Columbia College Chicago Digital Commons @ Columbia College Chicago Cultural Studies Capstone Papers Thesis & Capstone Collection 4-29-2019 Collective Political Action and Activism on Twitter: The Merits and Limitations of the Framing Tactics and Strategies of the 2018 National Prison Strike Philip Wasserburg Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.colum.edu/cultural_studies Part of the American Popular Culture Commons, Communication Commons, and the Cultural History Commons This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 4.0 License. ?<<53D9F5)?<9D931<3D9?>1>43D9F9C=?>,G9DD5B,85&5B9DC1>4%9=9D1D9?>C?6D85 B1=9>7,13D93C1>4+DB1D5795C?6D85 '1D9?>1<)B9C?>+DB9;5 2CDB13D ,85CE335CC?61>I3?<<53D9F5@?<9D931<13D9?>B5<95C851F9<I?>@E2<93?@9>9?> ,85 <5145BC?6D85C513D9?>CEC56B1=9>7D538>9AE5CD??@D9=9J5D85B5138?6D859B=5CC175 1>43?>F9>352B?145B@?BD9?>C?6D85@?@E<1D9?>D?CI=@1D89J5G9D8D859B31EC5 ,?41I =?CD@?<9D931<3?>F5BC1D9?>C1>44521D5C12?ED@B5CC9>7C?391<9CCE5CD1;5C?>C?391< =5491@<1D6?B=CCE381C,G9DD5B G89383?E<4253?>35@DE1<9J541C1F9BDE1<@E2<93 C@85B5 G85B549665B5>D9>49F94E1<C=55D1>449C3ECC@?<9D931<5F5>DC1>49CCE5C1C 5AE1<<I5=@?G5B5439D9J5>C1>413D9F5=5=25BC?6C?395DI "?G5F5B 9>@B13D935 C?=5 9>49F94E1<CB5=19>E>12<5D?@1BD939@1D59>D85C549C3?EBC5C1>43?>F5BC1D9?>C )89<9@/1CC5B2EB75H1=9>5CD8531C5?6D85 1B9?D1D%55?BB53D9?>1< 139<9DI9> +?ED81B?<9>11>4D85>1D9?>G945)B9C?>+DB9;5KD85<1B75CD9>D8589CD?BI?6D85->9D54 +D1D5CK9DDB9775B54 "5B5 /1CC5B2EB71B7E5CD81D4E5D?<571<B5CDB93D9?>C?> @B9C?>5BOCB978DD?6B554?=?6C@5538 D85F?935C1>4CD?B95C851B42ID85@E2<93?> C?391<=5491G5B5B5CDB93D54D?D8?C56B?=165G,G9DD5B133?E>DCBE>2I9>=1D5C G8938 G5B5B5C@?>C92<56?B3?>F9>39>712B?14<I@E>9D9F5<I9>3<9>54@E2<93D81D9>:ECD935CG9D89> D85@B9C?>CICD5=4?9>613D5H9CD ,8B?E7813B9D931<1>1<IC9C?6D856B1=9>7D538>9AE5C ?6D85C5C?391<=5491133?E>DC<5149>71>4?B71>9J9>7D85+DB9;5 16E<<5B@93DEB5 5=5B75CD81DB5F51<CD85<9=9D1D9?>C CE335CC5C 1>4C8?BD61<<C?6D89C@1BD93E<1B6?B=?6 3?<<53D9F5@?<9D931<13D9?>?>,G9DD5B ?<<53D9F53D9?> B1=9>7)E2<93+@85B5+?391<&5491 '1D9?>1< )B9C?>+DB9;5 B554?=?6+@5538 ,85)E>9D9F5,EB>9>-+%1G1>4E<DEB5 #>D85 C=5B931>C 1DD85@?<<C1>4D8B?E78<579C<1D9?> 5=2B1354B97941>4 5HDB5=5@E>9D9F5@?<9395C 1C5H5=@<969549><?>75B1>4D?E785BC5>D5>39>713DC CE381C D85L,8B55+DB9;5C1>40?EOB5(EDMBE<5 1CG5<<1C9>D859>3B51C54EC5EC5?6<965 C5>D5>35C1>4D85451D8@5>1<DI @B13D935CD81D=?CD45F5<?@543?E>DB95C81F5 12?