UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI
Date: 23-Feb-2010
I, Won Joon Song , hereby submit this original work as part of the requirements for the degree of: Doctor of Philosophy in Mechanical Engineering It is entitled: Study on Human Auditory System Models and Risk Assessment of Noise
Induced Hearing Loss
Student Signature: Won Joon Song
This work and its defense approved by: Committee Chair: J. Kim, PhD J. Kim, PhD
William Murphy, PhD William Murphy, PhD
Mark Schulz, PhD Mark Schulz, PhD
Teik Lim, PhD Teik Lim, PhD
3/3/2010 412 Study on Human Auditory System Models and Risk Assessment of Noise Induced Hearing Loss
A dissertation submitted to the
Division of Research and Advanced Studies of the University of Cincinnati
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
DOCTORATE OF PHILOSOPHY
in the Department of Mechanical, Industrial and Nuclear Engineering of the College of Engineering and Applied Science
2010
By
Won Joon Song
B.S. Mechanical Engineering Hanyang University, Seoul, Korea, 1995
M.S. Mechanical Engineering Hanyang University, Seoul, Korea, 1997
Committee Chair: Dr. Jay H. Kim
Abstract
Simulation-based study of human auditory response characteristics and development of a prototype for advanced noise guideline are two major focuses of this dissertation research.
This research was conducted as a part of the long-term effort to develop an improved noise guideline for better protection of the workers exposed to various noise environments.
The human auditory responses were studied with simulation models. A human full-ear model derived from an existing model, Auditory Hazard Assessment Algorithm for Human
(AHAAH), was utilized as a baseline for the study. Frequency- and time-domain responses of well-known human middle ear network models were cross-compared to estimate expected accuracy of the models and understand their proper use. Responses of the stapes to impulsive noises were investigated by using the middle ear models to understand the effects of the temporal characteristics of impulsive noises on the responses. Available measured transfer functions between the free-field pressure and the stapes response for human and chinchilla were also used to study the auditory response characteristics. The measured transfer functions were refined and reconditioned to make them have equivalent formats. Using the reconstructed transfer functions, time-domain stapes responses of human and chinchilla to impulsive and complex type noises were calculated and compared.
Applicability of the noise metrics defined in terms of the stapes response to assess the risk of the noise induced hearing loss was studied.
A prototype of an improved noise guideline was developed from existing chinchilla noise iv
exposure data. Applying a new signal processing technique to the time histories of the exposed noises and studying the relationship between the noise metric and the permanent threshold shift (PTS), the dose-response relationship (DRR) was established in a compatible way with the definition used in current human noise guidelines. From the DDR, noise induced hearing loss (NIHL) threshold is estimated as a function of frequency. An advanced noise guideline that enables quantitative, frequency by frequency assessment of risk of the noise was developed by utilizing the identified NIHL threshold. The guideline was developed so that it can be easily transformed to a human noise guideline. Therefore, the guideline serves as a prototype of a future human noise guideline.
v
vi
Acknowledgements
Theory , practice , knowledge and experience, inscribed at the entrance of Swift Hall and Old
Chemistry, are four elements that should be equipped to be a real engineer.
I must acknowledge the dedicated efforts of Prof. Jay Kim in guiding and assisting my research. With his valuable advices and innovative suggestions, I could proceed and finalize this work. I would like to express my appreciation to Prof. Teik Lim, Prof. Mark Schulz and
Dr. William Murphy for accepting to be in my dissertation committee and providing helpful review comments. My special thanks go to Drs. Price and Kalb in the U.S. Army Research
Laboratory (USARL) and Drs. Hamernik and Qui in SUNY Plattsburgh for supplying useful data. The financial support by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
(NIOSH), Grant number R21 OH008510, is to be highly appreciated.
I am deeply grateful to Shrikant Pattnaik, Steve Goley and Ed Zechmann for the friendship they showed to me. I really appreciate to my Korean friends in UC and international friends in Baldwin 445 for sharing great times with me. I wish all of them to make great strides in their future careers. I also would like to offer my special gratitude to Prof. J. K. Lim, a role model to me, in Hanyang University.
