DOCSLIB.ORG

Letter to Clearwater County

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Letter to Clearwater County June 22, 2017 Clearwater County Attn: Eleanor Pengelly Development Officer 4340 – 47th Avenue Box 550 Rocky Mountain House, AB T4T 1A4 RE: Proposed Leavitt Gravel Pit (NW13 – 37 – 6 – W5) Dear Ms. Pengelly, Trout Unlimited Canada is a national conservation charity that is science-based and volunteer-driven. Partners and volunteers are paramount to the numerous successful river restoration projects we implement every year. Our work protects and enhances water quality, water flow, and aquatic community health. TUC is proud of the critical role our organization has played in the protection of Canada’s natural resources for over 40 years and the value of this work to the lives of Canadians. We recently became aware of the above referenced Proposed Development within Clearwater County by Border Paving Ltd. to develop and operate a wet/dry gravel pit and associated activities including end pit lakes, near the headwaters of the North Raven River (Stauffer Creek). The North Raven River is known as one of the most stable and valuable spring-fed trout fisheries in central Alberta. It is estimated that approximately 2,500 anglers visit the region every year. This brings revenue to local communities in gear purchases, fuel, lodging and other tourism-related dollars which depends on this healthy river and its sustained, constant and cold groundwater flows. It is ultimately a highly sustainable, renewable resource that will continue to provide social and economic benefits as long as it is maintained. Trout Unlimited Canada, along with Alberta Conservation Association and Alberta Fish and Game Association are co-owners of the nearby Stainbrook Springs Conservation Site (SW19-37-05-W5) and the Leavitt Conservation Site (NW17-37-5-W5). Stainbrook Springs and Leavitt, located along the North Raven River, were purchased and are managed to protect the numerous headwater springs which are vital for maintaining the stable, coldwater flows into the North Raven River that support this fishery. Our organization, members, partners, and supporters have invested millions of dollars and countless hours of volunteer time and effort to restore and protect this fishery and this is widely considered an impressive success story in terms of stream restoration and sportfishery improvement. We are concerned about potential impacts from gravel extraction on the groundwater resources that feed the North Raven River. In their application package, Border Paving’s drainage map shows surface water flows off the property towards the northeast; groundwater very likely flows in the same direction. Excavations below the water table in such close proximity to the headwater springs could seriously impair the health of the system by negatively affecting the water quality and flow. The potential impacts Trout Unlimited Canada (403) 221-8360 1 (800) 909-6040 180-2880 Glenmore Trail SE, Calgary AB, T2C 2E7 from the proposed gravel pit would be absolutely counter to the gains made by years of dedicated conservation and restoration efforts. An additional groundwater study should be completed by Border Paving before a development permit is considered. A hydrogeological study should show the volume, temperature, and direction of groundwater in relation to the North Raven River. Additionally, the location of the proposed pit between the Clearwater River and North Raven River, and proximity to the Clearwater River could increase the risk of a flood event resulting in an inter-basin transfer from the North Saskatchewan River basin to the Red Deer River basin through the North Raven River. This has been identified as a concern in the past, particularly following flooding in 2005 and 2007. Please feel free to contact us if you require further information including scientific papers on the impacts of aggregate extraction below the water table. We look forward to your response on this issue. Sincerely, Lesley Peterson, B.Sc., P.Biol. Provincial Biologist, Trout Unlimited Canada CC: Clearwater County Staff: Marshall Morton - Director, Public Works Clearwater County Council: Reeve: Honourable Mr. Patrick Alexander Councillor Mr. Jim Duncan Councillor Mr. Kyle Greenwood Councillor Mr. Curt Maki Councillor Mr. John Vandermeer Councillor Ms. Teresa Laing Councillor Mr. Earl Graham Alberta Conservation Association – Mr. Todd Zimmerling, President and CEO Alberta Fish and Game Association – Mr. Martin Sharren, Executive Vice President Alberta Environment and Parks – Terrina Perley Trout Unlimited Canada (403) 221-8360 1 (800) 909-6040 180-2880 Glenmore Trail SE, Calgary AB, T2C 2E7 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Fisheries Barriers in Native Trout Drainages
