DOCSLIB.ORG

Casagrande Phd Dissertation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Casagrande Phd Dissertation ECOLOGY, COGNITION, AND CULTURAL TRANSMISSION OF TZELTAL MAYA MEDICINAL PLANT KNOWLEDGE by DAVID GREGORY CASAGRANDE (Under the direction of Brent Berlin) ABSTRACT The goal of this dissertation is to explain patterns in the distribution of medicinal plant knowledge among the Tzeltal; in particular, why some plants are more likely to be known for their medicinal use than other plants. Methods included botanical collection, structured ethnobotanical surveys, landscape vegetation surveys, discourse analysis and participant observation. The explanatory approach was synthetic, drawing on notions from cultural anthropology, ethnopharmacology, ecology, cognitive science, linguistics, and studies of cultural transmission. Explanatory notions were tested by comparing Tzeltal Maya who have lived in the temperate Chiapas Highlands for many generations with other Tzeltal who have migrated from the Highlands to the lowland tropical rainforest within the last 30 years. Both study populations show patterns in which a few plants are known by every- one, but distribution of knowledge decreases as the diversity of plants increases, and most knowledge is idiosyncratic. The effects of typicality in categorization and discourse account for the few widely known plants. Humoral (hot/cold) classification is highly variable, does not facilitate recall of medicinal uses of plants, and has no significant effect on the distribution of knowledge. Cultural interpretations of plant taste and mor- phology are very important in individual cognitive models, but lose importance at the scale of shared discursive models where social and pragmatic themes also influence the dissemination of knowledge. While humoral classification and cultural interpretations of taste and morphology may be important for expert curers, they do not significantly affect the dissemination of knowledge among novices. Species that are more accessible tend to be used more often, and frequency of use is weakly correlated with knowledge distribu- tion. Emic perception of efficacy is the variable that most accounts for the distribution of knowledge. But social organization, individual cognition, and random processes in cul- tural transmission shape and bias the flow of information, and knowledge about many species that fit emic conceptions of efficacy is not distributed throughout the populations. INDEX WORDS: Chiapas, cognitive anthropology, cultural transmission, cultural models, goal-derived categories, prototypicality, distributed cognition, discourse, efficacy, ecological anthropology, ecology, ethnoecology, ethnopharmacology, ethnopharmacognosy, human ecosystems, humoral classification, indigenous knowledge, information, Maya, medical an- thropology, medical ethnobotany, medicinal plants, Mexico, organoleptics, phytosociology, social networks, Tseltal, Tzeltal, variation, migration ECOLOGY, COGNITION, AND CULTURAL TRANSMISSION OF TZELTAL MAYA MEDICINAL PLANT KNOWLEDGE by DAVID GREGORY CASAGRANDE B.S., Southern Connecticut State University, 1984 M.F.S., Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, 1996 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY ATHENS, GEORGIA 2002 © 2001 David Gregory Casagrande All Rights Reserved ECOLOGY, COGNITION, AND CULTURAL TRANSMISSION OF TZELTAL MAYA MEDICINAL PLANT KNOWLEDGE by DAVID GREGORY CASAGRANDE Approved: Major Professor: Brent Berlin Committee: Elois Ann Berlin Ben Blount Steve Kowalewski David Giannasi Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia December 2002 Dedication To Donna, whose patience and courage made this dissertation possible. And to my parents, Guido and Dorothy, for their enduring belief in my ability to do whatever I choose. iv Acknowledgments I am deeply grateful to Elois Ann and Brent Berlin for their advice and insights regarding research and life in general, and for providing access to the PROCOMITH data- base. Their generosity, patience, and steadfast commitment to their students, regardless of whatever difficult times may be at hand, serve as a model for all of us. I am also deeply grateful to my other doctoral committee members, Ben Blount, Steve Kowalewski and David Giannasi. All of their advice and comments over the years, however subtle, have contributed to this work. I am also forever indebted to the people of Nabil, Ch’ixaltontik, Tenejapa center, Maravilla Tenejapa, Salto de Agua, and Nueva Matsab for their hospitality, curiosity, will- ingness to share ideas and adventures, and all-around goodwill. Because of political ten- sions that continue to plague the Maya communities, I have decided not to list names. But I especially appreciate the efforts of my host family in Nabil, who opened their home and hearts to my colleagues and me. I am also grateful to those who assisted me with field research, transcription, and translation. I would like to thank the administration, staff and faculty of El Colegio de la Frontera Sur in San Cristóbal for agreeing to sponsor me as a visiting researcher and for their gener- ous help over the years. In particular, Dr. Mario González-Espinosa, the library staff, and Dr. Mario Ishiki and the staff of the herbarium have all been very helpful. One of the great advantages of choosing Highland Chiapas as a field site was the ability to share resources, ideas, and advice about research with other students and researchers while in the field. I am especially grateful to have had