Complete Streets Design and Implementation Plan
June 2019 This report has been prepared under the direction of the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority (NJTPA) with financing by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) and the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) of the U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT). This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the USDOT in the interest of information exchange. The NJTPA is solely responsible for its contents. The NJTPA is the federally authorized Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) for the 13-county northern New Jersey region—home to 6.7 million people. It evaluates and approves transportation improvement projects, provides a forum for cooperative transportation planning, sponsors and conducts studies, assists county and city planning agencies, and monitors compliance with air quality goals. CONTENTS Executive Summary ...... i Introduction ...... 1 Foundations...... 7 Public Engagement ...... 11 Street Design Guide...... 13 Street Typology ...... 13 Street Design Elements...... 21 Pedestrian Realm...... 23 Travelway...... 29 Traffic Calming Toolbox...... 33 Green Lanes...... 35 Curbside Zone Management...... 39 Intersection Toolbox...... 43 Green Infrastructure...... 49 Special Focus Overlays...... 53 Observer Highway...... 55 4th/5th and 8th/9th Streets...... 57 11th and 12th Streets...... 59 15th Street Redevelopment ...... 61 Washington Street...... 63 Frank Sinatra Drive...... 65 Green Circuit...... 67 Implementation...... 69 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Purpose The Hoboken Street Design Guide (Design Guide) provides policy and design guidance for governmental agencies, consultants, private developers, community groups, and all others involved in street design decisions. The overarching goal of this manual is to help improve the safety and accessibility of streets for all users, regardless of age, ability, income, ethnicity, or travel mode. Overall, this Design Guide represents the City of Hoboken’s intent to design its publicly-owned streets to support safe, affordable, equitable, and healthy mobility options. This initiative embraces design as a method to advance the health and safety of the community, while promoting diverse transportation options and vibrant public spaces. What are Complete Streets? Complete Streets are designed to enable safe use and support mobility for all users and transportation modes. By prioritizing safety and accessibility, Complete Streets make it simple and inviting to cross the street, commute to work by bicycle, or access a bus stop, while also accommodating motor vehicle travel. To achieve this, a combination of physical street design features, enforcement of regulations and traffic laws, and effective street operations is required. Process Overview The 10-month process to develop the Hoboken Street Design Guide began in mid-2018 and concluded with the publication of this report in 2019. While primarily a technical process, the development of the Design Guide also incorporated input from local residents and stakeholders that was gathered through online surveys and public events and established partnerships with local and regional planning partners. Additionally, the project team conducted research on national best practices, local needs, and challenges. Who was Involved? The Hoboken Street Design Guide was a collaborative planning process between the North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority (NJTPA) and the City of Hoboken. Together, these partner agencies ensured that the guidelines and policies contained in this document were tailored for the unique mobility needs of Hoboken while also serving as regional best practices for other communities. Street Typology A typology refers to a categorization of items that have similar characteristics. To apply consistent design elements across similar streets, the Hoboken Street Design Guide groups all Hoboken streets into select typologies based upon width, use, and purpose within the overall transportation network. Often, streets are organized by community characteristics; however, this approach is less useful in Hoboken given the City’s compact and consistent urban character. Since most of Hoboken’s streets have reached their full width—except in places where redevelopment is planned to occur—an approach to classifying streets on the basis of physical characteristics and their purpose within the larger network was applied.
