sign in sign up
<<
Home , Landscape design, Landscape planning, Residential community

of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/ Element

COMMUNITY DESIGN ELEMENT

PURPOSE

The purpose of the Community Design Element is to set forth fundamental concepts and principles that will assure the highest possible quality of life, guiding and directing the physical design and development of the City of Palm Desert. In this regard, the element is intended to encourage creativity and design excellence in community design and development, which results in a community that is attractive, cohesive and in harmony with the natural setting and surrounding . Furthermore, the Community Design Element proposes design concepts and principles that enhance the community’s functional characteristics, to create a more livable, efficient and .

The Community Design Element helps the City examine current patterns of development, and identifies the City's challenges, resources, and opportunities for enhanced community design. The element also sets forth a and conservation ethic that is integral to protecting the City's most important and valuable characteristics. The goals, policies and programs bring together the principals of other elements into an overall set of qualitative guidelines that help enhance community connectivity, preserve the natural environment and improve the quality of living for all residents and visitors. They provide guidance to enhance the appearance of existing and new commercial and industrial development, residential neighborhoods, streets, public facilities, and parks and open spaces. The element is also intended to promote a more sustainable and healthy community.

BACKGROUND

The Community Design Element is interactive with and responsive to several other elements of the General Plan, including Land Use, Circulation, Open and Conservation, Parks and Recreation, and Arts and . The Community Design Element addresses the fundamental issues of these other elements and combines these ideas in a single element. The Community Design Element is effective when the management of land use, traffic, community safety and appearance, and environmental systems promotes continuity, uniqueness and a special sense of place. On a more basic , the Community Design Element reflects sensitivity to community quality, environmental integrity and a desire to preserve the best qualities of this resort residential community, while addressing the more practical and functional needs of it’s residents, businesses and visitors.

The state of California recognizes the necessity of standards in community design and development in Government Code and regulations. Government Code Section 65302 states that, “the General Plan shall consist of a statement of development policies and shall include diagram or diagrams and text setting forth objectives, principles, standards and plan proposals.” Government Code Section 65302(a) addresses standards that affect population density and building intensity. Mandates for the preservation of open space lands are set forth in Government Code sections 66477 and 65470.

Community Design Element III-135 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

State legislation also reinforces the adoption of community design standards. The 1990 California Legislature enactment of Assembly Bill 325, the Water Conservation In Act, recognizes the state’s responsibility in mitigating the effects of on its finite water resources, and the potential savings from water conserving practices. In accordance with the act, the City has adopted a water conserving landscape ordinance, which meets conservation targets and addresses community design concerns. Water conservation in is having a profound effect on community design.

By implementing the essential goals and policies of the Community Design Element the City confirms its support for sustaining and enhancing the quality of life and the built environment in the City. In addition to staff-level implementation of community design standards, the Architectural Review Board Commission, Commission and review and approve public and private development design proposals. Environmentally and aesthetically sensitive design is essential to the preservation and enhancement of the character and values of the community. Controlling the type and intensity of land uses, managing transportation, flood control facilities, and protecting community open space and conservation areas must compliment both the built and natural environments.

The Resort Community: A Tale of Two

Not all segments of the community will measure quality of life by the same yardstick. Developments and neighborhoods in Palm Desert can be divided into two types, A) residential and hotel resorts that serve the tourist, vacation and second home markets, and B) developments and neighborhoods that are geared to the City's permanent population. Many of the needs and community design issues of each differ, while others are common concerns of all facets of the community.

Vacationers and Seasonal Residents Residential resorts and vacation-oriented developments serve seasonal residents (snow birds) and short-term visitors. These developments range from gated golf course communities to timeshare and hotel-based resorts typically with their own golf and other recreational amenities. Seasonal residents and visitors to these developments are focused on vacationing and relaxation in a tranquil and largely self-contained environment, and do not typically involve themselves in the full range of community activities. Therefore, the internal relationships within these developments are more important than their relationship to some of the City's commercial , institutions, parks and open space, and other public facilities. Seasonal residents in the destination resort communities are typically less interested in engaging in the external neighborhoods of the general community. Nonetheless, the quality, attractiveness and safety of the community have a direct effect on the desirability of Palm Desert as a destination second home and tourist resort.

Permanent Resident Community Permanent residents benefit from the full range of commercial, institutional and recreational services and opportunities available in the City. These include the many services and uses enjoyed by the City's vacationers and seasonal residents, including fine dining, specialty retail, entertainment, golf and other recreational amenities.

Community Design Element III-136 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Permanent residents are the core of the community and typically live in neighborhoods where knowing and interacting with neighbors is the essence of a tight-knit community. Ideally, permanent residents, including families with children, should have a reasonable expectation of safe and convenient access to parks, shopping and other community services and amenities without the need to travel great distances or to rely primarily on the arterial roadway network.

