DOCSLIB.ORG

The Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics Reading Program K-2 As Measured by Student Performance and Teacher 74P

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics Reading Program K-2 As Measured by Student Performance and Teacher 74P DOCUMENT RESUME ED 430 215 CS 013 555 AUTHOR Dakin, Alexandra B. TITLE The Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics Reading Program K-2 as Measured by Student Performance and Teacher Evaluation. PUB DATE 1999-05-00 NOTE 74p.; Master of Science in Education, Dominican College. PUB TYPE Dissertations/Theses Masters Theses (042) Reports Evaluative (142) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC03 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Emergent Literacy; *Instructional Effectiveness; *Phonics; Primary Education; Qualitative Research; *Reading Instruction; *Reading Programs; Reading Research; Reading Skills; Teacher Attitudes IDENTIFIERS *Direct Instruction ABSTRACT This study focuses on the effectiveness and advantages of using an explicit phonics based reading program in kindergarten through second grade. The methods of decoding words that teachers introduce to the beginning readers must prove to be effective in introducing and building reading skills. Most recent studies have revisited and concurred with studies done in the 1930s and 1960s that the lack of phonics based reading instruction leaves students without important decoding skills necessary in recognizing letter/sound relationships in reading. The subjects in this study are 12 inner-city Catholic elementary school students. Four students at each grade level are evaluated and interviewed. Each student is at a different reading level identified as high, medium and low. Another component of the study is the teacher interview directed at each grade level teacher kindergarten through second grade. The teachers are interviewed as to their philosophy, style and methodology of teaching reading using explicit phonics instruction. The research method used is qualitative. Data gathering, evaluation and results are coded to ensure interviewed and research subjects confidentiality and anonymity. The implications of this study are to add to the existing research that the learning of the phonological structure of a word through use of phonetic decoding skills determines the success of the emergent reader kindergarten through second grade. An appendix contains unnumbered charts and tables of data, teacher interview questions and responses, a reading diagnosis chart, and several word lists. Contains 26 references. (RS) ******************************************************************************** Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. ******************************************************************************** Cs Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics 1 Running Head: EFFECTIVENESS OF A SKILL BASEDEXPLICIT PHONICS Dominican College San Rafael, California May 1999 The Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics Reading Program K-2 as Measured by Student Performance and Teacher Evaluation Alexandra B. Dakin Master of Science in Education BESTCOPYAVAILABLE PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE AND DISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL HAS U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION Office of Educational Research and Improvement BEEN GRANTED BY EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) This document has been reproduced as received from the person or organization originating it. kt") 0 Minor changes have been made to improve reproduction quality. TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) 1 -1 Points of view or opinions stated in this document do not necessarily represent official OERI position or policy. C/) Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author would like to thank her husband John, family and friends for their continuous support throughout this study. In addition, the author would like to acknowledge both Madalienne Peters, Ed.D., and Cate Diskin, M.A., for their inspiration, assistance and contributions to her post graduate work. 3 Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics The Effectiveness of a Skilled Based Explicit Phonics Reading Program K-2 as Measured by Student Performance and Teacher Evaluation Table of Contents Abstract 2 I. Introduction 3 II. Statement of Problem 5 III. Rationale 6 IV. Background & Need 8 V. Review of the Literature 13 VI. Methodology 23 VII. Results 36 VIII. Analysis of the Data/Discussion 40 IX. Conclusion 44 X. Reference XI. Appendix . 4 Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics 2 Abstract This study focuses on the effectiveness and advantages of using an explicit phonics based reading program in kindergarten through second grade. As teachers, the methods of decoding words that we introduce to the beginning readers must prove to be effective in introducing and building reading skills. Most recent studies have revisited and concurred with studies done in the 1930s and 1960s that the lack of phonics based reading instruction leaves students without important decoding skills necessary in recognizing letter/sound relationships in reading. The subjects in this study are twelve inner-city Catholic elementary school students. Four students at each grade level are evaluated and interviewed. Each student is at a different reading level identified as high, medium and low. Another component of the study is the teacher interview directed at each grade level teacher kindergarten through second grade. The teachers are interviewed as to their philosophy, style and methodology of teaching reading using explicit phonics instruction. The research method used is qualitative.It is practice based research done within the classroom environment. Each of the four students at each grade level are evaluated as to their reading level, word attack skills and use of phonetic decoding skill during the second semester of the 1998-1999 school year. The three teachers are interviewed with a set of eight questions on philosophy of teaching reading, style and methods of phonics instruction. Data gathering, evaluation and results are coded to insure interviewed and research subjects confidentiality and anonymity. The implications of this study are to add to the existing research that the learning of the phonological structure of a word through use of phonetic decoding skills determines the success of the emergent reader kindergarten through second grade. 