sign in sign up
<<
Home , Bhagwat Jha Azad, Dhalbhum, Gulzarilal Nanda, Jhansi district, Lalit Narayan Mishra, Rafi Ahmed Kidwai

Ptt. S^.IX62 — m —

V dnm e I WSKS Tuesday

No 1 - i | 13ihH ay, 1952

PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES

HOUSE OF THE PEOPLE OFFICIAL REPORT

(Part II—Proceedings other than Questions and Answers)

CONTENTS

Members Sworn [CoIb. 2— 18]. ,

secbetabiat NEW

Price Six Annas (Inland) Price Two Shillings (Foreign) HOUSE OF THE PEOPLE ALPHABETICAL LIST OF MEMBERS

B Abdullabhai, Mulla Taherali Mulla Babunath Singh, Shri (Surguja- (Chanda). Raigarh—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Abdus Sattar, Shri (Kalna-Katwa). ' Badan Singh, Chowdhary ( Achal Singh, Seth [ Distt. Distt.— West). (W est)]. Bahadur Singh, Shri (Ferozepore- Achalu, Shri Sunkam (Nalgonda— Ludhiana—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Reserved— Sch. Castes). Balakrishnan. Shri S. C. (Erode— Achint Ram, Lala (Hissar). Reserved— Sch. Castes). Achuthan, Shri K. T. (Crangannur). Balasubramaniam, Shri S. (Madurai). Agam Dasji, Guru Gosai (Bilaspur- Durg-Raipur— Reserved—Sch. Castes). , (Nawan Shahr). Agarwal, Acharya Shriman Narayan Balmiki, Shri Kanhaiya Lai (Buland- (Wardha). shahr Dist.— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Agarawal, Shri Hoti Lai [ Banerjee, Shri Durga Charan (Midna- Distt. cum Distt.— (West) pore-Jhargram). cum Dist.— (North)] Bansal, Shri Ghamandi Lai (Jhajjar- Rewari). ' Agrawal, Shri Mukund Lai [ Distt. cum Distt.— (East)]. Barman, Shri Upendranath (North Ahmed Mohiuddin, Shri ( — Reserved—Sch. Ca^es). City). Barrow, Shri A. E. T. (Nominated— Anglo-Indians). A jit Singh, Shri (Kapurthala- Bhatinda—Reserved— Sch. Castes). Barupal, Shri Panna Lall (Ganga- nagar-Jhunjhunu — Reserved — Sch. Ajit Singhji, General (Sirohi-PaU). Castes). - Akarpuri, Sardar Teja Sin^h (Gurdas- Basappa, Shri C. R. (Tumkur). pur). Basu, Shri A. K. (North Bengal). Alagesan, Shri O. V. (Chingleput). Basu, Shri Kamal Kumar (Diamond Altekar, Shri Ganesh Sadashiv (North Harbour). Satara). Bhagat. Shri B. R. ( cum Shah- Alva, Shri Joachim (Kanara). abad). Amin, Dr. IndubHai B. (Baroda West). Bhakta Darshan, Shri [Garhwal Distt Amjad Ali, Jonab (Goalpara-Garo — (East) cum Movadabad D^stt.— HiUs). (North East) ]. . , Rajkmuari (Mandi- Bhandari, Shri Daulat Mai (Jaipur). Mahasu). Bharati, Shri Goswamiraja Sahdeo Anandchand, Shri (Bilaspur). (Yeotmal). Ansari, Dr. Shaukatullah Shah Bhartiya, Shri Shaligram Ramchandra

