ploidy levels) in the population dynamics of species co-occur in the Czech Republic. To study the population plants. Specifically, we compared the dynamics of two closely dynamics of A. ramosum in contrasting habitats, 3 additional forest related species, Anthericum liliago (4n) and Anthericum ramosum (2n), in localities were chosen. Therefore, 6 localities and 9 populations the same habitat type in the same localities as well as the dynamics were studied in all (Figure 1). of A. ramosum in two contrasting habitats (forest and open habitat). At each locality in each studied population, the basic habitat Specifically, we asked the following questions. (1) What are the conditions were investigated separately for patches where A. liliago differences in single life history traits between the two species and and A. ramosum occurred. The populations of the two study species between populations of a single species in different types of never completely overlap in the open localities, so we selected habitat? (2) How do these differences translate into differences in patches with only one or the other species for comparison of the population growth rates? (3) Are the observed differences between habitat conditions. For each locality and species, the vegetation species comparable to the