DOCSLIB.ORG

Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics in the Light of Recent Achievements Konrad Bleuler Institut Für Theoretische Kernphysik, Universität Bonn

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics in the Light of Recent Achievements Konrad Bleuler Institut Für Theoretische Kernphysik, Universität Bonn Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics in the Light of Recent Achievements Konrad Bleuler Institut für Theoretische Kernphysik, Universität Bonn Z. Naturforsch. 45a, 1051-1058 (1990); received December 26, 1989 Dedicated to Hans-Peter Dürr on the occasion of his 60th birthday W. Heisenberg's unconventional - at his time even revolutionary - ideas on "elementary" particles are reviewed - or, better, rediscovered - within the framework of present day gauge- and string- theories. I. Looking back at a period long past, i.e. more than atmosphere and the outer space) by Pacini, Piccioni four decades ago, unforgettable hours of private dis- and Conversi (difficult to pronounce - the third name cussions with Werner Heisenberg come back to my was usually replaced by "Conversly" - and even more mind: I now realize that his then perfectly new physi- difficult to understand) had clearly shown that the cal ideas which, at that time, were not really appreci- then well-known cosmic ray particles (later on called ated, acquire by now, i.e. if re-interpreted in the light muons), whose mass and creation cross sections were of recent and breathtaking developments, a perfectly apparently in accordance with Yukawa's famous pre- new and unexpected physical meaning. In other diction, did, however, not exhibit the expected rela- words: Heisenberg's original principles [1] - if re- tively large absorption cross section as foreseen formulated within the framework of present day new through a most elementary quantum-mechanical and far reaching mathematical concepts and experi- argument. mental achievements - represent, in fact, an intuitive After a few months of questioning and discussions, insight into a future theory long before time was ready Occhialini's wonderful combined photographic plates for its implementation. It thus seems to me that the (exposed to the Bristol cyclotron) definitly showed sixtieth birthday of Hans-Peter Dürr, one of Heisen- that the particles produced in the highest layer of the berg's most devoted collaborators and successors, is the atmosphere by cosmic protons (very much in the same right moment to recall - in particular for a younger way as in a cyclotron) exhibit, in fact, a spontaneous generation - the story of that fascinating period of decay in flight long before they interact with matter on scientific doubts and struggles leading to the creation the earth, i.e. the photographic plates at "Piano of particle physics of our time, e.g. gauge- and string- Cervino". The decay of these new particle, i.e. the true theories, which appears in a way to be guided - as we Yukawa-particles (by now called pions) into the par- will see in these short and imcomplete lines - by ticles observed in cosmic rays (i.e. the muons) with Heisenberg's intuitions, or even visions, if I might be slightly lower mass and (observed) small interaction allowed to say so. cross section, immediately solved all contradictions. Instead of expounding on the (at that time lengthy II. Let me just start with a lecture of Heisenberg discussed and, in fact, evident) solution of this prob- which I occasionally heard as early as 1946 just after lem, Heisenberg took a quite unexpected and, for that the important, even decisive discovery (by Occhialini) time, perfectly new attitude: He nicely drew a vertical of the pion, i.e. the particle theoretically foreseen by line on the blackboard indicating with dots the various Yukawa. It appeared - at that time - to be a real mass values of the then known particles (i.e. electron, relevation, and the solution of an apparently clear-cut muon, proton, etc.) and thereupon frankly decleared: contradiction: The famous experiment at "Piano Cervino" (the laboratories of that time were the high "Look here, there is, by now, another dot, i.e. another mass value (that of the pion) or, much Reprint requests to Prof. K. Bleuler, Institut für Theoretische better, another spectral line of a (most probably) Kernphysik, Nussallee 14-16, D-5300 Bonn. infinite mass-spectrum, which has to be - and this 0932-0784 / 90 / 0800-1051 S 01.30/0. - Please order a reprint rather than making your own copy. Dieses Werk wurde im Jahr 2013 vom Verlag Zeitschrift für Naturforschung This work has been digitalized and published in 2013 by Verlag Zeitschrift in Zusammenarbeit mit der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft zur Förderung der für Naturforschung in cooperation with the Max Planck Society for the Wissenschaften e.V. digitalisiert und unter folgender Lizenz veröffentlicht: Advancement of Science under a Creative Commons Attribution Creative Commons Namensnennung 4.0 Lizenz. 4.0 International License. 1052 K. Bleuler • Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics 1052 was the decisive point - re-interpreted as a spec- early period) which might have led Heisenberg to trum of energy eigenvalues of a still unknown these general ideas which intuitively foreshadowed 'Hamiltonian' or, better, unknown quantum- the future: Having worked in almost all important mechanical system." domains (as easily seen from the enormous list of his publications), he might have realized that practically This fundamental assumption [1] exhibits, first of all physical domains of research (molecules, atoms, all, according to Einstein's well-known principle, the nuclei, etc.) appear to be characterized by a system of unification of the two different - but equivalent - spectra, however, spectra of very different magnitudes forms of energy, namely mass- and field-energies. As and different physical significancies. On the other seen from a more physical, i.e. empirical viewpoint, hand, they definitely exhibit very similar general prop- this principle immediately explains naturally the ap- erties (e.g. their general characterisation through the parent