I the Right Kind of Music: Fundamentalist Christianity As

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

I the Right Kind of Music: Fundamentalist Christianity As The Right Kind of Music: Fundamentalist Christianity as Musical and Cultural Practice by Sarah Bereza Department of Music Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Philip Rupprecht, Supervisor ___________________________ Louise Meintjes ___________________________ Jacqueline Waeber ___________________________ Jeremy Begbie Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Music in the Graduate School of Duke University 2017 i v ABSTRACT The Right Kind of Music: Fundamentalist Christianity as Musical and Cultural Practice by Sarah Bereza Department of Music Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Philip Rupprecht, Supervisor ___________________________ Louise Meintjes ___________________________ Jacqueline Waeber ___________________________ Jeremy Begbie An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Music in the Graduate School of Duke University 2017 i v Copyright by Sarah Bereza 2017 Abstract Fundamentalist Christians loosely affiliated with Bob Jones University (Greenville, SC) teach that music influences listeners’ faith and moral characters for both good and evil, expounding their views since the evangelical Worship Wars began in the 1960s over the use of popular music styles in church services. In their dichotomous moral view, good music reveals God’s nature, allowing born-again listeners to draw closer to God and witness their salvation to unbelievers, and bad music pulls listeners away from God by promoting immorality and false worship. Fundamentalists also prioritize mental engagement with music over emotional and physical responses to it because they believe that people more directly relate to God through their conscious minds and only indirectly with their bodies, as when fundamentalist musicians make music with their bodies, an activity that they believe glorifies God. Considering their discourse and practices from ethnographic and theological perspectives, I argue that these reveal a view that all musical sound is dangerous in its insistent entrance into listeners’ bodies: music is like fire—useful under control but devastating if unrestrained. I examine the outworkings of their beliefs in three primary areas: recorded music, congregational singing (both aloud and silent as congregants practice inner singing while listening to instrumental hymn arrangements), and solo and soloistic vocal music. Musicians’ invisibility on recordings underscores how fundamentalists’ iv beliefs are primarily about musical sound, not performers’ movements or appearances. Robust congregational singing reflects believers’ “joy of salvation,” but their collective emotional affects are limited, and they are physically constrained to small movements that almost never bloom into something fuller. Finally, although fundamentalist leaders consider classical music and its associated performance practice to be “excellent,” even this musical style must be restrained for classically trained vocalists to minister in their churches. These arguments are based on my fieldwork and my analyses of fundamentalists’ extensive written and recorded discourse on music. v Contents Abstract ......................................................................................................................................... iv List of Tables ................................................................................................................................. xi List of Figures .............................................................................................................................. xii Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................... xiii Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 1 The Perceived Effects of Religious Belief on Sacred Music ............................................... 9 Methodological Approaches ............................................................................................... 13 Fieldwork Overview ............................................................................................................. 18 Interpreting the Public and Private Views of BJU Employees ....................................... 20 A Fundamental Church Service .......................................................................................... 25 1. Separation as the Impetus for Fundamentalists’ Musical Subculture ............................. 33 Music and the Slippery Slope into Compromise .............................................................. 40 Music and Compromise at BJU ......................................................................................... 44 Separation and the Creation of Fundamentalist Subculture .......................................... 51 Denominational Surrogacy and Music at BJU ................................................................ 57 Institutional Reputation of BJU ......................................................................................... 62 The Worship Wars ................................................................................................................ 69 Secondary Separation’s Implications on Music and Its Associations ......................... 76 2. Fundamentalists’ Philosophy of Music ................................................................................ 84 Historical and Cultural Contexts to Fundamentalists’ Philosophy of Music .............. 86 vi Christian Thought on Music’s Moral Influence .............................................................. 87 Moral Associations of Music in the United States .......................................................... 93 Sources of Fundamentalist Music Philosophy .................................................................. 98 Music as a Communicative Moral Agent ........................................................................ 103 Black and White Morality ................................................................................................ 107 Music as a Mirror of God’s Nature ................................................................................. 111 Decoding Musical Elements .............................................................................................. 