B—contd. Cniettiar, Shri V. VR. N. AR. Nagappa (Ramanathapuram). Bhoi, Shri Giridhari (Kalahandi- Chinaria, Shri Hira Singh (Mohinder- Bolangir—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). garh). Bhonsle, Major-General Jagannathrao Chowdary, Shri C. R. (Narasaraopet). Krishnarao (Ratnagiri North). Chowdhury, Shri Nikunja Behari Bidari, Shri Ramappa Balappa (Bija- (). pur South). Birbal Singh, Shri [Jaunpur Distt.— (East)]. Bogawat, Shri U. R. ( Dabhi, Shri Fulsinhji B. (Kaira South). North). Boovaraghasamy, Shri V. (Peramba- Daga, Shri Sheodass (Mahasamund). lur). Damar, Shri Amar Singh Sabji Borrooah, Shri Dev Kanta (Nowgong). (Jhabua—Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Bose, Shri P. C. (Manbhum North). Damodaran, Shri G. R. (PoUachi). Brajeshwar Prasad, Shri (Gaya— Damodaran, Shri Nettur P. (Telli- East). chery). Brohmo-Chaudhury, Shri Sitaiiath Das, Shri B. (Jajpur-Keonjhar). (Goalpara-Garo Hills—^Reserved— Das, Shri Basanta Kumar (Contai). Sch. Tribes). Das, Shri Beli Ram (Barpeta). Buchhikotaiah, Shri Sanaka (Masuli- Das, Shri Bijoy Chandra (Ganjam patnam). , South). Buragohain, Shri S. N. (Sibsagar— Das, Shri Kamal Krishna (Birbhum— North Lakhimpur). Reserved— Sch. Castes). Das, Dr. Mono Mohon (Burdwan— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Das, Shri Nayan Tara (Monghyr Sadr Chacko, Shri P. T. (Meenachil). cum Jamui— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Chakravartty, Shrimati Renu (Basir- Das, Shri Shree Narayan ( hat). Central). Chanda, Shri Anil Kumar (Birbhum). Das, Shri Ramananda (Barxackpore). Chandak, Shri B. L. (Betul). Das, Shri Ram Dhani (Gaya East— Chandrasekhar, Shrimati M. (Tiruval- Reserved—Sch. Castes). lur—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Das, Shri Sarangadhar (Dhertkanal— Charak, Shri Lakshman Singh (Jammu West Cuttack). and Kashmir). Datar, Shri Balwant Nagesh (Belgaum Chatterjea, Shri Tushar (Serampore). North). Chatterjee, Dr. Susilranjan * (West Deb, Shri Dasaratha ( East). Dinajpur). Deb, Shri Suresh Chandra (Cachar- Chatterjee, Shri N. C. (Hooghly). Lushai Hills). Chattopadhyaya, Shri Harindranath Deo, H. H. Maharaja Rajendra Narayan (Vijayavada). Singb (Kalahandi-Bolangir). (Thaturvedi, Shri Rohanlal [Etah Distt. Deo, Shri Chandikeshwar Sharan ^ — (Central)]. Singh Ju. (Surguja-Raigarh). " Chaudhary Shri Ganeshi Lai [Shah- Deogam, Shri Kanhu Ram (Chaibassa jahanpur Distt.— (North) cum —Reserved—Sch. Tribes). — (East)—Reserved—Sch. Castes]. Desai, Shri Kanayalal Nanablkai Choudhri, Shri Muhammed Shaflee (). (Jammu and Kashmir). Deshmukh. Dr. Panjabrao S. (Amra- Chaudhurl, Shri Ranbir Singh vati East). (Rohtak). Deshmukh. Shri Chintamah Dwarka- Chaudhurl. Shri Rohini Kumar nath (Kolaba). (Gauhati). Deshmukh, Shri K. G. (Amravati Chaudhurl, Shri Tridib Kumar West). (Berhampore). Deshpande, Shri Govind Hari (Nasik Chavda, Shri (BahaAantha). Central). Chettiar, Shri T. S. AvinaihiUngam Deshpande, Shri Vishnu Ghanashyam (Tiruppur). (Guna). D—contd. Girraj Saran Singh, Shri (Bharatpur- Sawai Madhopur). Dholakia, Shri Gulab Shankar Amrit- lal (Kutch East). Gohain, Shri Chowkhamoon (Nomi­ nated—^Assam Tribal Areas). Dhulekar, Shri R. V. [Jhansi Distt.— (South)]. Gopalan, Shri A. K. (Cannanore). Dhusiya, Shri Sohan Lai [Basti Distt. Gopi Ram, Shri (Mandi-Mahasu— — (Central East) cum Reserved—Sch. Castes). Distt. — (West) — Reserved — Sch. Gounder, Shri K. Periaswami (Erode). Castes]. Gounder, Shri K. Sakthivadivel Digambar Singh, Shri lEtah Distt.— (Periyakulam). (West) cum Distt.— (West) cum Distt.— (East)]. G6vind Das, Seth (Mandla-Jabalpur South). Digvijaya Narain Singh, Shri (Muzaf- farpur—^North-East). Gowda, Shri T. Madiah (Bangalore— South). Dube, Shri Mulchand [ Distt. (N orth)]. Guha, Shri Arun Chandra (Santipur). Dube, Shri Udai Shankar [Basti Distt. Gupta, Shri Badshah (Mainpuri Dist*:. (N orth)]. — East). Gurupadaswamy, Shri M. S. (Mysore). Dubey, Shri Rajaram GiriHharlal (Bijapur North), Dutt, Shri Asim Krishna (Calcutta South-West). Har Prasad Singh, 3hri ( Dutt, Shri Biren (Tripura West). Distt.-West). Dutta, Shri Santosh Kumar (Howrah). Hari Mohan Dr. (Manbhum North— Reserved— Sch. Castes). Dwivedi, Shri Dashrath Prasad (Gorakhpur Distt.— Central). Hari Shankar Prasad, Shri (Gorakh­ pur Distt.—North). Dwivedi, Shri M. L. (Hamirpur Distt.). Hazarika, Shri Jogendra Nath (Dibru- garh). Ebenezer, Dr. S. A. (Vikarabad). Heda, Shri H. C. (Nizamabad). Elayaperumal, Shri L. (Cuddalore— Hembrom, Shri Lai (Santal Parganas Reserved—Sch. Castes). cum Hazaribagh — Reserved — Sch. Tribes). ^ Hem Raj, Shri (Kangra). Hifzur Rahaman, Shri M. ( Fotedar, Pandit Sheo Narayan (Jammu Distt.—Central). and Kashmir). Hukam Singh, Shri (Kapurthala- Bhatinda). Gadgil, Shri Narhar Vishnu (Poona Hyder Husein, Chaudhrj (Gonda Distt. Central). —North). Ganapati Ram, Shri [Jaimpur Distt. (East)—^Reserved—Sch. Castes]. , Shri Feroze [Pratapgarh Ibrahim, Shri A. (Ranchi North­ Distt. (West) cum Rae Bareli Distt. East) . (East)]. lyyani, Shri Eacharan (Ponnani— Gandhi, Shri Maneklal Maganlal Reserved—Sch. Castes). (Panch Mahals cum Baroda East). lyyunni, Shri C. R. (Trichur). Gandhi, Shri V. B. (Bombay City— North). J Ganga Devi, Shrimati ( Distt. , Shri (Shahabad South cum Bara Banki Distt.—^Reserved— —Reserved—Sch. Castes). Sch. Castes). Jain, Shri A jit Prasad ( Garg, Shri Ram Pratap (Patiala). Distt.—West cum Muzaffarnaear Gautam, Shri C. p . (Balaghat). Distt.—^Nortb). Ghose, Shri Surendra Mohan (Malda). Jain, Shri Nemi Saran (Bijnor Distt. Ghosh, Shri Atulya (Burdwan). — ^South). Ghulam Qader, Kh. (Jammu and Jaipal Singh, Shri (Ranchi W est- Kashmir). Reserved—Sch. Tribes). ^ Giri, Shri V. V. (Pathapatnam). Jaisoorya, Dr. N. M. (Medak). J—contd. Kami Singhji, His Highness Maharaja Sri Bahadur of Bikaner (Bikaner- Jajware, Shri Ramraj (Santal Churu). Parganas cum Hazaribagh). Kasliwal, Shri Nemi Chandra (Kotah- Jangde, Shri Resham Lai (Bilaspur— Jhalawar). Reserved—Sth. Castes). Jasani, Shri Chaturbhuj V. Katham, Shri Birendranath (North (Bhandara). Bengal—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Jatawir, Dr. Manik Chand (Bharat- Katju, Dr. Kailas Nath (Mandsaur). pur-Sawai Madhopur—Reserved— Kazmi, Shri Syed Mohammad Ahmad Sch. Castes). (Sultanpur Distt.—North cum Faiza- Jayaraman, Shri A. (Tindivanam— bad Distt.—South West). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Kelappan, Shri K. (Ponnani). Jena, Shri Kanhu Charan (Balasore— Kaushik, Shri Pannalal R. (Tonk). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Keshavaiengar, Shri N. (Bangalore— Jena, Shri Lakshmidhar (Jajpur- North). Keonjhar—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Keskar. Dr. B, V. (Sultanpur Distt.— Jena, Shri Niranjan (Dhenkanal— South). West Cuttack—Reserved— Sch. Khan, Shri Sadath Ali (Ibrahim- Castes). patnam). Jethan, Shri Kherwar (Palamau cum Hazaribagh cum Ranchi—Reserved Khan, Shri Shahnawaz ( Distt. —North East). —Sch. Tribes). ' Khardekar, Shri B. H. (Kolhapur cum Jhunjhunwala, Shri Banarsi Prashad Satara). ( Central). Jogendra Singh, Sardar ( Khedkar, Shri Gopalrao Bajirao Distt.— West). (Buldana-Akola). Joshi, Shri Jethalal Harikrishn* Khimji, Shri Bhawanji A. (Kutch (Madhya ). West). Joshi, Shri Krishnacharya (Yadgir). Khongmen, Shrimati B. (Autonomous Distts.— Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Joshi, Shri Liladhar (Shajapur-Raj- garh). Kidwai, Shri Rafi Ahmad (Bahraich Distt.—^East). Joshi, Shri Moreshwar Dinkar (Ratnagiri South). Kirolikar, Shri Wasudeo Shridhar (Durg). Joshi Shri Nandlal (Indore). Kolay, Shri Jagannath (). Joshi, Shrimati Subhadra (Kamal). Kosa, Shri Muchaki (Bastar—^Reserved Jwala Prashad, Shri (Ajmer North). — Sch. Tribes). Kripalani, Shrimati Sucheta (New Delhi). Krishna, Shri M. R. (Karimnagar— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Kachiroyar, Shri N. D. Govindaswami Krishna Chandra, Shri (Mathura (Cviddalore). Distt.—West). Kajrolkar, Shri Narayan Sadoba Krishnamachari, Shri T. T. (Madras). (Bombay City— North—^Reserved— Sch. Castes). Krishanappa, Shri M. V. (Kolar). Kakkan, Shri P. (Madurai—Reserved Krishnaswami, Dr. A. (Kanchee- — Sch. (Tastes). puram). Kale, Shrimati Anasuyabai (). Kureel, Shri Baij Nath (Pratapgarh Distt.—^West cum Rae Bareli Distt Kamal Singh, Shri (Shahabad—^North- — East—^Reserved—Sch. Castes). West). Kamaraj, Shri K. (Srivilliputhur). Kamble^ Shri Devroa Namdevroa Pathrikar (Nanded—^Reserved—Sch. Lakshmayya, Shri Paidi (Anantapur). Castes). Lallanji, Shri ( Distt.—North Kandasamy, Shri S. K. (Tiruchengode). West). Kanungo, Shri Nityanand (Kendra- Lai Singh, Sardar (Ferozepur- para). Ludhiana). — JBiUeqQ) *Q IJqS Lanka Sundaram, Dr. (Vlsakha- North). ' patnam). L—contd. Mehta, Shri Anup Lai (Bhagalpur X.askar, Prof. Nibaran Chandra cum Pumea). (Cachar-Lushai Hills—Reserved— Mehta, Shri Balvantray Gopaljee Sch. Castes). (Gohilwad). X.aisram Jogeswar Singh, Shri (Inner Mehta, Shri Balwant Sinha (Udaipur). Manipur). Menon, Shri K. A. Damodara (Kozhi­ Lotan Ram, Shri (Jalaun Distt. ciim kode) . Etawah Distt.— West cum Jhansi Mishra, Pandit Suresh Chandra Distt. — North — Reserved — Sch. (Monghyr—North-East). Castes). Mishra, Shri Bibhuti (Saran cum M Champaran). Mishra, Shri Lalit Narayan Mahapatra, Shri Sibnarayan Singh (Darbhanga cum Bhagalpur). (Sundargarh — Reserved — Sch. Tribes). Mishra, Shri Lokenath (Puri). TMahata, Shri Bhajahari (Manbhum Mishra, Shri Mathura Prasad South cum Dhalbhum). (Monghyr— North-West). Mahendra Nath Singh, Shri (Saran Mishra, Shri Raghubar Dayal (Buland- Central). shahr Distt). Mahodaya, Shri Vaijanath (Nimar). Mishra, Shri Sarju Prasad (Deoria Distt.—South). Mahtab, Shri Harekrushna (Cuttack). Mishra, Shri Shyam Nandan Maitra, Pandit Lakshmi Kanta (Darbhanga—North). (Nabadwip). Misra, Pandit Lingaraj ^Khurda). Majhi, Shri Chaitan (Manbhum— South cum Dhalbhum—Reserved— •Misra, Shri Bhupendra Nath (Bilas- Sch. Tribes). pur-Durg-Raipur). Majhi, Shri Ram Chandra (Mayur- Missir, Shri Vijineshwar (Gaya— bhanj—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). North). Majithia, Sardar Surjit Singh (Tam Mohammad Saeed Masudi, Maulana Taran). (Jammu and Kashmir). Malliah, Shri Srinivasa U. (Sbuth Mookerjee, Dr. Syama Prasad Kanara—North). (Calcutta—South-East). Malludora, Shri Gam (Visakhapatnam Morarka, Shri Radheshyam Ramkumar — Reserved— Sch. Tribes). . ( Ganganagar-Jhun j hunu). Mai via, Shri Bhagu-Nandu (Shajapur- More, Shri K. L. (Kolhapur cum Rajgarh—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Satara—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Malviya, Shri Motilal, (Chhatarpur- More, Shri Shankar Shantaram Datia-Tikamgarh — Reserved — Sch. (Sholapur). Castes). Mudaliar, Shri C. Ramaswamy Malviya, Pandit Chatur Narain (Kumbakonam). (Raisen). Islammuddin, Shri Malaviya, Shri Keshava Deva (Gonda (Purnea North-East). Distt.—East cum Basti Distt.— Muhammed Khuda Bukhsh, Shri West). (Murshidabad). Mandal, Dr. Pashupati (Bankura— Mukerjee, Shri Hirendra Nath Reserved—Sch. Castes). (Calcutta—North-East). “Mangalagiri, Shri Nanadas (Ongole— Murli ^^anohar, Shri ( Distt.— Reserved—Sch. Castes). East). Mascarene, Kumari Annie (Trivand­ Murthy, Shri B. S. (Eluru). rum). Musafir, Shri Gurmukh Singh (Amrit­ Masuriya Din, Shri ( Distt. sar). — East cum Jaunpur Distt.—West— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Mushar, Shri Kirai (Bhagalpur cum Pumea—^Reserved— Sch. Castes). Mathew, Prof. C. P. (Kottayam). Muthukrishnan, Shri M. (Vellore— Mathuram, Dr. Edward Paul Reserved—^Sch. Castes). (Tiruchirapalli). Matthen, Shri C. P. (Thiruvellah). Mavalankar, Shri G. V. (). Naidu, Shri Nalla Reddi (Rajab- Maydeo. Shrimati Indira A. (Poona- mundry). South) . Nair, Shri C. Krishnan (Outer Delhi). Ji—contd. Patel. Shri Bahadurbhai Kunthabhai Nair, Shri N. Sreekantan (Quilon cum (Surat— Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Mavelikkara). Patel, Shrimati Maniben Vallabhbhai Nambiar, Shri K. Ananda (Mayuram). (Kaira South). Namdhari, Shri Atma Singh (Fazilka- Patel, Shri Rajeshwar ( Sirsa). cum Darbhanga). Nanda, Shri Gulzarilal (Sabarkantha). Pateria, Shri Sushil Kumar (Jabalpur North). Nandkar, Shri Anant Savalaram (Thana—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Patil, Bhau Saheb Kanavade (Ahmed- nagar North). Narasimham, Shri S. V. L. (Gunt^v). Patil, Shri S. K. (Bombay C i t y - Narasimhan, Shri C. R. (Krishnagiri). South). Naskar, Shri Purnendu Sekhar Patil, Shri Shankargauda Veera- (Diamond Harbour—^Reserved—Sch. nagauda (Belgaum South). Castes). Patnaik, Shri Uma Charan Natawadkar. Shri Jayantrao Ganpat (Ghumsur). (West Khandesh—Reserved—Sch. Pawar, Shri Vyankatrao Pirajirao Tribes). (South Satara). Natesan, Shri P. (Tiruvallur). Pillai, Shri P. T. Thanu (Tirunelveli). Nathani, Shri Hari Ram (Bhilwara). Pocker Saheb, Janab B. (Malap- Nathwani, Shri Narendra P. (Sorath). pur am). Nayar, Shrimati Shakuntala (Gonda Prabhakar, Shri Naval (Outer Delhi Distt.—W esy. —Reserved—Sch. Castes). Nayar, Shri V. P. (Chirayinkil). . Punnoo&e, Shri P. T. (Allepi)ey). Nehru, Shri Jawaharlal (Allahabad B Distt.—East cum Jaunpur Distt.— Rachiah, Shri N. (Mysore—Reserved— West). Sch. Castes). Nehru, Shrimati Uma ( Distt. Radha Raman, Shri (Delhi City). cum Kheri Distt.—^West). Raghavachari Shri K. S. (Penukonda). Nesamony, Shri A. (Nagercoil). Raghaviah, Shri Pisupati Venkata Neswi, Shri T. R. (Dharwar—South). (Ongole). Nevatia, Shri R. P. ( Raghubir Singh, Choudhary (Agra Distt.—North cum Kheri— East), Distt.— East). Nijalinagappa, Shri S. (Chitaldrug). Raghunath Singh, Shri (Banaras Distt. Central). Raghuramaiah, Shri Kotha (Tenali). Pande, Shri C. D. (Naini Tal Distt. Raiji, ' Shrimati Jayashri (Bombay— cum Almora Distt.— South West Suburban). cum Bareilly Distt.—North). Raiabhoj, Shri P. N. (Sholapur— Pandey, Dr. Natabar (Sambalpur). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Pan(^t, Shrimati Vi jay a Lakshmi Ramachander, Shri Doraswamy Pillai (Lucknow Distt.— Central). (Vellore). Panna Lai, Shri (Faizabad Distt.— Ramaseshaiah, Shri N. (Parvathi- North-West — Reserved — Sch. puram). Castes). Rariaswamy, Shri P. (Mahbubnagar— Pant, Shri Devi Datt (Almora Distt.— Reserved—Sch. Castes). North East). Ramaswamy, Shri S. V. (Salem). Paragi Lai, Chaudhari (Sitapur Distt. Ram Dass, Shri (Hoshiarpur—Reserved cam Kheri Distt.—^West—Reserved —Sch. Castes). —Sch. Castes). Ram Nagina Singh, Shri (Ghazipur Paranjpe, Shri R. G. (Bhir). Distt.—East cum Ballia Distt.— Parikh, Shri Rasiklal U. (Zalawad). South West). Parikh, Shri Shantilal Girdharlal Singh, Babu (Hazari- (Mehsana East). bagh West). Parmar, Shri Rupaji Bhavji (Panch Ram Saran, Prof. (Moradabad Distt.— MahalK cum Baroda East—Reserved West). —Sch. Tribes). Ram Shankar Lai, Shri (Basti Distt.— Pataskar, Shri Hari Vinayak (Jal- CentraL East cum Gorakhpur Distt. Caon). — West) R—contd. Ham Subhag Singh, Dr. (Shahabad Saha, Shri Meghnad (Calcutta—North­ South). West). Bandaman Singh, Shri (Shahdol- Sahai, Shri Raghubir (Etah Distt.— Sidhi— Reserved—Sch. Tribesj. North East cum Budaun Distt.— Hane, Shri Shivram Rango East). (Bhusaval). Sahaya, Shri Syamnandan (Muzaffar- Hanjit Singh, Shri (Sangrur). pur Central). Hao, Diwan Raghavendra (Osmana- ^Sahu, Shri Bhagabat (Balasore). bad). Rao, Dr. Ch. V. Rama (Kakinada). Sahu, Shri Rameshwar (Muzaffarpur cum Darbhanga—^Reserved—^Sch. Rao, Shri B. Rajagopala (Srikakulam). Castes). Hao, Shri B. ^iva (South Kanara— Saigal, Sardar Amar Singh (Bilaspur). South). Sakhare, Shri T. C. (Bhandara— Hao, Shri Kadyala >Gopala Reserved—Sch. Castes). (Gudivada). Saksena, Shri Mohanlal (Lucknow Rao, Shri Kanety Mohana (Rajah- Distt. cum Bara Banki Distt.). mundry—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Samanta, Shri Satis Chandra ■Rao, Shri Kondru Subba (Eluru— (Tamluk). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Sanganna, Shri T. (Rayagada-Phul- Hao, Shri Pendyal Raghava bani— Reserved—Sch. Tribes). (Warangal). Sankarapandian, Shri M. (SarAara- Hao, Shri P. Subba (Nowrangpur). nayinarkovil). Hao. Shri Rayasam Seshagiri Sarmah, Shri Debeswar (Golaghat— (Nandyal). Jorhat). Hao, Shri T. B. Vittal (Khammam). Sathianathan, Shri N. (Dharmapurl). Haut, Shri Bhola (Saran cum Satish Chandra, Shri (Bareilly Distt. Champaran — Reserved — Sch. — South). Castes). Hazmi, Shri Said Ullah Khan Satyawadi, Dr. Virendra Kumar (Sehore). (Karnal—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Heddi, Shri B. Ramachandra Sen, Shrimati Sushama (Bhagalpur (Nellore). South). Heddi, Shri Baddam Yella (Karim- Sen, Shri Phani Gopal (Purnea nagar), Central). Sen, Shri Raj Chandra (Kotah Heddi, Shri C. Madhao (Adilabad). Bundi). Heddi, Shri Y. Eswara (Cuddapah). Sewal, Shri A. R. (Chamba-Sirmur). Heddy, Shri Halaharvi Sitarama Shah, Her Highness Rajmata (K um ool). Kamlendu Mati (Garhwal Distt.— Heddy, Shri K. Janardhan (Mahbub- West cum Tehri Garhwal Distt. nagar). ' cum Bijnor Distt.—^North). Heddy, Shri Ravi Narayan Shah, Shri Chimanlal Chakubhai (Nalgonda). (Gohilwad-Sorath). Heddy, Shri T. N. Vishwanatha Shah, Shri Raichand Bhai (Chhind- (Chittoor). wara). Hichardson, Bishop John (Nominated Sharma, Pandit Balkrishna ( —Andaman and Nicobar Islands). Distt.— South cum Etawah Distt.— Hishang Keishing, SJhri (Outer Mani­ East). pur— Reserved— Sch. Tribes). ^ Sharma, Pandit Krishna Chandra Hoy, Dr. Satyaban (Uluberia). (Meerut Distt.—South). Hoy, Shri Biswa Nath (Deoria Distt. Sharma. Prof. Diwan Chand —West). (Hoshiarpur). Hoy, Shri Patiram (Basirhat—^Reserved Sharma, Shri Khushi Ram (Meerut —Sch. Castes). Distt.—West). Hup Narain, Shri (Mirzapur Distt. Sharma, Shri Nand Lai (Sikar). cum Banaras Distt.—^West—^Re­ Sharma, Shri Radba Charan (Morena- served—Sch. Castes). Bhind). (vui)