irregularly or, better, non-triviality of this underlying symmetry group with the corresponding mass-spectrum in perfect analogy to all well-known representations) and are, from the physical side, based examples of eigenvalue-spectra. The same holds for - in each case - on a characteristic and more or less the characteristic assignments of spin, isospin, etc. basic interaction or, better, interacting field, between which are, in principle, perfectly analogous in the two the elementary constituents (e.g. phonon exchange be- cases, i.e. particles and eigenstates. On the other side, tween the (conduction-) electrons in normal supercon- this new - by now perhaps evident - viewpoint leads ductors; chemical forces (i.e. exchange-terms) in to the elimination (at least to a large extent) of the molecular band spectra; the electromagnetic force "beloved" concept of elementarity in particle physics (i.e. photon exchange) in the case of atomic spectra which, however, was still to survive - especially in the and, finally, the so-called nuclear forces (e.g. meson- perfectly unjustified case of hadrons - for many years. exchange) in nuclear spectra. III. The major aim of this (by far too short) contri- It thus seemed natural that a perfectly new and bution is, in fact, to show that this principle, stated by basic (so far unknown) field was definitely needed for Heisenberg at a period too early to be fully imple- generating this new particle spectrum, a quest appear- mented, mainly because of lack of a few decisive em- ing, however, strange to most physicists of that time. pirical facts, represents in retroperspective the guide- In view of our analogy one should have introduced, line of all later research up to our days and might, in fact, two fields describing a new kind of basic parti- therefore, righteously be called a scientific vision. On cles interacting in turn through another new field. the other side, its explicit realization through later Heisenberg, oversimplifying things, introduced, or, research looked rather different, i.e. by far more com- better, "invented" one single spinorial field endowed, plex or, better, by far more spectacular (and, in a way, however, with a self-interaction, i.e. in field theoretical not to be foreseen nor expected) than Heisenberg orig- terms, a field satisfying a non-linear field equation [2]. inally might have assumed [2]. As fas as the special choice of this field equation was In fact, present-day non-abelian gauge theories [3], concerned, he invoked general invariance principles as in particular QCD, fulfill - as we will see - Heisen- well as simplicity. In order to describe special massless berg^ principle in an enlarged sense, and I would like particles, he suggested (this, again, was new and un- to maintain that even latest theoretical attempts to- conventional !) the possibility of degenerate vacuum wards an all englobing basic theory, i.e. the so-called states (by now this idea is well established; but it was strings [4], should be seen under this same aspect. If we terribly criticized at his time) and the corresponding include, for the time being, this - rather problematic - massless Goldstone particles. second step, it may be realized that Heisenberg's quest for a complete elimination of the conventional particle V. Without going (for this moment) into further concept (to be replaced by "geometry", i.e. an enor- details, e.g. the unfortunate German expression mously enlarged Eigenvalue problem!) appears to be "Urfeld" (for the new field) with its philosophical satisfied (cp. the Appendix). touch and a definitely too simplifying single (but non- linear) field equation, let us jump over two, maybe IV. Before engaging, however, into these far-reach- three decades of misunderstandings (with even tragic ing and basic questions, let us try to reconstruct the consequences) and state at once the present-day arguments (within the scientific framework of that achievements: As a first step, we thus describe the K. Bleuler • Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics 1053 theory of hadrons, by now based on QCD: It exempli- which appears to be a typical consequence of the non- fies in a most striking form Heisenberg's general prin- linearity, again corresponds, in a way, to one of ciples mentioned above: Heisenberg's general hypotheses, which states that these new basic fields might no longer be interpreted 1.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Quantum Field Theory
    Quantum Field Theory Priv.-Doz. Dr. Axel Pelster Department of Physics Lecture in Winter Term 2020/2021 Kaiserslautern, February 12, 2021 Preface The present manuscript represents the material of the lecture Quantum Field Theory, which I held as part of the Master of Science in Advanced Quantum Physics program at the Depart- ment of Physics of the Technische Universit¨atKaiserslautern during the winter term 2020/2021. Due to the Corona pandemic the 28 lectures were both live streamed and recorded. The cor- responding videos are available at the platform Panopto at the national network of the state Rhineland Palatinate. After each lecture both the corresponding hand-written notes as well as this manuscript were made available to the students. The presented material is partially inspired by former lectures of Prof. Dr. Ulrich Weiß at the Universit¨atStuttgart from I which benefitted during my own physics study. And I had the pleasure to learn from the lectures of Prof. Dr. Hagen Kleinert at the Freie Universit¨atBerlin during my postdoc time, when I supervised the corresponding exercises. The manuscript is mainly based on the two valuable books: W. Greiner and J. Reinhardt, Field Quantization, Springer, 2008 • H. Kleinert, Particles and Quantum Fields, World Scientific, 2016 • which I recommend for self-study. Additional useful information, partially including historical insights, can be found in the following selected books: J. Gleick, Genius - The Life and Science of Richard Feynman, Vintage Books, 1991 • W. Greiner, Relativistic Quantum Mechanics - Wave Equations, Springer, 2000 • W. Greiner and J. Reinhardt, Quantum Electrodynamics, Springer, 2008 • W. Greiner and J.