    Alberta Conservation Association 2018/19 Project Summary Report Project Name: Fisheries Barriers in Native Trout Drainages Fisheries Program Manager: Peter Aku Project Leader: Scott Seward Primary ACA Staff on Project: Jason Blackburn, David Jackson, and Scott Seward Partnerships Alberta Environment and Parks Environment and Climate Change Canada Key Findings • We compiled existing barrier location information within the Peace River, Athabasca River, North Saskatchewan River, and Red Deer River basins into a centralized database. • We catalogued fish habitat and community data for the Narraway River watershed for use in a population restoration feasibility framework. • We identified 107 potential barrier locations within the Narraway River watershed, using Google Earth ©, which will be refined using valley confinement modeling and validated with ground truthing in 2019. Introduction Invasive species pose one of the greatest threats to Alberta native trout species, through hybridization, competition, and displacement. These threats are partially mediated by the presence of natural headwater fish-passage barriers, namely waterfalls, that impede upstream 1 invasions. In Alberta, several sub-populations of native trout remain genetically pure primarily because of waterfalls. Identification and inventory of waterfalls in the Peace River, Athabasca River, North Saskatchewan River, and Red Deer River basins isolating pure populations and their habitats is critical to inform population recovery and build implementation strategies on a stream by stream basis. For example, historical stocking of non-native trout to the Narraway River watershed may be endangering native bull trout and Arctic grayling. Non-native cutthroat trout, rainbow trout, and brook trout have been stocked in the Torrens River, Stetson Creek, and Two Lakes, all of which have connectivity to the Narraway River.
    [Show full text]
  • Water Storage Opportunities in the South Saskatchewan River Basin in Alberta
    Water Storage Opportunities in the South Saskatchewan River Basin in Alberta Submitted to: Submitted by: SSRB Water Storage Opportunities AMEC Environment & Infrastructure, Steering Committee a Division of AMEC Americas Limited Lethbridge, Alberta Lethbridge, Alberta 2014 amec.com WATER STORAGE OPPORTUNITIES IN THE SOUTH SASKATCHEWAN RIVER BASIN IN ALBERTA Submitted to: SSRB Water Storage Opportunities Steering Committee Lethbridge, Alberta Submitted by: AMEC Environment & Infrastructure Lethbridge, Alberta July 2014 CW2154 SSRB Water Storage Opportunities Steering Committee Water Storage Opportunities in the South Saskatchewan River Basin Lethbridge, Alberta July 2014 Executive Summary Water supply in the South Saskatchewan River Basin (SSRB) in Alberta is naturally subject to highly variable flows. Capture and controlled release of surface water runoff is critical in the management of the available water supply. In addition to supply constraints, expanding population, accelerating economic growth and climate change impacts add additional challenges to managing our limited water supply. The South Saskatchewan River Basin in Alberta Water Supply Study (AMEC, 2009) identified re-management of existing reservoirs and the development of additional water storage sites as potential solutions to reduce the risk of water shortages for junior license holders and the aquatic environment. Modelling done as part of that study indicated that surplus water may be available and storage development may reduce deficits. This study is a follow up on the major conclusions of the South Saskatchewan River Basin in Alberta Water Supply Study (AMEC, 2009). It addresses the provincial Water for Life goal of “reliable, quality water supplies for a sustainable economy” while respecting interprovincial and international apportionment agreements and other legislative requirements.