Shashtri, Pandit Algu Rai (Azamgarh Subrahmanyam, Shri Kandala (Vizia- Distt.—East cuvL Ballia Distt.— nagaram). West). Subrahmanyam, Sliri Tekur (Bellary)^ Shashtri, Shri Bhagwandutt (Shahdol- Sunder Lall, Shri (Saharanpur Distt.. Sindhi). — West cum Muzaffamagar Distt.— North—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shashtri, Swami Ramanand ( Distt. cum Rae Bareli Distt.— West Suresh Chandra, Dr. (Aurangabad). cum Hardoi Distt.— South E a s t- Suriya Prashad, Shri (Morena-Bhind Reserved— Sch. Castes). — Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shastri, Shri Harihar Nath (Kanpwr Swaminadhan, Shrimati Ammu> Distt.— Central). (Dindigul). Swami, Shri Sivamurthi (Kushtagi)u Shivananjappa, Shri M. K. (Mandya). Swamy, Shri N. R. M. (Wandiwash). Shobha Ram, Shri (Alwar). Syed Ahmed, Shri (Hoshangabad). Shukla, Pandit Bhagwaticharan Syed Mahmud, Dr. (Champaran— (Durg-Bastar). East). Siddananjappa, Shri H. (Hassan- Chikmagalur). Singhal, Shri Shri Chand ( Distt.). Talib, Shri Piare Lai Kureel (Banda Sinha, Dr. Satyanarain (Saran— East). Distt. cum Fatehpur Distt.— Sinha, Shri Anirudha (Darbhanga— Reserved—Sch. Castes). East). Tandon, Shri Purushottamdas [Allaha­ Sinha, Shri Awadheshwar Prasad bad Distt. (W est)]. (Muzaff arpur—East). Tek Chand, Shri (Ambala-Simla). Sinha, Shri Banarsi Prasad (Monghyr Telkikar, Shri Shankar Rao (Nanded). Sadr cum Jamui). Tewari, Sardar Raj Bhanu Singh Sinha, Shri Chandreshwar Narain (Rewa). Prasad (Muzaffarpur — North­ Thimmaiah, Shri Dodda (Kolar— West). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Sinha, Shri Gajendra Prasad (Palamau Thirani, Shri G. D. (Bargarh), cum Hazaribagh cum Ranchi). Thirukuralar, Shri V. Muniswamy Sinha, Shri Jhulan (Saran—^North). Avl. (Tindivanam). Sinha, Shri Kailash Pati (Patna— Thomas, Shri A. M. (Ernakulam). Central). Thomas, Shri A. V. (Srivaikuntam). Sinha, Shri Nageshwar Prasad Tirtha, Swami Ramananda (Gul- (Hazaribagh—East). berga). Sinha, Shri S. (). Tivary, Shri Venkatesh Narayan Sinha, Shri Satya Narayan (Samasti- (Kanpur Distt.—^North cum. pur—East). Farrukhabad Distt.—South). Sinha, Shri Satyendra Narayan Tiwari, Pandit B. L. (Nimar). (Gaya—West). Tiwari, Shri Ram Sahai (Chhatarpur- Sinha, Shrimati Tarakeshwari (Patna Datia-Tikamgarh). — East). Tiwary, Pandit Dwarka Nath (Saran Sinhasan Singh, Shri (Gorakhpur South). ^ Distt.— South). Tribhuan Narayan Singh. Shri Siva, Dr. M. V. Gangadhara (Chittoor (Banaras Distt.—East). —Reserved—Sch. Castes). Tripathi, Shri Hira Vallabh (MuzafEar- Snatak, Shri Nardeo (Aligarh Distt.— nagar Distt.—South). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Trioathi, Shri Kamakhya Prasad Sodhia, Shri Khub Chand (Sagar). (Darrang). Tripathi, Shri VishwamWiar Dayal Sofi, Shri Mohd. Akber (Jammu and (Unnao Distt. cum Rae Bareh DistU Kashmir). ^ —West cum Hardoi Distt.—South Somana, Shri N. (Coorg). East). ■ Somani, Shri G. D. (Nagaur-Pali). Trivedi. Shri Umashanker Muljibhat Soren, Shri Paul Jujhar (Pumea jum (Chittoor). Santal Paraganas—^Reserved—Sen. Tudu, Shri Bharat Lai (Midnauore- Tribes). Jhargram—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Tulsidas Kilachand, Shri (Mehsana— Vartak, Shri Govindrao Dharmaji West). (Thana). TTyagi, Shri Mahavir (Dehra Dun Veeraswamy, Shri V. (Mayuram— Distt. cum Bijnor Distt.— North Reserved—Sch. Castes). West cum Saharanpur Distt.— Velayudhan, Shri R. (Quilon cum West). Marvelikkara — Reserved — Sch. Castes). Venkataraman, Shri R. (Tanjore). Uikey, Shri M. G. (Mandla-Jabalpur— Verma, Shri Ramji (Deoria Distt.— South—Reserved—Sch, Tribes). East). Vidyalankar, Shri Amarnath Upadhyay, Pandit Munishwar Dutt (Juliundur). - (Pratapgarh Distt.— East). Vishwanath Prasad, Shri (Azamgarh Upadhyaya, Shri Siva Datt (Satna). Distt. — West — Reserved — Sch. Upadhyay, Shri Shiva Dayal (Banda Castes). Distt. cum Fatehpur Distt.). Vyas, Shri Radhelal (Ujjain).

