(0^"

SPORTCOATS! C-^^ .vii.-

SPORTCOATS!

vy>-- c SPORTCOATS!

Herringbones, j^laids, blazers and many more! We feature the ever-popular sportcoat in many fabrics, colors, sizes -r^- and styles ... a university man's best friend is his sportcoat.

;•<», 50 *34 upward

100% CAMEL HAIR

The greatest s])ortcoat buy of the year. Stop in, select yours now. $69.50

' '"• ~ V, ••,";

GILBERT'S S«v^?.»sf: >ampu^^hop ^£•k:i^ vv. t>N:THE CAMPUS ... NOTRE. DAMfciilftlilff

II *ii iifcfrftiaynirtiwrf.•^^•^^.^•r'^4..-<, " fc. , ; IN JANUARY IN FEBRUARY IN MARCH \:---.^:im NO OIJIRYING CHARGE ^im

WE REPEAT ... NO CARRYING CHARGE! &! fe.-! This is a very important feature of The Campus Shop m Way to Buy ... we never add a service or carrying charge for this best-of-all-ways to buy! Come in NOW, select V'il your apparel from our large selection of university-styled clothing and accessories . . . pay one-third in January, i- one-third in February and one-third in March of next % year. We repeat ... no carrying charge. ir\ f'l r'Z I/-: K-

r---: M-

/•:;%^- ^ILBERrS /.,- <••-•-

••-.\,

CAMPUS... NOTRE DA^E

•&\ :S2i^l.F- 'M ii£Jifa>.f^T&ftA-£wiigA*^ ..^...j-^... a^„„ r^f^fi iiT -^ mni'i i^" • ymam EDITOMALl

attempt to institute any novel ideas. The only dis­ concerting thing we can see is that a certain amount of work will be necessary to get a good room. And there are good rooms on what is now called the freshman quad. Upperclassmen have the first choice of these, and Keenan or Stanford are two of the most comfortable halls on campus. Among the major reasons for the change to this new system is that the old one is just not working. Either there is a large turnover of students each year, defeating the whole purpose, or there is an uncomfortable minority of students from one of the classes; they feel forced together, isolated from the whole idea of hall unity — again defeating the idea behind stay-hall. But many seem to feel that there is no good to be derived from bringing the freshmen into such a East Is East... ? system. After all, they're happy over there by them­ selves. More important than their being happy fifth- year high-school students, though, is that they be­ \^N STUDENTS ARE sometimes conservative. They come mature members of the Notre Dame com­ E don't like to be rushed out of their rut, especially munity, finding out as soon as possible what the when their shortsightedness makes them feel de­ Notre Dame spirit really is. This is not just an ideal­ graded. For instance, unparalleled horror seems to istic page-filler. Practicality must admit that fresh­ be tlie general reaction when someone from the men will get more out of living with upperclassmen west end of campus hears of the awful possibility — than anyone could ever hope to achieve by a well- tliat upperclassmen could be exiled to the freshman intentioned, but imposed, Senior Advisors Program. quad! Catastx'ophic event that it is, the objections SEP John Gearen, put it this way: "They will be­ are mostly irrational, but they usually seem to spring come more conscious of what Notre Dame is, more from a fear of tlie freshman ghetto and a feeling that conscious of what they themselves are to become, injustice is rampant, for everyone knows that there and will achieve some basic maturity long before it are no good rooms in tlie east quad. is expected of them under the present arrangement." Most of those hearty, west-end-or-fight myopics One argument has been that the freshmen will ai-en't really sure of what the new stay-hall proposal lose that magnificent spirit that characterizes each says, let alone what its many implications ai'e. Thus, exuberant class. The logical thing is not to let this for those who are interested: The proposed stay-hall excitement rot by itself, but to channel it into some­ plan, to be initiated for the coming year, works on a thing a little more constructive and mature than system of freshman integration and hall proportion- riots. Maybe some of it will even rub off on their ment Each haU will have a certain quota of each of elders, though this does seem a little ideal. tlie four classes. An upperclassman will be able to Everyone says that Notre Dame is growing. stay in his room, or if he wishes to switch mthin his Someday the enrollment is bound to increase signif­ hall, it is reported that he will be able to choose a icantly, and even now the University is facing the new room by his academic average. Once the quota problem of impersonality. There is a definite need of a class for a hall is filled, however, the student for the more personal unity of the hall. Students must go tlirough Academic Affairs, switching halls. can use their imagination to see some of the more A word about the quota system: The classes are cheering social and academic implications of an ef­ propoilioned, in decreasing numbers, as the student fective stay-hall system. moves from his freshman to senior years. This is But ND students have shown before that they not done with the intention of kicking seniors out in aren't too worried about much beyond the imme­ the snow; the rationale follows the pattern of student diate effects of any program — i.e., "Am I going averages and drop-outs. Each year a certain number to be inconvenienced?" — and we doubt that it is of students (approximated in the stay-hall system) possible to cure their shortsightedness by a simple leave school and otliers move off campus. The new explanation. We suggest a rational approach to the system follows the established pattern — it does not question by the student body. — J.W.

The Scholastic They know that strategy, tactics, and the use of modern weapons can help a small army fend off a large one. Further, they know that the difficulty of troop movements in China largely precludes the possibility of a surprise attack by Chinese ground troops. Finally, they know that any blatant and overt hostilities by the Chinese military forces would be met by the combined resistance of the members of SEATO. All of the tenuous comfort of this type of reason­ ing has been removed by the prospect of the bomb. The nations that are most vulnerable to Chinese aggression — Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand — must now face the prospect of a China that will make full use of the propaganda and intimidation potential of a nuclear capacity. Such a threat is bound to weaken the morale of Southeast Asian peoples, for no matter how well they might prevent Communist infiltration, and no matter how well they might de­ fend themselves against Chinese ground forces, it would still be relatively easy for short-range bombers to win a war almost immediately by dropping a few nuclear bombs on strategic installations. Red China's Bomb Two possibilities are left to the Southeast Asians. They can put all their trust in the good faith of the American commitment to defend Southeast Asia. AST WEEKj Red China successfully tested an atomic On the surface, this may seem easy and attractive, L device. The administration tried to lessen the but if Charles de Gaulle can seriously doubt that the shock by announcing that such a test was imminent United States would defend Europe from an attack several weeks before it occurred. Secretary Mc- by the Soviet Union, certainly a Pakistani must en­ Namara has been emphasizing at every opportunity tertain serious doubts about whether the United the vast difference between a crude nuclear test and States would risk nuclear war if Karachi were at­ a sophisticated nuclear capability. tacked. Granted, the Chinese nuclear capability is still The alternative is the course presently being fol­ in the crudest stage. Granted, it will take five or ten lowed by Cambodia. Rather than be hostile to China, years before China has any real stockpile of nuclear the theory is that a country can maintain its inde­ bombs. Granted, the Chinese do not at present have pendence by denouncing the West, turning neutral, any bombers large enough to deliver these nuclear and starting trade negotiations with Peking. There bombs. Nevertheless, China has proved that it has is no guarantee that this plan will work, since it is the personnel and the technological ability, and more essentially one of appeasement and accommodation, importantly, the will, to develop a nuclear striking but it seems more practical than depending on a force. country 3,000 miles away. It is this fact which explains the great fear which This type of reasoning can ultimately spell dis­ has resulted from the initial Chinese blast. For the aster for Southeast Asia. As its freedom is gradually United States and the Soviet Union, China can never eroded, it will drift more and more inexorably into be a serious military threat, because her economy the Chinese orbit, until China's satellite system rivals is not suflRciently broad or stable to allow the dis­ that of Russia, and threatens the Pacific outposts placement of the vast resources which such a goal of the United States. Faced with this prospect, the would entail. However, to the nations of Southeast United States has the difficult task of reassuring the Asia, even a small Chinese nuclear force is a fright­ Southeast Asians, of convincing them of our good ening prospect. These nations are accustomed to faith and of the dangers of accommodating the living with a China whose military consisted of mil­ Chinese. This will take firmness and courage, but it lions of soldiers. Even though this force may be awe­ is a step which is crucial to the safety of both the some, it is understandable to the Southeast Asians. United States and the free world. — B.McD.

October 30, 1964 SCHOLASTIC CONTENTS The Student Weekly of the University of Notre Dome

Editorials 4 Founded 1867 Stay-hall lor the masses — o bombshell for the campus. Red China — a bombshell for the world. Point of Order 7 Vol. 106 October 30, 1964 No. 5 The senators "considered" this year's budget last Tuesday night.

Letters to the Editor 8 Mel Noel News and Notes 11 . , . editoi'-in-chief Joseph Wilson Campus at a Glance 13 . . . managing editor On Other Campuses 16 David McElroy . . . business manager Stay-Hall: Pro & Con 17 Frank Smith, Bill McDonald Various voices from the crowd speak out. . . . associate editors Campaign '64 18 Al Dudash The third, and lost, of a series on this year's national political campaign: an analysis by Dr. Paul C. Bartholomew of the Department of Government and Inter­ . . . news editor national Studies. Rick Weirich Clashing Beads and Mutterings 20 . . . news assistant "The Church today is in need of reform" according to Professor James Cameron. Bill Krier He lectured in the library this week, gave the Terry Lectures at Yale, and will teach . . . features editor here next semester. John Whelan, Rex Lardner Poet John Logan 21 . . . sports editors He loves Notre Dame and has been much influenced by her; the poet read his work one evening in O'Shaughnessy. Jim Finch

Love With the Proper Passion 22 John Twohey . . . layout Passion's part in pictures by one director — as seen by Bob Holler. Understanding Our Trial 24 Carl Magel . art editor A somber note: two members of the Honor Council explain the more important parts of the Code. Pat Ford copy editor In the Beginning 25 Huarte to Snow 26 E. Brian Graham photography In your Huarte you Snow we're great! . circulation Voice In the Crowd 28 Dennis Allen How Huarte and Snow out-foxed Ralston; and that we've done as good on statistics this year as in all of lost; and, to renew an old warning — the next Five will be advertising very tough.

President's Cup and Scoreboard 29 Frank O'Malley The Last Word 34 faculty advisor

Vince Beckman, Jeff Blackwell, The SCHOLASTIC is entered u second-class Lee Cass, Robert Haller, The Scholastic will not be pub­ mail at Notre Dame, Indiana, at a special lished next week due to mid­ postage rate authorized June 23, 1918. The Jeremy Lane, Jay Macdonald, magazine is represented for national advertising Bill McGuire, John Meany, term exams. We will resurrect by National Advertising Service, Inc., 18 East 50th Street, New York 22, N.Y. It receives its Frank Obert, Bill O'Grady, on November 13. covers including the four-color back-page ad­ Jack Rowe .... contributors vertisement fnmi Collie Magazines Inc., of New York City. Published weekly during the school OUR COVER year, except during vacation and examination periods, the SCHOLASTIC is printed at Ave Tom Bettag, Jim Boland, Mike Brad­ John T w o h e y , Scholastic's Maria Press, Notre Dame, Indiana. The sub­ ley, Bill Cragg, Bob Edler, Geary El- scription rate is $5.00 a year (including all crtsy-craftsy political analyst, issues of the academic year and the FOOTBALL let, Estelle Ford, John Gorman, Leo depicts his feelings on the cam­ REVIEW). The special subscription rate for Hayes, Steve Hudson, Joe Magnana., St. Mary's students and faculty is $3.00 a year. paign. Which candidate will Please address all manuscripts to the SCHOL­ Mike Mclnemey, Jamie McKennaj you give your Mars Junior Bar ASTIC, Notre Dame, Indiana. All unsolidted material becomes the property of the SCHOL­ John Moran, Martin Murphy, John to? ASTIC. Noel, Chuck Ryan, Pete Siegwald, Don Wharton . . . staff The Scholastic POINT OF ORDER Money, Money^ Money . . . When by Frank Smith it rainSj it pours.