    [Show full text]
  • Land Use, Climate Change and Ecological Responses in the Upper
    Land use, climate change and ecological responses in the Upper North 1 Saskatchewan and Red Deer River Basins: A scientific assessment Land use, climate change and ecological responses in the Upper North Saskatchewan and Red Deer River Basins: A scientific assessment Dan Farr, Colleen Mortimer, Faye Wyatt, Andrew Braid, Charlie Loewen, Craig Emmerton, Simon Slater Cover photo: Wayne Crocker This publication can be found at: open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460140697. Comments, questions, or suggestions regarding the content of this document may be directed to: Ministry of Environment and Parks, Environmental Monitoring and Science Division 10th Floor, 9888 Jasper Avenue NW, Edmonton, Alberta, T5J 5C6 Tel: 780-229-7200 Toll Free: 1-844-323-6372 Fax: 780-702-0169 Email: [email protected] Media Inquiries: [email protected] Website: environmentalmonitoring.alberta.ca Recommended citation: Farr. D., Mortimer, C., Wyatt, F., Braid, A., Loewen, C., Emmerton, C., and Slater, S. 2018. Land use, climate change and ecological responses in the Upper North Saskatchewan and Red Deer River Basins: A scientific assessment. Government of Alberta, Ministry of Environment and Parks. ISBN 978-1-4601-4069-7. Available at: open.alberta.ca/publications/9781460140697. © Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Alberta, as represented by the Minister of Alberta Environment and Parks, 2018. This publication is issued under the Open Government Licence - Alberta open.alberta.ca/licence. Published September 2018 ISBN 978-1-4601-4069-7 Land use, climate change and ecological responses in the Upper North 2 Saskatchewan and Red Deer River Basins: A scientific assessment Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to the external reviewers for providing their technical reviews and feedback, which have enhanced this work.
    [Show full text]
  • South Saskatchewan River Basin Adaptation to Climate Variability Project
    South Saskatchewan River Basin Adaptation to Climate Variability Project Climate Variability and Change in the Bow River Basin Final Report June 2013 This study was commissioned for discussion purposes only and does not necessarily reflect the official position of the Climate Change Emissions Management Corporation, which is funding the South Saskatchewan River Basin Adaptation to Climate Variability Project. The report is published jointly by Alberta Innovates – Energy and Environment Solutions and WaterSMART Solutions Ltd. This report is available and may be freely downloaded from the Alberta WaterPortal website at www.albertawater.com. Disclaimer Information in this report is provided solely for the user’s information and, while thought to be accurate, is provided strictly “as is” and without warranty of any kind. The Crown, its agents, employees or contractors will not be liable to you for any damages, direct or indirect, or lost profits arising out of your use of information provided in this report. Alberta Innovates – Energy and Environment Solutions (AI-EES) and Her Majesty the Queen in right of Alberta make no warranty, express or implied, nor assume any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information contained in this publication, nor that use thereof infringe on privately owned rights. The views and opinions of the author expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of AI-EES or Her Majesty the Queen in right of Alberta. The directors, officers, employees, agents and consultants of AI-EES and the Government of Alberta are exempted, excluded and absolved from all liability for damage or injury, howsoever caused, to any person in connection with or arising out of the use by that person for any purpose of this publication or its contents.
    [Show full text]
  • North Saskatchewan River Drainage, Fish Sustainability Index Data Gaps Project, 2015
    North Saskatchewan River Drainage, Fish Sustainability Index Data Gaps Project, 2015 The Alberta Conservation Association is a Delegated Administrative Organization under Alberta’s Wildlife Act. North Saskatchewan River Drainage, Fish Sustainability Index Data Gaps Project, 2015 Mike Rodtka, Chad Judd and Andrew Clough Alberta Conservation Association 101 – 9 Chippewa Road Sherwood Park, Alberta, Canada T8A 6J7 Report Editors PETER AKU KELLEY KISSNER Alberta Conservation Association 50 Tuscany Meadows Cr. NW 101 – 9 Chippewa Rd. Calgary, AB T3L 2T9 Sherwood Park, AB T8A 6J7 Conservation Report Series Type Data ISBN: 978-0-9949118-3-4 Disclaimer: This document is an independent report prepared by Alberta Conservation Association. The authors are solely responsible for the interpretations of data and statements made within this report. Reproduction and Availability: This report and its contents may be reproduced in whole, or in part, provided that this title page is included with such reproduction and/or appropriate acknowledgements are provided to the authors and sponsors of this project. Suggested Citation: Rodtka, M., C. Judd, and A. Clough. 2016. North Saskatchewan River drainage, Fish Sustainability Index data gaps project, 2015. Data Report, D-2016-105, produced by Alberta Conservation Association, Sherwood Park, Alberta, Canada. 17 pp + App. Cover photo credit: David Fairless Digital copies of conservation reports can be obtained from: Alberta Conservation Association 101 – 9 Chippewa Rd. Sherwood Park, AB T8A 6J7 Toll Free: 1-877-969-9091 Tel: (780) 410-1998 Fax: (780) 464-0990 Email: [email protected] Website: www.ab-conservation.com i EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Alberta Environment and Parks Fish Sustainability Index is a standardized process of assessment that provides a landscape-level overview of fish sustainability within the province and enables broad-scale evaluation of management actions and land-use planning.
