Investigate the Current State of Knowledge Worldwide Regarding Neonectria Galligena
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DEPARTMENT OF HAL Report AP05029 PRIMARY INDUSTRIES Investigate the current state of knowledge worldwide regarding Neonectria galligena Show Desktop.scf Final Report Horticulture Australia AP05029 (November 2006) Edwards et al. Primary Industries Research Victoria, Knoxfield Centre HAL Report AP05029 Horticulture Australia Project No: AP05029 Project Leader: Dr Jacqueline Edwards Contact Details: Department of Primary Industries, Primary Industries Research Victoria, Knoxfield Centre Private Bag 15, Ferntree Gully DC, Victoria 3156 Tel: (03) 92109222 Fax: (03) 9800 3521 Email: [email protected] Project Team: Dr Oscar Villalta, Rachel Powney Address: Department of Primary Industries, Primary Industries Research Victoria, Knoxfield Centre Private Bag 15, Ferntree Gully DC, Victoria 3156 Purpose of project: The purpose of this project was to investigate European Canker of apple: current knowledge and the role of latent infections of N. galligena in fruit and rainfall for disease spread and its potential impact in Australia. Report completed: November 2006. Acknowledgments: The researchers gratefully acknowledge the financial support for this project from Horticulture Australia Limited (HAL), Apple and Pear Australia Ltd (APAL), the Federal Government and the Department of Primary Industries, Primary Industries Research Victoria. Disclaimer: This publication may be of assistance to you but the State of Victoria and its officers do not guarantee that the publication is without flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purpose and therefore disclaims all liability for any error, loss or other consequence which may arise from you relying on any information in this publication. Any recommendations contained in this publication do not necessarily represent current Horticulture Australia policy. No person should act on the basis of the contents of this publication, whether as to matters of fact or opinion or other content, without first obtaining specific, independent professional advice in respect of the matters set out in this publication. © State of Victoria, Department of Primary Industries, 2006 Primary Industries Research Victoria Knoxfield Centre HAL Report AP05029 CONTENTS Headings Media Summary 4 Technical Summary 5 Introduction 6 Materials and Methods 7 Results and Discussion 8 Stage 1- Literature Review of Past and Current Knowledge of European Canker and N. galligena worldwide 8 European Canker of Apples (N. galligena) 8 Epidemiology of European Canker 8 Life Cycle of N. galligena 9 Control 12 Symptoms 13 Woody tissue 13 Fruit 14 Symptoms on Apple 15 Symptoms on Other Woody Hosts 18 Host Range and Distribution of N. galligena worldwide 22 Host Specificity 25 Distribution of Potential Hosts of N. galligena in Australia 26 The Role of Nursery and Orchard Infections in Disease Spread 30 Disease Resistance 30 The Role of Latent Infection in Fruit for Disease Spread 30 Issues Raised in the IRA Report 30 The Process of Fruit Infection in the Field 31 Latent Infection in Fruit 31 Losses in Storage Due to Latent Infection of Fruit 32 Potential for Infection in the Packing House 32 Infected Fruit as a Source of Inoculum 33 Detecting Infections in Host Plants 33 The Effect of Rainfall on Disease Spread and Incidence 34 Issues analysed in the IRA Report in Relation to Spread of N. galligena 34 Effect of Rainfall on Disease Spread 34 Effect of Rainfall on Disease Incidence Worldwide 35 Rainfall Conditions in Australia 36 Stage 2-Predictive Modelling of the Potential Distribution of N. galligena in Australia using the Computer Programs CLIMATE and CLIMEX 37 (a) Prediction using the CLIMATE model 38 Method 38 Results 41 (b) Prediction Using the CLIMEX Model 45 Method 45 Results 45 Discussion 51 Stage 3–Simulation experiment to demonstrate whether symptomless infection of fruit has the potential to be a pathway for N. galligena into Australia 53 Symptoms of European canker in Northern Ireland, September 2006 54 References 58 1 HAL Report AP05029 Technology Transfer 63 Recommendations 63 Tables Table 1. Worldwide records of N. galligena. 23 Table 2. Locations used to generate the CLIMATE profile. 39 Table 3. Summary table of the CLIMATE profile for N. galligena. 41 Table 4. CLIMEX parameter values used to best fit the known worldwide distribution of N. galligena 46 Table 5. Locations in Australia, with eco-climatic indices (EI) greater than zero, as determined by the simulation model, CLIMEX 50 Figures Figure 1. Disease cycle of Neonectria canker caused by N. galligena. 10 Figure 2. Diagrams of the formation of the target-like canker on woody tissue. 13 Maps Map 1. Worldwide distribution of N. galligena. 23 Map 2. Countries where N. galligena has been recorded. 23 Map 3. Apple growing regions of Australia. 27 Map 4. Pear growing regions of Australia. 27 Map 5. Walnut growing regions of Australia. 