N LAST TUESDAY NIGHT^ the Senate standing member in NSA, an organi­ by Barry McNamara emd Bob Stew­ O held what is traditionally its zation founded in 1947 and composed art, who clearly listed the problems most important meeting of the year, of student-government representatives which such an association brings. the budget meeting. At this particular from schools throughout the nation. They dwelled upon the fact that mem­ meeting, the Senate began appro­ Whether Notre Dame should remain bership brings little in the way of con­ priating the $20,000 which it is al­ as a member of this student group crete contributions to the welfare of lotted from the student activities was the most disputed proposal in the the Notre Dame student, and more fee attached to the bill of every stu­ Financial Committee's preparation of importantly, that our membership in dent. Because of some lengthy debates the budget. The committee was split this organization lends our name to the Senate was able to approve only evenly over the question of Notre the frequent politiceil proclamations a part of the budget proposals made Dame's continued participation and which it meikes, many of which are by its Finance Committee. The rest thus the matter came to the Senate ultra-liberal and clearly leftist. The of the proposals will come under dis­ floor promising a good deal of debate. other side of the question was argued cussion on Monday night and it is The debate that did take place was very effectively by Geciren, Tom only at that time that the budget can generally conceded to be one of the Brejcha and Al Valkenaar. They be approved as a whole, and hence best and most intelligent to be heard pointed out that our affiliation with officially implemented. The Senate's in the Senate in the last couple of NSA is very beneficial because it gives actions at this initial meeting, how­ years. Unfortunately a good deal of our students a chance to shake off ever, are of interest because of the it was wasted on a majority of the their parochialism, emd to exchange importance of some of the issues con­ senators, who preferred to carry on our ideas on student government and sidered and because of the way it private conversations rather than to national issues with those of student handled them. have the courtesy to hsten to the leaders throughout the country. Fur­ The parts of the budget which the speakers. But at any rate the argu­ thermore they maintained that Notre Senate took under consideration at ments both pro and con were extreme­ Dame's participation in this associa­ the meeting were the allocations to ly weU presented and managed to ac­ tion is a chance for us to interject a be made to their various committees, complish one thing that is rarely done Catholic point of view into its ideas to the Hall Presidents' Council, to the in the Senate — present a dear view and perhaps to one day gain sufficient influence to guide it down an avenue four college councils, and to the na­ of the issues at hand so that the sen­ of thought more closely akin to our tional associations with which Notre ators can cast an intelligent vote on the question. own. When the dust had cleared, the Dame is affiliated. In general, the way Senate had voted 20-11 to continue in which the Senate went about its Opposition to Notre Dame's partici­ Notre Dame's affiliation with NSA. job showed much improvement over pation in NSA was primarily voiced previous Senate attempts to fulfill its legislative role in a responsible fashion. The meeting was character­ Parks igSfc^ O.H.V. Engine ized by brief flashes of efficiency and Easily inJHHHSI^^^E. • clear thinking, qualities which had Anywhere JP^PHB^L^I No Mixing been markedly absent in the Student k Oil & Gas Center amphitheater up to this time. The fact that the meeting was run as 200 MPG 1^BMT|B W Free Demonstration smoothly as it was can be primarily Low as $281.75 ^ Rides attributed to the determination of one man. Student Body President John "You Meet the Nicest People on a Hondtf' Gearen. Many members of the Stay Senate (the newly elected senators' ^Q ^O A ^'' MICHIANA, INC. contributions to the proceedings were Open 2531 LINCOLNWAY WEST —•MISHAWAK A limited to the taking up of seats in Weekdays, 9 to 9 3 B/OCICS East of Shoppen Fair Phone the overcrowded amphitheater) often Saturdays, 8 to 6 255-2388 attempted to waste time in long dis­ cussions over trivial matters. Gearen, on the other hand, doggedly used Contact Lens SpeddiUst every means of influence at his dis­ DR. M. MITTERMAYER posal to move through the agenda in optometrist a legislatively mature way and was Dr. T. R. nM successful enough to cause the five- EYES EXAMINED Optometrist hour meeting to be somewhat pro­ • ductive. Most of the allocations made were GLASSES FITTED EYES EXAMINED routine matters but one, dealing Fast Optical Repair Service OPnCJlL BEPADS with our affiliation with the Na­ GLASSES FITTED tional Student Association, was of 228 S. Michigan 234-6871 crucial importance and hotly contest­ (Next to Penneys) 212 S. Michigan 234-4874 ed. Notre Dame has been a long- October 30, 1964 ARSENALS AND APPEASEMENT road of appeasement." "Shall we con­ Letters • • • EDITOR: tinue," MiUer asks, "to preach accom­ William Miller in his nation-wide modation of the Communists and co­ CAMPUS RELATIONS search for a sympathetic audience has existence and thus suffer one defeat EDITOR: finally turned to the SCHOLASTIC to after another as we fight the cold war I applaud the item in "The Last impress upon us the weighty and mo­ on the Reds' terms?" For Miller this Word" of last week that commented mentous decisions of the coming is the most important question of the on the incredibly stupid conduct of election. After all, there is something campaign and it doesn't make any the pohce guarding (?) the field at festive about the aftermath of a foot­ difference whether the rest of Ameri­ football games. I was thinking of sug­ ball game which does not lend itself ca thinks so or not. gesting that what is needed is a total to the harum-scarum, gut-type politics For once I would like to hear the replacement of the personnel of the of MiUer. And, as usual, upon a care­ Miller-Goldwater sect define appease­ Notre Dame security (sic) force, be­ ful reading of his brief remarks, it ment. For many members of this ginning with Elmer whatever-his- is as evident as ever that he lias strange cult anything short of nuclear name and working down through the nothing to say. war is kowtowing to the Red bar­ ranks to Rent-a-Cop and the mus­ Nevertheless, the tone of his re­ barians and appeasement. If this is tachioed villain (Snidely WTiiplash) marks smacks handily of the small so, then I wiU admit to favoring ap­ who darts nerv^ously in and out of Radical Right element entrenched in peasement because I can still con­ the front-gate guard station nightly, the Government Department (under ceive alternatives to self-destruction. and would qualify admirably for an these circumstances one hesitates to For some Goldwater-Miller supporters insecurity force anywhere. As I say, call it a department of political the determination of the peoples of my original idea was that those people science) which has been issuing a lot Cuba, South Viet Nam, or Zanzibar should be dismissed, but then I of campaign flotsam and jetsam of to rule themselves is appeasement. realized what a rich source for aca­ late, with just about the same result They have stretched the word beyond demic investigation our security force — a flat taste and a nauseous odor. all its extensive meanings. They have v/ould be when the Psychology De­ Prof. Niemeyer told a meeting of turned the word into a meaningless partment is opened next year. Citizens for Goldwater-MiUer on campaign slogan, which even ihey Perhaps it's the public relations October 15 that the Johnson Admin­ don't pretend to define. department that needs replacing. (Do istration "is steering the United The only way to destroy Russia is we have one? It would seem un­ States toward war, along the low to destroy America at the same time. likely.) How many potential donors on the average weekend are shoved and insulted by the "clean" old men in the Bookstore whose only function in life is to keep the lines straight? (No one is allowed to buy a book on Saturdays; the line-keepers won't let We all anyone upstairs.) How many alumni in the course of make a year hope to take their families mistakes... through the campus and are insulted by the "I-own-the-campus" boys at the front gate? The front-gate-keep­ ers must go through a gruehng selec­ tion process; nowhere have I ever met a ruder, meaner, or more slovenly collection of individuals. It must have been quite a task to locate them. Of course, if the University would pay a li\ang. wage, we could hire someone besides refugees from a re­ ERASE WITHOUT A TRACE training program. There's hope for the Psychology Department, however; ON EATON'S CORRASABLE BOND even if someone would correct the "security force problem" at Notre Don't ^ell yourself short at the keyboard. Typing errors Dame (a task that ranks with clean­ don't show on CorrasaI)Ie. Eaton's paper with the special ing the Augean stables), the psychol­ surface makes perfect papers possiI)Ie every time, the ogists would have only to walk across first time. .An ordinary pencil eraser makes a rub-out a U.S. 31 to observe similar phenom­ cincli Willi never a telhale trace of evidence. ena on a smaller sccile with the St. Conasable is available in liaht. Mary's Kops; for advanced students, medium, heavy weights and an armed safari to the south could Onion Skin. In handy 100-sheet prove even more rewarding. packets and 500-sheet ream There is a single competent person boxes. Only Eaton makes /^ hiding in the washed-out blue of the Corrasable. /ry^f'^t Notre Dame police, but I won't be the one to betray him to Fudd and Co. A Berkshire Typewriter Paper Please withhold my name also; I hear they're considering issuing dogs and guns to the local Bull Connors. EATON PAPER CORPORATION (E) PITTSFIELD. MASSACHUSETTS Name Withheld

8 The Scholastic since there is no ultimate prepara­ CHARACTER OF A MANIFESTO ing political ends, however desirable tion against an all-out nuclear attack. EDITOR: such ends might appear. Perhaps Pro­ Miller's arsenal, once the nuclear I feel compelled to write concerning fessor Carberry has not reflected upon threat is removed, is fiUed with paper the remarks attributed to my col­ the matter suflSciently to recognize bullets prepared by the sloganeers. league, Professor Carberry, in your such a position, or perhaps he sub­ "The free world's economy is a Colos­ issue of October 16. In these remarks, scribes to the theory that "modera­ sus," "The free world's psychological whether wittingly or not. Professor tion in the pursuit of justice is no strength is a mighty fortress, that of Carberry has impugned the character virtue." Communism is a house of cards," and judgment of the entire engineer­ Professor Carberry is represented "Communism's fear-driven machine," ing faculty. further as pleading for a more liberal "The umbrella of false security," are Concerning the Johnson-endorse­ arts-oriented engineering education, only a few from his great stock of ment letter, I find incredibly shallow presmnably to save present engineer­ political cliches. Professor Carberry's reasoning that ing students from the fate of their It is hoped when the political cam­ those faculty members who refused professors. It is unfortunate that he paign is over and W. E. Miller is re­ to sign and were not pro-Goldwater should pose a serious question — tired from the national scene, as he are thereby proved guilty of a " 'dis­ namely, whether or not the engineer­ certainly wiU be, he wiU find time to graceful' lack of interest in either ing curriculum is sufiiciently liberal— return to school to complete his edu­ candidate." There are those faculty in such a cavalier and irresponsible cation. His remarks only show that members, among whom I count my­ manner. It might be alleged that this even Notre Dame can turn out a man self, who consider partisan political question is presently being ignored with a mind an inch wide, an inch activity by a faculty group identified by the engineering faculty in view of deep, and half a mile long. with a single university as inappropri­ the fact that the Engineering College Ronald M. Benson, ate to the nature of a university and Committee on the Liberal Arts Pro- Graduate Student, as an immoderate means for achiev­ (Continued on page 32)

October 30, 1964 We're very active in the field of communications, and we're growing. New technological ad­ vances have broadened areas of need for good people who You could be want to develop and who will become experts in their jobs. one of the To fill our management ranks we'll naturally reward those who can think for themselves, solve most important problems, and produce under pressure. persons Make your first move to a bright management future by We work in space ... we talk to signing up now at your Place­ ment Office for an interview this year! appointment. Our recruiting team will be on your campus very soon. Because of our policy of promoting from within, you could earn one of our top management jobs. That makes it important that we talk to you.

And important that you talk and under the sea ... with us. to provide the world's The Bell System—where peo­ finest communications ple find solutions to exciting problems—matches other com­ panies in benefits, salaries and working conditions. The Bell System companies are equal opportunity employers.

BELL SYSTEM

American Telephone and Telegraph Co. and Associated Companies

10 The Scholastic •ON SATURDAY^ October 24, Rev. News and Notes Theodore M. Hesburgh, C.S.C, re­ ceived a gift presentation of 50 books • DR. JAMES J. CARBERRY of the Engi­ head of the Notre Dame Theology for the Memorial Library from the neering Department seems to have Department, and Father Francis de- Canadian Government. The presenta­ succeeded in stirring up a political Graeve, S.J. Fr. deGraeve is a Belgian tion was made by Senator John J. hornets' nest at Notre Dame (see "Let­ Jesuit from Louvain University who Connelly, government leader in the ters" column). Two weeks ago he was is visiting Notre Dame this year and Senate, as the representative of Prime one of the principal sponsors of a let­ teaching a course in comparative re­ Minister Lester Pearson. Also present ter supporting the Presidential can­ ligion in the graduate school. The was Mr. C. F. Wilson, Canadian Con- didacy of Lyndon Johnson and de­ panels will be composed of selected sul-General in Chicago. nouncing the Goldwater-Miller team, students and faculty members. Both Mr. Pearson received an honorary' which was signed by 201 of the more sessions wiU be held in the Library degree from Notre Dame last year, than 300 faculty-status persons poUed. Auditorium. and sent the books as a token of The reaction was a protest from Dr. Canada's and his personal friendship Gerhart Niemeyer, a political science • INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS are in­ toward Notre Dame. In a letter to professor and a campaign advisor to vited to a reception sponsored by the Fr. Hesburgh, Mr. Pearson expressed Goldwater, in a letter to the South Ladies of Notre Dame on Monday, the hope that the gift would help Bend Tribune^ in which he said "Notre November 2, at 8 p.m. in the North stimulate "interest in relations be­ Dame is not represented by that state­ Dining Hall. Dr. Paul C. Bartholomew tween our countries and help ment." Niemeyer feels the statement of the Political Science Department strengthen the unique pairtnership was too easily interpreted as a con­ will speak on the national elections our two nations are so fortunate to sensus of University opinion, which to take place the following day. His share." he maintains it is not. Excluding purpose is to familiarize the students clergy and non-citizens, about 400 with the electoral system and voting faculty members should have been procedures of the United States. The • IN CONJUNCTION with charter flights eligible to sign the letter. Ladies of Notre Dame is an organiza­ and tours to Europe to be sponsored Carberry defends his letter for sev­ tion that includes wives of the faculty by the N.F.C.C.S. and Craven Tours, ered reasons, including a fear that and staff, and also professional wom­ Mr. and Mrs. Ian Craven of Liverpool, Miller was attempting to link the Uni­ en who work at the University. England, wiU be on the campus this versity with his Vice-Presidential afternoon and evening to explain the campaign since telegrams were sent program to all interested students by Miller backers to presidents of 169 and faculty members. Mr. Craven is Notre Dame alumni clubs asking the the National Tour Administrator for presidents to become chairmen of N.F.C.C.S. From 1:00 to 9:00 in the "Go, Go Miller Clubs." Student Center Amphitheater, Mr. and Mrs. Craven will show slides of Europe and answer any questions • THE HONOR COUNCIL has announced that questions, reports of violations, about the program or travel in etc., are to be mailed to the Honor Europe in general. Council, P.O. Box 81, Notre Dame. The charter flights are set up for Written accusations (which must be N.F.C.C.S. member schools, and cost made in all cases) should include the between $275 and S310 for round name of the violator, the course in trips. These flights are between $30 which the incident occurred, its sec­ and $50 cheaper than other similar tion and the instructor. Concerning flights. They are set up in conjunc­ the violation itself, the reporter tion with the regular program of should mention how he became aware European Tours, but students may of the incident, the nature and man­ take the flights without making the ner of the violation, and state its tour. The Student Government Travel date and hour. He is requested to Commission, giving full support to make the Honor Council aware of this program, is providing an infor­ how he can be contacted; only signed mation service to aid Notre Dame reports may be considered. students in their appreciation of the • WALSH HALL^ constrained by the European culture. Details on that • THE THEOLOGY DEPARTMENT,, which fact of the Senate budget meeting service will be forthcoming in the is sponsoring the Bibliccd Symposium last Wednesday, elected Gordon Nash second semester. being held this weekend, will also as its Senator in a special election sponsor an informal discussion by Dr. Tuesday night. With 90% of the hall • IT'S INTERVIEW TIME for this year's Paul Tillich on Wednesday, November voting, Nash won by a margin of 4-1 seniors. These meetings serve as 4. Dr. Tillich, a professor of theology over Guy Williams. The proposed new publicity for various graduate pro­ at Chicago University, will discuss hall government system was approved grams and help the schools to eval­ "The Problem of God and Faith." Two by a 9-1 margin. uate applicants. They are most im­ discussions will be held; the 4:00 ses­ In a special election held Wednes­ portant to the student, though, giv­ sion wiU be open to everyone, the day, October 21, Stanford HaU elected ing him a firsthand idea of the cost 8:00 session will be exclusively for John Darrouzet as Senator out of a and the program of the school to see faculty members. These sessions will field of four candidates, with Brian if he fits in. ! be along the lines of a panel discus­ Lake in second place. Three candi­ Interested seniors may arrange for sion, with a panel questioning Dr. dates ran for HaU President, and Dan the interviews for business schools by TiUich instead of a formal lecture. Lungren was the victor there; Her­ signing the roster near the Dean's Of­ Moderators for the discussions will bert Parker HI was elected Secretary- fice on the. second floor of the Com­ be Father Albert Schlitzer, C.S.C, Treasurer over Thomas McGrath. merce Building. i October 30, 1964 11 • The Paulist Father is a modern man in every sense of the word. He is a man of this age, cognizant of the needs of modern men. He is free from stifling formalism, is a pioneer in using contemporary ways to achieve the conversion of 100 million non-Catholic Amer­ icans. He is a missionary to his own people —the American people. He utilizes modern techniques to ful­ fill his mission, is encouraged to call upon his own innate talents to help further his dedicated goal.

