Evaluating the Reaching Out-Of-School Children Project in Bangladesh: a Baseline Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVALUATING THE REACHING OUT-OF-SCHOOL CHILDREN PROJECT IN BANGLADESH: A BASELINE STUDY Akhter U. Ahmed Submitted to the World Bank By the International Food Policy Research Institute 2033 K Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20006, U.S.A. In collaboration with the Data Analysis and Technical Assistance Limited 8/4 Block A, Lalmatia, Dhaka 1207, Bangladesh November 2006 In memory of Miss Salma Begum (field researcher), Mrs. Shandya Rani Ghosh (field researcher), and Mr. Mizanur Rahman (survey supervisor) who died in a tragic road accident on their way to a field-site to carry out surveys for this study i ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS CMC Center Management Committee DPE Directorate of Primary Education EFA Education for All ESP Education Service Provider ERP Education Resource Provider FFE Food for Education GER Gross Enrollment Rate GoB Government of Bangladesh GR Gratuitous Relief HSC Higher Secondary Certificate IFPRI International Food Policy Research Institute LC Learning Center LFP Labor Force Participation MoPME Ministry of Primary and Mass Education NER Net Enrollment Rate PD Project Director PEDPII Second Primary Education Development Program PESP Primary Education Stipend Program PKSF Palli Karma Sahayak Foundation PPS Probability Proportional to Size PTI Primary Training Institute ROSC Reaching Out-of-School Children SDC Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation SFP School Feeding Program SKT Shishu Kallyan Trust SSC Secondary School Certificate TR Test Relief UEO Upazila Education Officer VGD Vulnerable Group Development VGF Vulnerable Group Feeding WFP World Food Programme ii CONTENTS Acknowledgments..................................................................................................................vii 1. Introduction........................................................................................................................1 2. Salient Features of the ROSC Project................................................................................3 2.1 Rationale ......................................................................................................................3 2.2 Description of the ROSC Project.................................................................................4 3. Evaluation Design and the Data.........................................................................................9 3.1 Evaluation Design........................................................................................................9 3.2 Data for the Baseline Study .........................................................................................10 4. Village Census Results ......................................................................................................17 4.1 Age Distribution of the Census Population .................................................................17 4.2 Literacy ........................................................................................................................17 4.3 Primary School Enrollment..........................................................................................20 4.4 Educational Attainment ...............................................................................................22 5. Profile of Households and Educational Attainment of Children in ROSC Project and Control Areas................................................................................................................25 5.1 Profile of Survey Households ......................................................................................26 5.2 Educational Attainment and Related Issues.................................................................38 6. Performance of the ROSC Project: An Early Assessment.................................................58 6.1 Project Participation by Beneficiaries..........................................................................58 6.2 Profile of Ananda Schools ...........................................................................................61 6.3 Activities and Performance of Center Management Committees................................65 6.4 Activities and Performance of Education Service Providers.......................................71 6.5 Limited Information on Education Resource Providers ..............................................73 6.6 Assessing the Quality of Education .............................................................................73 6.7 Assessing the Impact of ROSC Project on School Enrollment ...................................76 7. Summary and Conclusions ................................................................................................82 References…..........................................................................................................................87 iii FIGURES Figure 5.1—Primary-school-age children not in school........................................................27 Figure 5.2—Age of first enrollment and primary education completion rate .......................42 Figure 5.3—Age distribution of grade 1 boys in Ananda schools and other formal primary schools in ROSC Project areas........................................................................44 Figure 5.4—Age distribution of grade 1 girls in Ananda schools and other formal primary schools in ROSC Project areas .....................................................................................44 Figure 5.5—Patterns of school enrollment for boys and incidence of child labor ................50 Figure 5.6—Patterns of school enrollment for girls and incidence of child labor.................51 Figure 5.7—Hours of work outside the home by boys..........................................................52 Figure 5.8—Hours of household work by girls and boys......................................................52 Figure 6.1—Source of parents’ knowledge of Ananda school..............................................59 Figure 6.2—Composition of Ananda students: First-time enrolled, transferred from other schools, or previously dropped-out...............................................................................59 Figure 6.3—Student receipt of free text books from Ananda schools...................................60 Figure 6.4—Source of receipt for education allowances.......................................................61 Figure 6.5—Receipt of text books and school supplies for ROSC Project students by Ananda schools .............................................................................................................63 Figure 6.6—Comparing facilities of Ananda schools established in 2005 and 2006 in grant areas .....................................................................................................................64 Figure 6.7— Comparing facilities of Ananda schools established in 2005 and 2006 in grant-plus-allowance areas............................................................................................65 Figure 6.8—Government agencies with which ESPs are registered .....................................71 Figure 6.9—Source of funding for ESPs ...............................................................................72 TABLES Table 2.1—List of ROSC Project Learning Centers (LCs) in 60 Upazilas...........................7 Table 3.1—Baseline survey locations....................................................................................13 Table 3.2—Information collected for the baseline study and mode of collection.................15 iv Table 3.3— Actual sample size .............................................................................................16 Table 4.1—Percentage distribution of population by gender and age group, 2006 ..............18 Table 4.2—Literacy rates in ROSC Project and control areas, 2006 ....................................19 Table 4.3—Enrolment rates in primary schools in ROSC Project and control areas, 2006..21 Table 4.4—Share of population that never attended school in ROSC Project and ...............23 control areas, 2006........................................................................................................23 Table 4.5—Highest level of education attained by population aged 25 and over in ROSC..24 Project and control areas, 2006.....................................................................................24 Table 5.1—Characteristics of respondent households, by expenditure quartile: Grant areas ..............................................................................................................................28 Table 5.2—Characteristics of respondent households, by expenditure quartile: Grant- plus-allowance areas .....................................................................................................29 Table 5.3—Characteristics of respondent households, by expenditure quartile: Control areas ..............................................................................................................................30 Table 5.4—Characteristics of respondent households by expenditure quartile: All areas ....31 Table 5.5—Budget share of food and nonfood expenditures, by expenditure quartile ........33 Table 5.6—Households receiving public assistance, by expenditure quartile.......................35 Table 5.7—Private transfers and remittances received, by expenditure quartile ..................36 Table 5.8—Selected household assets and dwelling facilities...............................................37 Table 5.9—Type of primary school attended,