    [Show full text]
  • Water Quality in the South SK River Basin
    Water Quality in the South SK River Basin I AN INTRODUCTION TO THE SOUTH SASKATCHEWAN RIVER BASIN I.1 The Saskatchewan River Basin The South Saskatchewan River joins the North Saskatchewan River to form one of the largest river systems in western Canada, the Saskatchewan River System, which flows from the headwater regions along the Rocky Mountains of south-west Alberta and across the prairie provinces of Canada (Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba). The Prairie physiographic region is characterized by rich soils, thick glacial drift and extensive aquifer systems, and a consistent topography of broad rolling hills and low gradients which create isolated surface wetlands. In contrast, the headwater region of the Saskatchewan River (the Western Cordillera physiographic region) is dominated by thin mineral soils and steep topography, with highly connected surface drainage systems and intermittent groundwater contributions to surface water systems. As a result, the Saskatchewan River transforms gradually in its course across the provinces: from its oxygen-rich, fast flowing and highly turbid tributaries in Alberta to a meandering, nutrient-rich and biologically diverse prairie river in Saskatchewan. There are approximately 3 million people who live and work in the Saskatchewan River Basin and countless industries which operate in the basin as well, including pulp and paper mills, forestry, oil and gas extraction, mining (coal, potash, gravel, etc.), and agriculture. As the fourth longest river system in North America, the South Saskatchewan River Basin covers an incredibly large area, draining a surface of approximately 405 860 km² (Partners FOR the Saskatchewan River Basin, 2009). Most of the water that flows in the Saskatchewan River originates in the Rocky Mountains of the Western Cordillera, although some recharge occurs in the prairie regions of Alberta and Saskatchewan through year-round groundwater contributions, spring snow melt in March or April, and summer rainfall in May and early July (J.W.
    [Show full text]
  • Northern Leopard Frog Recovery Program
    Northern Leopard Frog Recovery Program Year 5 (2003) Kris Kendell In cooperation with: Northern Leopard Frog Recovery Program Year 5 (2003) This publication may be cited as: Kendell, K. 2004. Northern leopard frog recovery program: Year 5 (2003). Unpublished report, Alberta Conservation Association, Edmonton, AB. 14 pp. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS....................................................................................................... iv EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................ v 1.0 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 1 2.0 STUDY AREA ......................................................................................................................... 2 2.1 Egg mass collection and frog release sites........................................................................ 2 2.2 Captive rearing site ........................................................................................................... 2 3.0 METHODS ............................................................................................................................... 3 3.1 Captive rearing.................................................................................................................. 3 3.2 Marking............................................................................................................................. 3 3.3 Release (2003) .................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Angling Opportunities
    Angling Opportunities North Raven River and Raven River Conservation-minded landowners and Alberta Conservation Association (ACA) have worked to improve the habitat surrounding and within the North Please remember to: Raven River and Raven River. These efforts have not only benefited wildlife populations, but also improved fish habitat creating a world-class brown • Stay within the fenced areas indicated trout fishery. Participating landowners have signed habitat lease agreements on the included maps. If you wish to go granting reasonable public access to the rivers to increase angling outside the fenced habitat opportunities in the area. Agreements include improvement projects such as lands, please use respect off-site watering systems, wildlife-friendly exclusion fencing, bioengineering and contact the respective projects, and tree planting. To help the public access the rivers for their landowner first. enjoyment, ACA has provided landowner contact requirements and maps • Obey all signage, do not block gates, illustrating public access points and boundaries. Landowners reserve the and park safely. Leave all gates as you right to refuse access to any person for any reason at any time. found them. Many landowners also own livestock so please be aware. Other significant stretches of these rivers are managed by ACA through our Land Management Program. These ACA conservation sites have also been • Follow all Alberta fishing regulations. included on the maps, where contact is not needed for use. Please refer to the Alberta Discover Guide for access conditions or restrictions. • Pack out what you pack in. All users accessing these properties do so at their own risk. All corridors are foot access only, day use only, and no open fires are allowed.