• If the vital spark of serving God through man has been ignited in you, why not pursue an investiga­ tion of your life as a priest? The Paulist Fathers have developed an aptitude test for the modern man interested in devoting his life to God. This can be a vital instrument to help you make the most impor­ tant decision of your life. Write for it today.

NATIONAL VOCATIONS DIRECTOR PAULIST FATHERS 415 WEST 59tii STREET NEWYORK.N.Y. 10019 Exhilarating...

FRANKIE's Restouront IWasculine... Free Deliveries to Circle Fresii as tlie ocean Nightly Specials for Students ... that's the way it is with $1.25 & Up Old Spice After Shave Lotion! 1.25 and 2.00 Party Rates SHU LTO N Seven-Course Steak Dinner — $2.00

Open 7 Days a Week 233-1115 1003 N. NOTRE DAME AVE.

12 The Scholastic support of Turkish national groups and the Ottoman Empire entered the campus war on the side of the Central Pow­ ers. The period following the war and lasting until after the second World War, 1918 to 1948, marked the pe­ riod of British ascendancy in the Mid­ dle East. During this time Britain had just slightly less than complete control of the affairs of this region. The end of this period came about through World War II and as a direct result of Indian independence begin­ ning a chain of events which proved to be the dismantling process of the British Empire. After 1948 the single largest prob­ lem in the Middle East was that of Palestine and it proved to be one the British were extremely loathe to solve. The final solution had to be one Notre Dame Coeds? Dame SBP, have discussed the mat­ of force which depended on the United Coeducational classes are being dis­ ter on the student level and there has States for assistance and the compli­ cussed (once again) as a possibility at been administration contact through­ ance of the Arab states. The latter the University of Notre Dame. Some out the development of the idea. Sr. was impossible to get. of the freshmen will undoubtedly ex­ Mary Grace, C.S.C, Vice-President As the U.S. gradually assumed perience a quick intake of breath at at SMC, and Rev. Charles Sheedy, more responsibility in the Middle that revelation, and sage upperclass- C.S.C, Dean of ND's College of Arts East, it advocated a policy of retain­ men will only mutter to themselves and Letters, have now been chosen to ing the status quo as nearly as pos­ that "We've heard that before," but work out the myriad of details in­ sible, using among others the Tru­ this time the administrations of both volved. While those "little" details man Doctrine and the Northern Tier Notre Dame and Saint Mary's have may take some time to v/ork out, the defense plan. agreed to the program — at least in idea of some sort of cooperative edu­ At this time direct Soviet influence its theory. One of the obstructions to cation program between the two evolved in the form of military and the plan in the past has been the SMC schools seems sure to be reahzed. technical aid to Egypt. ..- Administration's fear of the loss of 1956 was the year of the Suez crisis St. Mary's independence. Their ad­ Ascendancy of Order in which Britain and France attempt­ ministration has since been found, Monday night in the Rockne Me­ ed to gain a glimpse of the past. The however, in favor of Father Hes- morial Lounge, Professor Matthew combined British and French policy burgh's proposal, at least in its gen­ Fitzsimons delivered an address en­ in this particular case failed because eral outhne. titled "Political Order in the Middle of a lack of communication and co­ operation from the United States. K the plan is accepted, the first East," the content of which was classes might begin next semester. drawn in large part from his recent­ The Eisenhower Doctrine of 1957 Tentative plans would restrict the ly published book. Empire by Treaty. was another U.S. method to hold the types of classes offered (at least at Professor Fitzsimons began by giving line in the Middle East, guarding first) to "specialized" courses, i.e., a definition of politiced order in a against direct pressure from the those normally offered to upper-class given region as the way in which the U.S.S.R. This policy largely failed. students who have already decided existing states of the region and their 1958 marked the termination of on a major. Another aspect of the relationships to each other are recog­ British ascendancy in the Middle East types of classes to be included is that nized by those states themselves. This with the bloody revolution in Iraq they will probably be on the seminar political situation can be changed at which removed the last traces of pattern, calling for a mutual inter­ any time by movements within the British influence there. change of ideas rather than the mass- state, exterior political pressures or Professor Fitzsimons concluded by audience lecture approach. In addi­ a combination of both. saying that although the Middle East tion, student enrollment will probably The political order in the Middle has been quiet by contrast in the last be restricted much as our current East in the 19th century, according five years, there have been rumblings honors courses are, again at least dur­ to Professor Fitzsimons, hinged in a and the region continues to be one ing the early development of the pro­ large part on the existence of the of ferment and unrest. The ultimate gram. Ottoman Empire which enclosed the fate of the Arab world is going to now The concept of coed classes has of greater part of the then Middle East. have to be decided by its own leaders. course had much prior investigation The Ottoman Empire weakened and U.S. intervention grows more and and discussion within the ND-SMC neared political collapse for several more difficult as the states of the Mid­ community. During the past year, reasons: archaic wealth and organi­ dle East emerge. The Arab states of however, student government and zation; an exceptionally corrupt gov­ this region now face four great crises: administration figures of both schools ernment; the multitude of different the Islamic crises of meeting the 20th have been considering some of the nationalities within the Empire and century, technical modernization of specifics and delicacies that are in­ the rise of nationalism; and pressure the traditional Middle Eastern society, herent in such a concept. Helen from Russia and Great Britain. The a general recasting of education and Reichert, President of the SMC student Ottoman Empire finally ended in educational values, and the forces of government, and John Gearen, Notre World War I. Germany gained the nationalism in conflict with the de-

October 30, 1964 13 Badin Hall — Number One Otie and One Makes Homecoming Number One — FisJier Hall sire for Arab unity. The Arab leaders coming parade prize was won by St. time as his listeners. When many late must meet these crises not only in Mary's College and was announced to arrivals came drifting in after the the context of local struggles but also feminine cheers for the second concert had begun, expecting the tra­ in the context of the struggle for straight week of "We're Number ditional late stcirt, he held up his world dominance between the U.S. One!" The parade itself was well or­ right hand cUid explained how "this is and the U.S.S.R. ganized, and several South Bend car the hand that shook the hand of dealers got in plugs for their new Ringo Starr" until aU had been seated cars. The floats were very well done and he could resume the musical part Soaring Spirit and the bright colors stood out as of the evening. With the warm red, yellow and the motorized procession wound its Much of the music Mancini played browns of a balmy Indian summer way around the campus. weekend setting the pace, the 1964 was his own, including the well-known For the seniors, spirits high from Homecoming Weekend was a tre­ favorites from Breakfast at Tiffany's a great victory soared higher in the mendous success. The theme for the and his other motion picture scores, rarified atmosphere of Robert's Sup­ weekend was "The Spirit of '76" in but the program also included a trib­ per Club where Club '65 presented for honor of the 76th year of Notre Dame ute to Victor Young, a suite of the second time the amazing Baby football. The music of Woody Herman Academy Award Losers, and music Huey and the Baby Sitters. Those of filled the vast space of the Stepan by David Rose and others. Mancini a milder disposition and nonseniors Center and BCly May carried on at assured himself of the unconditional headed to the Stepan Center where LaFortune at the dual Friday night approval of his listeners when he be­ Henry Mancini and orchestra per­ celebrations, before our "revenge" gan the second half of the concert formed in concert. battle \vith the Stanford Indians at with the "Notre Dame Victory the Stadium. Miss Sharon Bums was Sunday came with its sad farewells, March." Every aspect of the concert crowned the Queen of Homecoming its Communion Breakfast for the big- was casual and relaxed, with Mancini after close voting in the election. weekenders, and its rush to catch up offering humorous introductions to Saturday morning saw the mirac­ with studies neglected from the previ­ many of the numbers and working ulous appearance of the decorations ous Friday — or earlier. such diverse elements as a few selec­ in front of each hall. Tom Oddo of tions by an excellent folk group, the the Hall Presidents' Council said that Casual Listening Neighbors, and the "Stars and Stripes the displays were in general the best Undoubtedly one of the best sounds Forever" by Sousa into a coherent since the contest started. The winners to come out of Stepan Center recently and most entertaining performance. were announced at halftime of our was last weekend's Homecoming Con­ When the show was over and Mancini fifth straight victory. Badin Hall took cert. Henry Mancini brought one of left the stage, he received such an first prize for a huge rocket which his 40-piece orchestras (he has sev­ enthusiastic ovation that he returned was periodically "launched" by a eral, each located in a different part for an encore, something he rarely crane donated by an alumnus. Walsh of the country) to Notre Dame for does. He returned the compliment by Hall won second prize for a live dis­ a performance of what he might have again playing the "Victory March" play that revolved around a skit tell­ described as "numbers I have re­ and then had to return to a number ing of Notre Dame football down corded." But instead of a mechanical played in the early part of the pro­ through the years. Fisher Hall finally rendition of quality easily dupli­ gram, as the orchestra had exhausted put away its "RAH!" sign of past cated on any phonograph, Mancini's its repertoire. Before leaving, Mancini years and won third prize for a re- presence sparked a performance full commented that he hoped to be asked staging of the Iwo Jima flag raising, of life and enjojmient which quickly to return to the geodesic dome next Notre Dame players lofting a huge captivated the audience. Mancini him­ year. Anyone who attended would be number ONE into the sky. The Home- self seemed to be having as good a glad to second the motion.

14 The Scholastic Pre-election Forensics one thing — that being that they dis­ technical director. The Political Science Academy agreed on the degree of freedom the The play is centered on Troy after sponsored a series of debates to pre­ people should have and the degree of the city has fallen into the hands of sent the views of the opposing parties control the government should have. the Greeks. The men of Troy have in the coming election on certain is­ Each man had ten minutes to pre­ been slain, and Trojan Women depicts sues. Members of the faculty rep­ sent a rebuttal. Mr. Blakey gave some the wives of Troy as they are waiting resented the two parties. The first more arguments for big government to be led away as the personal pos­ was held on Thursday, October 22, at and some examples of how it has sessions of the Greek warriors. The 7:30 p.m., in the Engineering Audi­ benefited the U.S. already. He finished playwright searches and questions torium. William O'Neill, President of up by saying, "I should forego some the morality of war, not by making the Political Science Academy, acted of my freedom to allow a minority a didactic statements from the stage as moderator and the topic was cen­ chance for human dignity." Dr. Nor­ but by examining the effects of war tralized government. Professor Robert ling gave a warning that the U.S. was on the people. What Euripides found Blakey of the Law School took the heading for dictatorship and armed to be the case 2300 yeeurs ago is stiU Johnson Administration's part and revolution. He said that we weren't true today, and the modern audience Dr. Bernard Norling, professor of his­ near that point now, but that the is given a very vivid picture. tory, represented the Goldwater Re­ trend was toward a totalitarian gov­ The St. Mary's production is a de­ publicans. ernment. Dr. Norling concluded with, parture from what is generally con­ "Not enough children and too many sidered the classical style. The dance The debate started with a ten- adults believe in Santa Glaus." is introduced and a primitive set with minute statement by Mr. Blakey in The original series was scheduled heavy, rocklike colors replaces the which he tried to point out that the traditional marble columns and splen­ federal government is not growing to contain four debates, but the Norling-Blakey encounter and two dor associated with antiquity. Area more powerful and that, in fact, the lighting is used to focus attention on state and local governments are get­ held this past Tuesday and Thursday completed it. The change was made prominent speakers, while the dancers ting more and more power. He stated, sway in the background, separated among other things, that the state when Doctor Gerhart Niemeyer re­ fused to appear in his scheduled de­ from the action of the play by a and local government now have almost screen. As a result the author's key as many workers as the federal gov­ bate with Professor Samuel Shapiro. He stated last Sunday that he had not observations are stated with an ur­ ernment, seven million and nine mil­ gency which demands the considera­ lion, respectively. Prof. Blakey also consented to debate. At that time al­ so. Prof. Shapiro reaffirmed his tion of the audience. said that the federal police force, the The character of Hecuba, the queen F.B.I., has only six thousand members willingness to meet Dr. Niemeyer. It should be pointed out that the of Troy, is played by Marilyn Petroff, while a city like New York employs who has acted on the stages of both eighteen thousand on its force. men taking part in these debates do not necessarily adhere to the views ND and SMC, but never in a dramatic Dr. Norling was allowed to ques­ which they propose, but are only rep­ role of this nature. Merry Kay tion Mr. Blakey for five minutes and resenting these views for the sake of Schatzle is her daughter, Cassandra, then got ten minutes for his opening informing the student body. who is to become the mistress of Ag­ statement. He declared that too little amemnon, leader of the Greek forces centralization is just as bad as too in the Trojan war. Andromache, the much and that a middle ground must Of Women and War wife of Hector, killed by Achilles, is be found. Dr. Norling accused the Euripides' Trojan Women is the portrayed by Doris Wilke. Sean Grif­ Democrats of using Socialist Party opening production of the St. Mary's fin holds the only male speaking part, platforms of fifty and sixty years ago. College Speech and Drama Depart­ that of Talthybius, the Greek mes­ During Prof. Blakey's five-minute ment. It wiU be presented Friday and senger, who reveals the fate of the question period the debate centered Saturday evenings at 8:15 p.m., and women of Troy to them. Helen, the around individual liberty or freedom. on Sunday at 7:30 p.m. Mr. Dennis disgraced wife of Menelaus and mis­ Federal farm programs, Medicare, Hayes, the new head of the depart­ tress of Paris, Hecuba's son, is de­ and private enterprise were discussed. ment, directs the Greek tragedy, picted by Pam Gallagher, and Mene­ The two opponents finally agreed on assisted by Mr. William Gratton, laus is played by Jim Clare.