Community Design and Quality of Life

The essential purpose or goal of effective community design is to assure the highest possible quality of life for the City's residents, whether part- or full-time, and for those who come to visit and vacation here. Community design issues encompass all aspects of the City, including its residential and commercial neighborhoods. Properly designed and integrated neighborhoods include a diverse cross section of the community and provide convenient opportunities for social interaction between residents. They are also small enough and have a sufficient level of interconnectivity to retain a distinct neighborhood identity. Creating and sustaining distinct neighborhoods is essential to the concept of community.

In general terms, quality of life can be addressed by assuring the following:

• An integrated community with a full range of housing, shopping and commercial services, work places, schools, parks and open space, and civic and institutional facilities essential to the daily life of the residents

• A land use pattern that efficiently distributes homes, employment centers, parks, schools and other institutions, shopping and services

• A logical and efficient hierarchy of streets that are part of a connected network, which disperses traffic by providing a variety of pedestrian and vehicular routes to any destination

• A distributed system of physical and service infrastructure that provides for the efficient delivery of utilities and public services

SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITY DESIGN

The concept of sustainable communities has only emerged fully in the last decade and still has many definitions and meanings. From an economist's perspective, sustainable community design is a means of ensuring the maintenance of our standard of living and quality of life. From an ecological perspective, sustainability involves a holistic view of the physical environment that includes not only humanity but also the physical and ecological context in which we are embedded. The sustainable community is integrated with its environment in a manner that optimizes its maintenance over time.

Major elements of the sustainable community include environmental health, energy efficiency, land use relationships and efficiencies, resource use and management, and efficient traffic and circulation. Economic vitality is also a primary component of sustainable quality of community design.

Community Design Element III-137 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Community Design Principles for a Sustainable Quality of Life

Some of the existing patterns of urban and suburban development can seriously impair our quality of life. The symptoms include traffic congestion and air pollution, the loss of open space, the need for costly improvements to roads and public services, the inequitable distribution of economic resources, and the loss of a sense of community by , disconnectedness and socio-economic isolation. Some of the fundamental principals that can help assure sustainable quality of life include the following:

A. A balanced and integrated community providing safe and convenient access on local streets and containing a diversity of housing, shops, work places, schools, parks and civic facilities.

B. A community with a diversity of housing types, sizes and affordability that serves residents from a wide range of economic levels and age groups.

C. A sufficiently diverse local economy that provides a range of sustainable employment opportunities for the community’s residents.

D. Centers of community focus that combine residential, commercial, civic, cultural and recreational uses.

E. Public spaces that encourage the congregation and interaction of people from all walks of life and at all hours of the day and night.

F. Streets, pedestrian paths and bike paths that provide fully connected and interesting routes to all destinations, encouraging pedestrian and bicycle use and optimizing safe integration with vehicular traffic.

G. A community plan that preserves natural terrain, drainage, and vegetation of the community within parks, greenbelts and community open space areas.

H. Community, development and that conserves energy and material resources, optimizes the efficient use and recycling of water, encourages use of drought tolerant landscaping and minimize waste.

I. Siting, design and orientation of buildings that contributes to the optimal seasonal use and avoidance of solar energy, enhances natural ventilation, and reduces overall energy demand.

Community Design Element III-138 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Regional Design Principles

In addition to those principles that should guide community planning and development, additional principles that address regional issues are also important. This is especially true in the Coachella Valley where urban development and jurisdictional boundaries are largely contiguous and interact with one another. The following regional principles address regional interrelatedness.

A. Coordinate with CVAG in regional land use planning integrated within the larger transportation network built around major transit nodes and facilities, including bus routes, rail stations and freeway interchanges.

B. Coordinate to provide a continuous system of integrated ecosystems, open space and wildlife corridors based upon the conservation, preservation and restoration of local environments and habitats.

C. Encourage regional architectural styles and design concepts that encourage the development of local character and community identity, emphasizing the use of materials and methods of construction responsive to local conditions, and exhibiting continuity of history and culture, and compatibility with the physical and aesthetic environment.

Understanding and Integrating the Natural Environment

The natural environment of the Coachella Valley is the physical complex of geology, topography, climate and ecological resources. It is the "natural" setting of the City and has influenced how the community and the have developed. Designing within the parameters of the natural environment can pose several constraints and opportunities for devel- opment, which if managed wisely can and have enhanced the community's quality of life. For instance, flood control facilities primarily serve to control and convey storm runoff, but they also function as wildlife corridors and as open space for recreational activities, such as hiking, equestrian, biking and golf. Environmentally sensitive community planning also supports the use of open space buffers, building and landscape that conserve energy and water, recycling valuable resources, reducing exposure to toxic chemicals in the environment.

