Lybrand, Ross Bros. & Montgomery
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY 1898 -1948: - Privately Printed LYBRAND, ROSS BROS. & 'MONTGOMERY This Issue of the L. R. B. &M. JOURNAL is Dedicated to the Founders of the Firm of LYBRAND, ROSS BROS. & MONTGOMERY by their Partners and Fellow Workers Table of Contents Foreword .......................... ' . .. ... 5 Fifty Years. 7 In Memoriam-Adam Averell Ross.... .. .. 13 Firm Meetings ............................. ' ..... 17 Opportunities Then and Now.. .. ......... 19 Professional Activities. .. 22 Contributions to the Literature of Accounting. 29 Nonprofessional Activities.. .. 35 World War 11...... .. 40 Some Effects of S. E. C. Legislation. 44 Staff Education, Selection and Training. .. 46 Staff Activities. 53 In Memoriam-Other Partners. .. .. 63 L. R. B. & M. JOURNAL. .. .. 68 A Few Unusual Engagements... .. 70 Published Articles of Lasting Interest. .. 86 Professional Standards. .. 87 To What Extent Can the Practice of Accounting Be Reduced to Rules and Standards? . 99 Ripley V. Winkle ..................................... 113 Professional Accounting Practice Today and Tomorrow. .. 121 The Certified Public Accountant on the Threshold of his Second Half Century. .. ............. 129 Epilogue-A Challenge... 138 Bibliography. 139 Foreword Every phase of the economic cycle has been encountered by the firm in the fifty years of its existence. There have been three wars, each accompanied by the artificial stimulus of war production, periods of normal prosperity, boom times, and at least three depres sions. Throughout these years there has been a steady growth in the accountancy profession with ever increasing responsibility. The requirements of credit grantors, investors and stock ex changes for the review of financial statements and the expression of opinion thereon by independent certified public accountants have vastly increased; we have seen the enactment of tax legislation undreamed of fifty years ago with its resulting impact upon the business world and the work of the accountant; federal and state securities laws have come into being; and a host of other develop ments have occurred, each tending to increase the responsibility o carried by the profession. Perfection has not been achieved by the accountant, nor will it ever be; the profession's continued growth, however, is dependent upon its continuous effort to achieve that goal. An outlook analogous to that held by the accounting profession was expressed by the late eminent jurist, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., who, speaking of the legal profession, said: The truth is. that the law is always approaching, and never reaching, consistency. It is forever adopting new principles from life at one end, and it always retains old ones from history at the other, which have not yet been absorbed or sloughed off. It will become entirely consistent only when it ceases to grow. The firm has had its share in the growth of the profession. Our partners and staff members have participated in the promotion of accountancy education and by their writings have contributed to the literature of the profession. They have taken, and will continue to take, an active part in the functioning of state and national societies. T. EDWABO Ross ROBERT H. MONTGOMERY WILLIAM M. LYBRAND Asheville. North Carolina - September 1948 Fifty Years The firm of Lybrand, Ross Bros. & Montgomery was founded in Philadelphia on January 1, 1898. The four original members, who had been friends and associates for almost ten years, were William M. Lybrand, T. Edward Ross, Adam A. Ross and Robert H. Montgomery. All had been associated with the late John Heins, a pioneer public accountant in Philadelphia, and one of the ablest men in the accounting profession in the nation. Mr. Adam Ross died in 1929. It is most gratifying that the other founders have been able to carryon their association in the firm for five decades. At its inception the organization comprised the four partners, one staff member and a clerical assistant. The staff member, Joseph M. Pugh, became a partner in 1904. Duties of secretary, typist and bookkeeper were performed by the sister of the Ross brothers, Miss Lillian A. Ross, who retired forty-six years later. I r-~~ L? /. M,~ :':/--Z~uz~;~A~a, 314' ~-""'7 _/.,fy-' E (ibt (~intrll l!.tfr Jn611r.mn'.1\nnltit!! .f [~6t ([tUnvan~. 01 Jlllllflcholpilitt. X}?~/£Ph~»~i; J~.~ tI-,~ 1_:'7 C. ~, _h. 3>£... 0) 7-' ---- ~ HM. ---- :ff*.-t'h;/,'j' -Ifts- ~ __ ,_,"~;.