A Weekend of Sounds to Hear . and Sights to See Octohcr 30, 1964 15 CORE, and Young Socialist Alliance to name a few). The University quickly clamped down on these and ordered some of the students operat­ ing the booths to report to the Dean of Students for disciplinary action. on other eatnpttses This touched off a 21-hour sit-in in the Administration Building by about 400 students. The next morning the tables were again set up. A police car • "SEXUAL EXPERIENCE is a great for release wherever they can find it. drove into the area and arrested a healer . ..." So saith Rev. Gerald He proposes replacing the "out­ student running the CORE table. But W. Paul in the newspaper of Carle- moded" and "irrelevant" standards it was 36 hours later before the 3000 ton University in Ottawa, Canada. Fr. with one standard that can be in­ to 8000 demonstrators (depending on Paul, representing the Anglican, Pres­ terpreted by each individual simply the time of day) were dispersed so byterian and United Churches on by asking himself, "Is this an act of the car could leave. Then it was con­ campus, decreed, "Only if we are love?" However, Father is very strict siderably battered from students giv­ certain the sexual relationship will in forbidding sex to those who fail ing speeches from its roof. As yet, help more than harm our partner in to answer this question in the aflSrma- the effect of the demonstrations is the long run as well as in the imme­ tive. The churches represented said not certain. A temporary truce has diate encounter, are we justified in that they would investigate the been called, and from aU indications •premarital sex." He classifies reason­ matter. the University wiU be forced to grant able students as those who feel that at least a small area to the political the commandment prohibiting adul­ • POLITICAL FREEDOM has long been organizations where they can freely tery does not apply to a tj^e of sex the cause of uprisings of every sort; operate. engaged in by two unmarried stu­ and at the beginning of this month dents. After all, this is only a psy­ it caused three days of demonstra­ • AN ANSWER to stopping chronic chological and religious insight of tions at the University of California. fire alarm pullers has been found by post-Victorian thinkers. Now, thinks After the Repubhcan convention in California State Polytechnic College. Rev. Paul, a new sex ethic should be San Francisco this summer, the ad­ The housing coordinator decided that introduced to accommodate what he ministration decided that it would be any student who had the irrepressible feels are the two types of students. best to ban any political activity on urge to pull the alarm could sign a First of all, there are those who are campus. However, to students of con­ list to this effect. Following finals an guided by tliose post-Victorian think­ viction this seemed completely ridic­ entire ctftemoon will be devoted to ers and take an absolute approach ulous. Thus, they began setting up these pranksters so that they can pull to sex activities. Then, there are the various booths in order to pass out the magic handle to their hearts con­ freethinking (perhaps nonthinking) literature and sohcit new members tent. . . . Incidentally no one has had students who might point to the ten­ and funds for their respective groups the courage, as yet, to put his signa­ sions of university life as justification (Students for a Democratic Society, ture on the list. feiffer

ALUMV r-- eoi AWPI wiMRi^ep AUPAFTUR im I 1( lOORKeiP WORKUP HARPATpgl/aOP- Hem OF lOAMTfl? 1r HARP AT HAI?PAT mM'/cmeReo WRKt B5- rom J psvei^op- -mremifj: 6AUTOWW6: mMV IU6MV (;p-m^ r w / MIWG Or / OFAMIWPORA WA$ (^^ hurv. PBR^miT^ ATTQoroa' 5 cmreR of w me PMBR memM' vPhvmemM Mti I4ft

Omt FIMALL-VI AMP I mtVJ THAT HOW CAM mW A /.ITTLf MCR5 A MAN) WAS wme mo R5H, A L/m^ WRe I MARRIgP de- WRK^ Belli- START "Mv eeouT. roo6R AU m THAT5 l\R5. o\ieR^ A6AIM?

16 The Scholastic npHE ANNUAL QUESTION Of the Stay- •^ hall system has again arisen on the Notre Dame campus. In last week's issue of the Voice a new sys­ tem was proposed to the students. The basic feature of the proposal is Stay-Hall: Pro and Con the elimination of the so-called "fresh­ man ghetto," the five freshman halls situated apeirt from the upperclass- men of the campus. This would be by Pete Siegwald accomplished by opening all the haUs on campus to all of the four classes, and limiting a certedn percent of the rooms in each haU for the members of each class. As usual, the pros and cons of the system are under fire by opposing sides. In an attempt to savor student opinion on the question, I talked with two groups of students: seniors, be­ cause they are supposedly looking at the question from outside; and fresh­ men, for they are now living in the "ghetto." Matt Lambert, Senior Class Vice-President, was the first person reached. Matt Lambert is against the pro­ posed stay-hall system. His reasons are many. To him, growing up as a freshman class is an important part of Notre Dame hfe, of life on any campus. There is a common bond of sweat and tears that is unique to the freshman class. How to overcome a problem is something that is better learned than given. And these experi­ ences are better learned while work­ ing with a group of one's own age and temperament. Study habits were pointed out by him as an example. The upperclassman has learned how through the years of Notre Dame life new type of spirit would be created and when to study through experi­ has eeumed his right to choose any common to all. ence. If a freshman were to follow the available room on campus that he de­ The freshmen view the question in example of the upperclassman, it sires. It seems unfair to bar him from much the same light, some pro and would often be to his detriment. Sorin or Walsh or Lyons because the some con. Lewis Pignatelli is avidly Another point made was that hall haU quota has been filled. against the system, and claims that tradition is now set in many of the A man fuUy backing the new sys­ many of his electors who voted him main quad halls. This is often the rea­ tem is Student Body President John Farley Hall Senator agree with him. son behind the choice of rooms by an Gearen. He states the purpose of the He realizes that the freshman needs upperclassman. To force a freshman proposal as being the desire for quick and wants help to become acclimated. into a set haU tradition would be to maturity on the part of the fresh­ But breaking up the class is against do him an injustice. men. The good accomplished in this, his principles. "Learning by doing" he feels, wiU outweigh the bad. By is the phrase he used. They must find Much of the spirit of the school giving a sense of haU unity, thus in­ out what needs to be done, and then comes from the freshmen, he noted. creasing the range of a freshman's must be given the chance to do it. It is they who follow the band, yell circle of friends, class lines, which He also considers the class impor­ loudest at the rally, become most ex­ take the blcmie for slow maturing, tant on another level. "These are the cited at the games. The records of the will be lowered. By associating with people we wiU be going to school with teams of the last few years mean and working near the more mature for four years. We need a chance to little to them. Notre Dame is new to upperclassman, the freshman wiU be­ know ourselves first." them and the spirit they bring as a come more than a super high-school And finally we have the view of class is new each year to Notre Dame. boy. Stanford's HaU Senator. There is both It was pointed out that, on the aca­ The breaking down of the idea of a good and bad to be reaped from the demic level, the freshmen are consid­ freshman quad is a key factor in this. change. The enthusiastic freshman, ered as a unit. The Freshman Year of It wiU require an amount of sacrifice working with the wiUing senior or Studies is set up to regulate their ori­ on the part of the upperclassman in junior or sophomore, would most entation gradually, yet more effective­ the near future. As the classes become Ukely gain some benefit. It would be ly. Why not the same idea on the integrated in their halls, the upper­ up to the people involved on each social level? classman will be able to advise, to lead, fioor, in each haU, he said. Thus it wiU And finally he raised the idea of sen­ to assist the younger (from the stand­ be the job of the students to decide iority. Any person who-has worked point of experience) student. Thus a the issue. October 30, 1964 17 --..£^* -^-;' *^-t C-i imttUMOKSik

by Paul C. Bartholomew lican nominations of at least semi- around these two. This, of course, was liberal candidates — termed "mod­ good politics. With most persons in Professor of Government erate" — with whom the liberals had one way or another economically well no great quarrel. The possibility that off, it was natural to encourage the 'T'HE EorroRS of the SCHOLASTIC have this "liberal era" with its ideological electors to "vote their pocketbooks." -^ asked us to do a piece surve5dng monopoly was coming to an end This was simply another go-around the current campaign in objective, aroused almost hysterical opposition on the "you never had it so good" and non-partisan fashion. To be objective on the part of liberals in both parties, the "two cars in every garage" themes is admittedly a difficult task in an and this attitude really has kejTioted of other campaigns. As might have area where one may have definite no­ the campaign. been expected, the Democrats com­ tions, but, as Fr. Hebert used to say, On the side of the Democrats there pletely ignored the question of the we do our best, the angels can do no has been the effort to create an "im­ basic source of this prosperity, and, more, and what follows is the result age" of Goldwater as irresponsible, while the Republicans made some­ of that effort. unstable, and maybe a little deranged thing of fiscal irresponsibility and the As this is being written, a number mentally. This gives one some notion matter of our living prosperously on of days remain of a Presidential cam­ of the level on which political busi­ our great-grandchildren's money and paign that — to date, at least — has ness has been conducted this year. the question of where does all this not lived up to expectations in some This is an "age of imagery" in pub­ lead eventually, the psychology of the respects and in other respects has lic life, and this year discussion of situation was against them. People surpassed what might reasonably the true issues hcis been shunned in prefer not to think about unpleasant have been expected. Here we are at­ favor of the creation of images — an things. They much prefer, in such in­ tempting a sort of advance post­ angel for your man, a devil for the stances, as one student put it, to be mortem, surveying what has been opposition. In this area of operation, philosophical about it: not think done by both sides and attempting things reached a new high, or a new about it. some "curbstone judgments" as to the low, depending on how one wishes to The peace thing cut two ways for political "rightness" or "wrongness" view it. the-Democrats. Not only did it gloss of such activities but stopping short The Republicans for their part over the very real fact of Vietnam of any prediction on the outcome of made every effort to picture Johnson with the very read and mounting the election. as, at the very best, a vicious oppor­ American casualties, but this issue This has been a campaign of vitu­ tunist and then ranging down through complemented their efforts to "sell" peration and vilification umnatched various categories to a completely the electorate on the "recklessness" in modem times. Even the "cemipaign unprincipled liar, cheat, and robber of Goldwater. This latter was, by any of prejudice" in 1928 when Al Smith who would trample his own mother standards, an unworthy effort by a was nominated did not equal, at least to attain material advantage. party. It was based originally on openly, the personal venom of the cur­ Meanwhile, those who were discuss­ Goldwater's advocacy of giving NATO rent effort. There have been more con­ ing the issues brought up such mat­ field commanders the power to use centrated imtruths, heilf-truths, and ters as government spending and the "conventional" tactical nuclear weap­ plain misrepresentations than possibly fiscal situation generally, the main­ ons in case of need. For this he was in any similar situation within the tenance of the peace, and corruption roundly criticized for suggesting and memory of living man. This is ex­ in public office. Without question, in urging something that would endan­ plained in part by the vociferous the area of issues, the two greatest ger peace. The Democrats encouraged opposition of liberals in both the Re­ items favoring the Democrats have this with the full knowledge that this publican and the Democratic parties been peace and prosperity. Insofar was and had been an accepted thing to Gk)ldwater who represents a de­ as Democratic spokesmen dealt with in reality for some time by every parture from the long line of Repub­ the issues, the campaign revolved President since Eisenhower. The "is- 18 The Scholastic sue" was thus a straw man of the Corruption in office, one of the In spite of repeated "challenges" 1960 "missile gap" variety. The Re­ main points of the Republicans, re­ Johnson refused to join in a 1964 "re­ publicans for their part displayed un­ ceived a new impetus with the Jen­ play" of the famous "great debates" believable stupidity in their handling kins case in the latter stages of the of 1960. Goldwater suggested that of the situation. Eisenhower was campaign, a matter that involved very this be done on tape to avoid the ar­ asked about it and might well have real questions of security as well as gument that a security risk was laid the ghost of this issue by noting of internal government decay. How­ involved in the President's speaking that the procedure advocated by Gold- ever, again the Republicans did not in a possibly heated exchange in a water had been the accepted thing find it possible to dramatize properly "live" debate, but this, too, was in­ under his own administration as well the Estes-Baker-Jenkins combine in a effective in luring Johnson to the joint as under Kennedy and, presumably, manner that had been so successful in podium. Late in the campaign a new also under Johnson. Instead he made previous campaigns, as, for example, television development was the re­ a noncommittal comment that he did the use by Franklin Roosevelt of his fusal of the FCC to allow equal free not think that such matters should be "Martin and Bcu:ton" refrain. time to Goldwater to answer John­ brought up in a campaign. Johnson A review of the chronology of the son's nationwide TV address on three immediately agreed with Eisenhower, campaign reveals that the Democrats networks following Red China's nu­ and it remained for Nixon and others began by Johnson attempting to re­ clear test. The FCC ruled the speech to make the point that Ike had missed. main aloof from the struggle while "nonpolitical" although newsman Bill using "nonpolitical" trips to govern­ Lawrence — before the Commission's ment establishments as a time-hon­ decision — had observed that Johnson ored means of keeping himself in the "took a jab at Goldwater" in the N BETWEEN, Goldwater and Repub­ public eye. Meanwhile, Humphrey was speech on the matter of bipartisan I licans of lesser rank continued to delegated the task of carrying the foreign policy. The Republicans then fail to take advantage of mistakes brunt of the partisan effort. This, purchased a half hour on one network in word and deed by the Democrats. however, did not prove satisfactory to answer Johnson. Even dedicated Goldwater supportei's and Johnson had to become involved All in ciU, the campaign has been were not as effective as one might with frankly political trips, speeches, featured by unprecedented vilifica­ reeisonably have expected. There was and television appearances. Meanwhile tion. There has been a notable lack of not the hard-driving approach that the Republicans started the campaign enthusiasm for Johnson on the part wins in football and in politics as by talking about everything without of Democrats, a tremendous dedica­ well. Democrats continued to make placing emphasis on any one or even tion to Goldwater on the part of his much of the "extremism" issue and a few issues. The result was an ap­ supporters, but great opposition to Republican failure to refute this ade­ parent lack of impact on the public. him by many in his own party as weU quately and effectively enabled the Later this approach was changed and as outside that party. Along with all Democrats to be successful in creating the party's speakers concentrated on of this there has been the unprece­ this Goldwater "image." This pcu:ticu- relatively few issues such as corrup­ dented showing of Johnson in the lar Republican failure was due at tion, centralized government, fiscal polls as weU as the presumed presence least in part to the selfish and myopic irresponsibility, and foreign policy. of a large "silent vote." With Election approach of some prominent Republi­ Miller, in somewhat the same fashion Day looming, as David Brinkley has cans, notably Romney, Rockefeller, as Humphrey, bore the brunt of the pointed out, if the majorities for and Keating. Pre-convention state­ unpleasant attacks on the Democrats. Johnson predicted by the polls do not ments and a later refusal or reluc­ The matter of civil liberties has not materialize, nobody will ever have tance to endorse Goldwater's candi­ been featured, at least openly, in the any faith in poUs in the future. There dacy aided and abetted this Demo­ campaign nearly as much as had been might, however, be a dissertation cratic "line." expected. topic or two involved in this. October 30, 1964 19 Beads and Mntterinp

by Tom VituUo

Prof. James Cameron, professor of philosophy at the University of Leeds, has just given the Terry Lectures at Yale University. He will return to Notre Dame in the second semester as a visiting professor of literature.

