Law Day Celebration in Onondaga County – Bringing the Community Together to Commemorate the Signing of the Magna Carta
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ONONDAGA COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION VOLUME 60 NUMBER 4 | APRIL 2015 CNY Philanthropy Center | 431 East Fayette St. | Syracuse, NY 13202 | Phone: 315-471-2667 Law Day Celebration in Onondaga County – Bringing the Community Together To Commemorate the Signing of the Magna Carta Hundreds of OCBA members, members of the local bells in recognition of the Magna Carta, OCBA President Judiciary, high school students and special guests joined in Jean Marie Westlake presented the celebration of the 2015 Law Day in Onondaga County the Liberty Bell Award to East on Friday, May 1st. Law Day is a local program put on by Syracuse-Minoa Social Studies the Onondaga County Bar Foundation. teacher Joseph Musolino, for his efforts to promote justice and The theme for this year’s national recognition of Law Day advance appreciation for the law in was the 800th Anniversary of the signing and sealing of the our community. Magna Carta. For the first time ever, the formal morning ceremony was held outside, on the steps of the Onondaga Nearly 150 high school students were County Court House during a beautiful spring morning. then treated to tours and programs at Before that ceremony, local attorneys and the Judiciary the Onondaga County Court House, assembled on the steps for a group portrait, taken by both the Criminal Courts Building and the Federal Court House. a photographer on foot and an aerial drone photographer. Organizing those tours were: the Hon. Michael Hanuszczak; Appellate Division Justice Edward Carni presided over the Sandy Holihan, Law Clerk to the Hon. Anthony Paris; morning ceremony (see his keynote address, page 3). After Assistant District Attorney Romana Lavalas; retired Judge welcoming the guests, many of whom were high school Langston McKinney; the Hon. Brenda Sannes, and Gioia students, Judge Carni introduced County Executive Joanie Gensini. Mahoney who offered her congratulations and delivered a Then, more than 300 convened at the new Sky Armory venue proclamation naming May 1st, 2015 as Law Day in Onondaga downtown for the traditional Law Day Luncheon. Retired County. Syracuse City Court Judge Langston McKinney delivered a Following Judge Carni’s address and a ceremonial bell- passionate introduction, encouraging those in attendance ringing of the Cathedral of the Immaculate Conception’s (and especially the youth) to protect and promote the Continued on page 5 Inside: Reflections on the Magna Carta – Justice Edward D. Carni MISSION : To maintain the honor and dignity of UPCOMING 2015 EVENTS: the profession of law, to cultivate social discourse among its members, Elder Law Fair Thursday | May 28 and to increase its significance in CPLR Update 2015 Friday | June 5 promoting the due administration of Justice. From the President: Dear Friends, After many months of planning and organizing, our annual Law Day celebration was held on Friday, May 1, 2015. It was a wonderful event attended by many people from our community as well as our members. Law Day is a huge undertaking of meetings, planning, scheduling, and organizing. The day would not be possible without the tremendous generosity of our volunteers. This year, the Law Day committee was chaired by Joseph J. Bufano, Esq. and Donald E. Budmen, Esq. from the law firm of Ferrera, Fiorenza, Larrison, Barrett & Reitz, P.C.. This was their first year as co-chairs. They were assisted by the following dedicated Law Day committee members: Kathy Birmingham Anne Burak Dotzler Gioia Gensini Hon. Deborah Karalunas Romana Lavalas Michelle Mack Hon. Langston McKinney Lanessa Owens Anastasia Semel Heather Saroney Joe Vargo Together, they did an outstanding job and made the day very special! It is volunteers such as Joe, Don and the committee members that we are so thankful for, as it is their hard work that allows the Bar Association to host events for our members and community. OCBA has many more events planned throughout the year. If you would like to get involved and volunteer, please contact Jeff Unaitis, Executive Director at (315) 471-2667. Regards, Jean Marie Jean Marie Westlake | OCBA President [email protected] Telephone: (315) 479-9000 2015 OCBA BOARD OF DIRECTORS President Immediate Past President Romana A. Lavalas Jean Marie Westlake Nicholas J. DeMartino Scott A. Lickstein Hon. James P. Murphy President-Elect Executive Director Frank B. Pelosi Anne Burak Dotzler Jeffrey A. Unaitis Wendy S. Reese Aaron J. Ryder Vice President Directors James M. Williams Blaine T. Bettinger David M. Snyder Kimberly M. Zimmer Treasurer Bruce R. Bryan John T. McCann Joseph J. Bufano Ex Officio Sam Elbadawi Dean Hannah R. Arterian Secretary Paula Mallory Engel Mark W. Wasmund Deborah Sundquist O’Malley Danielle