My parents deserve the greatest gratitude from me. From the bottom of my heart, I appreciate the unconditional supports that I owed to my younger sisters and brother-in-law.
vii
Contents
Introduction ...... 1
I. Introduction to the human auditory system: Structure and functions ...... 6
A. External ear ...... 7
B. Middle ear ...... 9
1. Tympanic membrane ...... 9
2. Ossicular chain ...... 11
3. Middle ear cavities ...... 13
4. Eustachian tube ...... 15
C. Inner ear ...... 15
II. Auditory system modeling ...... 19
A. Sound source and the external ear modeling ...... 19
1. From the free-field to the concha entrance ...... 19
2. Concha and the ear canal modeling ...... 36
B. Middle ear modeling ...... 45
1. Classic configuration of the human middle ear ...... 45
2. Tympanic membrane models ...... 50
3. Ossicular-chain and middle-ear transformer ...... 59
4. Nonlinear elements ...... 72 viii
5. Stapes-cochlea (SC) complex network model ...... 87
6. Network analogues for the middle-ear cavities ...... 105
C. Cochlear modeling ...... 113
1. Passive cochlear model by Zwislocki (2002b) ...... 113
2. Cochlear transfer function ...... 116
III. Comparative study of human middle ear models based on the frequency response solutions ...... 124
A. Middle ear network models ...... 124
1. Classic configuration of the middle ear network model ...... 126
2. Selected network models for comparison ...... 128
3. Impedance characteristics of reference network models ...... 130
B. Middle ear transfer functions of network models ...... 131
1. Pressure transfer function ...... 131
2. Middle-ear transfer admittance ...... 136
3. Displacement-pressure transfer function ...... 139
4. Volume velocity transfer function ...... 144
C. Comparison of frequency-domain stapedial responses of middle ear network models
(Song and Kim, 2008) ...... 147
IV. Comparison of human middle ear models based on their temporal responses to
ix
impulsive waveforms ...... 157
A. Methodology ...... 158
B. Comparison of temporal responses of human middle ear models ...... 159
1. Unit impulse responses of human middle ear models ...... 159
2. Parametric study on the responses of network middle ear models to impulsive
inputs ...... 165
C. Effect of impulse parameters on the inner ear responses ...... 178
V. Time-domain stapes responses obtained from reconstructed transfer functions ...... 184
A. Transfer functions from measurements...... 185
1. External ear pressure transfer function...... 186
2. Middle ear volume velocity-pressure transfer function ...... 188
B. Reconstruction of the transfer functions ...... 191
C. Time-domain responses of the stapes ...... 200
D. Noise metric based on the stapedial responses ...... 205
1. Design of stapes response based noise metric ...... 205
2. Comparison of the stapes response metrics of human and chinchilla...... 207
3. Correlation study ...... 214
VI. Development of a prototype of advanced noise guideline by using noise induced hearing loss threshold level of chinchillas extracted from existing exposure test data ...... 218
x
A. Reprocessing of the exposure data ...... 218
1. Re-analysis of exposure data ...... 218
B. Estimation of NIHL threshold and its applications ...... 220
1. Permissible exposure level (PEL) and NIHL threshold ...... 220
2. Applications of NIHL threshold data ...... 223
References ...... 230
Appendix: Variable Impedance component modeling using Simulink ...... 247
A. Equivalent model of a nonlinear electric component ...... 248
1. Equivalent modeling of a variable resistor ...... 248
2. Equivalent modeling of a variable capacitor ...... 251
B. Validity check of equivalent network models ...... 253
C. Application of the non-linear component models to the AHAAH ...... 259
xi
Introduction
With approximately 22 million workers exposed to hazardous noise environments in the
United States alone (Tak et al. , 2009), noise induced hearing loss (NIHL) is one of the most frequently reported occupational diseases (NIOSH, 2001). Various noise guidelines (OSHA,
1981; ISO, 1990; ANSI, 1996; NIOSH, 1998) have been used to protect workers from NIHL.