Community Design Element III-139 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Combined, these strategies value and preserve essential resources while expanding economic growth and opportunity; they can be characterized as being environmentally responsive. By practicing environmental responsiveness, it is possible for new development not only to minimize damage to the local ecosystem, but also to improve the surroundings. In fact, environmentally responsive development can serve as an "economic engine" for bringing about ecological restoration. This process of sitting lightly on the land, even when modifications to the landscape are made, is the essence of environmental responsiveness.

Harmonizing Community and Development Design

An essential aspect of community design involves harmonizing new land uses and developments with the existing built and natural environments. Design strategies can allow the City to retain the low intensity resort-residential community character in new development, even in areas where higher development densities are realized. Sensitivity to height limits, using natural materials, and complementary colors and tones for building surfaces, and the generous integration of open space into community design are in keeping with the essential character of the community.

Flexibility and sensitive design evaluation, and the ability to see the positive qualities of various architectural styles are also essential to a responsive process. If quality design is lacking and cannot be secured from the developer or architect, then unsatisfactory development proposals should not be approved. Sensitive design harmonizes with surrounding buildings and the environment, avoids excessive disruption and does not overtly compete for attention.

Contrasting design approaches should avoid being abrasive and seek a civilized and lively integration with the existing and planned development environment. It is equally important not to homogenize the design elements of a neighborhood, leaving it a boring repetition of elevations, rooflines and building materials and colors, or to promote an eclectic and unrelated collection of styles.

Community Design and Continuity

Community design, cohesiveness and continuity require a holistic community vision while maintaining and preserving the City's unique and cherished qualities. This perspective also recognizes the characteristics that have been handed down overtime, and that create connections to the natural and historic features of the City.

Continuity provides unity and stability to the community, and develops a sense of permanence and pride of place. In community design, this principle can be maintained through an adherence to quality land and site planning and architectural styles, an integration of desert landscaping, preservation of open space land and valuable natural resources, and the development of functional circulation patterns. Community design and continuity not only strengthen the City, but also help to establish meaningful relationships between the City's built environment, its residents and its natural environment.

Community Design Element III-140 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Establishing a Sense of Place

Establishing a sense of place, or , is an important dimension of sustainability and community design that enhance the quality of life. People need to feel attachment for a place in order to invest themselves in the community. To foster a sense of place, communities must cultivate built environment and settlement patterns that are enriching and uplifting, inspirational and memorable, and which create a feeling of belonging and attachment. A sense of place can also be nurtured by understanding and respecting the bioregional context of the community, including the climate and , open space lands, and native flora and fauna. Placemaking in community design also respects the history and character of existing and man-made features that have added to the familiarity of the place.

Lastly, placemaking requires that a special effort be made to create and preserve places, rituals and events that encourage greater attachment to and cohesiveness of the social fabric of the community. This can be attained with the development of gathering spots and public places, such as the Civic Center Park, as powerful focal points within the community, and by planning activities that promote community attachment and social interaction.

COMMUNITY FORM AND DESIGN PLANNING

The assessment of site planning and building design should determine the correlation between and influence of new and in-fill development to other structures and the environment; that is, the planning context must be fully considered. Careful consideration also needs to be given to the location and components of proposed development. Existing conditions should be a point of departure for area planning and design, optimizing possibilities while efficiently working around limitations. Planning and design criteria assist in determining a projects compatibility with the surrounding area. These criteria include:

* Planning Context Assessment * Site Analysis and Development Planning * Building Height * Building and Structural Setbacks * Proportions and Massing * Pattern and Rhythm of Structures * Roof Types and Materials

Community Design Element III-141 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

* Surface Color and Texture * Building Projections * Architectural Details * Landscape Design and Materials

Site Analysis and Development Planning

Understanding the natural conditions of the land through thoughtful site analysis must be the initial step in addressing development constraints and opportunities. This process is also essential in matching appropriate development with the characteristics of a site. On a landscape scale, this planning is embodied in the Land Use Element, while site specific analysis and planning are based upon the above-cited criteria. While land planning involves the consideration of area-wide elements, site planning primarily involves the distribution of buildings, parking, driveways and landscaped open space areas over a site. The development establishes the relationships between structures, parking and open space areas to the street and surrounding lands. The impacts of site design are not always easy to visualize and assess without the development of a detailed site plan. Frequently, the complexity or importance of a proposed development may warrant preparation of perspective renderings of the plan and structures.

Accurate representation of proposed future development can easily be accomplished through the use of inexpensive and powerful computer-based tools. Care should be taken not to allow artistic applications of color, landscaping and graphic “eye wash” to obscure or misrepresent the final built product. Together with building , site planning is the parameter determining the compatibility of proposed development with the existing development in the area and the character of the community.

Building Proportions, Height and Setbacks

Structures should be planned as integrated elements within the natural environment. This primacy is achieved by establishing guidelines for building scale and proportion, structure, height, and setbacks that are environmentally sound and sensitive.

