INVESTIGATIVE FILES

INVESTIGATIVE FILES The Lady Appears Thus began a pattern that was The reported visits of the Virgin Mary re peated each month during the spec- to Fatima occurred in a time of trou- ified period, although the children ble. After the fall of the Portuguese were absent on August 13 (having been monarchy in 1910, there came a wave detained by secular authorities who disbe- of anti-clerical sentiment and persecu- lieved their tale and held them briefly for tion, followed by various revolutionary questioning in the public jail at Ourém). conflicts and Portugal’s involvement in On July 13, the children claimed to have World War I. received a special that the lady The Real On May 13, 1917, three shepherd forbade them to disclose. The apparition children were tending their flock about re mained invisible to the onlookers, but two miles west of Fatima in a town near some reported seeing a little cloud rise Secrets of Ourém. The children were Lucia Santos, from (or from behind) the tree, together age ten, and her two cousins, nine-year- with a movement of the tree’s branches old Francisco Marto and his seven-year- “as if in going away the Lady’s dress had Fatima old sister, Jacinta. A sudden flash of trailed over them” (Dacruz n.d.). lightning sent the children fleeing down When the period ended on a a slope, whereupon the two girls beheld stormy October 13, as many as sev- the dazzling apparition of a beautiful enty thousand people were gathered at lady, radiant in white light, standing the site anticipating the Virgin’s final among the holly-like leaves of a small visit, many anticipating a great mira- holm oak. cle. Again, the figure appeared only to mong the intriguing mysteries Lucia was the only one who talked the children. Identifying herself as “the of modern Catholicism are the with the figure, who promised to identify Lady of the ,” she urged people to A “” and “secrets” sup- herself at the end of a six-month period, repent and to build a chapel at the site. posedly imparted by the Virgin Mary during which time the children were to After predicting an end to the war and at Fa tima, Portugal, in 1917 (Oliveira return to the site on the thirteenth day giving the children certain undisclosed 1999). In addition to an allegedly mirac- of each month. The woman said that visions, the lady lifted her hands to the ulous “dance of the sun,” there were all three of them would go to heaven sky. Thereupon Lucia exclaimed, “The three major secrets, two of which were but that Francisco, who could not see sun!” As everyone gazed upward to see revealed at the time. The third and her, would have to recite many rosa- that a silvery disc had emerged from final one—kept in an envelope by the ries. When she instructed Lucia to have behind the clouds, they experienced Vatican—was not made public until Francisco say the rosary, the boy became what is known in the terminology of mid-2000, provoking much interest and able to see the apparition, but he was Marian apparitions as a “sun ” controversy. I was involved in the media still unable to hear her speak. After she (Arvey 1990, 69–71). debate over the release of the third secret, in structed the children to pray for an end Miracle of the Sun appearing on a documentary for the to the war, the lady vanished into the sky. History Channel series History’s Mysteries Even though the children had agreed This Fatima “miracle” has been described titled “Fatima: Secrets Unveiled” (which that they should keep the event secret, in many very different ways. Some aired January 4, 2001) as well as being once home, little Jacinta blurted out claim ed that the sun spun pinwheel-like interviewed for newspaper articles (e.g., to her parents that she had shared in a with colored streamers, while others Valpy 2000; Barss 2000). Here is my of the Virgin Mary. News quickly maintained that it danced. One reported, investigative take on the entire Fatima spread throughout the town, and when “I saw clearly and distinctly a globe of phenomenon. the children revisited the site on June light advancing from east to west, gliding 13, they were accompanied by some slowly and majestically through the air.” Joe Nickell, PhD, is the author of numer- fifty devout villagers. Kneeling in prayer To some, the sun seemed to be falling ous books, including Entities and Adven- at the oak, the children saw the woman toward the spectators. Still others, before tures in Paranormal Investigation. Visit glide down from heaven and take a posi- the “dance of the sun” occurred, saw his Web site at www.joenickell.com. tion amid the oak’s foliage (Arvey 1990, white petals shower down and disinte- 66; Rogo 1982, 221–223). grate before reaching the earth (Larue

