DOCSLIB.ORG

A Critical Ethnographic Case Study on Voice, Democracy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Critical Ethnographic Case Study on Voice, Democracy YES, VIRGINIA, THERE IS DEMOCRACY: A CRITICAL ETHNOGRAPHIC CASE STUDY ON VOICE, DEMOCRACY, AND CHILDHOOD IN A DEMOCRATIC SCHOOL by Alicia Hill, B.S., M.A. A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Council of Texas State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy with a Major in School Improvement December, 2018 Committee Members: Melissa A. Martinez, Chair Patricia Guerra Timothy Kinard Michael O’Malley COPYRIGHT by Alicia Hill 2018 FAIR USE AND AUTHOR’S PERMISSION STATEMENT Fair Use This work is protected by the Copyright Laws of the United States (Public Law 94-553, section 107). Consistent with fair use as defined in the Copyright Laws, brief quotations from this material are allowed with proper acknowledgment. Use of this material for financial gain without the author’s express written permission is not allowed. Duplication Permission As the copyright holder of this work I, Alicia Hill authorize duplication of this work, in whole or in part, for educational or scholarly purposes only ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS It is with sincere gratitude that I acknowledge the many people who provided support, encouragement, and guidance during this dissertation process. Thank you to the members of my committee, each of whom contributed invaluable insight and perspective to this study; I am truly grateful for your unquestioning commitment of time and your thoughtful counsel. Thank you, Dr. Martinez, for the steady support and direction you provided throughout this journey. I cannot thank you enough for the countless hours you spent reading over my drafts and for the thoughtful feedback you were always willing to share. Dr. O’Malley, my entry into this graduate program was met with the opportunity to travel abroad and participate in your research project, from which this study drew inspiration. I am grateful for the good fortune I had to learn from you and experience this new world of scholarly academic research. Thank you for helping me bear in mind that the world is viewed through different lenses, and for pushing me to more thoroughly and thoughtfully make that connection in my writing. Dr. Guerra, I am forever grateful for the important role you played on my committee. As a steadfast advocate for a more socially just system, you were the consistent voice reminding me why we are doing this work. Thank you for directing me towards a more honest critique of my positionality, my work, and my purpose. Thank you, Dr. Kinard, for agreeing to serve on my committee after just one meeting. As a former early childhood educator myself, I continue to be inspired by the iv work you do that so befittingly acknowledges the often underappreciated potential of young people. I appreciate the perspective and insight you shared throughout this process. Thank you also to my mom, Annette Stafford, for your endless encouragement and love and for the many holiday meals you provided so I could spend time writing. You are and have always been a source of inspiration and strength. Finally, I want to thank my husband, John Rumrich, and sons, Gabriel and Nathaniel. Thank you for your love, patience, and support throughout this process. I am forever grateful that I have the honor to share this life and experience with each of you! v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................. iv ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................... ix CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................. 1 Background ..................................................................................................5 Democracy in America ..............................................................................11 Radical Democratic Education ..................................................................12 Statement of the Problem ..........................................................................16 Purpose of the Study .................................................................................18 Overview of Research Methodology ........................................................20 Contributions and Significance of Study ..................................................21 Organization of the Study .........................................................................22 II. REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE ..................................................................24 Constructing Childhood ............................................................................26 Locke-the imperfect state of the child ..........................................27 Rousseau and The Innocent child .................................................28 The Annals of Childhood ..............................................................29 Sudbury Education ....................................................................................32 Defining Student Voice in Education .......................................................34 Student Voice Through the Discourses of School Reform .......................38 Neo-liberal Discourses ..................................................................39 Student Voice and Discourses of Democratic Engagement .........41 Student Voice Within Poststructural Discourses ...........................42 Problems with Student Voice ....................................................................47 Conclusion ................................................................................................51 Theoretical Framework .............................................................................52 III. METHODOLOGY .........................................................................................55 Rationale for Qualitative Research ............................................................55 vi Critical Ethnographic Case Study ..............................................................58 Site and Participants ...................................................................................61 About Preferred School Site ..........................................................64 Hillview Staff Members .................................................................67 Participant Selection ..................................................................................70 Data Collection ..........................................................................................72 Stage One: Building a Preliminary Record ...................................73 Stage Two: Preliminary Reconstructive Analysis ........................74 Stage Three: Dialogical Data Generation .....................................74 Data Analysis .............................................................................................77 Stages Four and Five: Conducting Systems Analysis...................77 Reliability and Validity ..............................................................................78 Triangulation ..................................................................................79 Rich Description ............................................................................80 