All these noise guidelines recommend the permissible exposure level (PEL) according to a highly simplified method based on the equally energy hypothesis (EEH). For example,
NIOSH 98-126 (1998) and ISO-1999 (1990) adopts 85-dBA as the level that allows 8-hour daily exposure and the 3-dB exchange rate that halves the permissible exposure time for every 3-dB increase from the noise level. The approach is very simple to apply; however may not be accurate because it ignores the effect of temporal and spectral characteristics of the noise on the NIHL. It is a near consensus of researchers that the EEH based approach underestimates the risk of a complex noise environment where impulsive noises are embedded in a continuous background noise (Roberto et al. , 1985; Ahroon et al. , 1993;
Hamernik and Qiu, 2001; Harding and Bohne, 2004; Hamernik et al. , 2007). A new methodology to assess the risk of noises of any general type of occupational noises is urgently necessary, which motivated this research.
To develop a better noise guideline, an accurate noise dose-response relationship (DRR) is required. The task involves a wide range of scientific approaches including audiology, biology, engineering signal processing and statistics. Almost all past works in this area have 1
been human population studies (Taylor et al. , 1965; Burns et al. , 1970; Passcheir-Vermeer,
1983; Taylor et al. , 1984; Johansson and Arlinger, 2001; Johansson and Arlinger, 2002) or animal noise exposure studies (Nilsson et al. , 1983; Davis et al. , 1989; Dunn et al. , 1991;
Hamernik and Qiu, 2000; Hamernik et al. , 2002). Demographic studies were used to find
DRR by statistical methods. Numerous animal noise exposure tests were conducted to investigate effects of temporal characteristics of the noise (Hamernik et al. , 1974; Hunt et al. ,
1976; Blakeslee et al. , 1977; Roberto et al. , 1983; Henderson et al. , 1985; Roberto et al. ,
1985) and effects of chemicals on noise (Humes, 1984; Jock et al. , 1996; Boettcher et al. ,
1998).
Animal noise exposure studies provide valuable information on DRR because the results were obtained by well-controlled tests. Chinchillas have been used most commonly for exposure tests due to audiometric characteristics similar to those in humans (Miller, 1970;
Vrettakos et al. , 1988; Heffner and Heffner, 1991). Through research studies spanning two decades, Hamernik and his collaborators have obtained a comprehensive set of noise exposure data of chinchillas (Blakeslee et al. , 1977; Hamernik and Hsueh, 1991; Hamernik and Qiu, 2001). The auditory data were measured in a systematic way and the pressure wave forms were digitally recorded. This allowed the reanalysis of the data using newly developed signal analysis techniques to obtain additional information or insights in this study.
Various techniques and related theories of human ear simulation have been extensively 2
studied and applied to investigate the human auditory response characteristics. A simulation model is a convenient tool to estimate the response of the auditory system to any type of noise. If a very accurate simulation technique exists, a noise guideline may be developed solely based on the simulation method. However, quantitatively accurate simulation of the ear system, one of the most delicate organs, is believed to be beyond the current state of the art because much of the operating principle and damage mechanism of the hearing organ are not well understood.
Developing an accurate noise guideline is a challenge that requires a long-term effort. As a part of the long-term effort to develop an improved noise guideline, this dissertation focused on investigating the human auditory responses obtained from simulations and developing a chinchilla version of the noise guideline as a prototype for the future human noise guideline.
This dissertation consists of 6 chapters. Chapters I and II are devoted to explaining human auditory system and discussing typical methods to model the system. Anatomical and functional description of the human auditory system was summarized in chapter I. The modeling techniques of the human ear were discussed in chapter II. Network models for the source field and each functional part of the external and middle ear were represented in detail. Typical procedures to model the passive cochlea and deduce the cochlear transfer function were described at the end of the chapter. Simulation models of the human ear were developed using MATLAB (MATLAB®, 2007b) and Simulink (Simulink ®, 2007b) as 3
programming tools .
Investigation of human ear responses based on the simulation technique is described in chapters III through V. In chapter III, frequency responses of seven popular human middle ear network models were compared. Middle ear transfer functions of the models were cross-compared. Variations of the middle ear transmissibility when a part of the given model is replaced by that used in the other models were utilized to roughly estimate accuracy of the models. In chapter IV, the stapes responses simulated by the seven models were compared to study characteristics of human middle ear time-domain responses to impulsive stimulus. In chapter V, available transfer functions measured for human (Shaw,
1974; Mehrgardt and Mellert, 1977; Kringlebotn and Gundersen, 1985) and chinchilla
(Bismarck, 1967; Bismarck and Pfeiffer, 1967; Ruggero et al. , 1990; Murphy and Davis,
1998) were reconditioned and expanded to make them comparable to one another. Using the reconstructed transfer functions, time-domain stapedial responses of the human and chinchilla were calculated for selected noises and compared. Possibility of using the stapes responses to develop a noise metric was explored.
