An Eye for the Ladies

SI March April 2010 pgs:SI J A 2009 1/22/10 11:47 AM Page 29 SCIENCE WATCH K E N N E T H W. K R A U S E An Eye for the Ladies volutionary scientists made 2009 a Carnegie Museum of Natural History in megacanina. Ganlea possessed a distinc- remarkable year for the fairer sex. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, declared, “Ida’s tive feeding adaptation characteristic of ELet’s start with Darwinius masil - a fine fossil, but she’s not the missing modern saki monkeys from the Amazon lae—remember “Ida”? On May 19 the link.” Arguing that she “fails miserably” Basin of South America: an extremely world was introduced to the purported to display any anthropoid features that large canine tooth used to pry open tough “missing link” between primitive pri- evolved after that group’s split from tropical fruits to access their seeds. mates and humans—an exceptionally well-preserved, forty-seven-million-year- old cat-sized fossil belonging to an extinct branch of early primates called adapiforms. As an international team led by Jo/rn Hurum of the University of Oslo, Norway, released the PLoS One paper, Ida was ceremoniously unveiled to an enthu- siastic audience that included New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg at the American Museum of Natural History. A book and documentary film, both dub - bed The Link, quickly followed. Hurum claimed that although Ida m o c plainly resembled some prosimians s w e N (lemurs, tarsiers, and their extinct ances- : o t o h tors), her fossil also revealed anthropoid- P like (and thus human-like) features, The Ida fossil. This species was thought to be at the root of anthropoid evolution, when primates were first devel- including a partially fused lower mandible oping the features that would evolve into our own. and a foot bone called a talus. She also other primates, Beard bluntly character- Compared to adapiforms like Ida, Beard lacked the “toothcomb” and “grooming ized the Ida unveiling as “unbridled concluded, Asian amphipithecids like claw” more typical of lemurs. Because she hoopla” and warned his fellow scientists Ganlea were much stronger candidates for was recovered from an oil shale pit in against having their work “evaluated on the coveted title of ancestors to the Messel, Germany, Hurum’s team argued the same basis as the advertising cam- anthropoids. that Ida also challenged the more conven- paign for the next world tour of the tional wisdom that anthropoids had orig- Rolling Stones.” Kenneth W. Krause is a contributing edi- inated in Africa. On July 1 Beard published an article tor and science news columnist for the But criticism rained fast and furiously in the online Proceedings of the Royal SKEP TICAL INQUIRER, and a contributing on Ida’s well-publicized parade. In the Society B that introduced a thirty-eight- editor and books editor/columnist for the May 30 New Scientist, Chris Beard, cura- million-year-old fossil primate from My - Hu manist. He may be contacted at tor of vertebrate paleontology at the anmar (formerly Burma) called Gan lea krausekc@msn.com. SKEPTICAL INQUIRER March / Ap ril 2010 29 SI March April 2010 pgs:SI J A 2009 1/22/10 11:47 AM Page 30 In “Weak Link,” Kate Wong’s short brightly upon two much younger ladies— eclipse the ever-brightening limelight piece in the August issue of Scientific one from Aramis, Ethi opia, and the other cast upon the little lady of Flores, Indo - American, Robert Martin from the Field from the Indonesian island of Flores. nesia, known as LB1. About a meter tall Museum in Chicago and Richard Kay Clocking in at about 4.4 million with a chimp-sized brain, LB1 and her from the paleontology department at years old, Ardipithecus ramidus may rev- fellow “hobbits” were recovered late in Duke University piled on to the now- olutionize our long-held assumptions 2003 from Liang Bua cave sediments crowded anti-Ida bandwagon. Martin about the evolution of bipedality and dating from 95,000 to 15,000 years ago pointed out that fused lower jaws had the physiology of the six million year old (see my article, “Pathology or Paradigm evolved independently in several other last common ancestor between humans Shift?” SI, July/August 2009). From the mammals, including lemurs, but were and chimpanzees. “Ardi,” a fairly com- beginning, a small minority of scientists not present in the earliest anthropoids. plete skeleton found among thirty-six or have disputed the majority’s conclusion Like Beard, Kay judged that fossil evi- more individual African specimens, did- that LB1 represents Homo floresiensis, a dence of primitive Asian primates n’t knuckle-walk or swing through the species entirely separate from our own. proved that the lady from Messel was trees like an ape. Instead, she probably These detractors have hypothesized that not a direct ancestor of monkeys, apes, walked