Reflexivity......................................................................................80 Limitations .................................................................................................81 Ethical Considerations ...............................................................................84 IV. FINDINGS .......................................................................................................86 Hillview Sudbury School ...........................................................................86 Introduction to Study Participants .............................................................91 Raven .............................................................................................92 Olivia..............................................................................................93 Fynn ...............................................................................................94 Crystal ............................................................................................94 Fletcher ..........................................................................................95 Introduction Research Findings .................................................................95 Historical Sense of Self as Child ...............................................................95 Tensions Within the Constructivist Self as Learner ................................100 Self-Determination and Body Autonomy ................................................107 Choice Architecture .................................................................................111 Of the People, By the People, For the Individual ....................................117 Summary ..................................................................................................123 V. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION ............................................................124 Key Findings ...........................................................................................125 Summary of Study Themes .....................................................................126 Discussion of the Findings ......................................................................129 Implications for Practice, Policy and Research ......................................138
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Access, Equity and Activism: TEACHING the POSSIBLE! Progressivenational Education Conference Network New York City October 8-10, 2015
    1 Access, Equity and Activism: TEACHING THE POSSIBLE! Progressive Education Network National Conference New York City PEN_Conference_2015.indd 1 October 8-10, 2015 9/29/15 2:25 PM 2 Mission and History of the Progressive Education Network “The Progressive Education Network exists to herald and promote the vision of progressive education on a national basis, while providing opportunities for educators to connect, support, and learn from one another.” In 2004 and 2005, The School in Rose Valley, PA, celebrated its seventy- fifth anniversary by hosting a two-part national conference, Progressive Education in the 21st Century. Near the end of the conference, a group of seven educators from public and private schools around the country rallied to a call-to-action to revive the Network of Progressive Educators, which had been inactive since the early 1990s. Inspired by the progressive tenets of the conference, the group shared a grand collective mission: to establish a national group to rise up, protect, clarify, and celebrate the principles of progressive education and to fashion a revitalized national educational vision. This group, “The PEN Seven” (Maureen Cheever, Katy Dalgleish, Tom Little, Kate (McLellan) Blaker, John Pecore, Lisa Shapiro, and Terry Strand) hosted the organization’s first national conference in San Francisco in 2007. As a result of the committee’s efforts, the Progressive Education Network (PEN) was formed and in 2009 was incorporated as a 501 (c) 3 charitable, non-profit organization. Biannual conferences, supported by PEN and produced by various committees, followed in DC, Chicago, and LA, with attendance growing from 250 to 950.
    [Show full text]
  • Committee on City Healthcare Services: 2018 Report
    Committee on City Healthcare Services: 2018 Report October 2018 0 Contents Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 2 Background and Context ............................................................................................................................... 2 Health Data Summary ................................................................................................................................... 4 Summary of City Healthcare Services ......................................................................................................... 12 Administration for Children’s Services .................................................................................................... 12 Human Resources Administration (Department of Social Services) ....................................................... 13 Department of Homeless Services (Department of Social Services) ...................................................... 15 Department for the Aging ....................................................................................................................... 16 Department of Health and Mental Hygiene ........................................................................................... 18 Department of Education ....................................................................................................................... 20 NYC Health + Hospitals...........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Why Common Core Is No
    ' *<*_ r.^ pE©a¥ED / NOV 9 1 0()<i Independent Regulatory Review Commission / " CUIJ November 21,2013 / INDEPENDENT RcGIil AT„ Consideration of final-form regulation #6-326 (IRRC #2976) Chapter 4 (Academic Standards and Assessment) Good morning Chairman Lutkewitte and fellow Commissioners. My name is Lee Williams, and I serve as Chair of the State Board of Educations Committee on Academic Standards and Chapter 4. I'm pleased to be with you this morning to discuss the final-form revisions to Chapter 4 that have been the subject of much debate and deliberation. I'd like to begin by providing a sense of history related to the key issues addressed in this regulatory package, and then will discuss the process undertaken by the Board that has led us here today. In 2006, concerns were brought to the Board's attention that many students were graduating from high school without adequate preparation for entering the workforce or college. This was evidenced by data that showed more than 40% of Pennsylvania's high school graduates - representing more than 50,000 students each year - were being awarded diplomas without demonstrating proficiency on the state's reading, writing and math tests. Additional data showed that fewer than half of our high school graduates enrolled in college upon graduation, only 37% persisted to their sophomore year, and just one-third graduated from college on time. Further, a February 2009 survey of our state's 14 community colleges and 14 state-owned universities found that 62,000 students at the schools were enrolled in remedial coursework at a cost exceeding $26 million annually.