<9C854 EDG81D81C31EC54D89C@E>9D9F5@E2<931DD9DE4565GD85?B95C81F5 @B?F9454D5>D1D9F51>CG5BCD?D89C3?=@<5H@85>?=5>?> +?=51B7E5D81D<?31<>5GC CD?B95C651DEB9>7F9?<5>D3B9=516653D@5?@<5OC1DD9DE45C EDG89<5D85I6?E>4D81D@5?@<5 G8?G1D38CE38CD?B95CDI@931<<I81F57B51D5B<5F5<C?6@E>9D9F5C5>D9=5>DCD81>D8?C5 G8?4?>?D/194 %9>425B75D1< D89C9C13?BB5<1D9?>B1D85BD81>131EC1D9?>9D=1I25 D81D@5?@<5G9D8@E>9D9F51DD9DE45CC9=@<I38??C5D?G1D38=?B5?6D89C;9>4?6 @B?7B1==9>7 (D85BCD85?B9J5D81D@E2<93651B?61B1391<9J54N?D85BO<514CD?651B?61 2B51;4?G>?6C?391<3?85C9?>1>4D81D=978D25D8531EC5?681BC85B@E>9D9F51DD9DE45C #>4554 1B1>4?=9J54CEBF5I?6@5?@<59>D851IB51<9>;549>3B51C9>7<I @E>9D9F51DD9DE45CG9D8DG?613D?BC <13;?654E31D9?>1>4@5?@<5OC3?>35B>C12?EDD85 L453<9>59>=?B1<9DI1>449C39@<9>5G9D89>D8561=9<I1>49>3B51C5C9>D8549F5BC9DI?6 C?395DIM,I<5B?53;=1>> *1391<>9=EC,85?BI G8938@?C9DCD81DB14931<=5D8?4C?6C?391<3?>DB?<1B5 EC54G85>14?=9>1>DC?391<7B?E@651BC1B1391<9J54?D85B *5C51B389>D89C695<481C C8?G>D81DB1391<1>9=EC9C@B5C5>DB571B4<5CC?6D85@B?@?BD9?>?B5F5>@B5C5>35?6 =9>?B9D95C9>13?==E>9DI89B93?C 1>4D81D@5B35@D9?>?6D853B9=9>1<9DI?6?D85B B1391<7B?E@C9C<9>;54G9D89>3B51C54CE@@?BD?6@E>9D9F5@?<9395C89B93?C ,85B56?B5 G81D=1I251D@<1I85B59C=?B5?616554213;<??@G85B52I @5?@<5OCB1391<9J54651BC1B55>6?B3542IG1D389>7>5GCD81D@B9F9<575CCD?B95C?6F9?<5>D 3B9=5 5C@5391<<ID8?C531BB954?ED2I@5?@<5?63?<?B ,89CG?E<485<@5H@<19>D85 49C@1B9DI9>C5>D5>39>725DG55>2<13;1>4G89D5?665>45BC 1C2<13;?665>45BC1B5 C5>D5>354 ?>1F5B175 D? =?B5D9=5D81>G89D5?665>45BCG8?1B53?>F93D54?6 D85C1=53B9=5-++ B?=D85)E>9D9F5)E2<93D?*14931<)B?D5CD&?F5=5>DC ,8512?F5CDE495C1>4D85?B95C8978<978DD85B?<5D81D651B 61>>542ID85=5491 @<1IC 9>D85@E2<93CE@@?BD?681BC8@E>9D9F5=51CEB5C +DE495C?6D85@CI38?<?7931< @B?35CC5C?6@5?@<5G8?5=2B135=?B5@E>9D9F5@?<9395C8978<978DD859BEC5?6N16653D9F5O G1IC?6D89>;9>7 D89>;9>7=?D9F1D542I651B G85B51C@5?@<5G8?81F51N3?=@<5HOG1I ?6D89>;9>7381B13D5B9J5@B?2<5=C?63B9=9>1<:ECD9351>4@B9C?>C>?D1C=?B1<<I2<13; 1>4G89D5 2ED1C3?=@<5H@85>?=5>?>G9D8>E1>3541>CG5BC ,85I6?3ECD859B 1DD5>D9?>?>3?>3B5D5@B5F5>D1D9F5@?<9395C1B?E>43B9=5 CE381C9=@B?F9>753?>?=93 3?>49D9?>C B5=5491<54E31D9?>6?B@B9C?>5BC :?2DB19>9>79>35>DB1<39D95C >59782?B8??4 G1D38@B?7B1=C 7E>3?>DB?<<579C<1D9?> 1>4@EDD9>7=?B5@?<935?>@1DB?<+?D9B?F93 #>D89C3?>D5HD D85B?<5?613D9F9CDCG?E<4C55=D?25D?5>3?EB1751N3?=@<5HO G1I?6D89>;9>712?ED@B9C?>C1>4@E>9D9F5@?<9395C B1=9>7D85&5CC175 #>?B45BD?3?