Habitat Preference of the Sea Urchin (Parechinus Angulosus) Within Tide Pools Brian Hammond, Jennifer Miller, and Melissa Ross Bioe 159 Spring 2013
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Habitat preference of the sea urchin (Parechinus angulosus) within tide pools Brian Hammond, Jennifer Miller, and Melissa Ross Bioe 159 Spring 2013 Abstract Determining the habitat features associated with a species and its functionality gives insight into that species’ evolutionary history, life history characteristics, conservation requirements, biological interactions and spatial distribution. Urchin species’ potential to interpret environmental features through spatial vision and chemosensory perception allows them to distinguish and exploit beneficial habitat. The degree of predation on urchin species can have dramatic impacts on the algal community due to the herbivores' high-density aggregating and grazing tendencies. We observed that Parechinus angulosus (P. angulosus) aggregate within crevices and their spatial distribution was not consistent within or among intertidal pools and that vegetation and substrate type varied within pools. The purpose of this study was to determine the habitat associations of P. angulosus with respect to substrate type, biological cover, and provisioning of refuge. We collected data using the Uniform Point Contact (UPC) method in order to the test our hypotheses that the occupation rate of P. angulosus would be dis-proportional to the substrate, biological cover, and refuge available within tide pools. Overall we determined that P. angulosus exhibits habitat associations and habitat utilization which may be the result of adaptations in response to predation pressure, or may provide some fitness benefit. 1. Introduction Ecological systems are defined on the basis of interactions between organisms and their surrounding environment. An integral way in which animals interact with their environment is through their utilization of habitat (Bax, 1999). Understanding the distribution of organisms relative to their habitat can be fundamental to understanding the foundational ecology of a species (Syms,1995). 1.1 Importance of Habitat Associations A habitat is commonly defined as, “a place where a plant or animal is found” (Diaz, 2004). By building off of Diaz’s terminology we are defining a habitat association as: the relationship between a species and the physical and biological characteristics of its habitat. Determining the habitat features associated with a species and its functionality gives insight into that species’ evolutionary history, life history characteristics, conservation requirements, biological interactions and spatial distribution (Wahle and Steneck, 1990; Leber, 1985; Phillips et al., 2003). Knowledge of habitat is necessary for fishery and conservation policies such as the Manguson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, the primary law governing fisheries management in US originally enacted in 1976, which states “all essential fish habitat should be identified and protected” (Benaka, 1999). Distinguishing between essential and non-essential habitat by assessing of the quality and quantity of habitat is imperative for the development of appropriate conservation and management strategies (Diaz, 2004). 1.2 Behavioral Responses to Environment Animals exhibit a wide array of behavioral responses to their physical and biological environment by interpreting cues and signals as well as utilizing different forms of taxis (Main, 1987). Organisms’ behavioral responses to environmental stresses include physiological tolerances to environmental conditions and motility responses to physical stresses (e.g. desiccation, turbulence, salinity) (Iacarella and Helmuth, 2011); animals can navigate through their environment by migrating in response to environmental or biological stimuli (Sameoto, 2007). Even animals with low spatial resolution can detect the rugosity of the substrate to seek out refuge from predation (Blevins and Johnsen, 2004). Essentially, predators have the potential to significantly influence the behavior of prey organisms and induce a habitat association or preference (Carr, 2008). The common use of Fish Aggregating Devices highlights the influence that species-environment relationships have on animal distribution and systems through aggregation (Jaquemet et al., 2011). In addition, observations of organisms aggregating during spawning indicate that habitat associations may indirectly increase reproductive success (Pennington, 1985). 