In chapter VI, identification of the NIHL threshold levels of chinchillas and development of a prototype of an advanced noise guideline were discussed. Existing chinchilla noise exposure data provided by collaborators in SUNY Plattsburgh (Hamernik et al. , 1984;
Hamernik et al. , 1987; Hamernik et al. , 1989; Hamernik et al. , 1994; Hamernik and Ahroon,
1998; Hamernik and Qiu, 2001; Hamernik et al. , 2002; Hamernik et al. , 2003; , 2007) were 4
re-analyzed statistically. It was shown that the threshold noise level that induces NIHL to chinchillas can be identified by applying statistical methods and clever interpretations of the human guidelines and the noise exposure data. The threshold information was utilized to develop an improved noise guideline for chinchillas as a prototype for a future human guideline. The new guideline has new features that enable recommendations in a frequency-by-frequency and quantitative manner.
5
I. Introduction to the human auditory system: Structure and functions
The human peripheral auditory system, which has structural and functional similarities to the other mammalian species, encompasses the external ear, the middle ear, the inner ear, and the auditory-vestibular cranial nerve (i.e., sensory CN VIII) as shown in Fig. I-1. Each part plays a unique role in translating acoustic signals into electrochemical signals which the brain can decode. Airborne sound from free-field passes through the outer ear in the mode of pressure vibration. The middle ear changes acoustic vibration into mechanical vibration. The inner ear transforms the mechanical energy into the hydrodynamic motion of the cochlear partition, which generates an electrochemical signal (i.e., neural impulse) to the brain. An alternative mode of sound transmission, called “bone conduction”, conveys airborne sound directly to the cochlea through skull-bone vibration, bypassing the external and middle ear (Homma et al. , 2009a; Homma et al. , 2009b). This chapter provides the anatomical and functional description of the human auditory system engaged in the normal auditory pathway.
6
Fig. I-1. Schematic of the human ear. (from Flanagan, 1972)
A. External ear
The external ear, the outermost part of the auditory system, is comprised of the pinna (i.e., auricle) and external auditory meatus (i.e., ear canal). The pinna depicted in Fig. I-2 collects and funnels sound waves and helps sound localization. The pinna is shaped like a revered- horn as in Fig. I-3 and pre-amplifies the incoming sound pressure before it enters the earcanal. The auditory canal is an “S”-shaped passage approximately 2.5-3.0 cm in length, whose lateral 1/3 to 1/2 is cartilaginous portion while the medial rest of it tunnels through the temporal bone thus is osseous (i.e., bony) portion (Alvord and Farmer, 1997). The tube- like canal guides acoustic waves up to the tympanic membrane. The resonance frequency of the ear canal is about 3.5 kHz at which the peak pressure gain is about 10 dB in case of
7
human (Dallos, 1973b).
Fig. I-2. Anatomy of the pinna (from Figure 1 of Alvord and Farmer, 1997)
Fig. I-3. Sectional view of the ear canal (from Figure 2 of Alvord and Farmer, 1997)
8
B. Middle ear
The middle ear is located between the external and the inner ear, which couples the airborne sound to the fluid-filled cochlear duct (Rosowski and Relkin, 2001). The middle ear is functionally viewed as an impedance transformer buffering the impedance mismatch between the air in the auditory canal (i.e., medium of lower impedance) and the water-like liquid called perilymph in the inner ear (i.e., medium of higher impedance).
1. Tympanic membrane
The tympanic membrane is a cone-shaped thin membrane located at the end of the ear canal thus forms the boundary between the external and middle ear. The membrane has layered architecture (Alvord and Farmer, 1997); the outer epidermal layer of desquamating epithelium continuous with the skin of the auditory canal, the intermediate fibrous layer of collagen fibrils organized in radial and circumferential directions, and the inner mucus membrane layer continuous with the lining of the middle ear. The thick lower portion of the tympanic membrane called “pars tensa” is partially attached to the malleus handle and mechanically reinforced by the radial and circumferential fibrous layers. The thin upper portion of the tympanic membrane is called “pars flaccida”. The tympanic annulus (i.e., a bony ring) stretches the pars tensa while the pars flaccida is slack due to the opening in the annular ring.
