COOPERATIVE HOUSING BULLETIN A member service of the National Association of Housing Cooperatives Fall 2014 Thurgood Marshall’s Civil Rights Advocacy Leads the Way to Inter-Racial Cooperative Membership for His Family and Other Minorities By David J. Thompson CONTENTS Editor’s Note: Part 1 of this in Manhattan. It played a role Officers’ Column article ran in the summer issue in initiating the creation of the of the Cooperative Housing Mitchell Lama Law, which led 3 Bulletin. David J. Thompson is to the development of many writing a book about The Role similar housing cooperatives NAHC Responds of Cooperatives in the Civil throughout New York City. Being to HUD Rights Movement. This article close to Columbia University, 4 is excerpted from a chapter Barnard College, and numerous about Thurgood Marshall and other academic and theological FHA Cooperative cooperatives. OF CONGRESS OF LIBRARY PHOTO COURTESY institutions, Morningside Gardens Refinancing was a welcome affordable housing 4 ON DECEMBER 1, 1955, ROSA addition to the Morningside PARKS (Montgomery’s NAACP Thurgood Marshall with his Heights neighborhood. The intent chapter secretary) remained wife, Cecilia, and their two of the initial board of directors, led Legislative Action Alert seated on a Montgomery bus, children, Thurgood, Jr. and John. by Columbia President Grayson This photo was taken in their 5 and the NAACP was once again Morningside Co-op apartment. Kirk and the philanthropist David appealed to for help. Marshall, Rockefeller, was to create an inter- Board Members Make who was to be married December racial, middle-class multi-family a Positive Difference 17 of that year, asked Robert Carter in his office to community as a model for others in New York City. take on the Montgomery case. Since the death of his When Morningside Gardens opened in 1957, 8 first wife, Marshall had fallen in love with Cecilia the racial make-up of the cooperative members was (Cissy) Suyat, a secretary of Hawaiian and Filipino 75 percent white, 20 percent black, 4 percent Asian, Energy Credit Incentives descent, who worked at the NAACP headquarters. and 1 percent Puerto Rican. As a model of inter- 10 During all of his years in New York City, Marshall racial housing, it was thought at the time that the had rented an apartment. Because of restrictive percentage of blacks and Puerto Ricans should be Coopservations: Ferguson racial covenants in New York City, it was almost no more than 25%. But most importantly for the and Cooperatives impossible for blacks to buy homes even if they Marshalls, Morningside Gardens was open to inter- had the money. Marshall was now in an even racial couples. 15 more difficult predicament. The covenants were In fact, the Morningside Gardens’ cooperative even stricter about inter-racial couples and had organizers recruited the Marshalls to become Airbnb Update anticipated a black and white couple. In this case, members of the cooperative knowing of their 18 the Marshalls were an inter-racial black and Asian- inability to get home ownership in any other way in Hawaiian couple. Home ownership in New York Manhattan. The Marshalls moved into Morningside City was almost impossible for them. Gardens in the spring of 1958. They were the first About that time, Morningside Gardens was occupants of the new apartment. By the end of developed as a limited-equity housing cooperative 1958, every one of the cooperative’s 980 apartments on the upper west side. It was one of the earliest was occupied. owner-occupied inter-racial housing cooperatives Continued on page 6 > Thurgood Marshall [continued from page 1] Morningside Gardens Housing Cooperative, developed as a limited- equity housing coop- erative on the upper west side, was the first home the Marshalls owned. OF MORNINGSIDE GARDENS HOUSING COOPERATIVE PHOTO COURTESY The cooperative ownership and residency couldn’t in Virginia. Yet, Morningside Gardens Cooperative, have come at a better time for the Marshalls as they had in fact been the first home he and his family were about to have their second child (John born in owned, a decade earlier. July 1958.) Being welcomed into the cooperative meant This fact influenced Marshall greatly. obtaining a home in which to safely bring up their two When it came to his own work with cooperatives, young children. Morningside Gardens, with six, 21-story the place where Marshall made the most impact was buildings, became an inter-racial neighborhood that on the issue of developing inter-racial cooperatives was secure and friendly. The site covered 10 acres that at the end of the Second World War. When the war were beautifully laid out with significant open space and ended, numerous groups, ranging from churches to For the Marshalls, many facilities. The cooperative community of 3,500 veteran organizations, were intent on creating inter- Morningside Gardens people became a social and economic