>F5ID859B=5CC175D?12B?145B@E2<93 @B?D5CD=?F5=5>DC5>71759>D85 @B?35CC?66B1=9>7 G89389CD85G1I3?<<53D9F513D9?>?B71>9J1D9?>C@B5C5>DB51<9DI G81D D85I5=@81C9J5 D859B@EB@?C5 1>4G8?D85I1B5144B5CC54D? ,85G1IC9>G8938D85I 4?D89C9C8E75<I9=@?BD1>DD?D859BCE335CC9>719>9>7CE@@?BD ?<<53D9F513D9?>=?F5=5>DCB5AE9B51C5>C5?63?>C5>CEC?6?@9>9?>1>41> 17B554 E@?>@<1>?613D9?> ,85C51B53B51D54D8B?E784917>?CD936B1=9>7 @B?7>?CD93 6B1=9>7 1>46B1=51<97>=5>D 917>?CD936B1=9>7945>D9695CD85@B?2<5=1>4G8?9CD? 2<1=5 #D@B9=1B9<IED9<9J5CD85B85D?B93?69>:ECD935 =1;9>73<19=CB571B49>7G81D 3?>CD9DED5CD85<579D9=1D5 945>D96I9>71>1>D17?>9CD 1>41DD5=@D9>7D?CG1ID85@E2<93 2I@B?F949>7D85=G9D8D85@?<9D931<1G1B5>5CC>55454D?381<<5>75D89>7CD81DF9?<1D5 >?B=C?6<579D9=13I9EB5< #D9C9=@?BD1>DD?>?D5D81D=5D8?4C85B531>9>8929D D85C@B514?61=5CC175 1C945>D96I9>712CDB13D1>49=@5BC?>1<651DEB5C9>8929DC =?29<9J1D9?> )B?7>?CD936B1=9>7D1;5CD85>5HDCD5@2I945>D96I9>7@?CC92<5C?<ED9?>CD?D85 @B?2<5= ,85C5@B?@?C54381>75C31>2549F5BC59>>1DEB51>4@B17=1D93?B9451<9CD93 45@5>49>7?>D857B?E@ )B?7>?CD936B1=9>75=@<?ICD85B85D?B93?6945>D9DI9>1>566?BD D?6?B=1>?@@?C9D9?>1<3?<<53D9F5D81D381<<5>75CD85945>D969541>D17?>9CD D85651DEB5C ?6G893881F5255>4569>549>D854917>?CD936B1=9>7 %1CD<I =?F5=5>DC5=@<?ID85 B85D?B93?6175>3ID?5=@?G5B@5?@<5D?25<95F59>D85@?CC929<9DI?656653D9>7381>75 1>4D?@B?F9451=5D8?4D8B?E78G8938D?4?C?9EB5< (>351@B?7>?CD936B1=5CE381C1<9CD?645=1>4C 81C255>45F5<?@54 7B?E@C=ECD1DDB13D>5G=5=25BC =54911DD5>D9?> 1>4B5C?EB35C ,89C@B?35CC9C 31<<546B1=51<97>=5>D 1>43?>C9CDC?66B1=52B9479>7 1=@<96931D9?> 5HD5>C9?> 1>4 DB1>C6?B=1D9?> B1=52B9479>79CD85@B?35CCD8B?E78G89381=?F5=5>D19=CD?3?>>53DG9D8 1>?D85B=?F5=5>DG9D81C9=9<1B945?<?7931<?ED<??; ?BG9D81C57=5>D?6D8575>5B1< @E2<93D81D=978D25CI=@1D85D93D?9DC7?1<C?BC9DE1D9?> B1=51=@<96931D9?>9>F?<F5C 5=@81C9J9>7?>5?6D856135DCG9D89>D853?<<53D9F513D9?>6B1=59>?B45BD?719>7B51D5B CE@@?BD <D5B>1D9F5<I =?F5=5>DC=1I1DD5=@DD?@<1I?66?65H9CD9>7>?B=C 1<<I9>7 D85=C5<F5CG9D8?D85B7B?E@CG9D8?F5B<1@@9>77?1<C?B3?B525<956C B1=55HD5>C9?>9CD851DD5=@D545H@1>C9?>?616B1=59>?B45BD?9>3<E45@5?@<5 G8?C56B1=59C>OD9>49B53D?@@?C9D9?>D?D85= I5D9C>?D5H13D<I9>49B53D133?B41>35D? D853?<<53D9F513D9?>6B1=5?6D85C?391<=?F5=5>D %1CD<I 6B1=5DB1>C6?B=1D9?>9C1 <?>7 D5B=566?BDD81D19=CD?381>75D85E>45B<I9>7>?B= 3E<DEB1<F1<E5 ?B21C9C?61> ?@@?C9D9?>1<6B1=59EB5< ,85CE@@?BD1>?B71>9J1D9?>5<939DC6B?=D85@E2<931D<1B7545@5>4C?>D85 3?>D5>D?69DC6B1=5C 5C@5391<<ID856B1=5OCB5C?