Vaishnav, Shri Hanamantrao Ganeshrao (Ambad). Waghmare, Shri Narayan Rao Vaishya, Shri Muldas Bhudardas (Parbhani). (Ahmedabad — Reserved — Sch. Wilson, Shri J. N. (Mirzapur Distt Castes). cum Banaras Distt.—West). Vallatharas, Shri K. M. (Pudukottai). Wodeyar, Shri K. G. (Shimoga). Varma, Shri B. B. (Champaran North). Z Varma, Shri Bulaqi Ram (Hardoi Distt.—North-West cum Farrukha- Zaidi, Col. B. H. (Hardoi Distt.— bad Distt.—East cum Shahjahanpur North-West cum Farrukhabad Distt. Distt — South — Reserved — Sch. —^East cum Shahjahanpur Distt. Castes). .-South). HOUSE OF T m , PEOPLE

The Speaker

S h ri G. V, M a v a la n k a r . The DejnitySpeaker

Shri M. A nanthasayanam A y y a n g a r . Panel of Chairmen

P a n d it T u a k u r D as B h a r g a v a . S h rim ati A m m u S w a m in a d h a n . S h ri H a r i V in a y a k P a ta sk ah . Shri N. C. C h a tte rje e. S h rim ati R enu Chakravartty . Secretary

Shii M. N. K a u l, Barrister-at-law. Assistants of the Secretary

Shri A . J. M. A t k in so n . Shri S. L. S hakdher. Shri N. C. N and i. Shri D. N. M a ju m d a r. S hri C. V. Na r a yan a R ao. Committee on Petitions

Pandit T h a k u r D as B h a r g a v a . Shrimati R enu C h a k r a v a h t y . Sh ri A s im K r ish n a D u t t . Shri G o v in d r a o D h a r m a ji V a r t a k . Prof. C. P. M a t h e w . GOVERNMENT OF Members of the Cabinet Prime and Minister of External Aflairs—Shri . Minister of Education and Natural Resources and Scientific Research MaulEfna . Minister of Communications—Shri Jagjivan Ram. Mmister of Health—Rajkumari Amrit Kaur. Minister of Defence—Shri N. Gopalaswami Ayyangar. Minister of Finance— Shri C. D. Deshmukh. Minister of Planning and River Valley Schemes—Shri Minister of Home Affairs and States—Shri K. N. Katju. Minister of Food and Agriculture— Shri . Minister of Commerce and Industry—Shri T. T. Krishnamachari Minister of Law and Minority Affairs— Shri C. C. Biswas. Minister of Railways and Transport-—Shri L^l Bahadur Shastri. Minister of Works, Housing and Supply—Sardar , Minister of Labour—Shri V. V. Giri. Minister of Production—Shri K. C. Reddy.

