An Astronomical Approach
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Archaeoastronomy in the 1990s ARCHAEOASTRONOMY IN THE 1990s Papers derived from the third ‘Oxford’ International Symposium on Archaeoastronomy, St. Andrews, U.K, September 1990. Edited by CLIVE L.N. RUGGLES School of Archaeological Studies University of Leicester United Kingdom iv Archaeoastronomy in the 1990s Published by Ocarina Books Ltd. 27 Central Avenue, Bognor Regis, West Sussex PO21 5HT United Kingdom http://www.ocarinabooks.com First published by Group D Publications Ltd. 1993 First electronic edition 2014 Copyright © 2014 by Ocarina Books Ltd All rights reserved. Publisher’s note. This e-book has been regenerated from the original Word Processor files and by digitizing the original drawings and photographs. This process has resulted in some minor changes in formatting from the original edition, but many figures are now of improved quality, including a number in colour. British Library Cataloguing–in–Publication data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 978–0–9540867–4–9 (Ebook) Contents Preface ix Dedication xi List of contributors xii 1 Introduction: Archaeoastronomy—the way ahead. Clive Ruggles 1 I: Thematic contributions 2 Archaeoastronomy in the Americas since Oxford 2. Anthony F. Aveni 15 3 Space, time and the calendar in the traditional cultures of America. Stephen C. McCluskey 33 4 Some social correlates of directional symbolism. Stanisław Iwaniszewski 45 II: New horizons 5 Moon Man and Sea Woman: the cosmology of the Central Inuit. Susan M. Pearce 59 6 Time-reckoning in Iceland before literacy. Thorsteinn Vilhjálmsson 69 vi Archaeoastronomy in the 1990s 7 The geometry of pastoral stone octagons: the Basque sarobe. Roslyn M. Frank and Jon D. Patrick 77 8 The moon and Indo-European calendar structure. Emily Lyle 92 9 Some remarks on the moon cult of Teutonic tribes. Emília Pásztor 98 10 Astronomical knowledge in Bulgarian lands during the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age. Tsvetanka Radoslavova 107 11 Four approaches to the Borana calendar. Clive Ruggles 117 12 Astronomy in the ancient written sources of the Far East. Ildikó Ecsedy and Katalin Barlai 123 13 Orientations of religious and ceremonial structures in Polynesia. William Liller 128 14 Aboriginal sky-mapping? Possible astronomical inter- pretation of Australian Aboriginal ethnographic and archaeological material. Hugh Cairns 136 III: New techniques, methods and approaches 15 Basic research in astronomy and its applications to archaeoastronomy. Bradley E. Schaefer 155 16 A method for determining limits on the accuracy of naked-eye locations of astronomical events. Rolf M. Sinclair and Anna Sofaer 178 17 An integrated approach to the investigation of astronomical evidence in the prehistoric record: the North Mull project. Clive Ruggles and Roger Martlew 185 18 The astronomy and geometry of Irish passage grave cemeteries: a systematic approach. Jon D. Patrick 198 IV: Continuing research: new results 19 Sun and sun serpents: continuing observations in south-eastern Utah. Carol W. Ambruster and Ray A. Williamson 219 Contents vii 20 The origin and meaning of Navajo star ceilings. Von Del Chamberlain and Polly Schaafsma 227 21 Organisation of large settlements of the northern Anasazi. John McKim Malville and James Walton 242 22 Summer solstice: a Chumash basket case. Edwin C. Krupp 251 23 Counting and sky-watching at Boca de Potrerillos, Nuevo León, Mexico: clues to an ancient tradition. Wm. Breen Murray 264 24 Venus orientations in ancient Mesoamerican architecture. Ivan Šprajc 270 25 Mesoamerican geometry combined with astronomy and calen- dar: the way to realise orientation. Franz Tichy 278 26 Mesoamerican cross-circle designs revisited. Stanisław Iwaniszewski 288 27 Were the Incas able to predict lunar eclipses? Mariusz S. Ziółkowski and Arnold Lebeuf 298 28 Callanish: maximising the symbolic and dramatic potential of the landscape at the southern extreme moon. Margaret Curtis and Ronald Curtis 309 29 The Bush Barrow gold lozenge: a solar and lunar calendar for Stonehenge? Archibald S. Thom 317 30 New evidence concerning possible astronomical orientations of ‘Tombe di Giganti’. Edoardo Proverbio 324 V: Education and dissemination 31 An image database for learning archaeoastronomy. Clive Ruggles 335 Appendix: Abstracts of papers published in the companion Oxford 3 volume ‘Astronomies and cultures’ 343 Index 350 The conference logo depicts a version of the glyphic element often referred to as the ‘St. Andrews Cross’, fre quently found in celestial bands and forming part of the Mayan sky glyph ca(a)n. A similar design dates back to Olmec times. Preface The third ‘Oxford’ international conference on archaeoastronomy was held in St. Andrews, Scotland, in September 1990. The ‘Oxford’ confer ences, held at approximately four-yearly intervals, have aimed to provide a truly interdisciplinary focus on the study of astronomical practice in its cultural context, as well as a forum for discussing issues of theory and method. ‘Oxford 1’, held in 1981, was notable for bringing together, for the first time in substantial numbers, archaeoastronomers from the Old and New Worlds, as well as bringing face to face two very different methodological approaches, refected in the contents of the two volumes arising from the Oxford 1 conference (Heggie 1982; Aveni 1982). Over the decade since Oxford 1, the scope and variety of cultural investi gations involving astronomy has increased widely. ‘Oxford 2’ held in Mérida, Mexico in 1986 (Aveni 1989), and now ‘Oxford 3’, have demon strated the substantial progress that has been made in building bridges between the diversity of academic disciplines which have an interest in, and must inevitably be involved in, the study of astronomy in culture. A further set of issues was raised at Oxford 3 involving the relation ship of archaeoastronomy to the mainstream of its parent, or constituent, disciplines. It is clear that if archaeoastronomy is not to remain an ‘island discipline’, then communication between archaeoastronomy and these mainstream disciplines is of critical importance. It was with a view to en suring that archaeoastronomers do not merely communicate amongst themselves that two separate volumes of papers were planned to arise out of the contributions at Oxford 3. This, the first, is a volume of conference papers intended primarily for an ‘internal’ readership within the archaeo astronomical community. The second contains ten longer review papers, specially selected from contributions at Oxford 3, and is aimed at a wider readership. x Archaeoastronomy in the 1990s ‘Archaeoastronomy in the 1990s’ contains 31 papers covering a wide variety of current research topics in archaeoastronomy. Further details are given in the introduction which follows. The companion Oxford 3 volume, ‘Astronomies and Cultures’, aims to give an overview both of the scope of archaeoastronomy and of the broad range of problems being addressed within it. It is published by the University Press of Colorado, PO Box 849, Niwot, Colorado 80544, USA. Abstracts of the papers contained there are given in the Appendix of the current volume. The editor wishes to express his gratitude to the many people who made Oxford 3 possible, most notably Aubrey Burl, Michael Hoskin and Nicholas Saunders for their work within the National Organising Com mittee, and Tristan Platt for his work as local organiser. Special and warm thanks are due to the late Douglas Gifford, whose enthusiasm and foresight made the conference possible at St. Andrews. The conference is grateful to the British Academy and the British Council for financial support. References Aveni, A. F., ed. (1982). Archaeoastronomy in the New World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Aveni, A. F., ed. (1989). World archaeoastronomy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Heggie, D. C., ed. (1982). Archaeoastronomy in the Old World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Dedication The interval between Oxford 2 and Oxford 3 has witnessed the passing of Horst Hartung, a pioneer in the interdisciplinary field of archaeoastron omy. From his beginnings as an engineer (Diploma in Engineering, Stutt gart, 1948; Doctor of Engineering, Stuttgart, 1971) he became Professor of Pre-Columbian Architecture and Urbanism and a member of the Faculty of Architecture in the University of Guadalajara. What is little known to his academic colleagues is that Horst also was a practising modern architect of considerable skill and reputation. An early guiding inspiration to all archaeoastronomers was induced by a note from one of Hartung’s papers that read: ‘Astronomers might be able to find out whether the orientations and directions that are noted are related to any astronomical events’ (Centro de Investigaciones Históricas y Estéticas, Universidad Central boletín 11 (1969), 127–37; my trans lation from the Spanish). Horst had the wisdom to follow up his own suggestion and as a result he produced more than three dozen papers as well as a co-authored monograph and book. Beginning with an early interest in site planning and settlement patterns, Hartung recognised in his earliest publications, dating from the 1960s, that it would be possible to frame purposive hypotheses to explain the often unusual situation and orientation of certain ensembles of Pre- Columbian buildings. Among the interesting factors he brought into play were the sky and landscape surrounding the ceremonial centre. This led to an interest in particular specialised buildings that may have been designed deliberately for