14 Volume 33, Issue 6 Skeptical Inquirer 1990, 195–196; Arvey 1990, 70–71; have been reported at other Marian sites— written by Lucia in the convent [where Rogo 1982, 227, 230–232). at Lubbock, Texas, in 1989; Mother she later resided] between 1935 and Precisely what happened at Fatima has Cabrini near Denver, Colorado, 1941, many years after the series of been the subject of much controversy. in 1992; Conyers, Georgia, in the early experiences that constitute the appa- Church authorities made inquiries, col- to mid-1990s; and elsewhere, including rition event” (Zimdars-Swartz 1991, lected eyewitness testimony, and declared Thiruvananthapuram, India, in 2008. 68). Indeed, Lucia recorded her first the events worthy of belief as a miracle Tragically, at the Colorado and India sites, “prediction” of the children’s deaths in (Zimdars-Swartz 1991, 90). However, many people suffered eye damage (solar 1927—several years after the fact! people elsewhere in the world, viewing retinopathy)—in some instances, possi- As to the other predictions, they the very same sun, did not see the alleged bly permanent damage (Nickell 1993, were supposedly part of three secrets gyrations; neither did astronomical obser- 196–200; Sebastian 2008). that had been delivered to Lucia by the vatories detect the sun deviating from At the Conyers site, the Georgia apparition on July 13, 1917 (Gruner the norm (which would have had a Skeptics group set up a telescope outfit- 1997, 290–291). Lucia’s Third Memoir devastating effect on Earth!). Therefore, ted with a vision-protecting Mylar solar gave the first secret as a vision of hell. more tenable explanations for the reports filter, and on one occasion I participated The second was a statement that World include mass hysteria and local meteoro- in the experiment. Becky Long, president War I would end, “but if people do not logical phenomena such as a sundog (a parhelion or “mock sun”). On the other hand, several eyewit- nesses of the October 13, 1917, gath- ering at Fatima specifically stated they were looking “fixedly at the sun” or “tried to look straight at it” or otherwise made clear they were gazing directly at the actual sun (qtd. in Rogo 1982, 230, 231). If this is so, the “dancing sun” and other solar phenomena may have been due to optical effects resulting from temporary retinal distortion caused by staring at such an intense light or to the effect of darting the eyes to and fro to avoid fixed gazing (thus combining image, afterimage, and movement). Most likely, there was a combina- tion of factors, including optical effects and meteorological phenomena, such Photo by Joe Nickel Figure 1. At the Conyers, Georgia, site in 1994, skeptic Rebecca Long—using a as the sun being seen through thin telescope with a Mylar solar filter—looks in vain for a “sun miracle.” clouds, causing it to appear as a sil- ver disc. Other possibilities include an of the organization, stated that more than cease offending God, a worse one will alteration in the density of the passing two hundred people had viewed the sun break out during the pontificate of Pius clouds, causing the sun’s image to alter- through one of the solar filters and not XI” (who was pope from 1922 to 1939). nately brighten and dim and so seem to a single person saw anything unusual However, since the Third Memoir was advance and recede, and dust or mois- ture droplets in the atmosphere refract- (Long 1992, 3; see figure 1). penned in August 1941, the so-called predictions were actually written after the ing the sunlight and thus imparting The Secrets a variety of colors. The effects of sug- fact (Zimdars-Swartz 1991, 198–199). gestion were also likely involved, since Those who believe in the Fatima “mir- Before considering the important devout spectators had come to the site acle” also cite certain predictions the third secret of Fatima, and to fully fully expecting some miraculous event, ap parition allegedly made to Lucia, one comprehend the entire Fatima experi- had their gaze dramatically directed at being that Jacinta and Francisco would ence, we must look more closely at its the sun by the charismatic Lucia, and soon die. Both did soon succumb to central figure—not the Virgin Mary but excitedly discussed and compared their influenza: Francisco in 1919 and Jacinta Lucia de Santos. Born on March perceptions in a way almost certain to the following year. However, Zimdars- 22, 1907, to Antonio and Maria Rosa foster psychological contagion (Nickell Swartz observes, “much of what devo- Santos, Lucia was the youngest of seven 1993, 176–181). tees today accept as the content of the children. Five years younger than her Not surprisingly, perhaps, sun miracles apparition comes from four memoirs next-oldest sibling, Lucia was a petted