that there are many baptized not in conditions for the sacraments were full fellowship with us. We stand to­ only that we perform the rites and be gether against a hostile world. "in the state of grace." This appears At the heart of these problems are only a logical slide to avoid responsi­ two considerations: the nature of the bility to God. These are necessary laity and the legitimacy of the sub­ reasons, but that does not imply they jection of the laity to priestly author­ are sufficient. The purpose of the sac­ ity. raments are to give grace. Aquinas Christ has come to us as the High defines grace as that which brings Priest. He does away with the priest­ nature to perfection. The whole re­ hood of man, for He is the perfect deemed nature of man must be REVIEW of a lecture by Prof. and continuous priest and victim. The brought to enter into the sacraments A James Cameron. The lajmian Church is identified with the priestly —^his state in life, his intellect, his sits. Beads in fidgeting fingers clash, Christ. All men who enter into His desires, and so on. blend with the mutters of a priest, Body (i.e., baptized) become priests The liturgical life of the parish calls and die in the wall. as He is priest, and through the sac- for the same total commitment, and Possibly more than at any time in reunents do as He did. The sacraments the liturgical life that does not issue her history, the Church today needs are signs of what we know only by in concern for our neighbors, but reform. His spiritual world is becom­ faith. rather becomes the end of its own ing increasingly incomprehensible to This community of priests must existence, is Pharisaical. The Chris­ today's Christian. The Second Refor­ have a minister to act, in Christ's tian must be witness to the injuries mation must provide a deeper and con­ stead, as high priest. For the first the image of God suffers in man. tinuing analysis of our beliefs, and a two centuries of the Church, these There Eire positive suggestions to be more complete understanding of the ministers were not referred to as made to help the Christian to these implications .of our faith. That the priests. The Church alone bore that ideals of parish life. The parish must commimity cannot understand its own title, the community of priests. But unfetter itself from the worthless fi­ commimal act is only one of the symp­ by the third century the bishop began nancial burden of supporting primary toms of this need. The concept of the to be called priest and the distinction schools. The pcirishes' energies are ab­ parish has been lost. of this office from the rest of the sorbed by the overwhelming pecuni­ A parish is imderstood as the gath­ Church began. From this beginning ary problems; it is taught avarice ering of aU the people of God, those grew the ecclesiastical myth, that and kills charity. Empirically, the Catholic, those baptized, those in those who are not ordedned ministers system produces no significant differ­ grace, and those eager for the Word, are subjects of external power. This ences in the manners, morals, and in a particular time and place. It is is alien to the spirit of Christ (who customs of its students from the the communal subdivision of the Mys­ said to His Apostles—Luke 22:26-27— public-school systems. The parish tical Body. This is all readily ad­ "Let him who is greatest among you must tackle the problem of Christian mitted by most. But, in actuality, the become youngest, and him who is the education at its root — in the parents Catholic community is itself a sect chief as the servant. For which is who have had no religious instruction within a peirish, and considers itself greater, he who sits at the table or he beyond the primary-school catechism as a group which has the truth and who serves? Is it not he who sits? level. The reestablishment of the in­ is therefore "right." It looks on every­ But I am in your midst as he who stitute of the catechumenate, with its one else as "almost as good." In its serves") and heretical. We must come study of the word of God and trained self-satisfaction, it congratulates it­ to vmderstand this concept of the lay­ instructors would be a welcome so­ self. Catholics, in the English-speak­ man and the misused authority of the lution. ing countries as a whole, take the cleric. The Church of God was the place Church to be the body of Anglo- Most of us feel our congregational of reflective deliberation on the truth Hibernian rites, traditions, and super­ life—our sacramental and liturgical of God's word. It must return to this stitions, none of which can be chal­ life shared by all the parish—should position. By self-analysis and by lenged or rejected. At the same time, be the center of our joy. And yet study, the lajTnan must come to un­ they are suspicious of the elements it is not. derstand the place of Christ in his life. which are understressed in their tradi­ This is because we do not under­ In so doing he takes his proper place tion. For instance, Bible reading is stand our relationship to the sacra­ in the sacramental and liturgical life somdiow suspect — Protestant. We ments, and thus to Christ. In them of the congregation. And in imitating Catholics have a tribal mentality, we imitate Christ. Yet in each of Christ, he imitates both priest and tribal rites and a tribal style of life. them He speaks a truth to His Father. victim — to bring all men to the joy With how many of us is it an agony We have come to believe that the of the Word. 20 The Scholastic Poet John Logan

bv BiU O'Connell

and Mr. Logan illustrated this well. This poem is typical of much of Mr. In reading his poetry, he would often Logan's work in that it combines re­ draw a word out, stretching and ligious themes with a frank, contem­ squeezing it, hanging it up and slowly porary conversational style and a dropping it off the tip of his tongue, sensual, at times almost biological re­ so that the audience could relish the alism. Beginning with meditations fullness of the sensuality which his upon the sermon for the Third Sun­ words connnoted. Just as his late day of Lent (it is rare that one can friend e. e. cummings would some­ use the Sunday Missal as a literary times write phrases with the words reference book), he moves to violent allruntogether, Mr. Logan at times images of what could be a divine read phrases that bespoke exhilara­ madness, or a state of drunkenness — tion with a tripping quickness repre­ "Spread eagled on the soaking earth senting their joy. His rhythms were I let the rain never those of sentences, always move its audible little hands gently those of poetic lines. As he read, those on my skin. . ." of the audience who listened careful­ There is another abrupt change ly had the content of the poetry of mood brought out strikingly heightened for them by the emphasis in Mr. Logan's reading when the or lack of emphasis that particular poem switches to a conversational words or lines received. On the other style and tells, with a quiet seren­ hand, those who came for simple mu­ ity, of previous walks with his wife sical enjoyment had the pleasure of and a student. Such poetry, now A FORMER NOTRE DAME PROFESSOR hearing a voice used with such skiU soaring, then so very earthy — never -^*- in the General Program, John and cleverness that his poems seemed in a strange tongue, but always speak­ Logan, returned to campus on Octo­ to be seeking to cast a spell rather ing with the words of a contemporary, ber 21 to give a recitation of his own than tell a story. Mr. Logan has the enabled Mr. Logan, almost from his poetry. Although publicity posters gift of creating an image in sound first line, to take the audience firmly were few and late, he nevertheless with such facility that it produces a in hand and transport them with him drew a crowd which filled three delight independent of the meaning to varicolored recesses of mood, emo­ quarters of a double-sized classroom of the poem. tion, and thought. in O'Shaughnessy. Dr. Christin of Mr. Logan's selections were drawn Mr. Logan is a poet who clearly has the English Department, in his intro­ both from his published works and been influenced by his Catholic envir­ duction, read a portion of a London from poetry that he has written since onment. In "The Wooden Mirror," he Times review of one of Mr. Logan's his last book. Because much of this portrays the anguish of a sinner who books of poetry in which he was poetry was written while Mr. Logan fears that his heau't has grown cold praised as one of the best of the taught at Notre Dame, there were while he waits for his confession to younger poets of our time. He then many fascinating instances of the be heard. introduced Mr. Logan as not only a poet using particulars within our aca­ Mr. Logan, however, showed him­ skilled poet but a fine reader of demic community. Some of the inci­ self capable of treating greatly differ­ poetry. dents in the poems are set on the ent subject matter. His poem "The Despite the limitations of a room campus, and he read a line from a Picnic" is a gentle portrait of sweet better adapted to English classes than student's paper as a prologue to one young love on a perfect spring after­ poetry reading (the dramatic dimness of the poems. noon, and "The Zoo" is a fascinating of St. Mary's theater, where Mr. "Spring of the Thief," one of the mixture of vivid and funny descrip­ Logan has recited before, is much poems which Mr. Logan recited, is tions of animals and sardonic com­ better than a room with a distracting about a walk around St. Joseph's mentary upon the people who come to sunlit view of the main quad), the Lake. The statues of Christ and the see them. audience was soon captured by the two thieves, on the seminary side of One must agree with Mr. Christin intensity and skill of Mr. Logan's the lake, form one of the themes of in commending the Academic Com­ technique. Certainly the one who has the poem. In it, he speaks of finding mission for bringing a poet of such the best grasp of the subtleties of Sacred Heart Church locked up, rep­ prominence and depth back to our rhythm in a poem is the poet himself, resenting an estrangement from God. campus. October 30, 1964 21 Love With The Proper Passion

by Robert Haller

Audrey Hepburn: Breakfast At Tiffany's nPO SUCCESSFULLY UNITE the tWO tion, but she stands him up to go out ghetti with a tennis racket, finding ••- elements of grace and eros in a with his boss to Lemmon's apart­ it impossible to lose a game of gin motion picture and maintain the ment love-nest. On the next day he rummy to the invalid MacLaine, con­ union for the length of its duration finds her compact with its cracked fusing the keys to his apartment and is to effect one of the most difficult mirror, recognizes it as hers, and the executive washroom — and made and rewarding ventures a film maker drops her. But then Lemmon's mar­ one of the most effective films of the can undei'take. With this delicate ried employer drops her too, and in decade. combination sealed in his cameras the remorse she attempts suicide in the Robert Mulligan's Love With TJie director or screenwriter can com­ flat. It is Christmas Eve, and when Propei- ^trangei' and Robert Wise's mand of the most powerful emotional Lemmon comes home he finds her Two For the Seesaio are accidentally responses in his audience and with a drugged body with its life ebbing different from The Apartment in that chaste vision of often illusory beauty away. Then, with the quick aid of a the first has more of a stress on com­ before their eyes, irrevocably ensnai'e doctor, he saves her, and Wilder in­ edy, and the latter on drama. Essen­ them in his owTi vision of reality. itiates one of the most touching tially, though, they are identical to One of the finest examples of this relationships ever created on a movie Wilder's classic prototype in respect union is Tlie Aqyartment. a tragi­ screen. to the critical factors involving the comic portrait of our society that in­ He is able to do this because, (1) audience in the crises of the plot dicates the nature of the strains in he has touched the audience's experi­ through similarity of environment modern life by describing its effects ence by making MacLaine and Lem­ and appealing to their ideals. Dealing upon a love-linked pair of office mon victims of our huge and imper­ with common emotions and problems. workers. Director BiUy Wilder es­ sonal society, (2) he has had Love With tlie Proper Strangei' has tablishes his theme in the first Lemmon save her from death, the deeply moving scene in the taxi- sequence of the film when we see touching the audience's romantic cab as Steve McQueen and Natalie Jack Lemmon anonymously toiling ideals (as a kind of Prince Charm­ Wood escape from the abortionist, somewhere in an acx^e of identical ing), (3) he has absolved them of McQueen comforting her in the face desks, and then later working over­ guilt by their remorse and plight, of a vindictive, ruthless, and un­ time because his department head is again moving the audience with hope thinking world. In Tioo For The See­ using his apartment for a fast fall for itself, and (4) he has placed saw Shirley MacLaine reappears in with one of the secretaries from the Lemmon in a dominant position rel­ the role of the well-meaning but un­ steno pool. Wilder's underlying bitter­ ative to MacLaine — she is iU from lucky girl in the city who is taken ness (even present in Irma La Douce) the effects of the near-fatal overdose advantage of by cads and then taken points up the sordid quality of this of sleeping piUs — again touching care of by the wandering prince, and then contrasts it with Lemmon's the audience by altering the "un­ Robert Mitchum. The ending is differ­ feelings towards elevator operator naturally equal" male-female rela­ ent, but the pathos and eros stay true Shirley MacLaine who has apparent­ tionship shared by the contemporary to tradition: always restrained, it ly frustrated all the office wolves. viewer (at least psychologically). still moves the audience to appreciate Lemmon's courtesy to her (and as­ Against this \vistful background and involve itself in the crises of the sent to her individuality in the teem­ Wilder added some perfectly droll players. ing skyscraper) wins him her affec- comedy — Lemmon straining spa­ The one man who has most con- 22 The Scholastic sistently used this technique is the itself. Such is the case with Alfred game of who can be the most success­ expatriate American writer-director Hitchcock's Vertigo and, to a lesser ful fool. Love is, like everything else, Carl Foreman. All of his major films extent, John Frankenheimer's The sudden, compulsive, and once estab­ — High Noon, TJw Key, The Guns of Manchurian Candidate. In these pic­ lished, incorruptible. Laurence Har­ Navarojie, and The Victors — use tures style and directorial elan are vey, utterly unlovable in the normal a reserved passion both as a counter­ more important than any message to world, is carried away by passion point to violence and the mark that the mind, and what is so significantly (and/or, coincidentaUy, science in the determines the humanity of his char­ stylized are the elements of love, mys­ form of the red Queen); in much the acters. Foreman's world is one of tery, and suspense. Vertigo features a same way Frank Sinatra, sick be­ death, anarchy, and destruction, and dead-again, alive-again Kim Novak cause of brainwashing, falls for Janet wandering in this physical and moral caught between the opposed forces of Leigh, who first pursues him in his chaos his protagonists eventually find justice and evil, bewitching both the distraction, and then is pursued (and that only human compassion can audience and James Stewart, while dominated) when he is about to right serve as a reason for survival. In Hitchcock enchantingly wheels his the insane world. The film is fascinat­ High Noo7i Grace KeUy stays with story through San Francisco, across ing, not only in its construction and and eventually kills to help Gary the Bay, and then into a shadow-dap­ handling of the cryptic scenes of con­ Cooper even though she is a pacifist; pled forest of love enclosing a dream- fusion of identity, but also because it and when the duel is over she rides ridden tower of terror. Its mythic bases itself in the fears of and threats away with him, the only person or overtones and lushly golden beauty to the audience in reality. For politics value he does not discard. Although elicit responses that, whether con­ often is a fraud, science does seem she was not the cause of his deter­ scious or not, demand participation in to threaten man, and love does seem mination to stay and fight, she does what gradually evolves into a night­ to have lost its deep passion. represent a haven, something to sus­ mare of inexorable progression. The Another fantasy was Breakfast At tain him after he had fulfilled honor's frequently verbal protests caused by Tiffany's, a softly glowing treatment dictates. This is Sophia Loren's func­ the outrageous ending are the great­ of a wavering hetaira that lightly tion in TJie Key, the meaning of Eli est evidence of how deeply Hitchcock danced the thin lines of credibility Wallach's encounter with the shell- has hooked his audience. and wish-fulfiUment. Tiffany's is a shocked Jeanne Moreau in The Vic­ Like V&'tigo, The Manchurian Can­ rare kind of film though, and it tors, and the explanation of Gregory didate is a paranoiac exercise in a worked only because it was created Peck's protective consideration of the fantasy, describing an underground by one of the most competent teams girl he will later discover to be an in­ of utter depravity and absolute emo­ ever to be assembled. Had not script- former in The Gims of Navarone. tions behind the familiar facade of er George Axelrod (who also wrote society. When men fight they break The Manchurian Candidate), actress "DuT EROS CAN BE MORE than an in- tables with judo blows and kick in Audrey Hepburn, actor George Pep- •'-' strument for furthering the de­ their enemy's rib cages. Science and pard, director Blake Edwards, and velopment of a story; its treatment technology are invested with abso­ music man Henry Mancini been work- may become the purpose of the film lute powers and politics becomes a (Continued on -page 31) IBi:'--

