Shepparton North East Growth Corridor
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme – Shepparton North East Growth Corridor Planning Panels Victoria Committee Hearing Date: Tuesday 21st August, 2018 Report Date: 14th August, 2018 Prepared For: Margaret & Paul Bennett Instructed By: 10 Consulting Group Pty Ltd STATEMENT TO THE PLANNING PANEL BY HENRY TURNBULL, TRAFFIC ENGINEER Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme Shepparton North East Growth Corridor (Bennetts Property) Traffic Engineering Assessment Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme Shepparton North East Growth Corridor (Bennett Property) Document Control Issue No. Type Date Prepared By Approved By A For Panel 15/08/2018 J. Place/H. Turnbull H. Turnbull Traffix Template Version 1.0 – May, 2015 Our Reference: G25445R-01A G25445R-01A.docx Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme Shepparton North East Growth Corridor (Bennetts Property) Table of Contents 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 1 2 Qualifications and Experience .............................................................................................. 1 3 Summary of Opinions .......................................................................................................... 1 4 Background ......................................................................................................................... 2 5 The Subject Site .................................................................................................................. 4 5.1 Site Locality ................................................................................................................................... 4 5.2 Existing Road Network .................................................................................................................. 5 6 Amendment C118 ............................................................................................................... 6 7 Shepparton North East Precinct Structure Plan (PSP) ............................................................ 7 8 Shepparton North East DCP ............................................................................................... 11 9 Opinions ........................................................................................................................... 13 9.1 Need for “Level 2” Connector Street .......................................................................................... 13 9.2 Access to Grahamvale Road ........................................................................................................ 16 9.3 Access C Potential Closure .......................................................................................................... 16 9.4 Suitability of 5-Leg Roundabout .................................................................................................. 17 9.5 RD-02 Road Reservation Width & Alignment ............................................................................. 18 9.6 Interface Street – Verney Road ................................................................................................... 21 9.7 Interface Street – School ............................................................................................................. 21 9.8 DCP Compensation ..................................................................................................................... 22 10 Conclusions ....................................................................................................................... 24 List of Appendices Appendix A: Practice Note – PNVCAT2 Expert Evidence Appendix B: CV – Henry Turnbull G25445R-01A.docx Page i Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme Shepparton North East Growth Corridor (Bennetts Property) 1 Introduction I have been retained by Margaret and Paul Bennett of 145 Verney Road, Shepparton, to undertake traffic engineering assessments and to prepare an evidence statement in relation to the planning scheme changes proposed under Planning Scheme Amendment C118 affecting the Bennett property. In preparing this report, I have relied upon the facts, matters and assumptions detailed in Appendix A. 2 Qualifications and Experience Appendix A contains a statement setting out my qualifications and experience, and the other matters raised by “Planning Panels Victoria – Planning Panels – Expert Evidence”. Appendix B contains my CV. 3 Summary of Opinions Having perused relevant documents and plans and undertaken traffic engineering assessments, I am of the opinion that: a) development of the Bennett property in isolation and in the absence of a PSP would require a single local access street connection to Verney Road (likely to the north of Pine Road so as to avoid a cross-intersection), b) “Access C” to Grahamvale Road should be shifted south adjacent to Grahamvale Primary School, consistent with the earlier 2010/2011 development plan, c) subject to b) above (or retaining Access C in its current location shown in the July 2018 PSP), RD- 01 and RD-02 will be level 1 connector streets carrying less than 6,000 vpd and requiring a 24m reservation, d) the DCP should fund the difference between a 7.3m carriageway and an 11.6m carriageway for all connector streets and should fund the purchase of 8m of land to increase the cross-section from a 16m local access street reservation to a 24m level 1 connector reservation, e) RD-02 should be realigned to provide a straighter alignment, including a straighter cross- intersection at Verney Road/Pine Road, f) item e) will require some land take from Parcel 16 for the intersection and this can occur (via DCP and a PAO to ensure timely delivery of the intersection) without impacting on the existing dwelling, g) having regard to the locality and key traffic generators, VicRoads’ proposed connection to the PSP from the Grahamvale Road/Ford Road intersection is not necessary for the precinct but Access C (preferably in a more southerly location than shown on the PSP) is necessary, h) in the absence of Access C (regardless of the proposed connection to the PSP from the Grahamvale Road/Ford Road intersection), traffic volumes on Access D (IN-02 – Verney Road/Pine Road) will G25445R-01A.docx Page 1 Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme Shepparton North East Growth Corridor (Bennetts Property) exceed 6,000 vpd and will require trunk collector construction (30m reservation, with 14m reimbursed by the DCP), i) in the absence of Access C (regardless of the proposed connection to the PSP from the Grahamvale Road/Ford Road intersection), SIDRA assessments indicate that there is insufficient capacity at IN- 02 and revised assessments and a re-design will be necessary, likely requiring additional land for north-south stand-up lanes on Verney Road, j) frontage roads to the southern boundary of the PSP are unnecessary, k) if frontage roads are to be provided adjacent to Verney Road, Ford Road and Grahamvale Road, they would be one-sided (in terms of services, footpath and parking requirements, etc.) and need only be 12m wide, l) the PSP does not need to be prescriptive about the provision of frontage roads and should allow development to provide either a frontage road or landscape strip, m) frontage roads to the non-government school (Shepparton Christian College) are unnecessary, provide no meaningful service to the school, give a poor design outcome for the development of the Bennett land and should be removed, and n) the above-mentioned items require resolution prior to incorporating the PSP and DCP into the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme. 4 Background The Victorian Planning Authority (VPA), in consultation with Greater Shepparton City Council and Government agencies, is preparing the Shepparton North East Precinct Structure Plan (PSP) to guide new urban development in Shepparton. Precinct Structure Plan (PSP) and Development Contribution Plan (DCP) documents dated February 2018 were subject to community engagement and public exhibition from 8th March 2018 to Friday 13th April 2013. A number of background documents were also exhibited for public comment, including a Traffic Impact Assessment Report prepared by Trafficworks (Ref: 113040) dated 22nd August 20141. At the conclusion of the exhibition period, further investigations were undertaken and updated draft PSP and DCP documents were prepared, dated July 2018. An addendum to the Traffic Impact Assessment Report was also prepared by Trafficworks (Ref: 170769) dated 13th July 2018. 1 The traffic engineering background studies on the VPA website (https://vpa.vic.gov.au/project/shepparton-north-east/) include a Traffic Impact Assessment Report (Maunsell Australia Pty Ltd, November 2008), a Traffic Impact Assessment Report (AECOM Pty Ltd, December 2009) and a TIAR Traffix Group Peer Review (March 2011) in addition to the Trafficworks report. Notably, my firm was retained in 2010/2011 by Greater Shepparton City Council to peer review the traffic recommendations of the Shepparton North East Growth Corridor PSP, including reviewing the recommendations of the AECOM traffic report and PSP (February 2010 version) in relation to Verney Road, assessing the proposed roads against the IDM and make recommendations for any amendments to the PSP. The PSP considered at that time (including the road layout) differs from the current proposal. G25445R-01A.docx Page 2 Amendment C118 to the Greater Shepparton Planning Scheme