Within the context of existing development and appropriate design, new structures should be similar in height to and compatible with other buildings in the vicinity, with the goal of preserving and enhancing design qualities of the built environment while maintaining important viewsheds. Assigned setbacks should be harmonious with the streetscape, surrounding structures and scenic resources. Variations in building massing are encouraged but should reflect a sense of compatibility as a group.

Building proportions should neither dominate the street nor other structures, and should limit the fragmentation of viewsheds to the greatest degree practical. New developments can establish an important baseline for a neighborhood and provide a model against which to judge subsequent proposed development. Occasionally, it may be appropriate for new development to be equivalent or subordinate to older structures and the prevailing development pattern. Generally, however, the height and width of building elevations should not be dramatically out of character with existing neighborhood development, the streetscape or natural scenic viewsheds.

Community Design Element III-142 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Pattern and Rhythm in Community Design

Nature provides varied examples of pattern and rhythm, which are instinctively pleasing and inspiring. These natural patterns can be emulated in community design, primarily expressed in the distribution of structures and the expression of building architecture. Roofline designs and the voids and solids of buildings can articulate the recurrent and alternating patterns of the surrounding landscape, including the slopes and peaks of the hills and mountains. The patterns and rhythms that result from new and existing development should create a theme that conveys harmony and coherence between structures and the natural environment. At the street level, the viewer should be provided an interesting and varied integration of structures, hardscape and landscaping that tie these elements together in an effective and pleasing manner.

Roof Types and Materials

The design of roofs and the selection of roofing materials is an essential design element that effects how well a building is integrated into its context. Roof types and materials can play a critical role in either complementing or degrading the cohesiveness of the built environment and the natural scenic viewshed. Roof types provide a variety of possibilities for contrasting or imitating other elements of the built or natural environment, and range from flat to a multiple array of hipped roofs. The same design criteria of scale, pattern and rhythm are applicable to judging the compatibility of roof design and materials. Excessive building height is frequently associated with the desire to create more volume within a building, to accentuate the building facade or to accommodate roof-mounted HVAC and other equipment. Roof design must be balanced with the building elevation it helps to create.

Color and Surface Texture The Coachella Valley is frequently associated with the sunny and bright conditions of the Mediterranean and these conditions make the selection of surface texture and color especially important. In recent years, surfaces and colors that emulate and complement the course and warm tones of the surrounding environment have become highly desirable. Shiny or highly reflective finishes produce glaring surfaces that do not complement or integrate well with the viewshed or are not pleasing to the eye. Important examples have emerged in the City of how contrast can be made compatible within broader standards through the juxtaposition of architectural motifs and the use of contrasting, unusual colors and building materials.

Community Design Element III-143 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

The surface textures of buildings and other structures differ from the patterns and rhythms of building volumes and spaces in that texture is provided on a substantially reduced scale and may not be evident from a distance. Texture seldom acts as a strong design element that is equal in visual effect to architectural pattern and massing. Over time, architectural tastes and styles change, and while the use of strong color can play a dominant role in the design of structures, color is easier to change once construction is completed. Building surface textures can range from smooth adobe-type stucco or plaster to fluted or split-faced concrete aggregate block. Texture must be carefully considered to assure that it complements the overall design while being compatible with other building materials.

Building Projections and Architectural Details

While the first and most essential concern of building design lies in the creation of interior space that serves the planned function of the building, the development of architectural style and detail should also be integral to design. The articulation of a selected style is expressed in the details and projections that grow out of the building and play important functional and aesthetic roles. Architectural projections and details can address issues of screening and privacy, while also affecting how well the building harmonizes with surrounding development.

Residential living space can be further enhanced through the use of porches and verandas that provide protection from sun and wind, while providing a venue for communication with passers-by and enhancing residential community cohesiveness. Architectural details, whether simple or ornate, may represent legitimate design principles, however buildings of differing architectural styles can clash or strongly contrast with surrounding development, and thereby may suffer from the comparison. Once again, the context of the building's built and natural environment must be carefully considered in determining the appropriateness of a particular architectural style.

Community Design Element III-144 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Landscape Design and Materials

Landscape design is an essential part of accomplishing quality community design and has a profound effect on the quality of life enjoyed in the community. Desert conditions require creative landscaping designs responsive to limited water resources and to the natural setting. The desert terrain includes a versatile collection of plant life that should be explored and employed in all scales of landscaping.

Rock and stone arrangements, fountains and other water features further enhance, complement and contrast with the native scenery. Proper requires special attention to the water needs and exposure of plantings, and the selection and cultivation of suitable plant materials. While are visually important, they can also create micro-climates providing protection from strong winds, shade from the intense summer sun, and reduced outdoor and indoor temperatures.

One of the most prominent and visible exterior features of neighborhoods, private communities and other developments is parkway landscape treatment. Design can range from the formal to the “natural” or combinations of both approaches. Formal design may include ordered rows of date palms or other distinctive trees, regularly interspersed with equally ordered shrubs and beds for annuals plantings.