Ministers of Cabinet Rank (but not Members of the Cabinet) Minister of Parrliamsntary Affairs—Shri . Minister of Rehabilitation—Shri . Minister of State for Finance—Shri Mahavir Tyagi. Minister of Information and Broadcasting—Dr. B. V. Keskar.

Deputy Ministers Deputy Minister of Commerce and Industry—Shri D. P. Karmarkar. Deputy Minister of Works, Housing and Supply— Shri S. N. Buragohaia THE L/ PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (Part II— ^Proceedings other than Questions and Answers) OFTICIAL BEPOET

Vol. I. Mo, First day of tbe First Session of First ParUament of India.

HOUSE OF THE PEOPLE [S h r i G. V. M a v a la n k a r in the Chair] Tuesday, 13th May, 1952. MEMBERS SWORN Shri MaTalankar: The names of hon. The House met at a Quarter to Eleven Members who have to take the Oath of the Clock. or make the Affirmation will now be called by the Secretary one by one. [M r . S peaker in the Chairl The names of Members who do not QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS take the oath at the first call will be calied at the end. (No Questions: Part I not published) All efforts will be made by the Secretary to call the names of hon. 10-45 A.M. Members correctly, as far as possible, still, if there be any mistake, I trust Mr. Speaker: On this solemn occa­ the hon. Members concerned, will sion, when we meet for the first time generally excuse the same. as the elected House under the Consti­ tution, it is but fit and proper that we On the name of a Member being all stand in silence for two minutes, called by the Secretary, he will pro­ before we begin our proceedings. ceed from his seat to the right side of the Secretary’s table, where a copy Secretary: I wil now read out the of the form of oath or affirmation will orders of the President: be handed to him in or English as may be desired by the Member. The (1) “ Whereas the offices of Speaker Member will face me, while making and Deputy Speaker of the House of the oath or affirmation and will then, the People are vacant; after shaking hands with me, pass behind my chair to the other side of In exercise of the powers conferred the table, where he will sign the Roll upon me by clause (1) of article 95 of of Members. After signing the Roll he the Constitution, I, , will return to his seat. , hereby appoint Shri Ganesh Vasudeo Mavalankar, a Shri Jawaharlal Nehru [Allahabad Member of the House of the People, to District (Fast) cum Jaunpur Dis­ perform the duties of the Speaker trict ^West)] until the first sitting of the said House. Shri M. Ananthasayanam Ayyangar. RAJENDRA PRASAD, (Tirupati) The 17th April, 1952. President. Prof. Nibaran Chandra Laskar (Cachar-Lushai Hills—^Reserved— New Delhi, the 12th May, 1952 Sch. CastesT.7 (2) “I, Rajendra Prasad, President Shrimati B. Khongmen (Autonomous of India, hereby anpoint Shri G. V. Districts—Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Mavalankar and Shri M. Anantha- sayanam Ayyangar, to be the persons Shri Sitanath Brohmo-Chaudhury before either of whom members of the (Goalpara-Garo Hills—^Reserved— House of the People may make and Sch. Tribes). subscribe the oath or affirmation in Shri Bell Ram Das (Barpeta)'. accordance with the provisions of article 99 of the . Shri Rohini Kumar Chaudhurl (Gauhati). RAJENDRA PRASAD, Shri Kamakhya Prasad TrlDatbi The llfh May, 1952. President” (Darrangy, 89 P. S. Members Swom 13 MAY 1952 Members Sworn

Shri Dev Kanta Borooah (Nowgong). Shri Lalit Narayan Mishra (Dar­ Shri Debeswar Sarmah (Golagbat- bhanga cum Bhagalpur). Jorhat). Shri Banarsi Prasad Sinha (Mongfayr Shri S. N. Buragohain (Sibsagar- Sadr cum Jamui). North Lakhimpur). Shri Nayan Tara Das (Monghyr Sadr cum J amui — Reserved — Sch. Shri Jogendra Nath Hazarika Castes). (Dibrugarh). Shri Mathura Prasad Mishra (Mon­ Shri Chowkhamoon Gohain (Misfctmi ghyr North-West). Hills District). Pandit Suresh Chandra Mishra (Monghyr North-East). Shri S. Sinha (Pataliputra). Shri Anup Lai Mehta (Bhagalpur Shrimati Tarkeshwari Sinha (Patna cum Pumea). East). Shri Kirai Mushar (Bhagalpur cum Shri B. R. Bhagat (Patna cum Shaha- Pumea—Reserved—Sch. Castes). bad). Shri Brajeshwar Prasad (Gaya Shri Banarsi Prasad Jhunjhunwala East). (Bhagalpur Central). Shrimati Sushama Sen (Bhagalpur Shri Ram Dhanl Das (GayarEast— South). Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri Muhammad Islamuddin (Purnea Shri Vijneshwar Missir (Gaya North-East). North). Shri Phani Gopal Sen (Pumea Shri (Gaya Central). W est). Shri Bhagwat Jha ‘Azad’ (Purnea Dr. (Shahabad cum Santal Parganas). South).- Shri Paul Jujhar Soren (Purnea cum Shri Jagjivan Ram (Shahabad* Santal Parganas—Reserved—Sch. South—Reserved— Sch. Castes). Tribes). Shri Kamal Singh (Shahabad North­ Shri Ramraj Jajware (Santal Par­ West). ganas cum Hazaribagh). Dr. Satyanarain Sinha (Saran E ast).' Shri Lai Hembrom (Santal Parganas Pandit Dwarka Nath Tiwary (Saran cum Hazaribagh—Reserved—Sch. South). Tribes). Shri Bibhuti Mishra (Saran cum Shri Nageshwar Prasad Sinba Champaran). (Hazaribagh East). Shri Bhola Raut (Saran cum Cham­ Babu Ram Narayan Singh (Hazari­ paran—^Reserved—Sch. Castes). bagh West). Shri B. B. Varma (Champaran Shri A. Ibrahim (Ranchi Northr North). East). Dr. Syed Mahmud (Champaran Shri Jaipal Singh (Ranchi W est- East). Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Shri Chandreshwar Narain Prasad Shri Gajendra Prasad Sinha (Pala- Sinha (Muzaffarpur North-West). mau cum Hazaribagh cum Ranchi). Shri Digvijaya Narain Singh Shri P. C. Bose (Manbhum North). (Muzaffarpur North-East). Dr. Hari Mohan (Manbhum North— Shri Syamnandan Sahaya (Muzaflfar- Reserved—Sch. Castes). pur Central). Shri Bhajahari Mahata (Manbhum Shri Awadheshwar Prasad Sinha South cum Dhalbhum). (Muzaffarpur East). Shri Chaitan Majhi (Manbhum South Shri Rajeshwar Patel (Muzaffarpur cum Dhalbhum—Reserved—Sch cum Darbhanga). Tribes). Shri Rameshwar Sahu (Muzaffar­ Shri Kanhu Ram Deogam (Chaibassa pur cum Darbhanga—Reserved— —^Reserved—Sth. Tribes).- Sch. Castes). ^ Shri Akbar CHiavda (Banaskantha). Shri Satya Narayan Sinha (Samasti- Shri Gulzarilal Nanda (Sabar- pur East). kantha). Shri Shree Narayan Das (Darbhanga Shri Maneklal Central). (Panch Mahals cum Baroda East). Shri Anirudha Sinha (Darbhanga Shri Shantilal Girdharlal Parikh East). (Mehsana East). Rhri Shy am Nandan Mishra (Dar- Shri Tulsidas Kilachand (Meh8«n» ^hsinga North), W est), Members Sioorn is MAY 1952 Members Hwom