i North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Figure 1 Street Typology Map
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken ii Hoboken’s streets have been grouped into three different street typologies: • Neighborhood Streets: local connectors to community destinations, typically providing slower travel speeds due to short blocks, narrow right-of-way, and frequent parking • Community Corridors: primary community streets that connect neighborhoods while accommodating parking, loading zones, green lanes, and many forms of activities EXECUTIVE SUMMARY • Gateway Streets: streets that carry high traffic volumes, including freight traffic, through Hoboken to points outside the City Profiles of these street typologies are presented to provide guidance on the appropriate type of facilities, design treatments, and amenities that should be applied to these corridor types. Street Design Elements This Design Guide addresses all elements within the public right-of-way, including the travelway and the public realm. In Hoboken, this typically includes everything between the building facades on either side of the street, such as sidewalks, street trees and landscaping, parking, green lanes, and travel lanes. Each of these elements has been examined in detail and specific guidance have been provided for each street typology. Figure 2 below shows a typical street cross-section and all its elements addressed in this manual. Figure 2 Street Design Elements
PEDESTRIAN TRAVELWAY PEDESTRIAN REALM REALM
Special Focus Overlays Every community has unique places that require special treatment, such as waterfronts, parks, historic destinations, primary streets, and premium transit hubs. There are also areas that are more likely to experience change, such as places near significant community investment centers, places adjacent to community amenities and areas that have been planned for revitalization and redevelopment. While a consistent transportation strategy is important, these special focus areas require a departure from the norm to acknowledge, protect, and elevate the characteristics that make them unique.
iii North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Early in the process, several corridors that act as Hoboken’s primary streets were identified as “Special Focus Overlays” for their unique contributions to the community. These corridors connect neighborhoods to commercial services, schools, parks, and the Hudson River Waterfront. Given their opportunity to impact mobility and placemaking in a transformative manner, investments in these corridors should be a high priority for Hoboken. Special focus overlays were applied to the following corridors: • Observer Highway • Washington Street • 4th/5th Street and 8th/9th Streets • 11th/12th Streets • 15th Street The Design Guide provides long-term visions for the opportunities available in these corridors to improve mobility as well as the priorities that should guide future improvements in these areas. Green Infrastructure Green infrastructure is an approach to water management that uses natural processes to capture, store, and filter stormwater. This is especially important in coastal areas like Hoboken, which experiences recurrent flooding. The City can incrementally improve its stormwater management capabilities by incorporating these methods into future street improvement projects. Additionally, green infrastructure can enhance aesthetics and greenery in Hoboken. Within the right- of-way, there are several opportunities to include green infrastructure as street projects are designed and implemented. The most common opportunities in Hoboken include bioswales, permeable pavement, and stormwater trees. The Design Guide offers some guidance on each of these treatments as well as references that provide more detailed information Implementation Implementing the guidelines in this manual is critical to improving transportation equity, safety, and mobility in Hoboken. The goals, guidelines, and design techniques presented in this Design Guide should be incorporated into all roadway design projects, roadway maintenance, major development and redevelopment projects, and streetscaping projects. An action plan is provided to act as a roadmap to ensure that the Complete Streets vision is fully implemented throughout the City and becomes foundational to all projects moving forward Priority action items for implementing the Hoboken Street Design Guide are: • Adopt an updated Complete Streets Policy • Make the necessary regulatory changes • Adopt a Complete Streets and green infrastructure checklist • Leverage quick-build and pilot projects • Develop a Vision Zero action plan • Document success
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken iv Consolidated Street Design Table The table below lists the recommended dimensions and uses for each of the street design elements contained within this Design Guide. More information is provided throughout the document.
