Moving Towards a New Urban Systems Science
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ecosystems DOI: 10.1007/s10021-016-0053-4 Ó 2016 Springer Science+Business Media New York 20TH ANNIVERSARY PAPER Moving Towards a New Urban Systems Science Peter M. Groffman,1* Mary L. Cadenasso,2 Jeannine Cavender-Bares,3 Daniel L. Childers,4 Nancy B. Grimm,5 J. Morgan Grove,6 Sarah E. Hobbie,3 Lucy R. Hutyra,7 G. Darrel Jenerette,8 Timon McPhearson,9 Diane E. Pataki,10 Steward T. A. Pickett,11 Richard V. Pouyat,12 Emma Rosi-Marshall,11 and Benjamin L. Ruddell13 1Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, City University of New York Advanced Science Research Center and Brooklyn College, New York, New York 10031, USA; 2Department of Plant Sciences, University of California, Davis, California 95616, USA; 3Department of Ecology, Evolution and Behavior, University of Minnesota, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55108, USA; 4School of Sustain- ability, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85287, USA; 5School of Life Sciences and Global Institute of Sustainability, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85287, USA; 6USDA Forest Service, Baltimore Field Station, Baltimore, Maryland 21228, USA; 7Department of Earth and Environment, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, USA; 8Department of Botany and Plant Sciences, University of California Riverside, Riverside, California 92521, USA; 9Urban Ecology Lab, Environmental Studies Program, The New School, New York, New York 10003, USA; 10Department of Biology, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah 84112, USA; 11Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Millbrook, New York 12545, USA; 12USDA Forest Service, Research and Development, District of Columbia, Washington 20502, USA; 13School of Informatics, Computing, and Cyber Systems, Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff, Arizona 86001, USA ABSTRACT Research on urban ecosystems rapidly expanded in linchpins in the further development of sustain- the 1990s and is now a central topic in ecosystem ability science and argue that there is a strong need science. In this paper, we argue that there are two for a new initiative in urban systems science to critical challenges for ecosystem science that are address these challenges and catalyze the next rooted in urban ecosystems: (1) predicting or wave of fundamental advances in ecosystem sci- explaining the assembly and function of novel ence, and more broadly in interdisciplinary and communities and ecosystems under altered envi- transdisciplinary science. ronmental conditions and (2) refining under- standing of humans as components of ecosystems Key words: community assembly; ecosystem in the context of integrated social-ecological sys- function; evolution; social science; sustainability; tems. We assert that these challenges are also urban. INTRODUCTION Ecosystem-scale research on urban ecosystems has Received 25 April 2016; accepted 13 September 2016; expanded rapidly since the 1990s (McDonnell and Author contributions Peter M. Groffman wrote the first draft of the Pickett 1993; Alberti and others 2003) and is now a paper based on input from numerous colleagues in the Baltimore and widely accepted component of ecosystem science Phoenix U.S. National Science Foundation Funded Urban Long Term (Weathers and others 2016). This emergence was Ecological Research projects. Other authors reviewed the manuscript and provided text on specific aspects. driven by the recognition that urban, suburban, *Corresponding author; e-mail: [email protected] P. M. Groffman and others and exurban ecosystems are increasingly where analyses (Boyden and others 1981; Baker and others people are living, consuming resources, and pro- 2001) that broadened the focus of urban ecosystems ducing waste. Urban ecosystems thus have distinct research to include consequences of a city’s resource ecological characteristics and important environ- use for regional to global processes. mental impacts (Grimm and others 2008a, b); and However, interpreting results from urban gradi- they provide unique and powerful opportunities ent studies is complicated by the multiple factors for basic science advances in ecosystem science that covary along these gradients (McDonnell and (Pickett and others 2011; McPhearson and others Hahs 2008). Further, concerns about the large 2016). More practically, bringing ecological ap- number of natural and human factors influencing proaches to challenges associated with urbaniza- ecosystem processes and biotic community assem- tion can point towards solutions to some of the bly along such gradients hindered extrapolation to most pressing problems in environmental science broader areas of natural and semi-natural ecosys- (Childers and others 2014). tems. Now, an improved ability to parse diverse