Shirley MacLaine: Two For The Seesaio Jeanne Moreau: The Victors October 30, 1964 23 Understanding Our Trial

by Jeremy Lane and Lawrence Kellerman

'T'HE PROFESSOR STALKED into claSS, do not consider the entire purpose of Code. It is based not on the premise -•- slammed the tests down on the the Code. It can make the Notre Dame that the students are better proctors desk. "Unfortunately, we are now on Spirit into something binding, not than the prof, but on the conviction the Honor System. Now you can each "college kids," but men of honor. that Notre Dame is a truly Christian worry about your own exam — and They should not only demand honor community. This means a real desire everyone else's too." He turned of their fellow students; they must to help one another. The student who around and walked out. stand ready to help them realize this wants to help his friend does not do This little scene will sound famiUar ideal. so by helping him cheat or by remain­ to quite a few students. And it is re­ "In cooperation with the spirit of ing a silent spectator. But he can help grettable, because the Honor Code is the Honor Code, tlie instructor shall by warning him, by waking him to a fact. Its merits were argued for a assume tlie honesty of his students, his responsibilities. A word can be long time, but the decision has been and shall not act as a proctor during enough if the student is nearby. If made. Such debate and criticism can tlie exams." the violator is not close, or if other no longer be considered constructive; circumstances dictate, the student There have been many objections should give a general warning to the it should be suspended until we have to this article. One teacher has said, given the Honor Code a fair trial. To class, either vocally or by writing it "The student taking an examination on the board. do that we must understand the Code has enough to do. He shouldn't have as it is now written. to worry about what other students "Ill the case tliat a warning is not are doing." This would be a telling heeded, the observer shall report the violator to tlie Honor Council." "All work suhniitted for credit in objection, if two conditions are grant­ any form slmll he the result of the ed: the academic phase is completely How often have we heard the re­ stude7ifs own tlwught and honest ef­ divorced from other goals of a Notre frain, "Why should I turn someone in fort according to procedures estab- Dame education; and the student is for cheating? I'm not responsible for lislwd in tJie course." asked to go out of his way to spot him." The only answer to this is a flat anyone cheating. Neither of these is contradiction — you do have an obli­ This means that each student is gation to him, and to the community responsible for his own work. The the case. Notre Dame is more than just an academic institution. Every as well. The student who ignores a professor wiU continue to decide in all warning has consciously removed respects how his course is to be phase of life here should be aimed at building an educated Christian man. himself from the community of taught. The limit of cooperation honor. This separation is destruc­ among students, seating arrange­ And in the overwhelming majority of cases, cheating is an annoying and tive of both the individual and the ments during tests, and other pro­ community. There should be no hesi­ cedural matters are his prerogative. distracting intrusion on the student taking a test. Rather than distract the tation due to "conflicting loyalties." "Each student sliall be responsible student, the Honor Code should allow The two are one. The mechanism of not only for maintaining his own him to take his exams in unbroken the Honor Council has been construct­ honor, but also for denwbnding Jwnor concentration. ed to fulfill this dual obligation. The among Jiis fellow students. He shall goal is both protection of the commu­ consider himself part of the commu­ There have been many questions nity and the restoration of the vio­ nity of Jwnor and. if tliat Iwnor is about where the professor should stay lator to his rightful place in it. violated, it is his responsibility to .re­ while an exam is being given. If there "A violator is encouraged to ac­ store tliat community through tlie is a lounge of some sort on the same knowledge his guilt to the Honor means of tlie Honor Code." floor, or even within reasonable dis­ Council, whether lie lias been warned The meaning of the word "univer­ tance, this would be best. But if there or not." The whole aim of the Honor sity" includes unity. It is more than is no place, it would be a discourtesy Code can also be seen in the use of a random gathering; it is a coming to ask the teacher to stand in the cor­ graduated penalties: a penalty deter­ together of memy different people for ridor for an hour. It is important, how­ mined by the instructor, to be no the achievement of a common goal. ever, that the professor define his po­ worse than course failure; suspen­ The community is no stronger than sition to his students. Since he is not sion; expulsion. If the Appeal Board the bonds uniting its members. Notre acting as a proctor, the student should decides that a review is in order, con­ Dame has long been recognized by feel no resentment at his presence. The viction must be upheld by a majority that intangible called the "Notre professor's status as proctor plays a vote of four out of five. large role in the "friendly enmity" Dame Spirit." It is composed of many The whole Honor Code is aimed, not things, and it has changed and devel­ referred to above. And the line be­ tween this and a real student-teacher at weeding out cheaters but at build­ oped over the years. Under the Honor ing men. Notre Dame is the ideal Code, that spirit can be brought to dichotomy is dangerously thin. The Honor Code can help eliminate both place for tempering both personal in­ maturity, made more Christicm. Some tegrity and Christian responsibility. have expressed fears that the Code by placing student and teacher on the same side of the fence. If the Code is understood and is used will turn into a spy system, dividing wisely — if it is given a fair trial — the student body. In the past the stu­ "A warning shall be given wlien an it can prove a potent force in uniting dents were united in friendly enmity honor violation occurs." This could be and maturing the Notre Dame toward "the prof." But these people the key to the success of the Honor student. 24 The Scholastic IN Tbe feeciNNiNQ... SEE urn

IN PERSON

HETHER PROMPTED by a need for with lights, the grand Gregorian tones W fresh air or money for the of the Te Deum rang out, and the joy­ real Challenge I, Rev. Edward Sorin is ous tinkling of the chimes and the for the reported to have spent some 14 booming bass of the big beU could be months travelling through Europe in heard aU about. O, it was a scene 1867-68. The exact nature and results never to be forgotten!" Cecil B. De- MARDI GRAS of the trip are not known, but for the Mille rides again. record, the Austro-Prussian War was Although financially supported by begun while Fr. Sorin was visiting in the University, the early SCHOLASTIC KICKOFF Vienna. All of Fr. Sorin's accomplish­ nonetheless sought local advertising ments abroad, however, are dwarfed for its pages. Looking about in search by the grandeur of his return to his of parties likely to need advertising, stately pleasure dome in Indiana. their eyes fell upon their neighbor, CONCERT Whether Fr. Sorin passed out silver St. Mary's. Mother M. Angela, pre­ buUets as he left Paris is not known, siding monarch at the institution, in­ but if his departure was at all similar serted the following information in to his arrival at ND, it must have an 1868 edition: been material for "You Are There." "St. Mary's Academy, under the di­ SUNDAY NIGHT The triumphal reentry into Xanadu rection of the Sisters of the Holy is described by the SCHOLASTIC as fol­ Cross, is situated on the scenic St. in the lows: "South Bend was aU in commo­ Joseph River, eighty miles east of tion — flags gaily waved in the breeze Chicago, via Michigan Southern Rail­ STEPAN CENTER — the air was filled with sonorous road, and two miles from the flourish­ sounds of military music and the ing town of South Bend. The site of streets thronged with people. 'Helloa,' St. Mary's is one to claim the admi­ cried a stranger, 'what's going on ration of every beholder. Magnificent here?' 'Why, don't you, know,' said forest trees rising from the banks of a citizen, 'Father Sorin is coming!' one of the most beautiful rivers in Upon his arrival, the Rev. Father was the Mississippi VaUey still stand in formally received by the Faculty and native grandeur; music of bright wa­ placed in a carriage, which was fol­ ters and healthy breezes inspire ac­ lowed by many others, the whole tivity and energy, while the quiet se­ headed by the Notre Dame Concert clusion invites to reflection and study. Band, over which floated in ample For catalogue, write to St. Mary's folds the star spangled banner. The Academy, Notre Dame, Indiana." caravan was escorted to the bounda­ Appearing at the end of several of Remaining limited section ries of the University where the stu­ the 1867 issues was a section imag­ dent body was drawn up in orderly inatively titled "Jokes." Webster de­ tickets on sale silence to greet him — which they did, fines a joke as something done or said in order, but not in silence, as spon­ to excite a laugh. Ready? Better tomorrow in taneous shouts of joy went up from sit down for this one: "'Toute de the entire legion, awakening the suite/ said the conductor, a little im­ echoes for miles around. patiently, as one of the orchestra "The coup d'oeil presented in the bothered him by asking when he was ROOM 2B church was solemn and impressive: going to practice that new overture. the students were arranged in their 'But I can't toot sweet,' said the places, the sisters filled half the haU despairing musician with a clarinet, STUDENT CENTER \yith their numerous pupils (how imagining the remark to be intended many eyes did they have?), strangers, for himself." Yuk? and visitors. The altar was ablaze —JOHN TWOHEY October 30, 1964 25 Huarte

for 999 yards and nine touchdowns. If he continues at this rate he will break season records for most passes attempted, most completed, most touchdown passes and total yardage gained passing. Last week he set two single gcime passing records: most passes attempted (37) and most completed (21). Jack Snow is responsible for more than half of Huarte's completions. Against Wisconsin he broke the Notre Dame single game yardage record with 217 yards on nine catches. Last week he broke the All-Time season pass receiving yardage record. He has caught 34 passes for 595 yards and five touchdowns in only five games. In 1962, Jim Kelly, whose record he broke, caught 41 passes for 523 yards in ten games. At his present rate. Snow will break Kelly's season record of 41 catches and seven touchdowns as well as the career total of 71, held by Joe Heap. Snow had 10 receptions before this year. These records are impressive — even more impressive when compared to their past performances. Huarte had 45 minutes of playing time last year. Snow played be­ hind Kelly as a sophomore and caught only four passes; last year he had six. John Huarte's unorthodox three quarter But there is an explanation for their abrupt success arm passing and brilliant faking is the besides the natural ability which the pair obviously pos­ heart of Notre Dame's most successful of­ sesses. "Two years ago when Daryle Lamonica was throwing all those passes to Kelly, I was down on the fense in years. prep team throwing to Jack — we've been working to­ gether ever since," explains Huarte. Snow concurs, "This is no overnight fairy tale story. We've been waiting to get in a game for a long time. All that practice is be­ ginning to pay off." Many added hours of practice were spent this summer as a result of Huarte's shoulder separation. Immediately •^ToTRE DAME WASN'T SUPPOSED to be undefeated after after the separation, in the spring, Huarte could raise his -•-^ five games. The widely accepted because game-tested arm high enough to throw five yards. After two weeks axiom that a team with little experience, no depth, and of weight-lifting and swimming, he could throw only 15 a formidable schedule will have limited success has been yards. He decided to sacrifice his summer vacation, attend defied. summer school here and practice in the ctfternoon. Snow There are many reasons: a brilliant coaching staff, remained as well and they practiced together. Improve­ an impregnable defense, and an explosive offense which ment was slow — in three weeks Huarte's maximum dis­ includes consistent running and game-winning passing. tance was 25 yards. It was only a few weeks before fall Primarily responsible for the airborne half of an practice began that he returned to form. attack which has accumulated 1968 yards (1021 passing) All this practice improved timing and technique are Californians Jack Snow and John Huarte. The pair but more importantly it produced an instinctive com­ have already broken four single game passing-receiving munication between the two. Snow knows just how records and threaten to rewrite a large segment of the AU- Huarte will throw the ball in any situation euid Huarte Time Notre Dame season and career record book. In five knows exactly how Snow will run his patterns. This is games, Huarte has completed 62 passes in 111 attempts especially apparent on broken pass patterns. Snow often 26 The Scholastic to Snow