upright on the ground but also the hobbits are merely pygmoid or or humans. used her opposable big toes to negotiate pathological H. sapiens, and what re - Finally, in the October 22 Nature, a intermediate tree limbs on all fours. mains of the debate has, unfortunately, team led by Erik Seiffert at Stony Brook Ardi is one of just six skeletons dated grown somewhat venomous. University in New York compared the to more than a million years old and the Even so, the new-species proponents fossil traits of two adapiforms, Ida and the only one older than Lucy (Australo - have recently fortified their position. Indeed, the Journal of Human Evolution devoted an entire edition to more evidence and arguments in favor of H. floresiensis. Guest-edited by Michael Mor - wood, LB1’s Australian co-discoverer, The gods of paleoanthropology appear to be and William Jungers, a prominent an - smiling brightly upon two much younger ladies atomist at Stony Brook University, the November 2009 issue featured peer- —one from Aramis, Ethiopia, and the other reviewed articles analyzing much of the from the Indonesian island of Flores. hobbits’ tiny bodies, including their brains, teeth, mandibles, and limbs, along with their stone-flaking technol- ogy and environmental milieu. Doubtless, the evolutionary stakes over the Flores hominins are extremely high. thirty-seven-million-year-old Afra dapis pithecus afarensis) to be published. Tim Conventional wisdom has long held, first, longicristatus, to those of more than one White and others from the Middle that the Neanderthals were the last group hundred other living and extinct pri- Awash research group discovered these of hominins to cohabit the earth with H. mates. After evaluating 360 morphologi- wonderful fossils beginning in Decem - sapiens and, second, that no human cal features, Seiffert concluded that ber 1992. But only recently were eleven species had ventured from the confines although the adapiforms shared certain papers and author summaries dissecting of Africa prior to H. erectus. The hobbits traits with anthropoids—the loss of a the amazing details of Ardi’s anantomy, effectively challenge both paradigms, third upper and lower premolar, for diet, habitat, and evolutionary signifi- according to Jungers and his co-worker example—those characteristics had arisen cance finally released in the October 2, Karen Baab. In the December 2009 issue more than once among primates and were 2009, Science. An “unpredicted and odd of Significance, they discuss evidence “most parsimoniously interpreted as evo- mosaic,” writes White’s team, Ar. ramidus suggesting that LB1 may have descended lutionary convergences.” Ida was not a “is so rife with anatomical surprises that from a species much smaller and more haplorhine anthropoid, in other words, no one could have imagined it without ancient than H. erectus. but rather a strepsirrhine (a group includ- direct fossil evidence.” Ardi’s discovery Statistical analyses of skull shapes, for ing lemurs and lorises) that “left no was named Breakthrough of the Year in example, “find modern humans in one known descendants.” the December 18 Science. Deserving far grouping,” the authors say, “micro- Hurum’s team continues to defend more attention than I can deliver here, cephalic humans in another, and the Ida’s status as the so-called “missing link,” Ardi and her captivating cohorts will be hobbit, together with ancient hominins, but her claim to fame appears to be falling featured more prominently in an upcom- in a third.” They found that hobbit bod- on increasingly deaf ears. Even so, the gods ing issue of the SKEPTICAL INQUIRER. ies were unique too. The Flores speci- of paleoanthropology appear to be smiling But no fossil hominin’s gleam can mens were “far stockier” than any mod- 30 Volume 34, Issue 2 SKEPTICAL INQUIRER SI March April 2010 pgs:SI J A 2009 1/22/10 11:47 AM Page 31 ern human, including pygmies, and which are associated with fertility and But we shouldn’t be too surprised if although their arms were about the same intelligence. By comparison, the tiny Y over the next few centuries or so we notice length as those of pygmies, their legs chromosome stores just eighty-nine that the ladies sitting at those tables have were much shorter. To Jungers and genes and the average autosome only begun to change. In an attempt to show Baab, this peculiar ratio implies an evo- about eight hundred genes. Second, that natural selection continues to mold lutionary retention rather than a reversal because of how the X is passed down the human species despite modern medi- because selective forces would probably between generations, some grandmas are cine’s benign and insulating influences, not reverse more economical features biologically closer to some grandkids and that we can predict changes to spe- like long limbs.

Load more