Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study Elkhart County, Indiana
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study Elkhart County, Indiana May 2011 Prepared for: Simonton Lake Home Owners Association c/o William Broderick 1424 Johnson St. Elkhart, IN 46514 Prepared by: 708 Roosevelt Road Walkerton, Indiana 46574 (574) 586-3400 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Simonton Lake is a 301 acre (121.8 hectares) groundwater fed lake located in the northwest portion of Elkhart County Indiana. The Simonton Lake watershed extends north of Simonton Lake into Cass County, Michigan and encompasses approximately 5,233 acres (2,177.7 ha). The lake drains south through Lilly Creek (Osolo Township Ditch) into the St. Joseph River then to Lake Michigan. The soils surrounding the lake are primarily sands from glacial outwash or low muck areas that are wetlands. Soil erosion is not an issue as there are no permanently flowing surface streams entering Simonton Lake. Historically, the watershed was primarily upland deciduous forest pocketed with prairie, sedge meadow, swamp, and seeps. The watershed is now approximately 60 percent agricultural and 40 percent low intensity residential development, with residents in the vicinity of the lake connected to sewers since 1999-2000. A review of residential development around the lake noted 20 structures in 1939 on the south side of the west basin. By 1951, North Shore Drive had been extended to the narrows with over 30 homes along the northern lakeshore and approximately 30 homes on the south side. Development of the channels on the east end of the east basin began in 1957. By this time, as many as 100 structures existed on the south side of the west basin. Prior to 1965, the channel between the two basins was dredged; homes were being built on the east end of the east lake, and a channel adjacent to Forest Avenue was completed. The shoreline was nearly 100% developed except for the southeast corner of the east basin by 1973. A Conservancy District was formed and the majority of residents around the lake hooked to a sewer system by 2000. Simonton Lake has a volume of approximately 2,686 acre-ft (3,313,132 m3) with a maximum depth of 24 feet (7.3 m) and a mean depth of 12.1 ft (3.7 m). Approximately 84% of the lake surface area is less than 10-feet deep with less than 6 acres (2.4 ha) deeper than 20 feet. Approximately 99% of the total volume of the lake is within the photic zone and available for growing plants. The length of the shoreline is 43,170 ft (14,073 m), which results in a development ratio of 3.6:1. The Simonton Lake fishery is dominated by bluegill, largemouth bass, and redear sunfish. The sportsman’s club stocks the lake with walleye annually. IDNR surveys from 1964-2007 indicate the fishery has remained relatively consistent in regards to dominant fish species composition, relative growth rates, and condition factors (length/weight) of those species. Bluegills and largemouth bass have exhibited average to above average growth rates. Simonton Lake has been sampled five times since 1988 for water quality. The concentration of total phosphorus has decreased steadily over the years from a mean of 0.055 mg/L in 1988, to under 0.030 mg/L in 2010; keeping overall densities of algae low. The concentration of total nitrogen has also declined due to declines in ammonia and nitrate. The lake had adequate DO in the well-mixed epilimnion, but it decreased rapidly below 16 feet in the west basin. At the 20 foot (~6 m) depth, the concentration of DO was less than 1 mg/L, which is insufficient to support fish. The 1% light level extended to 21.5 ft (~7 m) meaning 99% of the lake can support aquatic submersed vegetation. Overall, there was a nice mix of phytoplankton and zooplankton in both basins and this resulting balance is important for a healthy lake ecosystem. The water quality of Simonton Lake is much better than most of Indiana’s lakes. Simonton Lake water quality parameters place the lake in the mesotrophic range with an Indiana TSI score of 22. The total nitrogen to total phosphorus ratios of 40N:1P for the west basin and 35N:1P for the east basin show a strong phosphorus limitation, which means more phosphorus will stimulate more algae growth. The water that enters Simonton Lake stays in the lake for 1.2 years on average. JFNew Project# 0812096.00 Page i Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study May 2011 Elkhart County, Indiana The plant community was surveyed in the two basins on May 27 and August 27, 2010. Aquatic plants were found at all 70 sites and muskgrass was the dominant submersed species of 16 different species collected. Four invasive species: Eurasian water milfoil, curly leaf pondweed, brittle naiad, and spiny naiad were all found in sparse populations. The state listed threatened species, white-stem pondweed was documented during the surveys at two locations. The most common of seven emergent species documented were cattail and arrowhead. Two floating leaf species