    [Show full text]
  • Geometric Approaches to Quantum Field Theory
    GEOMETRIC APPROACHES TO QUANTUM FIELD THEORY A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Science and Engineering 2020 Kieran T. O. Finn School of Physics and Astronomy Supervised by Professor Apostolos Pilaftsis BLANK PAGE 2 Contents Abstract 7 Declaration 9 Copyright 11 Acknowledgements 13 Publications by the Author 15 1 Introduction 19 1.1 Unit Independence . 20 1.2 Reparametrisation Invariance in Quantum Field Theories . 24 1.3 Example: Complex Scalar Field . 25 1.4 Outline . 31 1.5 Conventions . 34 2 Field Space Covariance 35 2.1 Riemannian Geometry . 35 2.1.1 Manifolds . 35 2.1.2 Tensors . 36 2.1.3 Connections and the Covariant Derivative . 37 2.1.4 Distances on the Manifold . 38 2.1.5 Curvature of a Manifold . 39 2.1.6 Local Normal Coordinates and the Vielbein Formalism 41 2.1.7 Submanifolds and Induced Metrics . 42 2.1.8 The Geodesic Equation . 42 2.1.9 Isometries . 43 2.2 The Field Space . 44 2.2.1 Interpretation of the Field Space . 48 3 2.3 The Configuration Space . 50 2.4 Parametrisation Dependence of Standard Approaches to Quan- tum Field Theory . 52 2.4.1 Feynman Diagrams . 53 2.4.2 The Effective Action . 56 2.5 Covariant Approaches to Quantum Field Theory . 59 2.5.1 Covariant Feynman Diagrams . 59 2.5.2 The Vilkovisky–DeWitt Effective Action . 62 2.6 Example: Complex Scalar Field . 66 3 Frame Covariance in Quantum Gravity 69 3.1 The Cosmological Frame Problem .
    [Show full text]
  • Arxiv:2011.03527V1 [Hep-Th] 12 Oct 2020 Uaino Eszmn W)Mdl1,Aconformal a of Model[1], Structure (WZ) Wess-Zumino of Mulation Does There and Partner
    Supersymmetry in Hadron Spectroscopy and Solitons in 2 Dimensional Fermionic Media Sadataka Furui (Formerly) Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Teikyo University; [email protected] (Dated: November 9, 2020) An overview of hadron spectroscopy obtained from an extension of superconformal field theory of de Alfaro, Fubini and Furlan, which originates from the supergauge transformation of Wess and Zumino and influenced on the string theory are preseted. The standard model of hadron dynamics is based on gauge theory. In the 4 dimensional (4D) QCD Lagrangian, the Faddeev-Popov ghost that appears to compensate unphysical degrees of freedom in internal fermion propagators can be regarded as the partner of a fermion. Donaldson formulated a 5D gauge theory. Fubini and Rabinovici formulated superconformal quantum mechanics in de Sitter space, and Brodsky and de T´eramond formulated relativistic light front holographic QCD (LFHQCD) in Kaluza-Klein type 5D anti de Sitter (AdS) space, using Dirac’s light cone gauge, and succeeded in obtaining spectroscopy of baryons (fermions) and corresponding mesons (bosons), except the pion which is an axial scalar meson that remains massless. In the LFHQCD, the time parameter τ = t z/c, (z C) appears by the choice of the light-cone gauge, or the front form of Dirac’s formulation.± The theory∈ is an extension of AdS/CFT correspo- dence of Maldacena in which incorporation of Einstein’s gravity theory in Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory was tried in the framework of the string theory. Taking mathematical frameworks of treating the supersymmetry by Brodsky, Witten, Connes and their collaborators as central thema, we summarize other supersymmetric approaches like string theory in particle physics and astrophysics.