the opportunity to work in the field with Aaron Lampman, Cameron Adams, Anna Waldstein, George Luber, Scott Taylor, Rick Stepp, Tania Cruz Salazar, Stephanie Paladino, and Becky Zarger. v I am also grateful to have inherited the ability to build on a long tradition of research of Tzeltal medicine beginning with the work of Duane Metzger and Gerald Williams, and continuing with the work of Elois Ann and Brent Berlin and that of their students: John Brett, who studied the role of organoleptics; Luisa Maffi, who documented Tzeltal illness classification; George Luber, for his work on explanatory models; and Rick Stepp, who studied the effects of vegetation disturbance and habitats. Without the cumulative results of their meticulous work and thoughtful insights I simply would not have had the opportunity to ask the questions that I did in this dissertation I would also like to thank John Brett, Dan Moerman, and Glenn Shepard for sharing their insights about my research during the 2000 AAA meetings. Thanks also to George Luber and Rick Stepp for sharing their archival data and obscure literary sources with me. Some of the ideas in this dissertation, especially the themes of synthesis, the new ecology, and information, can be attributed to my participation in the Human Ecosystems Group at the University of Georgia. I would especially like to acknowledge the inspiration and advice provided by Dr. Charles Peters, who always admonished the need to “take the next step,” and Becky Zarger for her help and advice regarding cultural transmission. Other group members that I have not already thanked above include Eric Jones, Mitch Pavao- Zuckerman, Felice Wyndham, Suzanne Joseph, and Warren Roberts. This dissertation research was funded primarily by a National Science Foundation Doctoral Dissertation Improvement Award (BCS-0079499). Additional funding was pro- vided by the National Science Foundation Ethnographic Research Training Program ad- ministered through the University of Georgia, the UGA Maya International Collaborative Biodiversity Group, and a UGA Center for Latin American and Caribbean Studies Disserta- tion Travel Award. vi Table of Contents Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................. v Introduction......................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1 Ethnographic and Ecological Context..............................................................10 Chapter 2 Basic Methods and Fundamental Patterns of Knowledge Distribution...........41 Chapter 3 Epidemiological Context and Tzeltal Illness Classification............................59 Chapter 4 Knowledge Distribution and Emic Perceptions of Efficacy ............................81 Chapter 5 Salient Plant Characteristics and Medicinal Plant Knowledge........ ................99 Chapter 6 Humoral Classification, Mnemonics, and Knowledge Distribution.............122 Chapter 7 Effects of Medicinal Plant Abundance and Frequency of Use on Knowledge Distribution......................................................................................137 Chapter 8 The Influence of Individual and Distributed Cognitive Processes on Patterns of Agreement about Medicinal Plants...................................................152 Chapter 9 Structured Bias and Stochasticity in Cultural Transmission as the Primary Constraints of Knowledge Distribution.................................................207 Chapter 10 Conclusion: Major Findings and Significance for Ethnopharmacology and Ecological Anthropology...............................................................................247 References Cited..............................................................................................................261 Appendix A. Questions Asked During Structured Ethnobotanical Interviews................279 Appendix B. Plants Reported as Medicinal by two or more Interviewees
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Botanischer Garten Der Universität Tübingen
    Botanischer Garten der Universität Tübingen 1974 – 2008 2 System FRANZ OBERWINKLER Emeritus für Spezielle Botanik und Mykologie Ehemaliger Direktor des Botanischen Gartens 2016 2016 zur Erinnerung an LEONHART FUCHS (1501-1566), 450. Todesjahr 40 Jahre Alpenpflanzen-Lehrpfad am Iseler, Oberjoch, ab 1976 20 Jahre Förderkreis Botanischer Garten der Universität Tübingen, ab 1996 für alle, die im Garten gearbeitet und nachgedacht haben 2 Inhalt Vorwort ...................................................................................................................................... 8 Baupläne und Funktionen der Blüten ......................................................................................... 9 Hierarchie der Taxa .................................................................................................................. 13 Systeme der Bedecktsamer, Magnoliophytina ......................................................................... 15 Das System von ANTOINE-LAURENT DE JUSSIEU ................................................................. 16 Das System von AUGUST EICHLER ....................................................................................... 17 Das System von ADOLF ENGLER .......................................................................................... 19 Das System von ARMEN TAKHTAJAN ................................................................................... 21 Das System nach molekularen Phylogenien ........................................................................ 22