will run his assigned pattern, sense he is covered, and run something else. Huarte knows instinctively when Snow is doing this, fakes the assigned pattern, thus drawing the defender in and enabling Snow to run another pattern. Their practice together has even enhanced the suc­ cess of assigned patterns. Because Huarte knows ex­ actly how Snow will run he can study the reactions of the defensive backs and throw before Snow actually makes his cut. The down and out and curl-in have been the most successful of the assigned pass patterns. On either pattern a linebacker generally picks Snow up at the line of scrim­ mage and stays with him for about ten yards. Then a safety picks him up to defend against the long pass and to provide double coverage. If the linebacker plays Snow to the inside he will break toward the sidelines after eight or ten yards. Huarte's pass in this situation is low and hard. Snow is often forced to dive for these down and out passes but this is not because the ball has been badly thrown. It is impossible to intercept such a pass and nearly impossible to defend against. If the linebacker plays Snow to the outside and the Scifety waits for him to enter his zone. Snow will run the curl-in. He fakes to the outside as he is about to enter Jack Snow's leaping catches have netted the safety's zone, Huarte pump-fakes, and Snow cuts inside, in front of the safety. Huarte passes hard and 5 touchdowns and 595 yards. His suc­ high to minimize the possibility of interception. This is cess has startled some^ but not Jack, he's a dangerous pass for Snow. He generally must jump to been working three years for this. reach the ball and the safety is right behind him ready to tackle viciously (see cut) the instant the ball touches his hands. The long scoring pass ("the bomb") is usually the result of a fake curl-in. This pass especially and all passes to a lesser degree require good protection. Snow runs a short curl-in, Huarte fakes the pass and Snow goes deep, hopefully getting behind the already committed tection has been exceptional; he has very rarely been defender. unable to pass and much of the credit for this belongs "The bomb" was especially effective against Wisconsin. to the offensive line. Some of it, however, is due Huarte Snow caught two for long touchdowns. Since that game, himself. No Notre Dame quarterback since Ralph Gug- Notre Dame opponents have played Snow "loose." The lielmi has faked so well — time after time Huarte's fakes strategy has been to prevent the long pass and to jar on play-action passes have deceived the opposing line­ the short ones from Snow's grasp. Good passes and sure backers and set up cinch completions. This coupled with hands have foiled this strategy thus far. his quick delivery and unique ability to throw "around" As good as Snow and Huarte are, their success would onrushing linemen have enabled Huarte to avoid the fate be impossible without Bob Meeker, Dick Arrington, Norm of opposing quarterbacks. Nicola, John Atamian and John Meyer. This should be Everything considered, there is no reason why Huarte apparent to anyone who has watched Notre Dame's first can't keep passing and Snow can't keep catching. And five games — especially Heirold Brandt, Bob Griese, Tim if they do, the Irish will keep winning. Murphy, Larry Zeno, and Terry DeSylvia. Huarte's pro- —^MiKE BRADLKY October 30, 1964 27 Voiee in the Crowd THE CRAGG-MIRE A NALYZING THE Notre Dame game films, Stanford Coach John Ralston PICKS OF THE WEEK •^^ noticed that quarterback John Huarte invariably looked for Jack Snow when fading to pass. If Snow was covered by two or three de­ MISSOURI AT NEBRASKA: Shake­ fenders, Huarte hesitated and then threw to a secondary receiver. Ral­ speare said that flesh is heir to a ston realized that Snow was catching 75% of Huarte's completed passes. thousand natural shocks. Missouri will His game plan was to double team Snow and not to worry about the be convinced of this Saturday when other receivers. the Cornhuskers reap the fruits of vic­ But it was the other receivers who thwarted Ralston's analysis; tory, and the Show-Me-Staters get the Snow caught eight passes, but Nick Eddy received five, Joe Farrell three. chaff in the Game of the Week. Bill Wolski caught two, and Denny Conway, Phil Sheridan, and Joe Kantor one each. OHIO STATE AT IOWA: Meanwhile, Ralston also observed that Snow had a tendency to fumble immedi­ Iowa, disguised as a mild mannered ately after being tackled. Ralston instructed Safetyman Ragsdale Big Ten team, is ready for a super­ to play exclusively for the long pass. When no one went long, he was human effort. The wise guise of Iowa to come up quickly, paying particular attention to Snow. If Snow will catch the Buckeyes napping, and caught the ball, a jarring tackle was supposed to cause many a fumble Snook's passing will prove the margin and incomplete pass. of victory in the Upset of the Week. To the dismay of Stanford fans, this play worked only once. In the third quarter, Ragsdale collared Snow as he received a look-in pass GEORGIA TECH AT DUKE: Tech's over the middle, and Snow dropped it. On four of his receptions, how­ first year as a free lance outfit has ever. Snow withstood Ragsdale tackles while making superb catches. been quite successful, but on Saturday, their corporate ability will be heavily After the game. Coach Ralston commented that Notre Dame had taxed by the Blue Devils. When the ". . . the most potent offense I've seen this year. Huarte and Snow are final figures are tallied, however, a great combination." The StEinford coach even went as far as to say, they'll still be in the black. "Notre Dame's defense is the finest I've seen in my 13 years of coaching. Mj'^ whole baU club almost fainted from the physical beating they took," MISSISSIPPI AT LOUISIANA STATE: Statistics tell the story. The Irish limited the nation's leading ground Last week, the Tigers were party to a gainer, Raj'^ Handley, to 43 yards — 70 below his average per game. dismal tie with Tennessee. They're sure The Indians' total rushing offense netted one yard, decreasing opponents' to be sharper this week, and any yards-per-carry average to 29 inches. Notre Dame's defensive secondary Rebel without a claw's mark on him played an outstanding game; Tony Carey was briUiant, breaking up must have watched the game from the three passes and becoming a six-star general. The Indians mustered only bench. four completions in 15 attempts.

COMPARED WITH '63 UCLA AT CALIFORNIA: UCLA's cruise With 18 tackles against Stanford, Captain Jim CarroU leads Coach in the seas of Eastern and Midwestern John Ray's unit with 78. Last year, after five games, Carroll had 28 football proved disastrous. Back in con­ tackles. Carey, with six interceptions, already has picked off more ference waters, they'll find that the enemjr aerials than Notre Dame's season leader for 1963, Tommy Mac- Golden Bear's Morton is an old salt, Donald. In five games, BiU Wolski has rushed for 362 yards; after five firm in his passing game, and capable games last fall, Notre Dame's rushing leader had 198 yards. John of leading Gal to a win. Huarte has already completed more passes (62) than all seven of Notre Dame's quarterbacks last year. ILLINOIS AT PURDUE: In most offensive and defensive departments, Notre Dame's five- There's a giddy young team from game statistics this fall are amazing improvements over the nine-game Purdue, statistics of last year. For example, Whose winning's too good to be true. '63 (9) '64 (5) But mini sagacity. a) points scored 108 151 Mixed with tenacity. b) first downs 119 112 Will bring them down from the blue. c) opponents yds. rush 1501 135 d) opponents yds./carry 3.71 0.84 OTHER GAMES: e) yards passing 654 1021 f) completion % 43 53 Texas over SMU g) passes intercepted 14 14 Syracuse over Pitt h) total offense 1980 1968 use over Washington It will be hard to duplicate these statistics in the five remaining Wyoming over New Mexico games. The Irish will face six outstanding quarterbacks on the next five Oregon over Stanford Saturdays — Roger Staubach of Navy, Fred Mazurek and Kenny Lucas Florida over Auburn of Pitt, Steve Juday of Michigan State, Gary Snook of Iowa, and Craig Arkansas over Texas A&M Fertig of Southern California. But more importantly, every team remaining on the schedule will be gunning for the Irish. Each team that we face will be trying to salvage a little glory from a mediocre season. The first five games were tough — the next five will be tougher. — REX LARDNER Last week: 8-4-1, 67%. To date: 42-18-1, 70%. 28 The Scholastic Zahm's three-yard line and a fumble on Zahm's 11 halted another. Both teams are tied for second place, THE PRESIDENT'S CUP though undefeated. Stanford moved into first place with a hard-fought, 6-0 victory over ARRY KAZMERSKI MAY NOT BE Off-Campus, which defeated Mor­ stubborn Breen-PhiUips. Breen-Phil- L Notre Dame's next Johnny Latt- rissey last week, scored an impressive lips had a number of scoring oppor­ ner, but the speedster from Morrissey 17-0 win over St. Ed's-Sorin. Dan tunities, but Stanford halted them on was the star of the day in last Sun­ Manion initiated the scoring with a each occasion. Stanford gambled on day's schedule of interhall contests. 4-yard burst off tackle and Ed fourth down in the fourth quarter — Kazmerski scored four touchdowns "The Toe" Hurley booted the extra the result was a 30-yard pass comple­ in his hall's 34-0 romp over Badin- point. The game was a standoff until tion on a fake punt. The play kept Fisher and closed in on Farley's Bill late in the third quarter. Jerry Hess a drive going which culminated when Kenealy in the interhall scoring race. grabbed a punt after a Sorin-St. Ed's Lou Blum hit Marty O'Hagen with a After the first three plays of the player had touched it, and ran for 35 51-yard pass for the game's only game, Badin was losing 20-0. On the yards and the second score. Hurley score. first play, Kazmerski scored on a converted, and later finished the scor­ Bill Kenealy had emother excel­ triple reverse pass play from Rick ing with a 22-yard field goal. The 17-0 lent day and kept Farley in the battle Dunn. He then ran 23 yards with a victory gave Off-Campus sole posses­ for first place. The league's leading ball that squirted out of the hands sion of first place in the Western Di­ scorer amassed all his team's points of Badin fullback Phil Brady. On the vision. in a 14-8 win over Cavanaugh. Ke- third play from scrimmage Kazmer­ Dillon broke into the victory col­ nealy's scores came on a 60-yard pass ski made a one-handed interception umn with a 12-0 conquest of Walsh- from Ted Samulski and later on a 10- of the hapless Badin quarterback's Alumni. John Mauro's 3-yard score yard run. He also slanted off tackle pass and returned it 30 yards for his and humble Dave MacNamee's 20- for the conversion. Cavanaugh fought third touchdown. Dunn then passed yard touchdown run, combined with back, tallying six points when Tom to Kevin Igoe making the score 20-0. a fine defense and clock-consuming Chemoi passed 12 yards to Jim Karol. Many thought American Medical were offense, enabled Dillon to move into Farley ran out the clock and clinched once again playing football. Kazmer­ a second-place tie with Morrissey and their first victory of the season. ski got his fourth score in the third Sorin-St. Ed's. This week's feature games are Kee­ quarter on a 58-yard pass from Dunn, In the Eastern Division, the feature nan vs. Stanford, and Morrissey vs. and Ed Kibler ran the conversion. game between Keenan and Zahm re­ St. Ed's-Sorin. Other contests include Morrissey concluded the debacle with sulted in a scoreless tie. Keenan com­ Dillon vs. Badin-Fisher, Off-Campus a 15-yard run by Joe Minolo. Badin pletely stopped Zahm's passing attack vs. Walsh-Alumni, Zahm vs. Cava­ forces were undismayed — last year and had numerous chances to score, naugh, and Breen-Phillips vs. Farley. they lost 42-0. but the clock stopped one drive on — Steve Anderson

Final scores: Mike O'ConneU 69 - 280 SCOREBOARD Pat Danahy 71 - 289 BiU Regnier 78 - 302 BiU Sebaske 78 - 302 CROSS COUNTRY: Notre Dame's meets. Welch's finish also was a hope­ Joe Smith 78 - 304 once defeated but fast improving ful sign of things to come — injured cross country team defeated Michigan in an auto accident, he has been un­ SOCCER: The Notre Dame Soccer State University (20-38). Bill Clark able to compete or practice all year. Club continued its winning ways, de­ repeated his victorious Notre Dame With the IC4A meet only two weeks feating Goshen CoUege (7-3) and Tri- Invitationeil performance, winning in away the return of Welch and Dean State CoUege (6-0). Hernan Puentes a time of 25:21.4 over the five-mile was more than heartening — it was was the leading scorer for the two National Collegiate Athletic Associa­ mandatory. contests with four goals. Mariano tion Championship course. Gonzales had two. The team stiU has GOLF: Mike O'ConneU fired a 69, an outside chance of attending the The victory was decisive, though his third subpar round of the tourna­ NCAA tournament. not as significant as it might have ment to win the Burke Open with a been since MSU's number one runner, 72-hole total of 280 — four under par. CROSS COUNTRY: Indiana State Dick Sharkey, was injured. This was O'Connell's second consecu­ Meet at IndianapoUs, October 30; Uni­ Junior Mike Coffey was second, a tive victory in the tournament. He versity of Indiana at Bloomington, tenth of a second behind Clark. Bob was second as a freshman and fifth November 6; Central CoUegiate Walsh, a sophomore, was third. Ed as a sophomore. O'ConneU completely Championship at Chicago, November Dean was sixth, Larry Dirnberger dominated the field; he led his near­ 13; IC4A Meet in New York City, ninth, Don Bergens eleventh, and Bill est rivcd, Pat Danahy, by nine shots, November 16; NCAA Championship Welch fifteenth. and defeated Bill Regnier and BUI at East Lansing, November 23. Sebaske, who finished third, by 22 The victory was heartening because RUGBY: Notre Dame at Palmer of the superb performances of Welch shots. O'ConneU's 280 total was sec­ ond lowest in Burke Open history. CoUege in Davenport, Iowa, November and Dean, both of whom are recover­ 1. ing from injuries. Dean's performemce O'ConneU credits his outstanding was truly remarkable after missing final round 69 to his mother's home- SOCCER: Notre Dame at North­ several weeks of practice and two baked cookies. western in Evanston, October 31. October 30, 1964 29 this year's election could be AN AMERICAN TRAGEDY according to your point of view

complete election coverage with the Group W news team WSNDAM-FM

Sikorsky fiircraft

ENGINEERING REPRESENTATIVES WILL BE ON CAMPUS TO GIVE SENIORS AND GRADUATES COMPLETE DETAILS ON

ENGINEERING OPPORTUNITIES

WITH THE PIONEER AND LEADING MANUFACTURER of VTOL AIRCRAFT

See your College Placement Office now for an appointment.

Thursday, November 5

SIKORSKY AIRCRAFT, Stratford, Conn. • Division of United Aircraft Corp. • An Equal Opportunity Employer

30 The Scholastic Proper Passion and what they created is a film of Rossen's new film, lAlith. The story high tragedy and quiet beauty. Al­ is at once as ethereal as Breakfast At (Continued from page 23) bright, like Kim Novak, has a talent Tiffany's and as deeply rooted in re­ ing together, the stuff of dreams that that almost instantly engages an audi­ ality as A Cold Wind In August, but Tiffany's is based upon would never ence's emotions and director Singer these apparently contradictory moods have been anything more than an correctly saw that he need make no do not clash because Lilith is about a unpleasant memory. For pleasant as concessions to it; instead he chose to young woman in a mental hospital, fantasy is to the audience, it requires elevate it. Never offensive, for he possessed by nymphomania. High in a total control and talent that is rare knew too well the power of sugges­ the mist shrouded hills of Maryland, in individuals, let alone groups of tion, he recorded a character who she has created her own world, devis­ hardly fitted the public image and cer­ ing for it a special language, spinning them. tainly was not a fantasy, collective or around it an alluring web of beauty, What is far more likely to become otherwise: Singer filmed a womem, and attracting to her both the sick the standard approach is the selective lonely, finally bitter, but with integ­ and the sane. Inside the web though, realism of the genre's best film to rity, a quality she shared with the her undeveloped emotions have relin­ date — Alexcmder Singer's A Cold film. The camera seems to be omni­ quished her to solitude and she will Wind in August. Briefly, it tells of a present but only when the film is over whisper in the book (perfectly de­ stripper who seduces her landlord's do we realize how little was seen and scribing the longing feeling Rossen son, falls deeply in love with him, and how much was implied with lighting, sought in the movie): then is heartbroken when he leaves editing, and one or two fleeting words. "Their hands for example ... never her because of her occupation. The A masterpiece of restraint, it defines held the thing they yearned for. story sounds trite, but Singer and an unrestrained passion. "A golden apple, or a scroll of fire actress Lola Albright have given it Another passion, this time fatal, is Or the breast of some impossible girl all of their not inconsiderable talent the subject of Robert {The Hustler) that they could never touch."