model for what racial cooperatives. As they reasoned, if they had New York City could be. fought a war and faced death together, why could they was open to inter- The Marshall’s home was a cooperative apartment not live together? racial couples...In on the 17th floor of Building VI in Morningside Regretfully, this new idea was prevented through February 1949, Truman Gardens. It would be theirs for nearly 10 years. Their racial covenants, “red-lining” (the practice of banks issued an executive cooperative share was $2,500, and their monthly not offering mortgages in black neighborhoods) and carrying charges were $21. It is probable that this targeted use of insurance funds by the Federal Housing order declaring such meant $21 a room. The October 1958 issue of the Authority (FHA). Throughout the United States, every housing finance Morningside Gardens News reported, “One of our attempt to create an inter-racial housing cooperative discrimination illegal. most active members is Mr. Thurgood Marshall, was turned down by the FHA. Whether it was York Building VI, who serves as a full-time lawyer for the Center Cooperative, IL, Usonia in New York State, NAACP. Mr. Marshall has pleaded many cases before Community Homes and Mutual Housing Association the Supreme Court, most of which he has won.” in Los Angeles, Sunnyhills, Milpitas or Ladera in Palo As a neighbor of the Marshall’s recalled, “We had Alto, all in California, the FHA fabricated excuses to a Fourth of July party here, and Thurgood and Cissy turn down inter-racial cooperatives. had over Alex Haley, Daisy Bates (champion of the The FHA’s unspoken opposition was that allowing Little Rock 9), and Lena Horne.” blacks to live in a cooperative would impact the The Marshalls might have stayed at Morningside marketability of the units and lower the value, thereby for the rest of their lives. However, in August of 1965, harming the FHA’s collateral investment. President Johnson appointed Marshall as the first One of these planned, post-war inter-racial black US Solicitor General. Soon after, the Marshall cooperatives was York Center Cooperative in Du family moved to Washington D.C. Page County, Ill. Conceived of by a group of religious In 1967, the US Supreme Court struck down a ban and progressive families in 1945, York Center bought on inter-racial marriage in Virginia and several other 100 acres to turn into a land cooperative for 79 states the Commonwealth of Virginia, and shortly homes. Although each home was to be owned by after, the Marshalls moved into a home now open to the cooperative member, the underlying land and them in Falls Church, VA, Marshall was 60 when he improvements were to be owned jointly by the 72 was legally allowed to own his first single family home members. The Chicago Tribune reported, “Members 6 Continued on page 7 > NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF HOUSING COOPERATIVES COOPERATIVE HOUSING BULLETIN | FALL 2014 Thurgood Marshall [continued from page 6] learned to tout the 100 acres of communally-owned property as an In later years, Morningside Gardens named its community economically mixed society that was tolerant of all races, religions center on La Salle Street the Thurgood Marshall Room. Many of and ethnicities.” the cooperative’s member events take place there. It is a fitting To create legal documents that would spell out and confirm tribute to a man who was helped by cooperatives and who helped the intent of their cooperative community, the original board cooperatives build a better America open to all races. CHB sought a pro-bono lawyer. They were fortunate to get the help of Ted Robinson, an attorney who worked in Chicago for the Illinois David J. Thompson is President of Twin Pines Cooperative Foundation, Department of Labor. Robinson spent over two years working [email protected]; 530/757-2233. through the articles, bylaws, membership documents, deeds, *Thurgood Marshall, “Memorandum to the President of the United States and model lease—all based on one member, one vote, and open Concerning Racial Discrimination by the Federal Housing Administration,” membership. National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (Library of At the conclusion of his work, Robinson decided he, too, should Congress Manuscript Collections), February 1, 1949, 14. apply to join the cooperative. The problem was that Robinson was black, and his wife was Jewish and their children of mixed race. A number of the cooperative members said they would leave if Robinson’s family was allowed to join. Robinson withdrew his application, not wanting the cooperative to come to an end due to his application. However, many members felt that if their intent was truly to have “open membership” that meant everyone, which surely included Robinson and his inter-racial family. The Robinsons were then approved for membership, and some members did leave the cooperative.