    [Show full text]
  • Wood Anatomy of Onagraceae, with Notes on Alternative Modes of Photosynthate Movement in Dicotyledon Woods
    WOOD ANATOMY OF ONAGRACEAE, WITH NOTES ON ALTERNATIVE MODES OF PHOTOSYNTHATE MOVEMENT IN DICOTYLEDON WOODS SHERWIN CARLQUIST Reprinted from ANNALS OF THE MISSOURI BOTANICAL GARDEN Vol. 62, No. 2, 1975 pp. 386-424 Made in United States of America WOOD ANATOMY OF ONAGRACEAE, WITH NOTES ON ALTERNATIVE MODES OF PHOTOSYNTHATE MOVEMENT IN DICOTYLEDON WOODS SHERWIN CARLQUIST Reprinted from ANNALS OF THE MISSOURI BOTANICAL GARDEN Vol. 62, No. 2, 1975 pp. 386-424 Made in United States of America WOOD ANATOMY OF ONAGRACEAE, WITH NOTES ON ALTERNATIVE MODES OF PHOTOSYNTHATE MOVEMENT IN DICOTYLEDON WOODS' SHEHWTN CARLQUIST2 ABSTRACT Vessel elements in Onagraceae correlate perfectly with groups of species; elements are long and wide in mesomorphic species, shortest and narrowest in the most xeromorphic species. Libriforra fibers in the family are thin-walled, hut many have gelatinous inner walls. The possibility that these represent not tension wood hut a water-storage mechanism is examined. Libriform fibers are mostly septate or nucleate or hoth in the family; this indicates longevity and simulation ol parenchyma in starch-stora.ue hmction. These fibers may compensate for the paucity of axial parenchyma. Interxylary phloem ("included phloem") does not occur in Fuchsia. Hauya, and Ludwigia, the genera in the family most generalized in other respects, and is absent in most annuals studied. Selective pressure for formation of interxylary phloem in the three genera may be minimal because of slow rates of photosynthate translocation within wood and selective pressure for formation of interxylary phloem in annuals may be minimal for spatial reasons. Interxylary phloem may be related to massive flowering that draws rapidly on stored starch, chiefly in the shrubby perennials.
    [Show full text]
  • Plants of the Humboldt State University Campus
    Humboldt State University Digital Commons @ Humboldt State University Botanical Studies Open Educational Resources and Data 2014 Plants of the Humboldt State University Campus James P. Smith Jr Humboldt State University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.humboldt.edu/botany_jps Part of the Botany Commons Recommended Citation Smith, James P. Jr, "Plants of the Humboldt State University Campus" (2014). Botanical Studies. 6. https://digitalcommons.humboldt.edu/botany_jps/6 This Humboldt State University Campus is brought to you for free and open access by the Open Educational Resources and Data at Digital Commons @ Humboldt State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Botanical Studies by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Humboldt State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. PLANTS OF THE HUMBOLDT STATE UNIVERSITY CAMPUS James P. Smith, Jr. Professor Emeritus of Botany Department of Biological Sciences Humboldt State University Arcata, California 17 December 2014 The purpose of this checklist is an accounting of the original atlas and they also found a number of new flowering plants, conifers, and ferns that occur on the plants on the campus. Humboldt State University campus. Most of the plants are ornamentals; a few are native species. The plants themselves are shown in two formats. In List 1, they are arranged first by botanical groups From a botanical standpoint, the most outstanding (ferns, conifers, and their allies, and flowering feature of our campus flora is its conifer collection, plants), and then alphabetically by plant family and due largely to the dedication and efforts of Dennis K.
    [Show full text]
  • Revised Classification of the Onagraceae
    Chylismia brevipes subsp. brevipes [Illustration by Alice Tangerini, based on Beatley 7918 (US) and colored in Adobe PhotoShop CS using images from CalPhoto (J. Andre, image 01040887; C. Cloud-Hughes, images 07040686 and 07040690)]. SYSTEMATIC BOTANY MONOGRAPHS VOLUME 83 Revised Classification of the Onagraceae Warren L. Wagner Peter C. Hoch Peter H. Raven THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF PLANT TAXONOMISTS 17 September 2007 SYSTEMATIC BOTANY MONOGRAPHS ISSN 0737-8211 Copyright © 2007 The American Society of Plant Taxonomists All rights reserved ISBN 0-912861-83-5 ISBN 978-0-912861-83-8 Printed in the United States of America Editor CHRISTIANE ANDERSON University of Michigan Herbarium 3600 Varsity Drive Ann Arbor, Michigan 48108-2287 Editorial Committee BRUCE G. BALDWIN JOHN V. F REUDENSTEIN University of California, Berkeley The Ohio State University LYNN BOHS DAVID M. JOHNSON University of Utah Ohio Wesleyan University DAVID E. BOUFFORD DONALD H. LES Harvard University University of Connecticut GREGORY K. BROWN THOMAS A. RANKER University of Wyoming University of Colorado REVISED CLASSIFICATION OF THE ONAGRACEAE Warren L. Wagner Department of Botany, MRC 166 Smithsonian Institution, P. O. Box 37012 Washington, DC 20013-7012 Peter C. Hoch Peter H. Raven Missouri Botanical Garden P. O. Box 299 St. Louis, Missouri 63166-0299 ABSTRACT. Recent molecular phylogenetic analyses in the plant family Onagraceae support the need for revisions in the family classification. In this paper we briefly survey the history of generic and suprageneric clas- sification in Onagraceae, summarize our knowledge of the morphological and molecular variation in the family in a phylogenetic context, and propose a revised classification that reflects that phylogeny.