After 25 years of research in urban ecology, we factors affecting community assembly (Swan and face exciting but challenging opportunities in this others 2011; Knapp and others 2012) and the discipline. In particular, there are two critical chal- emergence of ‘‘novel’’ communities and ecosys- lenges for ecosystem science that are rooted in urban tems in many places, that is, assemblages of ecosystems: (1) understanding the assembly and organisms and environmental conditions that have function of novel ecological communities and not necessarily evolved and assembled in the ab- ecosystems under novel environmental conditions sence of human action over long periods of time and (2) refining understanding of humans as com- (Hobbs and others 2014) has rekindled interest in ponents of ecosystems to create a deeper and more using urban areas as sentinels of ecosystem re- useful understanding of human–environment sponse to global change. The functions of novel interactions in the context of integrated social-eco- ecosystems are unknown in many respects and logical systems. These challenges are linchpins in the addressing this gap is a frontier challenge in further development of sustainability science, a ecosystem science over the next 20–50 years. problem-driven interdisciplinary field dealing with The presence of novel ecosystems in urban areas the interactions between human and environmen- thus represents an excellent opportunity to study tal systems that link knowledge to action to advance the assembly of novel communities and ecosystem the development of social-ecological systems that function under environmental conditions repre- are ecologically sound, socially equitable, and eco- sentative of and/or relevant to the new climates nomically viable (Matson and others 2016). There is emerging due to global climate change. It is not a strong need for new initiatives in urban systems clear if the often hyper-diverse mixtures of culti- science to address these challenges and catalyze the vated and spontaneously establishing species that next wave of fundamental advances in ecosystem include escaped cultivars, introduced weeds, and and environmental science. remnant or naturally establishing native species will function similarly to the ecosystems that urban systems have largely replaced. Moreover, there is THE ‘‘COMMUNITIES OF TOMORROW’’ ARE high potential for these novel ecosystems to spread BEING ASSEMBLED TODAY AT AN URBAN into surrounding non-urban regions and to influ- LOCATION NEAR YOU ence the composition, diversity, and evolution of the continental flora and its ecosystem functions Much of the early work on urban ecosystems was (Johnson and others 2015; McDonnell and Hahs driven by the idea that urban environmental condi- 2015). Indeed, it is likely that areas at the ‘‘wild- tions, with elevated temperatures, atmospheric CO2 land-(ex)urban interface’’ with agricultural and levels, nitrogen (N) deposition and pollutants (for less human-dominated ecosystems (Radeloff and example, ozone, heavy metals), dramatically altered others 2005) are where the communities and water balances, invasive species introductions, and ecosystems that will dominate the continent over rapid timescales of transition, were a useful analog the next 100 years are being assembled. Critically, for future environmental conditions. Early studies the linkage of biodiversity and community struc- along urban to rural gradients addressed these factors ture with ecosystem function and services is even (McDonnell and Pickett 1990; Pouyat and McDon- more uncertain in urban areas than in natural nell 1991; Pouyat and others 1995) and also provided areas, due to their novel composition and envi- a platform for larger-scale urban ‘‘footprint’’ analyses ronment. Hence, a focus on novel ecosystem (Luck and others 2001) and for whole-city flux assemblage, its drivers, and its consequences should Moving Towards a New Urban Systems Science facilitate fundamental advances in our ability to sumption, decomposition, nutrient cycling) in understand and predict the structure and function these novel ecosystems will produce fundamental of ecosystems in a rapidly changing world. information on fluxes of carbon, water, and nutri- In addition to terrestrial environments, urban areas ents over large areas of the earth. However, also provide analogs—even harbingers—for aquatic understanding the dynamics of these systems from ecosystems of the future. The widespread ‘‘urban a theoretical and mechanistic perspective will be stream syndrome’’ that derives from the physical challenging. How will organisms that have not degradation of urban stream channels due to in- evolved together over long periods of time interact creased high flows (Walsh and others 2005) involves with the environment and each other to produce changes in nutrient loads and the presence of a wide functional