Religion & Liberty
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RELIGION & LIBERTY January and February • 1995 A Publication of the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty Volume 5 • Number 1 The Time has Come to Reevaluate Strategy for Change Interview: Heather Richardson Higgins Higgins: Government impedes on several levels. First, it impedes at the Heather Richardson Higgins is Executive Director of the family level by disenfranchising the Council on Culture & Community which seeks to exam- father. There is no reason to have a ine and promote the attitudes and values essential for father around if you are so inclined, democratic capitalism and American civilization. She is if you don’t need the money, if the a Senior Fellow at the Progress & Freedom Foundation money is coming from somewhere and the Director of the Randolph Foundation. A gradu- else or, in fact, if having the father ate of Wellesley College and New York University, she around is a net drain on your in- has been editorial writer for the Wall Street Journal and come. In a recent television program Assistant Editor of The Public Interest.In addition to being a regular commen- regarding gang problems in Little tator on cable and public television programs, she co-hosts, with Newt Gingrich, Rock, Arkansas, fathers were the The Progress Report, a live weekly hour-long program on public policy issues. most salient absence in the whole hour of footage. They were not avail- R&L: How valuable are mediating from disciplining their children or able to impose any form of order in institutions to community life? they would be taken away and the lives of the young men. By mak- placed in foster care. This couple had ing fathers unnecessary, government Higgins: They play an extraordinar- already lost one child to this process has basically subsidized what Bar- ily valuable role. The family is prob- and will soon face a hearing. In this bara Whitehead calls the “separatist ably the most important institution. matter they don’t know what to do primal desires” of men and Yet it cannot flourish without com- because, if what the father says is women—that is for men to insemi- munal support. Just the other day I true, the community is not support- nate and leave, and for women to be was talking with a cab driver who ive of their efforts to provide better left alone to play with their dolls. works 12-plus hour days, as does his opportunities for their children, and Under these conditions, the essential wife, in order to keep their children keep them on the strait and narrow. cohesion that two responsible par- in private school which they believe Institutions which support parents ents offer a child is missing. is essential for their children’s succes. who seek to raise their children prop- Government programs pose se- But, while the parents were working erly become imperative. rious problems for community insti- outside of the home, the children had tutions when they directly compete fallen in with some very bad com- R&L: How do government policies with those organizations which at- pany which led to parental disci- impede the success of community- tempt to provide charity while seek- pline. The government then stepped based organizations? ing to assist the individual beyond in and told the parents to refrain materialistic ends. Properly per- INSIDE THIS ISSUE • Interview: Heather Richardson Higgins ❦ Articles: “The State that Justifies” by James V. Schall, SJ and “Reflections on the Bell Curve” by Noel A. Black ❦ Review Essay: “When Austrians Came to America” by David Prychitko ❦ In the Liberal Tradition: John Henry Newman ❦ Book Review: John-Peter Pham on Barbara von der Heydt’s Candles behind the Wall ❦ Column: “This Delicate Fruit, Lib- erty” by Robert A. Sirico, CSP ❦ Plus Book News. formed charity not only feeds you, problem lies in their calls for social more satisfying to feel you have but keeps your self-respect intact. It action. I am left with the distinct feel- done something on a national level teaches you to work, and helps ing that these clergy have aban- rather than merely in your own back make the connection between what doned one of religion’s most impor- yard; though in reality it is more ef- others do for you and what you are tant roles: to act as an agent for fective to pursue the latter. It seems expected to do for yourself. When a change and improvement within a to me that many people became un- government agency down the street community. But they refuse to do it comfortable with religion, particu- neither demands nor expects any- themselves, and instead become larly in the ’60s with its secular thing from aid recipients, entities goads for government action. Thus, trends. Even the religious people that wish to impose con- bought into the idea that ditions which will ulti- one shouldn’t impose mately lead to the better- Properly performed charity not only one’s values on someone ment of the recipients feeds you, but keeps your self-respect else. They wanted to do struggle that much more. good without any strings intact. It teaches you to work, and helps attached. So if you asked R&L: The Church and make the connection between what the government to do it, other religious mediating your personal sense of institutions provide a others do for you and what you are ex- good would remain intact positive alternative, don’t pected to do for yourself. and you would be less they? criticized. Also, the churches use Higgins: Religious institutions are in essence, they lose their moral au- government more and more because central because they are an organiz- thority and we lose one of the pri- the reasons for doing good have ing force within the community. mary institutions for affecting re- changed. The question is—What They are not simply an outlet for re- sponsible change. needs to change? The individual or sponsible action within the commu- society? You used to do good be- nity; they also encourage and re- R&L: Could you speculate as to why cause you wanted to help the per- mind us in an organized, systematic this has become the trend? What sort son in need have a better life by help- way to assist others. of forces have caused the leadership ing themselves. Later thinkers of the established churches to behave amend society, rather than the indi- R&L: In the past, you have noted in this way? vidual. Government policies were that some religious leaders fail to thus pursued because they made us uphold this vision. Higgins: Government solutions are feel good about ourselves; we were very tempting. If you think about it, “doing something” by calling for a Higgins: There is a problem of late, who wouldn’t want to go to a cen- government program. Considerably particularly with the mainline de- tral entity which has the power to less care was paid to whether some- nominations, and certainly with immediately affect the entire coun- thing actually worked and benefited some of the Catholic bishops. The try with vast resources? It’s much its intended beneficiaries. The Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Lib- RELIGION & LIBERTY erty was founded in 1990 to promote Classical Liberal ideas A Publication of the Acton Institute for among clergy and individuals who can best effect positive the Study of Religion and Liberty change in the moral climate of our time. The Institute is a Volume 5 • Number 1 nonpartisan, nonprofit, charitable, educational, and literary center. It is supported by donations from foundations, cor- Publisher: Rev. Robert A. Sirico, CSP porations, and individuals and maintains a 501(c)(3) tax- exempt status. Editor: John M. Vella Letters and subscription requests should be directed to: Contributing Editors: The Acton Institute, 161 Ottawa St., NW, Suite 301, Grand William B. Allen, Ph.D. Rabbi Daniel Lapin Rapids, MI 49503 or phone (616) 454-3080. John Attarian, Ph.D. Ronald Nash, Ph.D. The views of the authors expressed in Religion & Lib- Doug Bandow, J.D. Rev. James V. Schall, SJ erty are not necessarily those of the Acton Institute. Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn, Ph.D. Herbert Schlossberg, Ph.D. © 1995 Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty. 2 • RELIGION & LIBERTY JANUARY AND FEBRUARY • 1995 It was also a cheap and easy way its effort to start again after so the false notion that the economy is out. When the government tackles a many years of communism? a fixed pie in which it is morally rep- problem, you have a lot more leisure rehensible if anyone gets a larger time because you don’t have to vol- Higgins: One of the greatest slice than another. unteer yourself. Someone else solves deterrants, particularly in the Soviet Secondly, as changes occur, and the problem for you while you feel Union, is people’s refusal to give up change occurs rapidly, it will cause morally virtuous for making grand certain erroneous ideas. Misguided much distress. People are being statements about what the govern- notions of what constitutes equality asked to make immediate advances ment ought to be doing about it. seem to be one of the biggest errors. we have made over a much longer There is still a real social stigma at- time period. There are prices to be R&L: You have been active in the tached to anyone who excels in work paid for every advance, not least of United States in trying to build up or income. People believe that the which is the feeling of discomfort of communities.