Less informal designs seek to imitate nature by interspersing native and non- native desert plantings in more of a free-form or random pattern. Groupings of major elements and the use of lawn areas may also be integrated into both more and less formal designs. The need for progressive water conservation and control of landscape maintenance costs has also prompted the greater use of native and non- native drought-tolerant planting materials. The City has been a leader in the promotion of these desert landscape materials and design themes.

Residential Neighborhood Design

Residential neighborhoods are distinctly different from places where we work and shop, and should be viewed as refuges from the noise, light, traffic and commotion of City business districts. Nonetheless, the location of residential areas and their accessibility to neighborhood- serving commercial and community centers is also an important consideration. The push toward a more efficient use of residential lands has spurred development of higher density neighborhoods with integrated and well-distributed open space areas, narrower streets and an emphasis on walking and bicycling.

Community Design Element III-145 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

The cohesiveness of the neighborhood is substantially affected by the appropriateness and quality of architectural design. Architectural compatibility and variety can be established throughout the neighborhood through the coordinated and complementary use of various design components, including building colors, roof design and tile color, window and garage door treatment, and architectural building accents and details. These components should be mixed to create a balance of variety, compatibility and conformity or cohesion.

The City is host to numerous gated communities designed with walls and perimeter landscape treatments consisting of wrought iron, stuccoed concrete block, plain and painted slump stone, split-faced block, plastered, brick-capped or tile accented, and intermittent columns or pilasters. Walls may be straight, stepped or meandering. Interspersing solid walls with wrought iron fencing provides views into development open space areas and relieves the closed in feeling that walls can engender along roadways. While walls may vary in height, they are generally not to exceed six feet above .

In addition to closing off developments from the public right-of-way, continuous solid walls can create the above-mentioned canyon effect, while effectively mitigating the impacts of traffic noise on residential neighborhoods. Wider parkways provide additional wall set backs and landscape treatment that reduces the enclosed feeling. Wall breaks and fenestration along public rights-of-way help to integrate private community open space and viewsheds with those of the traveling public. The City should encourage the continued use of this type of viewshed window as a means of reducing the tunnel effect and preserving scenic vistas. Open Space and Parkland

Traditional suburban development typically divides land into a checkerboard layout of nearly identical residential lots with no designated open space. The result is a repetitive landscape of home lots and streets. This style of development, which is permitted by many local ordinances, can be inefficient and consumes open space and fragments wildlife habitat. However, by carefully clustering houses on smaller lots an efficient, conservation-oriented can provide the same number of buildable lots as a conventional subdivision and still preserve substantial open space.

This integrated planning approach not only reduces development costs by reducing the roads and utilities that must be built, it also helps foster a greater sense of community among residents. Walking paths and recreation areas get people out of their homes to meet neighbors and enhance neighborhood cohesiveness. Homeowners have smaller lots to care for and yet everyone shares attractive vistas and a community sense of spaciousness. Access to open space and conservation of habitat, scenic landscapes, ecologically valuable land and recreational areas are important components of livable communities and healthy economies.

Community Design Element III-146 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Landmarks and Focal Points

Other important elements of community include landmarks and focal points, which lend identity and character to the community. Landmarks or focal points may include natural, historic, architectural, or cultural areas of interest. Major entry points to the City and its neighborhoods also warrant special design consideration. The City's thematic entry signage program utilizing Arizona sandstone and Native American imagery complements the aesthetic and historic context of the community. The City has developed noticeable and distinctive transitions into the incorporated boundaries of the City and this concept is being extended into its neighborhoods. The provision of adequate area for significant landscape or architectural treatment, City entry signage, special paving, and other identifiable treatments all lend character and identity to City entry and other focus points.

Landscape architectural elements in the City include the Civic Center Park, which provides a public park environment and community gathering place profiling date gardens, , performance venues and the unique conditions of our desert environment. Landscaping elements, monumentation, sculpture, signage, site furnishings, and open space areas should all be considered in the development standards and policies for landmark or focal point enhancement.

Scenic Highways and Public Viewsheds

Scenic resources constitute some of the most important community assets of the City. Major scenic viewsheds include the San Jacinto, San Bernardino and other mountain ranges surrounding and encompassing the City, as well as the desert floor. Preservation of these scenic vistas has been an important goal of the community. However, various types of , the construction of buildings and walls, landscaping, roads and the extension of utility lines and other facilities have all impacted the scenic resources of the community. As viewed from public thoroughfares and private lands, the City’s natural scenic beauty provides residents and visitors with a direct experience of the dramatic landforms that define the character of the community. Promoting a quality image of Palm Desert is very much associated with the City’s viewsheds. Scenic resources are visible along essentially all major roadways in the City and its planning area.