Shri Muldas Bhuderdas Vaishya Shri D. P. Karmarkar (Dharwar (Ahmedabad — Reserved — Sch. — North). Caste). Shri T. R. Neswi (Dharwar South). Shri Fulsinhji B. Dabhi (Kaira North). Shri (Kanara). Shrimati Maniben Shri S. K. Patil, (Bombay City (Kaira South). South). Dr. Indubhai B. Amin (Baroda West). Shri V. B. Gandhi (Bombay City North). Shri Kanayalal Nanabhai Desai (Surat). Shri Narayan Sadoba Kajrolkar Shri Bahadurbhai Kunthabhai Patel (Bombay City-North—Reserved— (Surat—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Sch. Castes). Shri Govindrao Dharmaji Vartak Shrimati Jayashri Raiji (Bombay- (Thana). Suburban). Shri Anant Savalaram Nandkar Shri Bafbunath Singh (Surguja-Rai- (Thana—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). garh—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Bhau Saheb Kanavade Patil (Ahmednagar North). Sardar Amar Singh Saigal (Bilas- pur). Shri Shivram Rango Rane (Bhusa- val). Shri Resham Lai Jangde (Bilaspur— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri Hari Vinayak Pataskar (Jal- gaon). Shri Bhupendra Nath Misra (Bilas- pur-Durg-Raipur). Shri Shaligram Ramchandra Bhar- tiya (West Khandesh). Guru Gosai Agam Dasji (Bilaspur- Durg-Raipur—Reserved—Sch. Shri Jayantrao Ganpat Natawadkar Castes). (West Khandesh—Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Shri Wasudeo Shridhar Kirolikar (D urg). Shri Govind Hari Deshpande (Nasik- Contral). Pandit Bhagwaticharan Shukla (Durga-Bostar). Shri Narhar Vishnu Gadgil (Poona Central). Shri C. D. Gautam (Balaghat). Shrimati Indira A. Maydeo (Poona Seth Govind Das (Mandla-Jabalpur South). South). Shri Ganesh Sadashiv Altekar Shri M. G. Uikey (Mandla-Jabalpur (North Satara). South—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Shri Sushil Kumar Pateria (Jabal­ Shri B. H. Khardekar (Kolhapur- pur North). cum-Satara). Shri K. L. More (Kolhapur-cum- Shri Khub Chand Sodhia (Sagaf). Satara—Reserved— ^ h . Castes). Pandit B. L. Tiwari (Nimar). Shri Shankar Shantaram More Shri Syed Ahmed (Hoshangabad). (Sholapur). Shri Raichand Bhai Shah (Chhind- Shri P. N. Rajabhoj (Sholapur— wara). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri B. L. Chandak (Betul). Shri Chintaman Dwarkanath Desh- Acharya Shriman Narayan Agarwal mukh (Kolaba). (Wardha). Shri Vyankatrao Pirajirao Pawar Shrimati Anasuyabai Kale (Nag* (South Satara). pur). Shri Balwant Nagesh Datar (Bel- Shri Chaturbhuj V. Jasani (Bha*- gaum North). dara). Shri Shankargauda, Veerangauda Shri T. C. Sakhare (Bhandara— Patil (Belgaum South). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Major-General Jagannathrao Krishna- Mulla Abdullabhai MuUa Taherall rao Bhonsle (Ratnagiri North). (Chanda). Shri Moreshwar (Rat­ Dr. Pamabrao S. Deshmukb (Amra- nagiri South). vati East). Shri Rajaram Giridharlal Dubey Shri K. G. Deshmukh (Amravatl (Bijapur North). West). Shri Ramappa Balappk Bidari Shri Gosw^iraja Sahdeo Bharatl (Bijapup South). (Ycotmal). Members Swom 13 MAY 1952 Members Sworri

Shri Gopalrao Bajirao Khedkar 12 N oon (Buldana-Akola). ^ Shri O. V. Alagesan (Chingleput). Shri Laxman Shrawan Bhatkar (Buldana-Akola — Reserved— Sch. Shri Doraswamy Pillai Ramchander Castes). (Vellore). Shri B. Rajagopala Rao (Srikaku- Shri M. Muthukrishnan (Vellore— 1am). Reserved— Sch. Castes).

[S h r i M. A . A y y a n g a r in the Chair] Shri N. R. M. Swamy (Wandiwash). Shri C. R. Narasimhan (Krishna- Shri Kandala Subrahmanyam giri). (Vizianagaram). Shri N. Sathianathan (Dharmapuri). Dr. Lanka Sundaram (Visakapat- nam). Shri S. V. Ramaswamy (Salem). Shri Gam MaUudora (Visakapat- Shri K. Periaswami Gounder (Erode). nam—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). ^ Shri S. C. Balakrishnan (Erode— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri Velayndhan (Quilon cum- Mavelikkara—Reserved—Sch. Castes): Shri S. K. Kandasamy (Tiruchen- On a point of information, Sir, when gode). the Member has recited that, does he Shri T. S. Avinashilingam Chettiar understand what he has said? (Tiruppur). Shri M. A. Ayyangar: No point of Shri G. R. Damodaran (Pollachi). order now. Shri K. M. Vallatharas (Puduk- Shri NaUa Reddi Naidu -(Rajahmun- kottai). dry). Shri V. Boovaraghasamy (Peram- balur). Shri Kanety Mohana Rao (Rajah- mundry—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Dr. Edward Paul Mathuram (Tiru- chirapalli). Shri B. S. Murthy (Eluru). Shri R. Venkataraman (Tanjore). Shri Kondru Subba Rao (Eluru— Shri C. Ramasamy Mudaliar (Kum- Reserved—Sch. Castes). bakonam). Shri Sanaka Buchhikotaiah (Masuli- Shri V. Veeraswamy (Mayuram— patnam). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri Kadiyala Gopala Rao (Gudi- Shri N. D. Govindaswami Kachiroyar vada). (Cuddalore). Shri Kotha Raghuramaiah (Tenali). Shri L. Elayaperumal (Cuddalore— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri S. V. L. Narasimham (Guntur). Shri V. Muniswamy Avl. Thirukura- Shri C. R. Chowdary (Narasarao- pet). lar (Tindivanam). Shri A. Jayaraman (Tindivanam— Shri Pisupati Venkata Raghavaiah (Ongole). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri P. T. Thanu PiUai (Tirunelveli). Shri Mangalagiri Nanadas (Ongole— Reserved-*Sch. Castes). Shri A. V. Thomas (Srivai- kuntam). Shri B. Ramachandra Reddi (Nel- lore); Shri M. Sankarapandian (Sankara- Shri Rayasam Seshagiri Rao (Nand- nayinarkovil). yal). Shri V. VR. N. AR. Nagappa ChetUar Shri Halaharvi Sitarama Reddy (Ramanathapuram). (Kurnool). Shri K. Kamaraj (Srivilliputhur). Shri Tekur Subrahmanyam (Bellary), Shri S. Balasubramaniam (Madurai). Shri Paidi Lakshamyya (Anantapur). Shri P. Kakkan (Madurai—^Re­ Shri K. S. Raghjibaclrari (Penu- served—Sch. Castes). konda). Shri K. * Sakthivadivel Gounder Shri Y. Eswara Keddi (Cuddapah). (Periyakulam). Shri T. N. Viswanatha Reddy (Chit- Shrimati Ammu Swaminadhan (Din- tbor). digul). . Shri U. Srinivasa Malliah [South Shri T. T. Krishnamachari (Madras). Kanara (North).] Shri P. Natesan (TlruvaUur). Shri B. Shiva Rao [South Kanara Shrimati M. Chandrasekhar (Tiru- (South;.] vallur—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri A K. Gopalan (Cannanore). Members Sworn 13 MAY 1952 Members Sworn 10