Does / \ this I \ \ spot / feel sticky?

NEITHER DOES OLD SPICE STICK DEODORANT Dries as it applies ... in seconds. And stays dry! Gives you fast . . . comfortable . . . dependable deodorant protection. Lasting protection you can trust. Try it. Old Spice Stick Deodorant for Men. 1.00 plus tax. s M u i_"r o tsi

Octobrr 30, 1964 31 reaction of the students, for I want burden, faculty as a whole, student Letters to meet their legitimate demands. God body as a whole. We are one commu­ (Continued from page 9) grant that Notre Dame students today nity, and we must be united in an gram is going on its second year with and tomorrow be inolerant of medi­ untiring devotion to the creation of a its first meeting yet to be convened. ocrity in the theological courses of­ living theology in our midst. Let us I am a member of this committee, its fered here. Theology half dead and work and build together, for the good chairman is Professor Ccirberry. half alive has no place on the campus of the entire university community Prof. James L. Massey of a Catholic university. The student is involved in the good of a depart­ Dept. of Elec. Engr. here has every right to expect the ment of theology. Let us do away hving word of God to be taught by a with the "they" simply, when theol­ EDITOR: man who is vibrant with the truth ogy fails to be what it should be. The present Johnson vs. Goldwater Mature, responsible student activity verbal violence does not turn one's of Him who said: "I have come so in this area has much more to con­ thoughts irresistibly to Lincoln and that they may have life, and have tribute than mere negative criticism. Douglas or Disraeli and Gladstone. it more abundantly." Theology, of Locally, the 201 signers of the Car- course, is not to be identified with the I am not asking the students to stop berry Manifesto can hardly be said Faith, yet somehow the awesome, ex­ their criticism of the way theology to have improved the situation. To citing encounter of Faith with Life is taught at Notre Dame. No, keep it start wirh, employing the name and should penetrate every moment of up, as I said before, be intolerant of prestige of the University to heap in­ theological enquiry. mediocrity above all in theology. But discriminate praise on politicians of Some time ago Pope Paul VI in a if there is room for criticism, let it be any stamp seems inappropriate. More sermon to laymen outlined for them creative, not merely resentful and de­ questionable is the solemn attribution his tremendous burden amd responsi­ structive. Help us creatively. We want of "capable and responsible leader­ bility, and asked for their help. Sure­ to experiment in order to find the ship" to a man who has long kept for ly I can do no less in asking for the most effective way of carrying on the­ his closest associates and advisers help of the entire student body of ological pursuits. A living theology some of the most rancid characters Notre Dame to make theology here must be constantly on the move, Washington has seen since the Hard­ what it ought to be in fact. I am not changing as life itself is ever chang­ ing Administration. trying to evade the responsibility of ing. I know that I shall never be sat­ The most sticking feature of the the head of the Department of Theol­ isfied. We will have our successes and Manifesto, however, is its shrill, emo­ ogy toward the presentation of a dy­ our failures. But my aim will always tional contempt for the entire Gold- namic theology at this University. be to have theology at Notre Dame, water-lVIiller position. Whatever hap­ But all others share somewhat in this both undergraduate and graduate, pened to that blessed word "modera­ tion"? Political liberalism used to pride itself on its discrimination and respect for reason, but the tone of You mean, this document is that of an Estab­ lished Liberal Church chastising heretics. Apparently, too, salvation is because Fm a student by faith alone in this new church for the unhappy infidels in the Engineer­ or teacher I get ing Department who have decUned to embrace the gospel are summarily special rates at all dismissed as "disgraceful apoliticals." Against this less-than-exhilarating background it has been left to the HUton Hotels in the U.S.? SCHOLASTIC to provide informed and reasonably impartial local commen­ tary on tiie impending election. Bill MacDonald's October 16 summary of the two contrasting views of com­ munism was particularly good. One Hilton Hotels Corporation, point only might be clarified. There National Sales Office, Palmer House, is no danger of the United States setting up "a rigid wall of impla­ Chicago 90, III. cable hostility" to the communist world. It is there already: set up by Please send the Faculty-Student the communists themselves long ago. Rate Brochure that tells all. Bernard Norling I am a Faculty Member D Student D History Depaurtment

LET US CONTINUE NAME. EDITOR: HOME ADDRESS_ Thank you for your editorial with STREET some words of praise for the teachers and program in the Department of CITY STATE Theology this year at Notre Dame. COLLEGE NAME. Perhaps it Wcis all the more welcome in that we did not ask for it. I sin­ STREET CITY STATE cerely hope that these spontaneous words of approval reflect the general 32 The Scholastic second to none in the United States. But how many of you have really IMPRESSIONS Albert L. Schlitzer, C.S.C. been over here to judge for your­ EDITOR: selves, instead of upholding the bitter I wish to compliment Geof Bartz FAIR PLAY criticisms on hearsay? for his story on the World's Fair and EDITOR: We won't deny that there have been the SCHOLASTIC for printing it. Did you all have to follow the many "raw deals" on our part over The Fair was indeed a cross be­ leader? We feel that the traditional the years. However, these so-called tween reality and a fairyland. One ill feeling which is supposed to exist "raw deals" have been received as got the impression that one was sus­ between St. Mary's and Notre Dame well as given! The only difference is pended between a "Twilight Zone" of was carried too far Saturday after­ that we don't hold a few unfortunate lights, people and sounds and the per­ noon (October 17). incidents such as these against the ceptible harshness of steel and con­ We do respect your right to sup­ whole student body of Notre Dame. crete. port whichever team you please. But When we cheer for you, our hearts From a fellow Fair worker go con­ calling out "Barat" in response to St. are really in it. And we were truly gratulations to Geof Bartz, and to the Mary's cheers was in poor taste. disappointed when you let us down by SCHOLASTIC — a plea for continued Many boys claim that they dislike failing to show us any support what­ quality. This is indeed an improved the general atmosphere and attitude soever. publication. of everything and everyone connected Carol, Mindy, Cathy, Nancy, Sue Bob Thomas with "that school across the road." 249 Le Mans 233 Dillon

When Mike Pyle ;goes skiing... :^- '3.

Sv*.

f.ir

rl» A Pa. M 'Chap Stick'goes along! "Any guy who spends as much time outdoors as summer practice, and winter skiing off-season, I do really needs 'Chap Stick'," says the Chicago my lips used to get weatherbeaten twelve months Bears' star center. "For me, it's a necessity.What a year. But a couple of swipes with 'Chap Stick' with the real raw Sundays on the field, hot and my lips feel great—it helps heal them fast!"

'^P^4 ^^^ ''P ''^''" selected A favorite "**""'***' for use by the in Canada. U.S. Olympic Team.

DON'T LET DRY. SORE LIPS SPOIL YOUR FUN-WHEREVER YOU GO, GO WITH 'CHAP STICK' •CHAP STICK' IS REG. TM ©I4M MORTON MFG. CORP., LYNCHtURS, V* October 30, 1964 33 bers of the Fourth Estate gave weight academic excellence. This you may to the epithets by openly printing take as gospel truth and the deep them and discussing them over the conviction of our total administra­ Mel Noel... air. Last Monday Athletic Director tion and faculty." Edward (Moose) Krause told a lunch­ eon gathering of sports writers: As for the rumor factories, they will have nothing but their imagina­ "We always thought the season tions to work with until Fr. Hesburgh The was long enough and an extra releases his official statement. Neither month put a burden on the players. "Moose" Krause nor any other ath­ However, if it was for the national letic department official speaks for the championship, then we would send University policy makers. It would be Last our team there." well to remember that (according to Sports Illustrated, Jan. 5, 1959) in the This statement, coupled with an­ firing of Terry Brennan, Athletic Word nouncements that both the Sugar Director Krause did not learn of the Bowl and Orange Bowl were interest­ dismissal until Brennan himself did. ed in Notre Dame, gave the rumors Speculation in the press should also great respectability. be ignored, unless we wish to raise up Unfortunately, another statement our hopes for a brutal letdown in received little notice. Fr. Joyce, Exec­ December. Everyone would be better utive Vice-President, gave an informal off if Dick Hackenburg and company interview to WSBT radio in which he would stop building blue and gold repeated the long-standing University castles in the sky. policy on bowl games. Fr. Joyce said that we traditionally did not accept T N ADDITION to the death-dealing duo bowl bids and were giving no consid­ ••• of Huarte and Snow, Stanford was eration to any offers at this time. He exposed to another weapon of the pointed out that an extended season Fighting Irish last week. The game might hinder the academic life of progressed according to plan until many students. However, the WSBT the second quarter, when from the commentator finished up by speculat­ senior section came the voice of the ing that Notre Dame xoould accept a PHANTOM CHEERLEADER. Dis­ bowl bid. His excuse for this predic­ guised as a mild-mannered subway tion involved the great desire of alumnus by the name of "Sarge," the alumni and students to again see the phantom had appeared before at the Irish national champions. UPI took Wisconsin game. Then last Saturday up the cry next, saying that times had when we needed help badly in the sec­ changed at Notre Dame and that ond quarter the phantom appeared Moose Krause had left the door open again, but this time right in the midst for the team to accept a bowl invi­ of the senior section. He stood up, his tation. great bulk like a man-of-war outlined Rumors will continue to spread against the field. With a plastic (speculations in the press are no more trumpet in one hand and an "I like than printed rumors) as our team be­ Bud" button over his heart, the phan­ comes more successful. And no one tom led his boys through volley after will be certain of Notre Dame's bowl voUey of cheers in the greatest tradi­ fate until Fr. Hesburgh makes a de­ tion of Notre Dame spirit(s?). Never cision and announces it, probably at before had Steve Senior responded so the end of the season. However, it is energetically to anything, except may­ a good bet that Fr. Hesburgh's deci­ be a beer blast. And as a reward the sion will be in line with the tradition­ phantom led his followers in one final al University policy which he helped cheer before he vanished — S-E-N- , to write. Notre Dame has played in I-O-R-S, seniors, Rah! We don't know only one bowl in its long association whether or when he wiU appear again, vi^ith football. During all those unbeat­ but his disciples, on Saturdays in en years under Frank Leahy, every times of need, will look hopefully for invitation was rejected with a re­ the hearty shout and a hi-ho ND, statement of the long-standing policy. away! Fr. Hesburgh is known to believe that extending the football season damages the academic standing of players and /CONFIDENTIAL to Editor of the Lep- students both. It is doubtful that his ^^ reclumn: The University Admin­ /^NLY THE DEAF and the blind are opinion has changed since he officially istration fears that nothing can be ^-^ unaware of rumors circulating told Sports Illustrated in 1959: done about the "rancid, smelly, hate­ about a bowl bid for the Fighting ful" mold. It is attributed to the damp­ Irish. After our first victory, cautious "As long as we, like most Amer­ ness of their executive oflBces on the people were overheard to whisper ican universities, are engaged in fourteenth fioor of the water tower. such phrases as "number one, Sugar intercollegiate athletics, we will However, we understand the Adminis­ Bowl, and Rose Bowl." Then anarch­ strive for excellence of performance tration is willing to accept an oflSce in ists began to shout these phrases at in this area too, but never at the the editor's apartment if it is not too pep rallies. Finally, reputable mem­ expense of the primary order of drafty. 34 THE CURIOUS PARADOX OF ROGER STAUBACH • An exclusive interview reveals the conflicting traits that have made Navy's all-time quarterback college football's No. 1 star. ALSO, discover why All-America tackle RALPH NEELY is called "Oklahoma's Mild Monster."

* JIMMY BROWN'S 5 GREATEST GAMES In his latest album, "Ballads, Blues • The fabulous Cleveland Brown fullback selects his most outstand­ and Boasters," Belafonte brings to mind the words ing days in football. of an old spiritual,"... sometimes I'm up, sometimes I'm down..." With a wide variety of songs, he expresses the moods that every man (and SPORT keeps you apace of all woman) experiences at one time or another. events on the college and pro sports scene. Enjoy expert cover­ Boasters like "Tone the Bell Easy" and "Back of age, analysis, indepth features, the Bus," find Belafonte in a satisfied and action photos in expansive mood while blues such as "Blue Willow Moan" are for everyone who has ever known DECEMBER trouble. And, of course, ballads like "Four Strong Winds" find Harry right at home in his musical element. A dynamic Favorite nagazin* of the sports performance in Dynagroove sound! stars and the sports mindedl NOW ON SALE!

{^©WSte^^V^^il ELKttAffT

••OCT.31 ^ ^ 8:30 P.M.

BMERSi S3.50- il.^Q 1 $'..50 SAT, V NOV. 21 8:30 P.M. iNEW CHRISTY^ tMINSTRELS/ NewHiiuyiGioiiiI The most trusted name in sound ~'-"=^ i S3, so . S3.S0 SI .30

Office cKfriHeei JItlCtET SAtf RoDIM'S s ww«—f RSVISW OP POLITICS 1212 LIBRARY '^^^ P 0 BOX 4 MOTHfi j)AME INi)

A lot revolves around GT&E

Today, it takes the efforts of many states. And in manufacturing, our With so much revolving around people in many diverse fields and subsidiaries produce a wide variety GT&E, it is small wonder that we professions to build an active corpo­ of products for business, industry have become one of America's fore­ ration such as GT&E. and the consumer. most corporations. Because, at GT&E, we're involved A diversified program such as this As a young and aggressive com­ heavily in research, manufacturing calls for the best administrators, pany with no limit to its growth, and telephone operations. operating personnel, scientists, engi­ GT&E is an organization you may For instance, we have telephone neers and production managers. And wish to think of in the light of your operating companies in areas of 32 unity of purpose. own future.

GENERAL TELEPHONE & ELECTRONICS 730 THIRD AVENUE, NEW roRK I0OI7

GT&E SUBSIDIARIES: Telephone Operating Cos. • GTSE Laboratories • GT&E International • General Telephone Directory • GEAutomatic Electric • Lenkurt ElectricE • Sylvania Electri c Products