noted were spatterdock and white water lily. Secchi disc transparency depths ranging from 8.5 feet in the spring to 6.2 feet in the summer indicated good water clarity. Concerns of lake residents included overuse of the lake by nonresidents, too many boats accessing the lake, lake level control, aquatic plants in the channels, a decline in the fisheries, pier and funneling issues, water quality, and the need for dredging the channel between the lake basins. Swimming and boating are the primary uses of the lake, followed by fishing and irrigation. The public access site is located between the two lake basins on the south side of the lake. A boat count conducted by lake volunteers documented that pontoon boats were the most popular watercraft on all days. On weekdays, fishing boats are the second most common watercraft followed by speedboats. On the weekend (excluding July 3), fishing boats, speedboats, and personal watercraft have similar densities on Simonton Lake. Excluding July 3, the average number of boats on the lake was 15.6 during any one counting period. Approximately half that many were present in the morning hours with peak use occurring between 5pm and 7pm on the weekday and around 3pm on the weekend. Research suggests lake users should tolerate 6-8 pontoon boats or 3-4 high speed boats operating at the same time safely given the size of Simonton Lake. The lake may be at, or close to its socially acceptable carrying capacity for watercraft during most of the summer. The following management recommendations are suggested: 1) Limit phosphorus inputs by education of residents about fertilizer and animal waste 2) Encourage continued sewer system hookups 3) Establish and enforce an ecozone in the southeast corner of the east basin 4) Protect existing aquatic plants from damage by boat traffic 5) Encourage natural vegetated shorelines as alternatives to seawalls 6) Educate residents on invasive aquatic plants and implement monitoring & control 7) Consider dredging the channel between the basins to reduce sediment resuspension The projects selected as being feasible to implement are the establishment of an ecozone and the dredging of the channel between the two lakes. Establishing an ecozone in Simonton Lake can improve water quality and fish habitat. JFNew recommends the Simonton Lake Area Home Owners Association begin the petition process to the IDNR to create an ecozone. Dredging of the channel between the two basins will reduce sediment resuspension from watercraft. Hydraulic dredging is proposed for a maximum extent of 60,000 square feet based on a channel length of 2000 feet and a channel width of 30 feet. The estimated cost for engineering, permitting, and implementation of this dredging project is $105,000 of which potentially 80% could be paid for through the LARE program and another 10% through local in-kind services. Simonton Lake’s water quality has improved in the last 10 years and is considered to have good water quality when compared to other Midwestern lakes. This trend should continue with attention to management of phosphorus inputs from the vicinity of the lake through continued sewerage of adjacent residents, education of residents on the use of phosphorus free fertilizers, and enforcing idle speed limits in the shallow areas of the lake. Implementing the two feasible projects of an ecozone and the dredging are not critical to preserving the water quality of the lake, but would play an important role in controlling phosphorus resuspension. JFNew Project# 0812096.00 Page ii Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study May 2011 Elkhart County, Indiana ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study was completed with funding from the Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) Division of Fish and Wildlife Lake and River Enhancement Program with matching funds provided by the Simonton Lake Area Home Owners Association. JFNew appreciates the assistance received from individual Simonton Lake property owners in organizing meetings, providing a boat and driver for the plant surveys, conducting the boat counts, and attending the project meetings. We especially would like to thank Bob Putnam, Bill Broderick, and Bob Evans for their continued support of this project. William Jones, Clinical Professor of Limnology at Indiana University, was the research scientist who supervised the lake water quality data collection and analysis, completed the water budget, and contributed substantially to the summary and recommendations in the report. Individuals from JFNew that participated in the project included John Richardson, Betsy Ewoldt, Brett Peters, Erick Elgin, Tom Estrem, and Christine Dittmar. Heather Cecrle provided administrative support, review, editing, and assembly of the document. JFNew Project# 0812096.00 Page iii Simonton Lake Diagnostic/Feasibility Study May 2011 Elkhart County, Indiana TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE 1.0 INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................