114 The Relative Importance and Intelligibility of Lyrics .................................................. 119 Criteria for Secular Lyrics ................................................................................................ 121 Criteria for Sacred Lyrics ................................................................................................. 125 Decoding Music Itself ....................................................................................................... 127 The Meanings of Specific Musical Elements ................................................................. 135 The New Song ...................................................................................................................... 138 When the Mind Is Most Important ................................................................................... 148 A Trichotomous Human Being ....................................................................................... 148 Further Thinking on Neoplatonism ............................................................................... 160 3. Corporate Worship in Fundamental Church Services ..................................................... 169 Congregational Music and the Importance of “Right” Worship ................................. 174 Competing Views on the Purpose of the Song Service ............................................... 180 Influences on the Shape and Planning of the Song Service ........................................ 186 The Pastoral Role of Music Directors ............................................................................. 188 The Core Repertoire of Fundamentalist Hymnody ....................................................... 191 vii Standard Repertoire of Hymnals Popular in Fundamental Churches ...................... 192 Gospel Songs ...................................................................................................................... 196 Newer Songs ...................................................................................................................... 198 Hymnals and Their Supplements ................................................................................... 201 The Joyful Sound of Congregational Singing ................................................................. 206 Joy in Trials ........................................................................................................................ 209 Leadership of Congregational Singing ............................................................................ 216 Directives to Sing and Praise of Singing ........................................................................ 219 Piano Accompaniment of Singing .................................................................................. 222 Tempo and Durations ....................................................................................................... 227 Interpreting a Hymn for Congregational
Recommended publications
  • Download CD Booklet
    The Cambridge Singers Christmas Album directed by JOHN RUTTER AROLS AND CHRISTMAS MUSIC have always formed a part of the CCambridge Singers’ recorded repertoire, and this album picks out some of my The Cambridge Singers personal favourites. Most of the 23 items are taken from the two albums Christmas with the Cambridge Singers and Christmas Day in the Morning, and there are four previously unreleased tracks which were squeezed out of those two albums and which I am happy Christmas Album to have found space for here. There are three strands to the programme: traditional carols; choruses and motets; and composers’ carols. In fact these categories are not as separate as they might appear. Composers have always loved to take traditional melodies and incorporate them into their own compositions, sometimes considerably elaborating them in the process: think of all those L’homme armé masses or of Bach’s chorale treatments. The art of the arranger, widely thought of as a twentieth-century invention, is as old as composition itself. When we listen to a ‘traditional’ carol sung by a choir, we are in fact generally hear- ing the work of an identifiable composer who has arranged, in his own style, a melody by an unidentifiable or obscure composer from an earlier era. The earliest examples on this album are Victoria’s O magnum mysterium (1572), a four-voiced motet where the melodic outlines are based on a Gregorian chant, and Scheidt’s In dulci jubilo (1620), which takes one of the best-loved of all Christmas carols and turns it into a resplendent double-choir motet with two antiphonal trumpet parts.
    [Show full text]
  • Producing an a Cappella CD and Development of a Pitch Detection Program
    A Guide to Producing An A Cappella CD and Development of a Pitch Detection Program A Senior Project submitted in partial fulfillment of requirements for the Bachelor of Arts Degree in Liberal Arts and Engineering Studies By Jacob Ray Stringfellow Liberal Arts and Engineering Studies Department College of Engineering California Polytechnic State University San Luis Obispo Spring Quarter, 2012 Abstract An in-depth look at the steps required to produce a CD for an a cappella group. From what microphone and preamplifiers to use, to what steps to take during the editing, mixing, and mastering processes. Finished with a look at pitch detection algorithms and how they work, and a little bit of experimentation with my own algorithm and program. 1. Introduction We live in a world that is filled with music. This music comes in different varieties ranging from hip-hop and rap to country and classical. One genre of music that seems to be on the rise now a day is that of a cappella, or singing without instruments. With shows such as America’s Got Talent showcasing collegiate a cappella groups, and shows like the Sing Off that focus on a cappella singing, it seems that collegiate a cappella groups are reaching a peak in popularity. With a cappella groups being formed, and music being performed, there is also a rising demand to record their music. This presents an interesting challenge. Getting your a cappella group’s song recorded professionally can be costly, and on college student budgets it can be hard to afford. That being said, I suggest that there is a solution to this problem.