Community Design Element III-147 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Signage and Viewsheds of Public Rights-of-Way

Commercial signage along major roadways provides important business identification but also can degrade the value of the viewshed along public rights-of-way. Balancing the needs of business with the importance of preserving scenic views in an on-going process. The City sign ordinance provides the standards, guidelines and regulations that strike this balance. In some instances it may be appropriate to encourage or require the retirement of existing signs that are inconsistent with the goals, policies and programs of the General Plan and applicable ordinances. Reducing the impacts of commercial signage can minimize the adverse economic impact on business, while assuring a restoration of the viewshed along existing and planned commercial corridors. Businesses located within Agency (RDA) project areas may be able to participate in and benefit from RDA sponsored sign renovation programs.

Transportation and Community Design

As the community continues to grow, it will continue to face a broad range of transportation- related community design issues. Design issues and details include street signage, bus turnouts and shelters, bike lanes and other on- road graphics, and utility structures and facilities. Roadway congestion and other deterrents to the efficient movement of goods and people can result from inadequate land use and . Providing an efficient network of arterial roadways will address area-wide and regional transportation needs, while protecting residential neighborhoods from through-traffic.

Pedestrian and other non-motorized movement must also be facilitated through the development of a continuous system of sidewalks and bike and cart paths that are designed and constructed to assure safety, while complementing the resort character of the community. Such facilities not only meet the needs and interests of the community, but also serve to facilitate the use of non- motorized transportation and will contribute, however modestly, to reducing roadway congestion.

Community Design Element III-148 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

A logical hierarchy of transportation corridors should be designed to link residential neighborhoods, public facilities and commercial areas. Street design must facilitate the movement of people and traffic sensibly. Improving roadways and local transportation systems can reduce traffic congestion and air pollutants. Street systems that assign all traffic through a limited number of intersections at the arterial streets should be avoided to reduce congestion and enhance roadway operations. More options in driving from one destination to another should be offered to motorists as a means of reducing congestion on arterial streets. Creating pedestrian- and-transit-friendly districts allows people to drive to their destination, park once and accomplish their business at multiple outlets.

Community Design in Public Facilities

In addition to the community design issues associated private residential, commercial and institutional projects, consideration of community design issues should also encompass public buildings, utilities, and street traffic control and safety devises that have the potential to detract from the appearance of the community. The attractiveness of the community is important to residents and visitors alike, and the City should consistently make the appearance of the City one of its highest priorities. Current efforts include the development of unique and distinctive desert landscape treatments on major roadways. Desert colors and tones can also be integrated into street signs, traffic signals and lighting standards to soften their impact on the surrounding viewshed.

The design of bus shelters has also been a City priority, with the construction of new facilities that are functionally superior and aesthetically pleasing. Bus shelters can utilize architectural styles that complement the streetscape treatment and elevate the appearance of these utilitarian structures. Utility cabinets located along the street, including traffic signal and telephone switching facilities, are frequently painfully obvious. Efforts to have these installed in underground vaults have been resisted but more success has been had with having these highly visible facilities painted more neutral desert colors. Likewise, overhead utility lines intrude on scenic viewsheds that can be minimized through the City's ongoing program of utility undergrounding.

Art in Public Places

More than any other city in the Coachella Valley, Palm Desert's art-in-public-places program has been an extremely successful enhancement to the attractiveness of the City, and provides significant opportunities to express and reinforce the diversity and cultural cohesion of the community. Consistent with the principle of a resort community that values its mountains and wild places, public art can also integrate native landscaping to reflect the surrounding mountains and desert dunes and washes. It can include the attentive design and placement of public buildings, as well as placement of manmade monumental sculpture on public lands, or within the rights-of-way of major roadways.

Community Design Element III-149 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

The City's Art in Public Places Program has been created in order to promote an aesthetic experience of the city, balancing the community’s physical growth and revitalization of its cultural and artistic resources. The community's aesthetic values are reflected in, and provide the basis for, cultural identification throughout the community’s planning efforts.

The Arts and Culture Element presents policies and programs that maximize the role the City can play in encouraging and supporting the cultural environment of the community. In addition to the direct support given to City-sponsored activities and facilities, the City can and should play an important role in helping to encourage and enhance the activities of public and private nonprofit enterprises supporting the arts. The purpose and intent of this involvement is to further a better understanding, appreciation and enjoyment of the cultural environment in the City.

University Park Planning Area: Putting It All Together

The City has created and has the opportunity to implement land use and development principles and plans that complement and optimize the California State University (CSU) Campus and surrounding lands. The CSU campus creates unique opportunities for an integrated mix of institutional, commercial, residential and recreational uses that interact synergistically as a cohesive neighborhood providing an enhanced and sustainable quality of life for residents, employees and visitors.

Lands west of the CSU campus, south of US Interstate-10, north of Frank Sinatra Drive and east of Monterey Avenue comprise the University Park planning area. Residential development in this area should range from for students and residents, to single family neighborhoods and golf course-oriented resort homes. The planning area should also include a distinct neighborhood commons comprised of parks and open space, commercial uses and public gathering places, with nearby work, schools and residences.