    [Show full text]
  • INSIDE an Appeal to Texas Legislature: End the Tyranny of Standardized Testing! L Education in the News Has Pioneering a Future? by A.S
    The Magazine of Alternative Education EEducationE RRevolutionR Volume 19, Number 2 EESummer 2007 * $4.95 / $5.95 CDN RR Issue Number Forty Nine Rocket Day at Marietta Johnson School of Organic Education (see page 10) INSIDE An Appeal to Texas Legislature: End the Tyranny of Standardized Testing! l Education in the News Has Pioneering a Future? by A.S. Neill Marietta Johnson School of Organic Education Being There l From the Editor’s Desk l Plus Much More! Education Revolution The Magazine of Alternative Education Summer 2007 - Issue Number Forty Nine - www.educationrevolution.org Alternative Education Resource Organization (AERO) The Mission of Education Revolution Magazine is based on AERO, which produces this magazine quarterly, is firmly that of the Alternative Education Resource Organization (AERO): established as a leader in the field of educational alternatives. Founded in 1989 in an effort to promote learner-centered “Building the critical mass for the education revolution by education and influence change in the education system, AERO providing resources which support self-determination in is an arm of the School of Living, a non-profit organization. learning and the natural genius in everyone.” AERO provides information, resources and guidance to students, parents, schools and organizations regarding their educational Towards this end, this magazine includes the latest news and choices. communications regarding the broad spectrum of educational alternatives: public alternatives, independent and private alternatives, home education, international alternatives, and more. The common feature in all these educational options is that they are learner-centered, focused on the interest of the child rather From the Editor’s Desk than on an arbitrary curriculum.
    [Show full text]
  • A SCHOOL on a FARM (What One Family Can Do)
    The Magazine of Alternative Education Education Revolution I s s u e N u m b e r F o r t y F o u r Spring 2006 $4.95 USA/5.95 CDN ∗ ∗ E a s t H i l l S c h o o l ∗ ∗ A SCHOOL ON A FARM (What One Family Can Do) PLUS: THE VALUE OF THE THINGS THEY LEARN w w w . E d u c a t i o n R e v o l u t i o n . o r g Education Revolution The Magazine of Alternative Education Spring 2006 - Issue Number Forty Four - www.educationrevolution.org The mission of The Education Revolution magazine is based on that of the Alternative Education Resource Organization AERO, which produces this magazine quarterly, is firmly (AERO): Building the critical mass for the education revolution established as a leader in the field of educational alternatives. by providing resources which support self-determination in Founded in 1989 in an effort to promote learner-centered learning and the natural genius in everyone. Towards this education and influence change in the education system, AERO end, this magazine includes the latest news and communications is an arm of the School of Living, a non-profit organization. regarding the broad spectrum of educational alternatives: public AERO provides information, resources and guidance to alternatives, independent and private alternatives, home students, parents, schools and organizations regarding their education, international alternatives, and more. The common educational choices. feature in all these educational options is that they are learner- centered, focused on the interest of the child rather than on an arbitrary curriculum.
    [Show full text]
  • Ratner Nabs Nets
    Ed Weintrob / The real story is the land grab, not the Nets That the Nets are coming is ries in Thursday’s edition.) seizure of private property for too good a hub to leave fallow, more than a holding action. Ratner’s architect (sorry, the pay millions for homes in neigh- beside the point. And that is the The real story is that the At- private benefit ever in Brooklyn. and they should have suspected With virtually no public con- media’s been instructed to say borhoods abutting the condemn- real story, a story masterfully lantic Yards project — and its Let’s dispose of the sidebar that Ratner’s early step there — sultation (and no request for “world renowned” architect) ed sites) for many reasons, not buried by developer Bruce Rat- companion Downtown Brook- first: Atlantic Terminal is proba- the ugly, dysfunctional, failed competing proposals), Gov. Pata- Frank Gehry said his intent is to the least of which is it’s not Man- ner and his media shills. (When lyn Plan — is not about the Nets bly the best site in town for a Atlantic Center shopping mall he ki is apparently prepared to con- build a neighborhood from hattan but close to it, and it’s not the New York Times is your real (whose stadium would occupy a Nets arena, just as it would have opened in the ’90s and his demn enough privately-owned scratch. Brooklyn’s been hot for the kind of sterile, suburban cam- estate partner, it’s amazing the tiny part of the massive site), it’s been for the Dodgers in the ’50s.