Table 1 Consolidated Street Design Table
Pedestrian Realm Curbside Zone EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Green Lane Travel Lane Furnishing Zone Street Type Frontage Zone Through Zone Transit Treatment Parking Flex Zone (Priority treatments)
Use: Stoops, awnings, Street trees (smaller), Parallel parking, 7 to 8 feet width fenced-in small yards overhead utilities, and on both sides of the streets, except Desired width: 10 feet bioswales where preempted by other uses such Neighborhood Width: No more than Green-backed shared lane Streets as curb extensions and parklets markings recommended the maximum width Minimum width: 5 feet Desired width: 3 feet of other stoops on the Permeable pavement should be same block OR 3 feet Minimum width: 2 feet considered Dynamic spaces that are delineated for freight loading Striped lanes, buffered lanes, and unloading and rideshare/ Travel Lane: Street trees (larger, or protected bike lanes where taxi pickup and drop off Recommended width: 11 frequent), bike racks, space permits feet; decorative lighting, Guidance: One every Permeable pavement in benches, bioswales, other block at a minimum; Minimum width: 10 feet Space dedicated to bus protected bike lanes should trash cans, mailboxes, located at the beginning or pickup/drop off at all far-side be considered Community bike share stations, end of parking spaces Turn Lane: Not recommended intersections with marked transit stops, and Recommended lane width: Corridors transit stops shelters 6 feet Parallel parking, 7 to 8 feet width Desired width: 3 feet on both sides of the streets, except Minimum width: 4 feet Use: Stoops, awnings, On streets with special focus where preempted by other uses fenced-in small yards, Minimum width: 2 Buffer or protection width: overlay, transit only lanes or landscaping, café seating feet Permeable pavement should be 3 feet recommended, 1.5- Desired width: 10 feet queue jump lanes may be considered feet minimum Width: No more than considered Minimum width: 6 feet the maximum width On streets with mobility corridor Protected bike lanes of other stoops on the overlays and with sufficient width, recommended Street trees (larger, same block OR 3 feet angled parking may be considered Travel Lane: frequent), bike racks, Permeable pavement in Recommended width: 11 bioswales, trash protected bike lanes should feet; cans, mailboxes, bike Not recommended due to be considered share stations, transit traffic volumes, but can be Minimum width: 10 feet Gateway Streets Recommended stops,shelters, and considered on an as-needed lane width: 5 feet public art basis Turn Lane: Maximum one turn lane per intersection approach Minimum width: 4 feet Desired width: 3 feet if analysis is warranted by an engineering study Minimum width: 2 feet Buffer or protection width: 3 feet recommended, 1.5- feet minimum
v North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Pedestrian Realm Curbside Zone Green Lane Travel Lane Furnishing Zone Street Type Frontage Zone Through Zone Transit Treatment Parking Flex Zone (Priority treatments)
Use: Stoops, awnings, Street trees (smaller), Parallel parking, 7 to 8 feet width fenced-in small yards overhead utilities, and on both sides of the streets, except Desired width: 10 feet bioswales where preempted by other uses such Neighborhood Width: No more than Green-backed shared lane Streets as curb extensions and parklets markings recommended the maximum width Minimum width: 5 feet Desired width: 3 feet of other stoops on the Permeable pavement should be same block OR 3 feet Minimum width: 2 feet considered Dynamic spaces that are delineated for freight loading Striped lanes, buffered lanes, and unloading and rideshare/ Travel Lane: Street trees (larger, or protected bike lanes where taxi pickup and drop off Recommended width: 11 frequent), bike racks, space permits feet; decorative lighting, Guidance: One every Permeable pavement in benches, bioswales, other block at a minimum; Minimum width: 10 feet Space dedicated to bus protected bike lanes should trash cans, mailboxes, located at the beginning or pickup/drop off at all far-side be considered Community bike share stations, end of parking spaces Turn Lane: Not recommended intersections with marked transit stops, and Recommended lane width: Corridors transit stops shelters 6 feet Parallel parking, 7 to 8 feet width Desired width: 3 feet on both sides of the streets, except Minimum width: 4 feet Use: Stoops, awnings, On streets with special focus where preempted by other uses fenced-in small yards, Minimum width: 2 Buffer or protection width: overlay, transit only lanes or landscaping, café seating feet Permeable pavement should be 3 feet recommended, 1.5- Desired width: 10 feet queue jump lanes may be considered feet minimum Width: No more than considered Minimum width: 6 feet the maximum width On streets with mobility corridor Protected bike lanes of other stoops on the overlays and with sufficient width, recommended Street trees (larger, same block OR 3 feet angled parking may be considered Travel Lane: frequent), bike racks, Permeable pavement in Recommended width: 11 bioswales, trash protected bike lanes should feet; cans, mailboxes, bike Not recommended due to be considered share stations, transit traffic volumes, but can be Minimum width: 10 feet Gateway Streets Recommended stops,shelters, and considered on an as-needed lane width: 5 feet public art basis Turn Lane: Maximum one turn lane per intersection approach Minimum width: 4 feet Desired width: 3 feet if analysis is warranted by an engineering study Minimum width: 2 feet Buffer or protection width: 3 feet recommended, 1.5- feet minimum
