Homeschoolers and Public School Facilities: Proposals for Providing Fairer Access
\\server05\productn\N\NYL\10-3\NYL306.txt unknown Seq: 1 22-OCT-07 14:13 HOMESCHOOLERS AND PUBLIC SCHOOL FACILITIES: PROPOSALS FOR PROVIDING FAIRER ACCESS Christina Sim Keddie* INTRODUCTION .............................................. 604 R I. THE HISTORY OF THE HOMESCHOOLING MOVEMENT AND THE QUESTION OF SCHOOL CHOICE .............. 607 R A. Legal Grounds for the Right to Homeschool ...... 607 R B. The Current State of Homeschooling Regulations . 611 R 1. States Treating Home Schools as Private Schools ..................................... 611 R 2. States Requiring Home Schools to be Equivalent to Public Schools................. 612 R 3. States that Expressly Regulate Home Schools . 613 R C. The Question of School Choice .................. 613 R II. CONTEXT: CURRENT LEGISLATION REGARDING HOMESCHOOLER ACCESS TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS ......... 615 R A. Access to Interscholastic Sports .................. 616 R B. Access to Both Extracurricular and Interscholastic Activities ....................................... 617 R C. Access to Curricular, Extracurricular, and Interscholastic Activities ......................... 618 R III. JUDICIAL MATTERS: CONSTITUTIONAL ARGUMENTS FOR A RIGHT OF ACCESS ................................. 619 R A. Court Cases Rejecting a Right of Access ......... 619 R 1. Cases Involving Access to Curricular Activities ................................... 621 R 2. Cases Involving Access to Interscholastic Sports ...................................... 622 R * Associate, Dechert LLP, Princeton, NJ. J.D., New York University School of Law, 2007; B.A., Princeton University, 2003. The author wishes to thank Professor Paulette Caldwell for her invaluable guidance throughout the process of writing this Note, and Kate Rumsey and Judy Harvey, along with the rest of the staff of The New York University Journal of Legislation and Public Policy, for their assistance. Special thanks to Anne Porr, Debbie Boyce, Karen Ristuccia, and, of course, her husband, David.
[Show full text]