    [Show full text]
  • Sydney Program Guide
    4/23/2021 prtten04.networkten.com.au:7778/pls/DWHPROD/Program_Reports.Dsp_SHAKE_Guide?psStartDate=09-May-21&psEndDate=15-… SYDNEY PROGRAM GUIDE Sunday 09th May 2021 06:00 am Totally Wild CC C Get inspired by all-access stories from the wild side of life! 06:30 am Top Wing (Rpt) G Rod's Beary Brave Save / Race Through Danger Canyon Rod proves that he is a rooster (and not a chicken) as he finds a cub named Baby Bear lost in the Haunted Cave. A jet-flying bat roars into Danger Canyon to show off his prowess. 07:00 am Blaze And The Monster Machines (Rpt) G Treasure Track Blaze, AJ, and Gabby join Pegwheel the Pirate-Truck for an island treasure hunt! Following their treasure map, the friends search jungle beaches and mountains to find where X marks the spot. 07:30 am Paw Patrol (Rpt) G Pups Save The Runaway Turtles / Pups Save The Shivering Sheep Daring Danny X accidently drives off with turtle eggs that Cap'n Turbot had hoped to photograph while hatching. Farmer Al's sheep-shearing machine malfunctions and all his sheep run away. 07:56 am Shake Takes 08:00 am Paw Patrol (Rpt) G Sea Patrol: Pups Save A Frozen Flounder / Pups Save A Narwhal Cap'n Turbot's boat gets frozen in the Arctic Ice. The pups use the Sea Patroller to help guide a lost narwhal back home. 08:30 am The Loud House (Rpt) G Lincoln Loud: Girl Guru / Come Sale Away For a class assignment Lincoln and Clyde must start a business.
    [Show full text]
  • BFI CELEBRATES BRITISH FILM at CANNES British Entry for Cannes 2011 Official Competition We’Ve Got to Talk About Kevin Dir
    London May 10 2011: For immediate release BFI CELEBRATES BRITISH FILM AT CANNES British entry for Cannes 2011 Official Competition We’ve Got to Talk About Kevin dir. Lynne Ramsay UK Film Centre supports delegates with packed events programme 320 British films for sale in the market A Clockwork Orange in Cannes Classics The UK film industry comes to Cannes celebrating the selection of Lynne Ramsay’s We Need to Talk About Kevin for the official competition line-up at this year’s festival, Duane Hopkins’s short film, Cigarette at Night, in the Directors’ Fortnight and the restoration of Stanley Kubrick’s A Clockwork Orange, restored by Warner Bros; in Cannes Classics. Lynne Ramsay’s We Need To Talk About Kevin starring Tilda Swinton was co-funded by the UK Film Council, whose film funding activities have now transferred to the BFI. Duane Hopkins is a director who was supported by the UK Film Council with his short Love Me and Leave Me Alone and his first feature Better Things. Actor Malcolm McDowell will be present for the screening of A Clockwork Orange. ITV Studios’ restoration of A Night to Remember will be screened in the Cinema on the Beach, complete with deckchairs. British acting talent will be seen in many films across the festival including Carey Mulligan in competition film Drive, and Tom Hiddleston & Michael Sheen in Woody Allen's opening night Midnight in Paris The UK Film Centre offers a unique range of opportunities for film professionals, with events that include Tilda Swinton, Lynne Ramsay and Luc Roeg discussing We Need to Talk About Kevin, The King’s Speech producers Iain Canning and Gareth Unwin discussing the secrets of the film’s success, BBC Film’s Christine Langan In the Spotlight and directors Nicolas Winding Refn and Shekhar Kapur in conversation.