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken vi INTRODUCTION
Purpose The Hoboken Street Design Guide (Design Guide) is a roadmap that provides policy and design guidance to all parties involved in street design decisions, including governmental agencies, consultants, private developers, and community groups. The overall goal of this Design Guide is to support development of streets that are safe and accessible for all users. Overall, this Design Guide represents an intent by the City of Hoboken to devote its publicly-owned streets to provide affordable, equitable, and healthy mobility options. This initiative embraces design as a tool to advance the health and safety of the community, while promoting sustainable transportation options and vibrant public spaces. This document will enable planners, engineers, and policy makers to identify context-sensitive street elements that are consistent with Complete Streets best practices and suitable for Hoboken’s unique context. This Design Guide provides information on the City’s adopted street typology and contains specific guidance on the appropriate bicycle, pedestrian, transit, and travelway treatments to apply within each street type. The manual’s criteria and guidance is intended to support the City’s implementation of the Complete Streets vision and assist in making incremental steps toward a safer, more equitable future.
Goals By adopting and implementing this Design Guide, the City of Hoboken will: • Improve transportation safety for all users • Increase equity and access to high quality transportation facilities • Promote transportation system effectiveness and efficiency through increased transit ridership, walking, and biking • Improve system reliability • Improve resiliency and sustainability through increased green infrastructure investments and increased access to active and shared mobility modes • Promote innovation through quick-build projects
1 North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken 2 Willow Avenue at 11th Street (Photo: Civic Eye Collaborative) Background What are Complete Streets? Complete Streets are designed to be comfortable and safe for all users, regardless of age, ability, or travel method. By prioritizing safety and accessibility, Complete Streets make it simple and inviting to cross the street, commute to work by bicycle, or access a bus stop. Achieving this includes a combination of physical
INTRODUCTION street design features, enforcement of regulations and traffic laws, and effective street operations. Thinking about streets in this way not only represents a shift in traditional design principles, but also a shift in the way one thinks about the community. As Hoboken grows, the City can no longer afford to think about streets simply as the empty space between buildings where cars are parked. Streets are community-owned spaces that can and should contribute to its vibrancy. Complete Streets in Hoboken The City of Hoboken adopted a Complete Streets resolution in 2010. While the resolution provided a general voice of support to Complete Streets principles, it also included many exceptions and generally lacked specific guidance on implementation. The City’s Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan, also adopted in 2010, provided additional details on how and where to build out the active transportation network; however, much has changed in the decade since it was adopted. Residents now have high expectations for quality bicycle and pedestrian facilities and a changing demographic mix emphasizes the importance of ensuring the safety of vulnerable populations. This Design Guide considers the difficult tradeoffs associated with balancing multiple travel modes within a limited amount of space and provides a roadmap to create a truly multimodal network that supports vibrant neighborhoods, efficient and sustainable travel patterns, and a healthy population.
3 North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Benefits of Complete Streets This Design Guide is based on the principle that Complete Streets offer many economic, social, and environmental benefits as well as improve the transportation network. These include:
Health and Safety • Complete Streets create safe environments for all users by emphasizing designs that promote slower travel speeds and positively influence travel behavior • Complete Streets create walkable and bikeable communities, which contribute to community health and active living • Complete Streets help reduce the number and severity of motor vehicle crashes when implemented properly
Equity • Complete Streets provide a more accessible transportation system for all users, regardless of age, ability, ethnicity, income, or chosen travel mode • Complete Streets enhance the safety of vulnerable populations who are more likely to rely on walking, biking, and public transit
Economy • Complete Streets increase the number of people walking and biking to local businesses, generating benefits for the local economy • Complete Streets improve affordability of transportation by reducing car-dependency and transportation cost burdens
Sustainability • Complete Streets improve air quality by decreasing the community’s dependence on motor vehicles • Complete Streets integrate green infrastructure to improve the community’s rainwater retention and stormwater management
Placemaking • Complete Streets integrate opportunities for public art, landscaping, street furniture, and increased public space to enhance the look and feel of the community
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken 4 Why now? Why Hoboken?
