Ice Patches As Archeological and Paleoecological Data in Climate
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FINAL REPORT TO GLACIER NATIONAL PARK: ICE PATCHES AS SOURCES OF ARCHEOLOGICAL AND PALEOECOLOGICAL DATA IN CLIMATE CHANGE RESEARCH Complied by Robert L. Kelly, co-PI Craig M. Lee, co-PI RM-CESU Cooperative Agreement Number: H1200090004 (IMR) RM-CESU agreement #UWY-126 (2010) RM-CESU agreement #UWY-151 (2011) RM-CESU agreement #UWY-165 (2012) CU-Boulder Projects: Project 1548139, Awards: P11AC90625, P11AT00120, UCOB-80 Project 1548257, Awards: P11AC90615, P11AT00080, UCOB-82 Project 1548299, Awards: P11AC90650, P11AT10248, UCOB-85 Project 1549287, Award: P12AC10324, UCOB-94 Project 1550820, Award: 1001202 Scientific Research and Collecting Permit: GLAC-2010-SCI-0163 September, 2017 i Executive Summary Climate change is melting ice in America’s national parks and forests. Newly exposed artifacts and natural items with unique scientific and cultural value are threatened by destruction through accelerated taphonomic processes and inadvertent loss, e.g., unauthorized collection. Glacier National Park’s (GNP) alpine regions have long been important to the Salish, Kootenai, and Blackfeet. The Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes (CSKT), Blackfeet Nation (BN), and researchers from the University of Wyoming and University of Colorado at Boulder partnered in an unprecedented collaboration to develop and implement protocols for culturally appropriate scientific methods to recover and protect endangered objects. The protocol is an important resources and was shared with numerous parks as well as the park service’s Intermountain Region and Washington, DC office. Traditional Native uses of alpine areas were researched and a plan for Native American burials (in the event of a discovery) was developed; however, no burials or human remains were encountered. Student and tribal crews conducted three seasons of fieldwork in alpine and subalpine areas of the park in the late summers of 2010, 2012, and 2013, surveying 25 ice patches. No artifacts were located, but paleobiological specimens (e.g., wood, non-human bone) were collected and analyzed. In addition, the project cored an ice patch (Siyeh Pass), which produced evidence that the park’s ice patches had significantly retreated or even disappeared between 6000 and 7000 years ago. Skeletal remains of a bison (Bison bison) recovered at one of the ice patches were radiocarbon dated to 1000- years-old and the mtDNA signature of the specimen was added to a growing database of bison aDNA. Extant aerial images of ice patches in GNP obtained by the US Geological Survey in 1998 were orthorectified for comparison with modern extents, and now provide a data point for the park, CSKT and BN to monitor climate change at GNP ice patch locations in the future. Additionally, oblique aerial images of several ice patch targets were acquired in 2015. Results of the project, have been shared through papers and presentations in professional meetings and public outreach venues. A video conveying tribal perspectives on the impacts of alpine climate change to Native peoples, was shared at “Frozen Pasts: The 3rd International Glacial Archaeology Symposium” and is available with additional content through an interactive website developed by the project (www.glaciericepatch.org). ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank the Culture Committees of the Salish, Pend d’Oreille, and Kootenai Tribes, as well as the Blackfeet Nation, for their support of and participation in our work in Glacier National Park. We thank the Park Service and Glacier National Park in particular for their unflagging efforts to support our collective endeavor. Our work in Glacier National Park was financially supported by the National Park Service’s Climate Change Response Program, as well as by Glacier National Park. An incomplete list of individuals who helped with aspects of the project includes, Blackfeet Nation: John Murray, Carol Murray, Joe Riviera and Greg Hall; Confederated Salish Kootenai Tribe (CSKT): Kevin Askan, Francis Auld, Clarinda Burke, Rosemary Caye, Mike Durglo, Sr., Pete Gillard, Marcia Pablo, Ira Matt, David Rockwell, Don Sam, Dave Schwab, Frank Tyro, and Martin Zobel; National Park Service: Lon Johnson, Sierra Mandelko, John Kinsner, Deirdre Shaw, Leigh Welling, Melanie Wood, and Alexander J.S. New; Rocky Mountain Cooperative Ecosystem Studies Unit: Tom Fish, Kathy Tonnessen, and Pei-Lin Yu; University of Colorado Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research: Joan Eaton, Sedrick Frazier, Julie Hughes, Catherine Larkins, Leanne Lestak, Lindsay McCandless, and William Manley; USGS: Dan Fagre and Lisa Mckeon; University of Wyoming: Rick Weatherman, Rachel Reckin, and Claren Copp-Larocque; University of Wisconsin-Madison Ice Drilling Design and Operations: Kristina Dahnert and Jay Kyne. Wood collected was identified by Kathryn Puseman with preliminary identifications by Rick Weathermon and Claire Alix. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary …………………………………………………………………………..ii Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................. iii Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1 Glacier Cultural Resource Management Group (CRMG) .................................................... 3 Project Objectives ................................................................................................................. 4 Project Infrastructure ............................................................................................................ 5 Principal Investigators (PI’s) ............................................................................................ 5 Tribal Expertise ................................................................................................................. 5 Government Expertise ...................................................................................................... 5 Project Deliverables Completed ........................................................................................... 5 Fieldwork .................................................................................................................................. 6 Ice Patch Identification ......................................................................................................... 6 USGS Image Orthorectification & Refined Ice Patch Identification ................................... 7 Pedestrian Survey ................................................................................................................. 7 Survey Results ................................................................................................................ 10 Ice Patch Coring .............................................................................................................. 12 Ice Patch Extent Analysis ................................................................................................... 17 Aerial Survey .................................................................................................................. 20 Project Video and Website...................................................................................................... 20 Project Recognition ................................................................................................................. 21 Dissemination ......................................................................................................................... 22 Management Recommendations ............................................................................................. 23 References ............................................................................................................................... 25 Appendix A: Glacier Cultural Resource Management Group (CRMG) Appendix B: Annual Letter Reports, 2010—2013 Appendix C: Blackfeet Ethnographic Report (Maria Nieves Zedeño) Appendix D: Bison Genetics Report (Beth Shapiro) Appendix E: Contact Sheets, Kestrel Aerial Services Oblique Ice Patch Photos Appendix F: Advice for Inadvertent Discoveries Appendix G: Ice Patch photos, 2010, 2012, 2013. iv LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: QGIS Orthorectification Bundle Blocks ......................................................................... 8 Figure 2: Peak snowfall levels for Flattop Mountain SNOTL, which served as a proxy for snow levels in the Park during the project; the winter of 2010/2011 was the third highest snow year logged at the Flat Top Mountain SNOTEL (https://www.nwrfc.noaa.gov/snow/snow_peak_hist.php?id=FTMM8) .................................. 9 Figure 3: Location of archeological site in Red Eagle Pass. On right, site is located in foreground; left shows a portion of the trail where material was exposed. … ....................... 10 Figure 4: Calibrated (OxCal, IntCal13) 14C dates (N = 37) from Glacier National Park (paleobiological material, no artifacts) ……………………………………………….11 Figure 5: The ‘PrairieDog’, a Double-Barreled Torsion Stem Drill (adapted from Kyne and McConnell 2007). ................................................................................................................... 14 Figure 6: Siyeh Pass Ice Patch with coring locations, facing S. ................................................... 15 Figure 7: Graph of Siyeh Ice Patch Lags and 14C dates. ............................................................... 16 Figure 8: Ice patch margin at GLAC 30 (Red Eagle Pass) recorded by GPS during pedestrian survey on September 5, 2012 overlain