>1>35G9D81E495>35C G89389C 45D5B=9>549>DEB>2I9DCC1<95>351>43B54929<9DI ,85;5ID?3B54929<9DI9C3?>C9CD5>3I 1=?>725<956C1>43<19=C 1CG5<<1CG9D8B51<<96513D9?>C 5=@9B931<3B54929<9DI8?G G5<<D856B1=569DCG9D89>49F94E1<CO@5B35@D9?>?6B51<5F5>DC '(,13DE1<B51<9DI 1>4 D853B54929<9DI?6D856B1=5OC1BD93E<1D?BCCD1DEC @?C9D9?> 5H@5BD9C5 ?BDBECDG?BD89>5CC C1<95>353?>C9CDC?635>DB1<9DI8?G;5ID85F1<E5C 25<956C 1>49451C1B5D?D85D1B75D 1E495>35 N5H@5B95>D91<3?==5>CEB129<9DIO8?G3?=@<5D5<ID856B1=9>7C31@DEB5D85 5F5BI41I5H@5B95>35?6D851E495>35 1CG5<<1CD853E<DEB1<B5C?>1>35?6D85 =5CC1759EB5< <D8?E78D85B59C>??>5G1I?66B1=9>7D81D9C=?B556653D9F59>1<<C9DE1D9?>C D81>1>I?D85B B5C51B3845=?>CDB1D5CD81DD85G1I6B1=5C1B5ED9<9J5416653DC8?G =5CC175C1B5B5359F542I49665B5>D7B?E@C (>5CE38CDE4I3?=@1B54D8556653DC?6 1>D17?>9CD931<<I6B1=54F5BCEC@B?D17?>9CD931<<I6B1=54=5CC175C?>@5?@<59>CE@@?BD 1719>CD 1>4>5EDB1<D?G1B48978<I381B754@B?D5CD=?F5=5>DC 69>49>7D81D1>D17?>9CD93 6B1=9>7CE33554549>=?29<9J9>7@5?@<5G8?G5B51<B514I=?B5945?<?7931<<I5HDB5=5 G89<5=?B5>5EDB1<2ICD1>45BCG5B516653D54F5BI<9DD<5?B5F5>DEB>54?662I5HDB5=5 B85D?B93C<1>9 #>3E<DEB1<CDE495C9D9C9=@?BD1>DD?5=@81C9J5D81D>??>5D85?BI31>3?=@<5D5<I 31@DEB5D85CD1D5?6B51<9DI I5DD853?>35@D?66B1=9>7@B?F945C1EC56E<G1I?6 5F1<E1D9>7D856?B=1>45669313I?613?<<53D9F513D9?> %571<1BB95BC+@5538*5CDB93D9?>C9>)B9C?> ;5I@1BD?6@B9C?>B56?B=9C<9CD5>9>7D?G81D@B9C?>5BC81F5D?C1I12?EDD85 3?>49D9?>CD81DD85I<9F59> C9>3B51C545H@?CEB5D?<?31<>5GC@B?7B1=C G89381B5 B944<54G9D8CD?B95C12?ED3B9=5 9C1CC?391D54G9D889785B<5F5<C?6@E>9D9F5C5>D9=5>DC /194 %9>425B7 9D9C9=@?BD1>D6?BD85C5C1=5@5?@<5D?C555H13D<IG81D 3?>49D9?>C9=@B9C?>54@5?@<5<9F59>C?D81D9=@B9C?>549>49F94E1<C1B58E=1>9J54 1>4 C9=@<9CD93 651B 4B9F5>@E>9D9F5>5CC9CD5=@5B54G9D81>1@@B5391D9?>?6D853?=@<5H 3?CDC?69=@B9C?>=5>D+?D9B?F93 EDD85@E2<931>4>5GC?B71>9J1D9?>OC129<9DID? B5359F5D859>6?B=1D9?>12?ED81@@5>9>7CG9D89>@B9C?>C81C255>C5F5B5<I81=@5B54 2IDG?C5DC?6<571<13D9?>D85)B9C?>%9D971D9?>*56?B=3D?6)%* 1>4D85 +E@B5=5?EBD539C9?> ,85C5=1459DC97>96931>D<I=?B5 496693E<D6?B9>=1D5CO3?>35B>CD?25851B42I@5?@<5?EDC945?6@B9C?>C G9D8=1:?B B5@5B3ECC9?>C6?B9>6?B=1D9?>1F19<129<9DI4EB9>7D85'1D9?>1<)B9C?>+DB9;5?6 #> D85+E@B5=5?EBDC5F5B5<I<9=9D54D85<571<@B?D53D9?>C 79F5>D?2?D8?ED7?9>7=5CC175C1>49>3?=9>7=5CC175C 1<<?G9>7@B9C?>?669391<C>51B 9=@E>9DI9>453949>7G81D9>6?B=1D9?>@B9C?>5BCB5359F51>4C5>4?ED91>389 ,89C4539C9?>9>3B51C54@B9C?>14=9>9CDB1D?BCO129<9DID?;55@@B9C?>5BC6B?=