    [Show full text]
  • Drawing Theories Apart: the Dispersion of Feynman Diagrams In
    Drawing Theories Apart Drawing Theories Apart The Dispersion of Feynman Diagrams in Postwar Physics david kaiser The University of Chicago Press chicago and london David Kaiser is associate professor in the Program in Science, Technology, and Society and lecturer in the Department of Physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago 60637 The University of Chicago Press, Ltd., London C 2005 by The University of Chicago All rights reserved. Published 2005 Printed in the United States of America 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 1 2 3 4 5 isbn: 0-226-42266-6 (cloth) isbn: 0-226-42267-4 (paper) Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kaiser, David. Drawing theories apart : the dispersion of Feynman diagrams in postwar physics / David Kaiser. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn 0-226-42266-6 (alk. paper)—isbn 0-226-42267-4 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Feynman diagrams. 2. Physics—United States—History— 20th century. 3. Physics—History—20th century. I. Title. QC794.6.F4K35 2005 530.0973 0904—dc22 2004023335 ∞ The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of the American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1992. He teaches his theory, not as a body of fact, but as a set of tools, to be used, and which he has actually used in his work. John Clarke Slater describing Percy Bridgman after Bridgman won the Nobel Prize in Physics, 11 January 1947 Contents Preface and Acknowledgments xi Abbreviations xvii Chapter 1 .
    [Show full text]
  • Dirac: a Scientific Biography in Geneva, Bringing His Wife and Two Children with Him
    Dirac A SCIENTIFIC BIOGRAPHY HELGE KRAGH CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Published by the Press Syndic:a1e or the Uaiversity ol Cambridge The Pin Building, Tru~ton Streec, Cambridge CB2 1RP 40 West200l Slrl:el, New York. NY 10011-4211. USA 10 Stamford Road, Oakleigh, Victoria 3166, Australia 0 Cambridge Uaiversity Press 1990 First published 1990 Reprinted 1991, 1992 Printed in the Uaited Stales of America Ubrary of Congress Clllaloging-in-Publiwtion Data Kragh, Helge, 1944- Dirac : a scientific biography I He1ge Kragh. P. em. Bibliography: p. Includes indexes. ISBN M21-38089-8 I. Dirac, P. A.M. (Paul AdrieD Maurice), 1902- 2. Physicists- Great Britaia - Biography. I. Tille. DCI6.051K73 1990 530'.092- dc20 [B) 89-17257 CIP ISBN 0.521-38089-8 hardback TO BODIL CONTENTS Preface page lX I. Early years 2. Discovery of quantum mechanics 14 3. Relativity and spinning electrons 48 4. Travels and thinking 67 5. The dream of philosophers 87 6. Quanta and fields 118 7. Fifty years of a physicist's life 151 8. ''The so-called quantum electrodynamics" 165 9. Electrons and ether 189 10. Just a disappointment 205 II. Adventures in cosmology 223 12. The purest soul 247 13. Philosophy in physics 260 14. The principle of mathematical beauty 275 Appendix I. Dirac bibliometrics 293 Appendix II. Bibliography of P. A. M. Dirac 304 Notes and references 315 General bibliography 364 Index of names 383 Index ofsubjects 387 vii PREFACE NE of the greatest physicists who ever lived, P. A. M. Dirac 0 ( 1902-84) made contributions that may well be compared with those of other, better known giants of science such as Newton, Maxwell, Einstein, and Bohr.