Commercial development in the University Park neighborhood should range from that which supports the campus, its students, faculty and employees, to neighborhood shopping for local residents. Opportunities for entertainment retail are significant and may range from dinner theaters, nightclubs and conventional restaurants to specialty retail outlets. Strategically and conveniently located neighborhood shopping will meet the day-to-day needs of residents living in this area. There are also important opportunities in this area for the development of business park and research and development centers that take advantage of the CSU campus and programs and provide highly skilled and well-paying jobs.

The University Park planning area is bounded by arterial roadways that provide excellent access to the regional transportation network, while limiting the impacts of arterial traffic on local neighborhoods. Within the planning area, traffic circulation can be efficiently provided by smaller streets and a comprehensive network of pedestrian and bike paths that limit the length of trips and the need for the use of an automobile. This transportation network can also keep most intra-area traffic off of the arterial roadway network.

Community Design Element III-150 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

The University Park commercial will also benefit from the tourist and resort residential market in this area, including hotels, major timeshare projects, destination resorts and recreational facilities, as well as the substantial passer-by markets along the City gateway arterials of Cook Street and Portola Avenue. The sports and entertainment arena at the University will also complement and support development of an entertainment-oriented retail component along Cook Street.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

The City has made significant progress in improving the quality of life of its residents and visitors, and can continue to promote these qualities through thoughtful community design. The integrated application of planning, architectural and landscape design standards and principals will provide better guidance and direction to developers and design professionals. Community design considerations, ranging from integrated mixed-use developments to preservation and enhancement of scenic highways, can subtly and profoundly shape the image of the community. Basic criteria to promote good and thoughtful design enhances community cohesiveness and coherence and has allowed Palm Desert to emerge as a thriving and highly marketable resort community. It is evident that community design considerations are directly related to issues associated with land use, traffic, arts and culture, health and safety, and environmental systems.

The Community Design Element can be implemented by several mechanisms, including the thoughtful application of the other elements of the General Plan, the City Zoning Ordinance, and through Redevelopment Plans and Specific Plans for individual project areas. The most effective instrument will be the Zoning Ordinance and associated development codes and guidelines, which set forth specific standards and establish design parameters and guidelines for site planning, building and landscaping, and other areas of community design. On the zoning district level, the Zoning Ordinance will assure that development occurs in a manner consistent with the design goals of the community.

GOALS, POLICIES AND PROGRAMS

Goal 1 A high quality of life provided within a livable, sustainable and balanced community with a distinct character consistent with the City's status as a premier resort community and important commercial center. Goal 2 An aesthetically pleasing community appearance achieved on all levels, which preserves and enhances the City's resort identity, community image and natural setting.

Goal 3 Standards of community design, architecture, and landscaping that enhance land use and development efficiencies and are integrated with the City’s desert setting and natural scenic resources.

Community Design Element III-151 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Policy 1 Promote and maintain a land use pattern in the City and planning area that efficiently distributes homes, employment centers, parks, schools and other institutions, shopping and services.

Policy 2 Promote and maintain a logical and efficient hierarchy of streets that are part of a connected network, that disperses traffic by providing a variety of pedestrian and vehicular routes to any destination.

Policy 3 Promote and maintain a distributed system of physical and service infrastructure that provides for the efficient delivery of utilities and public services.

Policy 4 Equally apply City community design standards to all private and public sector development projects to assure protection of the community's scenic viewsheds, provide community cohesion and enhance the image of the City as a premier resort community.

Program 4.A The City Zoning Ordinance and other regulatory documents shall be amended and maintained to assure clear and concise development and design standards and guidelines within which both public and private development project must conform. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission; City Council Schedule: Continuous

Policy 5 New development proposals shall be reviewed by City staff to assure compliance with applicable neighborhood plans and to evaluate proposed design features, such as entry statements, recreational facilities, neighborhood parks and schools, and landscaping along public rights-of- way.

Policy 6 Specific Plans shall continue to be used to establish area-specific land use and development standards and guidelines that address community design goals for these areas.

Program 6.A The City shall continue to implement the adopted Specific Plan and, as appropriate, prepare new plans, and shall review development proposals within the planning area for compliance with plan land use, development and design standards and guidelines. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Redevelopment Agency, Planning Commission; City Council Schedule: Continuous

Policy 7 The City shall promote distinct and identifiable street corridors throughout the City that reflect coherent design, functionality and safety, balancing size and design with local needs.