5 Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics 3 Introduction One's earliest experiences in learning to read may be interactive, but what methods he or she uses to be a successful reader is the topic for discussion in this paper. In a documented report to the Superintendent of Public Schools in California, The Reading Task Force proposed that the State Board "adopt materials in grade 1-8 that include systematic, explicit phonics, spelling, and computational skills." (Reading Program Advisory 1996) This proposal had been presented in an effort to turn around the overall low reading performance of California students in each grade level. The Task Force concluded that the previous 1987 State Language Arts Framework was not adequate nor balanced enough in basic skills instruction to offer the beginning reader the skills necessary to succeed academically in the higher grades. The lack of explicit phonetic instruction left students without the important decoding skills necessary in recognizing letter/ sound relationships and word building patterns. The new guidelines proposed, called for the teaching of "an organized, explicit skills program with phonemic awareness, phonics and decoding skills emphathized." Without phonetic decoding skills, children will not be able to "understand, apply and learn the alphabetic principle and conventions of the written language." (Reading Program Advisory 1996) The reading process is a system used by successful readers to understand what they are reading. Three cueing systems are used interactively: the semantic cue uses background or prior knowledge of the reader, syntactic Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics 4 cues the reader's knowledge of language patterns, and the use of graphophonic cues taps into the understanding of the letter/sound relationship and letter/word patterns. Effective readers use these three cues together to decode their text. However, if one of these cues is not developed, such as the graphophonic cue which integrates phonemic awareness with phonetic decoding skills, the beginning reader will be hindered in his or her ability to understand the text. This study will explore the effectiveness and outcome of explicit phonics instruction in a reading program kindergarten through second grade. It provides evidence that the implementation of an explicit phonics program within the reading curriculum leads to better reading skills through evaluation of phonetic decoding methods used in written and oral comprehension of letter sounds in words of the beginning reader. 7 Effectiveness of a Skill Based Explicit Phonics 5 Statement of the Problem Given the implementation of an explicit instruction program, students in K- 2 will show evidence of reading skills in their word recognition assessments and comprehension evaluations. Teachers will also describe their reading philosophies and student progress in their interviews. Implementation ofan explicit skill based phonics program leads to increased reading skills and facilitates independent reading. Learning to recognize phonemes or individual sounds leads to phonemic awareness in beginning readers. Phonemic awareness in pre-k or kindergarten is an essential first step in beginning to learn to read words. Phonemic awareness is the ability to discern the alphabetic language's "sound system." (Chall 1996) This ability to discern separate letter sounds in the alphabet heightens
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Look at Linguistic Readers
    Reading Horizons: A Journal of Literacy and Language Arts Volume 10 Issue 3 April 1970 Article 5 4-1-1970 A Look At Linguistic Readers Nicholas P. Criscuolo New Haven, Connecticut Public Schools Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/reading_horizons Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Criscuolo, N. P. (1970). A Look At Linguistic Readers. Reading Horizons: A Journal of Literacy and Language Arts, 10 (3). Retrieved from https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/reading_horizons/vol10/iss3/5 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Special Education and Literacy Studies at ScholarWorks at WMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Reading Horizons: A Journal of Literacy and Language Arts by an authorized editor of ScholarWorks at WMU. For more information, please contact wmu- [email protected]. A LOOK AT LINGUISTIC READERS Nicholas P. Criscuolo NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT, PUBLIC SCHOOLS Linguistics, as it relates to reading, has generated much interest lately among educators. Although linguistics is not a new science, its recent focus has captured the interest of the reading specialist because both the specialist and the linguist are concerned with language. This surge of interest in linguistics becomes evident when one sees that a total of forty-four articles on linguistics are listed in the Education Index for July, 1965 to June, 1966. The number of articles on linguistics written for educational journals has been increasing ever SInce. This interest has been sharpened to some degree by the publi­ cation of Chall's book Learning to Read: The Great Debate (1).