The tympanic membrane is excited by the pressure difference on both surfaces, through
9
which impinging sound is converted into mechanical vibrations in the middle ear. The central portion of the pars tensa is mostly responsible for the mechanical energy transmission thus, different from the anatomical division, the membrane is functionally re- partitioned as the conductive part transmitting the mechanical energy into the ossicular chain and the independent (i.e., residual) part shunting the acoustic energy.
Pars flaccida
Malleus handle (i.e., manubrium)
Umbo Tympanic annulus Pars tensa
Fig. I-4. Tympanic membrane (modified from http://l.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/edu/ref/ga/l/910.gif)
10
2. Ossicular chain
The ossicular chain consists of three ossicles (i.e., malleus, incus, and stapes) and two interconnecting joints (i.e., malleo-incudal joint and incudo-stapedial joint) as shown in Fig.
I-5. The malleus is sustained by the anterior malleal ligament and the superior malleal ligament. The malleo-incudal joint connecting the round head and incus body is a type of ball-socket joint. The long process of the malleus (i.e., manubrium) is attached to the inner layer of the tympanic membrane as well as to the tensor tympani tendon. The incus is supported by the superior incudal ligament and posterior incudal ligament. The lenticular process of the incus and the stapes head are connected by the incudo-stapedial joint. The footplate of the stapes is suspended from the oval window by the annular ligament which restricts the stapes motion. At the head of the stapes, the stapedius muscle is attached.
a) Mechanical transformer
The ossicular chain forms a mechanical transformer through which impedance transition occurs. Since the long process of the malleus is a little bit longer than the long process of the incus, the length ratio exerts a lever effect on the energy transmission. The areal ratio between the effective area of the tympanic membrane and the stapes footplate area causes hydraulic advantage thus boosts up the energy transmission into the inner ear. The combination of the lever and areal ratio makes it possible to reduce the impedance gap existing between the external auditory canal and the inner ear.
11
The acoustic reflex (i.e., middle ear reflex), as a protection mechanism in response to high acoustic stimuli above 85 dB SPL, triggers the contraction of the stapedius muscle which pulls the stapes head along the major axis of the stapes footplate (Bennet, 1984) perpendicular to the direction of piston-like motion. Therefore, the middle ear reflex restricts the stapes movement increasing acoustic stiffness and finally reduces low- frequency acoustic transmission into the inner ear. Activated prior to self-vocalization, it reduces the masking by low-frequency noise thus enhances intelligibility of speech in the presence of environmental noise. The stapedius muscle solely involves the acoustic reflex in case of the human ear; however, both the tensor tympani and the stapedius muscle engages in animal (Møller, 2000). As with other biological responses, the reflex experiences the latency, adaptation, and recovery process.
12
Fig. I-5. Ossicular chain (from Yost, 2000)
3. Middle ear cavities
Located right behind the tympanic membrane, the human middle-ear air space schematically shown in Fig. I-6 is composed of the tympanic cavity, the aditus ad antrum, the tympanic antrum and the mastoid cells (Voss et al. , 2000). The tympanic cavity contains the ossicular chain system. The aditus ad antrum is a narrow passage which bridges the tympanic cavity and the tympanic antrum. The mastoid cells form a complex network of pneumatic cells attached to the tympanic antrum. It is known that the larger the middle ear air space, the better the low frequency middle ear gain (Rosowski and Merchant, 1995) thus the rodent such as gerbil with larger air cavity space than human shows better
13
audibility in the low frequency region.
Interacting acoustically with cochlear windows, the air space forms an acoustic transmission pathway whose acoustic resonance characteristic is similar to a Helmholtz resonator. Acoustic communication between the tympanic cavity and the antrum occurs through the narrow passage (i.e., aditus ad antrum). Middle ear air space contributes to the middle ear input impedance peak around 1-3 kHz but is not substantial in other spectral regions.