    [Show full text]
  • SOURCE WATER QUALITY PRIMER Red Deer River Municipal Users Group October 2016
    SOURCE WATER QUALITY PRIMER Red Deer River Municipal Users Group October 2016 SOURCE WATER QUALITY PRIMER Red Deer River Municipal Users Group October 2016 This report was written by Bill Shaw, FCIP, RPP of BPS Consulting Ltd for the Red Deer River Municipal Users Group. The cover photograph is the North Raven River, a tributary of the Raven River which is a tributary of the Red Deer River. The restoration and protection of the riparian lands along this famous trout stream is one of Alberta’s most successful riparian management programs. It was accomplished through the efforts of the Alberta Government (at the time Fish and Wildlife), Clearwater County and the many cooperating landowners and farmers along the stream. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY only 2 of the15 subwatersheds received a rating of “A” (good) - Panther, Alkali. These are at the most upper and lower Maintaining source water quality in the Red Deer River system portions of the watershed. Eight received a rating of “B” is an integral part of the Red Deer River Municipal Group’s (medium) - James, Raven, Little Red Deer, Waskasoo, Threehills, (RDRMUG) strategic goal to secure sufficient water to support Rosebud, Berry, Matzshiwin, and the remaining five received a sustainable communities. rating of “C” (poor) - Medicine, Blindman, Buffalo, Kneehills, Michini) (see Map 5). The main characteristics contributing to Source water is any untreated water found in rivers, streams, poor rating were linear development densities, resource reservoirs, lakes and aquifers used for the supply of raw water exploration and extraction activities, nutrient concentrations in for drinking water systems and for use by industries, irrigators surface water and land conversion activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Water Quality in the North Saskatchewan River (NSR) in the Last 60 Years Has Undergone Some Substantial Changes
    North Saskatchewan River Water Quality By: Steph Neufeld, M.Sc., Watershed Specialist, EPCOR Water Services Biography Steph Neufeld was born and raised on a farm near the McLeod River where she spent many summer days and nights on her banks or navigating through her waters. She completed both her undergraduate and masters degrees at the University of Alberta. Her M.Sc. degree investigated the effects of landuse change on water quality and aquatic insect communities in Alberta streams. After graduation, Steph worked in consulting as an Aquatic Biologist for several years and currently works as a Watershed Specialist for EPCOR Water Services where her focus is on drinking water source water protection and watershed management. She presently sits on the Integrated Watershed Management Plan steering committee for the North Saskatchewan Watershed Alliance, is president of the Alberta Lake Management Society, and a board member for RiverWatch. Abstract Water quality in the North Saskatchewan River (NSR) in the last 60 years has undergone some substantial changes. Water quality monitoring was first initiated in the 1940s in response to pollution problems in the NSR associated with the City of Edmonton. At that time municipal wastewater, which included domestic sewage and industrial wastes, received only primary treatment. Untreated sewage was discharged directly into the river during rainfall events, garbage was disposed along the river bank, and accidental oil spills at industrial sites were not uncommon. With these pressures, it is not surprising that water quality was poor. These conditions persistent until about 1960 when waste management was improved and flow‐ regulation by the newly constructed Brazeau dam increased winter flows and assimilation capacity during this critical time.