    [Show full text]
  • Lecture Outlines
    CHAPTER FOURTEEN: “SMELLS LIKE TEEN SPIRIT”: HIP-HOP, “ALTERNATIVE” MUSIC, AND THE ENTERTAINMENT BUSINESS Lecture Outlines Lecture 1: Hip-Hop and Techno I. Hip-Hop Breaks Out (1980s–1990s) A. In the mid-1980s, rap moved into the popular mainstream. B. 1986 saw the release of the first two multiplatinum rap albums: 1. Raising Hell by Run-D.M.C. a) Number Three on Billboard’s pop albums chart b) Over three million copies sold 2. Licensed to Ill by the Beastie Boys a) Number One for seven weeks b) Over seven million copies sold 3. Expansion of the audience for hip-hop music was the key to the commercial success of these albums. a) Included millions of young white fans, attracted by the rebelliousness of the genre C. Both Raising Hell and Licensed to Ill were released on a new independent label called Def Jam. CHAPTER FOURTEEN: “SMELLS LIKE TEEN SPIRIT”: HIP-HOP, “ALTERNATIVE” MUSIC, AND THE ENTERTAINMENT BUSINESS 1. Co-founded in 1984 by the hip-hop promoter Russell Simmons and the musician-producer Rick Rubin 2. Cross-promoting a new generation of artists 3. Expanding and diversifying the national audience for hip-hop 4. In 1986, Def Jam became the first rap-oriented independent label to sign a distribution deal with one of the “Big Five” record companies, Columbia Records. D. Run-D.M.C. 1. Trio: a) MCs Run (Joseph Simmons, b. 1964) and D.M.C. (Darryl McDaniels, b. 1964) b) DJ Jam Master Jay (Jason Mizell, b. 1965) 2. Adidas Corporation and Run-D.M.C.
    [Show full text]
  • Leading Congregational Singing Song/Hymn Leading Is an Important
    Leading Congregational Singing LEADING AS A VOCALIST - Joyce Poley DEVELOPING A STYLE Song/hymn leading is an important skill that can make an enormous difference to the way a congregation sings. If the song leader is primarily a vocalist, there are a number of qualities that are important for success: having enthusiasm for singing; being able to establish a good rapport with the congregation; being comfortable with your own voice; having accurate pitch and a pleasing vocal quality; being excited about introducing new ideas and repertoire. These attributes will help ensure a good singing experience for both the leader and the congregation. Song/hymn leaders use a variety of approaches when leading the congregation, and no single approach or style is “right”. What is important is to develop a style that is unique to your own personality and comfort level. The following are some things to consider: • Energy & enthusiasm Probably nothing affects your success as a song leader as much as your own energy and enthusiasm. People respond to those who love what they do; enthusiasm truly is contagious. Those who already enjoy singing will simply become even more enthusiastic; those who are more reluctant, or feel they can’t sing, will want to be a part of all this positive energy. The more encouragement they get from the leader, the better they will sing. The better they sing, the more confident they become, and the more willing to try new things. Enjoy yourself and be at ease, and they will journey almost any distance with you into the music.
    [Show full text]
  • Emotional and Linguistic Analysis of Dialogue from Animated Comedies: Homer, Hank, Peter and Kenny Speak
    Emotional and Linguistic Analysis of Dialogue from Animated Comedies: Homer, Hank, Peter and Kenny Speak. by Rose Ann Ko2inski Thesis presented as a partial requirement in the Master of Arts (M.A.) in Human Development School of Graduate Studies Laurentian University Sudbury, Ontario © Rose Ann Kozinski, 2009 Library and Archives Bibliotheque et 1*1 Canada Archives Canada Published Heritage Direction du Branch Patrimoine de I'edition 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington OttawaONK1A0N4 OttawaONK1A0N4 Canada Canada Your file Votre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-57666-3 Our file Notre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-57666-3 NOTICE: AVIS: The author has granted a non­ L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive exclusive license allowing Library and permettant a la Bibliotheque et Archives Archives Canada to reproduce, Canada de reproduire, publier, archiver, publish, archive, preserve, conserve, sauvegarder, conserver, transmettre au public communicate to the public by par telecommunication ou par I'lnternet, prefer, telecommunication or on the Internet, distribuer et vendre des theses partout dans le loan, distribute and sell theses monde, a des fins commerciales ou autres, sur worldwide, for commercial or non­ support microforme, papier, electronique et/ou commercial purposes, in microform, autres formats. paper, electronic and/or any other formats. The author retains copyright L'auteur conserve la propriete du droit d'auteur ownership and moral rights in this et des droits moraux qui protege cette these. Ni thesis. Neither the thesis nor la these ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci substantial extracts from it may be ne doivent etre imprimes ou autrement printed or otherwise reproduced reproduits sans son autorisation.
