Columbia College Chicago Digital Commons @ Columbia College Chicago
Cultural Studies Capstone Papers Thesis & Capstone Collection
4-29-2019
Collective Political Action and Activism on Twitter: The Merits and Limitations of the Framing Tactics and Strategies of the 2018 National Prison Strike
Philip Wasserburg
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.colum.edu/cultural_studies
Part of the American Popular Culture Commons, Communication Commons, and the Cultural History Commons
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
?<<53D9F5)?<9D931<3D9?>1>43D9F9C=?>,G9DD5B,85&5B9DC1>4%9=9D1D9?>C?6D85
B1=9>7,13D93C1>4+DB1D5795C?6D85 '1D9?>1<)B9C?>+DB9;5
2CDB13D
,85CE335CC?61>I3?<<53D9F5@?<9D931<13D9?>B5<95C851F9@E2<93?@9>9?> ,85 <5145BC?6D85C513D9?>CEC56B1=9>7D538>9AE5CD??@D9=9J5D85B5138?6D859B=5CC175 1>43?>F9>352B?145B@?BD9?>C?6D85@?@E<1D9?>D?CI=@1D89J5G9D8D859B31EC5 ,?41I =?CD@?<9D931<3?>F5BC1D9?>C1>44521D5C12?ED@B5CC9>7C?391<9CCE5CD1;5C?>C?391< =5491@<1D6?B=CCE381C,G9DD5B G89383?E<4253?>35@DE1<9J541C1F9BDE1<@E2<93 C@85B5 G85B549665B5>D9>49F94E1
)89<9@/1CC5B2EB75H1=9>5CD8531C5?6D85 1B9?D1D%55 ?BB53D9?>1< 139<9DI9> +?ED8 1B?<9>11>4D85>1D9?>G945)B9C?>+DB9;5KD85<1B75CD9>D8589CD?BI?6D85->9D54 +D1D5CK9DDB9775B54 "5B5 /1CC5B2EB71B7E5CD81D4E5D?<571<B5CDB93D9?>C?> @B9C?>5BOCB978DD?6B554?=?6C@5538 D85F?935C1>4CD?B95C851B42ID85@E2<93?> C?391<=5491G5B5B5CDB93D54D?D8?C56B?=165G,G9DD5B133?E>DCBE>2I9>=1D5C G8938 G5B5B5C@?>C92<56?B3?>F9>39>712B?149D9F53<9>54@E2<93D81D9>:ECD935CG9D89> D85@B9C?>CICD5=4?9>613D5H9CD ,8B?E7813B9D931<1>1
?<<53D9F53D9?> B1=9>7)E2<93+@85B5+?391<&5491 '1D9?>1< )B9C?>+DB9;5 B554?=?6+@5538
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slani, Soroush, et al. “Framing, Resonance, and Micro-Mobilization: Shall We Say What We Are for, or What We Are against?” PsycEXTRA Dataset, 2011, doi:10.1037/e734282011-059. Baker, Joseph O., et al. “Race, Xenophobia, and Punitiveness Among the American Public.” The Sociological Quarterly, vol. 59, no. 3, 2018, pp. 363–383. Bastos, Marco Toledo, et al. “Gatekeeping Twitter: Message Diffusion in Political Hashtags.” Media, Culture & Society, vol. 35, no. 2, 2013, pp. 260–270., doi:10.1177/0163443712467594. Bianchi, Evan, and David Shapiro. “Locked Up, Shut Up: Why Speech In Prison Matters.” St. John's Law Review, vol. 92, no. 1, 2018, pp. 1–28. Branham, Lynn S. “Toothless in Truth? The Ethereal Rational Basis Test and the Prison Litigation Reform Acts Disparate Restrictions on Attorneys Fees.” California Law Review, vol. 89, no. 4, 2001, p. 999., doi:10.2307/3481290. Chiricos, Ted, et al. “Racial Typification Of Crime And Support For Punitive Measures.” Criminology, vol. 42, no. 2, 2004, pp. 358–390., doi:10.1111/j.1745-9125.2004.tb00523.x. Chiricos, Ted, et al. “Undocumented Immigrant Threat and Support for Social Controls.” Social Problems, vol. 61, no. 4, 2014, pp. 673–692., doi:10.1525/sp.2014.13137. Ciurel, Daniel. “The Framing of Protest.” Professional Communication and Translation Studies, Nov. 2018, pp. 7–15. “DE-NJ NLG Prisoners' Legal Advocacy Network (PLAN) Mounts Legal Responses to Widespread Reports of Prisoner Abuses in the Aftermath of the 2018 National Prison Strike.” National Lawyers Guild, 20 Sept. 2018, www.nlg.org/plan-prison-strike-response- 2018/. “Demographic Differences in Sentencing.” United States Sentencing Commission, 24 Jan. 2018, www.ussc.gov/research/research-reports/demographic-differences-sentencing. Ellerbeck, Alexandra, and Avi Asher-Schapiro. “Amid Nationwide Strike, Media Access to Prisons Is Limited.” Columbia Journalism Review, 6 Sept. 2018, www.cjr.org/analysis/prison-strike.php. Habermas, Jurgen, et al. “The Public Sphere: An Encyclopedia Article (1964).” New German Critique, no. 3, 1974, p. 49., doi:10.2307/487737. Habermas Jürgen. The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: an Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society. Translated by Thomas Burger, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1991. Hancer, Eda. “The Role of Social Media as a Negotiation Sphere for ‘Public Good’: The Case North Cyprus.” Revista De Cercetare Si Interventie Sociala, vol. 59, 2017, pp. 86–103. Matheson, Donald. “The Performance of Publicness in Social Media: Tracing Patterns in Tweets after a Disaster.” Media, Culture & Society, vol. 40, no. 4, 2017, pp. 584–599., doi:10.1177/0163443717741356. Sotirovic, Mira. “Affective and Cognitive Processes As Mediators of Media Influences on Crime-Policy Preferences.” Mass Communication and Society, vol. 4, no. 3, 2001, pp. 311–329., doi:10.1207/s15327825mcs0403_04. “Struggles of Using Legal Recourse as a Path Toward Better Prison Conditions.” National Lawyers Guild, 7 Mar. 2018, www.nlg.org/struggles-of-using-legal-recourse-as-a-path- toward-better-prison-conditions/. Tyler, Tom R., and Robert J. Boeckmann. “Three Strikes and You Are Out, but Why? The Psychology of Public Support for Punishing Rule Breakers.” Law & Society Review, vol. 31, no. 2, 1997, p. 237., doi:10.2307/3053926. Umphres, Eleanor. “150% Wrong: The Prison Litigation Reform Act and Attorney's Fees.” American Criminal Law Review, vol. 56, no. 1, 2018, pp. 261–293. Waid-Lindberg, Courtney A, et al. “Blame the Media? The Influence of Primary News Source, Frequency of Usage, and Perceived Media Credibility on Punitive Attitudes.” Western Criminology Review, vol. 12, no. 3, 2011, pp. 41–59. Ware, Jared. “Interview: South Carolina Prisoners Challenge Narrative Around Violence.” Shadowproof, 12 June 2018, shadowproof.com/2018/05/03/interview-south-carolina- prisoners-challenge-narrative-around-violence-lee-correctional-institution/#q2.