SKEPTICAL INQUIRER November / December 2009 15 and spoiled child. Her sisters fostered in 1991, 68) in wording Ratzinger characterized as her a desire to be the center of attention “symbolic and not easy to decipher” Further evidence that Lucia orches- by teaching her to dance and sing. At (Valpy 2000)—Lucia had described see- trated the fantasy and manipulated the festivals, Lucia would stand on a crate ing (at no specific time in the future) other children is provided by certain to entertain an adoring crowd. Among “an angel with a flaming sword in his incidents. For example, when Jacinta her other talents was a gift for telling sto- left hand; flashing, it gave out flames first told the story, she stated that the ries—fairy tales, biblical narratives, and that looked as though they would set Virgin had said many things that she saints’ legends—which made her popular the world on fire; but they died out in was unable to recall but “which Lucia with village children, as well as an ability contact with the splendor that Our Lady knows.” Lucia’s own mother was con- to persuade others to do her bidding. radiated towards him from her right vinced that her precocious daughter Two years before the famous series hand: pointing to the earth with his right was, in her words, “nothing but a fake of apparitions occurred at Fatima, eight- hand, the angel cried out in a loud voice: who is leading half the world astray” year-old Lucia and three girlfriends ‘Penance, Penance, Penance!’” (qtd. in Zimdars-Swartz 1991, 71, 86). claimed to have seen apparitions of a The visionary continued describing snow-white figure on three occasions. Third Secret Revealed the appearance of a “bishop dressed in Lucia’s mother called the experiences But there was a third secret of Fatima, white,” who was “afflicted with pain “childish nonsense.” The following year, possessed by the Vatican since 1957 and and sorrow” as he made his way through Lucia, Francisco, and Jacinta were thrice the subject of endless interest and spec- a ruined city. Moreover, “he prayed visited by an “angel.” ulation (Gruner 1997, 291). Certain for the souls of the corpses he met on his way; having reached the top of the mountain, on his knees at the foot of the big Cross he was killed by a group of soldiers who fired bullets and arrows at him, and in the same way there died one after another, the other bishops, priests, Lucia’s own mother was convinced that her precocious men and women Religious.” daughter was, in her words, “nothing but a fake who Now, many of the faithful have seen the text as having forecast the attempted is leading half the world astray.” assassination of Pope John Paul II, who was shot and wounded by a Turk in 1981 (Fleishman 2000). However, nearly every aspect of the vision—if indeed it was supposed to predict the assassination attempt on John Paul— was in error. It described not a pope but Lucia’s background is revealing. The Catholic notables have claimed to have a bishop, who was not killed, who was seeds of her later visionary encounters the third secret, but their credibility is not shot by soldiers, certainly not by were clearly contained in her childhood at issue because they seem to describe arrows (an implausibility attributable to experiences and in her obviously fanta- documents that were not first hand in a child’s imagination); neither were all 1 sy-prone personality. Her charismatic their accounts. Nevertheless, they have of the other bishops and priests killed. ability to influence others drew little hinted that the text predicted another The vision only seems accurate if one Francisco and Jacinta into the Fatima world war and a great disaster of some engages in “retrofitting”—after-the-fact fantasy. As Zimdars-Swartz says of Lucia: kind (see Kramer 2006). matching that fits statements to facts It is clear that she played the leading In mid-2000, the once they are known. This is the same role in the scenario of the appari- revealed the third secret that was sup- process used to claim that the prognos- tion itself. All accounts agree that she posedly imparted to Lucia in 1917, tications of Nostradamus (1503–1566), was the only one of the three seers which she set down as text in a 1944 the French seer, accurately described to interact with both her vision and future events (see Nickell 1989, 45–47). with the crowd, carrying on conversa- letter. It was forwarded in 1957 to the tions with both while her two cousins Secret Archives of the Vatican’s Holy In the case of the “third secret,” the ret- stood by silently. She has said, more- Office where it since reposed. rofitting involves counting the plausibly over, and probably not incorrectly, On Monday, June 26, 2000, Cardi- correct statements (e.g., the pope is that Francisco and Jacinta had been nal Joseph Ratzinger—then prefect of “Bishop of Rome,” was dressed in white, accustomed to follow her directives and was struck by a would-be assassin’s before the apparition began, that they church doctrine, now Pope Benedict turned to her for guidance afterwards, XVI—spoke in a nationally televised bullet), while ignoring—or rationaliz- and that it was she who convinced news conference at the Vatican. Scrawled ing—the many erroneous facts. Never- them that they had to be very careful with a thick-nibbed pen in Portuguese— theless, the Vatican statement claimed in their experiences. (Zimdars-Swartz