Hoboken is growing. According to U.S. Census Bureau estimates, Hoboken’s population increased by approximately 38 percent between 2000 and 2016 to
INTRODUCTION 53,673 people. With a growing population comes rising expectations and increased demand on the transportation system from all travel modes.
Space is limited. The City of Hoboken is only 1.28 square miles and is not getting any bigger. Since street right-of-way is the largest single land use in Hoboken (246 acres total), it is prudent to ensure this space is used in the most efficient manner possible.
We travel in a variety of ways. Hoboken has the highest transit ridership in the country (over 60 percent of workers in Hoboken commute via transit) and an increasing number of people are choosing to commute by walking or biking. City streets should be designed in a way that ensures these travelers, as well as those in vehicles, have a safe and comfortable experience.
Our community has changed. Between 2000 and 2016, Hoboken saw major growth in the number of children and young families according to the U.S. Census Bureau. This places increased importance on safe crosswalks, improved access to parks and schools, and high-quality bicycle facilities where parents are comfortable riding with their kids.
5 North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Focus on Safety According to NJDOT crash data, two pedestrians were killed and more than 250 pedestrians and bicyclists were involved in injury-causing crashes in Hoboken between 2012 and 2016. A growing community means that, every year, more commuters, children, and families use the City’s streets to walk to work, take weekend bike rides, and take family trips to the park. It is important that the City ensure those experiences remain safe and comfortable for all. In addition to improved sidewalks, bicycle facilities, and crossings, this Design Guide also includes several elements that function as traffic calming measures, which encourage slower vehicle travel speeds. These coordinated design elements combine with existing City enforcement and education efforts to create a safe place to bike and walk.
Vision Zero Vision Zero is an international movement aimed at eliminating all traffic fatalities and improving traffic safety. The movement was first implemented in Sweden in the “We must enact bold, safe 1990s and is gaining momentum across the United States, with several major cities adopting Vision Zero streets policies so no one has action plans, including New York City and Jersey City. to endure the experience of Hoboken recently joined this network by adopting a goal of achieving zero traffic-related deaths or injuries being put in harm’s way while by 2030. Complete Streets supports this achievement by focusing on ways to design improvements that crossing a street.” protect pedestrians and bicyclists and reduce the risk of vehicle crashes. Through simple improvements -Hoboken Mayor Ravi Bhalla that influence travel behavior, Hoboken can become a safer city for all modes of transportation.
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken 6 FOUNDATIONS
Process Overview Development of the Hoboken Street Design Guide began in mid-2018 and the 10-month process concluded with the publication of this report in 2019. During that period, the project team consulted Hoboken residents through online platforms and public events, conducted research into national best practices, and spoke with local and regional planning partners to develop a strategy that fits Hoboken’s unique context. Who was Involved The Hoboken Street Design Guide was a collaborative planning process between the NJTPA and the City of Hoboken. Together, these partner agencies ensured that the guidelines and policies contained in this document were tailored to the unique mobility needs of Hoboken, but can also serve as regional best practices for other communities.