    [Show full text]
  • A Closer Look at Gluons 3
    A Closer Look at Gluons 1 Chapter 6 ACLOSER LOOK AT GLUONS Sadataka Furui* (formerly) Teikyo University, Graduate School of Science and Engineering Utsunomiya, Tochigi, Japan Abstract: Gluons are strong interaction gauge fields which interact between quarks, i.e. constituents of baryons and mesons. Interaction of matters is phenomenologically described by gauge theory of strong, electromagnetic, weak and gravitational interactions. In electro- weak theory, left handed leptons lL and neutrino νL, right handed leptons lR and left handed quarks u , d and right handed quarks u , d follow SU(2) U(1) symmetry. Charge of L L R R × leptons and quarks define hypercharge Y , and via Higgs mechanism SU(2) U(1) L × Y symmetry forms U(1)em symmetry. Presence of J P = 3/2+ baryons, or N ∗++ uuu suggests a new degree of free- ∼ dom “color” for quarks, which follows SU(3) symmetry group. Hence the gluon fields are expressed as a where a = 1, 2, , 8 specify the color SU(3) bases, and µ are 4- Aµ · · · dimensional space-time coordinates. The quantum electrodynamics was extended to quan- tum chromo dynamics (QCD). Since ∂µ a is not a free field, the gauge theory requires Aµ ghosts that compensates unphysical degrees of freedom of gluons. Gluons, ghosts, leptons and quarks are related by Becchi-Rouet-Stora -Tyuitin (BRST) transformation of electro- weak and strong interaction of the U(1) SU(2) SU(3) symmetric Faddeev-Popov × × Lagrangian. In order to describe Hadron dynamics properly, embedding of 4-dimensional space to 5-dimensional space was tried in lattice simulations, and in light front holographic QCD (LFHQCD) approach in which conformally symmetric light-front dynamics without ghost are embedded in AdS5, and a parameter that fixes a mass scale was chosen from the Prin- ciple of Maximum Conformality.
    [Show full text]
  • Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics in the Light of Recent Achievements Konrad Bleuler Institut Für Theoretische Kernphysik, Universität Bonn
    Werner Heisenberg's Ideas on Particle Physics in the Light of Recent Achievements Konrad Bleuler Institut für Theoretische Kernphysik, Universität Bonn Z. Naturforsch. 45a, 1051-1058 (1990); received December 26, 1989 Dedicated to Hans-Peter Dürr on the occasion of his 60th birthday W. Heisenberg's unconventional - at his time even revolutionary - ideas on "elementary" particles are reviewed - or, better, rediscovered - within the framework of present day gauge- and string- theories. I. Looking back at a period long past, i.e. more than atmosphere and the outer space) by Pacini, Piccioni four decades ago, unforgettable hours of private dis- and Conversi (difficult to pronounce - the third name cussions with Werner Heisenberg come back to my was usually replaced by "Conversly" - and even more mind: I now realize that his then perfectly new physi- difficult to understand) had clearly shown that the cal ideas which, at that time, were not really appreci- then well-known cosmic ray particles (later on called ated, acquire by now, i.e. if re-interpreted in the light muons), whose mass and creation cross sections were of recent and breathtaking developments, a perfectly apparently in accordance with Yukawa's famous pre- new and unexpected physical meaning. In other diction, did, however, not exhibit the expected rela- words: Heisenberg's original principles [1] - if re- tively large absorption cross section as foreseen formulated within the framework of present day new through a most elementary quantum-mechanical and far reaching mathematical concepts and experi- argument. mental achievements - represent, in fact, an intuitive After a few months of questioning and discussions, insight into a future theory long before time was ready Occhialini's wonderful combined photographic plates for its implementation.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 8 Maxwell Field
    Chapter 8 Maxwell Field All electrodynamic processes are described by the Maxwell equations. Surprisingly they repre- sent the equations of motion of afirst-quantized theory, although the Planck constant ¯h does not appear explicitly. This apparent contradiction is resolved by the following consideration. If the quanta of the Maxwellfield, i.e. the photons, had afinite rest massM, then it would appear due to dimensional reasons together with spatio-temporal derivatives as a mass term in the equations of motion in form of the inverse Compton wave length (7.21). Thus, performing the limit of a vanishing rest mass, i.e.M 0, also the Planck constant ¯h vanishes automatically → from the respective equations of motion. In this chapter wefirst review the relativistic covariant formulation of thisfirst-quantized Maxwell theory. Afterwards, we invoke the canonicalfield quantization formalism and work out systematically the second quantization of the Maxwell theory. In particular, we have to deal with the intricate consequences of the underlying local gauge symmetry, which is due to the vanishing rest mass of the quanta of the Maxwellfield. In this way we determine step by step the respective properties of a single photon as, for instance, its energy, its momentum, and its spin. Finally, we discuss the photon propagator, which represents an important building block in the Feynman diagrams of quantum electrodynamics describing the interaction between light and matter. 8.1 Maxwell Equations Forces of an electromagneticfield upon electric charges, which are at rest or move, are mediated by both the electricfield strengthE and the magnetic inductionB. Physically both vector fields are generated by the charge densityρ and the current densityj.
    [Show full text]