Fig. I-6. Human middle ear air spaces (from Stepp and Voss, 2005)
14
4. Eustachian tube
The Eustachian tube connecting the middle ear cavity with the nasopharynx of the throat equalizes the middle ear static pressure to the ambient pressure of the throat (Rosowski,
1996). Since the contraction of the tensor tympani pulls the manubrium toward the middle ear side to increase the middle ear pressure, it also helps open the Eustachian tube.
C. Inner ear
The inner ear is the innermost part of the auditory periphery, which consists of fluid-filled bony labyrinth running through the temporal bone of the skull. The frontal part of the labyrinth is the cochlea, the auditory organ, while the rear part is the semicircular canals, balancing organ. The vestibule is the cavity interconnecting the cochlea and the semicircular canals. It contains the utricle and saccule that contribute to balance and spatial orientation.
The cochlea, a snail-like auditory organ, is the time-frequency analyzer residing in the temporal bones. The cochlear section, as shown in Fig. I-7, has three chambers respectively called scala vestibuli, scala tympani and the scala media. The scala vestibuli and the scala tympani are bony labyrinth chambers filled with perilymph rich in , while the scala Na media is membranous labyrinth filled with endolymph whose ionic concentration is rich in
but low in . Helicotrema is the interconnection of the two bony chambers found at K Ca the apex of the cochlea. The stapes footplate is suspended in the oval window at the lower
15
extent of the scala vestibuli. The round window is at the basal end of the scala tympani. The round window serves as a pressure valve, that is, it releases the hydraulic pressure built up in the perilymph into the middle ear air space by bulging outward.
The Organ of Corti shown in Fig. I-8 resides in the scala media. It rests on the basilar membrane whose thickness and width varies along the distance from the basal end and generates the impedance gradient. The Organ of Corti has two types of receptor cells; the inner hair cell (IHC) innervated by afferent nerve fibers and the outer hair cell (OHC) innervated by both of afferent and efferent nerve fibers. IHC is basic sensor to convert mechanical signal into electrical spikes. OHC shows somatic motility in which its length changes by the activation of the prestin in the lateral wall and provides active feedback to the cochlear partition response thus is involved in the cochlear amplifier and sharper frequency tuning observed in the live cochlea. Each hair cell has sensory hair bundle called stereocilia whose bending motion opens or closes mechanically-gated ion channels. The tallest row of the OHC stereocilia is embedded in a gelatinous structure called tectorial membrane and is under direct shearing force; however the IHC stereocilia is not in contact with the membrane.
The stapes movement triggers the response of the inner ear. Piston-like motion of the stapes footplate generates the compressive waves in the perilymph of the cochlear duct. As the wave passes, hydraulic pressure difference is introduced across the cochlear partition
(i.e., the basilar membrane). The pressure difference elicits the up-and-down motion of the
16
cochlear partition thus traveling waves propagate on it. Propagated traveling wave reaches its maximum displacement at specific location of the cochlear partition and is rapidly suppressed. Due to the spatial impedanc e characteristic of the basilar membrane, high frequency waves propagate only at the basal region of the membrane while low frequency waves travel to the apex. The movement of the partition bends the stereocilia on top of hair cells by the relative motion to the tectorial membrane or by the shear flow of the endolymph, which leads to the electrochemical reaction in hair cells by opening or closing transduction channels.
Fig. I-7. Cochlear section (from Kessel and Kardon, 1979)
17
Fig. I-8. Organ of Corti (from Kessel and Kardon, 1979)
18
II. Auditory system modeling
In this chapter, modeling techniques of the human ear are discussed. Modeling of the external and middle ear utilizes acousto-electric analogy. Source pressure field is simplified by impedance networks of the head-related diffraction and acoustic radiation. The external ear and the middle ear are represented by several impedance blocks. Typical technique of cochlear modeling are reviewed. The procedure to model the passive cochlea in the frequency domain and obtain the cochlear transfer function is described at the end of this chapter.
A. Sound source and the external ear modeling
1. From the free-field to the concha entrance a) Parallel circuit representation of radiation impedance (Bauer, 1944)
(1) Pulsating sphere
The specific radiation impedance ( ) of a pulsating sphere of radius is: z r