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Phonics? Adapted From: Elish-Piper L
    NORTHERN ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY | JERRY L. JOHNS LITERACY CLINIC Raising Readers: Tips for Parents What is Phonics? Adapted from: Elish-Piper L. (2009/2010). Information and Ideas for parents about phonemic awareness and phonics. Illinois Reading Council Journal, 31(1), 52-54 Phonics is the relationship between letters and sounds. Children usually learn beginning sounds first, short vowels Readers use phonics to decode or sound out unknown next and then three letter words such as “cat,” “sit” and words. For example, when a reader comes to a word they “map.” Next, children learn about the silent “e” that comes don’t know, they can decode the word letter by letter such as at the end of words and makes a vowel a long vowel, meaning in the example “big” where they would identify the sounds that the vowel says its own name such as /a/ in the word /b/ /i/ /g/ to read the word “big.” Other words may have “tape.” Children also learn about other long vowel patterns as chunks or patterns that they can use to figure out unknown well as blends such as the letters /tr/ /br/ and /cl/. words. For example, when they come to the word “jump” Even if parents do not understand all of the phonics rules and they may identify the sound /j/ and then the familiar chunk patterns, they can still help their children develop phonics /ump/ that they knows from other words such as “bump,” skills. Here are 10 fun, easy activities that parents and “lump” and “dump.” children can do to practice phonics skills at home.
    [Show full text]
  • Recharging Reading Success Getting Struggling Readers Back on Track
    —Graeme Sloan/Education Week Braydan Finnerty, 2nd grade, chooses letter magnets off the board while doing a spelling exercise in front of the rest of the class at Beverly Gardens Elementary in Dayton, Ohio. Recharging Reading Success Getting Struggling Readers Back on Track EDITORS NOTE How Do Kids Learn to Read? What OPINION How can educators optimize literacy the Science Says ..........................................2 education among students who struggle to Connecting Reading & Writing ‘Is a read? In this Spotlight, learn how teachers These Schools Filled Vending High-Leverage Move’ .............................12 are implementing scientific research on Machines With Books. Will It Motivate Reading? .....................................6 Why I Created Book Groups for My reading into curriculum, how schools are Students ........................................................15 helping students foster a love of reading, A Look Inside One Classroom’s and how teachers are using writing to Reading Overhaul ......................................8 How to Make Reading Instruction compliment reading instruction. Much, Much More Efficient ................16 ‘Decodable’ Books: Boring, Useful, or Both?.............................................................. 10 Recharging Reading Success Published on October 2, 2020, in Education Week’s Special Report: Getting Reading Right How Do Kids Learn to Read? What the Science Says By Sarah Schwartz and Sarah D. Sparks ow do children learn to read? For almost a century, re- searchers have argued over the question. Most of the dis- agreement has centered on Hthe very beginning stages of the reading process, when young children are first starting to figure out how to decipher words on a page. One theory is that reading is a natural process, like learning to speak. If teachers and parents sur- round children with good books, this theory goes, kids will pick up reading on their own.
