Adapting the Environment Ranching, Irrigation, and Dry Land Farming in Southern Alberta, 1880-1914
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Great Plains Quarterly Great Plains Studies, Center for 1986 ADAPTING THE ENVIRONMENT RANCHING, IRRIGATION, AND DRY LAND FARMING IN SOUTHERN ALBERTA, 1880-1914 A. A. Den Otter Memorial University of Newfoundland Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly Part of the Other International and Area Studies Commons Den Otter, A. A., "ADAPTING THE ENVIRONMENT RANCHING, IRRIGATION, AND DRY LAND FARMING IN SOUTHERN ALBERTA, 1880-1914" (1986). Great Plains Quarterly. 982. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly/982 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Great Plains Studies, Center for at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Great Plains Quarterly by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. ADAPTING THE ENVIRONMENT RANCHING, IRRIGATION, AND DRY LAND FARMING IN SOUTHERN ALBERTA, 1880-1914 A. A. DEN OTTER For centuries the nutntlous grasses of the H. Y. Hind, and the British group, under the southwestern fringe of the Canadian prairies command of Captain John Palliser, identified a supported an abundance of game, providing fertile belt along the Saskatchewan River and a ample food for its nomadic peoples. Not until large arid region to the south (fig. 1).3 The the middle of the nineteenth century did prairies, an environment to be adapted to anyone look to this area as a farming frontier. l perceived needs, had taken on new economic By the 1850s, however, the curiosity of Ca value, a utility that could be realized only nadians about it was increased by a need for through exploitation. new territories for investment, scientific esti Acquiring the Northwest from the Hud mates that the land was more favorable for son's Bay Company took a decade and wrest agriculture than had previously been believed, ing the land from the native peoples another.4 and the fiery rhetoric of expansionist journal Once Canadian ownership was secured, the ists. 2 The need for more accurate knowledge struggle for control and means of exploitation prompted the Canadian and British govern continued. The government land policy as set ments to send scientific expeditions to Rupert's forth in the Dominion Lands Act called for Land, the vast area that drained into Hudson's the settlement of one family on every two Bay. The Canadian party, led by geologist quarter sections of land, but some areas of the prairies were unsuited for intensive cultiva tion. The extent of the barren land, soon Associate professor of history at the Memorial known as Palliser's Triangle, varied with the University of Newfoundland, A.A. den Otter has attitude of the speaker toward colonization of published many articles on western Canadian the West. In the southwestern fringe of the energy and transportation issues. His major book, prairies, which was semiarid, ranchers argued Civilizing the West: The Gaits and the Devel that the habitat was ideally suited for grazing, opment of Western Canada, was published in that it required no investment to adapt it for 1982. utilization. Farmers, on the other hand, in sisted that with modern irrigation techniques [GPQ 6 (Summer 1986): 171-189.] the environment could accommodate inten- 171 172 GREAT PLAINS QUARTERLY, SUMMER 1986 57"_------.-----__~ ______ I 1 ! \ \\ 100 200 MI 100 200 300 Kr'l FIG. l. Vegetation Zones: Western Canada. sive cultivation. Complicating the debate, habitable. Desiring to build the shortest line promoters of dry land farming declared that practical, as close to their American rivals as their techniques were capable of farming the possible, the directors of the Canadian Pacific wilderness. So there were three views of the Railway eagerly accepted Macoun's enthusias land's arability. Proposed land use defined the tic appraisal. They routed the CPR through character of the habitat. Supporting the feder the southern prairies, the heart of Palliser's al government's search for new lands, Canadi Triangle.6 Forced to defend the CPR's route an officials of the International Boundary change, Sir Charles Tupper, the minister of Survey and the North West Mounted Police railways and canals, gushed exuberantly, "We agreed that, except for some undefined "lim believe we have [on the prairies] the garden of ited area," the western plains were suitable for the world," a view readily parroted by his agriculture.s Conservative colleagues. 