    [Show full text]
  • Capitalizing on My African American Christian Heritage in the Cultivation
    Masthead Logo Digital Commons @ George Fox University Doctor of Ministry Theses and Dissertations 2-1-2019 Capitalizing on my African American Christian Heritage in the Cultivation of Spiritual Formation and Contemplative Spiritual Disciplines Claire Appiah [email protected] This research is a product of the Doctor of Ministry (DMin) program at George Fox University. Find out more about the program. Recommended Citation Appiah, Claire, "Capitalizing on my African American Christian Heritage in the Cultivation of Spiritual Formation and Contemplative Spiritual Disciplines" (2019). Doctor of Ministry. 288. https://digitalcommons.georgefox.edu/dmin/288 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Digital Commons @ George Fox University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctor of Ministry by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ George Fox University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. GEORGE FOX UNIVERSITY CAPITALIZING ON MY AFRICAN AMERICAN CHRISTIAN HERITAGE IN THE CULTIVATION OF SPIRITUAL FORMATION AND CONTEMPLATIVE SPIRITUAL DISCIPLINES A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF PORTLAND SEMINARY IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF MINISTRY BY CLAIRE APPIAH PORTLAND, OREGON FEBRUARY, 2019 Portland Seminary George Fox University Portland, Oregon CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL ________________________________ DMin Dissertation ________________________________ This is to certify that the DMin Dissertation of Claire Appiah has been approved by the Dissertation Committee on February 21, 2019 for the degree of Doctor of Ministry in Leadership and Global Perspectives Dissertation Committee: Primary Advisor: Clifford Berger, DMin Secondary Advisor: Carlos Jermaine Richard, DMin Lead Mentor: Jason Clark, PhD, DMin Expert Advisor: Clifford Berger, DMin Copyright © 2019 by Claire Appiah All rights reserved All quotations from the Bible are from the King James Version.
    [Show full text]
  • The Slow Integration of Instruments Into Christian Worship
    Musical Offerings Volume 8 Number 1 Spring 2017 Article 2 3-28-2017 From Silence to Golden: The Slow Integration of Instruments into Christian Worship Jonathan M. Lyons Cedarville University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/musicalofferings Part of the Christianity Commons, Fine Arts Commons, Liturgy and Worship Commons, Musicology Commons, and the Music Performance Commons DigitalCommons@Cedarville provides a publication platform for fully open access journals, which means that all articles are available on the Internet to all users immediately upon publication. However, the opinions and sentiments expressed by the authors of articles published in our journals do not necessarily indicate the endorsement or reflect the views of DigitalCommons@Cedarville, the Centennial Library, or Cedarville University and its employees. The authors are solely responsible for the content of their work. Please address questions to [email protected]. Recommended Citation Lyons, Jonathan M. (2017) "From Silence to Golden: The Slow Integration of Instruments into Christian Worship," Musical Offerings: Vol. 8 : No. 1 , Article 2. DOI: 10.15385/jmo.2017.8.1.2 Available at: https://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/musicalofferings/vol8/iss1/2 From Silence to Golden: The Slow Integration of Instruments into Christian Worship Document Type Article Abstract The Christian church’s stance on the use of instruments in sacred music shifted through influences of church leaders, composers, and secular culture. Synthesizing the writings of early church leaders and church historians reveals a clear progression. The early musical practices of the church were connected to the Jewish synagogues. As recorded in the Old Testament, Jewish worship included instruments as assigned by one’s priestly tribe.
    [Show full text]
  • Music for Contemporary Christians: What, Where, and When?