    [Show full text]
  • Water and Energy in the North Saskatchewan River Watershed
    IntegratedIntegrated WatershedWatershed ManagementManagement PlanningPlanning forfor thethe NorthNorth SaskatchewanSaskatchewan RiverRiver BasinBasin Presented to AlbertaAlberta HealthHealth SeptSept 17,17, 20092009 OutlineOutline WaterWater forfor LifeLife (2003)(2003) NSWANSWA functionfunction WatershedWatershed PlanningPlanning InitiativesInitiatives LakeLake ManagementManagement ChallengesChallenges WaterWater forfor LifeLife (2003)(2003) OutcomesOutcomes:: ¾ SafeSafe drinkingdrinking waterwater ¾ HealthyHealthy aquaticaquatic ecosystemsecosystems ¾ ReliableReliable waterwater suppliessupplies KeyKey DirectionsDirections:: ¾ KnowledgeKnowledge andand researchresearch ¾ WaterWater conservationconservation ¾ PartnershipsPartnerships forfor watershedwatershed managementmanagement andand stewardshipstewardship WaterWater forfor LifeLife RenewalRenewal (2008)(2008) Nov.Nov. 16,16, 20082008 MinsterMinster RennerRenner confirmsconfirms originaloriginal WFLWFL outcomesoutcomes andand keykey directionsdirections WPACWPAC rolerole inin watershedwatershed assessmentassessment andand planningplanning rere-- confirmedconfirmed WatershedWatershed PlanningPlanning AdvisoryAdvisory CouncilsCouncils NineNine WPACsWPACs havehave beenbeen Hay River watershed appointedappointed inin AlbertaAlberta • MandateMandate:: Peace River Watershed Athabasca River ¾¾StateState ofof thethe Watershed WatershedWatershed ReportsReports Lesser Slave Lake Watershed Council Beaver River ¾¾IntegratedIntegrated WatershedWatershed Watershed Alliance North Saskatchewan
    [Show full text]
  • Alberta Census Subdivisions and Provincial Electoral Districts
    Alberta Electoral Districts and N O R T H W E S T T E R R II T O R II E S Census Subdivisions Kakisa River Buchan Charles Lake Lake 225 Beatty Lake Charles Lake e o tl l t r i fa Legend L f e u iv Thebathi B R Bistcho 196 Pet Provincial Electoral District boundary (2010) itot Riv er Lake r e iv R lo Wood Buffalo Census Subdivision (2011) a ff National Park u B of Canada !( City !( Town Improvement District No. 24 r e !( iv Wood Buffalo Village R y a H Slave Summer Village River k Indian Reserve Mackenzie County k Indian Settlement Upper Hay r Allison Lake Athabasca River 212 e v i R Bay 219 National Park e c a e Provincial Park Hay Lake Margaret P 74 Lake Zama Peace River Lakes Lake Hay Lake Baril Rivers 209 Lake Lake Claire Alberta Main Roads Child John d'Or Lake Prairie 215 Mamawi 164A Lake Hay River Rainbow Beaver Lake Ranch 163 Fox High r Lake ve Ri h Level Bushe Boyer 162 rc Coordinate System: NAD 1983 10TM AEP Forest Bi Projection: Transverse Mercator River 164 Fort Old 207 Vermilion Fort 217 Datum: North American 1983 173B 0 20 40 80 120 Tall Kilometers Cree 59 Chinc haga River 173A Fort ´ !( McMurray-Wood r Tall Buffalo e v i Cree R a r c 173 e s v Northern i River a a b R kw Mik a a Lights h c t s A County a Namur b a W River 174A Wood !( Buffalo Legend Lake Namur Fort 37 Edmonton-Manning Lake 174B Mackay 48 Notikewin 58 Athabasca-Sturgeon-Redwater Clear Fort ST.
    [Show full text]