    [Show full text]
  • The Synthetic Phonics Teaching Principles June 2015
    The Synthetic Phonics Teaching Principles June 2015 Teach the relationship between sounds and letters by systematically introducing the letter/s-sound correspondences of the English alphabetic code (e.g. between three and five correspondences per week at first, including vowels and consonants). Start with mainly one spelling for each of the 42+ sounds (phonemes) identifiable in English speech before broadening out to focus on further spelling and pronunciation variations. (Initial teaching takes 2 to 3 years to teach a comprehensive level of alphabetic code; continue to build on this as required for phonics for spelling.) Model how to put the letter/s-sound correspondences introduced (the alphabetic code knowledge) to immediate use teaching the three skills of: Reading/decoding: synthesise (sound out and blend) all-through-the-printed-word to ‘hear’ the target word. Modify the pronunciation of the word where necessary. Spelling/encoding: orally segment (split up) all-through-the-spoken-word to identify the single sounds (phonemes) and know which letters and letter groups (graphemes) are code for the identified sounds. Handwriting: write the lower case, then the upper case, letters of the alphabet correctly. Hold the pencil with a tripod grip. Practise regular dictation exercises from letter level to text level (as appropriate). Provide cumulative, decodable words, sentences and texts which match the level of alphabetic code knowledge and blending skills taught to date, when asking the learner to read independently. Emphasise letter sounds at first and not letter names. (Learn letter names in the first instance by chanting the alphabet or singing an alphabet song.) Do not teach an initial sight vocabulary where learners are expected to memorise words as whole shapes.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Issues in Phonics Instruction. Hempenstall, K
    Some Issues in Phonics Instruction. Hempenstall, K. (No date). Some issues in phonics instruction. Education News 26/2/2001. [On-line]. Available: http://www.educationnews.org/some_issues_in_phonics_instructi.htm There are essentially two approaches to teaching phonics that influence what is taught: implicit and explicit phonics instruction. What is the difference? In an explicit (synthetic) program, students will learn the associations between the letters and their sounds. This may comprise showing students the graphemes and teaching them the sounds that correspond to them, as in “This letter you are looking at makes the sound sssss”. Alternatively, some teachers prefer teaching students single sounds first, and then later introducing the visual cue (the grapheme) for the sound, as in “You know the mmmm sound we’ve been practising, well here’s the letter used in writing that tells us to make that sound”. In an explicit program, the processes of blending (What word do these sounds make when we put them together mmm-aaa-nnn?”), and segmenting (“Sound out this word for me”) are also taught. It is of little value knowing what are the building blocks of our language’s structure if one does not know how to put those blocks together appropriately to allow written communication, or to separate them to enable decoding of a letter grouping. After letter-sound correspondence has been taught, phonograms (such as: er, ir, ur, wor, ear, sh, ee, th) are introduced, and more complex words can be introduced into reading activities. In conjunction with this approach "controlled vocabulary" stories may be used - books using only words decodable using the students' current knowledge base.
    [Show full text]
  • Learning About Phonology and Orthography
    EFFECTIVE LITERACY PRACTICES MODULE REFERENCE GUIDE Learning About Phonology and Orthography Module Focus Learning about the relationships between the letters of written language and the sounds of spoken language (often referred to as letter-sound associations, graphophonics, sound- symbol relationships) Definitions phonology: study of speech sounds in a language orthography: study of the system of written language (spelling) continuous text: a complete text or substantive part of a complete text What Children Children need to learn to work out how their spoken language relates to messages in print. Have to Learn They need to learn (Clay, 2002, 2006, p. 112) • to hear sounds buried in words • to visually discriminate the symbols we use in print • to link single symbols and clusters of symbols with the sounds they represent • that there are many exceptions and alternatives in our English system of putting sounds into print Children also begin to work on relationships among things they already know, often long before the teacher attends to those relationships. For example, children discover that • it is more efficient to work with larger chunks • sometimes it is more efficient to work with relationships (like some word or word part I know) • often it is more efficient to use a vague sense of a rule How Children Writing Learn About • Building a known writing vocabulary Phonology and • Analyzing words by hearing and recording sounds in words Orthography • Using known words and word parts to solve new unknown words • Noticing and learning about exceptions in English orthography Reading • Building a known reading vocabulary • Using known words and word parts to get to unknown words • Taking words apart while reading Manipulating Words and Word Parts • Using magnetic letters to manipulate and explore words and word parts Key Points Through reading and writing continuous text, children learn about sound-symbol relation- for Teachers ships, they take on known reading and writing vocabularies, and they can use what they know about words to generate new learning.