-t.. ..... tt._~ ~ rl;l~..L' Two of the firm's earliest checks, which were drawn one month after its founding, are shown above, 8 FiJty Years The first check was to reimburse Mr. T. Edward Ross for expenses incurred by him and three assistants in traveling to and from Jeddo, Pennsylvania, for the account of G. B. Markle & Company. The second check was for the purchase oLstationery. Two small rooms in the Stephen Girard Building comprised the first office of the firm. Indicative of the furniture and equipment in use at that time is the inventory shown on page 9 which was taken by Mr. Adam A. Ross on April 1, 1898. The oak roll-top desk which was valued at $35 served the four partners, and the six-foot standing desk was for the use of the staff. On page 11 is pictured an inventory of the bQoks which comprised the firm's library, which inventory was also taken by Mr. Adam A. Ross on April 1, 1898. It is interesting to note that the only two publications on accounting were "The Accountant" for the years 1893 to 1896 and Volume I of "The American Accountants Manual." Contrast this modest collec tion with the many thousands of books in the libraries of our offices throughout the nation today! On June 1, 1902, the firm sent to its clients in Philadelphia an announcement of the forthcoming opening of an office in New York City. A copy of the announcement appears below: LYBRAND.ROSS BROS.& MONTGOMERY SI6-SI~ STEPHEN GIRARD BUILDING CERTIFIED PUBL.IC ACCOUNTANTS PHILADELPHIA I~!..JUNE 1902 0lf <r {(Ji af.kA:e, I ""7 ~ ~ drJt... - r.Kv- . ·5 tkLIZ c~ Jq 4.,A, d~ n.<--~~7 h.~ c-c..~ ,h~(l1 I~ l ·C&.4.k ~.J-. I ,.l<.r. dA"'~""'-<V<f ". J ., "'-"-.t. ~~·V":'-~ -,. , I ~ 0 I ().8.-1( . /<.CAr o-C--'1 t.- It.=""-.... "-"'- 1{" .. w,L... Ll/fH.<A.~~~t;. -I """'f,.c." eeL .J I q 2,.. , . .1 {)~tJ( {,./fo "", .. <-1£. ~ ~~ , ': • 5 I f~';-;- , " . (J. • I t", ,,~'/ A:,."-",,, 'tah.-tc ' ,fC 4,,/" ' .(, R . J. I JV~'" C""~'/ A .... ~ {" ~ ., I" _ ( t.. ~.J f-( (.j, I," & ! {" ,.~,< , /' n •. " '''/Li!..t..; " 8 . ~ ';r'W~+ 7 'f/~/i, :-. ...,. I- "-, '·r/".J'fl7 iw. r-~ .L I SfeLl '/-"_;' "(4. ~ I!#.<..a....~ , I /l.a.-I- "-~ '- ,.;- I ;; ....... vt ~....,-t..A<- I (I(,. .... ~-"..C!.(!f..... _4.1 ~J..../ Cec-<L{<. ( w~_(1£) ~~.f( ~ _ ",1...,J. ddt... _ l-L ....~ .) - Ce.....u._~el J.~",-£c ~,('~ ~f~' :~_Q,..v :L !>-.. - .~.;;t:; ':'~/J ,;) . j 1 r, I" 1/ i~ 3~F 7 '" ~- 10 Fifty Years The following September this office, consisting of one room, was opened at 25 Broad Street. Colonel Montgomery was both the "member of the firm" and the "force of assistants." In the following year, Miss Anna M. Storey was engaged as secretary, a post which she held for twenty-three years. She was succeeded by her sister, Miss Reba Storey, who retired in 1945 after serving the firm for twenty-eight years. By 1908 the members of the organization were traveling with increasing frequency to Pittsburgh; accordingly, the firm opened an office there under the management of Walter A. Staub. The next office to be established was in Chicago in 1909. Walter Beans of the Philadelphia staff was the first manager, and he was succeeded two years later by Mr. Staub, who was transferred. from Pittsburgh as resident partner. In 1915 the New England practice of the firm necessitated opening an office in Boston. Its first manager, later a partner, was Carl T. Keller, who was an important factor in its foundation and has con tributed much to its growth and success. In 1916 Homer N. Sweet became a member of the organization and less than three years later was admitted to partnership. Developments which took place in governmental affairs, espe cially World War I agencies and the increasing number of tax cases, made it essential in 1919 to establish a Washington office. Soon thereafter the office was placed in charge of the present manager, J. Marvin Haynes. Toward the end of World War I, Detroit became increasingly important as a commercial and industrial center; consequently, an office was established there in 1920, with Richard Fitz-Gerald as manager, and later as resident partner. In the same year, the expansion of the firm's practice found a further expression in the opening of our first Pacific Coast office in Seattle. Two offices in the State of Ohio were opened in 1923. Prior Sinclair became manager of the Cleveland office and A. Charles Guy manager of the new office in Cincinnati. For many years Klink, Bean & Company had acted as agents for the firm in California. This arrangement eventually led to the merger of its practice with ours in 1924. At that time, George R. Keast was transferred from Pittsburgh as resident partner and assumed active management of the San Francisco and Los Angeles offices. Further expansion of the firm's practice in the East made it desirable to open an office in Baltimore in 1924. Frank E. Hare hiH>-·IU 1'1-. 4 iu_/" c.,.~...-..J~ f{f ..eo. '. :>.. '" '·'4 1Yt,.d<J.I ,....;. J>., I.".... .3 --It /0· " I \ S ff~ ...... JltLk (~fv~ Ii, ' (j,~.~~ h, tH.. IJJtf1>L~"""" I.\. ; »V 'Sf 1>. h{ I&r kN:dd .( ~- ~u-l''':-A/>,! 1 d~ / ~, 1~'-"'4-', ~~ f- J ~~'''r0'''''-J' t IV~Y.