16 Volume 33, Issue 6 Skeptical Inquirer all three secrets represented authentic References Inquiry into Wondrous Phenomena. New York: : “No one could have imagined Arvey, . 1990. Miracles: Opposing View- Dial Press. points. Great Mysteries series. San Diego, CA: all this” (qtd. in Valpy 2000). Greenhaven Press. Sebastian, Don. 2008. 50 people looking for In any event, many conspira- Barss, Patchen. 2000. The sun-dance secret. National Post (Canada), May 13. cy-minded Catholics refuse to believe that solar image of Mary lose sight. Available Dacruz, Rev. V. n.d. Quoted in Rogo 1982, the third secret has been fully revealed. 224–225. online at www.dnaindia.com/dnaprint. They opine it may be “an indictment Fleishman, Jeffrey. 2000. Vatican says “third secret” speaks of renewal. The Buffalo News, of most of the changes in the Church June 27. asp?newsid=1152984 (accessed March 12, since Vatican II” (held 1962–1965) and Gruner, Nicholas. 1997. Fatima Priest. Pound Ridge, NY: Good Counsel Publications. 2008). would thus cause embarrassment to the ———. 2006. Living our daily lives in light of current defenders of that council (Gruner the Fatima secret. The Fatima Crusader 82 Valpy, Michael. 2000. The Vatican, devotees 2006, 42). Meanwhile, the visionary who (Spring): 5–10, 40–51. Kramer, Paul. 2006. The third secret predicts: clash over Third Secret of Fatima. The Globe started it all, Lucia Santos—who became World War III and worse? The Fatima a Carmelite nun, Sister Lúcia of Jesus, Crusader 82 (Spring): 11–13, 52–62. and Mail (Toronto, Canada), June 27. Larue, Gerald A. 1990. The Supernatural, the and died on February 13, 2005—has Occult, and the Bible. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Visions: Messages from the Virgin Mary or delu- been placed on the fast track to sainthood Books. Lúcia Santos. 2008. Wikipedia. Available online sions? 1989. Los Angeles Times, April 9. (“Lúcia” 2008). Certainly, the story will at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucia_dos_ continue. Santos (accessed September 3, 2008). Wilson, Sheryl C., and Theodore X. Barber. 1983. ! Long, Becky. 1992. The Conyers apparitions. Georgia Skeptic 5(2) (March/April): 3. The fantasy-prone personality: Implications Acknowledgments Nickell, Joe. 1989. The Magic Detectives. Buffalo, I wish to thank Luis Helbling (Nepean, NY: Prometheus Books. for understanding imagery, hypnosis, and Ontario, Canada), Sherman Harbeson ———. 1993. Looking for a Miracle: Weeping Icons, Relics, , Visions and Healing parapsychological phenomena. In Imagery, (Milton, Florida), and Timothy Binga Cures. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books. (The (director of CFI Libraries, Amherst, New present discussion is largely abridged from Current Theory, Research and Application, ed. York) for generous research assistance. this work—pp. 176–181—and expanded to in clude revelation of the Third Secret.) Anees A. Sheikh, 340–390. New York: Wiley. Note Oliveira, Mario de. 1999. Fátima Nunca Mais (Fatima Never Again). Porto, Portugal: Zimdars-Swartz, Sandra L. 1991. Encountering 1. For a discussion of fantasy proneness, see Campo des Letras. Wilson and Barber 1983. Rogo, Scott D. 1982. Miracles: A Parascientific Mary. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

There’s much more S KEPTICAL INQUIRER content available on our Web site!

Here’s a sample of what you’ll find at www.csicop.org:

Angie McQuaig’s article Camp Inquiry Rocks goes behind the scenes at Camp Inquiry, a week-long skeptical summer camp in Holland,

Karen Stollznow’s column The Naked Skeptic: “When The Beatles Were Bigger Than Jesus Christ” tells the story of John Lennon’s infa-

For more online columns, features, and special content, visit www.csicop.org/whatsnew.

SKEPTICAL INQUIRER November / December 2009 17