Community Design Element III-152 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Program 7.A The City shall develop street corridor plans that set forth appropriate themes and design features, including wall and building setbacks, signage, street trees and other landscaping, bus shelters and other furnishings, and other distinctive improvements. Priority shall be given to arterials and other major roadways. Responsible Agency: Planning Department; Public Works Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Ongoing

Program 7.B The City shall establish expanded landscape areas and enhancements at corners and adjoining parkways located along Portola Avenue, including (1) Gerald Ford Dr. @ Portola Avenue, (2) Frank Sinatra Drive @ Portola Avenue, and (3) the planned major intersection between Gerald Ford Dr. and Frank Sinatra Dr. Specific design parameters shall be prepared for these locations.Responsible Agency: Community Development and Public Works Departments Schedule: 2004

Policy 8 Areas of special interest, including entry points, scenic roadway viewsheds and community landmarks shall receive appropriate treatment whether part of public or private development proposals.

Program 8.A The City shall require the submittal of detailed site and circulation plans, landscape, architectural and special signage designs, and other features to assure compliance with community design standards and compatibility with the natural and built environments. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Public Works Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Ongoing

Program 8.B Where appropriate and feasible, additional public right-of-way shall be secured from new development at major intersections and other entry and focal points to provide opportunities for special entry treatments and specific transportation facilities, including bus stops/shelters. expanded landscape areas, public art and other distinguishing features. Responsible Agency: Planning Department; Public Works Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Ongoing

Policy 9 Site-sensitive architectural designs and native desert landscape materials shall be incorporated into all public and private building projects to complement and enhance the connection between the natural and built environments.

Policy 10 Commercial, institutional and industrial development projects shall contribute positively to the design objectives of the community and the specific district or corridor design standards and guidelines in which they are located.

Community Design Element III-153 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Program 10.A The City shall review all commercial, institutional and industrial development to assure accommodation of pedestrian-oriented circulation, safe and convenient ingress and egress, screening of outdoor storage/loading and other unsightly areas, lighting, signage, and the planting of landscaping to provide an effect of permanency in the near-term. Responsible Agency: Planning Department Schedule: Continuous

Program 10.B The City shall amend the Zoning Ordinance implementing the C-OP designation to assure that appropriate, more restrictive architectural standards affecting building heights and setbacks, and other development standards are applied to office development along non-arterial street corridors to ensure compatibility with surrounding residential areas. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: 2004-05

Policy 11 Community and neighborhood activity centers shall be established at appropriate locations to create recreational opportunities, encourage social interaction and provide a sense of public space and center for neighborhood activity.

Program 11.A The City shall continue to actively pursue joint use agreement with the Desert Sands and Palm Springs Unified School Districts to promote the appropriate public use of school open space, and athletic and other facilities as integral parts of adjoining and nearby neighborhoods. Responsible Agency: Parks and Recreation Department, Planning Department, School Districts, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Continuous

Program 11.B The City shall review development proposals for opportunities to integrate parks, plazas, squares and other open space areas that allow and facilitate public use and social interaction. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Continuous

Policy 12 The City shall maintain and enforce a Sign Ordinance that minimizes the size, scale and number of signs needed to provide functional identification and exposure to convey messages, while minimizing impacts on traffic safety, streetscape appearance and scenic viewsheds.

Program 12.A The City shall review and, as necessary, revise the signage regulations set forth in the Zoning Ordinance addressing all aspects of sign review, and shall establish finite periods by which existing non-conforming signage shall be retired. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Continuous

Community Design Element III-154 City of Palm Desert/Adopted 3.15.04 Comprehensive General Plan/Community Design Element

Policy 13 Preserve the value of the community’s night sky and avoid unnecessary light and glare from signage, building and landscape illumination, or other sources of outdoor lighting.

Program 13.A The City shall revise the Zoning Ordinance and other appropriate sections of the municipal code to limit lighting levels, establish acceptable types of lighting and fixtures, and the location of lighting in relation to adjoining and nearby , the public right-of-way and the night sky. Standards shall establish maximum height and number of fixtures, and intensity of lighting needed to provide sufficient parking lot and building security and identification for public safety, enhance landscaping, and other site aesthetics. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: 2004-05

Policy 14 Incorporate the City’s identification symbol into street signage, planters, benches, public buildings, City vehicles, streetscape furnishings, and other appropriate applications.

Policy 15 Support a high level of Code Enforcement to encourage neighborhood beautification and to maintain values and quality of life.

Policy 16 Overhead utility lines shall be under grounded to the greatest extent practical through the establishment of an under grounding program and guidelines.

Policy 17 Public utility facilities, including electric power substations, domestic water and irrigation wells, switching and control facilities shall be screened, landscaped and/or otherwise obscured and integrated into the surrounding environment to limit their adverse aesthetic impact.

Program 17.A The City shall confer and coordinate with the various utility providers with facilities in the City and shall jointly develop screening and other strategies to reduce the adverse effects of these facilities on the appearance of the community. Responsible Agency: Planning Department, Planning Commission, City Council Schedule: Continuous

Policy 18 Continue to promote and facilitate the placement of public art to create a unique setting that enhances the cultural and aesthetic character throughout the City.

Community Design Element III-155