1.3 Habitat Usage Marine and terrestrial animals have obtained the ability to recognize a beneficial habitat feature and the functional significance in order to acquire a fitness gain (Blevins and Johnsen, 2004; Main, 1987). Some organisms’ sensitivity to biochemical cues allows them to respond to environmental changes that “have clear adaptive significance” such as acquiring shelter in response to predation (Bernstein et al., 1983). Urchin species’ potential to interpret environmental features through spatial vision and chemosensory perception allows them to distinguish and utilize beneficial habitat (Blevins and Johnsen 2004; Pinna et al., 2012). They have been known to migrate towards areas of high rugosity and actively provision refuge in the presence of predators (Pinna et al. 2012; Sheibling and Hamm, 1991). The degree of predation on urchin species can have dramatic impacts on the algal community due to the herbivores' high-density aggregating and grazing tendencies (Hagen 1994; Wright, 2005). 1.4 Parechinus angulosus in Betty’s Bay, South Africa The multiple bioregions of South Africa’s coastline are the result of various processes influenced by the Benguela and Agulhas currents. The combination of the distinctive water temperatures generates cool temperate, subtropical, and warm temperate climates that induce a biodiversity hotspot, distinguishing South Africa’s marine habitat. Cool water kelp forests, consisting mainly of Eklonia maxima, characterize the southwestern coastline of Betty’s Bay, South Africa. Numerous species of 2 | Page invertebrates that inhabit the rocky intertidal are largely herbivorous and include: Patella longicosta, Patella cochlear, Dendrofissurella scutellum, Parechinus angulosus, and Haliotis midae (Blamey and Branch, 2012). Impromptu observations in Betty’s Bay suggested that P. angulosus exhibited possible habitat associations with high rugosity substrate and crustose coralline algae. We observed that P. angulosus aggregate within crevices and their spatial distribution was not consistent within or among intertidal pools and that vegetation and substrate type varied within pools. We wanted to examine the potential habitat associations of P. angulosus. The purpose of this study is to determine the habitat associations of P. angulosus with respect to substrate type, biological cover, and provisioning of refuge. In a survey of 28 pools we predict that: (1) the occupation rate of P. angulosus will be disproportional to the substrate type observed; (2) the occupation rate of P. angulosus will be disproportional to the biological cover observed; and (3) the occupation rate of P. angulosus will be disproportional to the availability of refuge observed. We expect that the species will not utilize the habitat features of interest uniformly. 2. Methods 2.1 Study Site Studies were conducted between April 21, 2013 and April 30, 2013 in Betty's Bay, South Africa (34° 22′ 08″ S, 18° 54′ 20″ E) which is situated within a marine protected area along the south-westerly coastline. (Figure 1). The intertidal regions feature hard, jagged bedrock and boulders that create crevices and sheltered hollows. This system is characterized by Ecklonia maxima and other algae species such as Leptophytum foveatum and Ulva rigida. Other invertebrate species include the Tiger Topshell, Oxystele tigirina, Long-spined limpet, Patella longicosta, and the Pear limpet, Patella cochlear. P. angulosus is typically found to be associated with abalone, Haliotis midae and anemone species (e.g. Bunodosoma capensis). Data was collected at low tide from 28 tide pools which were chosen randomly and ranged in size from 10 to 30 m2, and depth from 0.25 to 1.0 m at varying tidal heights. The sites also had to meet the criteria that they must be pools located along the cove and any one area must not be overrepresented. 2.2 Study System The Cape Sea Urchins, Parechinus angulosus are important herbivores that occur commonly in the rocky intertidal of South Africa. Sea Urchins are known for their potential to transform the functionality of kelp forests through grazing (Blamey and Branch, 2012). This can have profound 3 | Page ecological implications due to the role kelp forests have as a refuge for larval development of many fish and invertebrate species (Andrew, 1993). P. angulosus feed primarily on trapped drift kelp as opposed to actively grazing (Day and Branch, 2002). This feeding pattern indirectly facilitates the urchin’s role in sheltering recruits and juvenile abalone. The Rock lobster, Jasus lalandii preys upon P. angulosus and is responsible for a drastic decrease in their abundance in beginning in 1990 when environmental conditions shifted the center of Rock lobster abundance south-easterly. Because P. angulosus individuals provide a suitable refuge for juvenile abalone, the shift in the Rock lobster habitat boundaries correlated to a decrease in abalone densities (Day and Branch, 2002). Figure 1. Study site in Betty's Bay, South Africa. Individual tide pools were chosen at random. 2.3 Habitat surveys: Substrate Type, Biological Cover, and Available Refuge We collected data using the Uniform Point Contact (UPC) method in order to the test