SAMNITE ECONOMY AND THE COMPETITIVE ENVIRONMENT OF ITALY IN THE FIFTH TO THIRD CENTURIES BC Daniel C. Hoyer* 1. Introduction The traditional view of central Italy in the early and middle Republican periods holds that the people living in the Apennine highlands, particu- larly the Samnites, were essentially uncivilized, violent, and a constant nuisance to the more highly developed communities in Latium and Etru- ria. Livy, for example, wrote that Samnites in the fourth century bc “dwelt in villages in the mountains and would raid the plain and coastal regions with a contempt for their cultivators, who were of a milder character, while they themselves were rough mountain-dwellers”.1 Such views, moreover, have been endorsed by several modern scholars. Most notable is Salmon, who claims that “Samnium was an economic backwater” which imported “nothing of demonstrable overseas provenance,” relying rather, as Livy had claimed, on plundering their neighbours for sustenance or mass migra- tions.2 Related to this view is the idea of defensive imperialism, popu- lar especially in the first half of the twentieth century, which asserts that most of the warfare in the early and middle Republic was caused by Rome defending herself and her allies against the aggressive activity of her Ital- ian neighbours.3 In short, the interaction between Romans and Samnites has often been envisioned as a clash of civilizations, pitting the highly advanced political and economic systems of Rome against the backwards tribes living in the Apennine highlands. Rome’s eventual victory, seen in this light, is thus presented as both remarkable in having overcome such * University of New York;
[email protected].