28 Map 6. Distribution of Acer spp, Betula spp, Malus spp, Quercus spp, Ulmus spp, Fagus spp, Fraxinus spp, Populus spp, Sorbus aucuparia and Crataegus spp across Australia. 28 Map 7. Distribution of Salix alba (blue) and Salix purpurea (red) across Australia. 29 Map 8. Map output of locations used to produce the CLIMATE profile of N. galligena. 43 Map 9. The potential distribution of N. galligena in Australia based on the CLIMATE profile 44 Map 10. Locations in Europe where N. galligena is established or has the potential to establish. 47 Map 11. Locations in North America where N. galligena is established or has the potential to establish. 47 Map 12. Locations in South America where N. galligena is established or has the potential to establish. 48 Map 13. Locations in Asia where N. galligena is established or has the potential to establish. 48 Map 14. Locations in Australia were N. galligena has the potential to establish (a) without irrigation, (b) with irrigation. 49 Photos Photo 1. Conidia of N. galligena. 11 Photo 2. A perithecium (sexual fruiting body) of N. galligena from bark canker tissue. 11 Photo 3. Ascospores of N. galligena. 11 Photo 4. Transverse view of a canker in the woody tissue of Manchurian Ash. 14 Photo 5. Transverse view of the canker in the woody tissue of Manchurian Ash approximately two years after inoculation. 14 Photo 6. Canker on apple caused by N. galligena. 15 Photo 7. Nectria Canker (European Canker) dead branch beyond the swollen canker. 15 2 HAL Report AP05029 Photo 8. Eye rot in storage caused by N. galligena. 15 Photo 9. Nectria canker girdling branch. 15 Photo 10. European Canker in crotch of limb (N. galligena). 15 Photo 11. Distal end of branch dying due to girdling by Nectria canker. 15 Photo 12. Infection of crotch and main stem of apple trees by N. galligena. 16 Photo 13. Branch girdled by canker (N. galligena). 16 Photo 14. Apple with nectria canker (N. galligena). 16 Photo 15. Apple with nectria canker (N. galligena). 16 Photo 16. Apple with nectria canker (N. galligena). 16 Photo 17. Nectria canker on an Empire tree. 17 Photo 18. Red perithecia of N. galligena in a canker on apple. 17 Photo 19. Close up of perithecia (sexual fruiting structures) of N. galligena. 17 Photo 20. Nectria canker on a black walnut trunk, caused by N. galligena. 18 Photo 21. Fruit tree canker caused by N. galligena. 18 Photo 22. Nectria canker on a black walnut trunk, caused by N. galligena. 18 Photo 23. Nectia canker caused by N. galligena. 19 Photo 24. N. galligena in a tree trunk in Germany. 19 Photo 25. Neonectria galligena. 19 Photo 26. Nectria canker on honey locust. 19 Photo 27. Nectria canker on oak. 20 Photo 28. Target canker on a paper birch tree is caused by N. galligena. 20 Photo 29. Nectria canker on maple caused by N. galligena. 20 Photo 30. Nectria canker on birch in the United States caused by N. galligena. 20 Photo 31. Bark in crown of West Indian mahogany (Swietenia mahogoni) infected by N. galligena. 21 Photo 32. Cankers caused by N. galligena. 21 Photo 33. Severe symptoms of dieback including leaf reddening, poor growth and early senescence caused by N. galligena. 54 Photo 34. Canker on the trunk of Royal Gala caused by N. galligena. 54 Photo 35. Canker on the trunk of Royal Gala caused by N. galligena. 54 Photo 36. Canker on the trunk and branch girdling caused by N. galligena of Royal Gala. 54 Photo 37. Numerous cankers on a branch of Royal Gala caused by N. galligena. 55 Photo 38. The open calyx of some apple varieties make them more susceptible to latent infection by N. galligena 55 Photo 39. Core rot of Golden Delicious possibly caused by N. galligena. 56 Photo 40. Twig dieback caused by European canker demonstrating that infections can be found when the tree is in full leaf. 57 3 HAL Report AP05029 Media Summary This project conducted a comprehensive literature review into the pathogen Neonectria galligena, which causes European canker in apples, and undertook a predictive modelling study using the software packages, CLIMATE and CLIMEX, to identify regions in Australia with environmental conditions favourable for establishment and spread of the pathogen. European canker is one of the most important diseases of pome fruit and many species of hardwood forest trees worldwide. Cankers develop on the woody tissues, girdling and killing branches and, occasionally, the whole tree. The disease was found on apple in Tasmania in 1958 and an extensive eradication program was carried out, resulting in area freedom declared in 1991. At the time, no estimate was made of the cost of this incursion to Australia. However, a realistic comparison can be made with the costs of eradication and surveillance associated with the fireblight outbreak in Victoria in 1997, which was estimated to be A$20 million. The main findings of this project are: • N. galligena has been recorded on more than 60 plant species from 20 genera and from climates ranging from sub-arctic (Iceland, Sweden, Canada), temperate (Europe, USA, Chile), arid (Syria, Saudia Arabia, Afghanistan) to tropical (Java, Florida).