    [Show full text]
  • Syllabus 1 Lín Táo 林燾 and Gêng Zhènshëng 耿振生
    CHINESE 542 Introduction to Chinese Historical Phonology Spring 2005 This course is a basic introduction at the graduate level to methods and materials in Chinese historical phonology. Reading ability in Chinese is required. It is assumed that students have taken Chinese 342, 442, or the equivalent, and are familiar with articulatory phonetics concepts and terminology, including the International Phonetic Alphabet, and with general notions of historical sound change. Topics covered include the periodization of the Chinese language; the source materials for reconstructing earlier stages of the language; traditional Chinese phonological categories and terminology; fânqiè spellings; major reconstruction systems; the use of reference materials to determine reconstructions in these systems. The focus of the course is on Middle Chinese. Class: Mondays & Fridays 3:30 - 5:20, Savery 335 Web: http://courses.washington.edu/chin532/ Instructor: Zev Handel 245 Gowen, 543-4863 [email protected] Office hours: MF 2-3pm Grading: homework exercises 30% quiz 5% comprehensive test 25% short translations 15% annotated translation 25% Readings: Readings are available on e-reserves or in the East Asian library. Items below marked with a call number are on reserve in the East Asian Library or (if the call number starts with REF) on the reference shelves. Items marked eres are on course e-reserves. Baxter, William H. 1992. A handbook of Old Chinese phonology. (Trends in linguistics: studies and monographs, 64.) Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. PL1201.B38 1992 [eres: chapters 2, 8, 9] Baxter, William H. and Laurent Sagart. 1998 . “Word formation in Old Chinese” . In New approaches to Chinese word formation: morphology, phonology and the lexicon in modern and ancient Chinese.
    [Show full text]
  • Shallow Vs Non-Shallow Orthographies and Learning to Read Workshop 28-29 September 2005
    A Report of the OECD-CERI LEARNING SCIENCES AND BRAIN RESEARCH Shallow vs Non-shallow Orthographies and Learning to Read Workshop 28-29 September 2005 St. John’s College Cambridge University UK Co-hosted by The Centre for Neuroscience in Education Cambridge University Report prepared by Cassandra Davis OECD, Learning Sciences and Brain Research Project 1 Background information The goal of this report of this workshop is to: • Provide an overview of the content of the workshop presentations. • Present a summary of the discussion on cross-language differences in learning to read and the future of brain science research in this arena. N.B. The project on "Learning Sciences and Brain Research" was introduced to the OECD's CERI Governing Board on 23 November 1999, outlining proposed work for the future. The purpose of this novel project was to create collaboration between the learning sciences and brain research on the one hand, and researchers and policy makers on the other hand. The CERI Governing Board recognised this as a risk venture, as most innovative programmes are, but with a high potential pay-off. The CERI Secretariat and Governing Board agreed in particular that the project had excellent potential for better understanding learning processes over the lifecycle, but that ethical questions also existed. Together these potentials and concerns highlighted the need for dialogue between the different stakeholders. The project is now in its second phase (2002- 2005), and has channelled its activities into 3 networks (literacy, numeracy and lifelong learning) using a three dimensional approach: problem-focused; trans-disciplinary; and international.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading Depends on Writing, in Chinese
    Reading depends on writing, in Chinese Li Hai Tan*, John A. Spinks†, Guinevere F. Eden‡, Charles A. Perfetti§, and Wai Ting Siok*¶ *Department of Linguistics, and †Vice Chancellor’s Office, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong, China; ‡Georgetown University Medical Center, Washington, DC 20057; and §Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 12560 Communicated by Robert Desimone, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, April 28, 2005 (received for review January 3, 2005) Language development entails four fundamental and interactive this argument are two characteristics of the Chinese language: (i) abilities: listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Over the past Spoken Chinese is highly homophonic, with a single syllable four decades, a large body of evidence has indicated that reading shared by many words, and (ii) the writing system encodes these acquisition is strongly associated with a child’s listening skills, homophonic syllables in its major graphic unit, the character. particularly the child’s sensitivity to phonological structures of Thus, when learning to read, a Chinese child is confronted with spoken language. Furthermore, it has been hypothesized that the the fact that a large number of written characters correspond to close relationship between reading and listening is manifested the same syllable (as depicted in Fig. 1A), and phonological universally across languages and that behavioral remediation information is insufficient to access semantics of a printed using strategies addressing phonological awareness alleviates character. reading difficulties in dyslexics. The prevailing view of the central In addition to these system-level (language and writing system) role of phonological awareness in reading development is largely factors, Chinese writing presents some script-level features that based on studies using Western (alphabetic) languages, which are distinguish it visually from alphabetic systems.