Shri Nettur P, Damodaran (Telli- Shri Ram Dass (Hoshiarpur—Re­ cherry). served—Sch. Castes). Shri K. A. Damodara Menon Shri Hem Raj (Kangra). (Kozhikode). Sardar Teja Singh Akarpuri (Gurdaspur). * Janab B. Pocker Saheb (Malappu- ram). Sardar Surjit Singh Majithia (Tarn Taran). Shri K. Kelappan (Ponnani). Shri Gurmukh Singh Musafir (Amrit­ sar). Shri Eacharan Ijo^ani (Ponnani— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Her Highness Rajmata Kamlendu Mati Shah [Garhwal Dt. (West) Shri P. Subba Rao (Nowrangpur). cum Tehri Garwal Dt. cum Bijnor Dt. (North).] Shri T. Sanganna (Rayagada-Phul- bani—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Shri Bhakta Darshan [Garhwal Dt. (East) cum H. H. Maharaja Rajendra Narayan (North East).] Singh Deo (Kalahandi-Bolangir). Shri Devi Datt Pant [Almora District Shri Giridhari Bhoi (Kalahandi- (North East).] Bolangir—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Shri C. D. Pande [Naini Tal District Shri G. D. Thirani (Bargarh). cum Almora District (South West) cuTfi (North).] Dr. Natabar Pandey (Sambalpur). Shri Satish Chandra [Bareilly District Shri Sarangadhar Das (Dhenka- (South).] nal-West Cuttack). Shri Mukuhd Lai Agarwal [Pilibhit Shri Niranjan Jena (Dhenkanal.- District cum Bareilly District. West Cuttack—Reserved— Sch. (East).] Castes). Maulana Abul Kalam Azad [Rampur Shri B. Das (Jajpur-Keonjhar). District cum BareiMy District (W est).] Shri Ram Chandra Majhi (Mayur- bhanj—Reserved—Sch. Tribes). Shri Ajit Prasad Jain [Shaharanpur District (\yest) cum Mazaffar- Shri Bhagabat Sahir (Balasore). nagar District (North).] Shri Kanhu Charan Jena (Balasore— Shri Sunder Lall [Shaharanpur Reserved—Sch. Castes). District (West) cum Muzaffamagar Shri Harekrushna Mahtab (Cuttack). District (North)—Reserved—Sch. Shri Lokenath Mishra (Puri). Castes.] Pandit Lingaraj Misra (Khurda). Shri Hira Vallabh Tripathi [Muzaffar- nagar District (South).] Shri Uma Charan Patnaik (Ghum- sur). Shri Khushi Ram Sharma [ (West).] Shri Bijoy Chandra Das (Ganjam South). Pandit Krishna Chandra Sharma [Meerut District (South).] Shri Tek Chand (Ambala-Simla). Shri Shahnawaz Khan [Meerut Shrimati Subhadra Josl^ (Karnal). District (North East).] Dr. Virendra Kumar Satyawadi Shri Raghubar Dayal Misra (Buland- (Kamal—Reserved—Sch. Castes). shahr District.) Shri Ranbir Singh Chaudhuri Shri Shri Chand Singhal (Aligarh (Rohtak). District). Shri Ghamandi Lai Bansal (Jhajjar- Shri Nardeo Snatak (Aligarh Rewari). District—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Pandit Thakur Das Bhargava (Gur- Seth Achal Singh [ gaon). (W est).] Lala Achint Ram (Hissar). Choudhary Raghubir Singh [Agra Shri Atma Singh Namdhari (Fazilka- District (E ak ).] Sirsa). Shri Digambar Singh [ Shri Bahadur Singh (Ferozepore- (West) cum Ludhiana—Reserved—Sch. Castes). (West) cum (East).] Shri Amarnath Vidyalankar (Jul- Shri Rohanlal Chaturvedi fEtah lundur). District (Central).] Prof. Diwan Chand Sharma Shri Mulchand Dube [Farrukhabad (Hoshiarpur), District (North).l l i Members Sworri 13 Ma V 1952 Members Sworn i i

Shri Badshah Gupta [Mainpuri Shri Masuriya Din [Allfiliabad District (East).] District (East) cum Jaunpur Shri Lotan Ram [Jalaun District District (W est—Reserved—S>ch. cum (West) cum Castes.] Jhansi District (North)—Reserv­ Shri J. N. Wilson [ ed—Sch. Castes.] cum Banaras District (West).] Shri Harihar Nath Shastri t'Kanpur District (Central).] Shri Rup Narsdn [Mirzapur District cum Banaras District (West)— Pandit Balkrishna Sharma [Kan­ reserved—:!5cn. Castes.] pur District (South) cum Etawah District (East).] Shri Raghunath Singh [Banaras District (Central).1 Shri R. V. Dhulekar [Jhansi District Shri Rafi Ahmad Kidwai [Bahraicl^ (South).] District (East).] , Shri M. L. Dwivedi (Hamirpur Chaudhri Hyder Husein [). District (North).] Shri Shiva Dayal Upadhyay (Banda District cum Fatehpur Disrict). Shri Ram Shanker Lai [ (Central East) cum Gorakhpur Swami Ramanand Shastri [ (West)] District cum Rae Bareli District (West) cum (South Shri Sohan Lai Dhusiya £Basti East)—Reserved—Sch. Castes.] District (Central East) cum Col. B. H. Zaidi [Hardoi District (West)—Re­ (North-West) cum Farrukhabad served—i»ch. Castes.] District (East) cum Shahjahanpur Shri Hari Shanker Prasad [Gorakh­ District (South).] pur District (North).] Shri Bulaqi Ram Varma [Hardoi Shri Dashrath Prasad Dwivedi District (North-West) cum Far­ [Gorakhpur District (Central).) rukhabad District (East) cum Shri Sinhasan Singh [Gorakhpur (South)— District (South).] Reserved— Sch. Castes,] Shri Sarju Prasad Misra [Deoria Shri R. P. Nevatia [Shahjahanpur District (South).] District (North) cum Kheri (East).] Shri Bishwa Nath Roy [Deoria Dis­ Shri Ganeshi Lai Chaudhary [Shah­ trict ( West).] jahanpur District (North) cum Shri Ramji Verma [ Kheri (East)—Reserved—Sch. (East).] Castes.] Shri Sita Rama Asthana [Azamgarh Shrimati Uma Nehru [ (West).] District cum Kheri District (W est).] Shri Vishwanath Prasad [ (West)— ^Reserved—5>ch. Chaudhari Paragi Lai [Sitapur Castes.] District cum Kheri District (W est)—Reserved—Sch. Castes.] Pandit Algu Rai Shastri [Azamgarh District (East) cum Shrimati Ganga Devi (Lucknow (W est).] District cum Bara Banki District— Reserved—Sch. Castes.] Shri Hat^ Prasad Singh [ (West).] Shri Feroze Gandhi [Pratapgarh Dis­ trict (West cum Rae Bareli District Shri Ram Nagina Singh [Ghazipur (East).] District (East) cum Ballia District (South West).l Shri Baij Nath Kureel [Pratapgarh District (West) cum Rae Bareli Shri A. K. Basu (North Bengal). District (East)—Reserved—Sch. Shri Upendranath Barman (North Castes.] Besngal— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Dr. B. V. Keskar [ Shri Birendranath Katham (North (South).] Bengal—Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri Lallan ji [ Shri Surendra Mohan Ghose (Malda). (North-West).] Shri Kamali Krishna Das (Birbhum— Shri Panna Lai [Faizabad District Reserved—Sch. Castes). (North West)—Reserved— Sch. Castes.] Shri Muhammed Khuda Buksh (Murshidabad). Shri Birbal Singh [ (East).] Shri Tridib Kumar Chaudhuri Shri Ganpati Ram [Jaunpur District (Berhampore). (East—Reserved—Sch. Castes.] Shri Jagannath Kolay (Bankura). 18 Members Sworn 13 MAY 1952 Members Sworn 14