7 North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Existing Plans Street Design Criteria and Guidelines Engineers and planners follow established standards and guidelines to prepare designs for roadway projects. The following standards and guides (shown below in Table 2) currently form the basis of Complete Streets best practices and policy guidelines. Each of these resources provide guidance for a particular area of street design:
Table 2 Existing Street Design Resources Organization/Legislation Guidance National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO) Urban Bikeway Design Guide Bicycle facilities and intersection design (2nd Edition) NACTO Transit Street Design Guide Transit facility design NACTO Urban Street Stormwater Guide Green infrastructure integration A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (American Association of State High and Roadway design, including multimodal facilities Transportation Officials [AASHTO] Green Book) Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices Street striping, markings, signage (MUTCD) USDOT Achieving Multimodal Networks: Multimodal network design Applying Design Flexibility & Reducing Conflicts Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Standards Accessible street design for Accessible Design Instittue of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: A Walkable street design Context Sensitive Approach
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken 8 Previous Plans Existing policies, guidelines, and plans were reviewed to fully understand the forces and trends that influence transportation policymaking and planning in Hoboken. This review included a selection of local policies and plans, New Jersey examples, and national case studies to provide an overview of best practices. Documents
FOUNDATIONS FOUNDATIONS reviewed include: • City of Hoboken Master Plan: Green Building and Sustainability Element (2018) • Hoboken Master Plan Re-examination (2018) • City of Hoboken Master Plan Land Use Element (2018) • Plan 2045 Connecting North Jersey (2017) • Rebuild by Design – Hudson River Project (2017) • Hoboken Citywide Parking Master Plan (2014) • Hoboken Green Infrastructure Strategy Plan (2013) • City of Hoboken Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan (2010) • City of Hoboken Complete Streets Policy (2010) • New Jersey DOT (NJDOT) Complete Streets Policy (2009)
9 North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken Supporting Community Goals Complete Streets aligns with many of the City’s long-term goals and objectives, as stated in the 2018 Master Plan Reexamination Report. Shown below is a selection of the City’s stated objectives that the Design Guide helps advance:
Hoboken is...
Maintain the scale and experience of the City’s shared streetscapes and built A COMPLETE environment, particularly within Hoboken’s interior residential neighborhoods NEIGHBORHOOD: Build, upgrade, and connect parks and open space amenities
Make Hoboken a better place for pedestrians, bicyclists, and transit riders, while improving conditions for those who drive Improve the efficiency of the roadway network, particularly at gateways to the A CITY OF City and through the Central Business District CONNECTED PLACES: Use all available tools to efficiently manage and improve parking conditions Improve the convenience of public transportation and other green alternatives to make these modes the first choice for user
BECOMING A Upgrade and innovate infrastructure systems SUSTAINABLE AND Adapt to climate change impacts and improve response capacity for RESILIENT CITY: emergencies and natural disasters
North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority | City of Hoboken 10 Public Engagement Engagement Results A public workshop and online survey, both held in Fall 2018, allowed Hoboken residents to voice their opinions and concerns regarding the current state of travel within the City. Both opportunities iallowed attendees to vote for their top transportation priority, voice their concerns, and remark on what they believed should change in the future. The
FOUNDATIONS FOUNDATIONS results from this public outreach was combined to create a cohesive set of data. Together, these results tell a story about residents’ transportation priorities and preferences, as shown below in Figures 3 and 4. A second survey in Spring 2019 gathered public opinion regarded the completed Street Design Guide. The final results of that survey are included in the document’s appendix.
Key takeaways from the engagement results include: • Hoboken residents travel in a variety of ways. More than half of respondents commute to work via the City’s various forms of transit, with another To get to work or school, I primarily... quarter choosing to walk or bike. Over 70 percent of respondents say they primarily walk to complete errands within the City, showcasing the importance of a robust pedestrian network. Ta e the PAT Ta e the NJ T AN T bus • Vehicles not stopping for pedestrians at Dri e crosswalks was the top safety concern. This is an example of behavior that can be al strongly influenced by design. ide a i e / cooter Ta e the erry • Bikers feel the least safe on Hoboken streets. When asked if they feel safe in certain situations, only 15 percent of participants agreed that they felt safe biking (walking across the street landed in the middle) in comparison to 56 percent who said they felt safe driving.
I feel safe... S D