    [Show full text]
  • Students Who Are Highly Mobile and Reading Instruction
    Reading on the Go! Volume 1: Students Who Are Highly Mobile and Reading Instruction Prepared for the National Center for Homeless Education by Patricia A. Popp, Ph.D. The College of William and Mary December 2004 NCHE Profile The National Center for Homeless Education (NCHE) is a national resource center of research and information enabling communities to successfully address the needs of children and their families who are experiencing homelessness and unaccompanied youth in homeless situations. Funded by the U.S. Department of Education, NCHE provides services to improve educational opportunities and outcomes for homeless children and youth in our nation’s school communities. NCHE is housed at SERVE, a consortium of education organizations associated with the School of Education at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro. The goals of NCHE are the following: • Disseminate important resource and referral information related to the complex issues surrounding the education of children and youth experiencing homelessness • Provide rapid-response referral information • Foster collaboration among various organizations with interests in addressing the needs of children and youth experiencing homelessness • Synthesize and apply existing research and guide the research agenda to expand the knowledge base on the education of homeless children and families, and unaccompanied youth Website: www.serve.org/nche HelpLine: 800-308-2145 Contact: Diana Bowman, Director NCHE at SERVE P.O. Box 5367 Greensboro, NC 27435 Phone: 336-315-7453 or 800-755-3277 Email: [email protected] or [email protected] The content of this publication does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of Education, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • The Activation of Phonology During Silent Chinese Word Reading
    Journal of Experimental Psychology: Copyright 1999 by the American Psychological Association, Inc. Learning, Memory', and Cognition 0278-7393/99/S3.0O 1999, Vol. 25, No. 4,838-857 The Activation of Phonology During Silent Chinese Word Reading Yaoda Xu Alexander Pollatsek Massachusetts Institute of Technology University of Massachusetts at Amherst Mary C. Potter Massachusetts Institute of Technology The role of phonology in silent Chinese compound-character reading was studied in 2 experiments using a semantic relatedness judgment task. There was significant interference from a homophone of a "target" word that was semantically related to an initially presented cue word whether the homophone was orthographically similar to the target or not This interference was only observed for exact homophones (i.e., those that had the same tone, consonant, and vowel). In addition, the effect was not significantly modulated by target or distractor frequency, nor was it restricted to cases of associative priming. Substantial interference was also found from orthographically similar nonhomophones of the targets. Together these data are best accounted for by a model that allows for parallel access of semantics via 2 routes, 1 directly from orthography to semantics and the other from orthography to phonology to semantics. The initial acquisition of most languages (with the orthography to meaning and two indirect routes to meaning important exception of sign language) is through speech. via a phonological representation, one based on spelling-to- When humans develop secondary verbal skills—reading and sound rules or regularities (a "prelexical" route) and the writing—it is unclear whether they establish a direct link other based on orthographic identification of a lexical entry from orthography to meaning or whether orthography is that leads to the activation of the word's phonological linked to phonology, with phonology remaining the sole or representation (a "postlexical" route).
    [Show full text]
  • Whole Language Instruction Vs. Phonics Instruction: Effect on Reading Fluency and Spelling Accuracy of First Grade Students
    Whole Language Instruction vs. Phonics Instruction: Effect on Reading Fluency and Spelling Accuracy of First Grade Students Krissy Maddox Jay Feng Presentation at Georgia Educational Research Association Annual Conference, October 18, 2013. Savannah, Georgia 1 Abstract The purpose of this study is to investigate the efficacy of whole language instruction versus phonics instruction for improving reading fluency and spelling accuracy. The participants were the first grade students in the researcher’s general education classroom of a non-Title I school. Stratified sampling was used to randomly divide twenty-two participants into two instructional groups. One group was instructed using whole language principles, where the children only read words in the context of a story, without any phonics instruction. The other group was instructed using explicit phonics instruction, without a story or any contextual influence. After four weeks of treatment, results indicate that there were no statistical differences between the two literacy approaches in the effect on students’ reading fluency or spelling accuracy; however, there were notable changes in the post test results that are worth further investigation. In reading fluency, both groups improved, but the phonics group made greater gains. In spelling accuracy, the phonics group showed slight growth, while the whole language scores decreased. Overall, the phonics group demonstrated greater growth in both reading fluency and spelling accuracy. It is recommended that a literacy approach should combine phonics and whole language into one curriculum, but place greater emphasis on phonics development. 2 Introduction Literacy is the fundamental cornerstone of a student’s academic success. Without the skill of reading, children will almost certainly have limited academic, economic, social, and even emotional success in school and in later life (Pikulski, 2002).
    [Show full text]