    [Show full text]
  • Ecology, Cognition, and Cultural Transmission of Tzeltal
    ECOLOGY, COGNITION, AND CULTURAL TRANSMISSION OF TZELTAL MAYA MEDICINAL PLANT KNOWLEDGE by DAVID GREGORY CASAGRANDE (Under the direction of Brent Berlin) ABSTRACT The goal of this dissertation is to explain patterns in the distribution of medicinal plant knowledge among the Tzeltal; in particular, why some plants are more likely to be known for their medicinal use than other plants. Methods included botanical collection, structured ethnobotanical surveys, landscape vegetation surveys, discourse analysis and participant observation. The explanatory approach was synthetic, drawing on notions from cultural anthropology, ethnopharmacology, ecology, cognitive science, linguistics, and studies of cultural transmission. Explanatory notions were tested by comparing Tzeltal Maya who have lived in the temperate Chiapas Highlands for many generations with other Tzeltal who have migrated from the Highlands to the lowland tropical rainforest within the last 30 years. Both study populations show patterns in which a few plants are known by every- one, but distribution of knowledge decreases as the diversity of plants increases, and most knowledge is idiosyncratic. The effects of typicality in categorization and discourse account for the few widely known plants. Humoral (hot/cold) classification is highly variable, does not facilitate recall of medicinal uses of plants, and has no significant effect on the distribution of knowledge. Cultural interpretations of plant taste and mor- phology are very important in individual cognitive models, but lose importance at the scale of shared discursive models where social and pragmatic themes also influence the dissemination of knowledge. While humoral classification and cultural interpretations of taste and morphology may be important for expert curers, they do not significantly affect the dissemination of knowledge among novices.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Non-Native Plants in the Integration of Non-Native Phytophagous Invertebrates in Native Food Webs
    The role of non-native plants in the integration of non-native phytophagous invertebrates in native food webs Submitted by Sally Luker, to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Biological Sciences in August 2020. This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and that any material that has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University has been acknowledged. Signature………………………………………………… Thesis outline 2 Thesis outline Abstract This thesis brings together a series of studies, examining the role of non-native plants in the integration of non-native invertebrates in native food webs. I use data from comprehensive surveys of formally-planted gardens to investigate the efficacy of straightforward measures of non-native plant presence and/or landscape parameters, as reliable predictors of non-native invertebrate presence, finding that non-native invertebrate richness increases with non-native plant species richness, with invertebrates showing a clear preference for woody plants. I then use the context of metapopulation theory to explore the facilitative role of non-native plants in the ability of a non-native invertebrate to persist within a community, finding that where host- plant habitat patches are closer together, the likelihood of a patch being occupied is greater, especially if the patch is occupied but that this effect is not universal, with species-specific effects present also.
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title A Physiological Approach to the Ecology and Evolution of Flowers Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9gc2x64j Author Roddy, Adam Bryant Publication Date 2015 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California A Physiological Approach to the Ecology and Evolution of Flowers By Adam Bryant Roddy A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Integrative Biology in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Todd E. Dawson, Chair Professor David D. Ackerly Professor Paul V. A. Fine Professor Dennis D. Baldocchi Spring 2015 A Physiological Approach to the Ecology and Evolution of Flowers Copyright 2015 by Adam Bryant Roddy Abstract A Physiological Approach to the Ecology and Evolution of Flowers by Adam Bryant Roddy Doctor of Philosophy in Integrative Biology University of California, Berkeley Professor Todd E. Dawson, Chair Flowers have long been considered one of the hallmarks of angiosperm evolution. They are morphologically complex structures that both promote efficient pollination and protect the developing embryo. When it was championed in 1793 by Christian Konrad Sprengel, this view of the role of flowers in reproduction, however, was highly controversial: how could a form so beautiful and pure as a flower ever be involved in something as vulgar as reproduction? Sprengel and his predecessor, Josef Köhlreuter, are considered the founders of pollination biology, and their work set the stage for that of Charles Darwin nearly a century later. Darwin saw the interaction between flowers and their pollinators as a prime example of the power of natural selection.
    [Show full text]