    Journal of the Adventist Theological Society, 13/1 (Spring 2002): 184Ð209. Article copyright © 2002 by Ed Christian. Music for Contemporary Christians: What, Where, and When? Ed Christian Kutztown University of Pennsylvania What music is appropriate for Christians? What music is appropriate in worship? Is there a difference between music appropriate in church and music appropriate in a youth rally or concert? Is there a difference between lyrics ap- propriate for congregational singing and lyrics appropriate for a person to sing or listen to in private? Are some types of music inherently inappropriate for evangelism?1 These are important questions. Congregations have fought over them and even split over them.2 The answers given have often alienated young people from the church and even driven them to reject God. Some answers have rejuve- nated congregations; others have robbed congregations of vitality and shackled the work of the Holy Spirit. In some churches the great old hymns havenÕt been heard in years. Other churches came late to the Òpraise musicÓ wars, and music is still a controversial topic. Here, where praise music is found in the church service, it is probably accompanied by a single guitar or piano and sung without a trace of the enthusi- asm, joy, emotion, and repetition one hears when it is used in charismatic churches. Many churches prefer to use no praise choruses during the church service, some use nothing but praise choruses, and perhaps the majority use a mixture. What I call (with a grin) Òrock ÔnÕ roll church,Ó where such instruments 1 Those who have recently read my article ÒThe Christian & Rock Music: A Review-Essay,Ó may turn at once to the section headed ÒThe Scriptural Basis.Ó Those who havenÕt read it should read on.
    [Show full text]
  • Magnificat: Vocal Score Free
    FREE MAGNIFICAT: VOCAL SCORE PDF John Rutter | 88 pages | 01 Aug 1991 | Oxford University Press | 9780193380370 | English, Latin | Oxford, United Kingdom Vocal Score for Rutter Magnificat : Choraline For soprano or mezzo-soprano Magnificat: Vocal Score, SATB chorus and either full orchestra or chamber orchestra. Minimum recommended string forces for the chamber ensemble are 2. This edition is a publication of Oxford University Press. Full scores, vocal scores, and instrumental parts are available on hire through Oxford University Press. Home Music scores and recordings. John Rutter Magnificat. Add to wishlist. Feedback Be the first to give feedback on this product. Proceed to purchase. Additional product information. He first came to notice as a composer during his student years; much of his early work consisted of church music and other choral pieces including Christmas carols. From —79 he was Director of Music at his alma mater, Clare College, and directed the college chapel choir in various recordings and broadcasts. Since he has divided his time between composition and conducting. Today his compositions, including such concert-length works as RequiemMagnificat Magnificat: Vocal Score, Mass of the ChildrenThe Gift of Lifeand Visions are performed around the world. His music has featured in a number of British royal Magnificat: Vocal Score, including the two most recent royal weddings. In he formed his Magnificat: Vocal Score choir the Cambridge Singers, with whom he has made numerous Magnificat: Vocal Score, and he appears regularly in several countries as guest conductor and choral ambassador. Personal details. You have to be logged in to write a feedback. Magnificat: Vocal Score questions about this work There are no questions and answers available so far or you were unable to find an answer to your specific question about this work? Then click here and send your specific questions to our Customer Services! Related products.
    [Show full text]
  • Augustinian Christian Philosophy
    AUGUSTINIAN CHRISTIAN PHILOSOPHY How does Christianity bear on philosophy? Is there such a thing as Christian philosophy, or are there only Christians who are also philoso­ phers? How should Christianity and philosophy be related? Should they be related? In "Advice to Christian Philosophers" I said that Christian philosophers should display more autonomy: they have their own fish to fry, their own projects to pursue, (or their own axes to grind, as some might prefer to put it). Here I want to say more about what these projects (or fish, or axes) are like. And the right way to think about these matters, so it seems to me, is broadly Augustinian. Accordingly, I want to propose a program­ matic sketch (a very programmatic sketch) of a conception of Christian philosophy that grows out of some central Augustinian emphases. I don't claim, however, that Augustine in fact thought of Christian philosophy the way I shall suggest. The primary focus of my paper is not historical (that would in any event be beyond my competence); what I want to do is make a suggestion as to how we should think about Christian philosophy now; but this way of thinking of the matter grows out of Augustinian roots.! It's worth noting, furthermore, that what is at issue is not just a way of thinking about Christianity and philosophy, but about Christianity and scholarship more generally. There are at least four elements in Augustinian Christian philosophy. The first two of these are widely recognized and relatively uncontroversial: I shall therefore be brief about them.
    [Show full text]