    [Show full text]
  • A Radical Way of Unleashing a Generation of Geniuses | WIRED
    A Radical Way of Unleashing a Generation of Geniuses SUBSCRIBE BUSINESS CULTURE DESIGN GEAR SCIENCE SECURITY TRANSPORTATION JOSHUA DAVIS BUSINESS 10.15.13 6:30 AM SHARE A RADICAL WAY OF SHARE 7 UNLEASHING A GENERATION OF TWEET GENIUSES PIN 3 COMMENT 1 EMAIL These students in Matamoros, Mexico, didn't have reliable Internet access, steady electricity, or much hope—until a radical new teaching method unlocked their potential. PETER YANG LATEST NEWS MOVIES Twitter Burn: The YOU CAN READ a version of this story in Spanish here. Independence Day Kids Pueden leer una versión de esta historia en español aquí. Get the Last Laugh 2 DAYS AUTO JOSÉ URBINA LÓPEZ Primary School sits next to a dump just Aston Martin’s Custom- Made Roadster Is Most across the US border in Mexico. The school serves residents Certainly Not for You of Matamoros, a dusty, sunbaked city of 489,000 that is a 2 DAYS flash point in the war on drugs. There are regular shoot- GAME|LIFE PODCAST outs, and it’s not uncommon for locals to find bodies Game|Life Podcast: What Bad Mighty No. 9 Reviews scattered in the street in the morning. To get to the school, Mean for the Future of students walk along a white dirt road that parallels a fetid Gaming2 DAYS Kickstarters canal. On a recent morning there was a 1940s-era tractor, a decaying boat in a ditch, and a herd of goats nibbling gray MORE NEWS strands of grass. A cinder-block barrier separates the school from a wasteland—the far end of which is a mound of trash that grew so big, it was finally closed down.
    [Show full text]
  • 91 1. Below Is the Peggy Mcintosh List of Unacknowledged White Privileges
    NOTES 1. Below is the Peggy McIntosh list of unacknowledged white privileges: 1. “ I can if I wish arrange to be in the company of people of my race most of the time. 2. If I should need to move, I can be pretty sure of renting or purchasing housing in an area which I can afford and in which I would want to live. 3. I can be pretty sure that my neighbors in such a location will be neutral or pleasant to me. 4. I can go shopping alone most of the time, pretty well assured that I will not be followed or harassed. 5. I can turn on the television or open to the front page of the paper and see people of my race widely represented. 6. When I am told about our national heritage or about “civilization,” I am shown that people of my color made it what it is. 7. I can be sure that my children will be given curricular materials that testify to the existence of their race. 8. If I want to, I can be pretty sure of finding a publisher for this piece on white privilege. 9. I can go into a music shop and count on finding the music of my race represented, into a supermarket and find the staple foods which fit with my cultural traditions, into a hairdresser’s shop and find someone who can cut my hair. 10. Whether I use checks, credit cards, or cash, I can count on my skin color not to work against the appearance of financial reliability.
    [Show full text]
  • The Morning Meeting: Fostering a Participatory Democracy Begins with Youth in Public Education
    Old Dominion University ODU Digital Commons Teaching & Learning Faculty Publications Teaching & Learning 2020 The Morning Meeting: Fostering a Participatory Democracy Begins with Youth in Public Education Rebecca C. Tilhou Old Dominion University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/teachinglearning_fac_pubs Part of the Curriculum and Social Inquiry Commons, Educational Leadership Commons, Educational Methods Commons, Political Theory Commons, and the Social and Philosophical Foundations of Education Commons Original Publication Citation Tilhou, R. C. (2020). The morning meeting: Fostering a participatory democracy begins with youth in public education. Democracy & Education, 28(2), 1-11. Retrieved from https://democracyeducationjournal.org/home/vol28/iss2/5/ This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Teaching & Learning at ODU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Teaching & Learning Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of ODU Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Morning Meeting Fostering a Participatory Democracy Begins with Youth in Public Education Rebecca C. Tilhou (Old Dominion University) Abstract There is a faltering sense of democracy in America’s current political climate due to polarized opin- ions about leadership’s decisions and antagonistic political parties. John Dewey (1916) proposed that education is the place to foster democracy, as schools can provide a platform to actively engage stu- dents in authentic democratic experiences that will empower them to act democratically beyond the walls of the school. The democratic schools that emerged during the Free School Movement of the 1960s and 1970s embody Dewey’s philosophy, specifically with the shared governance occurring in their School Meetings.