M. Fogel Stuart J. LaRose 2 REFLECTIONS ON THE MAGNA CARTA Justice Edward D. Carni, Appellate Division 4th Dept. When I was asked to preside over today’s particular experience or prior in-depth study of the “Great Charter Law Day ceremony, I quickly agreed. of Liberty” beyond the ordinary encounters one experiences in I was then asked to give a speech on high school, college and then briefly in law school. today’s theme - “the Magna Carta.” My The Magna Carta is often spoken of in those settings as the greatest first question was how long should it be? constitutional document of all time and the foundation of freedom Joe Bufano, one of today’s organizers against the arbitrary authority of the despot. As I prepared my responded - “about 20 minutes.” As Joe remarks for today, I learned many new and interesting things sat in my chambers, I looked over at the about the Magna Carta - not only with respect to the historical stacks of briefs and records and thought circumstances in which it arose, but perhaps more importantly of a lesson for the young lawyers, perhaps about its modern-day significance. The value of the 800 year-old even for the more experienced lawyers Magna Carta as a historical relic was demonstrated by the fact too. Less is more. Quite frequently I pick up a 40 page brief and that during WWII, in 1939, one of Great Britain’s copies of the think to myself - “that could have been done in 20 pages.” So today, document [there are only 4 copies remaining from the year 1215] I followed that formula and decided to reduce my comments to 10 was removed from Great Britain to the Library of Congress in minutes. Being in the Appellate Division, I of course put it up for a Washington, D.C. for safekeeping. When the United States entered vote and Justice Centra and Justice DeJoseph concurred. the war, the British copies of It is my great pleasure to have the opportunity to share this Law the Magna Carta were moved Day with all of you as we recognize and celebrate the 800 year to a secure hideaway at Fort anniversary of the Magna Carta. I would note that today is also Knox, Kentucky along with $21 the 57th anniversary of Law Day - a celebration and recognition billion in gold bars - and not of the rule of law first proposed by the American Bar Association returned until the surrender in 1957 and proclaimed by President Eisenhower in 1958. It is no of Germany. Notably, Great coincidence that Law Day is observed on the 1st day of May. In Britain’s priceless treasures the 1950’s, the traditional spring holiday of “May Day” on the 1st made their return to the of May was identified by Socialist and Communist organizations, United States in 2009 and with great support by the Soviet Union, as a day to celebrate were displayed at the Ronald and support Communist ideas and values. In response, in 1955 Reagan Presidential Library in President Eisenhower and Congress enacted “Loyalty Day” - a day California and at the Library of for Americans to reaffirm their loyalty to the United States and to Congress as recently as January recognize our great heritage of American freedom. 19, 2015. Loyalty Day remains codified at 36 USC § 115. “Law day” was Documents recently unveiled enacted by Congress in 1958 as a further extension of Loyalty Day by the British government demonstrate that in 1939, Winston and is codified in 36 USC § 113. Law Day continues to be celebrated Churchill, Prime Minister at that time, proposed the idea across this country with great success and positive impact as shown of making a gift to the United States of one of Great by this gathering here today. Britain’s four copies of the Magna Carta as a way to solidify Turning to the topic of the day, I must confess that when invited to the Anglo- American relationship and “butter-up” America offer some remarks for today’s Law Day theme on the significance of to induce her to join in the war against Germany. Internal the Magna Carta, an 800-year old document written in 3600 Latin memos from the British Foreign Affairs Department words on a single-page of parchment made of sheepskin, I had no Continued on page 11 3 OCBA’S Committee on Diversity and Inclusion’s Lawyer Chat Initiative Receives Spark Award Angela C. Winfield, Esq. | Hiscock Barclay, PLLC at Law) met with students during this inaugural half-day event. A new initiative of the Onondaga County “Lawyer Chat” was a tremendous success and well-received by all Bar Association’s Committee on Diversity involved. The nearly 75 students reached were genuinely eager and Inclusion called “Lawyer Chat” has to speak with lawyers about opportunities in the law and the been selected to receive the Manufacturers participating attorneys enjoyed engaging with youth and getting a Association of Central New York (“MACNY”) better understanding of students’ concerns about the law and legal Partners for Education and Business (“PEB”)’s profession.