Dr. Pashupati Mandal (Bankura— Shri Narayan Rao Waghmare (Par- Reserved— Sch. Castes.) bhani). - Shri Bharat Lai Tudu (- Shri Devroa Namdevroa Pathrikar Jhargram—Reserved—Sch. Tribes) Kamle (Nanded—Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri Nikunja Behari Chowdhury (Ghatal). Shri C. Madhao Reddi (Adilabad). Shri Satis Chandra . Samanta Shri H. C. Heda (Nizamabad). (Tamluk). Dr. N. M. Jaisoorya (Medak). Shri Basanta Kumar Das (Contai). Shri Baddam Yella Reddy (Karim- Shri Tushar Chatterjea (Serampore). nagar). Dr, Mono Mohon Das (Burdwan— Shri Pendyal Raghava Rao (Waran- Reserved—Sch. Castes.] gal). Shri Abdus Sattar (Kalna-Katwa). Shri T. B. Vittal Rao (Khammam). Pandit Lakshmi Kanta Maitra Shri Ravi Narayan Reddy (Nalgonda). (Nabadwip). ' Shri Sunkam Achalu (Nalgonda— Shri Ariin Chandra Guha (Shanti- Reserved—Sch. Castes). pur). Sbrimati Renu Chakravartty (Basir- Shri Mohanlal Saksena (Lucknow hat). District cum Bara Banki District). Shri Patiram Roy (Basirhat— Shri Vaijanath Mahodaya (Nimar). Reserved—Sch. Castes). Shri Nand Lai Joshi (Indore). Shri Kamal Kumar Basu (Diamond Shri Radhelal Vyas (Ujjain) . Harbour). ^ Shri Liladhar Joshi (Shajapur-Raj- Shri Purnendu Sekhar Naskar ‘ garh). (Diamond Harbour—Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri Bhagu Nandu Malvia (Shajapur- Raigarh—Reserved—Sch. Castes) Shri Asim Krishna Dutt (Calcutta South-West). Dr. Kailas Nath Katju (Mandsaur). Shri Radha Charan Sharma (Morena- Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee Bhind). (Calcutta South-East). Shri Suriya Prashad (Morena-Bhind- Shri Hirendra Nath Mukerjee Reserved— Sch. Castes). (Calcutta North-East). Shri M. V. Krishnappa (Kolar). The House then adjourned for Lunch Lunch at half Past Two of the Clock. Shri Dodda Thimmaiah (Kolar— Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri C. R. Basapna (Tumkur). The House re-assembled after Shri N. Keshavaiengar (Bangalore Lunch at half Past Tnjo of the Clock. North). [S h r i M. A . A y y a n g a r in the Chairl Shri T. Madiah Gowda (Bangalore South)'. Shri M. A. Ayyan8:ar: The Secretary Will now call the Members. Shri M. K. Shivananjappa (Mandya). Shri M. S. Gurupadaswamy (Mysore). Shri Ahmed Mohiuddin (Hyderabad City). Shri N. R a chi ah (Mysore— Reserved Sln-i Sadath Ali Khan (Ibrahim- —Sch. Castes). patnam). Shri H. Siddananjappa (Hassan- Shri K. Janardhan Reddy (Mahbub- Chikmagalur). nagar). Shri K. G. Wodeyar (Shimoga). Shri P. Ramaswamy (Mahbubnagar— Shri Hira Singh Chinaria (Mohinder- Reserved—Sch. Castes). garh). Shri Ran jit Singh (Sangrur). Shri Krishnacharya Joshi (Yadgir). Shri Ram Pratap Garg (Patiala). Dr. Shaukatullah Shah Ansari (Bidar). Shri Hukam Singh Kapurthala (Bhatinda). Dr. S. A. Ebenezer (Vikarabad). Shri Aiit Sineh rKapiirthala- Diwan Raghavendra Rao (Osmanar Bhatinda—Reserved—Sch. Castes). bad)'. Dr. Manik Chand Jatav-Vir (Bharat- Shri R. G. Paranjpe (Bhir). pur-Sawai MadhoDur—Reserved— Shri Hanumantrao Ganeghrao Vaish- Sch. Castes). Riv (Ambaa), Shri $hobha Ram (Alwar). 15 Members Swom 13 MAY 1952 Memhera Swom le

Shri Radheshyam Ramkumar Morarka Shri Ram Sahai Tiwari (Chhatar- (Ganganagar-Jhunjhunu). pur-Datia-Tikamgarh). Shri Panna Lall Banipal (Ganga- Shri Motilal Malviya (Chhatarpur- nagar-Jhunihunu — Reserved—Sch. Datia-Tikamgarh— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Castes). Shri Bhawani Singh (Barmer-Jalore), Bishop John Richardson [Nominated General Ajit Singhji (Sirohi-Pali). Andaman and Nicobar Islands.] Shri G. D. Somani (Nagaur-Pali). Shri (Nominated- Shri Nand Lai Sharma (Sikar). Anglo-Indian). Shri Daulat'Mal Bhandari (Jaipur). Shri A. E. T. Barrow (Nominated- Anglo-Indian). Shri Pannalal R. Kaushik (Tonk). Sardar Lai Singh (Ferozepore- Shri Hari Ram Nathani (Bhilwara). Ludhiana)’. * Shri Umashanker Muljibhai Trivedi Shri Vishnu Ghanashyam Deshpande (Chittor). (Guna). Shri Nemi Chandra Kasliwal (Kotah- Shri N. C. Chatterjee (Hooghly). Jhalawar). Shri Durga Charan Banerjee (Midna- Shri Rasiklal U. Parikh (Zalawad). pore-Jhargram). Shri Balvantray Gopaljee Mehta Shrimati Shakuntala Nayar [Gonda (Gohilwad). District (West).] Shri Narendra P. Nathwani (Sorath). Shri Udai Shanker Dube [Bast! District (North).] Shri A. Nesamony (Nagercoil). Shri Anil Kumar Chanda (Birbhum)’. Shri V. P. Nayar (Chirayinkll). Shri Santosh Kumar Dutta (Howrah). Shri R. Velajoadhan (Quilon-cum- iVT a vel ikk ar a—Reserved—Sch. Dr. Susilranjan Chatterjee (West Castes). Dinajpur). Shri Atulya Ghosh (Burdwan). Shri C. P. Matthen (Thiruvellah). Shri Shankar Rao Telkikar Shri P. T. Chacko (Meenachil). (Nanded). Shri A. M. Thomas (Ernakulam). Shri Mahendra Nath Singh (Saran Central). Shri K. T. Achuthan (Crangannur)'. Shri V. V. Giri (Pathapatnam). Shri C. R. lyyunni (Trichur). Shri N. Ramaseshaiah (Parvathi- Shri Jwala Prasad (Ajmer North). puram). Pandit Mukat Behari Lai Bhargava Shri Suresh Chandra Deb (Cachar- (Ajmer South). Lushai Hills). Sardar Jopendra Singh [Bahraich Shri Jhulan Sinha (Saran North). District (West).l Shrimati Sucheta Kripalani (New Shri Keshava Deva Malaviya TGonda Delhi). District (East) cum Basti District Shri Nemi Saran Jain [Bijnor Dis­ (W est).] trict (South).] Pandit Chatur Narain Malviya (Rai- Swami Ramananda Tirtha (Gulr sen). berga). Shri N. Somana (Coorg). Shri Bheekha Bhai (Banswara- Shri Goui rMandi-Mahasu— Dungarpur—Reserved— Sch. Tribes). Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri Balwant Sinha Mehta (Udai­ Shri A. R. Sewal (Chamba^Sirmur). pur). 3 P.M. Shri M. R. Krishna (Karimnagar— Shn* Laisram Jogeswar Singh (Inner Reserved—Sch. Castes). Manipur). Shri Meghnath Shah (Calcutta Shri Dasaratha Deb (Trioura East). North-West). Shri Biren Dutt (Tripura West). H. H. Maharaja Sri Kami Singhji Shri Bhagwandutt Shastri (Shahdol- Bahadur of Bikaner (Bikaner- Sidhi). Churu)'. Shri Rardaman Singh ^'Shahdol- Shri Sivamurthi Swami (Kushtagi). Sidhi—^Reserved-Sch. Tribes). [ S h r i G. V. Mavalankar in the Chairl Sard nr Raj Bhanu Singh Tewar: (Rewa). Shri Venkatesh Naravan Tivary TKanpur District (North"^ rum Shri Shiva Datt Upadhyaya (Satna). Farrukhabad Distict (South).T 17 Members Swom 13 MAY 1952 Members Sworn ig

Shri Raghubir Sahai [Etah District Dr. Suresh Chandra (Aurangabad;. (North East) cum Budaiin District akri Chimanlal Chakubhai Shal*. (East).] (Gohilwad-Sorath). Shri Hotilal Agarwal [Jalaun Dis­ ahri Amar Singh Sabji L amar trict cum Etawah District (West) (Jhabua— Reserved— Sch. Tribes). cum Jhansi District (North).] Shri C. Krishnan Nair (Outer Delhi). Shri Munisbwar Dutt Upadhyay [Pratapgarh District (East).] Shri Naval Prabhaker (Outer Delhi— Reserved—Sch. Castes). Dr. M. V. Gangadhara Siva (Chit- toor— Reserved— Sch. Castes). Shri Tribhuan Narayan Singh [Banaras District (East).] Shri Rupaji Bhavji Parmar (Panch Mahals cum Baroda East—Re­ Shri Mavalankar: Is there any other served—Sch. Tribes). hon. Member who is yet to take the Shri Chandikeshwar Sharan Singh oath: if so, he may kindly come to Ju Deo (Surguja-Raigarh). the table. Maulana Mohammad Saeed Masuodi (Jammu and Kashmir). I have not got with me the exact number of hon. Members who have Shri Lakshman Singh Charak taken the oath, but I am told that (Jammu and Kashmir). almost all—barring about forty or so, Shri Soft Mohd. Akber (Jammu and whatever that may be— have taken the Kashmir). oath. Now the taking of oath will be Pandit Sheo Narayan Fotedar done from day to day as those hon. CJammu and Kashmir). Members remain present here, with the result that—I believe a happy Shri rvluhammed Shaffee Choudhri one— tomorrow’s sitting is cancelled (Jammu and Kashmir). and we need not come here tomorrow Kh. Ghulam Qader (Jammu an