    [Show full text]
  • Schools on Trial: How Freedom and Creativity Can Fix Our Educational
    Copyright © 2016 by Nikhil Goyal All rights reserved. Published in the United States by Doubleday, a division of Penguin Random House LLC, New York, and distributed in Canada by Random House of Canada, a division of Penguin Random House Canada Ltd., Toronto. www.doubleday.com DOUBLEDAY and the portrayal of an anchor with a dolphin are registered trademarks of Penguin Random House LLC. Cover design by Emily Mahon Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Goyal, Nikhil, author. Title: Schools on trial : how freedom and creativity can fix our educational malpractice / by Nikhil Goyal. Description: New York : Doubleday, an Imprint of Penguin Random House, [2016] Identifiers: LCCN 2015023598 ISBN 9780385540124 (hardcover) ISBN 9780385540131 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Alternative education—United States. School improvement Programs—United States. School environment. Classification: LCC LC46.4 .G69 2016 DDC 371.04—dc23 LC record available at http://lccn.loc.gov/​2015023598 eBook ISBN 9780385540131 v4.1 ep Contents Cover Title Page Copyright Dedication Epigraph Introduction Chapter 1: The Radical Notion That Children Are People Chapter 2: The Disturbing Origins of Compulsory Schooling Chapter 3: No Child Left Uncontrolled Chapter 4: The Right to Learn Freely Chapter 5: The Right to Play Chapter 6: Schools Where Children Can Be Themselves Chapter 7: Not Your Father’s Shop Class Chapter 8: Enrolling in the Real World Chapter 9: School Without Walls Conclusion Acknowledgments Notes Selected Bibliography About the Author How could youths better learn to live than by at once trying the experiment of living? —Henry David Thoreau Introduction On most mornings, millions of young people depart from their homes and travel by cars and yellow buses to drab-looking, claustrophobic buildings.
    [Show full text]
  • 100 Years of Montessori Education!
    The Magazine of Alternative Education EEducationE RRevolutionR Volume 18, Number 4 EEWinter 2006 * $4.95 / $5.95 CDN RR Issue Number Forty Seven 100 Years of Montessori Education! INSIDE Being There l From the Editor’s Desk l Education in the News How to Start Your Own Alternative l Plus Much More! Education Revolution The Magazine of Alternative Education Winter 2006 - Issue Number Forty Seven - www.educationrevolution.org Alternative Education Resource Organization (AERO) The Mission of Education Revolution Magazine is based on AERO, which produces this magazine quarterly, is firmly that of the Alternative Education Resource Organization (AERO): established as a leader in the field of educational alternatives. Founded in 1989 in an effort to promote learner-centered “Building the critical mass for the education revolution by education and influence change in the education system, AERO providing resources which support self-determination in is an arm of the School of Living, a non-profit organization. learning and the natural genius in everyone.” AERO provides information, resources and guidance to students, parents, schools and organizations regarding their educational Towards this end, this magazine includes the latest news and choices. communications regarding the broad spectrum of educational alternatives: public alternatives, independent and private alternatives, home education, international alternatives, and more. From the Editor’s Desk The common feature in all these educational options is that they by Ron Miller............................................................ 3 are learner-centered, focused on the interest of the child rather than on an arbitrary curriculum. Being There Five Unique NY Schools Convene in Albany............ 4 with Jerry Mintz Cover Story Education Revolution The Magazine of Alternative Education 100 Years of Montessori Education..........................
    [Show full text]
  • Education Revolution
    The Magazine of Alternative Education Education Revolution I s s u e N u m b e r T h i r t y N i n e Fall 2004 $4.95 USA/5.95 CDN First Israeli GOLD Won By Democratic Schooler Big Small ALSO:Schools vs. Schools w w w . e d u c a t i o n r e v o l u t i o n . o r g Education Revolution The Magazine of Alternative Education Fall 2004 - Issue Number Thirty Nine - www.educationrevolution.org Looking for News The mission of The Education Revolution magazine is based on that of the Alternative Education Resource Organization Who Can Resist High Stakes Testing?.............. 8 (AERO): “Building the critical mass for the education revolution Any Children Not Left Behind?........................... 4 by providing resources which support self-determination in Killy Reopening................................................. 7 learning and the natural genius in everyone.” Towards this Windsor House Threatened............................ 7 end, this magazine includes the latest news and communications Gal Friedman’s Olympic Gold......................... regarding the broad spectrum of educational alternatives: public 8 alternatives, independent and private alternatives, home For Profit Charters Crash................................ 8 education, international alternatives, and more. The common Being There feature in all these educational options is that they are learner- centered, focused on the interest of the child rather than on an Renaissance School.......................................... 9 arbitrary curriculum. Mail & Communication AERO, which produces this magazine quarterly, is firmly Main Section..................................................... 11 established as a leader in the field of educational alternatives. Public Alternatives............................................ 16 Founded in 1989 in an effort to promote learner-centered Home Education..............................................
    [Show full text]