7 Compelled by the Plans for a transcontinental railway dis change in railway plans to examine the south solved the last doubts about the arability of ern plains, the department asserted that ap the plains. Defiant of all geographical barriers pearances were deceiving and argued con and immune to most weather conditions, the descendingly that an experienced surveyor railway assumed a mythical status so intense could recognize fertile land where a newcomer that many promoters accepted the most opti might see only barren country.8 mistic assessments of the territories through The official assessment of western climate which they projected their routes. The lush and soil fertility was made by outsiders who ness of the prairies during a particularly wet imposed upon the region an image colored by cycle at the end of the 1870s prompted John their agricultural interests. Tragically, the Macoun, an irrepressible botanist, to declare white comer's ethos discounted the value of that virtually all the northwestern interior was the landscape's natural life, and soon his SOUTHERN ALBERTA 173 efficient guns destroyed the abundant game warm Chinook winds regularly melted the that had blanketed the grasslands while sur snow cover." Utilizing their political influence, veys and railways transformed the commonly a small number of central Canadian and held expanse into privately owned real estate.9 British businessmen extracted large grazing Starvation forced the original prairie people to leases from the Dominion government (fig. 3). abandon their traditional way of life and By 1887, barely a dozen big companies occu accept integration into a new economy. 10 pied nearly ten million acres of prime grass lands, a development ideally suited to the semiarid ecology but clearly contrary to the CA TILE RANCHING government's homestead policy and an offense For several decades, cattie ranchers filled to land-hungry settlers. II the vacuum left by the disbanded natives and The privileged position of the ranchers decimated game. The same physical features sparked a bitter struggle for control of western that had sustained wildlife proved ideal for lands. When the North West Mounted Police pastoral use (fig. 2). Nutritious shortgrasses evicted several squatters from the grazing furnished abundant food throughout the sum leases, public reaction was so hostile that in mer, numerous coulees and river valleys pro 1892 the government opened the leases to vided shelter from vicious winter storms, while settlement. It also required the ranchers to FIG. 2. The prairie grasslands were ideally suited for grazing. Public Archives of Canada. 174 GREAT PLAINS QUARTERLY, SUMMER 1986 110° --------1"" FIG. 3. Southern Alberta: Leased Grazing Lands 1886. purchase at least one-tenth of their leases at prairies. li Pearce warned the government that $1.20 an acre, a concession that the affluent squatters were fencing off rich riverbottom among them quickly accepted. I] lands and lake shores. Fences rendered useless Undaunted, the ranchers developed a thousands of acres of surrounding semiarid more effective means of maintaining control grasslands by preventing cattle from reaching over the rangelands. A key player in the these rivers, lakes, or sloughs for water or formation and implementation of this strategy shelter. Arguing that the government should was William Pearce, nominally the Dominion protect the ranching industry, Pearce sug government's inspector of mines but actually gested reserving from settlement all lands its general agent in the Northwest. A surveyor surrounding crucial bodies of water in the by training, Pearce had an unusual apprecia Calgary, Macleod, and Medicine Hat trian tion of conservation and planning. Believing gle.'1; that reckless and destructive exploitation of Deferring to the politically powerful ranch prairie soil could destroy that invaluable ers, the Conservative government in Decem natural resource, he called for its wise and ber 1886 declared that large sections of the systematic utilization. 14 In the mid-1880's, with southwestern prairies were closed to agricultur the enthusiastic backing of the ranchers, he al settlement." William Pearce applied this launched a vigorous campaign for the creation policy in uncompromising fashion, evicting of stock water reserves on the semiarid western numerous squatters from the water reserves, SOUTHERN ALBERTA 175 seldom bothering with cumbersome court bonus in alternate townships rather than the proceedings. When written warnings failed to prescribed sections. 21 Despite the unusual dislodge squatters, he encouraged ranchers, concession, the company could not compete under police supervision, to pull down farm with the government's generous leasing policy; buildings. lo Although these tactics aroused by 1889, the company had sold less than an bitter resentment, Pearce never doubted that eighth of its grazing land and was looking for they were necessary to save the range for profitable optionsY One alternative